It took us a few weeks, but we have arrived at the finale. We can finally wrap up the Couch Managers 2017 Industry Mock Draft recaps. It feels like just yesterday I was getting started on what was likely to be a 60,000-word article on all 23 rounds of this mock draft before Grey slapped me and told me to put down the bourbon and split this into multiple posts. Below, I’ll be posting the results of rounds 19-23, my thoughts on said results, and the final team for every owner.
In case you have yet to see my previous posts, here is a quick recap of the league rules for this mock:
This mock was for a 15-team, 5×5 roto, with 23 roster spots made up of 9 pitchers (9), 1 spot for each position (8), a second catcher (1), 2 more outfielders (2), one corner infielder (1), one middle infielder (1), and one utility position (1).
Links to previous recaps:
Now, let’s get rounds 19-23 out of the way so that we can get to the good stuff!
Pick | Rd. | Name | Team | Pos | Owner |
271 | 19 | Joe Panik | SF | 2B | Paul Sporer |
272 | 19 | Drew Pomeranz | BOS | SP | @Tim_Heaney |
273 | 19 | Cameron Rupp | PHI | C | Mike Maher |
274 | 19 | Steve Pearce | TOR | 1B | DerekCarty |
275 | 19 | Eduardo Rodriguez | BOS | SP | rotoman |
276 | 19 | Jett Bandy | MIL | C | ToddZ |
277 | 19 | Daniel Norris | DET | SP | Tim McLeod |
278 | 19 | Domingo Santana | MIL | OF | genemccaffrey |
279 | 19 | Chris Owings | AZ | SS | Jimi@CM |
280 | 19 | Josh Harrison | PIT | 2B | Captain Hook |
281 | 19 | Francisco Cervelli | PIT | C | Joelhenardbddr |
282 | 19 | Matt Holliday | NYY | OF | RayHQ |
283 | 19 | Robbie Ray | AZ | SP | MikeGianella |
284 | 19 | Jordan Zimmermann | DET | SP | Doug Anderson |
285 | 19 | Derek Norris | WSH | C | lawrm |
Round 19 thoughts: Quick, can someone figure out how to tag Grey in a post? Robbie Ray just went at 283. Grey currently has him ranked at 199. Great spot to grab Josh Harrison for some depth and positional versatility. Great spots to grab guys like Daniel Norris and Jordan Zimmerman, too, though obviously for different reasons. Derek Norris? Blegch.
Pick | Rd. | Name | Team | Pos | Owner |
286 | 20 | Travis d’Arnaud | NYM | C | lawrm |
287 | 20 | Cam Bedrosian | LAA | RP | Doug Anderson |
288 | 20 | Joaquin Benoit | PHI | RP | MikeGianella |
289 | 20 | Robert Gsellman | NYM | SP | RayHQ |
290 | 20 | Huston Street | LAA | RP | Joelhenardbddr |
291 | 20 | Kevin Pillar | TOR | OF | Captain Hook |
292 | 20 | Joe Musgrove | HOU | SP | Jimi@CM |
293 | 20 | Yangervis Solarte | SD | 3B | genemccaffrey |
294 | 20 | Nate Jones | CHW | RP | Tim McLeod |
295 | 20 | Hisashi Iwakuma | SEA | SP | ToddZ |
296 | 20 | Trevor Bauer | CLE | SP | rotoman |
297 | 20 | Roman Quinn | PHI | OF | DerekCarty |
298 | 20 | Tyson Ross | FA | SP | Mike Maher |
299 | 20 | Corey Knebel | MIL | RP | @Tim_Heaney |
300 | 20 | Junior Guerra | MIL | SP | Paul Sporer |
Round 20 thoughts: I am a secret Kevin Pillar lover, so I really like getting him in the 20th round. He does a little bit of everything and not a lot of anything, except hit doubles and not take walks, but I love the guy. Nate Jones is a sneaky-good grab because Daniel Robertson is getting dealt at some point this season. It might be tomorrow, it might be in May, or it might be in July, but it’s happening.
Pick | Rd. | Name | Team | Pos | Owner |
301 | 21 | Corey Dickerson | TB | OF | Paul Sporer |
302 | 21 | Zach Davies | MIL | SP | @Tim_Heaney |
303 | 21 | Chris Tillman | BAL | SP | Mike Maher |
304 | 21 | Fernando Rodney | AZ | RP | DerekCarty |
305 | 21 | Freddy Galvis | PHI | SS | rotoman |
306 | 21 | Mitch Haniger | SEA | OF | ToddZ |
307 | 21 | Brett Gardner | NYY | OF | Tim McLeod |
308 | 21 | Devin Mesoraco | CIN | C | genemccaffrey |
309 | 21 | Austin Hedges | SD | C | Jimi@CM |
310 | 21 | Andrew Toles | LAD | OF | Captain Hook |
311 | 21 | Josh Tomlin | CLE | SP | Joelhenardbddr |
312 | 21 | Kolten Wong | STL | 2B | RayHQ |
313 | 21 | Andrew Susac | MIL | C | MikeGianella |
314 | 21 | Ben Revere | LAA | OF | Doug Anderson |
315 | 21 | Brandon Finnegan | CIN | SP | lawrm |
Round 21 thoughts: I think I hate almost this entire round except for maybe Brandon Finnegan. Ben Revere could be a nice get if he falls into regular playing time with the Angels, which is not looking likely right now. Freddy Galvis is…you know what, let’s just move on.
Pick | Rd. | Name | Team | Pos | Owner |
316 | 22 | Mike Foltynewicz | ATL | SP | lawrm |
317 | 22 | Tony Wolters | COL | C | Doug Anderson |
318 | 22 | Yan Gomes | CLE | C | MikeGianella |
319 | 22 | Jorge Soler | KC | OF | RayHQ |
320 | 22 | Shelby Miller | AZ | SP | Joelhenardbddr |
321 | 22 | Mitch Moreland | BOS | 1B | Captain Hook |
322 | 22 | Cameron Maybin | LAA | OF | Jimi@CM |
323 | 22 | Tyler Skaggs | LAA | SP | genemccaffrey |
324 | 22 | Shin-Soo Choo | TEX | OF | Tim McLeod |
325 | 22 | Seth Smith | BAL | OF | ToddZ |
326 | 22 | Alex Cobb | TB | SP | rotoman |
327 | 22 | Collin McHugh | HOU | SP | DerekCarty |
328 | 22 | Trevor Rosenthal | STL | RP | Mike Maher |
329 | 22 | Travis Shaw | MIL | 3B | @Tim_Heaney |
330 | 22 | James McCann | DET | C | Paul Sporer |
Round 22 thoughts: Shelby Miller is a solid gamble here. I know that advanced metrics had kind of foreshadowed the struggles he had last year, but even Bill James wouldn’t have thought Miller would be that bad. 300+ is a fine time to gamble on Miller’s upside and hope he turns in a solid year. If he is going to struggle again, you’ll know pretty early into the season and will be able to look for someone else. You know the drill by now. Unless you focus on starting pitching early in your draft and sacrifice other positions, you are more than likely going to be streaming at least one of your starting pitching slots for most of the season. There is no risk here in grabbing Miller. Mikey likes. Jorge Soler in Kansas City at 319? Sure. I’ll give it a whirl. Alex Cobb? Why not. Travis Shaw? Meh, pass.
Pick | Rd. | Name | Team | Pos | Owner |
331 | 23 | Pablo Sandoval | BOS | 3B | Paul Sporer |
332 | 23 | Mallex Smith | TB | OF | @Tim_Heaney |
333 | 23 | Adam Conley | MIA | SP | Mike Maher |
334 | 23 | Michael Saunders | FA | OF | DerekCarty |
335 | 23 | Mike Zunino | SEA | C | rotoman |
336 | 23 | Matt Strahm | KC | RP | ToddZ |
337 | 23 | Dan Vogelbach | SEA | 1B | Tim McLeod |
338 | 23 | Seth Lugo | NYM | SP | genemccaffrey |
339 | 23 | Peter O’Brien | KC | OF | Jimi@CM |
340 | 23 | Bartolo Colon | ATL | SP | Captain Hook |
341 | 23 | Nick Markakis | ATL | OF | Joelhenardbddr |
342 | 23 | Jose De Leon | LAD | SP | RayHQ |
343 | 23 | Lance Lynn | STL | SP | MikeGianella |
344 | 23 | Arodys Vizcaino | ATL | RP | Doug Anderson |
345 | 23 | Kendall Graveman | OAK | SP | lawrm |
Round 23 thoughts: I have very, very low expectations for Pablo Sandoval. But at 331 overall I definitely don’t hate Paul Sporer taking a flyer on him. The Michael Saunders pick looks better now that we know he is going to get regular playing time in Philadelphia in a tiny ballpark. That isn’t a bad flyer either. Lance Lynn? I like it. I like it a lot.
So, there you have it. All 23 rounds and 345 picks are in. I’ll post the complete teams below.
Here is a link to a spreadsheet with all of the results in order.
And here is every team, broken down by the available positions in this league:
POS | Paul Sporer | @Tim_Heaney | Mike Maher |
C | Gary Sanchez C-NYY | Russell Martin C-TOR | Wilson Ramos C-TB |
C | James McCann C-DET | Tom Murphy C-COL | Cameron Rupp C-PHI |
1B | Greg Bird 1B/MiLB-NYY | Chris Carter 1B-NYY | Tommy Joseph 1B-PHI |
2B | Daniel Murphy 2B/1B-WSH | DJ LeMahieu 2B-COL | Rougned Odor 2B-TEX |
3B | Jake Lamb 3B-AZ | Todd Frazier 3B-CHW | Kris Bryant 3B/OF-CHC |
SS | Trevor Story SS-COL | Tim Anderson SS-CHW | Francisco Lindor SS-CLE |
OF | Mike Trout OF-LAA | Mookie Betts OF-BOS | Adam Jones OF-BAL |
OF | Christian Yelich OF-MIA | George Springer OF-HOU | Khris Davis OF/DH-OAK |
OF | Marcell Ozuna OF-MIA | J.D. Martinez OF-DET | Hunter Renfroe OF-SD |
OF | Yasiel Puig OF-LAD | Eric Thames 1B/MiLB-MIL | Joc Pederson OF-LAD |
OF | Corey Dickerson OF/DH-TB | Mallex Smith OF-TB | Josh Reddick OF-HOU |
CI | Ryon Healy 3B-OAK | Alex Bregman 3B-HOU | Kyle Seager 3B-SEA |
MI | Joe Panik 2B-SF | Orlando Arcia SS-MIL | Ben Zobrist 2B/OF-CHC |
UT | Pablo Sandoval 3B-BOS | Travis Shaw 3B/1B-MIL | Jose Ramirez 3B/OF-CLE |
P | Kenley Jansen RP-LAD | Chris Archer SP-TB | Stephen Strasburg SP-WSH |
P | Kelvin Herrera RP-KC | Julio Teheran SP-ATL | Rick Porcello SP-BOS |
P | Gerrit Cole SP-PIT | Ken Giles RP-HOU | Felix Hernandez SP-SEA |
P | Steven Matz SP-NYM | Dallas Keuchel SP-HOU | Jim Johnson RP-ATL |
P | Kevin Gausman SP-BAL | Matt Shoemaker SP-LAA | Jeanmar Gomez RP-PHI |
P | Carlos Rodon SP-CHW | Hector Neris RP-PHI | Tyson Ross SP-TEX |
P | James Paxton SP-SEA | Drew Pomeranz SP-BOS | Chris Tillman SP-BAL |
P | Dellin Betances RP-NYY | Corey Knebel RP-MIL | Trevor Rosenthal RP-STL |
P | Junior Guerra SP-MIL | Zach Davies SP-MIL | Adam Conley SP-MIA |
POS | DerekCarty | rotoman | ToddZ |
C | Evan Gattis C/DH-HOU | Yasmani Grandal C-LAD | Stephen Vogt C/DH-OAK |
C | Yadier Molina C-STL | Mike Zunino C-SEA | Jett Bandy C-MIL |
1B | Mike Napoli 1B/DH-TEX | Carlos Santana 1B/DH-CLE | Edwin Encarnacion 1B/DH-CLE |
2B | Brian Dozier 2B-MIN | Robinson Cano 2B-SEA | Dee Gordon 2B-MIA |
3B | Miguel Sano 3B/OF/DH-MIN | Manny Machado 3B/SS-BAL | Nolan Arenado 3B-COL |
SS | Brad Miller 2B/1B/SS-TB | Jonathan Villar 2B/SS/3B-MIL | Didi Gregorius SS-NYY |
OF | Giancarlo Stanton OF-MIA | Nelson Cruz OF/DH-SEA | Carlos Gonzalez OF-COL |
OF | Ian Desmond OF/1B-COL | Gregory Polanco OF-PIT | Adam Eaton OF-WSH |
OF | Jose Bautista OF/DH-TOR | Odubel Herrera OF-PHI | Kole Calhoun OF-LAA |
OF | Carlos Gomez OF-TEX | Yasmany Tomas OF-AZ | Manuel Margot OF-SD |
OF | Roman Quinn OF-PHI | Byron Buxton OF-MIN | Mitch Haniger OF-SEA |
CI | Steve Pearce 1B-TOR | Yoan Moncada 2B/3B-CHW | C.J. Cron 1B-LAA |
MI | Ryan Schimpf 2B-SD | Freddy Galvis SS-PHI | Ian Kinsler 2B-DET |
UT | Michael Saunders OF-PHI | Max Kepler OF-MIN | Seth Smith OF-BAL |
P | Clayton Kershaw SP-LAD | Jacob DeGrom SP-NYM | Corey Kluber SP-CLE |
P | Aroldis Chapman RP-NYY | Kenta Maeda SP-LAD | Masahiro Tanaka SP-NYY |
P | Lance McCullers SP-HOU | Julio Urias SP/RP-LAD | Alex Colome RP-TB |
P | Matt Moore SP-SF | Sonny Gray SP-OAK | Rich Hill SP-LAD |
P | Aaron Nola SP-PHI | Raisel Iglesias RP/SP-CIN | John Lackey SP-CHC |
P | Sam Dyson RP-TEX | Shawn Kelley RP-WSH | Jerad Eickhoff SP-PHI |
P | Michael Pineda SP-NYY | Eduardo Rodriguez SP-BOS | Brandon Maurer RP-SD |
P | Fernando Rodney RP-AZ | Trevor Bauer SP/RP-CLE | Hisashi Iwakuma SP-SEA |
P | Collin McHugh SP-HOU | Alex Cobb SP-TB | Matt Strahm RP/SP-KC |
POS | Tim McLeod | genemccaffrey | Jimi@CM |
C | Willson Contreras C/OF-CHC | Salvador Perez C-KC | Brian McCann C/DH-HOU |
C | J.T. Realmuto C-MIA | Devin Mesoraco C-CIN | Austin Hedges C-SD |
1B | Freddie Freeman 1B-ATL | Anthony Rizzo 1B-CHC | Paul Goldschmidt 1B-AZ |
2B | Jose Altuve 2B-HOU | Dustin Pedroia 2B-BOS | Javier Baez 2B/3B/SS-CHC |
3B | Yulieski Gurriel 3B-HOU | Adrian Beltre 3B-TEX | Hernan Perez 3B/OF-MIL |
SS | Elvis Andrus SS-TEX | Aledmys Diaz SS-STL | Jean Segura SS/2B-SEA |
OF | Ryan Braun OF-MIL | A.J. Pollock OF-AZ | Kyle Schwarber OF-CHC |
OF | Kevin Kiermaier OF-TB | Matt Kemp OF-ATL | Jackie Bradley OF-BOS |
OF | Leonys Martin OF-SEA | Jay Bruce OF-NYM | Carlos Beltran OF/DH-HOU |
OF | Brett Gardner OF-NYY | David Peralta OF-AZ | Rajai Davis OF-OAK |
OF | Shin-Soo Choo OF-TEX | Domingo Santana OF-MIL | Cameron Maybin OF-LAA |
CI | Albert Pujols 1B/DH-LAA | Yangervis Solarte 3B-SD | Brandon Belt 1B-SF |
MI | Jason Kipnis 2B-CLE | Jose Peraza 2B/SS/OF-CIN | Chris Owings SS/OF-AZ |
UT | Dan Vogelbach 1B-SEA | Victor Martinez DH-DET | Peter O’Brien OF-KC |
P | Noah Syndergaard SP-NYM | Justin Verlander SP-DET | Madison Bumgarner SP-SF |
P | Aaron Sanchez SP-TOR | Yu Darvish SP-TEX | Danny Duffy SP/RP-KC |
P | Roberto Osuna RP-TOR | Wade Davis RP-CHC | Adam Wainwright SP-STL |
P | Jameson Taillon SP-PIT | Vincent Velasquez SP-PHI | Dylan Bundy SP/RP-BAL |
P | J.A. Happ SP-TOR | Garrett Richards SP-LAA | Joe Musgrove SP-HOU |
P | Adam Ottavino RP-COL | Jeff Samardzija SP-SF | Ivan Nova SP/RP-PIT |
P | Anthony DeSclafani SP-CIN | Mike Montgomery SP/RP-CHC | Zach Britton RP-BAL |
P | Daniel Norris SP-DET | Tyler Skaggs SP-LAA | Seung Hwan Oh RP-STL |
P | Nate Jones RP-CHW | Seth Lugo SP/RP-NYM | Addison Reed RP-NYM |
POS | Captain Hook | Joelhenardbddr | RayHQ |
C | Welington Castillo C-BAL | Sandy Leon C-BOS | Buster Posey C/1B-SF |
C | Chris Herrmann C-AZ | Francisco Cervelli C-PIT | Matt Wieters C-FA |
1B | Eric Hosmer 1B-KC | Hanley Ramirez 1B-BOS | Matt Carpenter 1B/2B/3B-STL |
2B | Trea Turner SS/2B/OF-WSH | Jonathan Schoop 2B-BAL | Kolten Wong 2B-STL |
3B | Josh Donaldson 3B-TOR | Evan Longoria 3B-TB | Anthony Rendon 3B-WSH |
SS | Dansby Swanson SS-ATL | Xander Bogaerts SS-BOS | Troy Tulowitzki SS-TOR |
OF | David Dahl OF-COL | Bryce Harper OF-WSH | Charlie Blackmon OF-COL |
OF | Andrew Benintendi OF-BOS | Nomar Mazara OF-TEX | Billy Hamilton OF-CIN |
OF | Lorenzo Cain OF-KC | Michael Brantley OF-CLE | Stephen Piscotty OF-STL |
OF | Kevin Pillar OF-TOR | Brandon Drury OF/3B-AZ | Matt Holliday OF/1B-NYY |
OF | Andrew Toles OF-LAD | Nick Markakis OF-ATL | Jorge Soler OF-KC |
CI | Matt Duffy 3B/SS-TB | Josh Bell 1B-PIT | Mike Moustakas 3B-KC |
MI | Josh Harrison 2B-PIT | Addison Russell SS-CHC | Brandon Crawford SS-SF |
UT | Mitch Moreland 1B-BOS | Justin Bour 1B-MIA | Kendrys Morales DH-TOR |
P | Jake Arrieta SP-CHC | Jon Lester SP-CHC | Chris Sale SP-BOS |
P | Johnny Cueto SP-SF | Jose Quintana SP-CHW | Craig Kimbrel RP-BOS |
P | Andrew Miller RP-CLE | Edwin Diaz RP-SEA | Danny Salazar SP-CLE |
P | Drew Smyly SP-SEA | Sean Manaea SP-OAK | David Robertson RP-CHW |
P | Tanner Roark SP-WSH | Jharel Cotton SP-OAK | Jon Gray SP-COL |
P | A.J. Ramos RP-MIA | Blake Snell SP-TB | Taijuan Walker SP-AZ |
P | Tony Watson RP-PIT | Huston Street RP-LAA | Brandon Kintzler RP-MIN |
P | Joe Ross SP-WSH | Josh Tomlin SP-CLE | Robert Gsellman SP-NYM |
P | Bartolo Colon SP-ATL | Shelby Miller SP-AZ | Jose De Leon SP-TB |
POS | MikeGianella | Doug Anderson | lawrm |
C | Andrew Susac C-MIL | Jonathan Lucroy C-TEX | Derek Norris C-WSH |
C | Yan Gomes C-CLE | Tony Wolters C-COL | Travis d’Arnaud C-NYM |
1B | Joey Votto 1B-CIN | Miguel Cabrera 1B-DET | Adrian Gonzalez 1B-LAD |
2B | Neil Walker 2B-NYM | Devon Travis 2B-TOR | Starlin Castro 2B-NYY |
3B | Justin Turner 3B-LAD | Maikel Franco 3B-PHI | Nick Castellanos 3B-DET |
SS | Eduardo Nunez 3B/SS-SF | Carlos Correa SS-HOU | Corey Seager SS-LAD |
OF | Justin Upton OF-DET | Mark Trumbo OF/DH-BAL | Starling Marte OF-PIT |
OF | Adam Duvall OF-CIN | Hunter Pence OF-SF | Yoenis Cespedes OF-NYM |
OF | Curtis Granderson OF-NYM | Dexter Fowler OF-STL | Andrew McCutchen OF-PIT |
OF | Jacoby Ellsbury OF-NYY | Jarrod Dyson OF-SEA | Ender Inciarte OF-ATL |
OF | Keon Broxton OF-MIL | Jason Heyward OF-CHC | Randal Grichuk OF-STL |
CI | Jose Abreu 1B-CHW | Chris Davis 1B-BAL | Jedd Gyorko 3B/2B/SS-STL |
MI | Asdrubal Cabrera SS-NYM | Logan Forsythe 2B-LAD | Marcus Semien SS-OAK |
UT | Wil Myers 1B-SD | Ben Revere OF-LAA | Steven Souza OF-TB |
P | Max Scherzer SP-WSH | Carlos Carrasco SP-CLE | David Price SP-BOS |
P | Kyle Hendricks SP-CHC | Zack Greinke SP-AZ | Carlos Martinez SP-STL |
P | Cole Hamels SP-TEX | Cody Allen RP-CLE | Mark Melancon RP-SF |
P | Marcus Stroman SP-TOR | Alex Reyes SP/RP-STL | Jeurys Familia RP-NYM |
P | Matt Harvey SP-NYM | Jake Odorizzi SP-TB | Michael Fulmer SP-DET |
P | Francisco Rodriguez RP-DET | Ryan Madson RP-OAK | Marco Estrada SP-TOR |
P | Robbie Ray SP-AZ | Jordan Zimmermann SP-DET | Brandon Finnegan SP-CIN |
P | Joaquin Benoit RP-PHI | Cam Bedrosian RP-LAA | Mike Foltynewicz SP-ATL |
P | Lance Lynn SP/MiLB-STL | Arodys Vizcaino RP-ATL | Kendall Graveman SP-OAK |
So, there you have it. Who do you think has the best and worst teams? Overall, I’m pretty happy with how my team rounded out in comparison to the other teams. I like the Sporer, Heaney, and McLeod teams, too.
If you want to talk fantasy football or have players you want Mike to feature, hit him up on Twitter at @mikeMaher or post a comment below!