Maybe Carlos Rodon is a bit more high, ahhh, ummm, profile than the usual pitching, ahhh, ummm, profile candidate I cover. After all, at points over the last few years this is a guy who’s been universally owned. Things have definitely been a different story in 2017, as he missed all of April and May, and most of June recovering from a biceps injury. Following two strong starts upon his return, we’ve seen “Bad Carlos” over the last three turns. The former third overall pick has been steady, but inconsistent throughout his first two seasons in the big leagues. Apt to spells of poor control and command, that typically led to some ugly pitching lines. Is that what’s happening here? Simply a case of “Bad Carlos”? Good or bad, something has obviously been amiss the past few starts, let’s take a look under the hood and see what’s going on. Are these problems fixable or is there a lingering injury? On Sunday Rodon faced the red hot Indians and my guess is you already know what happened. Here’s what I saw.


Scouting Report: Rodon’s arsenal consists of four offerings, a mid-90’s four-seamer, a low-90’s sinker, a mid-high 80’s slider, and a mid-low 80’s changeup. Far and away the best pitch of the four is his slider. The breaking ball has gotten whiffs at a 20% rate historically, and typically had batting averages against in the sub-Mendoza range. The pitch has some nice two-plane movement running in on righthanders. He will throw his slider to any part of the zone, but loves burying it armside under the hands of righties and lefties. His tendencies are to bury the pitch low in the zone to lefthanded batters while working up and in with the pitch to righties. His changeup has slight rise to it, and also generates a high amount of whiffs, checking in at the 13-15% range histrionically. Rodon’s four-seamer sits in the mid-90’s, and gets an above average amount of whiffs, and a majority of Rodon’s grounders come on this pitch, and his sinking fastball variation. He tends to work armside with the four-seamer, while preferring to work gloveside with the sinker.


Carlos Rodon vs The Cleveland Indians July 30th, 2017 @ Guaranteed Rate Field, Chicago, IL

First Inning

Francisco Lindor – Fastball high and over the plate at 94 for strike 1, fastball inside at 91, strike 2, slider down and in at 85, swinging strike three.

Austin Jackson – High fastball at 93, ball, high fastball at 92, swinging strike 1, slider at 84 low and inside, ball 2, slider at 85 fouled back, strike 2, 96 MPH just off the plate, ball 3, 95 MPH on the outside part of the plate fouled off, fastball at 94 hit between the short stop and the second base for a hit.

Jose Ramirez – 84 MPH slider in the dirt, ball 1, 92 mph sinker at the bottom of the zone is popped up in foul territory for out number 2.

Edwin Encarnacion – Strike at 94 on the outside part of the plate, 92 MPH sinker inside, ball 1, 94 MPH sinker too low, ball 2, slider at 84 on the inside, ball 3, 94 MPH fastball high and inside at 94 for ball 4.

Carlos Santana – 82 MPH changeup high, ball 1, 84 MPH slider on the outside, strike 1, 84 MPH slider high in zone fouled back, strike 2, 95 MPH fastball high in the zone is popped up to 2nd for the third out.

An inning that could have gotten away from Rodon was held in check. He located his slider well, but was inconsistent with his fastball. Every time he threw his sinker it missed the zone. Still got Lindor swinging, and induced two pop-ups, without allowing any hard contact.

Second Inning

Brandon Guyer – Fastball at 94 high and inside, ball, sinker at 91 fouled off, strike, slider at 82 off the plate, ball 2, changeup at 82 high and outside, ball 3, high fastball ball 4, walk.

Giovanny Urshela – sinker at 92 skied to rightfield for the first out.

Roberto Perez – Fastball on the outisde, pitch out, and Guyer steals second, ball 1, 82 MPH changeup shows bunt, strike 1, 85 MPH slider buried in the dirt, ball 2, 92 MPH fastball high in the zone swinging strike 2, 93 MPH sinker on the inside, ball 3, full count, changeup at 84 is hit to third for the second out of the inning.

Bradley Zimmer – 88 MPH slider in the dirt, ball 1, 93 MPH sinker low and on the outer part of the plate fouled off, strike 1, 82 MPH changeup called a ball but painted the corner, bad call, 84 MPH slider on the outside of the plate, ball 3, 84 MPH slider on the outside swinging strike 2, full count, 96 MPH fastball down Main Street, and Zimmer just watches it for strike 3.

Rodon, has limited hard contact, but I wouldn’t say he’s overpowering anyone. He’s nibbling a ton, with his balls outside the zone being easy to pickup vs whats in the zone. Needs to start attacking hitters more with his fastball. He once again limited the damage this inning despite allowing the leadoff man to get into scoring position.

Third Inning

Francisco Lindor – 83 MPH changeup in the dirt, ball 1, fastball at 94 is a meatball, and Lindor makes him pay parking it in the left field bleachers.

Austin Jackson – 92 MPH fastball too high, ball 1, 91 MPH sinker way off the plate, ball 2, 93 MPH fastball is hit for a hard ground ball and it just misses the glove of a diving Moncada.

Jose Ramirez – 92 MPH fastball low and off the plate, strike 1, 84 MPH slider middle-in taken for a strike, 92 Fastball off the plate, ball 1, 92 MPH sinker in the dirt, ball 2, 93 MPH fastball hit to dead center for the first out.

Edwin Encarnacion – slider way inside, ball 1, 94 MPH sinker off the plate, ball 2, 92 MPH fastball hit on the ground to third, Tyler Saladino makes a great play to snag the ball fire to second to start the double play to end the inning.

Despite giving up the homer to Lindor this was by far the most efficient inning of his day for Rodon. Only needing 12 pitches to get out of the frame. I expected Lindor to be more overpowering than he’s been.

Fourth Inning

Carlos Santana – 82 MPH changeup low in the zone, ball 1, 94 MPH fastball high and outside part of the plate, strike 1, 82 MPH changeup way high, ball 2, changeup again at 83 paints the high armside corner for strike 2, buries the slider under the hands of Santana for a swinging strike 3.

Brandon Guyer – 79 MPH slider way off the plate, ball 1, 94 MPH middle-middle swinging strike 1, 87 MPH slider, strike 2, 96 MPH high and outside, ball 2, 96 MPH on the outside part of the dish is taken for strike 3.

Giovanny Urshela – 95 MPH fastball high and inside, strike 1, 85 MPH slider to the same spot on the inner part of the plate, strike 2, slider way off the plate, ball 1, 85 MPH change at the top of the zone fouled off, 85 MPH slider in on the hands is popped up to short for the third out.

Great inning by Rodon, he was locateing his fastball, slider, and change, getting ahead in counts and burying the slider under the hands of righties. Rodon is getting stronger as the game goes.

Fifth Inning

Roberto Perez – 91 MPH sinker bottom of the zone, ball 1, bad call, 92 MPH fastball on the inside, strike 1, 93 MPH fastball on the inside again taken for a questionable strike 2, 86 MPH in the dirt, ball 2, 96 MPH fastball on the top of the zone fouled back, 97 MPH fastball down Main Street for a swinging strike 3.

Bradley Zimmer – 96 MPH off the plate to the gloveside, swinging strike 1, 88 MPH slider way off the plate, ball 1, 86 MPH slider high and on the outside part of the plate, strike 2, 96 MPH fastball on the inside and Zimmer jumps back, ball 2, fastball on the inner-half at 97 MPH and Zimmer swings and misses, for a swinging strike 3.

Francisco Lindor – Fastball called a strike over the outisde of the plate at 96 MPH, bad call, slider at 86 buried under the hands, swinging strike 2, 98 MPH fastball on the outerhalf is slapped at for a weak bouncer to Rodon who tosses to first to end the inning.

Since allowing the homer and single to Lindor and Jackson to open the third Rodon has been locked in. Going after every hitter and locating his fastball all over the zone. His velocity ticked up to 96-97 with his four-seamer the last two innings. This kid is a horse when he’s on.

Sixth Inning

Austin Jackson – Fastball is hit for a flyball for out number one.

Jose Ramirez – slider in the middle of the zone and Ramirez catches it with the end of the bat and puts to the left field corner for a double.

Edwin Encarnacion – 94 MPH fastball on the inner-half, strike 1, 93 MPH fastball on the inside, same spot, strike 2, slider in the dirt on the inside, ball 1, 86 MPH slider on the inside, breaks Encarnacion’s bat on a foul ball, slider under the hands gets a swinging strike 3 as Ramirez heads to third.

Carlos Santana – 85 MPH changeup high in the zone, strike 1, 97 MPH fastball low in the zone fouled off, strike 2, 97 MPH fastball way off the plate, ball 1, 85 MPH slider is grounded to third, and Saladino throws to first for the final out of the inning.

Rodon continued to cruise despite the Ramirez double. The fastball-slider combo is working right now and his fastball command, movement, and velocity have all improved as the game has gone on.

Seventh Inning

Brandon Guyer – 82 MPH changeup high and on the inner-half, strike 1, fastball at 94 in on the hands fouled off for strike 2, 96 MPH off the plate, ball 1, 96 MPH fastball in on the hands swinging strike 3.

Giovanny Urshela – 85 MPH slider paints the inside corner but it’s called a ball, fastball at 94 is fouled off, strike 1, slider at 85 fouled off to left field, 95 MPH fastball up in zone also fouled off, slider at 87 high in the zone fouled off, 97 MPH fastball is hit for dribbler by Tim Anderson for a hit.

Roberto Perez – Fastball at 94 on the outer-half, strike 1, 95 MPH on the inside, strike 2, 97 MPH fastball up and in, ball 1, 85 MPH slider on the inner-corner and he freezes Perez with the slider.

Bradley Zimmer – 96 MPH fastball high and inside to Zimmer for a swinging strike 1, slider off the plate at 85 is fouled off, 97 MPH fastball low in the zone and it’s hit to left for a base hit.

Final Line: 6.2 IP, 6 Hits, 2 Walks, 1 Run, 1 Home Run, 9 K’s, 13 Swinging Strikes, 110 Pitches, 69 Strikes

Summary: Rodon was like a different pitcher after the first two batters of the 3rd inning. The fastball command all of a sudden was locked in, and he even added a couple of ticks on the velo. The slider is a legit weapon particularly to righties under the hands. If Rodon gets ahead in counts, like most starters, he’s a very uncomfortable at bat. If he could waste less pitches on 2 strike fastballs way off the plate to the gloveside, he’d get into the 7th almost habitually. His slider was as good as advertised, a true whip-out pitch, that he locates well, consistently painting the zone. The change was okay, had some nice movement, but is pretty far behind the slider and fastball. His success started to tick up once he went away from the sinker, which didn’t seem to do much for him, other than miss the zone. All in all Rodon looked very good, let’s hope he’s finally shaken off the rust of missing spring training and a majority of the first three months. I’d start Rodon at home, and in plush matchups, might be primed for one of his famous second half runs.


Razzball Baseball

Updated Top 100 SP

(rankings for ROS based on 12-team Roto)

1 Max Scherzer, WAS 
2 Chris Sale, BOS
3 Corey Kluber, CLE  
4 Madison Bumgarner, SF  
5 Alex Wood, LAD 
6 Zack Greinke, ARI  
7 Jacob deGrom, NYM  
8 Luis Severino, NYY 
9 Carlos Carrasco, CLE 
10 Carlos Martinez, STL   
11 Chris Archer, TB
12 Dallas Keuchel, HOU
13 Gerrit Cole, PIT    
14 Yu Darvish, TEX 
15 James Paxton, SEA
16 Jimmy Nelson, MIL 
17 Jake Arrieta, CHC  
18 Rich Hill, LAD      
19 Danny Salazar, CLE   
20 Aaron Nola, PHI
21 Michael Fulmer, DET
22 Jon Lester, CHC  
23 Jose Quintana, CHC
24 Gio Gonzalez, WAS      
25 Sean Manaea, OAK   
26 Marcus Stroman, TOR   
27 Lance McCullers, HOU
28 Danny Duffy, KC
29 Jose Berrios, MIN  
30 Dan Straily, MIA   
31 Drew Pomeranz, BOS
32 Zack Godley, ARI    
33 Jameson Taillon, PIT     
34  Jacob Faria, TB
35 Mike Foltynewicz, ATL 
36 Michael Wacha, STL
37 Masahiro Tanaka, NYY       
38 Ivan Nova, PIT     
39 Kenta Maeda, LAD   
40 Kyle Hendricks, CHC   
41 Sonny Gray, OAK       
42   Mike Clevinger, CLE  
43     Jon Gray, COL
44 Taijuan Walker, ARI
45 Felix Hernandez, SEA
46 Mike Fiers, HOU 
47 Rick Porcello, BOS 
48 Jason Vargas, KC   
49 J.A. Happ, TOR 
50 Lance Lynn, STL  
51 Jordan Montgomery, NYY     
52 Alex Cobb, TB    
53 Charlie Morton, HOU          
54 Cole Hamels, TEX 
55 Luis Castillo, CIN 
56 Eduardo Rodriguez, BOS     
57 Jeff Samardzija, SF    
58 Justin Verlander, DET  
59 Patrick Corbin, ARI
60 Trevor Cahill, KC    
61 German Marquez, COL  
62 Trevor Bauer, CLE     
63 Ian Kennedy, KC
64 Carlos Rodon, CHW
65 Ervin Santana, MIN       
66 C.C. Sabathia, NYY           
67 Kevin Gausman, BAL  
68 Vincent Velasquez, PHI  
69 Jerad Eickhoff, PHI      
70 Mike Leake, STL       
71 Hyun-Jin Ryu, LAD     
72 J.C. Ramirez, LAA 
73 Sean Newcomb, ATL        
74 Collin McHugh, HOU        
75 Ariel Miranda, SEA      
76 Steven Matz, NYM        
77 Parker Bridwell, LAA  
78 Zach Davies, MIL       
79     Kyle Freeland, COL         
80 Jason Hammel, KC     
81                            Dinelson Lamet, SD                         
82 Tanner Roark, WAS  
83 Seth Lugo, NYM    
84 John Lackey, CHC  
85                                       Luis Perdomo, SD                                               
86 Brent Suter, MIL 
87 Julio Teheran, ATL
88 Jaime Garcia, NYY 
89 Dylan Bundy, BAL      
90 Jhoulys Chacin, SD 
91 Trevor Williams, PIT
92 Jose Urena, MIA   
93  Kendall Graveman, OAK  
94 Nick Pivetta, PHI 
95 R.A. Dickey, ATL 
96 Matt Moore, SF
97 Jeff Hoffman, COL  
98 Adalberto Mejia, MIN
99 Anibal Sanchez, DET
100 Chad Kuhl, PIT  


Disabled List (Ranking When Active):  Clayton Kershaw, LAD (3)Noah Syndergaard, NYM (8), Stephen Strasburg, WAS (9), Robbie Ray, ARI (12), David Price, BOS (24), Johnny Cueto, SF (28)Chase Anderson, MIL (29), Brandon McCarthy, LAD (42)Matt Shoemaker, LAA  (54), Adam Wainwright, STL (63), Aaron Sanchez, TOR (66) Matt Andriese, TB (68), Jake Odorizzi, TB  (69), Scott Feldman, CIN (84), Matt Harvey, NYM (99) Brandon Finnegan, CIN (100)

Dropped off: Mike Montgomery, CHC, Zack Wheeler, NYM, Marco Estrada, TOR, Andrew Moore, SEA

  • Grey mentioned it in his post this morning, but Kevin Gausman is en fuego. Over his last three turns, he’s 3-0 with a 0.44 ERA, 1.16 WHIP, .219 BAA, a 10.4 K/9, a 3.4 Bb/9, and a 58.3% groundball rate. Who is this masked man?
  • As bad as Justin Verlander has been there’s a time and a place to start him, at home in night games. Check out these splits; Day Games ERA: 5.18, Night Games ERA: 3.87, Home ERA: 3.29, Away ERA: 5.32. So start Verlander in night games at home.
  • Someone’s going to get traded before this post drops, and someone is going to say “So and so is no longer on such and such team”. I see you.
  • Wait, what R.A. Dickey? Why? Honestly, the knuckleballer should be higher, problem is, to steal a phrase from Flavor Flav, I can’t Truss it. He’s been solid since the beginning of June, compiling a 3-3 record with a 3.31 ERA, 7.9 K/9, 3.0 Bb/9, a .231 BAA, and a 1.21 WHIP.
  • After a bad outing last time out Vince Velasquez was efficient in his start Sunday, going 7 scoreless, and striking out 6 to only 2 walks in the process. He’s still too inconsistent for me to really believe in, but he moved up a little this week due to the upside when he’s right.
  • Over the last month Mike Fiers is 6th in all of baseball in K/9 with a 12.86 mark. He’s made the most of his opportunity accumulating a 2.86 ERA over the past 30 days, and forcing Brad Peacock to the pen.
  • Michael Wacha made a big jump to 40th overall with a bullet this week. Since posting a 8.17 ERA over 6 rough starts between May 25th and June 21st, the righty has been great, going 5-1 with 1.86 ERA, 9.7 K/9, 1.4 Bb/9, BAA of .193, and a 0.85 WHIP. No idea what Wacha fixed, but when he’s healthy he’ s a top 30 starter. Looks like he’s healthy and creeping toward the top 30.

Follow me on Twitter @Ralphlifshitzbb, and check out my weekly Live Baseball Show on Fantrax YouTube channel Tuesday’s at 9 PM EST

  1. bill amodeo says:

    Hey Ralph,

    You think Nola and Paxton keep pitching like this ROS or maybe look to sell high?

    Also Gausman or Rodon?

    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @bill amodeo: I like Nola and Paxton both rest of season. Not sure if they would shut down either due to their injury histories.

      Rodon by a hair. Gausman’s been great for two weeks.

  2. Buster Olney says:

    Gausman or T Walker keep forever dynasty?

    To that end – thoughts on T Walker – does he ever take the next step?


    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @Buster Olney: Walker, I think he has this year. He had 10 K’s in 5 2/3rds yesterday. He has a 3.55 ERA, and a mid-8’s k rate, he’s trending the right way, prolly not an ace though.

  3. John says:

    Hi Ralph,

    What are your thoughts on Rodon vs E-Rod ROS? E-Rod was pitching so well before his little bullpen mishap. I’m moving closer to my moves limit so it would be who I’m holding on to through the playoffs.


    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @John: There’s more for Ed-Rod to pitch for, and I have more faith in him right now. This was Rodon’s best start of the season.

      Worried about Ed-Rod’s legs though.

  4. What about reynaldo Lopez ros?

    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @Peter guigli: Could be a useful source of K’s, once he’s called up. Gotta be careful with his matchups though.

  5. Greg says:

    Is Peacock going back to the bullpen, or will he stay as a starter? Intrested in Bridwell or Gausmsan, but with DeGrom, Paxton, AWood, Faria, Taillon, Peacock and Salazar I’m thinking hold. 14t 5×5 yahoo.

    I have Will Myers, TPham, DSantana, APollock, with only two I can play. …but none of those seem droppable.


    • RobPopp says:

      @Greg: Peacock announced as Friday’s starter, as McCullers his the dl

      • Greg says:

        @RobPopp: I’m thinking Peacock should have earned an ongoing starter role, but he was pretty valuable in pen.

        • Ralph Lifshitz

          Ralph Lifshitz says:

          @Greg: Yeah I think it was how good Fiers has been that forced him out, but he’s back.

        • RobPopp says:

          @Greg: Excellent #s. Rooting for him this year and beyond. No doubt earned the role. They are so flush it doesn’t seem to matter where there guys go and for how long. I had him to start the year in my holds league (crushed in relief, but also interchangeable from the wire), I’d just rock him until he tires. The Ws just keep on coming. I’m rocking Morton and McHugh, too.

          But depending on your league, now with just two months left, you don’t have to commit to these guys for the long haul, take it as it goes. 14 team is deep, but if Gaus is still on the wire I’d bet there are a few other guys who can help along the way as well

    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @Greg: If you have to drop one, dump Pham for Gausman.

      • Greg says:

        @Ralph Lifshitz: Ah, Gausman scooped up. Would you drop Pham for Bridwell, or no? He’s been impressive.

        • Ralph Lifshitz

          Ralph Lifshitz says:

          @Greg: If you really need a starter

  6. Jerseyjon says:

    What are your thoughts on Weaver?

    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @Jerseyjon: I like him a lot, I’ve written about him a ton the last two years. Swings and misses, groundballs, throws lots of strikes.

  7. Oddball Herrera says:

    Willie Calhoun to TX! At about 4:05 the mouse was hovering over the drop button, thinking he was blocked in La all year…

    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @Oddball Herrera: Here we go Free Willie C!!!!

      • James T Kirk says:

        @Ralph Lifshitz:

        Probably no shot of him playing any second base tho

        • Ralph Lifshitz

          Ralph Lifshitz says:

          @James T Kirk: Aren’t you the guy that told me Devers wouldn’t be up until September? Who knows, I think we have to wait and see, he’ll play in the majors, and that power/contact approach plus his super low strikeout rate plays everywhere

  8. indefiniteinfinite says:

    Quick question Ralph. Has Mateo’s value/ranking increased significantly with this trade? Oakland happens to be the same team that’s decided to roll with Semien at short. Could we see Mateo stick at SS? As always, thanks.

    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @indefiniteinfinite: Perhaps, but they need some young outfielders. I’m thinking his future is in CF. The A’s don’t run a lot so I’m thinking it might hurt him. They’ve been in the bottom third of the league in steals for at least the last three years and had speed guys in their roster. So it might be playing time in spite of exploiting his best asset.

  9. Ralph Lifshitz

    Ralph Lifshitz says:

    Driving home from work should be back on for questions around 7 EST.

  10. Joe says:

    I own Sonny and Yu. I’m pumped about Yu heading to LA, thoughts on Gray in new york? Much shorter porches. My league also counts QS and not wins, so the better prospect of Ws doesn’t help me. Does the move help or hurt him if I don’t care about wins. Thanks.

    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @Joe: I think it could hurt Gray, at least on the surface, that’s a hell of a ball park switch. That said maybe he’s pumped to be part of a winner and that plays down the stretch. Yankees mystique and all that.

  11. Biggie Smalls says:

    Listened to Saturday’s Prospect Podcast today while driving to work.

    How are yall not going bananas over Ryan Mcmahon? Dude is obliterating everything right now. I know you did write about him in the rundown last week (I think). Can you whisper sweet nothings about Mcmahon to me/ and or Brendan Rodgers/ Raimel Tapia? Please?

    Unfortunately it is looking like a 2018 debut for him unless Reynolds gets hurt, but even then Desmond and Parra play 1B. I LOVE ROCKIES HITTING PROSPECTS.

    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @Biggie Smalls: Love McMahon, and I think we talked him with Grey in the big show last week.

      Take a look through our episodes we’ve covered him a few times. I love that he’s seeing time at 1B, 2B, and 3rd. Wouldn’t shock me if the Rocks called him up in a few weeks.

  12. Amed Rosario called up for tomorrow game in coors is he a must add at short had correa . Do I drop x. Bogaerts.

    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @Peter guigli: I don’t know if I’d do that, but it’s tempting based on Xander’s recent play.

  13. Chud says:

    Asked u yesterday about SS position n Xander. In a full keeper dynasty league would u deal Xander for DeGrom? I always go hitter but in this case not so sure.

    Have Didi, Barreto, and Tim Anderson right now and can add A.Simmons.


    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @Chud: I’d do it if you need pitching. You might kick yourself in two years if he snaps out of this funk.

  14. Can not spell wRONg without RON says:

    I’m no expert but it seems to me that Rodon is some what similar to Liriano.

    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @Can not spell wRONg without RON: He is pretty similar. Not Liriano now, but when he had upside.

      I’m no expert either, I’m a guy who’s hobby is writing about baseball.

      • Can not spell wRONg without RON says:

        @Ralph Lifshitz: Exactly what I was getting at. In Liriano’s younger days he would dominate for 7 or 8 games and then blow up for 4 or 5. I was always waiting for him to take it to the next level, but he never did. Hoping Rodon figures it out and gets to the next level.

        Me, I’m retired and one of my hobbies is playing and reading about fantasy baseball.
        Keep up the good work.

  15. Blue JA says:

    With Jim Johnson in a timeshare, and Gausman a free agent in my 12 team roto…is JJ droppab;e for the hot Gausman of I have AJ, Ziegs, and Neris??

    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @Blue JA: Yeah do it.

    • The Harrow says:

      @Blue JA: johnson isn’t in a “timeshare” all indicators that him (like casilla) are at the best in mop up duty and maybe move up to a 7th inning with a lead role later.

      • Ralph Lifshitz

        Ralph Lifshitz says:

        @The Harrow: I thought it was still a committee

  16. scythe says:

    Nice write-up!

    Straily is available in my league
    Should I drop Clevinger, Peacock, Morton or Suter for him?

    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @scythe: Suter

  17. Benintendo64 says:

    Love your pitcher spotlights each week!

    Is Syndergaard worth holding onto for the fantasy playoffs? Still no timetable for return..

    My current starters are Degrom, Nelson, Lester, Taillon, McCullers and Maeda.

    14 teams so waivers is pretty bare.

    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @Benintendo64: Yeah I’m holding him a few places for that reason.

  18. Robert says:

    10 team h2h redraft league: Clevinger or Morton? Just seems like I would be better off going with the veteran on the better team.

    • RobPopp says:

      @Robert: Morton signed that monster contract to start the year, plays for the team with the best record in the AL, and is pitching the best ball in his career. Clevinger is having a superb sophomore year, and plays for a very good defending pennant winner who will be fighting for the division til the end. I wouldn’t let his past two poor starts deter you, they are outliers so far. Maybe he ate some bad sausage in Cleveland, and then some bad chowda in beantown, who knows. I’d hold them both if you can

      • Ralph Lifshitz

        Ralph Lifshitz says:

        @RobPopp: Nah there’s no bad chowder in Boston. Prolly had some bad bagels or second rate pizza.

    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @Robert: The answer is above… haha

  19. Micah Vansciver says:

    I’m out of it this year in my dynasty league and I got offered Moncada, Donaldson, and Giolito for Arenado. Thoughts?

  20. Regular Guy says:

    14-team H2H with 5 keepers. I’ve been offered Adam Jones, Justin Smoak, Paul Dejong and Marcus Stroman for Cody Bellinger, Neil Walker, Victor Martinez and Jordan Montgomery.

    The other team really wants Bellinger. I’m in second place and could use some more firepower for our two-week per round playoff system.

    I have Goldschimdt, Seager, McCutchen, Matt Carpenter and Justin Turner as keeper options already for 2018 (and I’ve stashed Acuna if I want to go young or Eaton if I want a rebound guy).

    Make the trade for this year or keep Cody for 2018 and beyond?


    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @Regular Guy: I’d hold on Belly

  21. Swfcdan says:

    Tanaka’s K/BB is pretty damn beautiful, if he can just start keeping the ball on the ground more again then he could be a huge riser, even if not he’ll have a ton of value. Career best K/9 and one of his best WHIPs, people aren’t realising this. I bought low a few weeks ago…ka’ching!

    Darvish too has to be a winner moving to LA. Another pitcher I own, what’s up with my fetish for owning strikeout, homer prone Japanese pitchers!

    Go with Morton over Clevinger after his latest disaster?

    Oh yeah and DEVERS!!! This kid looks ridiculously polished already, scary. Great news for Fisher’s AB’s too, sayonara Aoki!

    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @Swfcdan: Yeah, he’s really been trending in the right direction for a month +, and looks solid of late.

      I hope darvish can get right he’s been pretty meh the last month. Word is he was tipping pitches against the fish.

      I’m still going Clevinger, I think he stays healthy I’m never sure with Morton.


  22. Huggiea says:

    As a Rodin owner in a deep league I’m looking for him to show me some good thinks the end of this year to determine if I’m going to keep him. Grea write up. Quick question, I’m in a keeper league where a player only comes off waivers once he plays his 1st MLB game. Could you give me a top 5 list of prospects coming up this year that have a shot of having a big impact in 2018. I have the third waiver and I’m looking for a lottery ticket. It’s looking pretty thin out there maybe Dom smith, Hoskins, Lopez???? Keep up the great work!!!

    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @Huggiea: Rosario, Albies, Smith, McMahon, Calhoun

      thanks for reading

  23. dubjay says:

    Hey Ralph,
    Which 2 do you like best for this season and in a keeper league?

    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @dubjay: Acuna and Brinson

  24. Hey Ralph, great article! Look forward to reading this each week!

    12 Team ESPN H2H normal 5×5 scoring:

    Felix Hernandez
    Jon Gray

    Kintzler (wish he wouldn’t have gotten traded!)
    Shane Greene

    As you can tell, my SP’s are not great. I have Thames, Mancini, Amed Rosario, and Parra on my bench as well.

    Couple of questions: (1) Would you drop any of the above bench hitters for Devers, Semien, or Arcia? I’m currently starting Bogaerts at SS.
    (2) Do you think Kintzler will see any save opportunities going forward, or would you recommend picking up Taylor Rogers as a replacement? The other option I have is a potential to trade Thames for Rosenthal and Treinen — would you recommend accepting that?
    (3) The waiver wire is loaded with SP’s from your list. Who would you pick for ROS SP from this list of available starters: Walker, Rodon, Happ, Castillo, Teheran, Lamet, Sabathia, and Matz? I’m leaning towards Walker or Castillo, but Rodon is tempting as well.

    Last question: Do you think there’s an undervalued SP to target with the bench hitters and/or closers noted above?

    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @Matt G.: Thanks for reading!!!

      Yes, Mancini for Devers.

      He could, after all this is Dusty Baker amiright?

      I’d got Walker and then Happ, then Rodon.

  25. Mordacious Levator says:

    anabelle and hoffman ranked but no conley? (awesome for 3 straight starts after recall)

    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @Mordacious Levator: He’s good again this week and he’s on it. I give a few starts before I buy in, and the K’s are meh.

      Outside of a bad start at KC Anibal has been solid, and Hoffman has had a better year than Conley. I can’t just ignore that after a strong week. Conley is one to watch though I 100% agree, and think you’ll see him next week.

      Thanks for reading.

  26. AJax says:

    Hey pal. Thanks for these posts. Where does Skaggs slot in when he comes back? Which sounds like it may even be late this week.

    • Ralph Lifshitz

      Ralph Lifshitz says:

      @AJax: Need to see a couple starts healthy and Judge from there. He needs to earn his way back into the circle of trust haha

Comments are closed.