Nothing is normal in Seattle this year. It’s like grunge has returned but as a clean-shaven Buddy Holly Happy Days music. Coffee is now tea, and the space needle is shooting adrenaline directly into our hearts. This team is an offensive juggernaut, emphasis on jugger, deemphasize naut. They were in Atlanta yesterday, who is also going through The Opposites. Everyone’s the unlikeliest on both teams. Starting with the most unlikely move, the Braves moved Acuña down in the order to 7th as he hits around .200 in the 2nd half. That, however unlikely, is the least of the Braves’ problems. They were destroyed yesterday and their pitching is mostly a big ol’ mess. How’sever, to fact-check this, I went to look at the team ERAs and the Rockies’ team ERA is 6.00. In almost 1250 innings! The 1996 Tigers had a 6.38 ERA, then you have to go back about 80 years to even get close. Leading the M’s onslaught like Don Slaught on greenies and PEDs, Eugenio Suarez (2-for-5, 3 RBIs and his 44th and 45th homer, three homers in two games). He’s actually the most likely of the unlikelies. It’s Eugenio and the Unlikelies: Josh Naylor (2-for-3, 2 runs and a slam (18) and legs (24), 2nd homer in two games). A 20/30 season from Naylor would be up there with the most unlikely seasons to ever happen. He’s molasses slow! Another unlikely season is Cal Raleigh (2-for-6, 2 runs, 3 RBIs and his 53rd homer, 2nd homer in two games). Coming into this year, he was merely a sideshow at the carnival. Sign above the cage read, “See the Giant Ass.” Now, he’s The Show. Really freakin’ unlikely! Then you have Jorge Polanco (1-for-3, 3 RBIs and his 24th homer), and this season is fairly unlikely too. He looked like he might be out of baseball after the last two years. Now he’s pretty valuable. Though, compared to the other M’s, he’s the most likely unlikely. He’s rocking normcore ooh wee ooh he looks just like Buddy Holly. Anyway, here’s what else I saw this weekend in fantasy baseball:
Hurston Waldrep – 5 IP, 2 ER, 7 baserunners (5 BBs), 5 Ks, ERA at 1.33. So, those five walks are incredibly scary, and I don’t want to be roofied. I like where my pancreas is currently housed. Streamonator has him getting the Astros next, and I think I’m too chicken.
Joey Wentz – 2 1/3 IP, 8 ER, ERA at 5.82. Ya know how if you come up too fast while scuba diving you get The Bends? If you streamed Joey, you get The Wentz.
Jurickson Profar – 2-for-4 and his 13th homer, hitting .261. When everyone is poo-poo’ing him next year, I’ll be wafting the air away from my nose as I enter the John and drafting Profar aggressively.
Luis Castillo – 6 IP, 1 ER, 6 hits, zero walks, 6 Ks, ERA at 3.85. M’s won 18-2, and Castillo cruised out to the Ivictory Coast for a free night at the W.
Luis Gil – 6 IP, 1 ER, 7 baserunners (4 BBs), 1 K, ERA at 3.31. Four walks and one strikeout is code and I’m a codebreaker. The code reads: Be very carefell–Carefell? What the hell does that mean? This code is wrong or I’m wrong and I’m never wrong!
Max Fried – 7 IP, 3 ER, 7 baserunners, 4 Ks, ERA at 3.02. If you would’ve told me in the preseason he’d have a 3.15 ERA, plus or minus .15, I would’ve shrugged and said, “What, you do just super random predictions? Is that your thing?”
Ben Rice – 1-for-4, 3 RBIs and his 23rd homer. Ya know what he’s starting to feel like? A guy who is pushed up too much next year because of catcher eligibility.
Max Scherzer – 4 1/3 IP, 4 ER, ERA at 4.36. Damn, Unc let us (me) down!
Matthew Boyd – 7 IP, 2 ER, 7 hits, zero walk, 3 Ks, ERA at 2.92. It’s headed to the home stretch and Boyd has a sub-3 ERA. Cust kayin’.
Daniel Palencia – 0 IP, 5 ER, ERA at 3.00, and left with a shoulder injury. Bad news, everything to do with Palencia. Good news is since he left with an injury, it means this voodoo doll of mine works. Brad Keller and Andrew Kittredge have both been solid, and Keller has worked as the setup man, but Kittredge has received the last two non-Palencia saves, so I’d go Kittredge, but it could be either. I doubt they go back to Porter Hodge. but I guess they could.
Carson Kelly – 2-for-4 and his 15th and 16th homer. Third homer in the past week, and maybe a slight schmotato, but he also doesn’t play all that much. Does that matter? Hmm, yeah, gonna say it does.
Robert Hassell III – 1-for-3 and his 3rd homer. Aw, one for each Robert Hassell.
Sandy Alcantara – 6 IP, 4 ER, 8 baserunners, 4 Ks, ERA at 5.67. Streamonator didn’t love this start (I would’ve started him, for what it’s Wuertz), but it does love his next one.
Otto Lopez – 3-for-4, 4 RBIs and his 13th and 14th homer, hitting .248. That’s because he was hitting cleanup. You put OLo in the cleanup role he’s gonna cleanup. He’s a call answerer. He answers calls.
Jesus Luzardo – 6 IP, 2 ER, 9 baserunners, 8 Ks, ERA at 4.01. At the end of the year, Luzardo’s gonna have an ERA of, like, 3.90 or 4.05 or something, and it’s going to tell us nothing. It’s like looking at the wrinkles of an 80-year-old. You don’t know the shizz he’s seen and you don’t know what we’ve had to endure to get that Luzardo ERA.
Trea Turner – Hit his 15th homer, and now sounds like he’s gonna hit the IL with a strained hamstring. Oh no, Treat Urner you were such a good boy. Speaking of good boys, my dog Ted turns 100 (in dog years) in October. Crying emoji that is wrapping him in bubble wrap.
Jonah Tong – 6 IP, 4 ER, 7 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 4.09. I watched most of this game so, if I may channel my inner Hefner, Tong should trust his fastball more.
Brandon Sproat – 6 IP, 3 R, 7 baserunners (4 BBs), 7 Ks as he was called up. Just gave you my Brandon Sproat fantasy. Nothing really changed after this start. He looked a tad better than I expected, but not enough to change my expectations.
Juan Soto – 1-for-4 and his 38th homer. I’m kinda surprised Sexy Dr. Pepper didn’t stop at 1st base on his homer and try to steal 2nd and 3rd. I take back what I said about him wanting a 40/30 season. I think he’s sniffing 40/40. He is running every time he’s on base.
Brett Baty – 1-for-3 and his 16th homer. It sucks that Baty and Vientos are in a platoon, but, since the platoon is working, it stamps CONFIRMED on the word SUCKS. If one was not doing well, then the other might take over full-time, but it’s not looking that way.
Hunter Greene – 7 IP, 1 ER, 1 hit, 2 walks, 12 Ks, ERA at 2.59. Going in drafts next year we have a good chance for it to be Brown then Greene in the Hunter category, back-to-back.
Drew Rasmussen – 5 IP, 0 ER, 6 baserunners, 2 Ks, ERA at 2.64. Not bad for a guy they were shutting down seven weeks ago. I’m sure that won’t cause issues for him next year.
Carson Williams – 1-for-3 and his 2nd homer, hitting .209. One of the more puzzling callups. He had a 34 K% in the minors; now he has a 38% in the majors. Seems completely ill-prepared but okay.
Parker Messick – 6 IP, 1 ER, 8 hits, zero walks, 4 Ks, ERA at 1.93. Told you to grab him when he was called up and now I’m saying, same same.
Hunter Brown – 6 IP, 0 ER, 7 baserunners, 8 Ks, ERA at 2.25. Not quite a 2.25 ERA pitcher, though there’s only two guys who are even close to that, so no dur. Brown’s peripherals look solid though, and, last week I was saying how there’s three clearcut starters for next year, then four through 20 are a tossup, but Brown could lay claim to a single digit spot in the starter rankings.
Jake Burger – 2-for-3, 2 RBIs and his 14th homer, 2nd homer in three games. Burger with a side of schmotatoes!
Joe Ryan – 2 IP, 5 ER, ERA at 3.32. Joe Ryan’s 2nd half is like watching Jack Ryan in Clear and Present Danger if he died in the opening credits.
Byron Buxton – 1-for-2 and his 30th homer, and left with a knee contusion. Being real sincere, Buxton, you’ve done enough this year. It was a success. Take an IL stint and rest up for March.
Kody Clemens – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 16th homer, 2nd homer in three games, while dreaming of throwing a bat at Kody Piazza. Hot schmotato alert!
Bailey Ober – 5 1/3 IP, 1 ER, 5 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 5.08 vs. Michael Lorenzen – 5 1/3 IP, 4 ER, 7 hits, zero walks, 5 Ks, ERA at 4.63. This matchup was billed as, “What a bore-zen. Mmm, herbed cheese that comes in a wheel.”
Yusei Kikuchi – 2 IP, 7 ER, ERA at 4.18. Yustink.
Jo Adell – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 35th homer. 34 homers is for little babies. 35 homers is a benchmark for The Breakout.
Mitch Farris – 6 IP, 2 ER, 4 baserunners, 4 Ks, ERA at 2.45. He wasn’t good in Double-A, so you either explicitly trust the Angels’ coaches or whatever I say on the other side of the “or” is clearly the answer.
Tyler Soderstrom – 2-for-3 and a slam (24) and legs (8). Has a hit in every September game, and hit .330 in August and only 11 games since the break where he failed to record a hit. That’s sparkling, Soderstrom.
Manny Machado – 2-for-4, 3 RBIs and his 23rd homer. Also, in this game, Ramon Laureano (1-for-5) hit his 23rd homer; Gavin Sheets (2-for-5) hit his 19th homer and Jackson Merrill (3-for-5, 2 runs) finally reached double digits with his 2nd homer. Have I mentioned the Rockies have a 6 ERA?
Brayan Bello – 6 IP, 3 ER, 5 baserunners, 2 Ks, ERA at 3.12 vs. Ryne Nelson – 6 IP, 1 ER, 6 baserunners, 3 Ks, ERA at 3.48. This matchup was billed as, “You want upside and yawn at boring, but both of these ‘boring’ guys are better than upside, unless the upside is good. Let’s assume it’s not for this example.”
Brandon Pfaadt – 6 IP, 1 ER, 6 hits, zero walks, 7 Ks, ERA at 5.18. Without fact checking, I’m gonna go out on a sturdy limb and say this was his first good start of the year.
Ryan Walker – 0 IP, 3 ER, ERA at 3.93 on Saturday. Welp, he sucks, but hopefully he settles down, because my entire shizz is relying on him!
Riley O’Brien – 1 IP, 0 ER, ERA at 1.60 as he got his 3rd save, and the Cards continue to committee. Co-tittee? Actually, don’t say that aloud, you might get slapped.
Jacob Misiorowski – 7 IP, 1 ER, 5 baserunners, 8 Ks, ERA at 4.09. Listen, I’m all for throwing your starters as many pitches as they can throw, but how do you tamp down Misiorowski for almost two months straight, then throw him for 108 pitches? How does that make sense?
Bubba Chandler – 2 2/3 IP, 9 ER, ERA at 7.36, as he started his game, and I liked Bubba better when he was working in relief.
Tarik Skubal – 7 IP, 0 ER, 3 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 2.10. It’s not even Skubal and Skenes and everyone else this year on the Player Rater. It’s Skubal and every other pitcher.
Lenyn Sosa – 2-for-4, 2 runs, 3 RBIs and his 20th homer. Convincing myself Lenyn Sosa is a big-time power threat to make myself feel better about Gunnar lagging him by so many homers.
Trevor Rogers – 5 1/3 IP, 2 ER, 9 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 1.51. What a fantastic rum!
Yoshinobu Yamamoto – 8 2/3 IP, 1 ER, 1 hit, 2 walks, 10 Ks, ERA at 2.72. He came within one out of a no-hitter when Jackson Holliday homered. Smdh, Holiday doesn’t respect the game. Seriously, though, the Dodgers took a 8 2/3 IP no-hitter in and left with a loss. Their pen is such a mess. On Sunday, Jack Dreyer got the save, and he might get the next one or give up 5 ER in 1/3 IP.
Shohei Ohtani – 2-for-2 and his 47th and 48th homer, hitting .279. Someone needs to do like Marty did to his dad George McFly and wake Dave Roberts in the middle of the night with a Sony Walkman on his ears and tell him to use Ohtani as the closer.
Mookie Betts – 2-for-5, 2 RBIs and his 16th homer. “Ohtani/Betts?!” That’s Ippei in jail reading the Dodgers’ lineup.
Dalton Rushing – Hit the IL with a shin contusion. With no Rushing, the Dodgers are now the Bills! Bam! Did that make sense? Seriously, I’m asking. I’m also asking if you’d like to purchase a fantasy football subscription. You’d instantly move above members of my family for “possibly getting a Xmas card, but ultimately not.”
Would you be interested in starting Weathers at home against Washington on Thursday in a 14 team category h2h playoffs?
I’d start Weathers
Grey, with Palencia out, I’m down to one closer vs my opponent who has three. IMO I need to punt saves and try to win the other four categories. That leads me to my question. How good do you feel about Zebby Matthews tomorrow @LAA? The Robot really likes it. Does Grey?
I’d start Zebby
Semifinal week and starting some real schomhawks tonight – LFG!
Haha, LFG!
Hey Good people! Who would you pick to start between Luzardo /home vs Mets or T. Rogers /away vs Bluejays? TIA
Rogers
Glasnow is apparently pitching tonight. Just noting in case someone who needs to know sees this here.
Thanks!
Looking for some confirmation on a few guys …
-Who you go this week for 3b?
Vientos 4@Phil, 3 vs Tex
N. Marte 3@SD, 3@Athletics
Muncy 3 vs Col, 3 @SF
Burger 3 vs Mil, 3 @NYM
R. Lewis 3 @LAA, 3 vs Ariz
-Who you go at 1b?
Manzardo 4 vs KC, 3 vs ChW
Steer 3@SD, 3 @Athletics
Burger 3 vs Mil, 3 @NYM
Nate Lowe 3@Athletics, 3 vs NYY
-Last OF benching Tucker, who replaces him?
PCA – 3 @ATl, 3 vs TB
N. Marte – 3 @ SD, 3@Athletics
Steer – 3 @ SD, 3@Athletics
Bader – 4 vs NYM, 3 vs KC
Currently I have Vientos, Manzardo and PCA
Thanks
Vientos
Manzardo
Steer
Would you start either this week. Confidence level 1-5. 2nd week playoff H2H, K/9, WS, total K’s
Y. Gomez VS TB @CLE
Cade Cavalli @MIA, vs PIT
J. Latz vs MIL @NYM
1
0
0
Not starting any then?
no idea how deep your league is…I am not, Gomez is best if you need it
Afternoon & Happy World Physical Therapy Day!
Unfortunately, my 3B (Alec Bohm) decided to take this literally and promptly went to the IL.
I’m now left in the playoffs with a gaping hole at 1B/3B. Who you like best to band-aid?
thank you kindly my good man!
Ha, damn…Manzardo
Thanks!
Forgot to mention its a 6×6 OPS league. Was already leaning Manzardo or Chapman. I assume OPS doesn’t change anything for ya, does it?
Also, SON seems to like Zebby tomorrow. Would you advise cutting Charlie Morton for Zebby?
Thanks again!
It doesn’t
Yes, I’d go Zebby
thank you as always!
No problem
Redraft. Marsee or Profar in a Categories league
OBP, XBH, SB
Profar
In a keeper league,would you prefer holding Jonah Tong or Sheehan for 2026?
Do I hold Ozuna or drop for McLain as a possible keeper? Beck another option?
Thanks!
Tong and McLain
@Grey: weekly roto. witt out of the lineup again today. would you sit for any of these guys or roll the dice and play him anyway?
hoerner – 3 @ atl, 3 vs tb
t freeman – 3 @ lad, 4 @ sd
c walker – 3 @ tor, 3 @ atl
need avg and sbs most.
I’d play Witt
Hi Grey,
Start of our H2H playoffs in my 10 team league. Wanted your thoughts on a few lineup options:
1) need top 2 of following:
Neto 7 games MIN / @SEA
Oneil Cruz 6 games @ BAL/ @WSH
Adell 7 games MIN / @SEA
Grisham 6 games DET / @BOS
Manzardo 7 games KC / CWS
2) need 1 of:
Christopher Sanchez NYM or
Emmett Sheehan at home to COL
Thanks and wish me luck!
LG
Neto, Adell — Sanchez
Oh great Grey,
in a points league, would you start either (both) of these 2-starters over a one-start Skubal (@Mia) this week?
Darvish CIN; COL
McLean @Phi, TX
No
ESPN h2H points league. Who are you benching this week?
Langford
Profar
Happ
Soderstrom
Happ
h2h points league. Live by the 2-start week, die by the 2-start week (we’ve seen some atrocious negative point-yielding starts from pitching this year). Which one are you going with:
Beiber v HOU
Cavalli @MIA + vPIT
Bibee v CHW
Bieber
Hang onto Abbott in standard 12 team re-draft or move on for streaming options? His next two starts are @SD and @STL…
Move on if you have better options
@Grey: weekly roto. need to start one of these guys. who do you like?
mis – vs stl
slade cecconi – vs kc, vs cws
thanks!
Mis
Slade Cecconi… Hitting the wall and likely not usable for ROS, or just a cold spell and start in good matchups?
He is now at 107 IP (previous high of 77 last year). His last 5 starts: 25 IP, 23 ERA (8/28 ERA). Opponents were CHW, TEX, ATL, TB and BOS, so not exactly a murderer’s row…
Start him @CHW in 12 teamers or sit him?
Seems fine to start
ESPN points, this week only, please rank top 4:
Pepiot @Chi WS
Bradish vs Pitt
Bergert @ Cle
Sheehan vs Col
Ryne Nelson @ Minn
Schlitter vs Det
Thanks
Bradish, Pepiot, Sheehanm Bergert
Hi Grey – Triage time. Need a catcher to replace Smith. Runs scored primary importance–the category will be decided by no more than a handful of runs.
This in mind, pick one for the stretch run: Alvarez, Torrens, Wells, Stephenson, Murphy, Kelly, Fermin, Quero, Pages.
Batting average a plus, but it’s runs scored I’m after
Thanks!
Alvarez
An early Happy Birthday to Ted!
Haha, thanks!
Who do you like for 2nd right now-McNeil, Otto, Baty, L. Garcia or Durbin?
Thanks
Otto
Morning Grey!
Ravaged by injuries (streaming and hitting the waiver wire hard) but somehow cobbled together enough to get into the final 4 of my 5×5, ESPN, head to head, 12 team league. Looking for a little guidance with my starters for this week, need 5 of the following;
Snell vs Col
Alcantara vs Wash
Gallen @ SF
Sheehan vs Col
Tong vs Tex
Nelson @Min
Bradish vs Pit (if 5 man rotation he would get a turn @TOR, but I think they are running a 6 man rotation)
Kershaw @SF
Darvish vs Cin and vs Col
Bibee vs ChW
Cavalli @MIA vs Pit
Thanks for looking, apologies for all the options.
Sheehan, Bradish, Snell, Sandy, flip a coin, I guess Tong or Bibee
Perfect, thanks Grey.
A little surprised not to see Gallen, he seems to have turned it around over the last month. Would Gallen @SF be close to Tong or Bibee?
I almost said Gallen instead of Bibee
And yet Skenes has been the best pitcher in real baseball this year.
Yeah, when you don’t factor in stats
Highest WAR, lowest ERA. Skubal has given up 1/2 again
as many home runs
Skubal’s fWAR is 6.5, Skenes is 5.8
Baseball reference WAR. Skenes is 7.0. Skubal 6.7
I get it, you don’t like Skenes. I still laugh about the time you said Skenes is thinking about Skubal. hahaha.
I ranked Skenes in front of Skubal in the preseason
Grey, how do you feel about Nelson @ MIN and Luzardo vs NYM this week? Which one are you more comfy with? Nelson has been great for me, but I noticed that he has struggled on the road.
Luzardo
Also, Tucker hasn’t played since 9/2 and is already listed as out for Monday, although Cubs have said he won’t go on IL.
Sit him in weekly lock H2H? I’d be starting the following over him:
Buxton (also DTD)
Lile
Varsho
Manzardo
Sit Tucker
Hey Grey, I didn’t see the Trea Turner injury. If we don’t hear any updates before gametime, would you sit him? Based on the roster shuffling I’d have to do, it would basically mean I’m starting Andres Gimenez instead of him for the week.
I’d be surprised if he doesn’t get IL’d
Please rank the top FIVE following SP options for this week:
Schlittler vDET
Bibe @CHW
S Smith vTB
Bergert @PHI
Cecconi vCHW
Weathers vWAS
2-start YGomez vTB and @CLE
Tolle @ATH (maybe the bulk guy?)
Assad @ATL
LGarcia @ATL
Thank you.
Slade, Weathers, Smith, Cam, Gomez
10tm H2H, Total IP, Total K, QS
Opponent punts SVHD so I need to try to keep up in IP and K.
Championship Week!
Sit 2:
Cease vs Col
Lodola @ SD, @ Ath
Trevor Rogers @ Tor
Alcantara vs Was
Tong vs Tex
THANKS!
Lodolo, Tong
I think I need the IP from 2 start Lodolo even if he’s risky @ Bing Bong. Who would be my next Sit if I started Lodolo?
Rogers
Need to drop one pitcher for this week:
Morton 9/13 @MIA
Lodolo 9/8 @SD 9/14 @ATH
Cease 9/12 vCOL
Ryne 9/13 @MIN
Luzardo 9/11 vNYM
Sheehan 9/9 vCOL
Losses and Total Bases Allowed count against pitchers so volume isn’t necessarily a good thing here.
Lodolo
Hey Grey, looks like Burleson is back today. Trying to figure out which three guys to SIT out of these due to injury uncertainty and slumps:
Riley Greene (6, @NYY, @MIA)
Weenceel Perez (6, @NYY, @MIA)
Taylor Ward (7, MIN, @SEA)
Dylan Crews (7, PIT, @MIA)
Burleson (6, @SEA, @MIL)
Tucker (6, TB, @ATL)
Busch (6, TB, @ATL)
Tucker, Busch, Crews
Morning Grey!
My pitching staff is in a bit of a shambles. Which 3 to SIT this week?
Glasnow (COL, I think???)
Zebby (@LAA)
Sanchez (NYM)
G. Williams (KC)
Flaherty (@NYY)
N. McLean (TEX, @PHI)
Messick (CHW)
Mize (@NYY, @MIA)
Qunitana (@TEX) – thought he had 2 this week, but CBS doesn’t think so
Tolle (not specified – may follow an opener on Wed)
Flaherty, Tolle, Mize
Need a batty call at 2b for today:
Austin Martin @LAA
Gelof vsBOS
Cody Freeman vMIL
Ha-Seong Kim vsCHC
Gorman @SEA
I was leaning Gelof due to Bing Bong but the computer hates it.
Gelof
1. Would you drop Blaze for L.García Jr.? In theory Blaze may have a good matchup against the struggling Ray tomorrow but García is facing all RHPs this week and Blaze has been fading.
2. Would you stream Cameron tomorrow? I have four adds left this week, and he’s been scuffling, but Cleveland is a bottom 3 team against LHPs. SON is barely positive on his start.
1. yes 2. i’d hold my adds
grey quick ones for my streamers this week for semi finals 5×5 head to head cats.
1. .I own luis garcia(sp) vs tor would you drop for E.Sheehan vs col (in LA)? or hold Luis Garcia? and drop Quintana for sheehan?
2. would you throw luzardo vs Mets(later in week) or move on now? hes been good lately but hes always scary as you know.
3.also im feeling a 2 start J.Cantillo vs KC and Shite Sox.
hes been good since joining rotation..
4. better bat otto lopez or gavin sheets? otto lopez gets good pitching matchups( 4 against Nationals) sheets is platoooney.
appreciate it as always.
1. Yes, Sheehan, lose Garcia 2. I wouldn’t trust him 3. Yes, Cantillo is decent 4. Otto
1 more weathers vs Nats? fresh off IL…
I like him…him over who? Or just him?
just wondered if you liked his start vs wsh. thank you sir much appreciated.
No problem
Happy Monday!
Chasing W’s and K’s, so 2-start pitchers have a certain appeal. Can you rank the following 2-start options? And yes, I know they are not good.
Liberatore @SEA and vCIN
Y Gomez vTB and @CLE
Burrows @BAL and @WAS
K Hendricks vMIN and @SEA.
Leaning toward Gomez, W Sox don’t win a lot of games, but he is going against two team that also lose a lot, so there’s a chance, right?
Sure, try Gomez
Morning Grey! I’m desperately trying to hold onto first place – hoping you can keep me honest here. Should I bench Busch (6, TB, @ATL) in favor of Triolo (6, @BAL, @WAS)?
Yes
Morning Grey! Looking for a streamer today in a pile of hot doodoo. SON like Darvish vs CIN and is luke warm on Cecconi vs KC. Not sure how much that changes if Witt Jr. is in the lineup today. Was actually looking at rolling the dice on Bryce Elder today? SON has him at 5+ IP, 6 H, <3ER, <5K, 2BB VS CHC today. That line (not accounting for a W or L) would be roughly 15 points. W/L would be +5/-5 and HR allowed are -5. Imanaga going for the Cubs so a W is probably less than a coin flip, but Cubs have been rough in the second half. Elder went 7.0, 4H, 0ER, 0BB, 6K and the W against the Cubs last time out for 40 points.
I’d start Slade
Weekly Closer question! Which one of these three would you sit this week? Feels like it has to be Pagan, no?
Pagan (6, @SD, @ATH)
JoJo Romero (6, @SEA, @MIL)
Suarez (7, CIN, COL)
Vest (6, @NYY, @MIA)
Yes, Pagan
Just rolled my way in to the semis. Need some recommendations if you have the time:
12 team 6×6 with OBP being an additional cat
At 3B:
Noelvi
Colson Montgomery
Blaze
Meidroth
McMahon
Durbin
Correa
At SS:
Oneil Cruz
Correa
Colson
Tovar
Jeremiah Jackson
Winn
Blaze
Otto
Durbin
one from each? Colson, Otto
Yeah… thanks!
No problem
Hey Grey, would you start Kody Clemens 3@LAA, 3 vs ARZ over either of Grisham 3 vs DET, 3@BOS or Hoerner 3@ATL, 3vs TB?
Also, pick one SP to start: Ginn vs CIN, Keller @ WASH or Tong vs TEX
Thanks
Nelson @ MIN is also a SP option to start.
Grisham
Tong
Thanks. So you would start Hoerner and Grisham over Clemens? What are you doing with King this week…looks to start against either Col or Cincy
Yes, over Clemens…I wouldn’t start King
Good morning Grey! Lost it laughing on the “Ohtani/Betts” line…
We discussed it over the weekend, but McLean is adding a start and Framber pitched yesterday, so the Robot has a new order.
Revisiting my pitching rotation for this week, semi finals, QS and IP/start as categories, start 5.
Robot now has my options in order as follows:
Start:
Webb vs LAD, vs AZ
Sheehan vs COL
Nolan McLean @PHI and vs TEX
Joe Ryan vs AZ
Bradish vs PIT
Bench:
Framber @ATL
Sandy Alcantara vs WAS
Ranger vs Mets
Trevor Rogers @TOR
We’d agreed over the weekend that Rogers needs to be started with the run he’s on, so I’d swap him in for Bradish. I also am inclined to go with the robot and start McLean with the 2 start, do you agree?
Any concern on Joe Ryan? Has given up 5er in three of the last four outings. No detectable velocity loss though.
Last, are you also confident in Sheehan over either Framber or Sandy and if so which one? Sheehan had a short outing last time, while Sandy and Framber got through 7 each.
Thanks again for all your help all year! Hoping for another win this week so I have a reason to ask for one more set of advice for my finals.
Have a great week!
I’d start Rogers over Ryan, tough calls tho
12 team H2H points semi-finals playoffs – which two OF would you start this week PCA, Acuna, Adell, Duran, Soderstrom?
Without knowing matchups, Adell, Soder
Need help picking my last SP in my H2H points league playoff game.
Nolan McLean @PHI (Nola) & vs TEX (Latz)
Luzardo vs NYM (Peterson)
I’ve got other possibilities as well but not sure I trust many of them (Sheehan, Zebby, Pfaadt, Messick, Ray & Baz). McLean starting at Philly is scary although attempting to dodge the Whammy from Luzardo is equally so. Streaminator says McLean.
McLean
Hey Grey!
10TM H2H..SP Help, Please…
1) Start Lodolo @SD (12.0) Yes/No
2) Start Cessoni vs KC (7.1) Yes/No
3) Start Luis Morales vs BOS (-5.2) Yes/No
4) Start McLean @ PHI (-6.4) Yes/No
5) Start Rasmussen @ CHC (8.9) Yes/No
6) Start Luis Morales @ TOR (-7.3) Yes/No
Thanks!
1) Start Lodolo @SD (12.0) Yes
2) Start Cessoni vs KC (7.1) Yes
3) Start Luis Morales vs BOS (-5.2) Yes
4) Start McLean @ PHI (-6.4) No
5) Start Rasmussen @ CHC (8.9) Yes
6) Start Luis Morales @ TOR (-7.3) Yes
Excellent! Gracias!
Crap, I typed the same one twice..I meant 7) Luis Garcia @ TOR (-7.5)
That doesn’t sound good
ok. Thanks again! Have a great day!
You too!
No problem
Tough decision this period on who to start. It could be Quintana tonight @TEX. The Robot does not like it but it never likes Quintana.
Michael King returns from the IL tomorrow @ CIN. The Robot loves it but I don’t think it understands injuries, only matchups.
Or Jason Alexander @ TOR (Robot hates) or Logan Allen @ KC (Robot also hates for some reason).
Grey I need the right choice. Who should it be? If I lose this period, I’m out.
Quintana
Trying to avoid blow-up starts and protect my ratios the last few weeks as best I can, so considering streaming options. This week, which of these would be your top two? Is there a close 3rd?
Luis Castillo @LAA
Luzardo vNYM
Trevor Rogers @TOR
Cade Cavalli vPIT
Mitch Keller @WAS
Messick vCHW
Bryce Miller @WAS
Priester vSTL
Ryan Weathers vWAS
Michael King vCIN
Messick, Priester, Meh….i guess weathers
Thanks — Eury Perez vWAS and Scherzer vBAL are also options. Would either of those be preferable to Priester vSTL?
Nah
Jo Adell had to leave Sunday’s game for feeling nauseous. I guess all those homers made him dizzy!
Haha nice
Hi Grey!
Love your work as usual, especially the Mookie Betts one today!
Scraped through the first week of H2H playoffs and need to line up starts for second week. Which are the top 3 among:
Seymour @CHW (not sure if he’ll start given he piggybacked last time)
Wells vs PIT
Bergert @CLE
Morton @MIA
Severino vs CIN
Lodolo @ATH
Verlander vs LAD
Cecconi vs CHW
Thanks! Wells, Slade, bergert
Thanks, mixing in a couple other start options – which are the top 3 now?
Wells vs PIT
Slade vs CHW
Bergert @CLE
Bello vs NYY
Boyd vs TB (Only adding in because he hasn’t been stunning, just solid, and I’m thinking I’m willing to take a bigger risk if needed)
Messick vs CHW
Boyd, Messick, Wells
Oops, I’m my starts all mixed up – apologies for asking over and over. I need to pick two of these (or a different one from the original list):
Bello vs NYY
Bergert @CLE
Slade vs CHW
Doesn’t change the top 3
Got it, so not Bello vs NYY. Appreciate your help as always!
No problem
Need to sit 2 in the playoffs:
Woo vs. Stl, LAA
Houser @ CHW @ CHC
Ray vs. Ari
Sheehan vs. Col
Williams vs. KC
Nelson @ Min
Misiorowski vs. Stl
Daily lineups league so can start Houser in one game and sit him in another. Thanks!
Houser @CHC and Ryne
Thanks grey. Does that change if I mention it’s a QS league instead of Wins?
No
Hey Grey, need one; Darvish v Cin, vCol ; McLean @ Phil, v Tex; or Morales v Bos, v Cin. Thanks
Morales
There are two new entries on the 100 Best Fantasy Starts list from the weekend. Greene earned his third spot and Cincinnati’s 8th, while Woodruff got back on track after giving up 13 runs in 14 and a third innings in his last 3 outings. The Brewers have 4 of the top 100 starts:
17 Nick Lodolo Jul 23 @WSH
22 Quinn Priester Jun 28 vs COL
35 Andrew Abbott May 30 @CHC
37 Hunter Greene Sep 7 vs NYM
40 Nick Lodolo Apr 27 @COL
49 Andrew Abbott Jun 10 @CLE
51 Brady Singer Mar 31 vs TEX
52 Hunter Greene Apr 13 vs PIT
56 Hunter Greene Apr 7 @SF
64 Quinn Priester Jul 18 @LAD
72 Brandon Woodruff Sep 6 @PIT
73 Freddy Peralta Aug 29 @TOR
Great stuff, Vin!
Grey!!!!
Awesome!!
Rodney Dangerfield quote of the day for September 8, 2025
Fiddle Viracola (Blanche Genaro): Look at him, he’s such a beautiful boy. He’s got my eyes.
John Scoletti (John Genaro): And he’s got my nose.
Rodney Dangerfield (Monty Capuletti): Yeah, and my sympathy.
– Easy Money (1983)
Cheers,
Ante
So many names, I can’t keep track of the funny!!!! LMAFOLMAFOLMAFO!!!!
Thanks!
WT actual F does one do with Wheeler on a keeper team? (Keepers lock in mid march). I know the answer is wait and see but till then lol
Also if you’re keeping 3 of the following which 3?
M King
Glasnow
Yelich
Busch
Marsee
J Jackson
Casas
Jobe
Answer is likely what options do you have? Yelich, Busch, These are terrible, Glasnow or King
The only thing skubal really has on skenes is wins which is the dumbest of all fantasy stats imho
At the end of every season in my dynasty league I move to get rid of wins and replace it w some pitching ration like k/bbb or literally anything else and every year the vote loses 5-7
Ha
Yes
Hittertron has these 3 dead even for this week, which is semi-finals.
My league has OBP as a ctg + ctg’s for std roto + 1/2/3B
Would you rank them this way?
Vientos (7 games – @PHI, TEX)
Bregman (6 games – @ATH, NYY)
Polanco (7 games – STL, LAA)
Would your 2/3 rank be better than:
O Lopez (7 – WSH, DET)
Lile (7 – @MIA, PIT)
Burleson (6 – @SEA, @MIL)
Woof – Maybe not Burleson.
Cards face
Woo, Kirby, Gilbert
Woodruff, Misiorowski, Quintana
not even sure he’s healthy
Saw that he’s coming off the IL today but passing anyways
Gotcha
are you asking to rank all 6? Vientos, Bregman, Otto, Polanco
Yep, you got it! Rank the 3B options & then whether any of the other replacements are better than the 3 3B options. Thank you!
No problem
Dios mio, rolled my way into the semis. Points league. Which three do you like the most?
Bradish vs PIT (85 wRC+ vs RHPs). I assume he’s not picking up a 2nd start @ TOR.
Ranger Suarez vs NYM (101 wRC+ vs LHPs, but 82 wRC+ vs LHPs in road games). Could he pick up a 2nd start vs KC? Phillies have Buehler scheduled for Friday but he pitched crappy today in triple-A, not sure why the Phillies would stick with a 6-man rotation instead of moving to a 5-man rotation that excludes Buehler.
Gausman vs HOU (98 wRC+ vs RHPs)
Pablo Lopez vs ARI (111 wRC+ vs RHPs)
Joe Ryan vs ARI (111 wRC+ vs RHPs). Ryan has given up 5+ ERs in 3 of past 4 starts.
Safe to assume Turner is hitting IL? He headed toward the dugout immediately, and he was out for a while with a hamstring injury last season.
Bradish, Suarez, Gausman
I’d be shocked if Trea isn’t IL’d
Naylor basically being Abrams but at 1B is hilarious.
I thought you were for sure gonna lead from Giant Ass to The Big Show.
Carson Williams is an odd one. I get it. He is raw take him for a test drive. I think he hit .166 until end of May and then went on a 6 week tear to get the average up to .220ish. Power/speed/glove but that contact is….yeah. Of course I am sure they arent messing with his head. On Saturday they used him as a PH with the bases loaded and had Mangum try to steal home and get caught to end it.
Tong I could not tell if the C was being too cute with the gameplan or Tong was the issue. It felt like going away from his strength.
Sosa and Montgomery probably would have carried me to a championship rather than the established bums on my team to be honest.
Why does Royce Lewis want to steal so much now? RUNNING IS WHAT CAUSED YOUR CRIPPLING BEFORE! You should have a PR from the batters box to first!
I saw that on the stealing home…Incredible…Tong didn’t seem to be comfortable at all, not sure…Sosa and Montgomery are basically Mantle and Maris
That was just the second time all year the Cards used O’Brien back-to-back days. He threw just 8 pitches and got the win on Saturday.
Any opinion on Svanson? They dont really seem inclined to use him for setup but numbers look good.
Seems good to me, but I don’t consider myself a good judge of talent, especially pitching. I also don’t retain knowledge of pitches. I’m quite useless as a resource. I know he hasn’t done anything to make me hate him.
Haha
Gotcha
Head to Head league with OBP and AVG as separate categories and going into championship week.
Thanks as always
Royce Lewis also an option to add at 3b
He’s been running, so if you need SBs
Thank you. Where does Weathers fit in the group of pitchers in my lat questions
Sandy, Cantillo, Weathers
Grey,
Looks like McLean now getting 2 starts next week (@Phi;TX). Would you take him over Darvish who has 2 home starts (CIN; COL)?
Yes