Cardinals won’t make the playoffs, but they should’ve been a 100-loss team and they might end up at .500. That takes ingenuity. Like parallel parking a golf cart while drinking six beers out of a boot. Ingenuity does not show up on the leaderboards. You’re not going to find ingenuity as a category in your fantasy league (unless you’re in one of those dumb leagues with like errors, HBPs and ingenuity). But ingenuity goes unaccounted for too often when we’re playing this game called fantasy baseball (sound like Winston Churchill in my head). Teams’ culture and ingenuity (and Devil Magic when speaking about the Cardinals, specifically). Those things matter. The Angels sucked because of a lack of ingenuity. Cardinals though? They’re better for it. Enter Quinn Mathews (6 2/3 IP, 1 ER, 6 baserunners, 8 Ks, ERA at 3.62). You look at his underlying numbers (8.7 K/9, 3.9 BB/9, 4.12 xFIP); his insane walk rate in the minors (5.6 BB/9, um wut?) and his under-94 MPH fastball and it’s meh, guys and five girl readers. But the Cardinals don’t let meh coast on its meh-ness! Cardinals step meh up and say go be slightly better than mediocre! Or at least as good as McGreevy. Anyway, here’s what else I saw yesterday in fantasy baseball:
Alec Burleson – 2-for-3, 1 RBI, hitting .285. He leads the majors in RBIs with 110. Cards’ Devil Magic!
Rafael Devers – Will undergo core surgery today and I will be performing it. Devers should be ready for Spring Training. Fingers crossed! Not mine though!
Clarke Schmidt – Will be returning from Tommy John surgery this week. Wish I could put how inconsequential this news is in a little capsule and feed it to everyone who asks next March questions like, “Grey, handsome stuff on your face. Anyway, why do you hate Pablo Lopez? Sounds like he could be back by May, might want to boost him in your rankings.”
Will Warren – 5 2/3 IP, 0 ER, 7 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 3.89. He’s turned around his bad 2nd half in the last few starts. ACKSUALLY, now that I look at his game log, Warren hasn’t been bad in about a month. Streamonator hates his next one in Arizona, but I don’t mind it.
Jose Caballero – 2-for-4, 2 runs, 2 RBIs and a slam (14) and legs (32). Made him my batty call in one league and now I might ask him to stay for breakfast, lunch and dinner until Tuesday’s game.
Aaron Judge – 1-for-4, 3 RBIs and his 18th homer. Eighteen homers for Judge wouldn’t be bad. Dot dot dot. If this were May. He only has four more homers than Caballero!
Josh Bell – 2-for-4, 2 runs and his 20th homer, 2nd homer in four games. That means he’s due for another in the next three. This is Bell Math.
Dean Kremer – 5 2/3 IP, 1 ER, 3 baserunners, 5 Ks, ERA at 5.35. His opponent, the Yankees, have these games where their hitting looks like ’27 Yankees. Not the 1927 Yankees, and obviously not next year’s yet, but the 1827 Yankees. A group of barnstormers who never heard of baseball and used fruit bats to suck scurvy out of their blood.
Reynaldo Lopez – 3 IP, 5 ER, ERA at 4.54, and headed back to the IL with shoulder soreness. A Braves’ beat reporter said, “Lopez made just one start before undergoing shoulder surgery last year. He has posted a 4.54 ERA over 79.1 IP this year and with lingering shoulder issues his value next year seems questionable.” Yeah, you don’t say!
David Peterson – 6 IP, 0 ER, 6 baserunners, 7 Ks, ERA at 5.05. Cubs managed to figure out a way to have the wind blowing in when their pitchers are pitching and blowing out when their hitters are hitting.
Pete Crow-Armstrong – 4-for-5, 4 RBIs and a slam (42) and legs (37), hitting .281. PCA better stop hitting the ball out of the stadium so he can get to 40/40.
Jonah Tong – 6 IP, 0 ER, 5 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 3.43. Streamonator loved this start for Tong and hates his next one, and I don’t trust Tong, but we’re at the “hold onto your hat” portion of the season
A.J. Ewing – 1-for-3 and his 10th homer. Soto and Lindor will be based on where you are drafting, but in 2027 can we say Benge and Ewing are 2027 sleepers, if they weren’t on the Mets?
Brandon Young – 5 IP, 1 ER, 10 baserunners (5 BBs), 6 Ks, ERA at 3.65. I should be hired by teams for situations that always arise, and all I’ll do is say, “Nuh-uh.” I’m The Nuh-Uh Guy. Here, I’ll show you what I mean: Front office exec, “We have a good one in Brandon Young.” I walk by and poke my head in, “Nuh-uh.”
Gunnar Henderson – 1-for-4 and his 23rd homer. How cool is this, I thought he retired. Or did he retire and return for one final game?
Troy Melton – 2 2/3 IP, 2 ER, ERA at 2.52. I watched this start (mostly I watched to see if I could cool off Vlad Jr.’s hot hitting and mission accomplished), and I’m not even sure how Melton threw 76 pitches, gave up nine baserunners in under three innings and only allowed two runs.
Kazuma Okamoto – 1-for-4, 3 RBIs and his 33rd homer. Yeah, okay, but Murakami’s gonna hit 40 points lower than him in average, so there!
Kade Anderson – 4 1/3 IP, 5 ER, ERA at 5.33. Who’s the Mariners’ pitching coach and can they be fired?
Cal Raleigh – 1-for-4, 3 RBIs and his 22nd homer. He’s hitting .181. Not to get all Gregorian on you, but it’s the middle of September.
J.P. Crawford – 2-for-5 and his 12th homer, 2nd homer in three games. John Paulringogeorge Crawford seems to be a hot schmotato.
Reid Detmers – 6 IP, 3 ER, 8 baserunners, 8 Ks, ERA at 3.36. Wouldn’t say I’ve had the most stellar year in my RCL; it’s actually been my worst year I think, but I did make a pickup and hold of Detmers and I’m holding onto that as a highlight. When the season ends, I will forget it the next day. But for right now, it feels good to cherish it!
Edwin Diaz – This is how I heard the latest on Edwin. I saw a news article that said, “Dave Roberts talks about the latest with Edwin Diaz.” Okay, so I opened that and Roberts said, “(Edwin) needs to pitch better in rehab.” So I was like, “Okay, how bad could it be,” so I then opened his latest numbers and he’s thrown 3 1/3 IP and given up six earned with seven walks. Howling! Bro, what happened to Edwin Diaz? He’s the closer in March of next year, where does he get drafted and are you interested at all? The bounce back is alluring, but he might just be broke. Wouldn’t be the first time it happened to someone.
Emmet Sheehan – Sent down to the minors as Roki Sasaki and Kris Bubic return. Can’t say I’m that mad about it, because I had dropped Sheehan in a 12 out of 10 rage and I didn’t want to see him succeed.
Tarik Skubal – 7 IP, 0 ER, 4 baserunners, 9 Ks, ERA at 2.70. Dodgers have so many stars sometimes I forget they also have arguably the top pitcher in baseball, at least he was coming into this year.
Teoscar Hernandez – 1-for-3, 2 runs, 2 RBIs and a slam (14) and legs (5), hitting .265. Last night was Teoscar’s night, and Teemmy’s.
Kyle Tucker – 1-for-2, 2 runs and a slam (15) and legs (11), hitting .227. Rooting for Tucker to have a huge postseason so some poor saps out there draft him next year. Enjoy, saps!
Nick Lodolo – 7 IP, 4 ER, 7 baserunners (4 BBs), 4 Ks, ERA at 5.12. If you ever think you had a bad year, remember Lodolo lost a full year to a blister.
Elly De La Cruz – 1-for-4 and his 27th homer, hitting .284. E!’s put to bed any whispers of a bad 2nd half hitter. Now come back next year and go 30/50!
Gavin Williams – 5 IP, 1 ER, 7 baserunners, 7 Ks, ERA at 3.72. Polar opposite feelings to mine on Kyle Tucker. I want the Guards eliminated and Gavin to go home and rest his arm for the next six months, so I can confidently draft him next year.
Miguel Vargas – 2-for-4, 2 runs, 2 RBIs and a slam (31) and legs (19), hitting .249. Had a thought that the White Sox, as a team, had a terrible K% and 2nd half offense, in general, but the stats didn’t pan out. They did hit .224 in the 2nd half, which is 29th. Other stats were middle-ish. Different than Middle Earth. That’s Mordor Vargas.
Corbin Burnes – 4 2/3 IP, 5 ER, ERA at 5.87. Has any pitcher ever come back from surgery and pitched well? A question, I ponder.
Jordan Lawlar – 2-for-4, 2 runs, 2 RBIs and a slam (5) and legs (5). Lots of slams and legses for a short schedule day. I’d ask Lawlar to count them all but he’d hurt his quad and miss the rest of the season.
Javier Sanoja – 2-for-4, 2 runs, 3 RBIs and a slam (9) and legs (11). Might be misremembering this, but it feels like Sanoja has been hot for the better part of the 2nd half.
Pete Fairbanks – Walked the leadoff man, then was removed from the game because the next batter up was not a barn, so he had no chance of hitting it. Gotta assume he’s headed back to the IL and likely done for the year. My guess would be Calvin Faucher, but it could be Tyler Zuber or The Staircase’s Michael Petersen.
Jesus Sanchez – Claimed off waivers by the DBags. Hearing this is the first time there’s been a Jesus in the desert. Not into learning anything new, so that’ll have to be true for me.
Corbin Carroll – 2-for-5, 3 RBIs and his 21st homer, hitting .240. After the walk-off homer, the DBags’ announcer exclaimed, “The DBacks are the comebackiest team in the majors once again!” D-ComeBackiest was right there.
Cole Carrigg – 2-for-5 and his 8th homer, hitting .261. 2027 sleeper? Absolutely short-listed. Even if he didn’t play his home games in Coors.
Manny Machado – 1-for-5, and his 28th homer, and 2nd homer in two games. Macho, macho, Machado!
Fernando Tatis Jr. – 1-for-5, 2 RBIs and his 22nd homer. Fun The Jewels! His bat speed is so juicy, I regret to inform I will be a Fer-Stando again next year.
Ty France – 3-for-5, 1 run, 1 RBI as he was activated from the paternity list. Sending congrats to France and his wife as they welcomed into the world an eight-pound, three-ounce croque monsieur.
Bazzana is going crazy in half a September
That’s 5 homers after zero in August!
Rook’s gonna go 15/20 and that’s not counting a month in MiLB
Sign me up in 2027 for a piece of this Aussie!
Freeman available in my league, dropped due to his knee injury. He was 3/5 tonight. Worth picking up over Bolte, Otto, Seager, or Xavier? Knee could bench him again I guess. Xavier also benched tonight after only two games back from IL. Ugh.
What’s good Grey? Need to pick up two starts for this week and was wondering how you’d rank the following “best” options with a limited waiver wire:
Sean Burke vs. DET
Justin Wrobleski vs. SF
Davis Martin vs. DET
Michael McGreevy vs. WAS
Randy Dobnak @ PIT
Happy Ides of September, and hi to Ted!
You could throw a wild card Emmett Sheehan in there as well?
Sheehan was sent down, did you hear he’s back?
Ted says hi!
No, but I think he will be.
Risky I guess but over mcgreevy if you want to try
Burke, McGreevy
Bauers or Wilson Contreras? Thx
Willson
Do baseball beat reporters exist any longer? If so, how much do they get paid to do nothing? I would like to apply somewhere
Haha the dream job
How would you rank streaming these starts in a league where Losses and Total Bases Allowed counts against pitchers?
Wacha @HOU
or
Gausman vsATL
or
Jax vsATH
Jax………………..Gausman, Wacha
Would you:
1. Start or sit Wilson Contreras at Degrom’s Texas Rangers?
2. Start or sit Mickey Gasper at Degrom’s Texas Rangers?
3. Would you start or sit Sal Stewart at home vs Yamamoto?
Thank you!
Why not start all 3?
I probably overthinking it because the tough pitching matchup.
who would start at 1B, Gasper or Wilson Contreras?
Thanks!!
Willson
Thanks!!
No problem
Over the last two weeks,
Who would you rather have:
Wilyer Abreu who is at Texas, at TB and home vs Cleveland
or Cole Carrigg is home for three series vs SD, vs Seattle, and vs Arizona
Thanks!!!
Carrigg
Thanks!
No problem
Are we thinking brass balls to fire up Jared Jones vs the Brewers tomorrow?
Not if they clinch tonight
Grey, on the podcast I can’t play it on the non YouTube one. There isn’t the regular play thing on there.
Thanks for alerting me, fixed
Hey Grey, needing to pick up a pitcher, not many great options on the waiver, would you go Pallante or Aaron Nola?
Thanks as always!
Who are they facing
Pallante vs SFG
Nola vs NYM
Pallante
Hey Grey! Awesome write up!
Sorry in advance for the long question!
I’m trying to hold on to first in my 5×5 roto OBP and SV+H with hits as an additional CAT league with less than 2 weeks to go! I have one move left and looking for some advice! I have a 2 point lead at the moment but have a slim lead on (Losing Devers hurts!)
Hits (3 ahead of next team)
HR (4 ahead of next team)
RBI (2 ahead of next team)
W (tied with 3 teams with another 1 win behind me)
K: (18 behind the next team)
Here is my squad:
C: Herrera
1B: CES
2B: Arraez
3B: Sal Stewart
SS: Elly
OF: Schwarber, Springer, Chourio, Carroll
UTIL: Witt Jr
Bench: Walter Jenkins, Wetherholt (on IL)
SP: Skubal, Glasnow, Tolle, Ian Seymour, Logan Henderson, Clay Holmes, Andrew painter, Jared Jones, Troy Melton
RP: Varland, Latz, Webb, Riley O’Brien
IL: Max Meyer, Devin williams, Holderman, Devers
It looks like I am defending 3 points in the hitting cats and there are 2 points available in the pitching cats. With one move left would you:
1) Pick up one of these pitchers to gain W’s/K’s; (i’d drop Jenkins)
2) Drop Jenkins for one of these Hitters to protect RBI, HR and HIts)
3) or just wait till the final week to see how the needs change!
Thanks as always!
Wish you would’ve acted sooner to get Jax’s start today….I’d wait until next week now
Thanks, I sat on that decision for a while last night and then fell asleep before i could make it lol
HAHA
After many attempts to persuade our commish to reduce the fantasy season by two weeks…he has not. I’m cringing to think how next week will go, but I’m in the finals thanks to you Gray. I appreciate all the humor and advice. It looks like it’s going to be a fun postseason, (Go Rays!) and in hope it ends up enjoyable for us all.
Is Antonnaci worth holding or should I shift to Bazzana or Ewing? 2B has been rough this year for me.
Hope so! Go to Bazzana
H2H championship week. i had bailey ober from last week thinking he was going to get a start on last weekend. Do you start him today vs the Yankees?
Nope
Grey,
please rank for final week of a H2H pts league:
Gausman MIA; @Bos
Jones STL; @Det
Martinez @NYY; @Phi
Nick, Jones
Thanks for your advice on not trusting Melton yesterday. I was tempted to pick him up, but didn’t. Phew!
For this last week and final championship push, pick up any of: Konnor (v. MIL, v. KC), Suarez (v. LAD, v. CHC), Bazzana (v. CWS, v. ATH), Cags (@HOU, @PIT), or Marsee (@AZ, @SD)
Over any of: Seager (v. BOS, v. TOR), Bolte (@TB, @CLE), Otto Lopez or Xavier Edwards (both @AZ, @SD)?
Nah
Okay, thanks! And thanks for your fantasy baseball wisdom all season, I’m playing for the championship this week. Much appreciated!
No problem
Good morning. Head to head matchup against team with best pitching. No chance for me to win K’s and very doubtful for Wins.
Please rank my SPs for ERA & WHIP this week:
Rasmussen vs. A’s
Messick vs. CHW
Gilbert @LAA
Gray @TX
Rodon @MN
Woo @COL
Thank you.
Rasmussen vs. A’s
Messick vs. CHW
Gray @TX
Gilbert @LAA
Rodon @MN
Woo @COL
Hey Grey! You like either Kirby @LAA or Joe Ryan @LAA? Angels are bad vs RHB and bad at home, and bad in general, but dunno if it’s worth the risk with these two.
Ryan I don’t trust at all…I guess Kirby if I needed it
Couple start or sit questions:
1. Start or sit Griffin vs white Sox at home?
2. Start or sit Griffin Jax vs Athletics at home?
Thanks as always for answering my questions, it’s much appreciated!
Morning Grey,
Rethinking moves in championship H2H matchup – 12 team points league:
A. Who are the top 4 from this bunch:
Amador vs SD vs SEA
Carrigg vs SD vs SEA
Mayo @NYM vs MIL
Heriberto @ARI @SD
Jones @MIN @ARI
Eldridge @STL @LAD
Saggese vs SF vs WSH
Caglianone @HOU @PIT
Mesa Jr vs ATH vs BOS
Marsee @ARI @SD
Crawford @LAA @COL
Canzone @LAA @COL
Mitchell @PIT @BAL
B. Rethinking starts for the week. Which are the best 3:
Johnson vs MIN
Scott vs PHI
Javier vs KC
Quantrill vs TOR
Jobe @CHW
May @PIT
Quinn vs MIN
Thanks as always
Carrigg, Crawford, Amador, Heriberto B. Quantrill, Scott, May
Who would you start between Cavalli (PHI) or Henderson (@ PIT). Cavalli is facing Wheeler…Henderson is facing Jones. SON likes Cavalli. This is a weekly points league.
Cade
If you’re like me, you’re wondering how you came to have Pete Fairbanks rostered for so long when he’s not really that good.
Well, I’ll tell you. It’s because he was always available on waivers at the right time.
When Edwin Diaz went down, Pete was there.
When Ryan Helsley went missing, Pete was there.
When Devin Williams and Raisel Iglesias hit the IL, and all the Cubs closers decided to be terrible, Pete was there.
When you noticed that during all the worst weeks of your RP slot, there were multiple blown saves, and you asked, “Why, Pete? Why, when I needed you most, you have not been there for me?”
Pete replied, “that is when I carried you.”
HAHAHAHA, same
carried us to fifth place
Grey
11 team Roto
Would you drop Kade Anderson who has not been great
for
Quinn Mathews home vs Washington
Jackson Jobe @ CHW
Christian Javier @ home vs KC
Javier
Re: your Burnes blurb, Melton seems like one of the few pitchers to come back from surgery and pitch well (albeit hitting a wall this past month or so)
Yeah, there’s some
Skubal earned his 2nd and the Dodgers’ 5th entry on the 100 Best Fantasy Starts list:
12 Tyler Glasnow Apr 23 @SF
32 Yoshinobu Yamamoto Jun 13 @CHW
45 Justin Wrobleski May 29 vs PHI
80 Tarik Skubal Sep 14 @CIN
94 Yoshinobu Yamamoto Jul 4 vs SD
He’s in a 8-way tie at #80:
Nolan McLean (NYM) Jun 17 @CIN
Bryan Woo (SEA) Jun 18 vs BAL
Tarik Skubal (DET) Jun 30 @NYY
Dylan Cease (TOR) Jul 3 @SEA
Joe Ryan (MIN) Jul 5 @NYY
Mitch Bratt (ARI) Aug 5 vs SD
Jesus Luzardo (PHI) Aug 26 @SEA
Tarik Skubal (LAD) Sep 14 @CIN
Good stuff, Vin!
7 SLAM & LEGS!! Previous high was 6 on May 30.
Sanoja since the break: 60 for 188 (.319) 26 R/6 HR/29 RBI/6 SB.
Last 30: .362 with 5 HR/5 SB.
In September, .385 with 3 HR/2 SB.
# Leagues I own him: 0
# Leagues I have owned him: ALL
I even picked him up and dropped him this month.
Wow! I knew there seemed like a lot…Pretty remarkable on Sanoja because I look at his season-long stats and I see very little there…basically did it all in the 2nd half
Would you stream either, neither or both of these guys tonight?
Griffin Jax at home versus the A’s
Foster Griffin at home versus the White Sox
Yeah, Griffin, I think
Haha
Both
hi grey
im deciding who to put for a couple slots:
A: Catcher Hicks or Jensen
B: OF 3 of Langford Trout Mccarthy Griffin or Carrigg with one concern being griffin vs the miz
C: For my util slots Im deciding between any of the listed players above but also Lombard Mayo and Naylor
Thank you again
A. Jensen B. Carrigg C. McCarthy
since i have 3 outfield and two util slots who else would you start
Langford Trout Mccarthy Griffin, Carrigg
I detest Dodgers, but Tucker is on my potential buy-low list for next season.
Why?
Because he’ll be undervalued. I take a look at every player who might be undervalued, and see where their ADP or draft cost lands pre-season.
Some aspects to support it:
1) First year after a megacontract, usually with a new club, is often a downer
2) He’s a perennial 20-20, up to a 30-30 candidate, hitting in the middle of the best offense in baseball.
I’m not saying he’s an early rounder, but if he were to drop several more rounds into the right range, I’d think about it.