Allow me to paint a visual metaphor. A vetaphor. The entire league’s pitching is cornered on the grounds of a wildlife preserve. A tiger, we’ll call him Blister, stalks towards the league’s pitching. There’s no way out, but the league attempts to urinate on Blister to keep him away. Then, out of nowhere, Nat Gio, dressed as Lord Beasley, a world famous butterfly collector from Gilligan’s Island, rides his Eddie Bauer jeep into Blister’s den, and befriends the beast, saying, “I slay pussy,” then off everyone’s look, “…cats.” Yesterday, Gio Gonzalez had yet another great start — 6 IP, 0 ER, 5 baserunners, 4 Ks, ERA at 2.49. I’d love to be a fly on the wall when Gio hears people talking about the new baseball and how offense is up. Maybe he’s the one pitcher who likes a tightly-sewn baseball. Up until this year, he must’ve been like, “Geez, is this ball going to unravel when I throw it?” Of course, his outlook for 2018 fantasy doesn’t look anywhere near as optimistic. Besides his ERA, there’s nothing promising in his peripherals. He has left 85.7% of men on base. That’s more than a wife with a headache. Anyway, here’s what else I saw yesterday in fantasy baseball:
Trea Turner – Took batting practice on Tuesday, and is about ten days away. That news is so sexy my ears are now pregnant. Hope you’re happy, Turner, you’ve made my ears preggers!
Howie Kendrick – 2-for-4 and two homers (5, 6), hitting .353. Howie like me now! Or if a cat is reading, Howie like meow. That’s not a .353 average since his trade to the Nats. That’s on the season. However, he has been on the DL for about half the season, so he has less than 200 ABs.
Tyler Skaggs – 5 IP, 2 ER, 9 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 3.63. His only blemishes were the Howie homers. Okay, and those neck razor bumps he got from shaving without Soothing Aloe Barbasol. Definitely worth trying Skaggs if you’re struggling with pitching, and, really, who isn’t?
Andrew Heaney – Ready to return from Tommy John this weekend. He’s looked terrific in rehab (2.60 ERA, 29/5 K/BB in 27 2/3 IP), but using him for his first start back in almost 16 months? Be smart, humanoids, use your Bobby the Brain on Heaney. Also, he was a bit of a ham-and-egger even before the surgery.
Carlos Correa – Could take BP this weekend. No way is Correa taking our oil! Oh, wait, batting practice, carry on.
Lance McCullers – Threw a bullpen session. No timetable yet for his return, but I can hypothesize. You want me to hypothesize? Okay. He goes on a rehab assignment this weekend, throws two rehab games, returns the first week of September, looks solid, if rusty, then looks dominant on September 13th, which would’ve been Roald Dahl’s 101st birthday, and to that I say, “BFD to The BFG!”
Brad Peacock – 4 2/3 IP, 4 ER, ERA up to 3.30. If you accidentally type “Bra Peacock” into Google, you get some interesting results. Don’t those feathers tickle? Any hoo! Peacock is alternating good start with bad start, and may be tiring. I’d still hold him for his next start, seeing as how the Stream-o-Nator likes it.
Anthony Banda – 4 IP, 8 ER, ERA at 7.32. It feels like Banda horses every time he pitches, especially the song, The Funeral.
Ketel Marte – 2-for-5, 1 run as he hit leadoff, hitting .286. Not sure if Diamondbacks’ manager, Torey Lovullo, just saw Ketel, thought of vodka and put him one, but this would be a boon for his value if he stays at leadoff. By the way, didn’t Torey Lovullo marry Brad from the Real World/Road Rules Challenge?
Madison Bumgarner – 6 IP, 4 ER, 10 baserunners, 4 Ks, ERA at 2.99. Said this before, will say it again. I won’t own Bumgarner because he will be too expensive next year, but the Giants are fools for not shutting him down this year. Let him get the rest.
Denard Span – 3-for-4, 3 runs, 2 RBIs and a slam (8) and legs (7). When he hit that home run, Ben Revere felt a twinge 3,000 miles away and instinctually ran around the bases.
Giancarlo Stanton – 2-for-4, 2 runs and his 44th homer, and 80th homer in the last 79 days. Another question for our legal community, if I break into Giancarlo’s bathroom, dressed up like a toilet, is this illegal?
Marco Estrada – 4 1/3 IP, 6 ER, ERA at 5.09. Someone mentioned in the comments yesterday something I construed as them saying Estrada is a top 20 starter, and I nearly fell off my chair, and I stand all day or sit in a Barcalounger, which doesn’t allow for falling, so you can imagine my surprise.
Josh Donaldson – 2-for-3, 3 RBIs and his 18th homer, hitting .263. Imagine if he did this in April and May and collapsed in the 2nd half, rather than vice versa. Teams that quit in June would still be competing and may not be signing up to compete in our fantasy football leagues. (Smooth segue!)
Wilson Ramos – 3-for-4 and his 5th homer, and 2nd homer in as many games. Get him now before he hurts himself again!
Blake Snell – 6 IP, 4 ER, 8 baserunners (1 BB), 4 Ks, ERA at 4.78. Results haven’t been gorge, but his command has been improved. Guess what I’m saying is I am a monocled cyclops. By the way, love to be a person who just stumbled on this site. “Monocled cyclops? Is this person a mental patient?” Well, no, I’m not…yet.
Cory Spangenberg – 2-for-4, 2 runs, 4 RBIs and his 12th homer, and 4th homer in three days. Yesterday, I called him a hot schmotato, and today, I say, yup.
Jorge Alfaro – 1-for-3, 2 RBIs and his 1st homer, a rocket to center field. Alfaro, did it go? 415 feet. He is a top catcher prospect with huge raw power. He did next to nothing in the minors — hitting .241 with seven homers, but he could be a 20-homer catcher with everyday at-bats. Definitely worth an NL-Only look, we’ll see about the rest.
Rhys Hoskins – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 3rd homer, and 3rd in two games. You consonant having, in Petco driving, buttercup
Matt Joyce – 2-for-5, 2 runs, 4 RBIs and his 17th homer, 2nd one in three games. Also, in this game, Matt Olson (2-for-4, 2 runs, 2 RBIs) hit his 8th homer, 3rd one in four games. Someone wake Matt Chapman, because the A’s are on the Mattack!
Mike Moustakas – 1-for-4 and his 35th homer. Moistasskiss! (Seriously, though, 35 homers from Moustakas! SERIOUSLY THOUGH!)
Eric Hosmer – 2-for-4, 2 runs, 4 RBIs and his 20th homer. Moistasskiss and Hosmer both took Blake Treinen deep in the 8th inning of a game the A’s were losing and, gah, that is the worst, right? It’s like, “I’m going to sleep with another great pitching day,” three hours later, some random West Coast reliever gives up runs and you wake the next day with an ache in your heart, but a vulture win!
Alex Wood – 7 IP, 1 ER, 6 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 2.30. In the 2nd half coming into this game, he had a 4.25 ERA with only 19 Ks in 29 2/3 IP. Yesterday’s start vs. the White Sox at home isn’t really indicative of anything. As Billy Butler likes to lick his lips over, it was a cakewalk. His next start on the road will be a better indication if Wood’s going flaccid.
Tim Anderson – 1-for-4 and his 14th homer, and third homer in the last four games, and third time in the last four days I’ve mentioned him. Nope, no idea what you’re waiting for either.
Juan Minaya – 1 IP, 0 ER. He threw a solid 7th inning of a losing game, and the fad of Jake The Petrocka (2/3 IP, 2 ER) looks over before it started. Nice closer shituation, White Sox. Just go with A. Bummer, at least it would be appropriate.
Mike Leake – 4 1/3 IP, 8 ER, ERA up to 3.88. I don’t know, Mike, that looks more like a flood to me.
Dexter Fowler – 3-for-4, 1 run, 2 RBI, hitting near-.415 in the last week, and owned in less than 50% of ESPN leagues, and the ESP is most definitely not extrasensory perception.
Xander Bogaerts – 3-for-5, 1 run, 1 RBI, and maybe the 5th time I’ve mentioned him across five months, because, ya know, in 17 games, Rafael Devers (2-for-4, 2 runs, 1 RBI) has the same number of homers as Bogaerts. Bogaerts is the Nat Gio of hitters. Did Bogaerts used to train by hitting a loosely-rolled sock and now the tightly wound ball has him all messed up? I told everyone to sell him in April, but not even I expected anything this bad.
Chase Anderson – Will return to the rotation on Sunday for a start in Colorado. Chase, you might want a flare-up that pushes your start back a day.
Zach Davies – 6 2/3 IP, 1 ER, 8 baserunners, 2 Ks, ERA at 4.26. I wouldn’t eff this guy with your fantasy team.
Gregory Polanco – Hit the DL with the strain of a lost season. There’s no knowable cure yet.
Ivan Nova – 6 IP, 1 ER, 7 baserunners (3 BBs), 4 Ks, ERA at 3.77. Okay, but this start was in Miller Park, so you couldn’t have started him here, and three walks for him in six innings is essentially a flashing sign that reads, “Cauton.” Someone needs to fire that sign maker too. Cauton? What the eff is cauton?
Kyle Freeland – 6 IP, 3 ER, 6 baserunners, 5 Ks, ERA at 3.74, as he was activated from the DL. He’s returning from a groin strain that happened when Freeland had a free hand.
Nolan Arenado – 1-for-4 and his 27th homer. I can’t believe I finally completed my house I made of styrofoam peanuts, I’m going to donate this to a family in need—NOOOO!!! Torenado!!!
Mark Reynolds – 1-for-3 and his 24th homer. Even if you told me I could only start Mini Donkey in Coors, I’d own him all year.
Trevor Story – 1-for-3 and his 16th homer. Look at this schmohawk rolling up like he hasn’t been terrible all year. Nice of you to show up every 12th game. You’re a real champ!
Danny Salazar – 7 IP, 1 ER, 3 baserunners, 10 Ks, ERA at 3.92. On my team where I’ve had him since he’s returned from the DL: 32 1/3 IP, 1.39 ERA, 0.84 WHIP and 46 Ks. K-zar!
Carlos Santana – 3-for-3, 3 runs, 3 RBIs and his 17th and 18th homer. Also, in this game, Jason Kipnis (1-for-4) hit his 9th homer; Edwin Encarnacion (1-for-4) hit his 27th homer and Austin Jackson (3-for-4, 3 RBIs) hit his 5th homer. All of these guys are owned commensurate to leagues, and I don’t know what commensurate means, but Jackson could be available, and a schmotato.
Joey Gallo – 1-for-3, 2 runs, 2 RBIs and his 34th homer. Serious question, in 2018, Gallo if he were guaranteed a .375 BABIP or Judge and a .250 average? Only luck separating them? You said it, not me. (Okay, I said it.)
Robinson Chirinos – 1-for-3 and his 14th homer. Uh-oh, Chirinos!
Justin Verlander – 6 IP, 5 ER, ERA up to 4.11. We discussed Verlander on yesterday’s podcast, and what to expect from him next year. It’s a real humdinger, which sounds like a command in a brothel.
Devin Mesoraco – Out for three to six weeks with a fractured foot. He has almost as hard a time staying on the field as he does standing in front of a mirror.
Luis Castillo – 6 IP, 0 ER, 4 baserunners, 7 Ks, ERA at 3.39. Dizzamn, doode’s impressing on the reg. I was one ‘hella’ away in that sentence from sounding like your embarrassing uncle who wears his baseball cap everywhere. Have no faith in rookie pitchers in general, but Castillo throws 98 MPH, 9 K/9, 3.89 xFIP and looked dominant against some of the toughest hitters in the league. He’ll have Growing Pains that we’ll call Boners, but I do own him in a mixed league, so I’m not totally opposed.
Kyle Hendricks – 6 IP, 0 ER, 9 baserunners, 6 Ks in 93 pitches, ERA at 3.45. Wow, that was like a 130-pitch complete game for Hendricks.
Aroldis Chapman – 1 IP, 2 ER and the save, but felt tightness in his hamstring. Funny, his owners have felt tightness in their chest recently. The Yankees might play it safe with Aroldis, and give him extended rest, but if Robertson and/or Betances are available in your league, can I get in your league? Do you play for payola?
Gary Sanchez – 2-for-3, 2 RBIs and his 21st homer. Frequent commenter, Packers, mentioned yesterday that Sanchez has 41 homers in 138 career games. Imagine what he’d have if the Yankees played an extra inning game that lasted 1,242 innings. (He’d have 82 homers.)
Jacoby Ellsbury – 1-for-4 and his 6th homer, and 2nd homer in the last three games. Ellsbury could be a hot schmotato, or he could tear a hamstring. I’m going with the latter, like Altuve getting down cereal.
Amed Rosario – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 2nd homer. A *pinkie to mouth* Rosarip! No? Okay. Both of his homers have come against closers and have gone the other way. What does all this mean? Not much, he looks like he has 384-feet power. Just enough giddy up. Definitely more impressed with him so far than Ozzie Albies, but a few weeks means nothing. Oh, and this is the longest blurb ever recorded. Move on already, Grey!
Dominic Smith – 1-for-3, 2 RBIs and his 1st homer. If the future is female, someone needs to haze Amed and Dominic and put them in skirts.
Noah Syndergaard – Threw 20 pitches off the mound. Not timetable for Syndergaard, but, like with McCullers, I’d guess around Roald Dahl’s 101st birthday too for the remake called, Games and the Giant Pitch.
Can you rank Hoskins, Broxton and Margot in a redraft?
Rosey pulled with injury. So much for that experiment….
Yup, grab Oh or Duke
@Grey: ugh….in that order?
@herschel: what about lyons? hes been pretty solid recently and has been pitching the 8th?
@herschel: it’s probably lyons (or oh just from “having done it”) with duke last. duke is back WAY early from TJ.
@goodfold2: i’ve added lyons myself in a few spots.
grey whats the deal with Hanley? someone dropped him do you think hes worth grabbing hoping he gets hot? OPS league
No, let him go
@Grey
This Beckham guy has been on a tear as of late. Do you think he is forrealz?
Odor has picked it up recently. Not sure why theyre batting him 8th tonight.
Odor or Beckham?
Thanks brotha
I’d go Odor, but tomato-tomahto at this point
I need power to win this year. Keeper league.
Trade my Tim Beckham + Ian Desmond for his J Upton? He wants future.
Good or hold?
Works for me
@Grey: weekly roto redraft, need to drop one of c-dick or rosario. leaning c-dick. thoughts?
Dickerson
@Grey: thanks. i know football isnt really your thing, but are you on last chance u? its pretty great….
Yeah, I love Last Chance U… Waiting for Wagner to sleep with one of the kids
@Grey: that had to have happened at some point, no??
Ha, yup
total fire in this one top to bottom.. the Torenado is the funniest fantasy running gag ever (bc a tornado could easily destroy regular to strong stuff, much less the most fragile things ever) and all this Roald Dahl with the callback ending? almost too much
Ha, thanks!
I love how any momentum my team gets is immediately halted by a 2/28 .069 batting effort so far on the day. This has happened to me a ton of times this season with various lineups. I swear these guys randomly call eachother and say, “wanna just fuck off tomorrow?” There isnt 30 Chris Salesezuhsezuh pitching today! Wtf?! Oh and the guy ive benched the last 2 days has consecutive days with steals, which the last time he stole a base Judge was batting .330. Haaaaaa! Ok rant over. Btw Great article Grey!
Haha, been there!
AL only with holds and saves sold separately. have rogers/belisle/giles/j.wilson (we still get stats if they are traded away midseason). somebody just dropped treinen. holds can be replaced nearly equally (tepera out there). drop rogers or belisle for treinen?
Rogers
10 team Yahoo H2H 7×7
W, L, SV, K, ERA, WHIP, QS
Was already going to start Morton vs. ARI (6.1) tonight so leave these two benched or start one of them?
J Gray vs. ATL (-8.1)
Lynn @BOS (-27.6)
Benched
@Grey: word thanks for the confirmation!
No problem
Grey!
Should I drop Desmond at this point? I have room to carry him on my bench, but no longer sure there’s a point. Also, I haven’t watched any Twins games lately, is Buxton actually improving at the plate, or has it just been better results? Thanks!
Yes, drop Desmond — Buxton looks like he’s improving
@Grey: thanks for the promptness! Wow, Diaz has no idea where his pitches are going…
Haha, none at all
@Grey: Well at least no one got a hit on him haha, batter coach strategy on Diaz, don’t swing, you’re welcome
Haha
@dtbran: yessir
Drop Leake for Junis or E. Jackson? Mike Flood sucks (apparently). Thanks in advance Grey!
Edwin
grey: in a 12 team 5×5 h2h league i have the following team:
1b- Freeman
2b- Moncada
3b- Donaldson
Ss- Simmons
Of- Trout
Of- Giancarlo
Of- Blackmon
Util- Bellinger
Util- Benintendi
Bn- Marte
Bn- C. Davis
Bn- Longoria
Bn- Rosario
Sp- Carrasco, Verlander, Nelson, Taillon, Peacock, Castillo, Ryu
Rp- Holland, Rosenthal, Greene
it’s looking like Bedrosian is the closer in Anaheim…who do i drop to add him? Thanks!
@Matthew Lehman: also is anyone worth dropping for T Beckham?
Simmons… Get rid of you bench bats
Amed
Grey,
To this day I still say Amed Rosario with a goofy robot voice. Both out loud and in my head. Just wanted to say thanks for that.
You’re welcome!
Man, your weekly lineup recommendation to me of 5-game Villar and Brox is paying off in spades despite neither playing all games yet . . . SB and perfectly fine hitting from Villar, 2 HR already from Brox today. And these aren’t even the @COL games. Thanks!
Nice!
Pull landmine Richard before he ruins his beautiful outing please! He’s done enough for the win already.
Haha…Good ol’ Petco streamers
Rhys or Domingo as a keeper in a 10 teamer?
@demribbies: sry forgot this bit, if it helps, 10 team w/ 12 keeps (top 120)
Rhys
Stanton didn’t hit a homerun today. Cut?
Prolly time to look elsewhere
McCullers or Wood as a keeper for next year? Top 60-75 range?
One more… keeper value next year. Smoak or Severino?
About same as Wood/McCullers
Sounds about right
Thanks. Who’s your favourite out of the bunch?
Wood
To the guy who didn’t wanna start Jimmy Nelson… I’ll pray for you.
At least we don’t have to start him at Coors this week, right? Though this is prob the same type of start we’d get there. I’m not watching, only listening on the radio.
Jimmy! Please get your head outta your ass, jeeeez!
Yeah, blech on this start
@Grey:
Gerrit Cole too jeeze hes a weird pitcher
Looking for daily streamers in playoffs…Matz is on ww going up against NYY tomorrow and stream-o-nator has him at $9.2. Are you buying that or is the streamonator humping my ipad? Fiers is also available against Ari but only got $1.0.
I don’t like either, but am starting Fiers
Can you rank the following ROS:
Eddie Rosario, Amed Rosario, Aaron Hicks, Manuel Margot, Josh Harrison, Tommy Pham
Pham, Hicks, Margot
Is Seager droppable for a good SON streamer? I can slot Freeman at 3B, Smoak at 1B, and there are other 1B on the wire I could rely upon in the event I trade Smoak.
12-team, h2h, 5×5, redraft.
C – Realmuto; 1B – Freeman; 2B – Dozier; 3B – K.Seager; SS – Machado; OF – Merrifield, Duvall, Melky ; Util – Smoak; Bench – Souza, Santana, Pham ; DL – Correa
SP – Severino, Wood, Taillon, Salazar
RP – Holland, Greene, Doolittle, Rosenthal, Vizcaino, Bedrosian
Yes
Grey! ROS God or Giancarlo (he already stole a base today,!!!); dude must of been created by Prometheus, because he is strait FIRE.
Giancarlo, easy call
I’m pretty much out of the running in one league now that Harper is injured so I’m looking at my keepers. It’s a 12 team league with wonky batter stats (R, RBI, HR, NSB, OBP, SLG) where you can keep 6 guys forever. I believe my keepers will be:
Harper
Stanton
Bryant
Benintendi
Devers
Hoskins
Would you keep any of these guys over those 6:
Albies
Rosario
Lucroy
Fisher
Mazara
Dominic Smith
Tough calls, too early to say, prolly your six
Looking to shore up my bench bats in a 12 team Redraft H2H Points League…would you drop any of GPolanco, IHapp, LBrinson, OAlbies & BZimmer for any of the following of Pirela, Buxton, Broxton, ERosario, Spangenberg or Beckham? Thanks again for always responding & for your awesome articles!
All of them… Forget Broxton
@Grey: Who would be your 3 drops & 3 pick-ups?
@NoOneIsHome: Polanco, Zimmer, Brinson… Beckham, Buxton, Spangenberg
@Grey: You da man!!!
No problem
Hey Grey, who would you rather keep in dynasty league for next season: Randal Grichuk, Melky Cabrera, Tommy Joseph or David Peralta?
None? Grichuk
Devers or Kyle Seager ROS points Ieague
Devers
Dynasty league: Do I trade Jonathan Villar, Brendan Rodgers, and Jose Adolis Garcia for Matt Chapman, Nick Gordon, and Ozzie Albies?
Meh, pretty fair, I’d take Albies
Great write-up Grey!
Didi, Beckham or Spangenberg ROS?
Thanks!
Thanks! Beckham
What’s the haps on the craps Grey? Playoffs start after next week, so good to hear that Trea Turner should be back in the fold by then. I’m thinking Margot would be the cut, but could also go with Cozart or Thames. What’cha think?
Some commenters chiming in on Dinelson Lamet above. I agree with your assessment. Essentially, if you watch the stream-o-nator, you know when to start him and when to leave him alone. Depends on the league, but I do think he’s moving from a streamer to a regular rostered starting pitcher. You da’ poop!
Margot — can’t start Lamet in away games with any confidence
I have GPolanco, IHapp, BZimmer, OAlbies & LBrinson on my bench in 12 Team non keeper H2H Points League. Would you drop any of them for any of the following to shore up bench depth? ERosario, BBuxton, KBroxton, TBeckham, Spangenberg or Pirela? As always, thank you for your responses & awesome articles!
Can you please rank top two of Gio, Bauer, Carlos Martinez ROS? Thank you.
C-Mart, Gio
@Grey: thanks Grey
No problem
Given new on Madson’s finger is worse than expected would you drop him for Ziegler in a points league?
Sure
Am I crazy for wanting to drop Gyorko? I’m making a decent run this year and he’s been eating up a bench spot for a few weeks. Are you optimistic he’s going to figure this knee out?
Not crazy
Question: Who bats higher in the Nats lineup – Rendon or Lind?
Answer: You’re wrong.
Nice write-up Guru!
4 more weeks until playoffs.. and then 3 weeks of playoffs
no one taking miggy in trades.
miggy droppable for hot schmotatoes and streamers at this point? like Cory SpankinBurger?
Thanks! Spankinburger!
If you own Chapman, would you drop Kintzler for Robertson at this point? And yes, Robertson is available, you can join our league any time!
Yes
start Faria tonight in TOR?
Nope
@Grey: watched Ozark first episode last night. Just like you said, pleasant surprise. Started kinda cutesy and then suddenly you are into this dark, brooding violent drama.
Yeah, it’s solid, I’m 4 eps in and it stays aight
@Grey: try Goliath one day curious if you would like it. I did.
Yeah, it’s on my list with Sneaky Pete
Grey-another great article.
Trying to finish out the ROS line-up in a 10 team H2H league that uses SV+H, and QS. I need 1 more RP from F Rodney, LeClerc, Ziegler, Greene, Bedrosian, Viscaino and Barraclough. Any clear favorite?
I would also like to add 1 more SP. Any of these for ROS or are they all streamers-Roark, Gray, J Garcia, Z Davies or Folty?
Thanks again for all of the advice.
Thanks! Vizcaino — Streamers
@Grey:
Appreciate it.
No problem
Hey Grey, Love your stuff, wish I listened on Spandy :( He gone now.
I have Bell, Rosario, Avisail Garcia recently picked up and I’m rotating them through 1 OF and 1 UTIL spot. Should I drop one of them for Hoskins?
C-Weiters
1B-Zim
2B-DJ LeM
3B-Freeman
SS-Marwin G
OF-Myers, NCruz, JBell
UTIL-Rendon, Devers
BENCH-Rosario, Arcia
In 8th place, 8 games back of 6th (6 teams playoffs), 12 team H2H, standard 5×5
I live by these Daily Notes, so thank you.
Bench: Rosario, AGarcia*
@Juarez: Thanks! Bell for Hoskins
@Grey: Thanks! Bell has batted .300 since the ASB and is 58/20/63 on the year… any particular reason why him?
Cause I prefer Hoskins… Who you wanna lose Avisail? Amed? They’re all coin flips… Hoskins does what Bell does
@Grey: Fair enough. Appreciate the go-back response!
No problem
What do you think of me making any of these trade offers?
1. Wood + OF for Judge (or Yoenis)
2. Smoak + Merrifield for Darvish (or Greinke)
3. Souza for Happ
4. D.Santana for S.Gray
5. Pham for Morton
12-team, h2h, 5×5, redraft.
C – Realmuto; 1B – Freeman; 2B – Dozier; 3B – K.Seager; SS – Machado; OF – Merrifield, Duvall, Melky ; Util – Smoak; Bench – Souza, Santana, Pham ; DL – Correa
SP – Severino, Wood, Taillon, Salazar
RP – Holland, Greene, Doolittle, Rosenthal, Vizcaino, Bedrosian
@Not your average Joe: Could see 4 or 2 — 3 & 5 are whatever, and 1 looks like you need an SP
Would you drop either Eickhoff or Straily for Corbin, Bauer or Rodon? Or, are they all streamers at this point? Thanks.
@tank1: Streamers
Skaggs: I’m struggling for pitching, but his next 3 match-ups look to be Tex, Hou, @Tex. You still try him?
@Fungazi: Try him vs Texas and take it from there.
@Fungazi: @home is good
Hey guys, I wanted your opinion on this offense. Lately I’ve been killing it, and, though I’m out of contention, I’m still trying to gain as many points as possible. I was curious about how you thought this offense would rank going into next season:
C – Sanchez ($1), McCann ($1)
1B – Abreu ($25)
2B – Pirela ($1)
3B – Devers ($1)
SS – Rosario ($1)
MI – Bregman ($1)
LF – Mazara ($1)
CF – Benintendi ($1)
RF – Judge ($1)
OF – M. Cabrera ($1), Kepler ($1)
Util – Hoskins ($1)
BN – Hanley ($1), Fisher ($1), Rodgers ($1), McMahon ($1), Acuna ($1)
Polanco ($22) was just dropped today and I will try to pick him up as a FA once he (hopefully) clears waivers for $1.
With a $300 budget, my thoughts were to go all in next draft on Scherzer and Kershaw, who will both be available, and spending as much as possible, even if that means $75 each. Pair them with Kluber, deGrom, (maybe) Manaea and Stroman, and I think I’m gold, but that depends on how good you think my offense is.
11 team roto keeper. All of the above players could be kept.
I think your offense is solid, but lots of young guys… You need Benny, Maz, Judge, Hoskins, Amed, Devers, etc to all do well… Could happen, or they could have sophomore slumps
Would you sit Starling Marte tonight to start Hoskins…
Only reason why I am questioning it, is because I can gain ground in SB and AVG which is Marte’supside.. also the matchup looks decent against Jimmy Nelson (8/24, 4 SB)
Thanks!
@Fabsy: Not if you need steals.
@Fabsy: Agree with Cram
Which mi do you like Ros in obp league?
Albie’s, A Rosario, pirela, Dejong, wong, spangenberg
@Wacha Wacha: DeJong
Hey Grey, drop Miggy for Hokins? H2H playoffs in two weeks, and not sure how much longer I can give Miggy to turn it around? Thanks
@Matty: yes
@Matty: Agree with WR
Odubel Herrera or Brett Garnder?
@Mike: Gardner
Weekly Moron Manager Post:
Mattingly removes Dan Straily after 5 innings at 77 pitches. Straily was not pinch hit for in the bottom of the 5th nor did he start the Top of the 6th and get into trouble. I know he wasn’t dominating but they just took him out at 77 pitches with a 4-3 lead for something named Odrisamer Despaigne.
Of course the Marlin bullpen imploded so no win and no quality start for Straily.
@Michael DePinto: Yeah, saw that too, so goofy
And then less than 24 hours later Mattingly takes Urena out at 90 pitches in the 5th inning with a 5-0.
Haha, just making it up as he goes along
Cruz for Lorenzo Cain and Gio? Fair?
@Ben: Cruz
@Ben: Agree with Fabsy
@Ben: It is fair tho, if you’re dire on SPs
@Grey: thanks guys
No problem
@Grey: how about if it’s Hosmer instead of Cruz? And between Hosmer and Cain who would you rather keep? Thanks again.
Hosmer over Cain
I gotta lose one of these guys:
AJ Ramos, Zieger, or Belisle. Who would you suggest gets the cut? This is a SV league.
@PB&J: Belisle
@PB&J: Agree with Cram
Hey guys, I wanted your opinion on this offense. Lately I’ve been killing it, and, though I’m out of contention, I’m still trying to gain as many points as possible. I was curious about how you thought this offense would rank going into next season:
C – Sanchez ($1), McCann ($1)
1B – Abreu ($25)
2B – Pirela ($1)
3B – Devers ($1)
SS – Rosario ($1)
MI – Bregman ($1)
LF – Mazara ($1)
CF – Benintendi ($1)
RF – Judge ($1)
OF – M. Cabrera ($1), Kepler ($1)
Util – Hoskins ($1)
BN – Hanley ($1), Fisher ($1), Rodgers ($1), McMahon ($1), Acuna ($1)
Polanco ($22) was just dropped today and I will try to pick him up as a FA once he (hopefully) clears waivers for $1.
With a $300 budget, my thoughts were to go all in next draft on Scherzer and Kershaw, who will both be available, and spending as much as possible, even if that means $75 each. Pair them with Kluber, deGrom, (maybe) Manaea and Stroman, and I think I’m gold, but that depends on how good you think my offense is.
11 team roto keeper. All of the above players could be kept.
Hey Grey
Nervous to start Jimmy Nelson vs Pirates tonight… here’s my options….
1) Cut him (and stream)
2) Bench him but hold him
3) Cut Nelson / pick up Carlos Rodon and start him
4) Cut Nelson / pick up Rodon and bench him for Dodgers game but start him ROS
5) Start Nelson and stop overthinking it
Thank you sir
@Murph: 5. He had one terrible start all year. Get past it.
@Cram It: he was off and on terrible early in the year (otherwise i’d own him all over, rather than have just streamed him or owned him for 2-4 starts since early in the year). but yeah, in months probably that one bad one.
@Joey Jo Jo Jr Shabadoo: He had a bad April month, but he’s been an ace the last 3 1/2 months. Point being, you don’t drop the guy because you’re scared off by a disaster outing.
@Cram It: agree with Cram – not really close
@Murph: Agree with Cram
@Grey: Thank you everyone
No problem
Pivetta @ SD ($4.9) or J. Garcia @NYM ($4.0) stream tonight.
@BAC: Neither? Pivetta
Re: Stanton
The short answer is “yes”.
@Wilsonian: Haha, thanks!
Who sits out of Odor, Gyorko, Albies, Alonso, Moncada and Rhys?
@Five-On-One: Sorry – Need to sit two out of Odor, Gyorko, Albies, Alonso, Moncada, Rhys and Arcia. 5×5 roto with weekly lineups, so not just for today.
@Five-On-One: Albies, Alonso
@Five-On-One: Agree with Cram
MY LORD, YOU ARE A MASTERFUL WORDSMITH! ALL HAIL!
@Tehol Beddict the God: HAIL!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@Tehol Beddict the God: Thank you, sire
Hanley, Reynolds, or Hoskins? ROS pts league
@mthom42: Reynolds
@Grey: Thanks!
No problem
Two questions. Tim Anderson or Arcia? And which OF between Dickerson, Grichuk, Broxton, Odubel, Margot.
@Jhohnnhy: Anderson, probably Margot
@Jhohnnhy: Anderson, Margot
“Serious question, in 2018, Gallo if he were guaranteed a .375 BABIP or Judge and a .250 average? Only luck separating them? You said it, not me. (Okay, I said it.)”
Seriously! That and Gallo is 2 years younger. Dont let delusional yankee fans hear you compare the 2.
@TheOne: wow, judge really was in the minors for a long damn time. didn’t know that.
@TheOne: Ha, yup
Gausman, Fulmer, Pomeranz rest of the way?
@Tu-Flock: pomeranz has been consistently awesome for months now. fulmer sure looks still hurt. gausman, well, if you’ve owned him for the over on 2.5 consecutive starts at ANY time this year….
@Tu-Flock: Agree with Harrow
I usually have Rookie Nookie Avoidance Syndrome for late season call ups. But I took the plunge this year and secured Brinson, Williams and Ozzie while missing out on Devers, Ahmed, Moncada and Rhys. All my rooks are back on the wire. Ugh.
1. I picked up Mikie two weeks ago and have been rewarded. But realistically, isn’t he soon to go back on the wire in a 12 teamer once he settles down? Out of this illustrious group, who would you be eyeballing? Gomez, Grandy, Markakis (don’t laugh, lots of walks, average), Taylor, Phillips, Zimmerman, Chisenhall, Dom Smith.
2. Is it crazy to be looking to stream both Lamet and Chacin versus The Nats? Or too clever by half?
3. All commentators had Taillon as a drop after several short outings and then two games where he was destroyed. After a decent last start, is he now seen as more than a streamer? Seems to be ranked in top 35 SP for ROS now while guys like Happ, Cobb, Faria, Chacin, Castillo are ranked much lower??? One game v Padres changes things?
@No Pun Zone:
Zimmer, not Zimmerman. Auto correct hell.
@No Pun Zone: I hear ya…. 1. Smith 2. Chacin’s home ERA is 1.86, no reason to not pitch him 3. Meh, I’d stream at this point with him
14 team h2h with OBP over AVG, total bases added. 12 max starts per week explains the 3 BN bats.
C hedges
1B goldy
2B schoop
3B longo
SS albies
MI pirela (2B/LF)
CI hoskins
LF braun
CF pollock
RF stanton
OF pham (CF/LF)
util fisher (LF)
BN avila (C/1B)/arcia/taylor (CF)
drop arcia for ketel one or do i have too few steals guys for this (could grab maybin for that, but he’s not done that since returning from DL)
@Eli Man Penguin Boy: I’d drop Albies for Ketel.
@Cram It: this is option too grey. so rephrase that to ketel over either of arcia/albies. albies of course has the best speed indicators (and worst performance thus far)
@Eli Man Penguin Boy: You probably won’t be competitive in steals regardless.
@Eli Man Penguin Boy: Agree with Cram
trade my carlos martinez for his ryan zimmerman in our keeper league? does Zimmerman have any hope of a repeat?
thanks
@Josh: He could, but doubtful. I’d hold C-Mart
@Josh: not in a keeper, could do it in a redraft for needs.
@The Harrow:
Thanks both!
@Josh: Agree with others
Damn you murdered that write up G.
@ty: Thanks!
Howie Kendrick or Scooter Gennett in a 6×6 H2H league?
Counts R RBI HR SB AVG OBP
@morningsunshine: Scooter
Hey Grey (in advance, thanks for all your hard work),
H2H 10-team cat. keeper (keep12) balanced stats (R,H,HR,RBI,SB,BB,AVG, OPS,XBH / W,CG,SV,K,GIDP,ERA,WHIP,QS) – 35 moves max a year (no streaming), but we have very deep teams, with 6 bench spots.
Okay so with Chapman hurt, there are some RP’s available (only half the teams have RP’s, the other teams punt saves, but everyone has been stocking up for playoffs): Betances, Robertson, Britton, Ramos, Hand, Brach, Dyson, Rodney
I’d like to rock 4 RP’s as it also helps my Whip and ERA (lower) but to grab the replacement, I’d need to drop someone, who do you recommend out of the RP’s available and who would you drop from my team below
Waiver:
Hit – E. Inciarte (LF.CF), C. Santana (1B,RF), E. Rosario (Lf,CF). K. Wong (2B, CF) J. Harrison (2B,3B,LF), C. Hernandez (2B), D. Pedroia (2B), Y. Alonso (1B), M. Semien (SS), J. Kipnis (2B), T. Anderson (SS), HanRam (1B), M. Margot (CF), E. Gattis (C), B. McCann (c), M Reynolds (1B), N. Castellanos, T. Mancini, M. Franco, Odubel Herrera, R. Martin(c), C. Vazquez (c), M. Weiters (C), M. Zuzino
PIT – M Foltynewicz, C. McHugh, R.A Dickey, T. Bauer, J. Urena, J Zimmerman, A. Cashner, R.A. Dickey
My Team:
C – EMPTY
1B – Paul Goldschmidt
2B – Brian Dozier
3B – Justin Turner
SS – Xander Bogearts
Mi- Tim Beckham
CI – Justin Smoak
LF – Christian Yelich
CF – Charlie Blackmon
RF – Lorenzo Cain
Util- Ryan Braun
BN – Mark Trumbo
BN – Ian Kinsler
BN – Nolan Arenado
DL – Trea Turner
Sp – Alex Wood
SP – T. Bauer
SP – Carlos Carrasco
RP – Aroldis Chapman
Rp – Greg Holland
P- Edwin Diaz
P – Wade Davis
BN- Quintana
BN – Gerrit Cole
BN – Justin Verlander
BN – Jimmy Nelson
DL – Masahiro Tanaka
DL – James Paxton
thanks in advance
@Marv: Trumbo and Kinsler are pointless at this time of the season…. Can lose Trumbo first…. Betances
Starting Lynn tonight @BOS?
Also, are you Starting Bundy vs. LAA tomorrow? Thanks
@Papa Jean Seugra: I am re; Lynn, but wish I weren’t… Yes on Bundy
Yo Grey! Keep up the amazing work…. Another awesome write up as always… Big move possibly on the table … 12 Team forever keep 10 … + 10 Farm….
I’m in a serious battle for top 2-3…. Last place team is offering :
His Abreu or Healy, Taijuan Walker, and Faria or Jordan Montgomery (for my farm)
FOR My Maitan
Not to Be long winded, but my potential keepers going forward are Salvador Perez, Bruce, Nunez, Shaw, Cutch, Cain, Longo, Adam Jones, Souza, Lemahieu, Salazar, Maeda, Andrew Miller .. and lots of guys Ralph has recommended on my farm
Thank you as always !
@Landisimo3: Thanks! Abreu side
Add Villar over Moncada in a redraft league? I need some runs and steals quickly before the 1st place team gets Trea back.
@Alex: or Ketel.
@Alex: Curious that you’re considering this with 10 days before Trea comes back and not 6 weeks ago. He’s in 1st, is a couple of extra steals going to make a difference for you in the standings?
@Cram It: Yeah, I’m only 3 steals behind. I picked up Margot awhile back, but he hasn’t stolen much.
@Alex: Can try Villar
Judging by the comments recently I may be the last man standing w Story starting at SS. I said I would give him through this homestand because Coors, but there’s some decent goodness on the wire. Lose story time for Rosario, K Marte, T Anderson, or Semien? 12T h2h redraft. Thanks Grey, if you have time later today to steal my phone and actually be the one to push the drop button for me it’d be a huge help!
@I only use Grey Poupon because of Razzball: Meh, you held this long, he just homered and he’s in Coors all week…See no point right now to drop him
Thanks for the McCullers update, i wasn’t sure where he stood. He’s my Freddie Prince Jr Summer Catch fling this season and this pains me but is rostering both he and Paxton smart right now? Early Sept and we’re looking at 2-3 more Mcullers starts max? I’m in first place in my 10 team roto thanks to you. Up a ton of runs, rbi’s & hrs but down like 90 pitcher innings and hurting for holds and saves. Should i drop Mcullers for Minaya or a streamer?
Have you listened to Lice 3 or Fashawn?? Both are really good!
Thanks Grey!
@J-Hova: Nah, haven’t listened — McCullers for a streamer is fine, Minaya’s terrible
@Grey:
I know you’re not an Aesop fan so probably won’t like Lice but the Fashawn is really good
Not that I’m not a fan, just don’t know him that well