I’m attempting something new with this year’s top 100 keepers article. It’s something I’ve always thought about doing but never had the time or brainpower to figure out. I want to try to objectively (impossible) rank each player on how many projected categories they provide for your team.
I broke each standard 5×5 category down into five statistical outcome ranges. Take runs for example.
|Runs||Under 54||55-69||70-84||85-99||Over 100|
|HRs||Under 16||17-23||24-30||31-37||Over 38|
|RBI||Under 54||55-69||70-84||85-99||Over 100|
|SBs||Under 8||9-13||14-18||19-23||Over 23|
|AVG||Under .254||.255-.269||.270-.284||.285-.299||Over .300|
|W||Under 7||8-10||11-13||14-16||Over 17|
|K||Under 159||160-184||185-209||210-234||Over 235|
|ERA||Over 4.45||3.96 – 4.44||3.46-3.95||2.96-3.45||Under 2.95|
|WHIP||Over 1.33||1.24-1.32||1.15-1.23||1.06-1.14||Under 1.05|
|SV||Under 11||12-17||18-23||24-30||Over 30|
It isn’t a perfect system by any means, but here’s how it works: Ronald Acuna, by all projection models, is expected to score over 100 runs so he gets 1 point for the runs category. While Marcell Ozuna’s average projection expects him to score around 83 runs so he gets a .5 for that category. So I did this with all 10 standard 5×5 categories. This method is with the understanding of the fact that few people are projected for over 100 runs — but many players will fall in the 70-84 range. That helps explain why only three elite players got perfect scores as you’ll see below.
“But Kerry! How does your system take into account age, regression, lineup slot, the team the player is on and injury-prone players?”
Most of that is baked into their projections. We know that Giancarlo Stanton is going to miss games. (Surprise! He already is!) That’s why Steamer only has him projected for 494 ABs and his stats reflect those decreased ABs. If he reaches 600 ABs — he’s got maybe the best chance of reaching 60+ HRs in the league — but will he? Probably not. We also know that no matter where Trey Mancini hits in the Orioles lineup his runs and RBI totals are going to take a hit this year because there aren’t many solid major leaguers around him.
Age is a bit of a trickier “category” to track and it’s one that I’m definitely going to try and quantify more in the future. Statistics dictate that most players reach their primes in the 27-29 age range, but don’t tell that to Justin Verlander, Nelson Cruz or Juan Soto! Verlander and Cruz’s ages continue to have us devalue them because Father Time and Mother Nature are undefeated and we’re waiting for the regression. However, you can’t deny their production even as Verlander recently turned 37 and Cruz turns 40(!) this year. And Juan Soto can’t even ride the bumper boats at Disney World, but he could hit 40 HRs this year!
Regression is an even HARDER “category” to figure out because while luck can be quantified in RPG video games — they can’t in baseball. A strong, windy day in Chicago might turn your 110 MPH exit velocity HR into the longest F8 in the scorebook. However, we can look at a player’s prior year’s stats (if available) and try to determine if something is realistic or not. Is Jose Ramirez going to hit .218 in the first half, but .327 in the second-half again? Do you feel lucky? Well, do ya, AJ Puk?
Don’t even get me started on the juiced ball “category” — right now only Rob Manfred and that guy who collects all the baseball mud know how that is going to impact player performance in 2020 and I fully expect a TON of overreaction from fantasy and real baseball analysts alike during every at-bat this year.
“But starting pitchers can only contribute 4 categories in any given season! This isn’t fair!”
You’re right — and such is life. That’s why I’m probably a bit lower on starting pitcher as keepers instead of hitters. That’s also why you’ll only find one reliever on this entire ranking. They can provide wins, sure — but it’s a bit unpredictable. They might contribute 60 or so innings of ERA/WHIP/K help on a week-to-week basis, but over the entirety of a season, it’s less impactful than the 180 innings you’ll get from a great starter. Josh Hader is the one reliever who should provide enough innings and strike-outs to have a meaningful impact. Truly elite starting pitchers like Gerrit Cole are almost guaranteed to give you 4 category production and his ranking reflects that.
The Shohei Ohtani problem.
The player who was the most difficult for me to rank was the Japanese Babe Ruth, Shohei Ohtani. As a hitter alone I have him in the 50-60 keeper range. (His average projections show him hitting roughly 74 runs/26 HRs/80 RBI/12 SBs/.278 AVG.) But how should I incorporate the 98 IP, 7 wins, 3.67 ERA, 1.24 WHIP and 118 Ks he could also contribute as a reliever? In my opinion, that’s a huge boost if he counts as one player in your daily moves league. That makes him a solid contributor in about 7 categories.
Again this system isn’t perfect (none are!) but I’m going to keep tweaking it to get it to work better every year. And remember — this is for keeper rankings for 2020. There’s a little bit of 2021 cooked into the rankings, but a lot of this ranking has to do with 2020.
Enough banter — let’s get into it!
|1||Ronald Acuna Jr.||ATL||OF||22|
Rank ‘em how you want ‘em — but there’s your top four! All four of these players are almost guaranteed to give you 5 category production. I’m giving Acuna the nod based on his age and the strength of the top of the Braves lineup. I have Lindor at 4 because there was a major injury last year and his lineup (right now) isn’t as strong. Plus, I’m getting the feeling he will be traded — probably to a more competitive team. However, maybe it takes him some time to adjust to a new team, park, pitchers etc. Just a few more questions than the other three. Although I am a little worried about Yelich’s knee.
All of these guys are phenomenal players — but there are just a few more question marks than the top-4. However, I still anticipate a lot of vitriol in the comment section!
Will Soto continue to steal double-digit bases despite never really doing so in the minors?
How long will Bellinger steal double-digit bases until he goes the way of Paul Goldschmidt? He’s much younger than Goldy was when the steals dwindled though.
Betts I think has the best bet to move into the 5 category arena — but it depends on what the balls are like this year. It also depends on where he hits in the lineup and if he’s more of a 16 stolen base hitter — or 30 SB.
Which Ramirez half will we see this season? I was very tempted to put Jose Ramirez in the 5 category group, but his average and the aforementioned first half gave me some pause. However, 95/30/95/30/.280? Wow.
Why do we continue to disrespect Trevor Story? I (along with many other people) are still not forgiving Trevor Story for his 2017 average. However, he’s hit over .290 in both of the last two seasons with fantastic team and individual stats.
Where will Trea Turner be hitting in the lineup this year? Early reports are 3rd — does this impact his stolen base numbers?
There are the pitchers! Gerrit Cole, Walker Buehler, and Jacob deGrom are very close. Their age and performance are elite and will contribute at a high level in all 4 starting pitcher categories.
And there’s Nolan Arenado! A 12 ranking feels disrespectful even to me — but he just doesn’t steal the bases we need. In TGFBI I grabbed Juan Soto with the last pick in the first round and followed it up with Nolan Arenado with the first pick in the second round. Every subsequent pick I made was trash — but I was king of the world for two hours!
Alex Bregman, Javier Baez, Ozzie Albies and Yoan Moncada are a lot closer than I expected. They all contribute well in all 5 categories, but not without their warts. Bregman: dwindling stolen bases, Baez: sub-elite average, Albies & Moncada: sub-elite RBI totals, sub-elite average.
If Devers can continue to grow past the 30 HR mark and even touch double-digit SBs I’ll move him up.
|27||Fernando Tatis Jr.||SD||SS||21||3.5|
There’s definitely some upward mobility in these players. Tatis, Hiura, Jimenez, Bichette, and Meadows are all destined for the upper tiers if their performance continues to match their pedigree. With Tatis, I want to see that 29.6% K/rate come down. With Hiura I’m a little worried about the power ceiling and he was never a huge stolen base threat in the minors. If Jimenez’s power profile continues he’ll at least move up 1 tier — but he’s completely opposed to stealing bases. I can see him in the Nolan Arenado territory though. I’m interested to see where Bichette’s power numbers settle in — but I’m confident he can steal 20-25 bases. Meadows is somehow the old man of this group at only 24, so I’m actually most confident in his resisting a regression. Was that 33 HR outburst in 2019 aided by the juiced ball though? We’ll have to see.
Based on hype alone Bryce SHOULD be a lot higher — but his average is holding him down and I think he knows that. 100/35/100 should be a lock at this point — but his high-risk Eric Byrnes motor makes me nervous for his health and what that could mean for his stolen base totals. Sprained ankle here, a twisted knee there — and we could be facing another low SB season.
40 HRs is the floor for Pete Alonso — unfortunately, .260 feels like his ceiling.
If Gleyber played for the Royals would we love him as much? The team production numbers should be fine on the Yankees — but I just get the feeling he’s more of a 30 HR player than 40 HR. Plus that .270 average is solid — but not elite.
I love the Marte cousins hitting right next to each other atop the Diamondbacks lineup (no relation.) However, we have to see how many bases Ketel can swipe and how many ABs Starling can accumulate. Under 10 SBs? Ketel is accurately ranked. Under 550 ABs? Starling is accurately ranked. Anything over those numbers and they’ve earned you value.
|49||Vladimir Guerrero Jr.||TOR||3B||21|
Josh Bell has a lot of upward mobility here. But the wild drop off from April & May to June to September was worrying.
Charlie Blackmon’s SBs predictably disappeared last year, but don’t extrapolate that dip to his other stats. 112/32/86/.314 is still a great player to have. Same goes for Goldschmidt — I think the average rebounds. He had 7 straight seasons of a .290+ batting average — the .260 was an aberration.
Anthony Rizzo is the most boring fantasy contributor due to his consistency. 90 runs, 28 HRs, 98 RBI, 5 SB, .288 AVG. QUOTE ME!
For Vlad I think the average will be over .300 in his sophomore year. But with no steals and 20-25 power I think this is where he belongs for now. If he starts getting into the 30+ HR territory I will move him up next year.
Matt Chapman is also boring — mainly due to his name. His average is the main thing holding him back from the upper tiers. 100 runs, 100 RBI, 30+ RBI are a lock — but .250ish average? Miss me with that.
20/30 Robles is a fantastic fantasy piece. 70 RBI, .260 AVG Robles is not. I’ll just split the difference and pair him with Yelich!
45 SB in 2018, 20 in 2019. How far do Merrifield’s stolen bases fall in 2020? I think he can still get 18-22 — but he’ll remain a HR and RBI liability on your team.
McNeil lacks top tier name-value sex appeal — but depending on his lineup slot I love the 85/20/75/10/.300 potential.
More pitching! With Snell and Strasburg, it comes down to innings. Snell only reached 107 last year and couldn’t replicate his 2018 when he was on the mound. I think there is huge bounceback potential here — but I can’t bank on it just yet. As for Strasburg, he pitched over 180 innings for the first time since 2014. Hopefully, this is a turning point for him health-wise.
I want Benintendi to be better. I really do. He’s averaged 16 HRs and 17 SBs over his last 3 seasons. 4 more HRs and 3 SBs really aren’t much — but it would look so much better if he could just put together a 20/20 season. It’s looking like he’ll be leading off in 2020 which I really like for his fantasy numbers.
Marcus Semien is too unpredictable in the power numbers to rank any higher this year. 27 HRs in 2016; 15 in 2018; 33 in 2019. It has been nice to see his average climb each year since 2016 however: .234, .249, .255, .285. His SBs you can set your watch to though. His totals since 2015: 11, 10, 12, 14, 10.
Let me tell you about the juiced ball. It turned DJ Lemahieu into an MVP candidate. He couldn’t top 20 HRs in COORS FIELD. 2019 happens and he hits 26. Never hit over 70 RBI in 7 seasons with the Rockies. 2019 arrives and: 102! He’s always had great bat to ball skills — but deez balls turned him into a completely different player.
I’m going to call my shot twice in these next two sentences Franmil is going to shock us all and hit 45 HRs with 100+ RBI and a .280 average and place in the top-5 in MVP. Also: next year I’ll write “Is this for real?” in my top 100 keepers article.
Castillo: Less sinkers, more sliders!
Giolito: HUGE 2018 – 2019 difference. Maintainable?
Correa: Stay healthy! Steal bases? DUCK!
Nola: Cy Young upside — but was 2018 a fluke?
Mondesi: Stolen bases and? Stolen bases and? Health risk!
Hoskins: Up 4 tiers in OBP leagues. .226 AVG will be a fluke.
Corbin: Forgotten ace behind Stras & Scherz.
Laureano: Maintain AVG + 25/20? To the moon!
Bauer: Use the hatred flow through you to get your ERA back under 4!
Realmuto: SBs will fall — but still best C in the game by far.
Muncy: AVG holds him down — but 90/30/90 is fantastic.
Darvish: Jose Ramirez in pitcher form with half splits.
Villar: Lateral trade from Orioles. HOW?! 24 HRs unrealistic.
Rosario: Top of lineup? STAR. Bottom of lineup? Fine.
Ozuna: So many ducks on the pond! .231 RISP in 2019 = yuck.
Moustakas: See the other MM 5 players above.
Brantley: Two healthyish seasons. Solid, unspectacular. DUCK!
Paddack: Innings limit only thing hold him down.
Syndergaard: Best stuff, best hair, best nickname. COULD win Cy Young if all goes right.
Glasnow: Four seamer CHECK! Curve? Check!……
Berrios: More K’s = Cy Young conversation.
Seager: Isn’t the #1 prospect we thought he was. And we let him off the hook.
Kepler: Juiced ball beneficiary. But solid lineup for team stats. Think 25 HRs — not 35.
Dahl: Is he injured yet?
Buxton: See Dahl.
Gotta decide between Corbin in the 10th round(stole him in the 20th a couple years ago) or Paddack in the 15th and it’s making me crazy. Any advice?
Paddack for me too.
Take the yout. He’s got a higher ceiling.
ESPN, 6 player keep forever, 5X5, head to head … keeper question.
Keep for sure: Acuna, Bellinger, Betts, Tatis, Flaherty
Last keeper between Scherzer, Huira, Mondesi, Robert
I have flip flopped several times on this … who would you suggest given my 5 other keepers?
Keep forever I’d rank them Hiura, Robert, Mondesi, Scherzer.
The only thing holding me back on Robert is the K:BB ratio.
Thanks, interesting … I was kind of leaning in the Huira, Robert direction. Grey was on Mondesi …
Curious how much of a gap you feel there is between Huira and Robert? I am intrigued with Robert … I know if I let him go I will not get him back.
Thoughts? And thanks in advance.
I totally understand the Robert love (hell even Eloy called him the next Mike Trout) but he isn’t a 100% given just yet. Could he be? Sure. But Hiura has ABs under his belt, plays a weaker position and is still a fantastic player.
They’re close — but I am a very risk-averse player.
I think mondesi may jump top a 4.5 cat… depending on Obp skills and health. Much like Trea Turner he needs health .
I tend top value quantity. SB is a rare category and so is average. He has the speed, the power to hit 20 plus if healthy and possibly hit. 270 plus.
Seems everyone expects meadows to be the next 5cat stud. If Tampa will move him between 1to4 in the lineup. I expect him to approach 35 20 this year and get 90 plus ribs and runs. Everyone expects a .300 plus average and I agree. Health is the key.
Yea I was low on Mondesi last year too. I get it — he could steal 60 bags any given year. But what will his health & average look like?
Yea — I’m ready for Meadows to move up. If Rays make the Yankees sweat this year he could garner some MVP votes with a good season. 30/20 with solid team stats and a great average is the hope (and room for more!)
Just joined a start up Hometown League. You have to have at least 4 players from your hometown team on the roster and you get to pre select two players before the full draft. It is basically a dynasty league (keep 18). I have Houston.
Are Bregman and Yordan the no brainer selections to protect before the draft?
This sounds like a really fun league format!
Bregman and Yordan = yes definitely.
Gotta choose 2 keepers in a H2H league with 9 batting cats (R, RBI, HR, SB, AVG, K, BB, TB, Fielding%). I don’t love any of my guys with these cats, they all either have horrible K/BB ratios or have other warts/can be redrafted.
I also have Nola and Paddack. My gut says keep 2 hitters but then I look at my hitters and get sad cuz none are studs.
How much risk are you willing to take?
For me — I play it safe and go Baez/Marte for the across the board production.
I like the simple matrix to come up with values. It is sinple but effective. I like the approach and I am a statistical freak.
If I knew someone who was good at math & excel I could really perfect this thing.
So my final keeper decision is between Harper and Y. Alvarez. I am coming back with the following players:
Should I keep Harper at $35 or Y. Alvarez at $6? Who will have the better year and is most needed on my team with who I have coming back? Thanks.
Y. Alvarez at $6, giddy up
I like Yordan at $6 for the value, but like Harper better than Chapman, Machado, Kershaw, Glasnow, and Kimbrell. Not sure how your league works/if you can make that call.
Alvarez at $6. HUGE value and that’s what this game is all about.
Track his knees though for the next few days.
I also don’t really love Kimbrel — I typically don’t keep relievers.
I just received an interesting offer in my 14 team h2h dynasty league. I was offered wilson contreras andrew vaugn seth corry for gary sanchez casey mize and logan gilbert, not sure how I feel about losing all this sp depth, but getting vaugn seems like the safer prospect. Should I consider this trade?
c gary sanchez
1b jose abreu
2b ozzie albies
3b rafael devers
ss bo bichette
lf juan soto
cf ronald acuna
rf austin meadows
Util yuli gurriel
bn cj cron
bn domingo santana
na robert puason
na corbin carroll
na jeter downs
na julio rodriquez
sp brandon woodruff
sp julio urias
sp max scherzer
Sp robbie ray
rp ty buttery
rp ryan pressly
P Kevin Gausman
p zach efflin
p jon lester
bn alex wood
bn deivi garcia
bn sixto sanchez
bn edward cabrera
na logan gilbert
na luis patino
na casey mize
Ehhhh — I agree with you on the SP depth. Mize and Gilbert could anchor your pitching stats for years.
Kerry, if you were rebuilding a deep dynasty team, would you trade Freeman for Eloy+? I’m trying to target young guys that basically can’t miss. Eloy seems like a good one. Anyone else you’d recommend?
For a rebuilding 100% definitely. Who else does the Eloy owner have? That’ll dictate the offer.
Freeman for Eloy might be a good enough offer — but let’s see what else we can get.
(My initial thought is someone of Kingery quality)
Then you and I are thinking the same. Good to know. Thank you.
This is awesome stuff. Thank you! Looking at SP’s, I don’t see a full point difference between Flaherty and Bieber. They seem very close in most projections – what are you seeing differently?
Re-looking at my stats — as embarrassing as this — that may be a typo. It should say 3.75.
This is way too sensible – where’s our Beckett Price Guide of all the most-hyped players with inflated market values?
Seriously though, nice list — pretty refreshing, actually.
I agree on McNeil – he gives you a little of everything + average. Hard to ignore, if he weren’t a Met.
Correa so low…probably a realistic projection, but we all know what he is capable of.
Mondesi – should he get 2 points for steals?
I feel like Robles will take a step forward this year in AVG, although he looked a little lost in the postseason, which is usually a good indicator of studhood.
I’ve seen a bunch of sites predicting the Mets win the East. I have the Braves because a lot has to bounce the right way for the Mets to win.
Correa was my guy for a few years — but he can’t stay healthy and he’s not stealing bases. I WANT him to be better — but he’s gotta show me something. Also this is completely unscientific – but I”m not keeping him for the first time in a few years so he’ll probably win the MVP.
Mondesi — lol that’s actually a great point. He’s a freak-a-leak on the basepath.
I like Robles this year — maybe he tired with that many games.
Additional detail/thoughts on Yordan Alvarez?
After today’s knee news — I’m not sure.
Before today’s knee news: 40+ HRs, great team stats and a .300+ average. Easily.
Don’t even care about the UTIL only slot.
Great list. Loving the enthusiasm for Eloy + Franmil. Definitely dreaming on the upside of Eloy being the next generation of Arenado, easy .300 40+ indefinitely, no speed. Been trying to acquire Franimal but the other owner wanted my Scherzer ($34) for him ($13), which was a little too much to jump.
On Chapman, he claims to be working on his with to try and hit .300 + 40 HR this year. Who isn’t?! That said, nice to hear that he’s trying to improve AVG without sacrificing power, and he’s improved every year so far…
Yea for this year Scherzer is the better bet — especially because we don’t know what level of ball juiciness.
Chapman has an MVP in him if he gets a .300 and the forgotten Athletics make the playoffs again.