On phone, “War Room, hello? How is your vacation going after draft season? You’re in Turks? Wow, very cool! Must be lovely there. I heard their beaches are beautiful. You heard that too, but your travel agent was actually using a shortened nickname for Turkey? Oh, well, I’m sure that’s nice too. You actually thought you were in a travel agency but you were in a Subway and you bought a turkey sandwich? Oh…But it worked out because you were famished? Well, I’m calling because I want to thank you for having me draft Mark Vientos in every league. With Juan Soto’s injury, Vientos now has everyday playing time. How’d you know Soto would be hurt? You didn’t but were ordering a soda?” So, one’s methods for getting Mark Vientos might not all be same, but I’d pick up Vientos now. His peripherals (small sample) look excellent, and, while Soto is out, it will hopefully give Vientos time to supplant Baty on the depth chart (or Jorge Polanco or Semien or any of these terrible hitters the Mets signed this offseason). “Oh, one last thing, War Room, is this why you told me to draft Jake Burger?” Anyway, here’s some more players to Buy or Sell this week in fantasy baseball:
PSYCHE! This post was released a week early for Patreon members. It will be released all year early for Patreons, so if people are getting a jump on you, it’s because they paid the $10. Anyway, the Fantasy Baseball Buy/Sell:
BUY
Daniel Susac – Likely more of an NL-Only pickup still, but he’s the only bright spot in the Giants’ lineup, as they collectively hit like it’s the Dead Ball Era, and their bats have been neutered. If you missed that pun, read it back to your male dog and watch as he crosses his legs.
Liam Hicks – I’d just want to say Liam Hicks isn’t actually bad with the bat. He’s not incredible, but not bad. Is he a superstar? No way! But he’s okay. Is he even the best catcher in Miami? No! He’s–Okay, I’ll stop trying to sell him, because it’s making him sound worse.
Dalton Rushing – A little hint on how to get a jump on your competish. First, and foremost, don’t ever say competish out loud, someone will have every right to punch you in your mouth for saying such a douchey word. Second, the 7-day Player Rater is up and running. You can see all the hot schmotatoes.
Josh Bell – More like Gosh A-Ring-Ding-Ding, as he was called by Sammy Davis Jr.
Jake Bauers – More like Make Sours, as he was known to Willy Wonka, okay, I’ll stop doing that now.
TJ Rumfield – I hope he never needs Tommy John surgery, but I would like to hear a conversation with the doctor’s receptionist if he ever checked in for TJ.
Jonathan India – Wonder if India can sneeze onto some of his teammates so they start hitting for power. Mostly talking about the Italian ones. Let’s think of it as a reimagining of the Marco Polo story, but instead of spices, it’s sneezes.
Max Muncy – The good Muncy! The NoCal Muncy! The no-snacks-after-breakfast-you’ll-ruin-your-lunchy Muncy!
Ramon Urias – Hot schmotato, yes, but also don’t look at how many homers the Cards have from their Gorman/Urias platoon compared to what you have from your 1st round draft pick named Juan Soto.
Angel Martinez – He had one big game this week to shoot up the 7-day Player Rater, which is more than quite a few of my 1st round draft picks.
Edouard Julien – I have Julien in quite a few leagues so I’m trying not to say this just because it benefits me and thus jinxes me, but he’s been hitting at the top of the 1927 Rockies’ lineup, which is good for value.
Nasim Nunez – Him stealing bags while being free in drafts was one of the most obvious oversights. Not quite as obvious as Chandler Simpson, but close. Chandler hits for average, which I told you repeatedly. He was not a one-category cat. Yes, this is mostly about Chandler Simpson in Nasim’s blurb, because there’s nothing to say about Nunez other than: Steals.
Brady House – In the minors, he had 60-grade power and 50-grade speed, and I loved him when he was promoted, so why did I and basically everyone forget about him in drafts? I’m not entirely sure, tee bee aitch. He will hit .230 at some point, but 25/10/.230? That doesn’t play? Rhetorical!
Cam Smith – Should be at 100% rostered by now, but he’s not, so here he is.
Jordan Walker – Gave you my Jordan Walker fantasy last week. It was written while caring for an elderly hamster. “He said he has cheese!” screaming into the elderly hamster’s ear.
Garrett Mitchell – Guys who I liked the most who were on the shortlist for the ledes this week: Mitchell, House and Vientos. I’d say Cam Smith, but he should just be rostered.
Jorge Soler – He’s been hot with the bat and in fiery machismo!
Richie Palacios – [building a sand castle with a giant shaft coming out of the ground] This is for Richie Palacios.
Troy Johnston – Hi, I’m Troy Johnston, and you might remember me from the preseason rankings where I was barely ranked in the top 500 with such statements by Grey as, “Is he really the 1st baseman? Will he play? Who the heck is Troy Johnston?” He’s likely nothing more than a bat to play in Coors, but Rockies are hitting him in the middle of the order and his last year in the minors produced 12/31 for Miami’s Triple-A team in only 314 ABs. Maybe he goes 20/20. Wouldn’t completely shock me.
German Marquez – This is a Streamonator call, like the call it makes to a delivery robot it just met.
Jameson Taillon – This is also a Streamonator call. “If you want, I can bring dinner over to your place. No, I’m not mocking your work.”
Didier Fuentes – Did, Dider, Didest, Didier! Stash now!
Bryan Baker – Seems excellent and could be the closer all year, and be one of the biggest pickups. Or not get another save for three weeks because: Kevin Cash.
Gregory Soto – Pirates’ manager LL Donkey is likely going to Dennis Santana for saves, but if a lefty-heavy 9th comes up, maybe Soto will get the save. I also am only 70% sure this is accurate. Soto might just get the Pirates saves.
Bryan King – Should just be the Astros’ closer until Hader returns, not from the future or from the past. Hader doesn’t have a time machine. Why would you think that? You read Ashcraft’s blurb first? C’mon, these are meant to be read in order.
Hogan Harris – Saw Mark Leiter Jr. was listed as Mark Leiter on CBS without the Jr. and I made an email address [email protected] and sent CBS an email cursing them out, and telling them to put some gee-dee respect on my name. Will let you know if they respond. A’s closer could be Hogan Harris or Mark Leiter Jr. (!) or no one worth rostering.
Jakob Junis – Pronouncing his name JAH-cobb to feel something.
Caleb Kilian – I don’t know who the Giants closer is. I want to say it’s Ryan Walker, but [shrugs]. Only thing that seems clear is Tonnato Vitello is in over his head and throwing Hail Marys two weeks into the season to make something work. Maybe he’s consulting with a space rock.
Graham Ashcraft – Looks like the first real big middle reliever breakout. Of course, it’s only, like, six innings, so who knows, middle reliever breakouts are shots in the dark for a few weeks, but he’s showing extra velocity and already was throwing high 90’s. He has an early K/9 that would’ve made a young Hader blush, if a young Hader had a time machine and went to the future and looked at Ashcraft’s K/9.
SELL
Pete Crow-Armstrong – Honestly, I still think it’s too soon to sell anyone. How do you know what a guy has with barely two weeks of a sample size? I don’t think you do. The first two weeks of Sells (Zack Wheeler, Mike Trout) were layups, because I don’t think you should be taking away a lot from, like, 12 games. I’ve barely even made any moves yet. Dropping guys in April is usually a good way to burn yourself in May. I’ve said this multiple times, and mostly ignored, so I’m just talking now for my own amusement. I’m still here, though. I could be researching stuff I care about, like how long a human can subsist on a sea monkey’s diet, but I’m not. I’m committed to you! So, this sell is also somewhat janky because I told you to avoid PCA in drafts, but if you did ignore me and want to make like a beaver and be damned, here’s your chance! I still don’t like PCA. I wouldn’t trade Pete Crow-Armstrong for a sentient doll that was evil, but I would go to the Fantasy Baseball Trade Analyzer and explore options.
12 team redraft H2H QS league
Would you trade Flaherty and Ranger for Shane Baz, Chad Patrick and Didier Fuentes
Yes
Thanks!
hi Grey. losing patience with heloit ( busch too but…) do you see marsh being a pickup for heloit or hold ? thanks have a good w/e/
Hold
thanks
No problem
Springs or Sheehan?
Sheehan hopefully
Would you add Rumfield or Mitchell for utility spot to replace Rooker?
TJ
It’s early but are you holding mcclanahan ? Would you rather grab fuentes or weathers? My concern is more about the rays letting mcclanahan pitch. He isn’t even going 5 innings. Qs league. Weathers is not exactly a guy i can bank on staying healthy though.
I’d go weathers
14 teams
with Rooker on the IL who to pickup
Bauers
DDLS
Angel Martinez
Soler
Palacios
Troy Johnston
Should I also pickup a second for Marte?
Soler as long as he’s playing, otherwise Troy at home, maybe Angel, might need to try different guys
Hey Grey, starting Merrick at Atlanta on Saturday? Thanks much.
Yes
12 team, 5×5 roto.
1) My last OF/UTIL is Lile and Happ. Would you add Ceddanne or Vientos over either?
2) The back end of my rotation is Early, Reynaldo, Taj and Weathers. Would you add Cantillo, Abbott or Didier over any?
1. Ceddanne over Lile 2. Taj or one of those is a matchups thing, wouldn’t make a move
Better pickups-
Thanks
Senga
Baker
Stott or Cole Young ?
Stott
In one league I have Soto, Chourio, and Rooker all on the IL. Substitutes at the moment are Adolis Garcia, Luis Robert, and Burleson. Would you add any of Soler, Josh Bell, or De Lauter in place of these guys? Thanks
Hold
Junk or Harris? Also is Jordan Beck worth keeping in Dynasty? Thanks as always!
Junk
Maybe in some leagues
Pretty deep league… I’ll hold, thanks!
No problem
Is 0-26 good? Asking for a friend from Chicago. Oh, I also have an amazing Phillies stack of Trea, Harper, Schwarber
phillies got shut out for the last 20 innings against the giants
Haha
Hey Grey
Thoughts on my Langford for his Gausman?
My OF + UTIL without Wyatt would be Yordan/Walker/Ward/Springer/Adell. Rotation is currently DeGrom/Bradish/Gray/Gore/Keller.
Thanks!
Wyatt side not close
Oh interesting ok, thanks! How about Wyatt for Fried? I’m guessing he’d reject that but worth a shot if you think it’s fair
Wyatt
Busch was dropped in my league. Definitely been ice cold but would you drop Manzardo for him? If so, I got 1000$ faab for the season how much should I throw on him? Thanks, I’m a cubs fan so I’m a little biased and think he turns it around.
$37
Howdy Grey!
Seeing your thoughts on a few adds
H2h pts weekly lock
Add Jorge soler (DH/OF). Or Owen caissie I’d drop Jackson Holliday
Add either
– Dansby swanson
– Jacob Wilson
– mark Vientos
* my drop would be story
For pitcher
Add
Bryan Woo, Mackenzie gore , clay holmes
I’d look to drop: tanner bibbee, Andrew painter , ranger suarez or lance mccullers
Thanks man!
Woo, Gore, Holmes over painter, ranger, Lance
Redraft, 10 team, standard 5×5 roto
1. Need to drop IL guy: Churio, Rooker, Hader, or Boyd. Has to be Boyd, right? (Even though Boyd probably will return the soonest.)
2. Please rank top 5 of: Langford(waivers), Bregman(waivers), Aranda(FA), DeLauter(mine), Griffin(mine), Moniak(mine).
3. Different league: Best OF FA-C. Smith, O’Hearn or Caissie?
Thanks.
1. Boyd 2 Wyatt, breg, Konnor, delauter 3. Cam
Add OF J. Duran(waivers) to question 2. Thanks.
I have Soderstrom, Vinnie, and Busch. I should probably be patient with Vinnie but what about Busch? Worth holding in a 12×12 and the options ahead of him or should I throw him back? Too early perhaps?
Hold
Aaron Boone strikes again. Rice is on the bench against a lefty; even though he’s hitting over .300, and is 1-2 with a triple against Matz. I don’t remember this many big-brain-manager lineups being such an established thing league-wide before. I mean, I’m a constant rosterbator in my RCLs, but I’m playing a game with no real stakes. He’s messing with his hottest hitter’s momentum–not to mention his career. Is it that these retired-players-turned-managers hate that they can’t grab a bat and join the fun, so they get off on moving players around like chess pieces? WTheactualF?
Haha, figured it was coming
Buying a guy who will miss 6 games in the near future is…well i hope your league doesn’t have a cap on moves…
Jorge Polanco or Max Muncy (ATH)?
Thought Polanco was going to be an RBI machine hitting 4th in the Mets lineup and playing everyday.
Bad start and now the Achilles soreness. Don’t know if he’s worth dropping for Muncy or not.
Muncy
Keep 10 Forever.
Would you drop any of Abel and/or Libby for
Springs, Roupp, Mize or Flaherty?
Hold
In dynasty would you rather have Anthony or Wood? I have Anthony and am pondering an offer straight up for Wood.
Wood
Hi Gray,
Who are you most confident will be relevant for the rest of the season out of the following? I listed eligibility in case it helps.
J. Bauers (1B, OF)
Kyle Isbel (OF)
Wiemer (OF)
E. Julien (1B, 2B)
C. Meidroth (2B, SS)
Nine? Julien
Acuna or T. Turner and J. Wood. Leaning Acuna. It’s a SS upgrade over current J. Wilson.
Hold
In a 12 team roto auction keeper league, my possible drops are Beavers $10, Ramos $2,McClanahan $2 and Burrows $2. Would you drop one to stash Didier at $10 or hold? Who is the drop? Thanks!
Beavers
its crazy how bad hitting has been. I thought it’s my team, then I look at every other matchup in my league and it’s the same thing. My OF is Greene, Tatis and Tucker. 1 homer between them. Only hitter I’ve dropped is Durbin, to pick up Willie Castro for Rocks home weeks. Walks are up, K’s are up, it’s been cold, whatever is going on Josh Bell has the vaccine, but he’s not sharing.
I have a 12 team league where most teams have three or fewer homers
Sorry, for this week I mean
Still!
What’s up Grey?
Do you think any of these guys are worth speculating on as closers in leagues where you have to pay $5 for a waiver claim? For context, I already have Munoz, Erceg, Hader, G. Jax, Sands, and Taylor Rogers (we start 3 RPs). It’s a deep league as you can see.
G. Ashcraft
Bryan King
Santillan
H. Harris
Hold
Can start 1
Ranger @ STL
Sasaki vs TEX
Ashcraft @ChC
Scherzer vs Min
Thanks!
Or Taillon from above
None? I guess Scherzer
Yeah, I feel the same. May not stream this weekend. Thanks again!
No problem
Hey Grey,
What order would you prioritize any of these guys for picking up? Several have two starts next week, but I’m thinking more about who we think can also be good for an extended period.
Joey Cantillo (STL, BAL)
Jeffrey Springs (TEX, CHW)
Randy Vazquez (SEA)
Matthew Liberatore (CLE, @HOU)
Chad Patrick (TOR)
David Peterson (@LAD, @CHC)
Landon Roupp (@CIN)
Cantillo, Randy
Need an outfielder to fill in for Rooker. I have Canzone but he hasn’t done much since opening day. Would you pick up Troy Johnston or stick with Canzone?
Try Troy
Bobby Witt has scored one run!!!!
Carrying my offense!
Maybe be can lead the league in steals and go 50/30/30/30. That 50 sb, 30 hr, 30 rbi, 30 runs
Hahaha
Lyle or T. Johnson?
Have a great weekend!
Troy since I don’t know who the other person is
I don’t blame you. Lile on the Nats. Sorry…..
Meh I’d go Troy
Great stuff, Grey! I always look forward to the Buy/Sell. I also love how the Buy is always a hundred guys and the Sell is always one lonely player with bad peripherals.
You’re so right about “dropping guys in April.” I can see myself at the end of this season telling people about how I had league-winner Jordan Walker on my teams for a couple of games at the beginning of April… yet dropped him after a couple of subpar games. Sure, someone else got 35 home runs, but I saved myself from four strikeouts.
Today’s a big day for me. Kevin Cash is FINALLY using the lineup I’ve been screaming for all season–Chandler Simpson leading off, followed by Caminero, Aranda and Yandy. Fingers crossed this goes well or Cash Money will think he was right to continually bury Junior behind the likes of Fraley and Mullins.
Have a great weekend!
Ha, yup!
Weird question but disregarding position eligibility, who would you drop out of Garret Mitchell, Moniak, and Liam Hicks?
Thanks as always and I hope Jordan Walker nets you many hoebaggers.
Hicks…haha
Quick follow-up since Ben Rice is actually platooning as expected…Moniak or Mitchell?
Moniak
Happy Friday Grey the White!
Love the list! Although, I got a head start on it Wednesday! ;)
At what point, in roto, do you look at the categories in your standings decide it’s time to address some weaknesses. Obviously, not making irrational decisions on players off to slow starts, but is it time to address low power numbers? Or low AVG?
Thank you!
Maybe end of April
Time to grab Max Clark? I don’t feel Perez is going to occupy a spot all that long, with the offense generally struggling. But does Clark have enough pop in his bat to be worth it?
Sure
My Buxton or his Nolan McLean?
Works for me
Super Fantasy Lothario Master, Grey-son,
I thought he was in Turkey too. Thank you for taking us down that rabbit hole. At least someone was fed and not fed up with some of the 1st round picks.
Who’s the drop to stash Sir Didier-est:
Early, Hancock or Cameron?
Hope you had a great lunch, you know that’s purely selfishness. Your long tenure here is looked forward to, thank you.
CCC
Haha, thanks! Hancock
Hey Sport:),
What do you think of this possible trade?
Kurtz/Schlittler for Jazz, but my 1B would be J Naylor.
Kurtz side, not close
After I entered in the “trade analyzer”, I realized that, thank you for confirming, have a great weekend.
No problem
Shota has a no-no thru 6… With 9 K’s… And 100 Pitches.
What are the odds that we will see a 9-inning, single pitcher no-hitter this year?
Sandy is only one I’d bet on
If Miz could go 9…maybe in a couple years lol
Haha
Shota has a no hitter through 6, and I have no fear of jinxing him. He has thrown 100 pitches. Wonder if he even comes back out for the 7th. It’s a scoreless game
Nice jinx! Kidding, I don’t believe in jinxes…here’s to Bobby Witt Jr having zero home runs all year
Ha! At least he made it to 6 IP and got my QS. No W for Shota today.
Haha
mlod squad! little whippy no ks and of course no run support. i swear i could make a fortune betting the under on runs scored by teams i have a pitcher starting for.
also if you can bet live lines, my pitcher just left inherited runners. relievers who follow my starters have a 0% strand rate
Haha
Same!
Good news for you Steve. Pirates pulled Mlod when PCA came to the plate, so of course Pete bailed you out. Sell! Sell! Sell! :)
Haha
i saw that. the old opposite reverse jinx paid off
Not sure where it went…. Here goes again
1) power outage. I was offered DeLauter for Mikel. I have plenty of of speed
2) I have lots of outfielders. Who drops to stash Didier: Marsee or Lile
Great stuff
Answered
1) Santana, Soto, King, Junis, Baker… Please rank for save-only 5×5 league.
2) 2-start starters for next week…
Keller vWSH, vTB
Cantillo @STL, vBAL
Hancock @SD, vATL
Lowder vSF, @TB
Meyer @ATL, vSTL
Weathers vLAA, vKC
Boyle @CHW, vCIN
Please rank top 4.
3) Have a great weekend.
1. Baker, Santana, Juno’s 2. Weathers, Keller, Cantillo, Hancock
Trade Michael King & Soderstrom for Vinnie P. and Eovaldi?
Sure
1) As recently mentioned, I need some power… I was offered DeLauter for Garcia? I have enough speed to cover.
2) Also have Soderstrom, Simpson, Cags, Marsee and Lile for OF and was thinking to drop one to stash Didier
1. Meh 2. Lose lile
Who would you drop for Hogan Harris? Bryan King, Bryan Abreu, or Abner Uribe?
Abreu
Would you offer Acuna and Grant Holmes
to get Jordan Walker and Chase Burns from another manager?
Thanks!!
No
Thanks!
No problem
😬
Lol
Drop Ranger Suarez?
For?
Hogan Harris. Related to my question above about who to drop for Harris. Still Bryan Abreu, or Ranger Suarez?
Hold
Thanks
No problem
Holds separate category
Drop Jax for Ashcraft
Yes
Master Lothario are we starting soroka at Philly? Need to keep whip low
Yes
philly is scary because they’ve been lousy and one day they won’t be and feels like any day could be the day.
sell pca! sell sell sell! i welcome your negative ratings points razzball commentarians.
is that how long a human could live on a diet consisting of sea monkeys or a diet consisting of the foods consumed by sea monkeys?
Foods consumed by sea monkeys naturally
loving the 1927 Rockies meme-let. meet you at the rock pile.
It’s rocktober—Aprickies!
everyime you say rocktober i hear it in dane cook’s voice
Haha
I might be there on the 18th.
Tell em Steve
Alright OaktownSteve, I will bite. Why are we selling PCA so quickly? You commented earlier today that the temps are impacting teams playing games in the cold weather. Cubs have been @Was, Wrigley, @Cle, Wrigle. This week we did finally get to Tampa for some warm weather, and what do you know he finally hits a HR. Let’s stay consistent with this cold weather theory.
Plus I am a huge Cubs homer, so I am not a fan of you guys Schmohawking my CF.
i wouldn’t sell him. i just can’t stand him.
Haha
would you drop
H.Kim, Canzone, Varsho, Durbin, or N. Marte 4 Garrett Mitchell?
Kim
10-Tm , NL-Only H2H 5×5 (OBP) w/ OBP
$280 Auction (5 Keepers)
CA Hererra (7)
1B Devers (34)
2B Wetherholt (23)
3B Baty (4)
SS Swanson (12)
INF Stewart (18)
OF Carroll (37), Griffin (22), Yaz (3), Caissie (1)
Util AgRam (9)
B Nuñez (1)
IL Chourio (27)
SP Peralta (21), Cabrera (10), Holmes (10), Nelson (4), Patrick (7), Williamson (1), Roupp (1), Griffin, Junk
RP – Diaz (22), Ginkel (1), Kilian
IL – Jones
I love having Carroll, Chourio, Griffin, Wetherholt and Steward to build around for the next few years. Howsever, Carroll and Chourio will increas about $5 each taking me up to about $140 next year going into the draft. Would it be worth trading one of JJ/Griffin/Chourio along with one of Nelson/Patrick to get more Power/OBP and and Saves to help me out in H2H this year? If so, who would you move?
Depends what you’re getting, doesn’t it?
A) True about who I get. I really should have just asked which of the 3 between Chourio/JJ/Griffen would you part with first? My gut is Chourio since he only has OF Eligibility and this is an OBP league. I was hoping to get something good for him now that can help me over the couple of weeks rather than doing nothing on the IL.
I guess it’s just wait and see since it’s so early and it’s possible that Kilian gets to see S opportunities sooner taking away the need for a CL.
B) Am I okay cutting Ginkel for Julien? Can never have too many MI options, especially with Baty gaining OF eligibility in a few days for my league.
Thank you!
A. JJ B. Sure
Should I drop Royce Lewis or Luis Garcia Jr. for Vientos?
Vientos
wait I mean which would you drop to add Vientos? Thanks!
Oh, ha, sorry…Garcia
You prefer Liam Hicks or Francisco Alvarez?
Alva
Thank you!
No problem
Are you dropping Colt Keith or Okamoto for Vientos?
Keith