Jacob Misiorowski (7 IP, 0 ER, 4 hits, zero walks 10 Ks, ERA at 2.12) needs to get through a whole season without losing his command like he did in the 2nd half of last year. Still a lot of time for that to happen. Remember, we all thought he might be the best rookie ever when he first came up last year, then, poof, like Keyzer Sozë it went bye-bye. But, if he does hold his command all year, he’s a top three starter. Basically, Skenes, Sanchez, Mis. Maybe not that order. Ooh, he floats a possibility! Skenes for sure first, but Sanchez or Mis? What about Sanchmiz and we don’t decide because it’s only mid-May. Sancho Miz likes that idea, that’s the masked luchador who is standing on your roof waiting to pounce on top of your head as soon as you walk outside. Don’t take my word for it, climb onto your roof to see. Right now, The IO Update’s perfs are 14.1 K/9, 3 BB/9, and I am hooting that’s so gorge. Wait there’s more! Literally! He’s thrown more 102 and 103 MPH pitches than all other MLB starter in the Statcast era combined (2008-2026). He’s prime deGrom. He’s prime Sale. He’s prime rib, baby, I’m salivating! Though, now that I think about The IO Update’s fantasy value might take a hit because Aaron Ashby is behind him trying to take away all his wins. Does Ashby take the mound dressed as a vulture for the wins he steals? I find answers compelling, so tell me. Anyway, here’s what else I saw yesterday in fantasy baseball:
Michael King – 5 2/3 IP, 1 ER, 8 baserunners, 5 Ks, ERA at 2.63. Now, he is not close to this good. King’s looking pauper-y.
Gavin Sheets – 2-for-4, 3 RBIs and his 6th homer. Appropriately enough, SHEETS! was what people who roster Misiorowski were screaming when he lost the win. “Hey, man, you have to give up the lead to teams who don’t have Mason Miller.” That’s Aaron Ashby taking Abner Uribe (1 IP, 3 ER, ERA at 4.96) under his wing.
Robby Snelling – Hit the IL with a UCL sprain. Glengarry Glen Ross’s Shelley crosses “Snelling” off his list of potential things he can “Always Be” doing. The Rock whispers, “I don’t know what the Snelling be cooking.” A 3rd grader sobs, “If you Snelt it, you dealt with an elbow injury!” The bright, shining star of positive news comes from the Marlins bringing up Braxton Garrett to replace Snelling. My most Braxton thought is why was he in the minors? I’m seriously not sure. On January 8th, 2025, he had UCL surgery. He was ready since Spring Training, and had a 3.66 ERA in 159 2/3 IP in his last full season with the Marlins (2023). He’s been ready to join the Marlins for months. Actually, thought he’d be up before Snelling. Braxton’s been a number three starter in the majors already. He’s struggled a bit with command during his rehab, but that’s always the last thing to return after surgery. He’s rosterable everywhere, assuming his command is back. I’m not making that assumption, I’m just saying where he’ll be if he shows it. Now, to return to mourning Snelling. I didn’t even get to use the pun, that’s just Robby Whiffing hitters! Damn it!
Pete Fairbanks – Activated from the IL. Oh, thank God, I can stop speculating on stupid Marlins saves. Goodbye, Faucher, don’t let the door hit ya, where the good Lord split ya. Listen, Phillips, you don’t have to go home, but you can’t stay here. Sorry, Nardi, pardi’s over–Actually, no, I never rostered him.
Owen Caissie – 1-for-3, 2 runs, 2 RBIs and his 3rd homer, hitting .202. I’d say the Cubs won the Caissie/EdCab trade, but I don’t think the Marlins were trying to win it, which is kind of a problem in MLB.
Max Meyer – 5 2/3 IP, 4 ER, 9 baserunners, 9 Ks, ERA at 3.21. His underlying numbers are great. Better than I remembered. He looks like a solid number two to three with potential.
Byron Buxton – 2-for-4 and his 14th and 15th homer. So, how does this work now? Does he not hit a home run in his next game because he hit two or does he now hit two more in his next game? Kalshi needs to know!
Bryce Miller – 5 1/3 IP, 2 ER, 9 baserunners, 3 Ks, as he was activated from the IL. Was only supposed to throw a few innings and piggyback with Luis Castillo, but Miller’s way too good for that. Getting the sense Miller’s available in some leagues, and he shouldn’t be.
J.P. Crawford – 2-for-5 and his 5th homer, and that’s four homers in his last 12 games, and has appeared in the last two Buy columns, because he’s been hot for about that long.
Luke Raley – 2-for-3 and his 9th homer. He’s been towards the top of the 7-day Player Rater for the last, well, seven days.
Christian Walker – 1-for-5 and his 10th homer. Onward Christian Walker!
Lance McCullers Jr. – 5 1/3 IP, 2 ER, 9 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 6.86. Some would say the best thing you can do is leave your fantasy team alone in April, and the people who picked up McCullers that first week might attest.
Kumar Rocker – 5 IP, 0 ER, 7 baserunners (4 BBs), 3 Ks, ERA at 4.34. No idea where Harold is but Kumar got something from White Castle called a Jake Burger.
Jake Burger – 2-for-4, 3 RBIs and his 7th homer, and now batting in the 8-hole. White Castle is actually good. I’m sorry, Jake’s a sad burger: wet lettuce, homemade ketchup that’s varieties-less, stale bread, pickles that were just cucumbers in someone’s butt.
Jacob Latz – 0 IP, 3 ER, ERA at 2.08 vs. Paul Sewald – 2/3 IP, 3 ER, ERA at 4.70. Well, not really “vs.” but combined Paul Sewald and Latz were a Pautz.
Ryne Nelson – 7 IP, 3 ER, 4 hits, zero walks, 8 Ks, ERA at 5.40. Ryne is a career 4.30 ERA pitcher. He’s doing himself proud this year by staying true to his roots. Streamonator is vaguely meh on his next start, and same.
Nick Kurtz – 2-for-4, 4 RBIs and his 6th homer. Ya know what I want? A four-homer game. Give me that, Kurtz.
Zack Gelof – 1-for-4 and his 4th homer, hitting .257. This is not your slightly older brother’s Gelof who couldn’t hit for average. This is your slightly older older brother’s Gelof who could hit .260.
J.T. Ginn – 6 IP, 1 ER, 10 baserunners, 3 Ks, ERA at 3.12. His initials stand for Jsorta Tusable. The J.T. are silent, oddly enough.
Shohei Ohtani – 7 IP, 0 ER, 6 baserunners, 8 Ks, ERA at 0.82. Can’t believe he’s taking days off from hitting now. Being a top five starter is not enough, okay?
Mookie Betts – 1-for-4 and his 3rd homer. Mookie Best!
Robbie Ray – 4 2/3 IP, 3 ER, ERA at 3.04. He got into a few jams and he couldn’t wriggle out, kinda like his pants.
Anthony Volpe – 0-for-3 as he hit 8th. I gave you my longwinded thoughts on Volpe yesterday. Scroll on, scroller.
Max Fried – 3 IP, 3 ER, ERA at 3.21, and left with elbow soreness. Oh no, not my favorite pitcher. I’m gonna have to find a way to replace him on all zero of my teams. How will I ever do it?
Dylan Beavers – Hit the IL with an oblique strain. That means my IL slot is now stuffed with regret.
Kyle Bradish – 6 IP, 0 ER, 1 hit, 3 walks, 7 Ks, ERA at 4.21. As I kept saying in April about Bradish and what I keep saying about Eury, you never know when these guys are going to figure it out. It appears that Bradish has figured it out. It just took a tweak to “you rostering him in your fantasy league.” Bradish can be an ace, and you absolutely should get back in if you can.
Adley Rutschman – 1-for-3, 3 RBIs and his 6th homer, hitting .291. Every time I see anything from Basallo or Adley, all I can think is how the O’s have one half-decent starter and a catcher they could easily trade for an arm.
Angel Martinez – 1-for-4, 2 runs and a slam (7) and double legs (7, 8), 2nd homer in two games, three steals in two games, and now hitting leadoff. I’d say hot schmotato, but usually reserve that for guys under 50% rostered, and not sure Angel is, but if he’s out there, he’s clearly hot.
Parker Messick – 6 2/3 IP, 2 ER, 7 baserunners, 7 Ks, ERA at 2.35. Underlying stats are still pretty. We will continue to Parker like we’re on Blueberry Hill.
Zach Neto – 2-for-3, 2 RBIs and his 7th homer. Don’t have Neto in any league so I didn’t realize how poorly he was doing. He’s been around the 7th best shortstop and are you kidding complaining about that? I’m over here with Lindor who’s done diddly squat! That’s different than Reese McGuire. That’s a diddle squat.
Reid Detmers – 5 2/3 IP, 3 ER, 8 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 4.38. Someone by the username of Reddit Meers said Reid Detmers was an ace–Hey, wait a minute! Detmers always underperforms his underlying stats, but he is pitching better this year. Previously, he was a 4.00 ERA guy, and now he’s around a 3.75 one. Baby steps, Bob.
Drake Baldwin – 1-for-4 and his 11th homer. It feels like he has twice as many homers I’ve mentioned him so much, right? Drake must just have a Hotline Bling to his name. Boo! Boo me!
Mauricio Dubon – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 3rd homer, hitting leadoff, and .263. Braves won’t give Harris II the leadoff spot, but Dubon, they’re like,”Go ahead, champ.”
JR Ritchie – 4 1/3 IP, 1 ER, ERA at 3.32. His peripherals are atrociously awful, and he’s got a rock solid ERA because the Shroud of Touki. Don’t believe me, I don’t care.
Shota Imanaga – 7 IP, 2 ER, 5 hits, zero walks, 6 Ks, ERA at 2.32. This year he’s not gonna waste his Shota.
Framber Valdez – 6 2/3 IP, 2 ER, 7 baserunners, 7 Ks, ERA at 4.32. Look at that, a solid start and he didn’t randomly bean anyone. A win-win, or rather, a win-win-no decision.
Christian Scott – 4 2/3 IP, 2 ER, ERA at 3.45. Regarding the winless Scott, Ron Darling was talking about how it took a while for him to get his first win, eventually he did, throwing a complete game on his final start of the season, and that led into a convo about how no rookie would ever throw a complete game now, and that had me thinking about dinner, because I was eating at the time. Fin, story complete.
Mitch Keller – 5 2/3 IP, 6 ER, ERA at 3.59. Why can’t regression come when he’s, like, on the road in Yankee Stadium or somewhere where I’d bench him? Why at home vs. the pitiful road Suckies? Why, why, why, to quote Nancy Kerrigan.
Ryan O’Hearn – 2-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 6th homer, hitting .287. O’Hearn’s putting up one of those seasons where it might feel like watching paint dry, but it’s surprisingly valuable. Call it a Dutch Boy.
Mickey Moniak – 3-for-5, 5 RBIs and his 12th homer, hitting .315. He was basically free in drafts or off waivers, but the thing is: He shouldn’t have been. He was good last year.
TJ Rumfield – 3-for-4, 2 runs and his 6th homer, 2nd homer in a week. Hot schmotato alert (mostly because the Suckies are going home)!
Seth Lugo – 5 IP, 5 ER, ERA at 3.76. Think he’s back to a Streamonator.
Bobby Witt Jr. – 1-for-3, 2 runs, 2 RBIs and his 7th homer, and 2nd in two games, third in four games, and fourth in a week. Tatis, hello, pay attention to the Joys de Witt bounce back like a bra-less Chrissy Snow.
Colson Montgomery – 3-for-4, 2 runs and his 11th homer, hitting .230. I could be missing it, but I think he’s seldom spoken of in glowing terms and woefully under-appreciated. Glow! Appreciate!
Noah Schultz – 4 1/3 IP, 3 ER, ERA at 4.91. Little peek behind the curtain. I write these all sorts of out of order. I held back on Noah, because I saw he had a no-hitter through three and I was thinking he might be the lede if he kept it going, and ha! Almost!
Griffin Jax – 5 IP, 0 ER, 8 baserunners, 1 K, ERA at 3.91, as he finally seems stretched out as a starter. Or as a Rays’ starter. He’s as stretched as Rasmussen or McClanahananananan. For the Rays’ next trick, they will turn Cedric Mullins into a lights-out reliever.
Dylan Cease – 7 IP, 1 ER, 6 baserunners, 9 Ks, ERA at 2.41. His numbers say he’s a top seven starter. At the very least.
Daulton Varsho – 1-for-4, 4 RBIs and his 5th homer. I’d love to see him get hot. Please, grant me a wish, and stop smiting me with “having to start Jake Irvin.”
Roman Anthony – Making incremental progress. Red Sox manager Chad Tracy said, “Eventually, we’ll get to strong gripping. That’s the biggest thing for him: when do we get to feel like the grip strength is there? When we’re in there, we’re in a better spot.” Right now, he’s at the grip strength where they drop a went salmon between his hands and he has to try to grab it.
Trevor Story – 2-for-3 and his 3rd homer. “We could use his body as sandbags in case of heavy downpour-Hold on! Story moved! He’s alive!”
Sonny Gray – 6 IP, 1 ER, 3 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 3.18. Gray, him, just needed Grey, me, to not be interested this year.
Andrew Painter – 5 IP, 1 ER, 4 hits, zero walks, 4 Ks, ERA at…Guess. Go ahead! What could it be? Guess within .50 on his ERA. How hard could it be–Bzzt! Wrongo! It’s 6.21.
Justin Crawford – 1-for-3 and his 2nd homer. He returned to Fenway, where his dad once played, and homered. That’s gotta be cool. Next, he can rip off Megan Thee Stallion of her recording contract money like his dad. (You think I’m kidding.)
Daylen Lile – 2-for-4, 3 RBIs and a slam (6) and legs (3), hitting .269, and third homer in two games. Is that 2026 preseason sleeper Daylen Lile? Hot damn, it is!
Keibert Ruiz – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 3rd homer, and 2nd homer in four games. My promise to you is if you ask me Keibert vs. any other starting catcher, I will just pick the other guy. Except maybe Patrick Bailey.
Nick Lodolo – 4 IP, 5 ER, ERA at 8.68. Commercial offers for Blistex aren’t about to roll in.
Chris Paddack – Signed with the Reds. Ya know, I was thinking where could a guy with a 1.8 HR/9 go after Miami to become valuable? I came up with the idea of him pitching in Jupiter. Not Jupiter, Florida, but Jupiter the planet, because its gravity is 2.5 times stronger than Earth. I never considered Cincy.
Ola Grey!
Quick Query:
POINTS league..12-team, very shallow (only 3 OF/DH active spots)..
For Rest of Season, please pick two:
Bleday
Ward
Nimmo
Lile
Sheets
Benge
Thanks Fantasy Master Lothario Do Not Abbreviate you Rat Bastreds!!
Dropping Bradish was my fault for listening to bad advice.
D
Parker messick or Kevin Guaman rest of season, we account qs and wins and losses
Gausman
Grey, drop Stowers for either Bleday or Lile or would you hold?
Hold
Hey Grey! I saw you sided with patience re: Lodolo, but I imagine you’d say pull the trigger to drop him for Kyle Harrison. Correct?
Yes
What’s good Grey? So, I like my pitchers in the 12-team H2H keeper league that I play in, but they’ve sucked for the most part. Thinking of making a change and got two others for you as well.
(1) Would you add Braxton Garrett, Zebby Matthews or Christian Scott OVER any of my current starting pitchers?
Noah Schultz
Landon Roupp
Andrew Abbott
Nick Lodolo (kinda want to wait on him)
Logan Henderson
Bubba Chandler
(2) I loved Kyle Stowers last season, but he’s just…meh. Would you drop him for either Carson Benge, Heliot Ramos, Luke “Hotpants” Raley or Ceddane Rafaela?
(3) I drafted Luke Keaschall really early this year, but he’s just been brutal. Would you drop him for either Ceddane Rafaela or Zach Gelof?
Appreciate the input as always and hello to Ted.
Ted says hi! Scott over Bubba 2. Meh I’d hold 3. Yes Gelof
TY
Best chance to stick on a 12 teamer long term….Soroka or Mize?
Soroka
1.) Looking for a bat while i wait for soderstrom to not be unlucky and chourio to do anything.
Gelof, Benge or Varsho (im really wanting varsho to be a thing)
2) Lost Dollander and Snelling back to back days to likely the same thing. B.Miller swaps with Snelling who’s the grab for Doll?
Taillon, C.Scott, Zebby, Ober
My jjbleday irrational fomo is only getting fomo-ier. added S.Steer but hes not cutting it.
1 Gelof 2. Scott
yep, my exact answer when anybody wonders about ruiz the catcher. him and bailey like for sure the worst 2 hitting catchers with some minimum starts last 4ish or whatever years. if you add either you are in a VERY deep spot and badly need a catcher right now, and don’t want to input the effort (and/or don’t have enough adds per week if a h2h) to stream that spot literally every day or almost. bailey worse.
Ha, yup
12 Team H2H 6×6 OPS Redraft
Please rank these OF options ROS:
Ewing, Bleday, Lile
Thanks
Bleday, Lile
Follow up question:
SVHD
Need two of the following:
Whitlock, Fairbanks, Uribe, Cleavinger, Vesia
Thanks again kind sir!
Whitlock, Vesia
Would you mind clarifying… you say Bryce Miller should not be available in most leagues, but on the rankings I have, it shows him at #392 and a 4.23/1.37 for ratios. What changed?
what changed from someone else’s rankings? I don’t know, they’re not mine
No, I meant your rankings but the version I am referring to. Current ranking page shows him at #386 and the same ratios. Just curious what to be optomistic about since he is available in most of my leagues.
I don’t have any rankings that go up to #386. Maybe they’re Rudy’s ROS rankings
The Burger take got a little dark. LOL
Nick Lowe or Grayson ROS?
Nick Lowe, the singer? Grayson
I thought there was a singer named Nick Lowe. A old pop guy. Maybe not. Thanks BTW.
Haha
Just Googled it. “Cruel to Be Kind”
Excellent song
Could be a rockpile too
Sorry, Nate. Nick’s the singer.
a really weird 14’er roto dynasty, weird since:
(-) players (mostly, this isn’t 100% true but pretty close) don’t enter system till called up, some goofy yahoo spot. it’s real “fun” homework predraft figuring out which guys ARE already in system every year, and clearly not everybody does that homework, right during draft whoever gets drafted and others: “oh crap i didn’t know he was available” etc comes out quite a lot. this creates a spot where FAAB holding the whole 100 of it, and waiting till a good waiver tiebreaker (reverse standings from last year on this as it should be) to use ANY of the FAAB for the tippy top prospects. not all owners do this, and many values can be found at much cheaper of course.
(-) scoring has: OBP replace AVG (this not that weird i wiped out AVG in all my leagues a long time ago anyway, i don’t run this one though), and slugging replacing HR’s, the comish wanted to balance 2 ratios for both hitters/pitchers.
have this, somehow been top 3 team all year (mostly 1st, which only seems odd as last year with near identical roster i was more 7th-9th)
shallow yahoo rosters, so no CI or MI and only 3 OF, 1 util, 1500 max innings. i got waiver 4 now, it didn’t really matter till around top 5 at all, one would be quite sure to not win any top prospect even if bidding 100.
C: goodman (him losing OF sucks here), w.smith, basallo
1B: burleson (OF), eldridge
2B: h.kim (LAD, SS/OF), semien
SS: b.lee (2B/3B, used the full 100 late a few years back on him, as did others)
3B: riley
OF: (3): moniak, o.cruz, merrill, grisham
util (1)
IR: edman, stanton
stash spots: (3): k.alcantara (CUBS)
SP: m.king, gausman, henderson, n-mart, burke, wacha, kirby, soroka, eovaldi
RP: (3, and saves only); ROB, vodnik, b.king
IR: e.diaz, steele
stash: d.espino, t.gibson
so both bolte and ewing off waivers shortly, would you blast the whole 100/4th waiver at either, from rankings ewing higher (both itch and others, esp ewing he’s very high on) and i’m pretty steals weak and his lack of HR’s aren’t as bad here from slugging over HR’s. grisham pretty likely the drop here as my depth at IF (non catcher) being a lot worse than OF.
or wait for one of these (noted as up at some point this year by either itch and/or other spots): j.made, LDV, emerson, clark, jenkins, t.white (SP), k.anderson, a.miller, b-mont (WSOX), those ranked clearly higher by itch/and others.
I’d wait for a higher prospect like clark or made etc
10 team weekly standard roto.
Is Messick for Soder fair?
Sure
Would you trade Soder to get Messick or would you want more? I was offered Messick, but unsure about pulling the trigger.
I’d want more
Soderstrom goes 0-5, seeing 12 total pitches. ONE called strike. The Soder is flat.
Sigh, it is
Just to sound the sad trombone again, I have Eugenio, Brown, Taj and Woodruff already on the IL (not to mention Eovaldi DTD) – and it’s getting hard to justify holding Yelich. Is he a drop? He wouldn’t get a lot of use in my lineup, even on those rare occasions when he’s healthy enough…
Sure
Streamonator loves Sheehan today. I wish i had the same level of excitement.
Same
Hey Grey,
Here is my team (10-team league):
Herrera, C
Pasqauntino, 1B
Marte, 2B
Abrams,SS
Riley, 3B
Tucker,OF
Chourio, OF
Wood, OF
Alvarez,Utl.
DeLauter, Bench
Starting Pitchers:
Ohtani
Soroka
Gausman
C. Sanchez
Rasmussen
Cantillo
R. Suarez
Bubic
E.Cabrera
L. Henderson
Burke
Closers:
O’Brien
S. Dominquez
Palencia
IL:
Woodruff
Mize
C. Burnes
-Would you drop DeLauter (and go with 0 offensive bench players) to add Mize off the IL or cut a pitcher (and if so, which one)?
-Would you cut any of the above to add a 4th closer (Killian best available)?
-Previously dropped Bichette to pick up Riley…would you ride Riley for awhile, or drop for Muncy or Jung?
Thanks!
Lose Burke
–no
Muncy
12 team roto league with OBP and QS. Grey, 1. Drop Sal Frelich for Tyler O’Neil? 2. With Dollander hurt, drop him for either Ryne Nelson, Christian Scott, or Griffin Jax? 3. Since I am not guaranteed to get the pitcher I want, how would you rank them?
1 no 2/3. Scott, Nelson
Is Logan H. a drop for Bradish and or B. Miller (2 leagues)?
Bradish
Also have Leiter in 1 league and Tolle in both.
Bleday more than a schmotato? I could drop Ramon for him. Adames also on the wire. Would be for a bench bat
Bleday over Ramon
Thanks, Grey. Still dishing the advice late in the day!
LFG!
Drop Dollander to activate Mize for his return this weekend? Dollander cooked and droppable regardless?
Thanks!
Yes
Vientos or Steer?
Vientos
Please rank: Taylor Ward; Bleday; Jake Bauers; Rumfield; Ryan Waldschmidt. Thanks.
You did
Would I be over reacting by dropping B Garrett for Zebby? Lol
unless this is for a really deep league you added one or both in the last few days likely, or hours if zebby. also go back like 1.5 or so years, probably less, consensus was quite on zebby’s side anyway.
short answer: for non deep spots it’s not a permanent answer, i.e. check SON as at most depths they’re both streamers. i know in NL only where it’s real hard to get to min innings when people get injured and the dearth of any SP’s in FA i grabbed and held garrett the second paddack got cut, held even when snelling noted as getting that job. did similar in AL only but it was a.morris i went with the exact second j.ryan looked hurt like a week+ ago, zebby was called up with small timeframe before noted.
Sure
After losing Lindor and Caballero at SS I’m looking for a replacement in a 12 team H2H points league with pickup limits. My options are Ha-Seong Kim, Duran or Rocchio. I’m thinking Kims the best bet right?
Sure, Kim
What up Grey! I have a decent but underperforming team… I effed up and traded JRod early for pennies (you already gave me ish for it) Question is, is Kwan worth holding on to, or should I drop for a hotter bat like Reynolds or Adell and just stream hitters in that spot? Or I could grab Ewing. I’m panicking…. Thanks as always!
Lose Kwan for Adell
Would you move Wheeler to land freeman? Starters include Wheeler, Brax Ash, Freddy P, Spaghetti, and Joe Ryan (w Hunter Brown and Schmidt on the IL). Already have Harper at 1B and Murakami and Reynolds for UTL bat.
Sure
Do I play him over Murakami? OPS league (no avg or K penalty)
No
Jezuz H bleepin’ Krist. 100 pitches for Kyle Harrison to get through five. I think he went full count on just about everyone. Efficiency is not his calling card
Ha
Bleday with 2 slams and 6 RBI today, including one off the lefty starter, so he’s not in a platoon anymore. Stats are backing up the fire engine red Statcast page…
The monocle is getting HOT. Could this be the long awaited breakout for a post post post hype prospect?
Hopefully!
Would u drop any of Delauter,Ward,Varsho or Bolte for either of Yelich or Teoscar ?
Are these starters? Bolte for Yelich assuming he’s healthy
12 teamer, rank’em RPS…Detmers, Schultz, Garrett, M.Kelly
Detmers, Noah
McLain or Bazzana ROS? Thanks!
Bazzana
Hi Grey! In a 12 team league,my bottom three starting hitters are Laireano,Heliot and Dansby(DH). I have Waldschmidt and Bolte on the bench. I would like to add Grayson Rodriguez but need to make space. Which hitter goes? Or should I hold? Thanks!
Ramon
Grayson Rodriguez 11 Ks in 4.2 at AAA. Any interest?
I would have to drop Joey Cantillo or Christian Scott to make the switch.
Yes
Lose Scott
So happy I dropped a perfectly good set-up man to activate Braxton “there’s a strike zone? Huh, no one ever told me!” Garrett. 2 innings in a row loads the bases without an out. 2nd time he then coughed up a double.
What a joy the Braxton Garrett experience has been. Ow my WHIP!
5 BB. He should have had 6 but Brooks Lee got bored and swung at ball 4 for his only out of the 2nd. 2-0, bases loaded for Bell on a tidy 62 pitches.
Dropped his bum ass already. Gah!
Somehow throws 4 straight balls in the zone to go 0-2 on Bell. What a perfect time to hang a center cut slider belt high.
4-0 Twinkies. 64 pitches, 1 out, runners on 2nd & 3rd and the manger has thrown in the towel. 1.1 IP, 4, 4, 4, 5 BB, 3 K
FML
Incredibly awful
Final line: 1.1 IP, 33.75 ERA, 6.75 WHIP
and remember – he left with runners at 2nd and 3rd, so shockingly, it could have been worse.
Thank you, Faucher
Cut him a break. He got called up and started. It’s not like it was his first ever MLB appearance. If he does it again next time, then you have a clear head.
If he does, he will get that chance on someone else’s roster. Dude was unhittable in AAA.
He couldn’t throw a strike today to save his life. I watched it – he was not competitive at all.
The only amazing part was in the 1st with the bags chucked he got 3 straight K’s.
Then came out and walked the 1st batter on 4 balls that weren’t close. Impressive for all the wrong reasons.
Haha, yeah, brutal
Awful
Andrew Abbott, Sean Burke, or Jacob Lopez?
Abbott
Rank for CI in 5×5 league:
Julien, E. Duran, Rumfield.
Thank you.
Rumfield, Julien
Decided to YOLO on Braxton today and he instantly terrified me by loading the bases. Of all the ways to get out of that jam, three straight strikeouts is definitely the best way!
Following up: 2nd inning, zero command and zero control. Not looking good. Fingers crossed…
Brutal
Not great!
McLain or Stott who’s the drop ? Daily lineups league
McLain
Another one bites the dust. Dollander off with the trainer after surrendering 3 in the first @ Pittsburgh
Bummer
howdy
my staff: Ashcraft, Eovaldi, Kirby, Weathers, McLean, Sheehan, EuryP
Would you swap any of these gents for Bryce Miller?
I’m thinking Eury though the potential could bite me later…. I’ve been bitten before twice shy…
thx
Sure, Eury
Hey Grey!
Any moves below in a 10 Team H2H?
Available pitchers: Bradish, Mize, Bryce Miller
Roster: Schlittler, Warren, Weathers, M King, Harrison, Hancock, Ed Cab, Lodolo, Taj (IL), J Jones (IL), Woodruff (IL)
Meh I’d hold for now
Hi Grey,
I always appreciate your perspective.
I have Alonso at 1B, Freddie Freeman in the DH slot, and Wilmer Abreu in LF, Merrill in CF and Trout in RF
I have Casey Schmidt to back up Altuve. However Luke Riley is available and is hot. He has 1B and all three OF potential available.
I could cut pitchers such as Vasquez or Arrighetti or Roupp or Griffin. I still have visions of bundling these pitchers to improve at 2B. My league is not well known for trades.
1. Would you cut Schmitt to pick up Riley?
2. Would you cut any of these pitchers to get Riley or pass?
Your help is always appreciated!
Thanks!!
1. Sure
Done!
1.Would you try and trade Arrighetti for Alec Burleson?
2. Would you try and trade vasquez for Burleson?
Thanks!
1. yes 2. sure
I need to move Cal Raleigh to the IL and drop one of the following IL pitchers to pick up another catcher:
Hunter Greene
Shane Bieber
I also have Ryan Helsley on the IL
Greene
Dollander throwing meatballs to the Pirates. He had a couple electric games…but wow he dropped off fast. It’s sad, honestly. I like him.
Damn
He is a Rockies pitcher. No such thing as as a reliable Rockies pitcher.
Ranger vs. Luzardo at Boston today. I got both SPs off the wire when other managers gave up on them, which I’m starting to understand with Luz…start both today?
Start both
Thanks!
No problem
Cam Smith or Angel, points redraft
Angel
Would you add Bohm in dynasty he was recently dropped? I would drop Andujar
Yes
Hey Grey,
I have the same issue with The Big Dumper being on the IL now.
Options are Stephenson, Kelly, Mack, and Susac who could be back tomorrow and take over in SF from Rodriquez. Rodriquez, Wells and Realmoto also available.
I’m leaning gambling on Susac but wanted to hear your thoughts.
Why Susac?
Stephenson
Just a feeling based on how he started, there is a clear runway now with Bailey gone, and looks good in his rehab games.
Thanks!
I guess you can try him, it’s not like these other guys are great
Kelly was great last year, not so much this year, unfortunately. Stephenson was very good in ’24, so they both have it in them. I’ll gamble and watch the others. Not like everyone is running to grab any of them. Thanks sir!
No problem
Drop Will Warren to grab Lile off waivers?
No
Hi Grey,
Thanks for all your help! I am glad that I followed your advice on Valdez!
1. I was just going to sit Roupp at LAD. Thoughts?
2. would you start or sit Foster Griffin at Cinn?
Thank you!
1. Sure 2. sit
Thanks!!
No problem
I have to drop someone when Mize gets activated this weekend. Who’s the drop in a 12 tm QS league: Mize, Arrighetti, Miller (SEA)
Arri
12 team, 5×5 roto
Would you start either Angel Martinez or Luis Garcia over Keaschall?
Angel
Hey Grey,
In a 20 team h2h dynasty cats:
Bregman for Colson Montgomery
Yes, its mid May, but my gut is feeling Bregman “looks” and “feels” like he may be a better real life player. Locker room superlatives are grate, but sadly irrelevant (even as a Cubs fan) in fantasy. Bregman side is a contender.
What say you? Breggy or Monty? Idek if they like being called that lol
Thanks for all you do.
Colson
please rank. Bradish, Cabrera, Meyer. Thanks.
You did
have Sewald, Abner & Latz on one team – 9 ER in 1 2/3 IP, ouch!
Ouch
Grey
I have a feeling Raleigh is going on the IL at some point very soon if not later today.
If and when he does who would be your top 2 picks
Valenzuela
Fortes
Kelly
Ruiz
I must be psychic or psychotic take your pick
As soon as I asked the question and hit post I see Raleigh hit the IL
😊
Ha
He was IL’d already
Valenzuela
didn’t see it
But thanks
No problem
Morning & Happy Dance Like A Chicken Day!
I could use your input on whether these SP’s should be dancing on my team/ in my lineup today or get fried on the WW/ bench:
Start/Sit:
Roster/ Cut:
Thanks as always!
Haha…start both
Cut Snelling
NL 10 team keeper league. I have an offer to trade my Bubba Chandler $3 in 2nd year of 3, & a 2028 no1 minor league pick for Webb in last year and his injury replacement Morejon $3 1st year. If Webb were activated Morejon would need an open spot per demotion or injury or would have to be waived. I would also get a 2028 second round minor pick.As I am contending and could always use Ks and [hopefully] good ratios ROS, I am inclined to do it. I do have some concern about Webb’s performance to date and his recent injury. Please critique. Tks.
Works for me
Would I be better off moving $1 Dollander instead of Bubba?
Sure
12 team h2h. is Mitch Keller a drop? is eury perez a drop?
Sure, both
Just noticed someone dropped Machado in one of my leagues. That’s a definite good use of my #2 waiver priority, right?
He can join my squad of disappointments with Ketel, Kwan, Maikel, Vlad, Neto, Yandy, etc.
Yes
Lile or Waldschmidt?
Lile
Can you pick two? Latz, Sewald, Baker, Fairbanks, Dominguez
Baker, Fairbanks
NL-only, LoGuJu, Rengifo or Ha-Seong Kim?
Kim
Trade proposal..which side
15 team OBP rather than BA league and k/bb rather than whip
Gilbert and Messick for Tatis and Seager
The Trade Analyzer significantly likes the hitters over the pitchers, but I think I disagree
Thoughts?
Thanks as usual
I hate it, but I want to say Gilbert…kinda depends who takes over for you at 2B and SS
I didn’t want to prejudice you. I’m trading the pitchers. I need a SS for Cabellero and an outfielder because my outfield sucks. Of course, Tatis fits right in with his suckiness. It’s a deep league and the pitcher replacements are thin, but I think I can get by.
It’s fair enough if you want to take the flyer on the hitters, but they off peripherals-wise and you know Seager’s going to get hurt at some point too
Thanks again
No problem
Hi Grey,
This was a painful write-up – laughing and crying all together.
I swear I followed the don’t touch your team in April wisdom – last year, I made a calendar reminder for myself to not drop anyone after making some incredibly dumb moves last April, and I’ve been getting the notifications over the last few weeks. Proud of myself for doing better not going crazy with the moves over the first month, but not sure it’s paying off!
Anyways, held on longer than I thought I could with Bradish – dropped him right before he made this pivot, you’re welcome everyone! I’ve got Anthony, sigh – they should add grabbing salmon into the statcast metrics. Lodolo, ugh. Nancy Kerrigan, bahaha!
A. Which start would you roll with:
Roupp @LAD
Burke vs CHC
Civale vs SF
Severino vs SF
B. Waldschmidt, Cortes, Bleday, Steer, Marsh, McCarthy – who are the top 2?
Also, who is a buy low pitcher you’d target with one of my bats:
Basallo, Kurtz, Keaschall, EDLC, Maikel, Tucker, Walker, Anthony (IL), Treaturner, Vinnie P.
Maybe Rodon? Snell? Webb?
Haha A. Burke B. to actually start? Marsh, McCarthy
Ewing or Bolte over Marsh or McCarthy?
Ewing over Marsh
Good morning, Grey,
Showing my age a bit but I started hearing Lionel Ritchie when I was reading “Gray him… Grey me…”
Have a roster spot to fill after jettisoning Trev Rogers. 10 tm redraft, OBP and QS H2H.
On one hand, I want to get Jared Jones on my team, with his velocity back and his command also not looking shaky during the rehab starts. For reference, my starters are Ashcraft, EdCab, Tolle, Gore, Harrison, Weathers, Warren, Eovaldi, with Webb on the IL.
There’s also two bats on the wire that have been as hot as anyone: Lile and also JJ Bleday, where the latter’s Savant page is about as ridiculously red as you can have. Since Bleday has been recalled, he has produced as a top 15 bat. Lile is also scorching in the top 25 over that period, and is a top 3 batting producer over the last 10 days in my format.
My weakest bat right now is Stowers, who had one sign of waking up after a slam and double as part of a 3-4 day last week, but he hasn’t built on that would not be adverse to starting Lile or Bleday over him, at least for now.
How would you prioritize filling my Rogers roster spot between Jones, Lile and Bleday?
Assuming you would also not drop Stowers, is there another pitcher (Gore/EdCab/Warren or Tolle?) I should also consider dropping to get both Jones and one of the FA bats on my squad?
Have an excellent afternoon. Thanks!!!
Haha, Grey it for always, that’s the way it should be….Jones, Lile, that order, can’t see losing anyone, so just Jones for now
Love it. Would buy the T-shirt. Thanks again!
Ha, No problem
Haha, love it!!!
was just offered J-rod for Juan Soto. I do need steals, what do you guys think?
JRod
Start or sit Kyle Harrison today vs Padres?
Start
Bleday is a bench bat for me now that I acquired Happ and Bux. WW has Soroka, Mize, J Jones on it. Swap for one or aim higher in a trade (M Meyer?). Or is either option acceptable?
Meyer’s not higher
Martinez is the first player with 3 Slam & Legs this season.
Damn, I knew he did do it on back to back days
Roto weekly redraft , is time to start thinking of putting Othani as a SP instead of batter on certain weeks.
That time was a month ago
ah the fond boyhood memories of 70s bra-less sitcoms. Chrissy Snow dancing is something to behold
Haha
Good morning Grey! Indians Angel Martinez or Phillies Brandon Marsh in the OF rest of season in a 12 team Points league?
Angel
Hey Grey!
Bradish BACK in the circle of trust!? oh, man. <slams computer shut, jumps out window>
I had Eury, droppped. Had Bradish, dropped. Had Sheehan, bye!
I had and dropped most of your your Tier 6 pre-season rankings. (say McLean,Miz,Schittler as they were gone)
Now what am I do with this stupid tuxedo shirt I got fitted for, huh? know any bat mitzvah’s I can crash? lol.
Still holding on to Lodolo and Yesavage tho..(feel like a dummy)
So, drop Lodolo or Yesavage for Bradish? or wait n see…
10tm H2H
Thanks!
Wait and see
First Rudy clotheslines me with the Heat Miser/Cold Miser title, then you jump off the top rope and nail me with the Crawford V. Stallion rabbit hole I almost didn’t escape from. Well played, gentlemen.
Are you starting Ranger at home (after his long layoff) against Luzardo & Phils? Any chance you’re throwing Roupp out there on the road against Sheehan & Dodgers? I know you’re a braver man than me.
If you absolutely had to drop one of Roupp, Tolle, Logan H or Kyle Harrison to activate Bryce Miller, who might that be? Related: Does Woodruff’s return affect my two brewers?
Many thanks!
Haha, sorry!
I’d start Ranger everywhere until further notice
I would start Roupp
Logan is drop
on 3/18 I traded away Mis for Ben Rice. Both studs but who won that trade?
Ask in 3 months
Hey hey hey, Grey, Grey, Grey!
No Bolte notes??? 2 for 2 with a walk. Seems pretty good for nervy debut.
Check out the highlights: https://www.mlb.com/news/a-s-prospect-henry-bolte-makes-mlb-debut
And PLEASE see 0:36 for a highlight among highlights. Please. Just trust me.
Lurves!!!!
What am I looking at, how fast he is or Nolan Gorman not being able to play 3rd? Lurves always
Those were 2 errors pre- Manfred.
Manfred hired all liars to be scorekeepers
Go to 0:36. There is one person in that Sutter Health crowd of 800 that caught my creepy eye.
It’s 9:30 AM, go take a cold shower
ahahahhaha
Yo Grey!
Firstly, would you kindly rank these outfielders? And would you dump one for O’Hearn?
Chourio
Waldschmidt
Nimmo
Secondly, would you give up on Ketel Marte yet (even drop in a 12 team)?
Thirdly, you into either Night Manager or Margo’s Got Money Problems? Both great shows.
Thank you!
Chourio, O’Hearn, Wald
No on Ketel
I loved Night Manager, didn’t watch Margo yet
Dump Chourio? 😬
Well I didn’t necessarily mean “dump,” but I’ve been a little off the grid. The rule changes and my team’s bad announcer have me fighting to not hate baseball. Thanks to you both!
Brooks Lee, Comson or Story for SS ROS?
Colson or B. Lowe for MI ROS?
Colson
Lowe
Hey Grey! Would you trade a nonkeeper Strider or $4 Luzardo for:
Any two of Taj (il but doesn’t sound serious), Foster Griffin, Antonacci?
Might be able to get Corbin Burnes as one of the two returning pieces but not sure
Thanks!
No
Tho, if playing for next year, I guess Strider doesn’t matter, but I’d want more
thanks! playing for this year (as long as im not losing out on someone important for 27, which is none of these guys). Appreciate it!
No problem
Here’s a fun fact. Jorge Polanco 2/40M to replace Alonso, has already missed more games as a Met, than Pete did in his 7 years. The good news, Mets fans won’t have to see Pete decline in 2030, when he’ll only play 140 games and hit 30 homers.
Haha
Are we still extrapolating Gunnar as a 49/20 along with a sizzling sub Mendoza line batting average? Or is it time to admit he’s nothing more than a middle infielder version of Joey Gallo? And no he’s not getting to 40 HRs, notwithstanding extrapolation arithmetic with that strikeout rate.
Ok
Start yes or no
Luzardo @ Boston
Roupp @ LAD
Start both, but both are risky
Good morning Grey
11 team roto
Would you drop either Brooks Lee or Keaschall for any of the following
Angel Martinez
Ezequiel Duran
Zach Gelof
For what its worth you can also add Rocchio to the list
Thanks
Luke for Angel
I agree Luke has got to go. Big disappointment.
Who would be your 2nd choice after Angel. Any love for Ezequiel just in case. I like his multiple positions. But i will try for Angel
Thanks as always
Gelof
gotcha
thanks
No problem
Mornin Grey!
QS league- could you rank Eury, Bradish, Roupp, and Sheehan ROS?
Bradish, Roupp
Hey Grey, great writing today. Mis has been fun to watch!
Two questions:
1.) Now with Tatis getting 2B status on ESPN, is he a better play than Turang ROS?
2.) is Tatis a better play at 2B than Marte rest of season?
Thanks
Turang, Ketel, Tatis, that order
Thank you!
NL only redraft; questions for you:
1. You starting Dollander at Pitt or Garrett at Minn today?
2. To activate Garrett, I would need to drop one of Dollander, Ray, C Holmes, Sheehan. Is Chase the drop? I hate to do it.
3. My other option is to drop J Estrada and punt holds for a couple weeks to see how my needs shake out.
Thanks!
With every passing day I realize Seager is just an overrated Arenado. I benched Lile this week for him in my Util spot points league…mostly because CBS projected him to have so many more points than Lile. Seriously want to rage drop and just plug in Lile and carry an extra pitcher…like B Miller.
I hear ya
The Top 25 on the RAZZBALL PLAYER RATER with their RCL ADP March17-24 (25 drafts):
1 Drake Baldwin 144
2 Matt Olson 37
3 Aaron Judge 2
4 Oneil Cruz 85
5 Ben Rice 76
6 Shea Langeliers 84
7 Elly De La Cruz 7
8 Jordan Walker ND
9 Paul Skenes 15
10 James Wood 28
11 CJ Abrams 47
12 Andy Pages 141
13 Cam Schlittler 118
14 Byron Buxton 68
15 Yordan Alvarez 32
16 Liam Hicks ND
17 Sal Stewart 147
18 Kyle Schwarber 19
19 Mason Miller 49
20 Chris Sale 53
21 Jose Soriano 274(4)
22 Brice Turang 36
23 Bobby Witt Jr. 3.5
24 Mike Trout 155
25 Jacob Misiorowski 110
KNOCKED OUT
26 Munetaka Murakami 142
28 Davis Martin ND
35 Ozzie Albies 118
36 Christian Walker 187
So much for Judge holding the top spot for a while. Olson surpassed him earlier in the week, but Baldwin surged to the top yesterday to regain #1 for the first time since April 9. The 4 newcomers (BOLD) are all first-timers on the list. Martin and Christian Walker lasted just 1 week in the top 25.
Wow! Three catchers in the top six really shows the quality depth of that position nowadays. Liam Hicks showing up at 16 might speak to that even more.
Wow, I can’t believe Baldwin is on top, that is wild considering he gives few steals…Misio sneaking in at 25 gives 4 SPs, and 3 you could’ve had in any league
Misiorowski would have landed in the top 20 on the 100 Best Fantasy Starts list if he had picked up the win. So, Ohtani ends up with the best start of the day with #65. He has 2 other entries (#64 & #90). Bradish also made it into the top 100 (#69).
Good stuff, Vin!
Would you start Ben Brown in a Fangraphs points league where wins don’t matter for scoring….it’s just about efficiency. Can he go 3-5 (almost) clean innings against the Braves? Hard to say.
Yep
Yeah, I had Sewald and Latz in my lineup yesterday, WTF
OK, ESPN Points, ROS only…I have 2 SP’s who have had great starts but I fear their underlying peripherals may forecast a regression fairy visit. Please give me your thoughts (hold or try to sell high) and what other SPs or closers to target in a sell high trade:
1) Michael King
2) Arrighetti
Thanks
Ouch 1. Rasmussen? Ashcraft? Soroka? 2. Same names? Weathers? Harrison?
So do you agree with my assessment that both King and Arrighetti are ripe for regression?
Ha, yeah
I am so smart, I cut Braxton Garrett and Shields yesterday morning. I had to have a share or two of Bolte. Snelling on nearly every team I have. Son of an elbow! For my next trick I will cut Tatis so he can finally Homer!
Haha
This is non baseball. Tried to watch watch “what about bob” the other day, needed to pay 4.99 to rent or 7.99 to buy. Went up to the attic, got out my DVD player (look it up), found my what about bob DVD (look it up) and watched it twice for free.
Home run.
Ha, nice!
Baby steps to the doorway. Baby steps down the hall. Baby steps to the elevator…
Hahaha
Max Meyer is a solid number two. (Insert Beavis and Butthead laugh)
Ha
In a 12 team H2H OBP league and my outfield sucks, specifically at CF. I have Jackson Merrill and have picked up Ewing and Marsh this week to just park Merrill on the bench. Looking at trading for someone like Pages or Moniak. Who would you target first? And then if you were structuring a one for one with me sending back a SP, who would you offer?
SPs: Burns, B. Ashcraft, Mclanananananahan, McLean, or Hancock?
IL SPs: H. Brown, H. Greene, Jared Jones
I also just noticed I have two pitchers named Hunter with a last name being a color. Neat.
Thanks, Grey!
Pages…Hancock, Ashcraft, Burns, Shane, McLean
Moniak…Hancock, Ashcraft, Burns, Shane
Been looking at Vaughn Grissom statcast and look good.
Any thoughts on him. I know Laura did a small write up on him 2 weeks ago. Is anything he’s doing real and what is his upside?
Looks like it could be real, too early to say…
16 team h2h league. Needing starts this week… Zebby called up to face Marlins at home, should I start him?
Side note: I’ve been a Joe Ryan owner for few years now. Feels like he’s got more QS + L than any SP I can think of recently (haven’t looked up officially). Very frustrating!
No
I hear ya
I’m just posting now so I can come back in a few months.
I traded Miz for Tatis in a 15 team roto league and that was a GREAT move.
Please. Please.
Ha
Big WHIP trouble: 12-team roto: 1.32 good for 2 points with 20% of my 1,250 IP gone. 9-point category level = 1.19. ERA not much better.
Presumably SP help coming from the IL with Skubal, Brown, Ragans, Bieber–just activated Snell–but is it possible to estimate how much a premium middle reliever might shave from ratios ROS?
Would you pref an MR over the likes of waiver fodder Cameron, Painter, Wacha? Hang on with my current Henderson, Sheehan, Early, Scott, Bubba, or wait for the IL cavalry?
Thanks in advance, Grey!
Bubba is not helping your WHIP, I’d lose him for an MR
Possible to close the gap with my IL stashes–provided they’re healthy?
What’s your other option? Continue to start Bubba and fall further in WHIP?
Badly phrased, Grey. I meant *assuming* Bubba drop, with IL returnees + MR, do you like my chances of making up the gap? It’s an oddball question. Just wondered if you had a hot take …
I don’t know if it’s possible to answer, no idea who you’re picking up, can’t hurt
Thanks. Sorry to run on
No problem