Often pitchers are kept in the minors so they can work on certain pitches. They reportedly need more polish. Pirates are the first team to hold a pitcher in the minors so they can polish something — the key to the city, which Paul Skenes will rightfully be receiving one day. Prolly after his first Cy Young, but maybe after his third. Imagine the Pirates’ chagrin when they realized they’re gonna have to pay for Skenes and a key to the city. Did the Pirates factor that into their budget? If I ever got a key to a city, I’d just walk from store to store opening them when I wanted something. “Buddy, it’s not a skeleton key.” That’s my friend as I try my key to the city at my favorite boba place. Any hoo! Pirates finally said they’re calling up Paul Skenes for Saturday, and there hasn’t been a minor league pitcher who looked as ready as him in some time. If you were to tell me, he’s a MLB pitcher, who was rehabbing because he was on the IL after a bad case of vertigo, which caused him to chase a blonde girl around the city of San Fran, it would not surprise me. Every clip I see of Skenes I come away thinking the same thing, he could be on his 3rd year of the majors. Pitchers only get so many bullets before they are shooting blanks, which makes it a shame he was wasting them in the minors, but soon, my Precious. The Pirates just needed to find an affordable locksmith. Anyway, here’s what else I saw yesterday in fantasy baseball:
Dylan Cease – 7 IP, 0 ER, 1 hit, 2 walks, 12 Ks, ERA at 2.19. Cease as in sheesh, that’s good. Carpe Cease’r! It’s not even Julius on the calendar and us Cease’rs are diem’ing? Are any of these good? I’m workshopping! His stuff. It’s beautiful. His .210 wOBA is top 4% in the league; his 4-seamer produces a .164 batting average against — that’s on a pitch he throws more than 40% of the time! Hope you’re not allergic, because that’s nuts! Oh, and that’s his 2nd best pitch! His slider he throws 40% of the time has a .127 BAA. Dylan Cease is about to win the NL Cy Young, and looks like an easy top five pitcher in the majors. Barring the Padres calling up Ettoo Brute.
Christian Yelich – 0-for-5 as he was activated from the IL. Kevin from ESPN’s Get Him In Your Lineup Department said, “Sure, I can stop mimicking Back to the Future with ‘Where we’re going we don’t need Rose,’ every time I leave for lunch and pass Rose at reception.”
Tyler Black – Optioned to the minors. “Oh c’mon!” said like Jim Carrey in Liar, Liar. This is ridiculous. Do they know they have Jake Bauers still on their team? Oliver Dunn?
Gary Sanchez – 2-for-3, 2 runs and his 5th homer, and 2nd homer in the last three games. Filthy Sanchez is a hot schmotato!
Brady Singer – 5 1/3 IP, 1 ER, 7 baserunners, 4 Ks, ERA at 2.36. There’s a story, of a man named Brady, who was thought to be a streamer, but wasn’t at all…He was also a gay architect. Long story.
Bobby Witt Jr. – 2-for-3, 3 runs and his 5th homer, hitting .327. Glad to see he remembered we don’t want “just line drives” from him. Don’t become Vlad Jr.!
Chris Bassitt – 6 IP, 2 ER, 1 hit, 2 walks, 6 Ks, ERA at 5.06. Better, but still not 100% right. He definitely seemed to flip a switch at one point and knocked down 12 batters straight, then was kept in too long. He showed flashes, but if I can be more of a downer, he was a foot away from getting killed in the 3rd. If you’re a hangdog and wearing your ‘I’m with Bassitt’ t-shirt, the results should have you mildly optimistic.
Aaron Nola – 5 2/3 IP, 4 ER, 9 hits, zero walks, 7 Ks, ERA at 3.67. Speaking of guys who don’t seem 100% right, but this is going back a year-plus with Nola. He was nearly beat for a home run by Israeli-Diner Falafel, which was inches from making this start look way worse.
Tanner Bibee – 4 IP, 4 ER, ERA at 4.91. This was the afternoon game I watched, and Bibee looks remarkably bleh. Call him Blehbee. Usually Blehbee has solid command, and he wasn’t locating anything, and, like you before puberty, was leaving his balls up. Not great, Blehbee.
Emmanuel Clase – 1 IP, 0 ER, ERA at 0.47 and his second win. In the files of It’s Better To Be Lucky Than Good, I wanted no part of Clase, and “accidentally” drafted him, and it was one of my better picks. Ain’t ever shaking the “I’m an idiot” rep.
Reese Olson – 6 IP, 1 ER, 1 hit, 2 walks, 4 Ks, ERA at 2.52. Unlike Blehbee, Olson looks better than his peripherals. He desperately needs better command to be anywhere close to a forceful candidate for shallower leagues. Right now, he’s borderline in deeper mixed leagues. At any point, everything Reese’s built can fall to pieces.
Jason Foley – 2/3 IP, 0 ER, ERA at 2.51. Way to secure the. Dot dot dot. 7th inning? Hmm, that doesn’t seem to be a closer’s usage. I looked to grab Alex Lange everywhere; he’s been lights-out since inexplicably being removed from the job.
Dane Dunning – Hit the IL with a shoulder issue. Too bad, so sad–Oh, wait a second! We have:
Jack Leiter – 4 IP, 4 ER, ERA at 12.91 as he was recalled. Leiter could be an ace. He needs to figure out command, but that comes out of nowhere sometimes. Is he usable right now? Absolutely not.
Marcus Semien – 6-for-10, 4 runs and his 7th homer, and his 2nd homer in as many games. That’s a Semien blast! Which sounds like the worst name for a toothpaste.
Leody Taveras – 2-for-8, 3 runs, 2 RBIs and his 2nd homer. Leody is a burning hot schmotato!
Evan Carter – 1-for-6, 1 run, 1 RBI, hitting .218. Sat out 1st game, shat out 2nd game. How long until he’s demoted?
Shea Langeliers – 5-for-9, 3 runs, 8 RBIs and his 8th and 9th homer, and a single short of the cycle in the 1st game. Sia’s favorite schmotato, Langeliers!
Brent Rooker – 5-for-9, 2 runs, 3 runs, 3 RBIs and his 9th homer. Was going to say how sad it was that I was worried when he was pulled from the 1st game early, thinking there might be an injury, but that’s not sad at all to be worried about Rooker. He’s been fantastic!
Juan Soto – 3-for-5, 5 RBIs and his 9th homer. Sexy Dr. Pepper gonna have a 45-homer, .330 season then leave in free agency and in two years no one will remember he ever played for the Yanks.
Giancarlo Stanton – 1-for-4 and his 8th homer. That homer was 120 MPH off the bat, the fastest hit ball of the year and it reminded me why I fell in love with Giancarlo all those years ago, then was issued a restraining order, then, dressed as mailbox, sat outside his house for five years.
Aaron Judge – 3-for-5, 3 RBIs and his 8th homer. This was the first time Giancarlo, Soto and Judge all homered in the same game. I blame Judge.
Carlos Rodon – 6 1/3 IP, 2 ER, 7 hits, zero walks, 7 Ks, ERA at 3.56. Not to poo-poo the positive, but this looked more like “Astros look lost” than “Rodon looks great.”
Kyle Tucker – 1-for-5 and his 11th homer, and 3rd homer in three games. Hey, it’s all good, but where are the steals, Mr. H2H?
Jorge Soler – Hit the IL with a shoulder strain. It is slightly curious when a guy only performs well in his contract year. Cust kayin’.
Kyle Bradish – 5 IP, 1 ER, 6 baserunners, 9 Ks, ERA at 1.86. Impressed by how good he’s looked since his return. Looking Bradish, not even Bradish-ish.
Gunnar Henderson – 2-for-5 and his 11th homer, hitting .271. Nice of him to rejoin the “Gunnar’s quest for AL MVP.” Hard to carry on without him.
Anthony Santander – 1-for-3 and his 6th homer, and 2nd homer in three games. Don’t let Santander get good in the O’s lineup too.
Craig Kimbrel – 2/3 IP, 2 ER, ERA at 4.73 and another high leverage Hold. Great stuff! Not sure how long they’re going to let Cano or Coulombe pitch much better in every inning except the 9th and let Kimbrel try to fork over every game.
Mitchell Parker – 5 2/3 IP, 2 ER, 6 baserunners, 3 Ks, ERA at 2.67. As long as his BB/9 is 1.7 hard to see how bad this could turn out, and Streamonator has him facing the White Sox next. (which is the dreaded jinx).
Christian Encarnacion-Strand – Hit the IL with a fractured wrist that will sideline him for eight weeks. Outside of very deep leagues, you can move on. Not to Espinal, who is taking over for CES, unless things are dire.
Graham Ashcraft – 5 IP, 3 ER, 9 baserunners, 2 Ks, ERA at 3.86. Watched this Reds/DBacks game and my biggest takeaway was Elly is gonna steal 100 bags.
Jordan Montgomery – 7 IP, 2 ER, 9 baserunners, 2 Ks, ERA at 4.70. Oh, no, is he suffering from the same ailment as Bailey Ober? Is he throwing too many strikes? Don’t forget to waste one here, guys!
Kevin Ginkel – 1/3 IP, 1 ER, ERA at 3.14. Good news for Ginkel owners is he was still brought in for the save with Sewald back. Bad news is he sucked.
Eugenio Suarez – 2-for-3 and a slam (3) and legs (1). Back in Cincy and barely recognizable, because he changed his hair, thankfully. You don’t remember his hair? Oh are you in for a treat!
Nick Pivetta – 4 IP, 5 ER, ERA at 3.60. Pivetta, one of the greatest teases in modern lore. There’s a whole section on–Well, it’s called PivettaHub.
Marcell Ozuna – 2-for-3, 4 RBIs and his 11th and 12th homer. Could Ozuna sneeze on Olson, perhaps?
Chris Sale – 6 IP, 0 ER, 7 baserunners, 10 Ks, ERA at 2.95. Cut up his old teammates for old times’ sake.
George Kirby – 5 IP, 4 ER, ERA at 4.15. Honestly, whatever, I just don’t want him to be hurt. Please be healthy.
Willi Castro – 2-for-3, 2 RBIs and his 3rd homer, hitting .273. I have a list of guys who I like way more than I should, Willi’s near the top of that list.
Carlos Correa – 1-for-4 and his 2nd homer, hitting .261. I have a list of guys who I hate way more than I should, Correa’s on the top of that list.
Trevor Larnach – 1-for-2 and his 3rd homer, hitting .360. He’s not on a list. Listless.
Chris Paddack – 5 1/3 IP, 1 ER, 9 baserunners, 10 Ks, ERA at 4.34. Was surprised to see his peripherals look pretty good — 8.9 K/9, 1.9 BB/9, 3.50 xFIP. Still a batting practice fastball, but if he has his command, he can be decent. Am I picking him up? Meh, the tough thing is he’s solid for a deep league, but there he’s rostered.
Braxton Garrett – Activated from the IL. Still like Garrett, but I can’t help feeling everything the Fish touch turns to rotten. That’s ancedotal, and I would try Garrett in any league, but I am way less excited about than when I gave you my sleeper on him in the preseason.
Edward Cabrera – Hit the Ineffective List with a totally real injury to his shoulder and not at all a made-up injury because he was pitching like a poop emoji.
Bryan De La Cruz – 2-for-4 and his 8th homer, and 2nd homer in the last two games. Marlins are Jazz, Cruz and snooze.
Teoscar Hernandez – 2-for-3, 3 RBIs and his 10th homer. [banging head on desk to emphasize each word] Such…an…obvious…draft…pick!
Daniel Hudson – 1 IP, 0 ER, ERA at 3.38, and his 2nd save. Vesia’s save the other day tells me this is a timeshare, like the thing you go to look at to get $10 in chips in Aruba.
Gavin Stone – 7 IP, 1 ER, 6 hits, zero walks, 4 Ks, ERA at 3.55. Still getting questions about picking up or dropping Stone, like you’re a dietician in Britain, when he should likely just be rostered in all leagues.
Martin Perez – 5 IP, 4 ER, 8 baserunners, 5 Ks, ERA at 3.60. Streamonator hates his next, so that’s it on him, but if anyone better than Perez faces this Angels’ lineup again, start them:
What if the Angels traded away Trout? pic.twitter.com/t6IcdhMVVV
— Razzball (@Razzball) May 8, 2024
Jo Adell – 2-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 5th homer, hitting .259. Without knowing anything but the bare minimum, how is Adell batting 8th in that lineup? How much coke is Ron doing?
Jose Soriano – 4 2/3 IP, 4 ER, ERA at 4.32. Jose Sorry-ass-oh!
Taj Bradley – Activated from the IL. Definitely worth a flyer in most leagues. He has some of the best stuff in baseball. He could be an ace. Stamina? Might not be there. Consistency? We’ll see. But you should try in most leagues.
Aaron Civale – 4 2/3 IP, 2 ER, ERA at 5.88. If you have a league with things like xFIP, then cool. If you’re in normal leagues where you need things like wins, ERA and WHIP, I’m not sure of your options, but I’d be calling an option play.
Paul DeJong – 2-for-4, 2 runs, 2 RBIs and his 5th homer, and 2nd homer in two games. Colonel Mustard in the trash for a hot schmotato and a banana peel!
Anthony Hoopii-Tuionetoa – Rangers traded him to the White Sox for Robbie Grossman. Aw sookie, we have a big trade to discuss! Roll up your sleeves and let’s get to it! Or should I say roll up your grass skirts for Hoopii-Tuionetoa? Good try by the White Sox to get rid of Grossman, but fans are still gonna say that for their lineup. You can’t trade away an adjective.
In a 6×6 roto. We use QS & W.
Was offered Sale for Kirby. Which side do you take? I’m a little concerned about Kirby, but it’s early.
man black going down hurt so much in a weekly… batting 3rd to minors instantly!!! I liked getting steals from 3b lol.
What would u take instead yawning yandy who just is so boring, Josh Smith, Rojas or Senzel. I have Jr stashed so hopefully that works out.
Thx
They’re all boring, I’d go Yandy
D’rnaud, o’ hoppe, langaleirs, campusano, wong, Stephenson or Gary Sanchez?
Logan
Who you prefer as a stream tomorrow?
Irvin v AZ
Abbot @ SF
SON likes Abbot, is meh on Irvin…
Neither? I guess Abbott
Grey, 10T 5×5 Category OBP Keeper League
Can you rank as a backup 3B and/or bench bat
J. Candelario
J. Smith
C. Mayo (stash)
C. Rafaela
Thanks buddy
Mayo, Ceddanne
Stream Robert Gasser tomm against the Cards
Sure
What to do with Greene? Keller is available. Pull the plug and pick up Keller?
Thx
Sure
Do like Mountie or Westburg better at the Corner spot?
West
Walker Buehler or Rodon ROS ?
Walker
Suzuk (once active) or Pages?
Seiya
Hey Grey! Gausman for Alonso in obp, good offer if I need pitching?
Sounds fine
Tatis/Yordan or Acuna/Evan Carter?
Yordan
Sorry I should have clarified that this is a keep forever- still Yordan side or does that change things?
No
Gilbert and Stroman really making this a day to remember.
Stroman could do with a double play about now…
Only following online, so don’t really want to know the location of Yordan’s flyout…
Haha
Ha
Screw baseball. Watching this on repeat instead.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GCX635Z7_PE
An oldie but goodie
Hi Grey – I need some OF help. Please rank top 3 from this group:
BDLC, Taylor Ward, Rooker, Winker, Verdugo
Thanks!
LG
Cruz, Rooker, Ward
Thanks!
Grey, if it makes you feel better (it won’t), I had Teoscar all queued up to draft, and for some reason when the time came, I went with Seiya instead even though you had him ranked a hair lower. I didn’t even really need the extra saves! AND WE COUNT SLG%!
Teoscar went literally the next pick.
Damn
Keppler, DeLuca, or JD Martinez? Need to drop one. Thanks
I figure DeLuca
hey Grey- having trouble gauging this…
if I package Skenes and Mason Miller, what kind of bat could I realistically ask for- would guys like Altuve, Seager be possible? I don’t want to insult anyone
thx
or Sal Perez..
I also don’t want to do something dumb, these are great arms
I doubt it but you can try…maybe Seager since struggling
Bradish pulling a Tanaka. Let’s hope he either wasn’t hurt that bad or he has the same kind of elasticity in what is holding his ucl together.
Yeah
Please rank (saves). thanks.McArthur, Megill, Fairbanks.
McArthur, Fair
I was offered Houck for my Tyler O’Neill, got to stick with the offense and keep Tyler, right? Thanks!
Hold
Please rank – Bednar, Fairbanks, Yates
Bednar, Yates
Very shallow roto 5×5 league, better OF play moving forward…Lourdes or B De La Cruz? Pretty close, I’m assuming?
Add Kepler to this list please sir!
Cruz…it’s close
Pham or chourio?
Chourio
He’s out again today. Now two in a row. What do you think that’s about? Maybe just while he’s slumping?
I’m sure, he’s been awful
Grey,
Someone dropped Bichette in 1 of my leagues. I have like 3 SS eligible players, Cruz, Volpe, and Garcia. So I don’t need him, BUT, I said out a $5 FAB bid in for him. Why not? I was the only person who bid.
I had no choice right? I mean he can’t be this bad in a full season right?
Ty.
Sounds smart
Robert Gasser called up with the Brewers. 17K’s in 12 IP 4 HRs allowed too. Lotta giddyup on his gas ( no pun intended, well maybe a little.) Starting Friday v St Louis.
dear lord i was first in the FCL and got him. thanks chucky!!
Gasser looks unspectacular. worth a hold for a start though. fun stat: in 12 Aaa starts he’s yielded a total of 5 FBs and 4 have gone for homers. an 80% hr/fb ratio may not play
Ha yikes
Haha nice
Yeah exciting!
Good Thursday afternoon Grey. Someone dropped O’Hearn in our 12 team H2H league. Trade Analyzer says its close, but would you drop either Marsh or Cronenworth for O’Hearn? Thanks.
Marsh
Bad to worse – lost everyone to IL, dtd injury, flu, mosquito bite, bad tacos, idk n whatever else could go wrong…Need another SS n OF. Josh Smith worth a add over Gurriel? also ROS – friedl, kepler, pages?.. Thank you.
Nope…Friedl
Would you offer either Adolis, Ober or Bradish for Skenes? Points league and guy has signaled he will trade Skenes
I also have Helsley, Munoz and Duran as closers
Ober seems fair
10 team H2H points league
Which SP moving forward:
G. Stone or B. Woo
Stone
How about Stone or J. Hicks?
What happens when Bobby comes back? Paxton to the pen or 6 man rotation?
Cross that bridge in June
Gilbert getting a summer sausaging
Hahaha
And his BFF Julio, taking it in the shorts (0-3) again, as usual.
Yeah
Which streamer do you like most for tomorrow:
Irvin vs ARI
Taillon @PIT
Crochet vs CLE
Thanks!
Crochet
Can we throw Civale into a pit of snakes?
Dejong can’t hit the broad side of a barn but managed to hit a HR off of Civale. xFIP may be irrelevant for him. Routinely putting the ball on a tee (middle/middle) and throwing too many strikes will lead to a HR problem and an era & whip problem. So frustrating.
Haha, yeah that’s allowed
Yahoo, 10 team, 5×5 roto, daily lineups
Was just offered his Bryan Reynolds for my Walker Buehler
Current roster is:
C – Y. Diaz
1st – Steer
2nd – Thairo Estrada
3rd – Westburg
SS – Bogaerts
IF – Albies
4 OF – Nimmo, JuRod, Profar, Chourio
UTIL – Arozarena
BN – Pages
IL – N. Jones
NA – Jr. Caminero
2 SP – Imanaga, Skubal
2 RP – Hader, Suarez
3 P – Neris T. Megill (mil RP), Hoffman
BN – Singer, Burnes, Lugo, Buehler, Bryce Miller, Lodolo, C. Scott
IL – Philips, deGrom, Fairbanks
NA – Skenes
Plan is to drop Hoffman to activate Skenes tomorrow for the Saturday start.
Is Reynolds of any benefit to me worth losing Buehler for? Any better at this point than what I have?
Nah hold
That was my initial thought, thanks.
His roster:
Rutschman
Vinnie P
Mookie Best
McMahon
Vope
IF – Rizzo
4 OF – Judge, Alvarez, Jazz, Josh Lowe
UTIL – Ginacarlo
BN – Harris II, Gleyber, Reynolds
IL Edman
NA – J. Walker
2 SP – Cease and Wesneski
2 RP – Kimbrel Finnegan
3 P – Ginkel, Cano, Nestor Cortes
BN – yamamoto, Verlander, Eovaldi, Kershaw, Severino,
IL – Snell, Cole, Devin Wiliams
NA – Meyer
Would you give up Buehler for Rutschman or Vinnie as a counter?
Is this the best time to try and sell Skenes before he has thrown a pitch in a counter offer?
How do you compare Buehler, Skenes and Christian Scott as potential trade chips?
Any counteroffer you would make looking at the rosters?
If it matters, he is in 3rd, Im in 4th at the moment, separated by 2 pts.
Adley seems fair…Skenes, Walker, Scott
Earlier this week, put Julio on the Trade Block to gauge interest in a 12 team Dynasty. Received two offers.
1) B DLC and Steer
2) Carrol even up
oof
As much as I don’t like to admit it. Julio, at this point, probably isn’t worth much more, if that.
last year he hit 19 hrs and had 15 sb in 289 ABs 2nd half
Yeah not really worried
Really just biding his time until the Mariners are just this side of being burried in the division.
Ha yeah but the Mariners’ front office isn’t providing much help either
it feels like they can’t develop offense across the organization. clase came up and i was like, “this is your guy guy?”
Yeah, true, not sure…park doesn’t help that’s for sure
Lee, Stanton or Bryan De La Cruz for my 4th OF?
Stanton
That wasn’t a who’s hottest contest.
Thanks Grey!
Haha
SV+Hold League Who is the drop?
Kenley
Kittredge
Finnegan
Barlow
Treinen
Schreiber
I am guessing that you say Barlow. Why Barlow over Kenley or Treinen? Just wanting to understand.
Why not
Barlow has more SVHD, more IP, more Ks, lower WHIP, Higher K/BB and has only given up 3 more runs than Kinley.
Treinen has pitched 7 innings in the last 3 years.
In today’s edition of nobody is starting him, I’m going to give fastball spin doctor Tobias Meyers a final shot. If not against the Cardinals then never.
The Jordan Hicks went about as expected with the W on the board and an bunch of meh behind it.
Love Jeffers.
Yeah, I saw on Hicks, it was about as meh as they get…good luck with Meyers
you liked meyers I remember. it’s really been homers that have done him in.
Matt and Julio Down By The Schoolyard. another show about nothing
Yeah he looks real good stuff wise but you know how that goes
SVHD, Keep forever league
A. Matt Olson and Dansby
B. Lindor, Muncy, David Robertson
B
Grissom over Arcia?
Grissom
Let’s play Am I Stupid:
I Dropped Loperfido for Rooker
Grey, Am I Stupid?
Verdict: Not stupid
12 Team H2H Categories
Seager & Springer to get CJ Abrams. Which side ya got?
CJ
Grey, guess this list (already in order)
imanaga
r. lopez
wheeler
assad
gilbert
suarez
crawford
skubal
lugo
t. williams
houck
blanco
That’s not a bad list, umpy!
thats because its the current ERA leaders for sp.
at least half of those guys werent even drafted!
side note i only have 1 of those guys lol (assad) and a few i still wouldnt even pick up! pitching is broken.
Saying that… i drafted alcantra, traded for strider and stashing eury in a keeper league cause im stubborn.
Not broken but fickle
Haha, nice!
Hey Grey…shallow 5×5 roto Keep forever league…my Bichette and Gavin Stone for his Riley Greene? 10 team league so I can replace Gavin with streamers, hes my last SP…
Greene
Hey Grey, Ceddanne, Willi Castro…care to share a few other names of guys on that list of guys you like way more than you should?!?
Ha, no top secret!
But I’m a patreon member lol! All good, I will continue reading roundups and listening to podcasts for the little golden nuggets!
Umpy did a pretty good job above
Ctrl + F Umpy….nice, thank you Boss!
Haha
K looked at buy sell and found one, Batty for Baty baby! Better spec play (aka bench bat) moving fwd in a shallow roto 5×5 keeper league (so potential upside helps a tad)…Baty or W Abreu? Thanks boss!
Abreu
Patrick Sandoval. Anything to see here?
Streamer
With Suzuki come back should I drop Wilyer Aubrey or Verdugo?
Also with Phillips on IL my only closer is Kimbrel ugh, available closers Hudson Estevez and Alexis Diaz who should I pick up? Thanks
Abreu
Diaz
Do I burn the #1 waiver priority (which only applies to players dropped from other teams) on Friedel? I’m pretty meh in OF with Soler being cold and now with a shoulder. I could use the speed. Do I gamble on him bouncing back?
Sure
Have to pick one Fedde vs CLE, Taj @ NYY or Littell @ NYY
Thanks as always!
Littell
Another question: (1st world problems; along with Clase & Helsley, this staff is top 3 in every P category).
1) Start Skenes vs. CHC? (I would have to drop someone. See below.)
Here are my SPs: Yamamoto, Ryan, G. Rodriquez (IL), Darvish, Berrios, Montgomery, Assad, Lodolo, Skenes
2) Who is the first drop? (I am leaning Montgomery because of the low strikeouts)
3) When G. Rod returns, who is the 2nd drop?
Thank you.
1. Yes 2. JoMo 3. Ask then
Trusting Hunter Greene at home against Arizona? Thank you.
Yes
12 team pts league, choose one DH for ROS
Castro OF, 3B, 2B
Rooker OF
DeLuca OF
Kepler OF
Cowser OF
Why? Are you going on a 5-month vacation? I guess Rooker
Someone dropped Luzardo in an NL-only redraft…what % of faab would you bid?
7%
10 team OPS weekly H2H. Keep 3 for 1 year.
A: Freeman, Pages
B: Carroll, Nate Lowe
*****Carroll can be rostered thru 2025. Freddie only thru this year.
Corbin
Going for a Coors stack today. Elias Diaz, Elehuris Montero, Charlie Blackmon. Wish me luck!
Good luck!
I have Skenes for $3 in a 12 team keep forever (inflation is very low so price wise he’d always be keepable if the talent is there).
Would you trade him for nonkeeper Teosar + one of $1 Gil or $2 Gore?
No
Thanks!
To the window, to the Paul…..til all Skenes Skenes Skenes…
HAHAHA
OBP League 5×5
Need a catcher with a pulse lol
Luis Campusano, Danny Jansen, Elias Diaz l, Shea Langeliers, Connor Wong, Gary Sanchez or MJ Melendez?
Jansen
Who would be next 2 after Jansen ?
Wong, Langeliers, just play matchups
Skenes over Lodolo, H. Greene, or Brax?
Can try over Brax
Thanks!
No problem
With Skenes coming up, any word on the debut of the Cubs’ Horton?
Haven’t heard anything
The CBS Fantasy ticker guys are about a half step removed from 8 year olds playing mad libs.
“Ok, I need the name of a baseball player, a verb, a noun and a game result.”
*Lars Nootbaar regurgitates tater in Cardinal evisceration…”
then they laugh until milk comes out of someone’s nose
Haha
Which streamer do u prefer
Cole Irvin home vs Arizona or
Crochet home vs Cleveland?
Crochet
Thank u for quick response
India or Bogaerts? Thanks
Xander
Please rank: Thairo Estrada; Luis Garcia; Vaughn Grissom.
You did
Redraft, 12 teams, standard 5×5.
Please rank these RPs R.O.S.: T. Scott, A. Lange, R. Garrett.
Thank you.
You did
With Taj Bradley and Braxton Garrett (two guys with first names for last names and vice versa) both coming back from the IL who do you like better for the rest of the season? (I’ve been sitting on both on the IL, but only have a slot to swap one back into the roster at the moment).
Thanks.
Brax
Please rank ROS. Taj; Braxton Garrett; Luzardo. Thank you.
Reverse them
10 team pts should I offer Munoz and Bradish for Julio Rodriguez?
I have Peralta, Eflin, Buehler, Imanaga, Woo, Helsley and Jhoan Duran as well. Montgomery is on waivers as well. My outfield is Acuña, Judge, Adolis, and Arozarena. I’m 6-0
Sure
Need to replace Langford. Do you like Verdugo or Kepler for the next 6-8 weeks? Thanks!
Verdugo
But have you seen his girlfriend?
Haha
Who would drop out of VinnieP and Mullins for DH spot? Is it team needs based or is there a clear choice?
Vinnie
6×6 roto with AVG and OBP – QS and W
1. Teo or Adolis
2. Stott or Friedl
3. Kirby or Shota,
1. Adolis 2. Friedl 3. Shota
Abraham Toro, potential breakout or schtomato? What do think his stats will be ROS. Thank you
Castro or Abe?
Schmotato
Good morning Grey,
Been holding Skenes in an NA spot, and can finally put him in an active spot Saturday! Huzzah!
To do so, who is the drop?
Y. Diaz
Steer
Estrada
Westburg
Bogaerts
IF – Albies
4 OF – Nimmo, JuRod, Profar, Chourio
UTIL – Arozarena
IL – N. Jones
NA – Jr. Caminero
2 SP – Imanaga, Skubal
2 RP – Hader, Suarez
3 P – Neris T. Megill (mil RP), Hoffman
BN – Singer, Burnes, Lugo, Buehler, Bryce Miller, Lodolo, C. Scott
IL – Philips, deGrom, Fairbanks
NA – Skenes
After dropping 1 to activate Skenes, is there another drop for Taj, Means, Keller, Littel, Braxton, Chris Sanchez, or Tyler Anderson?
Depending on who the drop is for Skenes, BDLC, Verdugo, Winker, toro, Marsh, Benson, Langaliers a better option for my offense?
Thanks!
Hoffman…you have no one else to drop
Been running Tovar at SS this season to awful results
Was offered Swanson for my Lugo, worth taking ? Or aim higher
Not like Swanson has been good either but the projections systems like him a lot, and he looks like the same guy last year, despite a slight increase in K% + decrease in BB%
Take Swanson
Burn waiver 2 priority on Keller in a 12tm qs league?
Rest of my pitching staff: Glasnow, Eflin, Miller (sea), Crawford, Irvin, Stone, Sanchez
Nah
ESPN points, rest of season, please rank top 3:
Gleybar Torres
Jose Rojas
Willi Castro
Massey
India
Thanks
Gleyber, Willi, India
looking to trade one of my younger OFers for some pitching. Which would you rather keep ROS. Pages or Cowser?
Pages
Would you drop any of the bats below for Kyle Gibson? He has 5QS and ratios aren’t too bad.
Drop?
Gleyber (I have Thairo, Stott and Luis Garcia)
Adell
Jacob Young
Rooker
Manzardo
Pages
Stash Tyler Black or Manzardo or drop any other guys above to stash Tyler Black and keep Manzardo?
Manzardo
Drop Manzardo for Gibson or for Black?
Black who? The guy who was just sent down or the pitcher who was terrible in his first outing
?
Gibson
10 team 5×5 OBP.
Peralta, ryan, lugo, Garrett, Scott, Bibee, berrios, kikuchi, Ober.
Need to drop one. I think I wait to watch Garrett start then him or bibee right?
Yes
Morning Grey,
Need to make room for a couple guys coming off the IL. 10 team, H2H, points, keep 25.
Left Yelich on the IL yesterday and dropped a reliever who wasn’t playing today to activate him. Need to make a move for tommorrows games though. Who’s the drop…
Maikel Garcia
Evan Carter
Trevor Larnach
Also have Braxton Garrett coming of the IL. Have a full roster of 9 SP so have to drop one to activate him. Will include all 9 for context.
Greene
Gausman
Valdez
Skubal
Steele
Crawford
Lugo
Lodolo
Means
I may just roll without the extra releiver though Sunday. Effectively keep Garrett on the bench (via IL) for his first start and reevaluate after Lugo makes his start Sunday. Maybe Valdez will go back to the IL and everything resolves itself.
Thanks!
Larnach — Means
Thanks
No problem
What? What does Larnach mean? Grey, don’t leave us hanging….
WHAT DOES IT ALL MEANpp
Hi Grey,
I would appreciate your critical review of my analysis of my pitching situation.
I am in a Yahoo points league which limits the amount of innings to 1450. At this point, I have 1050 innings left. There are 145 days left to the season or 20.7 weeks. Thus, if I divide 1050 innings by the number of weeks (20.7). then I “have” 50.7 innings in a week or about 10 starts.
Since I am always starting Burnes, Wheeler, Tarik, Ragans and Nola
, then The amount of starts for Kutter, Cristopher Sanchez, Jack Flaherty, Reese Olson, Jon Gray, GreyRod and Javier are going to be limited.
I came to the conclusion then I should try
and move Nola, Kutter, etc to improve my lineup.
I wish that I done this analysis earlier.
1.Do you agree with this conclusion?
2. Which pitcher or pitchers would you think have any trade value?
Any input would be much appreciated!
Thanks for reviewing my analysis. Jeremy Pena is on the wire. Should I pick up and waive one of my streamers from above list or you can do better in a trade?
thanks!!
Do better
perfect. thanks
No problem
My current 3B are Luis Rengifo and Ryan McMahon (plus Jose Rojas who I have playing SS).
My SS are Josh Rojas
3B: trade fare:
Alec Bohn
Max Muncy
Jordan WestBurg
Isaac Paredes
SS:
CJ Abrams
Lindor
My possible pitchers are Nola, Kunner, Cristopher Sanchez, Reese Olsen and Jon Gray plus Javier who is on IL
I was even thinking of offering Nola and Cristopher Sanchez for Lindor. On paper a Nola for Lindor is equal according to Razz trade analyzer.
Looking forward to your ideas.
Thanks!
Martin
Sounds solid!
Thanks for responding so quickly. Sorry to ask for clarification:
Do you mean that my current SS and 3B are solid or that the proposed trade for Lindor is solid?
Thanks!!!
The trade you’re asking about is solid
Thank you!!
He turned Down the trade for Lindor. I was going to offer Rengifo besides Nola plus Sanchez. worth a try or is it overpaying
If he turns this down, among CJ Abrams, Born, Muncy, Westburg, and Parades, who is the second best?
thanks!!
can try it…I dont know who Born is…Abrams
among Alec Borm, Muncy, Westburg, CJ Parades, who to
pick?
thanks
CJ Abrams
Would you offer Nola or Sanchez or both? thanks for your patience!
Both
Thanks!!
No problem
Dynasty H2H trade offer: C. Carroll and B. Bichette for C. Morel, O. Cruz, F. Lindor. Which side and is it fair?
Morel
10tm H2H With QS Would u drop Ober for Bradley?
No
Need a bat in a 6×6 OPS…..Y.Diaz(1b/tb) ,..Pages, or Deluca? In order for ROS, thanks….
Pages
Does anyone recall the price of gasoline the last time Elly got a basehit?
HAHA
QS no wins. Ratios have been a nightmare past two matchups.
Adell is my OF6
Adell for Singer, Gil, or hold?
In the meantime, will be protesting for my league to switch to xFip. Thanks!
Singer
Hi Grey,
10 team, Roto, Mixed, 5×5
Time to cut the T’s (Torres, Torkelson)?
I lost Casas and CES, so I needed Tork but there’s Singleton and Loperfido out there.) Stott is doing better and I acquired Hoerner. My patience runneth low. Thanks.
Loperfido hasn’t done anything…So, same as Tork…who you can lose if you like
Heard Skenes innings will be limited – in a 12 team league with QS vs Wins, do you like any of these P more than Skenes ROS: Kutter, Lugo, Gil, Lodolo, Morton, Pivetta?
Kutter, Lugo or Lodolo possibly…depends how many IP we see from Skenes
Trade Christian Scott for Junior Caminaro or Coby Mayo? Thank you! 13 team dynasty 5×5
Yes, Junior
Do you prefer Gavin Stone or McKenzie Gore ROS?
Great question. Can we add Buehler and Keller to that list?
Walker, Gore, Keller, Stone
Gore
13 team dynasty 5×5…keep Cooper Criswell or Hayden Wisneski? Ha ha ha! The Bibee blurb made me shoot coffee out my nose I laughed so hard!
Ha, Cooper
How is your boy Giancarlo looking? Yes Grey we know, I meant how is he looking at the plate. I need a 4th OF and finally dropped Lourdes for Jung Ho Lee’s COL stand. He doesn’t feel like the answer though.
Haha
Can’t believe I’m writing a post like this but I have to ask: I was offered Elly for Julio, straight up. At the beginning of the season I wouldn’t have even considered this, but we’re now in May and Elly’s numbers speak for themselves. Meanwhile, aside from his SB total, Julio’s are more than underwhelming, to say the least. Grey, would you even consider this trade or do you think Julio’s numbers look better at the end of the season? I appreciate your time.
I’d want JRod
Does Matt Olson have any options left? Maybe they need to demote him to AAA. I can’t take it anymore, between him, Carroll, and Riley, my top 3 picks are killing me!!!
That’s why you should subscribe to the Grey rule of not drafting pitchers too early. LOL
To be fair, Corbin Carroll was a first round pick for a lot of ppl. And he has not lived up to that so far.
lol, he’s no Gerritt Cole or Strider
Haha
My pitching stinks, drafted Luzardo as my #1 so i need upside. Would you go for Taj over Stone and Gore?
Maybe Loperfido can get an AB or two today huh?
Nah
Would you drop Foley for Lange?
Prolly not
Tucker or Tatis Jr/Chourio ?
My worst categories are avg and steals
Tucker
Is there any risk Chourio gets sent down ?
I had such high hopes for him :'(
Yes
I need 1B. Trade Ward for Cronenworth?
Sure
Andy Pages great statcast, but what is with the lack of walks. A red flag? He was good at walking in the minors….so just curious.
His O-Swing percentage is 40%. Way too high. I think he is just trying to be aggressive to stay up with the big club. Once his role and place is more secure (lets hope), he should calm down. Young players are usually big swingers. Its a good thing his hit tool is very good as his strikeout rate is reasonable for a first time call up.
Meh, small sample
What’s up with Julio Rodriguez? Any concerns? Still 1hr and statcast is lacking.
He just started playing on May 1st…kid, kinda…I have faith still, he’s too talented to no come out of it
A. Would you drop Goldschmidt in a points league? Here, even hitting singles and doubles is valuable, but he’s been awful. How many cents on the dollar would you trade him for? Below top 20 1B? I have Bellinger at 1B.
B. Would you trade away CES for Ober or Means in a points league?
C. Are you saying Singer is now more than a streamer? He’s rostersble?
I’m not Grey but Singer should be rostered unless it’s a terribly shallow league. Only one bad start this year.
A. Goldy prolly around a top 20, barely B. Ober C. He’s not a streamer
You think Brandon Lowe takes playing time away from Rosario or Caballero?
Own both in deep league…and a little concern with Lowe and Tampa’s depth? If/when Junior comes up, who is getting the boot?
Amed is not an everyday starter, Caballero plays SS, Lowe is not playing SS
My starters include Ryan, Steele, Lugo, Lopez, C Scott, Woo, Sale, and Jared Jones. Would you drop any for Bradley or Civale? Hicks is a free agent as well.
Thinking of grabbing Candelario for Black. Do it or just grab Coby and maybe eat a week or so of stats. Thanks!
Why would you drop any of those guys? Woo is hurt so maybe but then again Civale basically sucks and I dont trust young pitchers unless they are Jared Jones.
No on the SPs — sure on Jeimer
No one in their right mind started Pivetta yesterday but please tell me he will still be a viable back of the fantasy pitching staff guy for my team.
Always depends on how deep your league is.
Hopefully
Happy Thursday meng..,w taj coming back … need to cut 1 out of …Pages, jazz, mountcastle… Triston, King, Pfaddt , Gore?
(12 teamer h2h points redraft) Tough call, as I value all of them… I do have an extra bench bat, if that helps. Btw you’re write up on Taj got me excited.
Thank you
Triston
You think Cabellaro is going to provide enough steals to be rosterable all year?
Im going to cut Torres i think… its time.
Also, i asked itchy, (you wouldnt believe the physical harm he might consider doing to mustachioed men) Should I drop Ohoppe for Jansen? Angels might be worse than the A’ss but i hate picking catcher scabs.
Is Castro the add over Vabellero? Was gunna SAGNOF jose. Just plug and play him i hope, will cash-money let me do that?
And, optionally, i got Thairo Estrada, Lugo, hicks and Yates, should i trade before the faeries find them? Who would you target (as in, ‘stupid managers will want to cut bait with this stud’).
Thank you fantasy guru, be well
I’d want Caballero and Logan…trades depends on who you’re getting…i don’t know what you need…those guys aren’t getting much tho…who’s trading for Seth Lugo?
Ok, Sagnof and dont pick my scab/trust the fml. Hopefully undervalued assets. I need 1 stud OF and pitching pitching pitching (got Romano n Claase).. yeah im trying to bilk someone, rather that than drop, in my life Thairo is blocked by lindor, k.Hayes by torenado, and teo/varsho/pages/kepler isnt enough. Ja-Dominationguez soon thou.
Thank you guru
Don’t know what you’re asking
Neither do i boss, neither do i
Ha
Need a Starting pitcher. Please rank Woo, Means and Taj Bradley.
Thank you Grey.
Taj, Means
So, you drop Woo for Taj?
Sure
Hi Grey,
Would you drop Grissom for Pham?
No
Thoughts on Washington’s Trevor Williams? He’s got a decent two step next week on the road @ CHW and @ Philly.
Worth a shot
Regression Fairies gonna eat his Corey Hart out
Haha
Would you trade Shota Imanaga and Tanner Houck for Corey Seager? In a 5×5 OBP league?
My pitching staff would be the following if I traded away Houck and Shota:
Chris Sale, Kevin Gausman, Taj Bradley, Zach Eflin, Christian Scott, Jordan Montgomery, Bryan Woo, Braxton Garrett and Joe Musgrove would be my rotation
Thanks!
Yes
Tyler Black, the classic “you’re either hitting 3rd or 4th everyday, or in minors”
its a shame a lot of ball clubs dont know how to manage young players. Every team in the league should be looking at the Orioles and how they are doing it.
Haha, incredible
Who’s the better option out of the four? Stott, Luis Garcia jr., Brujan, or toro
jmho, LGJ, although I do have a soft spot for Stott.
Garcia
Bottom 3 RP for SVHLD
Treinen, Vesia, Estevez, Barlow, Schreiber, Austin Adams or Sewald
Adams, Estevez, Barlow
Grey!!!!
Awesome, read! Only superlatives can describe it!
a. Add Bassitt (on my wire, 12-team RCL)? With Gelof almost back, I could drop Brujan or Gasser for him. Over whom?
b. Chris Rock quote of the day for May 9, 2024
If you wanna get away with murder, all you gotta do is shoot somebody in the head and put a demo tape in their pocket! “This is a rap killing. Let’s go home!”
Cheers,
Ante
Thanks! A. Gasser
Cease recorded the 4th Best Fantasy Start this season. It was his 2nd straight start and 4th overall to make the list:
4 May 8 @CHC 7 IP/ 3 BR/ 0 ER/ 12 K
11 Apr 22 @COL 7 IP/ 1 BR/ 1 ER/ 8 K
46 May 3 @ARI 6.67 IP/ 3 BR/ 1 ER/ 8 K
69 Apr 10 vs CHC 6 IP/ 4 BR/ 0 ER/ 7 K
The Cubs can rest easy as they don’t have to face Cease again this year!
Damn, he looks good!
The wind was at his back all game. I’ve taken to scouting the wind before all my starters games this season. It is really paying off last few days I started doing it haha
Yo Grey, would you lateral from Civale to Taj?
Yes