This one goes out to all five of our lady readers. Whether you’re mothers or not, you’re beautiful and I love you. Happy Mother’s Day, and a special shoutout to Christian Yelich’s mother. Said like Tupac, “You are appreciated.” Now, let’s get down to business. Diamondbacks called up Plaster Shizz on Friday and because Saturday is the day of Grey’s Sabbath, when he soaks his fingers in Epson salt and smokes grass, I missed telling you my thoughts on Ryan Waldschmidt (2-for-4, 1 run, 3 RBIs, as he hit 9th). That won’t stand! Or Waldstand! So, let’s hear what I have to say by quoting Itch, “The 31st overall pick in the 2024 draft, Waldschmidt represents the windfall profit from Corbin Carroll’s Rookie of the Year award. At 6’2” 205 pounds from the right side, Waldschmidt features plus contact skills, speed and power, a valuable trio of traits in the fantasy game. In 134 games across High-A and Double-A, he slashed .289/.419/.473 with 18 home runs, 29 stolen bases and a 16-to-17.6 percent walk-to-strikeout ratio. And my want-to-punch Grey ratio is 100%.” Okay, not cool. I’d grab Plaster Shizz in all leagues, he has power and speed. Remember, you can’t always get what you Wald, but you can get what you need and you need Wald. Anyway, here’s what else I saw this weekend in fantasy baseball:
Merrill Kelly – 7 IP, 1 ER, 6 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 7.62. Fantasy Doctor, “Take nine of these and call me in the morning.” The pill bottle contains a Mets’ lineup of hitters.
Eduardo Rodriguez – 8 1/3 IP, 1 ER, 7 baserunners, 4 Ks, ERA at 2.25. One of the best two-start weeks I’ve had in some time. Thank you, Streamonator. And now I’m dropping EdRod, before it all comes back to haunt me.
Logan Webb – Hit the IL with knee bursitis, and will take a two-start break. Can’t be much worse than how he’s been. Trevor McDonald will be called up to replace him and you have to be a clown to get excited for McDonald’s stuff.
Ryan Walker – Optioned to the minors. There was a moment in Saturday’s game when Tonnato Vitello just stared off into space for a good 30 seconds. Not noteworthy on its own, but it was noteworthy because he was standing on the mound, making a pitching change. Pitchers in the pen were jumping up and down, motioning to him, all looking around wondering who he was calling in. Finally, and I kid you not, Willy Adames signaled for the next pitcher. Maybe Vitello has that same ailment as the doctor on The Pitt. Anyway, Giants are a train wreck from Posey down, and Caleb Kilian is likely the new closer.
Heliot Ramos – 2-for-6, 2 runs, 2 RBIs and his 4th homer, hitting .272. Examples of learning the wrong lessons: Heliot was the only hitter to ever hit it into McCovey Cove as a righty — draft him everywhere! Andy Pages actually swung and missed vs. Clase when he was trying to throw a ball — avoid Pages!
Braxton Ashcraft – 7 IP, 1 ER, 6 hits, zero walks, 6 Ks, ERA at 2.77. Was available in any league if you wanted to draft him. Cust kayin’.
Konnor Griffin – 1-for-5 and his 3rd homer. Is he 60 years old already?
Oneil Cruz – 1-for-5, 2 runs and a slam (10) and legs (15), hitting .255. On pace for 40/60. If he does that, I’ll say it was a pretty good year.
Bubba Chandler – 5 IP, 2 ER, 6 baserunners (1 BB), 3 Ks, ERA at 4.62. Bubba found his perfect matchup: The SF Giants who swing at everything.
Bryce Miller – Will be activated from the IL on Wednesday. They’ll move to a six-man rotation, then use Miller and Castillo to piggyback. They should send Luis Castillo to the pen, and not this “vet has paid his dues” nonsense keeping Castillo semi in the rotation, but at least they’re not bumping Emerson Hancock.
Luis Castillo – 4 IP, 4 ER, ERA at 6.57. I’m not even sure he’s rosterable in AL-Only leagues.
Logan Gilbert – 6 IP, 0 ER, 1 hit, zero walks, 9 Ks, ERA at 3.78. Finally, he pitched well! Even though the M’s gave away this game like a bunch Bazardos! If someone could get this bit of wisdom to MLB managers: You have over-managed if you’re removing Canzone to pinch-hit with the .120-hitting Refsnyder.
Davis Martin – 6 IP, 1 ER, 5 baserunners, 9 Ks, ERA at 1.62. Asking for my fantasy teams where I have Martin, can we postpone his regression until next year?
Aaron Civale – 5 IP, 0 ER, 9 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 2.59. Seems silly to suggest Streamonator when a guy has an ERA near-2.50, so let’s not be silly. I’m a Silly Saver! I save people from Silly!
Jacob Wilson – Sounds headed to the IL. Shame he doesn’t seem capable of staying on the field. I got him for average and he needs to offset Gunnar.
Shane Baz – 4 2/3 IP, 5 ER, ERA at 5.48. What a Baztard, which is a bastard pronounced by Antonio Banderas.
Nick Martinez – 5 2/3 IP, 1 ER, 7 hits, zero walks, 3 Ks, ERA at 1.70. Was watching the Rays’ broadcast and they mentioned how their starters throw for less velocity and Ks, and more changeups than other teams, and they get by with command. Um, hello! Credit me! I said that shizz three years ago! As more starters lean on throwing 100 MPH, be the team of Nick Martinezes — Team Martini?
Junior Caminero – 1-for-4 and his 11th homer. Vroom! Vroom! Tiny car!
Payton Tolle – 5 IP, 3 ER, 7 hits, zero walks, 4 Ks, ERA at 2.78. He’s solid, you know that, so let me just say he looks like he’s about 43 years old. Call him Payton Place because he understands that reference.
Rhett Lowder – Hit the IL after an injection in his AC joint. You smoke a joint, you don’t inject it, you nimrod!
Pierce Johnson – 1 IP, 0 ER, ERA at 3.38 and his 1st save on Saturday, and might be the Reds’ closer since Tony Santillan hasn’t run with the job. Almost didn’t recognize Pierce Johnson by his proper name. I always heard him called Prince Albert.
Spencer Steer – 1-for-5 and his 7th homer, and 2nd homer in five games, and once again the Reds have too many cornermen and they’re benching one the hottest ones in Nathaniel Lowe for a heating up one in Steer.
Andrew Abbott – 6 IP, 0 ER, 4 baserunners, 5 Ks, ERA at 4.47. Ha! Right after I dropped him, he decided to remember how to pitch. Are him, Flaherty and Bradish just effin’ with me? Abbott’s value is based on his ability to locate, so as long as he’s all Abbott but not aBBot, he’s okay. He’s not more than a number four even if going right.
Chase Burns – 6 IP, 1 ER, 7 baserunners, 2 Ks, ERA at 2.11. Wrote a Burns sleeper, and still 100% love him, but, just so ya know, he’s pitching closer to a 3.50 ERA guy.
Spencer Arrighetti – 5 2/3 IP, 1 ER, 8 baserunners, 5 Ks, ERA at 1.88. Rolling off what I said for Burns, Arrighetti is closer to a 4.50 ERA guy. At some point, if you have Burns/Sp. Arrighetti, you’re hoping for spaghetti all’assassina, but you’re gonna be assassina-jackpot.
Cristopher Sanchez – 7 IP, 0 ER, 6 hits, zero walks 7 Ks, ERA at 2.11. Admittedly, I think for him to win the NL Cy, Skenes might need to oversleep his alarm clock from July through September, but Sanchez is at least in the running.
Bryce Harper – 1-for-4 and his 10th homer, hitting /281. He was pulled from the game on Saturday, due to an ocular migraine, and I get those too! Bryce and I, handshake emoji wrapped around a glass of raw milk, showing people our lactating nipples.
Kyle Schwarber – 3-for-4, and his 15th and 16th homer, hitting .227. Schwarber visiting the set of the Marla Gibbs-starrer .227, after visiting Abbott Elementary.
Jack Leiter – 4 2/3 IP, 0 ER, ERA at 4.85. A manager can remove a starter who has thrown less than 100 pitches and given up zero runs, but he must pay his entire salary from the game. This is my new rule, as your baseball commissioner.
Jacob deGrom – 7 IP, 0 ER, 3 hits, zero walks, 10 Ks, ERA at 2.62. I’m gonna say what I said this preseason, why not just draft deGrom and Schlittler instead of Tarik or Skenes and whoever?
Evan Carter – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 5th homer. This homer came off Daniel Palencia (2/3 IP, 2 ER, ERA at 2.57), who missed two weeks and now Craig Counsell no longer understands how to use him. Did Counsell hit his head?
Edward Cabrera – 5 IP, 5 ER, ERA at 3.88. EdCab making me want to take the bus.
Randy Vasquez – 5 IP, 1 ER, 6 hits, zero walks, 6 Ks, ERA at 3.05. Streamed him on Saturday, and Streamonator hates his next one, and I’m gonna cut Randy with the cold calculation of Herb Brooks.
Nick Castellanos – 1-for-2, 2 RBIs and his 2nd homer. For this home run, he used Tatis’s bat, so Tatis was credited with a home run in horseshoes and hand grenades.
Jordan Walker – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 11th homer. Every day Walker does well is a reminder I’m never wrong, just early.
Kyle Leahy – 5 IP, 0 ER, 6 baserunners (4 BBs), 5 Ks, ERA at 4.31. Will say this for Rockies, Cards and Nats, they were three teams with personnel changes up top that were more “stats based” and they’ve paid off.
Michael Wacha – 7 IP, 0 ER, 4 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 2.63. Recently, realized he’s been pitching in the majors for 14 years and has been almost exactly the same pitcher every year. A consistent ebb with a mediocre flow.
Kerry Carpenter – Hit the IL with bruised ego for allowing Bobby Witt Jr. to run an inside-the-park home run on Saturday while Carpenter did some shizz trying to field. By the way, it’s run an inside-the-park home run not hit an inside-the-park home run, to Witt. Gage Workman was called up (and homered in his 1st at-bat!). Odd to lose a Carpenter, and purchase a workbench. Workman has power, speed and might hit .180, if he’s lucky.
Cam Schlittler – 6 IP, 0 ER, 2 hits, zero walks, 6 Ks, ERA at 1.35. He was hit by a 101 MPH comebacker on his leg and I began to weep, sob really, then he stayed in the game and pitched well and my heaving sobs became joyous cries.
Carlos Rodon – 4 1/3 IP, 3 ER, as he was activated from the IL. Kevin from ESPN’s “Get Him In Your Lineup” Department said, “I’m wearing a paper bag on my head because I forgot my sunglasses.”
Aaron Judge – 1-for-3 and his 16th homer. Only time in the last four years he’s had more homers in his first 40 games (17), he hit 62.
Logan Henderson – 5 IP, 2 ER, 5 baserunners, 5 Ks, ERA at 4.15. Must gave you my Logan Henderson fantasy. It was highlighted in sparkler Sharpie.
Brice Turang – 2-for-4 and his 6th homer, hitting .298. Bill Hall filing a trademark infringement lawsuit. Turang and CJ Abrams were both guys who should’ve been drafted in the top 20 who weren’t.
Addison Barger – Day-to-day with a sore elbow. Maybe he won’t have these problems, if he stops throwing 101 MPH from the outfield.
Yariel Rodriguez – Being recalled from the minors. Jays spelled “DFA Lauer” out in seashells on Instagram. Not entirely clear why Yariel couldn’t have been in the majors this whole time. Dude’s 29 and clearly a long man that has some real world value. For fantasy? Meh, maybe AL-Only.
Jose Soriano – 7 2/3 IP, 1 ER, 6 baserunners, 7 Ks, ERA at 1.66. Damn, I already dropped him after his last bad start, oh well.
Jo Adell – 3-for-4, and his 5th and 6th homer, hitting .273. You’re about to see one of the streakiest hitters go absolute Dongey Kong.
Cade Cavalli – 5 2/3 IP, 2 ER, 5 baserunners, 4 Ks, ERA at 4.02 vs. Sandy Alcantara – 6 IP, 2 ER, 7 baserunners, 3 Ks, ERA at 3.90. Went to look at Cade vs. Sandy on the Player Rater, thinking I was gonna do a GOTCHA that Cade was more valuable than Sandy, but, no, no gotcha. I did see the top five starters on the Player Rater right now, and I have to say I don’t think anyone could guess them. Massive Hint: Four are mentioned in this post.
Blake Snell – 3 IP, 4 ER, as he was activated from the IL. It’s a low-key credit to Ohtani that he doesn’t say, “Hey, you need me for October, right? So, how about I take April through July off like Snell, Glasnow, Betts, Freeman, Smith, etc.” Through a translator, obviously.
Spencer Strider – 6 IP, 0 ER, 3 baserunners, 8 Ks, ERA at 2.89. That’s the best a Spencer’s looked in Los Angeles since Robert Urich.
Bryce Elder – 5 2/3 IP, 0 ER, 1 hit, 4 BBs, 8 Ks, ERA at 1.81 vs. Justin Wrobleski – 8 2/3 IP, 7 ER, 8 baserunners, 7 Ks, ERA at 2.42. You know that meme, Coughing Baby vs. Hydrogen Bomb? Wrobleski vs. Elder is Coughing Baby vs. Coughing Baby acting like Hydrogen Bomb vs. Hydrogen Bomb. Wrobleski vs. Elder was Cher slapping Nic Cage in Moonstruck but saying, “Why’d you draft Hunter Brown?”
Drake Baldwin – 1-for-4 and his 10th homer, hitting .297. Drake better get his ass out of LA.
Matt Olson – 1-for-4 and his 14th homer. 21 more to go!
Taj Bradley – Hit the IL with pectoral inflammation. The missing Marx Brother Zebby Matthews might get called up, and I wouldn’t bet your life he’s good.
Joe Ryan – 6 IP, 1 ER, 5 baserunners, 5 Ks, ERA at 3.43 vs. Tanner Bibee – 6 IP, 1 ER, 1 hit, 2 walks, 9 Ks, ERA at 4.17. This game was so old school, both pitchers went into the 6th inning! This game was so old school, Ryan threw 107 pitches! This game was so old school each pitcher was allowed to noogie Robin Ventura!
Gavin Williams – 6 IP, 5 ER, ERA at 3.74. Now 16 ER in his last 25 2/3 IP, and I’m saying maybe he should change his cologne because it’s attracting the Regression Fairies.
Patrick Bailey – Traded to the Guardians. Aaron Boone can never have a decent 3rd baseman, because it’ll reflect back on his own playing days. Related, Buster Posey just shipped the Giants’ 2nd post-Posey “catcher of the future.” I’m only maybe 20% joking. If Posey was a great mentor, maybe he’d coach up some of these guys, no? Not sure if that bodes well for Jesus Rodriguez in the long-run, but in the short-term, he gets a pretty nice boost for 15-team mixed and deeper.
Bo Naylor – Optioned to the minors. Guards couldn’t take Naylor anymore and his .143 hitting. They now welcome the .141 hitting Bailey.
(Deleted–replied to wrong post)
Kim
Hey Grey. 12 team, H2H, 7×7.. thinking about offering my Gunnar, Basallo and Lile to an O’s homer needing a C. For his Tucker, Turang and Cam Smith. Your thoughts please.
Rasmussen 100 pitches??? Impossible. Hell must have frozen over
HAHA
Damn now A.J. Ewing gets the call. Who do we like more between him and Bolte?
Bolte
Thank you for the quick reply on this one! Much appreciated.
Also I just learned his name is pronounced “Bolt-ay.” Feels wrong
it could go either way
Do you think playing time will be an issue for either of these guys?
Yes, I don’t know either’s…My guess is Bolte’s is a little safer, but who knows
Remember this? 10 years ago today!
Wow! A real throwback
Can’t believe this was ten years ago
You and me both.
Also the anniversary of us (and royce!) watching Kershaw toss a CG 3-hitter with 13 Ks vs the Mets. In two hours!
Good times.
Wow! I can’t believe it’s been a decade
I gotta show Cougs this
One more Grey,
Dynasty points.
Emerson/ Benge for Kirby/ Painter
Or
Emerson for Eury straight up
Kirby
Hey Grey, who’s the drop in a 12 team 6×6 with OPS to activate Dookie Butts?
Marsh-O’Hearn-Nimmo-Soler-Vinnie P – could see any of them but leaning Nimmo or Soler
Stuck with the Mook in my IL for the time being.
Soler
Which of these 3 gems?
Waldschmidt, S.Steer, A.Vaughn
Ryne Nelson or Reid Detmers or matchup dependant?
Vaughn — matchups
What’s good Grey? My team is mired in a slump after a good start to the season. It’s a 12-teamer with 4 OF slots. I got Yordan, Chourio, Soderstrom and Stowers. My question is if Bolte is a better option over Soderstrom or Stowers, or am I just moving deck chairs around? Hi to Ted. Good Day.
Ted says hi! I wouldn’t go Bolte over them
Bolte is kind of a sexy pick-up though, but I see what you saying. Thank you.
No problem
Grey
1) would you drop Spencer Jones for Waldschmidt or Bolte
I am afraid once Stanton or Dominguez come back Jones will be sent down
2) I assume Fairbanks will be the closer once he comes off the IL on Wednesday
I have to drop 1
Brooks Lee or
Keaschall
Wald 2. Luke
Hey Grey. Who is more droppable..Daylin Lile or Chase Dollander. I could do either or. Ty
Lile
Been meaning to ask this. What’s your concern level for altuve? He started off hot but really has taken a nose dive. Lots of grounders. Hoping a 7 game homestand can get him back on track, i.e, pulling some balls in the air toward those Crawford boxes
The end is near or here
I guess I can live with that response. Hopefully I can squeeze one more year out of him
Yeah
put me in that hope category since I also have Altuve.
Someone dropped Casey Schmidt; would you drop Sam Antonacci to get Casey Schmidt?
Thanks!!
Sure
Wheeler or Rasmussen – ERA, WHIP, W, QS, OBPA, K in a 8-team daily roto league
Rasmussen
Eury or George Kirby Dynasty Points
Kirby
Is house a droppable 3B in rcls (I might have maybe already dropped to stream)
Yes, droppable
When did Jung become relevant? Statcast backing it up.
Maybe 2 weeks ago
Cruz xBA in 2024 was .259 and finished with a .259 AVG. 2025 was .213 xBA and finished with a .200 AVG. so far his xBA is .263 and AVG is .255.
His historical xBA tends not to deviate too much from his actual. He could manage a .250 AVG and go 40/40.
That would be great
Would you rather have Cruz or Belli in a small 7×7 roto (AVG, OBP, SLG ratio categories)
Actually, in what order with those scoring categories – Cruz, Belli, Bux?
Cruz, Belli, Bux
Cruz
Would you drop Taj Bradley for Abbot, Junk, Ryne Nelson, Christian Scott, Jacob Lopez, Cochin or jack Leiter?
Or Burke.
Or Cecconi (not Cochin)
Burke
Nyet!
Sal Perez or Jeffers?
Bleday or Nimmo?
spanks
Jeffers
Nimmo
Whos the pick up if Eavoldi goes on IL ?
Framber Valdez
Mike King
M.Meyer
Lodolo
King
Eovaldi scratched with side tightness FFS. Get in the casualty room with Taj, Brown, Woodruff, Yelich and Eugenio.
Ugh
Why can’t he get scratched when pitching poorly? I swear i lose a player every day. Well its been 3 days in a row now after a brief quiet period
I know, seriously
Hi Grey,
Would you start Sasaki at home vs Giants tonight?
Soroka @ Tex
Cecconi home vs LAA
Im in a H2H categories lease that scores:
Hme Runs
Holds (HLD)
ERA
WHIP
K/9
Quality Starts (QS)
Net Saves (NSV)
Sure, can start Roki in H2H…And I’m starting Slade
thank you so much. i need to pivot too because of the eovaldi news
Grey,
can only start one:
deGrom @ Hou
Sale CHC
Sale
Grey
Head to Head points league 10 team
Would you drop Rasmussen for
Davis Martin or Max Meyer
No
@Grey: weekly roto. eovaldi scratched. who should i replace him with?
bradish vs nyy
warren @ bal
ray @ lad
roupp @ lad
schultz vs kc
scott vs det
or start an extra closer (latz – 3 vs ari, 3 @ hou)
thanks!
@Grey: or, per my earlier question, move ohtani to pitcher and have colson montgomery dh?
Yeah, sounds fine
Noah S.
DeLauter, Michael Harris , or Bolte. Need to drop one . Could use the speed and batting average.
Bolte
Henry Bolte or Ryan Waldschmidt – anyone of them would work for me to add in a keeper league Sir
Stephen Kolok or Dean Kremer going forward this year
thanks man
Wald
Kremer
Seranthony and RicoG until Helsley returns, thank you
OR, thank you
Seranthony
Thank you
No problem
10tm H2H, OBP, OPS & QS league:
Julio 2. Cam, it’s fair 3. Albies
Travis Bazanna or Miguel Vargas? I need to plug a hole at either 2B or 3B. Thank you!!
Vargas
Bolte over Spencer Jones? OBP instead of Ave
Yeah, try Bolte
Hi Grey,
A. Cortes or Wald
B. Which two are the best:
Roupp @LAD
Scott vs DET
Snelling @MIN
Tolle @ATL
Wald B. Scott, Snelling
Thanks,
Longer term, how do you rank Scott, Snelling, Tolle, Henderson
Snelling, Logan, Tolle
J. Isbel or Z. McKinstry in AL only roto? I’m thinking McKinstry for the flexibility and last season upside
McKinstry
Assuming this is a no but I’m going to ask it anyway. Would you drop Teoscar for DeLauter?
No
Drop Butler for Bolte?
I see someone asked this already. I already made the move I just wanted to feel better about it.
Sure
Henry Bolte called up Grey, lets go!
Let’s go!
Hi Grey,
Great stuff like always!
In my 12 team h2h keeper I’m looking to drop one of Jack Leiter or Christian Scott to activate Betts from the IL. I’m kind of intrigued by Scott and want to hold on longer. Do you agree with that or would you drop Scott and hold Leiter instead?
Thanks!
Cersy
Sure lose Leiter
Snelling or Chirstian Scott ROS?
Snelling
Which start do u prefer ?
Meyer at Minny
Framber at Mets
Lodolo home vs Nats
Lodolo
(if important), 2 catcher league: Jesus Rodriguez (SF) or Dalton Rushing?
Rushing
I just dropped Rushing to pick up Jesus!
He’s cold and doesn’t play often…
Ok
Redraft, 12 team, standard 5×5 roto. Sheehan or Lodolo?
Thanks.
Lodolo
10 team 5×5 OBP. Drop Soderstrom for Bolte? Soderstrom started very slow last year as well but its brutal now.
No
Please rank these three for my waiver claims.
10 TM H2H Points. I need everything.
Justin Wrobleski
Alex Bregman
Luis Castillo
Breg, Wrob
Would you drop Donovan, Pena, or Adames in a roto OBP league for either Antonacci or Arroyo?
Nope
Best 2 of 3 ROS : Raley Gelof Grisham.
Not Trent
Raley or Gelof ranked first?, thanks
Raley
Drop snelling for Randy vasquez?
No
Bello looked good last week coming in after an opener, maybe he found something
Top 2 of Bello Henderson Flaherty Prielipp Kumar Leiter Mahle Lambert Burrows Abbott
thank you
Bello has some of the worst stats of any pitcher in baseball
I know, but I am a stupid Red Sox fan…
What about top 2 of these other superstars, thanks
They all have some issues, I’d look at matchups…outside of that, Abbott, Prielipp
Ryan Waldy or Spencer Jones??!
Wald
Standard weekly roto – Soriano or Rasmussen ROS?
Soriano
Taking the chance on Bolte over L Butler?
gonna be interesting, Kotsay likes him
Yeah, go for it
Brooks Lee or Antonacci. Obp format.
Lee
Points Scoring
Pick up Ray and drop any of
Eury, Warren, Snelling, Harrison, Junk, Henderson and Tolle?
Junk
Do you think Caballero is a top 75 hitter ROS? Close?
Debating whether to move him.
Thanks!
Close
Hi Grey,
Pick 1:
Rodon @ NYM or Logan He season @ MIN
Thanks!
LG
Rodon
Happy Monday Grey!
Points League (+4 HR, -1 strikeouts, etc.)
ROS who would you want from Bregman, Langford, and DeLauter?
Thanks!
Wyatt
Apropos of nothing…I nominate Addison Barger as the best looking player in baseball. He’s dreamy.
Haha
This guy acting like Roman Anthony doesn’t exist
Haha! Yet both of you have chosen to ignore the strong side platoon adonis that is Kerry Carpenter.
Haha
Checks stat sheet, confirms that neither one of them exist.
HAHA
1. How do you balance a quality of SP with quality of opponent? E.g. good SP against good hitting lineup vs. worse SP against bad hitting lineup?
2. Any renewed faith in Bradish after his last start against ATH? Assume he’s still a sit against NYY this week even though SON approves at $15? Does he deserve a monocle?
3. SON hates my best SP this week: 2-start Robbie Ray @LAD (-15) and @ARI (-6). I know, its sad that he’s my best SP, but start or sit?
4. Can I ask a couple more start or sits in a 11-teamer?
Dollander @PIT (SOM hates this one too at -28)
Severino vSF ($4)
Tolle @ATL ($7)
Cantillo vCIN ($1.4)
SonnyG vPHI ($14)
Lambert vTEX (-22)
C Patrick @MIN (-24)
Civale vSF (-1)
1. depends on specifics 2. I’d sit him vs. Yanks 3. looks like awful matchups and @ARI is next Monday, that’s not this week 4. Agree with SON except I like Dollander
Henry Bolte just got the call from the A’s… who would you say is a decent comp? Would you grab over someone like Bleday?
Thanks, G!
-IANASM
Interesting…I’d say 10/20/.230 over 100…Sure, grab him
Done. Thank ya
No problem
Grey: One more RP trade question: Hader for Will Warren or Trent Grisham. My staff is DeGrom, Luzardo, Eury, Sonny Gray, MacKenzie Gore, Chase Dollander, and Janson Junk with Jared Jones and Corbin Burnes on the IL.
I’d take Hader for either, Trent first
Hey Grey,
I’m assuming you wouldn’t start Logan Henderson (@MIN) over any of the following?
Chase Burns (@CLE)
Parker Messick (LAA)
Sanchez (@PIT)
Sheehan (SF)
Nah
Henderson (@MIN), Schultz (KC), Sonny Gray (PHI), Dollander (@PIT), Ritchie (CHC), Severino (@SF), Snelling (@MIN), Tolle (@ATL).
Need 3. Which ones would you choose? I was thinking Dollander, Henderson, and Schultz.
Gray, Noah S., Chase
Which side
1. Pages and McLean or Woo?
2. Belli and Cease or Carroll?
Pages, not close
Corbin, this is fair tho, depends on needs
Thanks, I’m mulling the offer for Corbin.
Do you prefer Julio or Corbin?
Julio
Points
Who sits? Junk, Parades or Cags?
Cags
AL only – Flaherty (@NYM and TOR), Baez (@WASH), or Rocker (ARZ).
Scared to use anyone of these. Who do you start? Need one.
Flaherty
In an NL only keeper, would you trade your Snelling $1, James Tibbs $1, and Luis Garcia $9 for Matt Olson $27?
Yes
Drop Teoscar for Waldo?
Nah
Power is my weakest category (but entire offense is poor): Waldschmidt or Soler?
Wald
in 12 teams points leauge… Is Christian Scott good enough to keep over Snelling? He has looked good so far…im worried about how long Snelling will take to acclamate to the big leagues.
Christian Scott vs DET or Snelling @ MIN
I have them both in separate leagues and not starting either. Interested to see Scott v a banged up Tigers lineup minus Carpenter. But jeez the Mets suck, just a more expensive version of the 1962 model.
Yeah, I hear you. I want them to be good…but they are just painful to watch. From a fantasy perspective Scott has been solid. He sees to line up for a two start week next week. Snelling probably wants to prove himself, but he gets ATL next week? Meh. I don’t have the answers.
Sure
Coin flip. Roger.
Yup
Which side do you like better? Gunnar or Neto/Albies?
Neto/Albies, it’s fair
@Grey: weekly roto redraft. in leagues where you can only use ohtani at dh or sp, gotta still dh him, right? which pair do you like better?
ohtani (dh) – 4 vs sf, 3 @ laa with hancock vs sd
or
colson montgomery (dh) – 3 vs kc, 3 vs chc with ohtani vs sf
thanks!
Ohtani
Can’t believe he’s asking that very question that I been pondering. Lost by 9.5 in no small part to Otani’s lousy 14.5 contribution
Yeah
@Grey: assume you mean keeping him at dh? ohtani is in both scenarios (just dh or pitcher).
Oh, then let him pitch
Hey Grey, a follow-up question if you don’t mind.
I have to start two of these guys – what do you think? I’m running low on HR and RBI if that matters (I’ve got lots of runs).
Ballesteros (6, @ATL, @CHW), 4 righties, 2 lefties
Jac Cags (6, @CHW, @STL), only one lefty
J. Bauers (6, SD, @MIN), no lefties scheduled so far
Canzone (7, SD, @HOU), no lefties
Bauers, Cags
12 team OBP roto league. Looking to trade Aroldis to a team scraping for saves. We have discussed Ketel Marte, Teoscar Hernandez, Trent Grisham, Otto Lopez. How would you rate the players offered?
Otto or Ketel
Hope you had a Great and relaxed weekend.
The Cubs Taillon ,AZ’s Ed Rodriguez and Braxton Ashley had positive starts over the weekend.
Ed Rod’s next start is at CO.Taillon’s next start is at CWS. Ashcraft’s next start is home vs Phil and at StLouis.In the
I am not sure of any these three have tweaks a pitch or their delivery.
Would you pick up any over my staff of Messick, Weathers, Griffin, Schultz, Vasquez, Arrigghetti or Roupp?
Thanks!!
Ashcraft over Vasquez
Thanks!!
No problem
Ashcraft was scoped up. Would you trade one ot two of the following to get Ashcraft or hold?
Messick, Weathers. .Arrigghetti, Roupp, Vasquez, Griffin, Noah Schultz or Mitch Abel?
Hold
Who’s the best and worst for saves from this group of sad-sack relievers?
Santana
Perkins
Santillan
Santillan
Happy Monday Grey!
So I am toting Jung around as my Util in our Yahoo 10 Team H2H Points League. Would any of these other guys be better:
H. Ramos
Bleday
Vaughn
Waldy
Soler
Cags
Grisham
I am in 1st Place because of my infield and pitching and obviously not my Util, but still…
Thanks much Grey.
Oh, and I dropped Taj (IL stint seems lengthy) to add Springs for his 2 Starts, but I should probably add him back if possible. Right?
Thanks again Grey.
Sure
Meh, Jung’s been decent, no? Can try Vaughn if you want
Yes, you are right. Jung’s (do you say “jung” or “young” – HA!) been fine Grey. I thought I saw a question below that involved Jung and others, hence my question. I will Hold.
And yeah, I probably should have just held onto Taj, as my team can probably beat my opponent this week without the 2 starts from Springs (he better not screw me – HA!), but oh well.
Thanks for all this Grey.
And you know, what you usually say about waiting on pitching is so true. I think about the staff one could have pulled together off the crap heap, especially in our 10 Teamer:
J. Soriano
D. Martin
T. Bradley
Dollander
L. Henderson
Weathers
Hancock
Roupp
Etc. I am obviously guessing on a few of those, but you get the gist.
Thanks Grey.
Yeah, nice!
No problem
Weekly AL Only 5×5 Category League: Start Jose Soriano home vs. dodgers OR Will Warren @BAL?
Soriano
Hi Grey,
Who to start this week? H2H QS league with extra weight towards longer starts with an IP/start category. Please pick top 2 from:
EdCab @CHW
Tolle @ATL
Warren @BAL
Henderson @MIN
Harrison vs SD
Thank you and hope it’s a good week!
Harrison, Warren
Add waldo to that list…
Pena, Waldo
Hey Grey,
Plz rank:
Lile
Keaschall
J pena
Thanks!
Start D.Martin (Cubs) or King@Mil. H2H pts league a win is 10 points. Thx in advance.
Hey Grey. 12 team 7×7. Do you like Pierce Johnson or Caleb Kilian for SV/HOLDS. TY
Kilian
Plaster Shizz doesn’t quite have the same ring to it as Au Shizz!
Plaster Shizz!
this has to be the week Lawrence Butler rebounds right? 6 games in Bing Bong vs 5 righties. right? RIGHT? as I do the Fred Sanford heart clench
Yeah, hopefully
From the Rhett Lowder blurb, I liked learning how Daffy and Bugs Bunny brought “nimrod” into American vernacular as a synonym for “moron,” when they were mocking Elmer Fudd’s hunting skills, calling him “my little Nimrod” — the mighty hunter from the Book of Genesis.
Did anyone catch the Lodolo game on Friday? 53 strikes out of 78 pitches is nice; how was the velo and pitch selection?
Yeah, Lodolo was fine
Hi – can you rank the top 4 RPs from the following RPs for a standard 5×5 league?
Baker
Jansen
Santana
Perkins
Kilian
Santillan
Baker, Jansen, Kilian
Who do you think will end the season higher on the player rater Devers or Soderstrom?
Thanks
Soder
Rank these CIs ROS
Vinnie Pasq
Josh Naylor
Tyler Soderstrom
Soder, Naylor
Rocchio or a returning Ha-Seong Kim as a Wilson replacement?
Kim
Please rank, oh great FML: Waldo, Bleday, Lile. Thanks!
That rank
Kudos on directing me to start Dean Martin for his 2 step last week! Need help again:
Pick 3 of:
Shota @Atl
Martin home vs Cubs
Warren @Balt
Lugo @CWS
Emerson Hancock, home vs SD
Prielipp home vs marlins
Hancock, Martin, toss up, I guess Shota
Drop Luke Keaschall to grab Waldschmidt?
Sure
Gelof or Julien? Who do you like more ROS?
Julien
ESPN Points, ROS only
Which side? Close?
A: Jacob Latz, RP (Tex)
Michael King, SP (SD)
B:Jhoan Duran, RP (Phi)
Will Warren, SP (NYY)
King, close…only problem with Warren is if he gets bumped for Cole
Drop Helsley for G. Soto?
Nah
Drop Marse for any of these players Adell, Soler, Waldschmdit, bleday, s. Jones, moniak?
Adell
Dude, you’re getting Adell (1990s commercial reference)
Vasquez at SEA, Ray at LAD, or Dollander at Pitt? Streamonator hates all three, but no other option this week, unless I do Bryce Miller coming off the IL at Houston?
Randy
I have a empty spot on my 10t h2h league. Is Springer a good pickup. I worry that his season will be more like 2024 where he hit .220 with 19 hr’s and 74 runs.
Other chooses are Ramos vs LAD for 4 games, Arraez, Rutschman or Kwan.
Thank you
Heliot
Howzit Brah! Got 2 for you.
Grisham, Bleday or Waldo ROS?
Cavalli, R. Nelson, Snelling?
Many Aloha’s!
Waldo
Snelling
Mahalo
Aloha! Guess who’s going to Hawaii over ASB
kirby yates?
Kirby Yikes?
Keep forever league. Keep 13
IP, K, QS, ERA, WHIP, K/BB
This is my current staff:
Kirby 2.94 ERA 1.10 WHIP 3.25 K/BB 5 QS 39K
Weathers 3.03 ERA 1.19 WHIP 4.50 K/BB 2 QS 45K
Framber 4.57 ERA 1.41 WHIP 2.33 K/BB 5 QS 35K
Freddy P 3.12 ERA 1.20 WHIP 2.39 K/BB 2 QS 43K
Cease 2.58 ERA 1.24 WHIP 3.67 K/BB 3 QS 66K
Tolle 2.78 ERA 0.88 WHIP 4.50 K/BB 2 QS 27K
Snelling 5.40 ERA 1.80 WHIP 0.50 K/BB 0 QS 2K
Would you drop anyone above for anyone below?
McGreevy 2.18 ERA 0.86 WHIP 3.30 K/BB 5 QS 33K
F.Griffin 2.12 ERA 1.03 WHIP 2.80 K/BB 4 QS 42K
R.Vasquez 3.05 ERA 1.17 WHIP 3.23 K/BB 3 QS 42K
Soroka 4.14 ERA 1.43 WHIP 3.82 K/BB 2 QS 42K
Cantillo 3.43 ERA 1.37 WHIP 1.95 K/BB 1 QS 37K
Nope
vientos or a. vaughn?
vaughn
Morning grey. 1) In a vacuum can you rank these guys moving forward? Tatis, Jarren Duran, Altuve, Arozarena. And 2) regardless of where ranked, are any of these guys buys in general?
Tatis, Duran, Randy 2. not really, maybe Randy
Hey Grey, looking for help with my starters this week. Which 3 of these guys would you start this week?
Sheehan (SF)
R. Vasquez (@SEA)
EdCab (@CHW)
Henderson (@MIN)
Cantillo (LAA, CIN)
Eovaldi (ARI, @HOU)
Eovaldi, Cantillo, Sheehan
Morning Grey!
Which one of these guys do you start this week?
Ballesteros (6, @ATL, @CHW), 4 righties, 2 lefties
T. Johnston (6, ARI, @PIT), only one lefty
Troy
Feel like Keaschall’s plate discipline and SBs are such that he only needs to not be swinging a wet noodle to be valuable. Think he gets there? Probably looking at a desperation play like Gelof or Schmitt instead
I’d try Gelof
Hey Grey, this is a bit of a sad question. If you had to start one of these guys this week, which would it be on the off chance one of them actually either gets called up or comes off the IL? I got injury problems, y’all!
Gleyber
Lindor
Volpe
Throwing darts, I don’t know…maybe Lindor
Volpe sounds like he might be returning
Can you rank these SP in a QS league, 12 team
B Miller, C Scott, T McDonald, Burke
Thanks!
Add Arrighetti to that mix
Burke, Miller, Arrighetti
What pitcher would be fair value for michael harris in a keeper league – Kirby, Imaga, Peralta, or Cease?
Shota, Freddy, Cease
Dynasty trade question. Sorry in advance for the long setup…
Was offered his Tatis Jr and Robert Suarez for my Langford and Keaschall.
16 team, h2h points, daily lineups, dynasty on Fantrax so Tatis doesnt have 2B yet…needs 10 games to get it, 15 to keep it for next year.
We use a lot of scoring categories, singles, doubles, triples, HR, BB, K, SB, sac fly, sac hit, R, RBI, intentional walks, cycles, HBP, GIDP, CS
W, BB, K, saves, holds, IP, shutouts, QS, perfect games, No hitters, Losses, hits allowed, ER, hit batsmen, balks, complete games.
My current roster:
Dingler
Aranda
Jazz
Okamoto
3 OF – Rooker, Soler, Stowers
2 Util – Xavier Edwards, Keaschall
BN – Dubon, Marsh, Ceddanne
IL – Eugenio, Lindor, Langford
4 SP, 1 RP, 3 P spots
SP – Gilbert, EdRod, Bradish, Early, McLean, Ray, Ashcraft, plus Seymour, Hurt and Newcomb to fill SP spots when I dont have 4 starters going
RP – Jansen, McGill, Phillips, Whitlock, Ryan Walker (going to drop for someone)
IL – Cole, Skubal, Edwin Diaz, Erik Miller
Is Tatis broken to the point of not taking him on?
Most trade analyzers say it is relatively even, but how much of that is hope that Langford lives up to his potential that he has not really shown yet?
Thoughts?
I wouldn’t buy Tatis
Oh great Grey – who’s the choice this week for a pts league?
Sale vs. CHC
or
Peralta vs. DET; NYY
Freddy
Schwarber or Tucked?
Schwarber
Grey,
Peralta or Rodon ros pts league?
Freddy
The Revenge of the Nerds and Pierce Johnson blurbs were elite. If I lose the Waldschmitt speakstakes, what are the top 2 consolation prizes between Bleday, Marsh, Antonacci, and Varsho?
I suppose Gelof is also in the mix but probably at or near the bottom…
Bleday, Varsho
Bleday or Marsh?
Bleday
Hi G,
Hope you had a lovely weekend. Who do you prefer between Cortes or Bleday in a daily lineup 5×5?
Thank you!
-IANASM
Bleday
So when do we talk about Ohtani being asscheeks on offense lately.
Ha
Throw in vlad also
He is clearly focusing on getting that Cy Young and I’m over here sighing. No way to fit young in there as a joke I’m sorry I’m not clever.
Morning & Happy National Eat What You Want Day!
I know I’ve asked the same/ similar question previously, but with 2 nice matchups & SON liking both, would you cut Jack Leiter to pick up Eury Perez (@ MIN & @ TB)?
Also, what are we doing with Imai now that he’s getting activated tomorrow (SON absolutely hates this start)? hold on the IL to see how his 1st start goes? cutting? something else?
thank you as always my good sir!
Sure, can go Eury
I’d hold Imai on my IL for now
Thank you!
Additionally, do we think we’ll See Jeff Hoffman ever regain closer duties in TOR this year or is he just a head case as it relates to the 9th?
Need to cut either Hoffman or Santillan as my 3rd “closers” in saves-only.
Thanks again
Varland stumbles for two weeks and Hoffman looks good? Sure…may not happen tho…Cut Hoffman
Appreciate it… and I just re-re-read all notes on Santillan too. What the heck CIN?!? just make him the dang closer!
Haha
would you drop Dollander for Sorotka ?
Yes
Thanks!
No problem
Can you rank these starts this week:
Ed Cab – @ CWS
Prielipp – vs. Miami
Leiter – @ Hou
Roupp – @ LAD
C. Scott – DET
Gracias.
Connor, EdCab
Hi Grey,
Hope you had a nice weekend.
I moved to 2B Stewart and Rafaela got mover to 3rd OF/Bench.
I have been ciruling my 3rd OF since Yelich in OL.
In the waiver option of my bench options are:
Heliot Ramos, Wilyer Abreu, Carlos Cortes, Rafaela, Lile, Steer.
Lately, i have been wanting to add Steer and drop Cortes.
Thanks for your help!
What are you asking?
sorrym wasn’t clear.
Which of the below OF you like better moving forward (OBP league):
Heliot Ramos, Wilyer Abreu, Carlos Cortes, Rafaela, Lile, Steer.
thanks,
chris
Wilyer
i need to find a 2nd baseman – who from this list is the best option?
12 team 7×7 H2H
Rocchio
Cole Young
Semien
Antonnaci
Stott
Gelof
Stott
Do you like Ben Brown? statcast looks good, gets atl and isnt stretched but thinking long term.
Waldschmidt or Heliot over Nate Lowe?
Yes this is a real question as i drafted devers/soto/soderstrom
Brown looks looks decent, mid-3 ERA solid enough Ks, doesn’t look like a future ace, but usable
I’d try Wald, but Heliot is likely better
Am I correct to trade Vlad Jr. for Alonso if I need power ? Or should I keep Vlad
I’d take Alonso
Do you think Henderson stays in the rotation when the other Brewers starters come back, Woodruff and Priester? thank you
Priester was pulled from his rehab start and Woodruff is tentatively throwing…Neither of them are coming back for at least a month, likely longer
Morning Dr. Grey! I followed your medical advice from Friday and picked up some Oxy(Condon) and while it hasn’t kicked in to help at the Major Payne level, I am hoping to re-up my prescription soon. In fact, I have almost an entire bench of minors “leaguers” who need to be called up or my bench will continue to be Barely League-AL. So, I am counting down the days for N. Marte, A. Ramirez, and C. Condon can make an impact.
While I wait…I have other decisions to make between underperforming players for my final Pitching spot in my weekly lineup. Would you rather start Abbott @ CLE, Bradish v NYY, or start a third RP – Santillan instead? (My other RPs are C. Smith and B. Baker)
One more question, I have Santillan because Pagan is on my IL. Keep Santillan or drop him for C. Killian?
Thanks Doc!
Me too!
I’d start Abbott, may not be pretty
Drop for Kilian, play Kilian over Abbott if that’s an option
Bryce Miller or Logan Henderson in points league…ROS
Miller
Hey Grey! Team is flat on power at the moment. How would you rank these for UTIL bat: Vaughn, Jung, Aranda, Bleday, Waldschmidt
Vaughn, Wald, Bleday
ROS Vientos or Paredes? Thank you!
Paredes
Think we can hope both Wald and Lawlar play when Lawlar returns?
Cross that bridge when Lawlar returns in a month
Dbacks absolutely will find a way to not play Lawlar.
Lawlar will find a way not to play Lawlar!
Haha
ESPN Points ROS only, Utility spot, position irrelevant
Jake Burger (ice cold but can get hot)
or
Heliot Ramos
Ramos
Grey, you being from New Jersey and about the same age as me, you must be familiar with the Dead Milkmen. Given that, I think that whenever Junior Caminero hits a dinger, you should just quote DM’s best song and say “Bitchin’ Caminero!” For a particularly good game, you could even use a longer song quote, like
“Bitchin’ Caminero!
Bitchin’ Caminero!
Doing donuts on your lawn.
Bitchin’ Caminero!
Bitchen Caminero!
Tony Orlando and Dawn.”
On an actual fantasy baseball note, would you start Robby Snelling this week at the Twins? I’ve got Skubal, Taj Bradley and Logan Webb sitting on my bench onthe IL (no IL spots in my league) so my choice is either Snelling or a fourth closer Sewald). Thanks!
Haha, yes! For me and you! I’d start Snelling
Dingler or Jeffers ROS? Carter Jensen has caught the Royals cold. Points league. Thanks!
Jeffers
Thanks Grey!
No problem
deGrom earned a top 10 spot on the 100 Best Fantasy Starts list with the best start of the weekend:
10 Jacob deGrom May 10 vs CHC
36 Spencer Strider May 9 @LAD
44 Michael Wacha May 9 vs DET
75 Cristopher Sanchez May 10 vs COL
88 Jose Soriano May 10 @TOR
95 Bryce Elder May 10 @LAD
98 Andrew Abbott May 10 vs HOU
In 2025, deGrom finished with 2 in the top 100:
44 Jun 7 @WSH
93 Jun 25 @BAL
Texas now has 4 entries on the list:
53 Nathan Eovaldi Apr 13 @ATH
54 Nathan Eovaldi Apr 29 vs NYY
55 MacKenzie Gore Apr 8 vs SEA
It is the Cubs’ first appearance as the opponent.
Wow, didn’t think that was a top 10 start, was great tho…Who has most starts in the top 100?
Not which team, mean which starter
Cam Schlittler is the only one with 4. Three each for Chris Sale, Cristopher Sanchez, Gavin Williams, Jose Soriano, Max Fried, Nathan Eovaldi, and Paul Skenes.
Cool, thanks, Vin!
drop bleday or j.bauers 4 waldschmidt?
Bleday
Wrobleski actually pitched 8.2 innings and gave up 7 ER. So his WHIP was under 1 for the game and his ERA was over 7.
oops, will fix
Which two
Wald, Barger, Spencer Jones
Wald, Barger
12 team points, would you drop Issac Paredes for Marsh or hold?
Drop someone else.
Hold
Hi Grey,
Thanks for your patience with the number of questions.
In the majority of your fantasy leagues, what pitchers have you drafted?
Thanks!!
What pitcher have I drafted more than anyone else? I’d guess deGrom
Thanks!
No problem
Hi Grey,
Wow! your track record on recommendations whether to start or sit a SP has been truly amazing!
1. Start or sit Weathers at Baltimore?
2. Start or sit Nick Schulz at home vs LAA?
3. Start or sit Valdez at the NYM?
4. Start or sit Randy Vasquez at Milwaukee?”
Thanks!!
Thank you!
No problem
Hope you had a Great and relaxed weekend. The Cubs Taillon ,AZ’s Ed Rodriguez and Braxton Ashley had positive starts over the weekend. Ed Rod’s next start is at CO.Taillon’s next start is at CWS. Ashcraft’s next start is home vs Phil and at StLouis.
In the past, all three seem inconsistent.
I am not sure of any these three have tweaks a pitch or their delivery.
Would you pick up any of these over my staff of Messick, Weathers, Griffin, Schultz, Vasquez, Arrigghetti or Roupp?
Thanks!!
Ashcraft over Vasquez
Laughing at the Leave It to Beaver reference
Hehe
yes, the references this year have been the best since I came around in 2019. Gold!
How do you rank these guys in a qs league: tolle, snelling, Logan henderson?
And would you rather have them any of them over sheehan or are you still giving sheehan more time? Velocity is not holding. Thanks
Henderson pitch count so far has been 76 and 74 in his two starts.
Logan, Tolle…I’ve dropped Sheehan
That is what I wanted hear more than anything. My gut kept saying that but I have tried to hold on