LOGIN

Framber Valdez is out with a sore elbow. Feel a bit like I’m living in a Twilight Zone, where I say in the preseason, “Don’t draft (pitcher’s name) because they were injured last year or just so awful last year they must’ve been injured,” then everyone ignores that and pretends that a player’s injury is completely out of nowhere. I could go back and pull quotes from my preseason rankings, and, what the heck! Here’s what I said, “Maybe because I rostered him last year, but I see Framber going in the top 15 starters and I can’t help remember how badly I wanted to drop him in the 2nd half. When he was clearly hiding an injury of some sort, Framber had a 4.66 ERA in the 2nd half; his Ks went into the compost heap; his walks were egregious, and I don’t bring out the Johnnie Cochran “egregious” often. His homers went up, up and away; his sinker went from a pitch he threw 51.6% of the time in April at 95.2 MPH to 38.2% of the time in September at 94.7 MPH, and he was equally atrocious in the postseason. Want a guy who looks like he’s not making it out of Spring Training with a mysterious arm injury? Look no further!” And that’s me quoting me! Seriously, be honest: Do you ignore me or just think you know better? Is there a difference? Anyway, here’s what else I saw yesterday in fantasy baseball:

Yordan Alvarez – 3-for-5, 3 runs, 3 RBIs and his 4th homer, 2nd homer in as many games. Captain Woo Cubano needs 46 more!

Andrew Heaney – 3 2/3 IP, 6 ER, ERA at 7.56. Feel like we’re friends in a parasocial type way, so I’m gonna be honest, it is so nice to not roster Heaney on any teams this year.

Wenceel Perez – 0-for-2, as he was called up by the Tigers. Senor Wenceel is not a face drawn on a sock worn by A.J. Hinch. He’s a middle infield prospect, who was playing some outfield in the minors to get him into the lineup. Prolly better than Javier Baez, but that contract is worse than former Padres’ prospect, Al B. Tross, who got $50 mil and never saw any ABs. I don’t know if Wenceel actually plays, but if he does, here’s what Itch said previously, “Perez posted a 124 wRC+ in 35 Triple-A games by slashing .264/.394/.493 with three home runs and six home runs with a 16.9-to-18.1 walk-to-strikeout rate. That line is a good reproduction of general outcomes throughout this minor league climb. The upside might not be monstrous here, but he’s a capable up-the-middle defender with great plate skills and a solid hit tool. It’s easy to envision Perez sneaking into a lineup spot and holding it for several years, like I’ve dreamt of sneaking into Grey’s bedroom and curb-stomping him.” What the heck?

Reese Olson – 4 1/3 IP, 6 ER, ERA at 5.40. [picks up phone] Hello, operator, my ratios are cooked.

Mitch Keller – 6 IP, 2 ER, 8 baserunners, 9 Ks, ERA at 5.29. Wish I could say how good he looked with a bounce back start, but he looked pretty mediocre, not quite awful. This wasn’t hell and Keller, nor am I being blind to his flaws.

Bryan Reynolds – 2-for-5 and his 2nd homer. You ever accidentally draft someone and you want them to turn out bad to prove yourself right, even though it would be counterproductive for your fantasy team, then they turn out good and it makes you feel stupid? That’s Bryan Reynolds for me. We should have a glossary term for that. Please suggest in the comments.

Jose Miranda – 0-for-2 as he was called up by the Twins to seemingly sit on the bench for two to three weeks then be sent down again.

Bailey Ober – 5 IP, 1 ER, 5 baserunners, 7 Ks, ERA at 12.79. Sonavabench! Getting borked vs. the Royals and dominating the Dodgers? Oh, I see! You’re passive aggressive! Very cute!

Shohei Ohtani – 3-for-5, 2 runs and his 3rd homer. Someone hammered the over.

James Outman – 1-for-4 and his 1st homer. Damn, and you dropped him already after a full week and half of games! Bummer.

James Paxton – 6 IP, 2 ER, 4 baserunners, 4 Ks, ERA at 1.64. Watch him be the best Dodgers starter. Kidding. He’s pretty mediocre.

Jesus Luzardo – 4 2/3 IP, 7 ER, ERA at 7.20. Welp, I wanted to bench him, but sucked in by the two-start week. More like a two-star move (out of hundred stars) by me.

Juan Soto – 2-for-3, 3 RBIs and his 2nd homer. Sexy Dr. Pepper with the pop!

Anthony Volpe – 1-for-3, 3 RBIs and his 2nd homer. One of the hottest early bats, and that he’s not hitting leadoff for the Yanks gives you an idea how incredibly slow-to-react MLB managers are.

Nestor Cortes – 8 IP, 0 ER, 2 hits, zero walks, 6 Ks, ERA at 3.50. Think we’re at Streamonator level for Nestor still since this was vs. Marlins, but it likes his next start too.

Will Benson – 2-for-3, 2 runs, 2 RBIs and a slam (2) and legs (2) Can Benson keep playing every day? Who cares! I care about Will Benson!

Elly De La Cruz – 3-for-4, 4 runs, and a double slam (1, 2) and legs (6). His 2nd homer was an inside-the-parker, and I could’ve sworn I counted only six steps from home back to home. The “Elly is overrated narrative” I’ve been pushing took a big hit, but there’s still roughly 95% of the season left, which is close to his K%, so we’ll see.

Graham Ashcraft – 5 2/3 IP, 5 ER, ERA at 5.40. Streamed Ashcraft in a bunch of leagues (while benching Luzardo, but not benching Luzardo everywhere really is still killing my vibe as I continue to write these blurbs. Jesus! Literally!), and it only turned out a bit better because Dumb Bell took forever to pull him.

Aaron Ashby – 3 2/3 IP, 4 ER, ERA at 9.82. In most leagues, he’s likely a streamer, but if you’re in deeper leagues, and Ashby is out there, I could see grabbing him. He’s always been parts better than sum (10.6 K/9, 3.29 xFIP last year), but parts better than sum turns into a little sum-ting sum-ting at sum point sum times.

Brice Turang – 2-for-4, 2 runs, 4 RBIs and his 1st homer. If he ends up with 45+ steals (easily within range of his talents), it’s gonna be hard for him not to be valuable.

Christian Yelich – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 4th homer. My Yelich MVP ticket is burning a hole in my pocket! Let’s go!

Ivan Herrera – 1-for-3, 2 runs and his 2nd homer. Know what’s not great if you’re the Cards? It feels like they need to trade away a guy for him to get playing time and break out.

Spencer Turnbull – 6 IP, 0 ER, 3 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 0.00. Time to look at him! [opens his player page] Nice…very nice…very, very nice! So, 10.6 K/9, 0.8 BB/9, but way too soon to say anything definitive. His velocity is at its lowest, but he might’ve found a better pitch mix for himself. Willing to pick him up to see if it’s real, but I’m not convinced yet Spencer won’t turn to bullshizz.

Jeff Hoffman – 1 IP, 2 ER, ERA at 3.38. Grabbed him to vulture saves, because I had a feeling and Hoffman came in the 9th for the save and, oh boy, check out my premonition, baby! Then he blew his 2nd save.

Brandon Marsh – 2-for-4, 2 runs and his 3rd homer. Bra-Ma is hot, oh God, why did I have to nickname him that?!

Marcell Ozuna – 2-for-5, 2 RBIs and his 5th homer. We talk about Ozuna on this week’s podcast. He was basically free in drafts, and it’s not exactly clear why.

Julio Teheran – 2 2/3 IP, 4 ER in his 1st start with the Mets. He’s gonna fit in perfectly!

Brandon Nimmo – 4-for-4, 5 RBIs and his 1st and 2nd homer. Nimmo found two!

Tyler Anderson – 7 IP, 0 ER, 5 baserunners, 3 Ks, ERA at 0.0000000000000000. Tyler Anderson, 2024 AL Cy Young.

Mike Trout – 3-for-5, 2 runs, 2 RBIs and his 5th homer, and 2nd homer in as many games. Sell! Seriously, if you have him, and expect more than 100 games, you’re a sweet, naive baby. I want to wrap you in a blanket, put you in a basket and float you down a river.

Zach Eflin – 5 IP, 5 ER, ERA at 6.35. Effin’ Eflin.

Jake Bird – 1/3 IP, 0 ER and his 1st save. Rockies have kept it close to their vest who their closer would be. Or, they simply haven’t won many games or any close ones.

Blake Snell – 3 IP, 3 ER. Bit of a rocky final rehab start. When does he return to the majors? Oh.

Lane Thomas – 3-for-5, 3 RBIs and his 1st homer. Too bad! Already dropped him for Random Schmohawk #3!

Yu Darvish – 3 IP, 4 ER, ERA at 3.86. Not being spiteful, but, after what he did to me last year, I love Yu on your teams, and not mine.

Jake Cronenworth – 1-for-2, 2 RBIs and his 1st homer, as he hits third. He also has a 40+% line drive rate, which is shrieking in a high-pitched voice, “It’s still really early!”

Fernando Tatis Jr. – 1-for-4, 2 runs, 2 RBIs and his 4th homer. Fun the Jewels fast!

Xander Bogaerts – 1-for-5, 2 RBIs and his 1st homer. For a guy who only hits two months a year, and one of them is April, it’s about time he did something.

Adbert Alzolay – 2/3 IP, 1 ER, ERA at 3.86, and the blown save. All closers are brutal to roster in April except Evan Phillips.

Jose Ramirez – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 2nd homer. He’s so fun. Have nothing else to say. He’s just super fun to watch. We love JoJoRam.

Triston McKenzie – 5 /3 IP, 0 ER, 7 baserunners (4 BBs), 2 Ks, ERA at 4.00. He looked bad. Like, malnourished. Oh, his pitching? Not great either. If this wasn’t vs. the White Sox, he would’ve been rocked.

John Brebbia – Hit the IL with a calf strain. Can’t spell Brebbia without BRB, but for now the Bullpen Chart is updated.

Luis Robert – Will miss two months. Mentioned this on the podcast a few weeks ago, but I know some of y’all don’t listen. I heard recently about how poker was the perfect balance of luck (cards have a certain randomness) and skill (not totally random if you know what you’re doing). I was thinking fantasy baseball is like this, just a perfect mix of luck and skill. Is it luck if you had Luis Robert last year and avoided him this year? Yes, I would say so, but also skill. Was it skill or luck me telling you to avoid him last year and draft him this year? Both. If the draft price is good, then it’s worth the risk. Was the risk always there whether it was last year or this year? Yes.

Jose Berrios – 6 2/3 IP, 0 ER, 5 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 1.45. Thank you, War Room!

Luis Castillo – 5 IP, 4 ER, 10 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 6.89. Please don’t let him be hurt. Purdy purdy please.

Cal Raleigh – 1-for-4 and his 1st homer. When he went to the plate, people in the front row cheered, screaming for joy, seeing the 2nd moon eclipse of the day.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

314 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
John Feehan
John Feehan
20 days ago

Reynold’s Rap!

Lucky Dog
20 days ago

Civale deserves better defense behind him.

Lucky Dog
20 days ago

Stop me if you’ve heard this one before – Moncada is hurt.

Man, what could have been with that dude if he weren’t Mr Glass.

Lucky Dog
20 days ago

Ask me how much I love Steer hitting 7th & Gorman hitting 5th, go ahead ask me I HATE IT!

managers are so dumb.

rhodyballer
rhodyballer
20 days ago

Is Bednar cooked?

Dude
Dude
20 days ago

Great stuff as always!!!
Who is the drop?
Thairo Estrada
Brandon Marsh
David Hamilton
Jose Siri
Nelson Valazquez

Lets play two
Lets play two
20 days ago

Kirby looks fantastic again! Pffft.

Crazy J
Crazy J
20 days ago

I was gonna talk crap about Bichette too, a little negative reinforcement!

Gotime
Gotime
20 days ago

12tm pts redraft and J Walker my spare OF / bench – Braxton enough to drop Walker for?

toolshed
20 days ago

Fantasy MLB today pod. Listening to it now. Good stuff. Thanks

Shitwolf
Shitwolf
20 days ago

feels like Zap Brannigan is piloting the ship at MLB HQ right now. DID YOU GUYS SEE HOW I MADE MLB BETTER. I SIMULTANIOUSLY SPED THE GAME UP BY FORCING PITCHER TO THROW FASTER AND REDUCING THE GRIP OF THE BALL AT THE SAME TIME! Excellent Work commisioner Brannigan, but how did you account for all the injuries that started happening because of this? Simple I just sent wave after wave of my own pitchers until the 162 game season was complete! Best Season Ever!

TJ81
TJ81
20 days ago

Framber hittin IL. Already have Steele and Bueler. Do I drop Framber for Turnbull, Whitlock, Blackburn, or Cortes?
Or hold and ride The pain?

lets play 2
lets play 2
20 days ago

Someone dropped Jordan Walker already. Pick him up over Michael Busch or Gorman?

lets play 2
lets play 2
Reply to  Grey
20 days ago

Thanks!

Randy
Randy
20 days ago

svhd minter, ian hamilton, d hudson, or mcarthur? thanks grey

Bad Mother Tucker
Bad Mother Tucker
20 days ago

12 team, 5×5 roto. 1250 Max IP. 1168 Remaining (+0.2)

Would you stream:

(1) Logan Allen v. CHW with 10-15mph wind blowing out? ($17.9)

Dancin Homer
20 days ago

Afternoon & Happy Jumbo Day!

And speaking of the elephant in the room…. Bednar (Some jerk in my league drafted Aroldis too)

with his impending mystery IL stint to get right, I’ll need to proactively fill my Closer-gap.

Any of the below worth adding & if so, who (if anyone) you cutting from my below roster?

Available RP’s:

  • Chad Green – Looks like the closer in TOR now…?
  • Alex Lange – got a save recently, but who is the closer in DET??
  • Justin Lawrence – will COL get more than like 5 save chances?
  • Any other possible “closer in waiting” you can think of…

12-team, 6×6 (OPS/QS), H2H, Redraft league
 
C: Keibert
1B: Vladdy
2B: Mookie
3B: Chapman
SS: Gunnar
IF: Torkelson
OF: Teoscar, J. Duran, Langford
UTL: Westburg
BN: W. Benson
 
SP: Webb, Peralta, Bassitt, Pepiot, Keller, Hicks, Kikuchi, Dunning,
RP: Bednar, Uribe, Alvarado, G. Jax
 
IL (3 slots): Romano, Lodolo, Garrett, G. Cole, D. Williams
 
NA (minor league stash spot): E. Ruiz

Thanks in advance!!

Dancin Homer
Reply to  Grey
20 days ago

Had a feeling that was gonna be the case. Guess I’ll need to dip my toe into the trading pool…. I hate the trade pool

Will (the other one)
Will (the other one)
Reply to  Grey
20 days ago

Lange pitched the 7th inning today whereas Foley got the 9th and the save. Looks like a committee in Detroit.

The Stait Man
The Stait Man
20 days ago

McArthur or Uribe?

Remain patient with Torkelson and McCormick in a 12 team?

Thank you.

RicoSuave
RicoSuave
20 days ago

excellent work Grey.

Glossary term… Fear boner

16 team points league…

how would you rank them? Frelick, Kirilloff, Outman, Yoshida, Jordan Walker

Thanks

RicoSuave
RicoSuave
Reply to  Grey
20 days ago

thanks.

Outman seems to be sitting against LHP… does that affect your ranking?

RicoSuave
RicoSuave
Reply to  Grey
20 days ago

yeah, it is a weekly league… :(

The talented Mr dope man
The talented Mr dope man
20 days ago

AL only

Soriano (LAA) or Cole Irvin?

Cohen
Cohen
20 days ago

Drop Jordan Walker for Dunn,Baty,Olivares or Taveras or hold?

Daze
Daze
20 days ago

Grey
In anticipation of Bednar going on IL
1) Would you drop Robertson for Chapman
(I picked up Robertson thinking LeClerc was losing his grip on closer role)
or
2) Would you drop Robertson for McArthur

Will (the other one)
Will (the other one)
20 days ago

T Antone out with elbow surgery. Josiah Gray to the IL with a flexor strain. The starting pitcher injury apocalypse continues…

Joey Jo Jo Jr Shabadoo
Joey Jo Jo Jr Shabadoo
Reply to  Will (the other one)
20 days ago

antone’s been injured for like 2 str years, not a recent thing there.

Will (the other one)
Will (the other one)
Reply to  Joey Jo Jo Jr Shabadoo
20 days ago

This will be his 3rd elbow surgery

Jim
Jim
20 days ago

Grey
You mentioned benching Luzardo. He was best pitcher available in all my draftwhen I picked one. Should I bench for next start? are you worried about him in the long run?

John
John
20 days ago

SVHDs minter, Daniel hudson or Ian Hamilton?

birrrdy
birrrdy
20 days ago

Glossary suggestions:

  • Curseadoodle Doo
  • Grace of Mistaken Identity
Raindoggg
Raindoggg
20 days ago

in need of a couple pick ups…

obp league….Benson, nate lowe (can move bellinger to OF) or n Velazquez

ip instead of k’s league…Elder, Bradish, or T Anderson

offered musgrove for snell also…yay or nay

Lucky Dog
Reply to  Grey
20 days ago

No call-up for Elder yet. The fantasy gods don’t want me to look smart.

Ben
Ben
20 days ago

Hi Grey,

1) Guy in my league is asking about O’Neil. Would you send him for any of Jared Jones, Houck, Freddy Peralta, Kirby? If so, which ones?

2) Would you send Castellanos, Siri, or Santander for any of the pitchers above? I have an extra OF and need some pitching help.

3) Any major concerns about Castellanos, or just a rough start? He’s been brutal.

Thanks!

Ben
Ben
Reply to  Ben
20 days ago

That is, O’Neill with two l’s, not one l. Thank you.

Ben
Ben
Reply to  Grey
20 days ago

Buck O’Neil? (Okay, I just wrote that follow up without looking)

Will (the other one)
Will (the other one)
Reply to  Grey
20 days ago

Oneil Cruz would like a word

Ben
Ben
Reply to  Grey
20 days ago

Thanks, Freddy first?

And would you send Castellanos or Santander for just Freddy or Kirby from the list of pitchers in my initial message too?

Thank you.

Ben
Ben
Reply to  Grey
20 days ago

Thanks!

toolshed
20 days ago

Shelby Miller notched his 3rd win of the year after pitching a grand total of 7 innings. Wins are such a bull$hit stat. I loathe them.

Dave D
Dave D
20 days ago

Good takes, once again!

Well, Although my Reese Olson shares were hurting me yesterday at least I leveraged it in a few leagues with Keller and T. Anderson. Dare I say spring training carried over into season? Maybe its just that T. A. is one of those even year types.

Dave D
Dave D
Reply to  Grey
20 days ago

In a DC when you have Braxton, Means, Taijuan, E.Cabrera on the IL he is much better than taking zeroes! Desperate times call for desperate meausures…

John
John
20 days ago

SVHDs Daniel Hudson, Minter or Ian Hamilton?

los locos
los locos
20 days ago

Grey, I think you were off one year with sleepers last season.
ONeil, Ward and Singer.

They been fire since season started.

Ward and Singer are both on waivers.

Drop Flaherty for Singer?

Starters
Logan O’Hoppe C | LAA
Freddie Freeman 1B | LAD
Spencer Steer 1B,2B,3B,OF | CIN 
Gunnar Henderson 3B,SS | BAL
Oneil Cruz SS | PIT 
Corbin Carroll OF | ARI 
Michael Conforto OF | SF 
Tyler O’Neill OF | BOS
Anthony Volpe SS | NYY 
 
Bench
Junior Caminero 3B | TB 
Nick Castellanos OF | PHI
Jordan Walker OF | STL
IL
Matt McLain 2B,SS | CIN 
Starters
MacKenzie Gore SP | WAS
Kyle Harrison SP | SF
George Kirby SP | SEA
Jesus Luzardo SP | MIA 
Joe Ryan SP | MIN
Edwin Diaz RP | NYM
Andres Munoz RP | SEA
Bench
Hunter Brown SP | HOU
Kutter Crawford SP | BOS
Reid Detmers SP | LAA
Jack Flaherty SP | DET
Nick Lodolo SP | CIN 
Max Meyer SP | MIA
IL
Eury Perez

Dave D
Dave D
Reply to  los locos
20 days ago

That is one challenge we all face: being too early on a breakout or resurgence then being “out” the next year when they are “on”.

TJ81
TJ81
20 days ago

Have Bednar. Drop Mountcastle, my worst batter for Finnegan, or straight drop Bednar for Finnegan? Hold?
HALP!!!

boggy
boggy
20 days ago

Could you rank Lugo, Whitlock, Blackburn ROS?

toolshed
20 days ago

Tyler O’Neill 6 HR’s. All solo shots. Is it too much to ask for somebody to be on base when he hits?

1000007558
Got the runs
Got the runs
20 days ago

Hi Grey. Pitchers this year, what a crapshoot! I have Luzardo, Berrios, Kelley, Keller, Bibee, Maneae, and Allen (maybe just for today). Still on the wire: Lugo, Kremer, Suarez,and Kikuchi (and Stroman, but…). What changes would you make, if any? Thank you for your help.

patdaddy1985
patdaddy1985
20 days ago

Good lord what is up with Bednar? Is he a hold?

toolshed
20 days ago

Bednar didn’t seem to be ready after that lat injury. Those seem to take a long time. He looks like he should have gone on a rehab assignment to start the year.

moses mashers
moses mashers
Reply to  Grey
20 days ago

He looks cooked because he is having command issues? Haha

WhiteRabbit
WhiteRabbit
20 days ago

The Reynolds Trap

Cohen
Cohen
20 days ago

Who would be the first drop from this staff?
Keller
Jones
Gausman
Ober
Peralta
Hicks

Dan
Dan
21 days ago

Hi Grey. So….in a trade discussion i’m giving Gleybor for Altuve.he wants a throw in added. Who if any of these : Dunn,caballero,casas,jeimer,Rodon,Kremer,Hunter Brown,kikuchi,Reynaldo Lopez,nootbar ,Houck,ward,jd mart ? Thanks

Dan
Dan
Reply to  Grey
20 days ago

He mentioned brown but had offered silseth and wanted gausman included if that tells you how he thinks. I offered nootbar or matz and he rejected

Pops
Pops
21 days ago

Against my better judgment, I’m schmotatoing with Conforto. Between Parker Meadows Can Lose and Suwinski And A Miss, who’s the drop?

I got Ozuna in the 15th round of a 10-teamer. I was looking around the draft room waiting for someone to tell me I missed an injury report.

Pops
Pops
Reply to  Grey
21 days ago

Thanks, Grey!

Gotime
Gotime
21 days ago

12tm pts redraft how much FAAB you bidding on Braxton out of 100?

combo722
combo722
21 days ago

Drop Mitch Keller for MacKenzie Gore?

Will (the other one)
Will (the other one)
21 days ago

Trevor Story season ending surgery, out for the year. Brutal.

Cora said Rafaela might get some time at 2b and SS now. Does that make Ceddane worth adding now? Thanks.

Will (the other one)
Will (the other one)
Reply to  Grey
21 days ago

So CR sticks in center then, got it. Thanks. Now just tell me CR is the second coming of Ozzie Albies and I’ll go pick him up, lol.

Dingo37
Dingo37
Reply to  Will (the other one)
21 days ago

Grissom factor in somewhere?

Will (the other one)
Will (the other one)
Reply to  Dingo37
21 days ago

Cora mentioned him as possibly playing some SS when he’s back

The Stait Man
The Stait Man
Reply to  Grey
20 days ago

He was terrible last year at SS.

go dubs
go dubs
21 days ago

Stephenson or Herrera? Thanks!

aintlifegrand
aintlifegrand
21 days ago

Grey,

I know you had them ranked Braxton, Lugo, Lodolo in the top starters rankings preseason even accounting for their injuries. You still have it that way? QS league 10 team redraft.

Thanks!

Joe Shlabotnik
Joe Shlabotnik
21 days ago

Yo BRHA (Bob Ross Happy Accident)
I Stepped In It
Look What You Made Me Do

Joe Shlabotnik
Joe Shlabotnik
21 days ago

hey grey- I have N. Velazquez as a bench bat. Is it worth swapping him to stash B.Garrett? (I guess it depends who we think will have a more impactful season, nelson or braxton?)
thank u kindly

I Am Not A Smart Man
21 days ago

Unbelievable… just lost Pivetta to… can you guess?

AN ELBOW INJURY!

I have more injuries on my roster than healthy pitchers. Changing my team name to General Hospital.

-IANASM

Lucky Dog
Reply to  I Am Not A Smart Man
21 days ago

Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!

/vader

The FBB gods have finally smited me. Smote? Whatever. That sucks.

I Am Not A Smart Man
Reply to  Lucky Dog
21 days ago

We both done got smoted.

I have Pivetta, Valdez, and Steele

Lucky Dog
Reply to  Grey
21 days ago

Is it though? He’s 31. Getting old sucks.

Lucky Dog
Reply to  Grey
21 days ago

I got out of my delivery van and heard a groaning noise – looked around and realized it was me. Sigh.

martinrostoker
martinrostoker
21 days ago

Hi Grey,

I could use a legitimate 3B. I have Ryan McMahon and Nolan Gorman. I read that Nola’s velocity is down. What would you think of trading him now for a 3B. If yes, who would you go after?

Another option is to pursue a SS. My current SS is Jackson Merrill. If yes, who would you try and get in a trade?

of course, i could wait for now.

thanks!!!!

your answers are always appreciated

FMFU
FMFU
Reply to  martinrostoker
21 days ago

I think you’ve reached your Razzball question quota for the day Martin

For another 10 questions, please Cash App $10 to @Grey

Fungazi 2.0
Fungazi 2.0
Reply to  FMFU
21 days ago

I don’t know how this guy even ties his shoes without asking Grey directions.

Philip
Philip
21 days ago

Good stuff, Grey! How would you rank these infielders in a dynasty: Maikel Garcia, Colt Keith, Brett Baty, Luis Rengifo, Jordan Westburg? Thanks!

Philip
Philip
Reply to  Grey
21 days ago

Thanks!

Trishul Jotangia
Trishul Jotangia
21 days ago

Hey Grey! Excellent Write up!

I’m struggling with what to do with Mullens. I only drafted him cause he fell a lot in the draft but i don’t have any faith in him. Is it worth sending him to the WW and using the roster spot to steam hitters or should i hold.

thanks,

Trishul Jotangia
Trishul Jotangia
Reply to  Grey
21 days ago

That’s what I thought, thanks!

Mrs. Roger. Dorn.
Mrs. Roger. Dorn.
21 days ago

Who do you like for my last UTIL spot? 10-team re-draft roto..

Jordan Walker
Victor Scott
Tovar

Jason Murray
Jason Murray
21 days ago

Assad or Boyle for the end of my rotation in a 12-team H2H? Thanks!

StonePony
StonePony
21 days ago

I have a black hole at 1B on an otherwise strong team. 12-team, standard league. Drop Pasquantino for any of Kirilloff, Mountcastle or Bell?

anothersoldbyjavid
anothersoldbyjavid
21 days ago

I have Carroll, Adolis, Bellinger, Langford, Chourio and Tyler O’Neill. 6 good players for 5 spots. Makes it tough to decide who to bench ….. I’ll keep using the streamer tool for hitters

Steve Tim
Steve Tim
21 days ago

I’m just about ready to give up on Andrew Vaughn. With Jung going down I could use a second 3rd baseman for days when Westburg isn’t playing. Are any of these guys worth taking a flier on to see what they can do or should I sit on Vaughn for a bit longer and see if he can develop?

Brett Baty, Candelario, Moncada, Curtis Mead, Flores, Michael Busch, Josh Smith

Razz Stache
Razz Stache
21 days ago

Hey Grey, 12 man 5×5 redraft, drafted Neto for my MI, love the guy but see Oliver Dunn and Orlando Arcia on waivers, thoughts?

Drop Neto for one, or just drop Kirolloff for one and hold Neto? Kirilloff just holding for U, have haniger there now……

martinrostoker
martinrostoker
21 days ago

Hi Grey,

Last question on Tyler Anderson – I promise- who would you prefer Anderson or Cristopher Sanchez or hold?

thanks

martinrostoker
martinrostoker
Reply to  Grey
21 days ago

thanks

Nightpandas
Nightpandas
21 days ago

I like Reynolds Wrap as mentioned….or the Bartolo pick

Steer for real ? Got offered Arenado and K Jansen for him in a partial keeper

Thanks boss

William Hung
21 days ago

Rodon is the top rated pitcher today on SON – only the marlins can make him potentially look good

Fastball Freddy
Fastball Freddy
21 days ago

Gunnar/Santander or Swanson/TON ?

chuckdaman
chuckdaman
21 days ago

You just performed a FFU (Fat Finger Upgrade) when you accidentally drafted
Bryan Reynolds…I do them all the time

Chuckdaman

Fogimon
Fogimon
21 days ago

Someone mentioned ‘there are no mistakes only happy accidents’, which reminded me of that teenie bopper song ‘oops I did it again’, which makes me think Britney Spears for your glossary term but takes a bit of puzzle pieces to get there.

lastplace
lastplace
21 days ago

AL Only in TX: Smith or Foscue?

lastplace
lastplace
Reply to  Grey
21 days ago

gracias!

OaktownSteve
OaktownSteve
Reply to  lastplace
21 days ago

Don’t know if you saw Fosue hit the IL

Nordberg
Nordberg
Reply to  Grey
21 days ago

I think he pulled a muscle. He must have jumped up at an exciting moment HAHA

Likely Double Post
Likely Double Post
21 days ago

Great write up, great advice which earns you a dumb question…who would you keep out of Baty, Dunn, or Donovan (tie-breaker goes to 3B eligibility – probably won’t be a keeper unless top 50)?

Five-on-One
Five-on-One
21 days ago

1. Jax (7 games) or Finnegan (6 games) for this week?

2. Please rank these SPs for this week:
2-start Bradford (vOAK and @DET)
Keller (@PHI)
Luzardo (vATL)

3. 11-team 5×5 league. Trying to be patient with Bichette and Nolan Jones. Harder with Stott and Candelario. Keep the faith or start looking for replacements?

Five-on-One
Five-on-One
Reply to  Five-on-One
21 days ago

Did you skip this one on purpose?

Umpy70
Umpy70
Reply to  Five-on-One
21 days ago

he gets 300 + comments a day. If he misses yours, hes still at 99.6% response rate. Relax. Even ELDC cant even K at that rate.

Dave Funnell
Dave Funnell
21 days ago

Are you worried about Goldschmidt? Would you try to sell high? I say high because the season is so young.

Would you buy low on Vinnie? I think his shoulder needs some working in. And the weather is still cool. I anticipated a slow start.

The sportsguy
The sportsguy
21 days ago

10 Team AL 5×5…very worried about Jose Abreu….any chance he loses his starting gig? Seems unlikely but he looks lost out there

jimmy
jimmy
21 days ago

great write up! CES is struggling, being patient…read somewhere he might get sent down

Cable
Cable
21 days ago

h/h points ..12 team …. Am I suppose to drop Stott and pickup Cronenworth ?

yankee candle factory worker
yankee candle factory worker
21 days ago

Thanks!

martinrostoker
martinrostoker
21 days ago

Hi Grey,
Would you grab Tyler Anderson and drop Mize or even a hitter?

thanks so much!!

martinrostoker
martinrostoker
Reply to  martinrostoker
21 days ago

Would you grab Tyler Anderson and drop Mize or even a hitter?

thanks so much!!

martinrostoker
martinrostoker
Reply to  martinrostoker
21 days ago

sorry or Sean Manaea?

thanks

martinrostoker
martinrostoker
Reply to  Grey
21 days ago

I am sorry to ask for clarification- the answer below seems to keep Manaea?

thanks for your patience!

martinrostoker
martinrostoker
Reply to  Grey
21 days ago

Thank you- appreciate your patience!

Cocowillie
Cocowillie
21 days ago

Good day

Should I grab TAnderson for any of these

Menaea
Littel
Detmers
Lugo
Lodolo

Much appreciated

Cable
Cable
21 days ago

12 team h/h …. Have Judge,
Ju Rod,Casas,Stott,Castellanos, Moreno… ask me how I’m doing ?

I Am Not A Smart Man
21 days ago

G-money!

Pretend this isn’t a catcher question… Drop Garver for Moreno or Reese McGuire? Reese is looking a little sexy, but maybe I am just having buyer’s remorse due to the cold start from Garver.

Thanks again!
-IANASM

Cable
Cable
21 days ago

h/h points league 12 team … has anyone seen Ju Rodriquez or A Judge ?

Snacks
Snacks
Reply to  Cable
21 days ago

JuRod was a slow start last year also. Hoping he wakes up.

Lucky Dog
Reply to  Snacks
21 days ago

I’ve always felt like April is more for pitching and then when it warms up the bats start to come alive. Patience is everything.

Todd Time
Todd Time
21 days ago

Need to drop one- Lars Nootbaar or Bryon Buxton? Also, who should I pick up- PeePee PooPoo or PooPoo PeePee?

lindorphins
21 days ago

Blessing in These Guys for the Reynolds glossary term.

What are your levels of confidence in Volpe, Jarren Duran and Tyler O’Neill keeping up their hot starts? I’m getting the itch to sell them high, but don’t want to miss out on a full breakout season.

Also, now that Strider (kept, didn’t draft) is done for, my pitchers are Luzardo, Imanaga, Darvish, Morton, Pivetta and Wacha. Who would be your first drop if you needed a bat? It’s a K/9 league if that makes a difference.

Lastly, stop hating on Elly! I have a left infield of him and Oneil. I’m probably cruzing for a bruising with the K rates but I want to believe.

Thanks as always for the thoughtful writeups!

call me el jefe
call me el jefe
21 days ago

Please no on the JoJoRam lol

pugs slugs
pugs slugs
21 days ago

Slow start for Acuña, Carroll, and CES is making it really difficult to wait for E. Montero to start hitting. You okay with dropping him this early for a hot schmotato in a 10 Tm NL-Only H2H?

Last edited 21 days ago by pugs slugs
Turd Ferguson
Turd Ferguson
21 days ago

Do you think @thepainguy on twitter is full of shit or does he have some valid points re: pitching mechanics and TJ

Lucky Dog
Reply to  Turd Ferguson
21 days ago

Pitchers do something totally unnatural, and start doing it earlier and earlier. They’re throwing breaking pitches from like 8 years old & spend 10-15 years torquing their elbows *before* they hit the show.

Eventually the tendon is going to snap. It’s inevitable.

Turd Ferguson
Turd Ferguson
Reply to  Lucky Dog
21 days ago

true but it does seem certain guys in recent era have had a knack for staying healthy. JV, scherzer, CC, Cole until this year

Lucky Dog
Reply to  Turd Ferguson
21 days ago

And back in the day, guys threw both games of a double header multiple times a year.

Some pitchers go their entire career throwing breaking balls and never have a problem.

Some pitchers tear their UCL in jr high and we never even know their names.

Luck of the draw IMO.

I will say that recent emphasis on spin rate probably isn’t helpful towards the goal of not snapping a UCL like a rubber band that’s been stretched 100 times too many, but who can know for sure.

The good news is that other than the devastating blow to FBB managers like us, to a pro athlete TJ is no longer career ending – usually.

Lucky Dog
Reply to  Grey
21 days ago

Oh shiz, it’s that d-bag? Yeah, class act.

Dan
Dan
21 days ago

Any word if Bradford stays in the rotation after his next start with Lorenz coming back ? Or scrap both and grab Soriano from halos ? Thanks for your advise

Freedminds
Freedminds
21 days ago

Saw that EDLC is batting .297, but has nearly a 42% K rate l m a o

His BABIP must be insanely high how does he keep doing it

Bradley Kukenberger
Bradley Kukenberger
21 days ago

Here’s “Love Poem” by Richard Brautigan to help you enjoy not rostering Heaney this year:

It’s so nice
to wake up in the morning
all alone
and not have to tell somebody
you love them
when you don’t love them
any more.

OaktownSteve
OaktownSteve
Reply to  Bradley Kukenberger
21 days ago

that’s good commenting

Brandon
Brandon
21 days ago

Riley Greene v. Taylor Ward ROS?

FMFU
FMFU
21 days ago

Cortes just a Streamonator call in 12 teamers ?

His velocity was still down a bit last night

Keeks
Keeks
21 days ago

Glad JoRam went JoBam but we need more JoRan

Keeks
Keeks
Reply to  Keeks
21 days ago

Also, idea for glossary term: Strong Swimmer. You didnt want to have them on your team but they made it there anyways somehow..

Kas
Kas
21 days ago

Good Morning Grey,

If you had to go with either Riley Greene or Jorge Soler ROS, who would it be? I appreciate your help man.

Justin Ralph
Justin Ralph
21 days ago

I’ve been trying to sell Charlie Morton since his first start with no luck. Would you drop him for Singer, Turnbull, Tyler Anderson or Lugo?

Slumping1Bs
Slumping1Bs
21 days ago

Which of these slumping 1Bs is a better bet for RoS — CES or VinnieP?

Earl
Earl
Reply to  Slumping1Bs
21 days ago

I really hope it is CES as I got him on several teams!!

Justin Ralph
Justin Ralph
21 days ago

Drop O’Hoppe for MJ Melendez? Yes I know MJ has done his damage against the CWS but thought I would ask.

Chris
Chris
21 days ago

10 team H2H points league

Which SP to keep for now:

Stone or Lugo?

Gary C
21 days ago

ESPN Points, Potential trade
Bibee vs Eflin

Which side is better?
Thanks!

David
David
21 days ago

Nominating your do not draft list for others to draft has worked out well so far. I wasn’t sure Yamamoto/Berrios/Grayson would anchor a staff. But, they are coming through.

Brian Friel
Brian Friel
21 days ago

1. 14 team league bench bat can pick up 1

Nelson Velazquez, Bryan De La Cruz, Brandon Marsh, (Varsho and Scott II were just dropped today too)

2. 10 team league

Should I be patient with Bo Naylor, Estrada and Julien or can move on from any of them?

How about Lipscomb with 3 SB last night!!

Last edited 21 days ago by Brian Friel
brian s
brian s
21 days ago

12 team league, someone dropped machado. I have the #1 waiver, is he worth using it on?

I Am Not A Smart Man
21 days ago

Well I certainly wish I had read that Framber blurb. At least I have Triston McKenzie to fall back on.

-IANASM

E_Bl6cqVIAEevc_-1
Timboski
Timboski
21 days ago

Christian Encarnarcian-Strand is a blowhole of a roster spot. What are the odds he sits 0-50 in my lineup and the day i drop him he hits 2 HR?

Earl
Earl
Reply to  Timboski
21 days ago

IF it follows my experience, I would say shortly after dropping player they do better, lol!

scoboticus
scoboticus
21 days ago

Jake Burger is the Brian Reynolds in my Yahoo league. Auto drafted when I briefly lost connectivity.

Jeremy Burke
Jeremy Burke
21 days ago

Yesterday while reading the comments you said you took Luzardo out of your lineup. So i took him out of mine. Then you wrote that you put him back in, so i did too. Oy vey.
Are you worried about either Luzardo or Eflin yet?
Have a good one!

H to the Izzo
H to the Izzo
21 days ago

Who’s a nice heist for Trout?

Gotime
Gotime
21 days ago

H2H pts league start 2 out of
K. Hayes vs Mize
Stott @ Gray
Paredes @ Sandoval
Also, starting M. Kelly @ Coors? Scores IP Ks Hits BBs HRs

OaktownSteve
OaktownSteve
21 days ago

Reynolds you magnificent bastard.

I started Luzardo and Ober and Keller. Ober looked fantastic. If I influenced your Luzardo start you can blame me if it takes the sting off. Efflin’ OTS!

Swaggerjackers
Swaggerjackers
21 days ago

Glossary term: you were looking for confirmation buy-ass

Dingo37
Dingo37
21 days ago

Draftochist

steve stevenson
steve stevenson
Reply to  Dingo37
21 days ago

This is good.

I Am Not A Smart Man
Reply to  Dingo37
21 days ago

I think this is the winner

tigres
tigres
21 days ago

Grey! I looked directly at my pitchers and now I’ve permanently damaged my retina… Hoffman with the vulture win-after-the-blown-save, though!

Joed1414
Joed1414
21 days ago

Hey Grey, seems like Marsh always comes out of the gate hot. Streamed him yesterday….Nickname swamp ass….

Last edited 21 days ago by Joed1414
Fred
Fred
21 days ago

12 team categories, drop severino for Blackburn? Need ERA

2ndCitySox
2ndCitySox
21 days ago

Grey, for your Reynolds post definition request I thought of Bob Ross saying, “There are no mistakes, only happy accidents.”

I also tried to figure out a way to make Careless Whisper work but I failed.

aardvark
aardvark
21 days ago

Would you offer Tyler O’Niel for Jarrren Duran in a points league?

TarmanGotHim
TarmanGotHim
21 days ago

I don’t usually ask Catcher questions, but I have one.

I have O’Hoppe in 1 league, Campusano in 1, and MJ in 3. I’ve never been this satisfied at the Catcher position in a wealth of leagues obviously taking a Catcher’s in the last couple of rounds. I think MJ is breaking out, hence the stop Prospect moniker.

Question is, someone dropped Raleigh in a league where I own MJ. Someone also dropped O’Hoppe in another. Should I just stand pat or drop MJ for Cal and O’Hoppe on the leagues available?

Ty!!

galica1234
galica1234
21 days ago

Grey!!!!

Awesome report!!! Amazing Exxon Valdez lede, some birds are still oily since!

a. On your question as to why we don’t listen, you should put it to a poll. My gut is 75% ignore you and 25% think they’re smarter/better (my computer keypad kept returning spontaneously to the beginning of smarter/better, with a popup after the 10th time saying are you sure you know what you’re writing).

b. On the term, LQA+Roster=MVP+IQ90

c. No questions, only sadness. Still, some things are normalizing and Snell rarely pitches well in April so there’s that.

d. Chris Rock quote of the day for April 9, 2024

The material comes from whenever you realize that you and someone else have something in common. So any conversation you’ve had more than once, anything you see happening to you that you see happening to a friend, you go, “Hmmm, that’s a situation I can make funny.”.

Cheers,
Ante

The Artist Formerly Known as Manley
The Artist Formerly Known as Manley
21 days ago

Exactly how often do you accidentally draft players, Grey?

patdaddy1985
patdaddy1985
21 days ago

Would you still try to buy Eflin?

patdaddy1985
patdaddy1985
Reply to  patdaddy1985
21 days ago

And Castillo

Chin Music
Chin Music
21 days ago

Last pitch for Reynolds wrapped…youve wrapped yourself/team in reynolds wrap (jus realized its aluminum and not plastic, oops..but alas..) u wont out so bad, u struggle, but! It works! And keeps u in. Ok im done lol

Micah
Micah
21 days ago

I’ve been offered Pete Crow Armstrong for Raisel Iglesias in a dynasty league. Should I take it?

Chin Music
Chin Music
21 days ago

Youve wrapped ur team in a flimsy plastic protective wrap that u feel definitely wont stick but it does and keeps the team safe and…fresh?? Lol. Eh maybe not..but maybe so!! Reynolds wrapped! :”)

Chin Music
Chin Music
21 days ago

First!!!…errr second? Lol

Chin Music
Chin Music
21 days ago

Reynolds wrapped? Lol.