LOGIN

Hope everyone had a great Memorial Day! Let’s honor our vets by looking at the way vet pitchers adapt despite their best selves no longer shiny and new. I’m reminded of Justin Verlander. Not this year’s Verlander. That guy is just old and dusty. I’m reminded of Verlander under Dusty. When he looked gassed and disillusioned coming off terrible years on the Tigers. Would he become a shell of himself and quit the game to do marginal podcasts using his name that he once made famous and interrupt his brother’s business model? Or would he reinvent himself? And like John Travolta in Pulp Fiction, the reinvention was under way. Now, Kevin Gausman (8 IP, 1 ER, 5 hits, zero walks, 6 Ks, ERA at 3.68) walks a similar path. No longer does he possess his best stuff, but his pinpoint command has made it so he’s been remarkably valuable, even without huge Ks. Then, you have Jacob deGrom and whatever the hell that was. He went 5 1/3 IP, 2 ER, 7 baserunners, zero Ks, ERA at 2.42. Elias Sports Bureau said, “This is the first time deGrom in 229 starts that he did not strikeout someone, we think. The caveat ‘we think’ is because Owen spilled Orange Drink on our hard drive, and we saw this factoid on Google and that’s not as trustworthy as it was.” A tale of two vet pitchers and one who might need the vet. Anyway, here’s what else I saw yesterday in fantasy baseball:

Kumar Rocker – Bruce Bochy said he’s considering using Rocker as his closer when he returns. Bochy then pushed a handkerchief into his right ear and pulled it out of his left ear. Nah, for reals, when I see a guy with a 8.10 ERA, my first thought is, “Closer.” I guess Rocker does have the “failed starter” thing going for him.

Wyatt Langford – 1-for-4 and his 10th homer, hitting .244. Fun fact! The opposite of “Why not” is Wyatt.

Daulton Varsho – 3-for-4 and his 8th homer, hitting .221, as he hits third. That’s eight homers in 20 games. If he played 162 games, he’s going to hit 80 homers. “I’m at a Memorial Day BBQ, where I’m prorated to eat 15 hot dogs, after eating 1.5 in an hour, since I’m expecting to stay here for ten hours, so I don’t have time to check your math, but Varsho hitting 80 homers, sounds wrong.” That’s Mr. Prorater.

Gavin Williams – 4 2/3 IP, 4 ER, 10 baserunners (6 BBs), 3 Ks, ERA at 4.27. Wasn’t a good start vs. the Dodgers, but on the other hand, I didn’t expect it would be.

Shohei Ohtani – 1-for-3, 3 runs and his 19th homer, hitting .295. Shame the shoulder surgery is hindering him. Would be cool if he already had 40+ homers.

Will Smith – 2-for-3, 2 runs and his 5th homer, hitting .333. So wild how different of a game Ohtani is playing. Will Smith? Not a bad hitter, has five homers; Ohtani 19. Wild.

Yoshinobu Yamamoto – 6 IP, 2 ER, 5 baserunners, 7 Ks, ERA at 1.97. Yah ‘moto be there!

Jonathan Aranda – 2-for-4, 2 runs, 3 RBIs and his 7th homer, hitting .302. Has cooled off a bit in the last two weeks, hitting .176 in the last week and .222 in the last two weeks, prior to yesterday. His BABIP is still inflated (.380) so he is likely to come down a bit still, and he gives no speed whatsoever.

Danny Jansen – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 4th homer, 2nd homer in a week. Welp, roughly eight days ago wasn’t a great time for me to drop him.

Zack Littell – 6 1/3 IP, 1 ER, 3 hits, zero walks, 4 Ks, ERA at 3.97. Solid strikeout game for him, since he has a 5.8 K/9. A five point eight strikeout per nine? Is he Bill Gullickson? Hey, man, are you Rick Rhoden?

Chris Paddack – 5 1/3 IP, 2 ER, 5 hits, zero walks, 5 Ks, ERA at 3.92. His peripherals are The Worst I’ve Seen From A Guy With A Sub-4 ERA, which is a bit unfortunate.

Carlos Correa – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 4th homer, hitting .238. Solid stats if this were April 3rd. Not bad if this were April 13th. Bit troubling if this were April 23rd. Droppable if this were the 1st week of May.

Derek Hill – Hit the IL, and the Marlins called up Victor Mesa Jr. aka the Kiddie Table. KT has speed and likely no playing time, except for the crayons provided by the waitress to color the placemat.

Jesus Sanchez – 2-for-4, 2 runs and his 3rd homer, hitting .231, and leadoff. What’s kinda interesting, Sanchez has four steals in May and was caught last night. If he wants to steal 20 bags, that’s interesting.

Ryan Weathers – 5 2/3 IP, 0 ER, 6 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 1.15. Should be at 100% rostered. Can’t say it much clearer.

Manny Machado – 1-for-4 and his 6th homer, 2nd homer in two games, 3rd in four games, hitting .319. Macho macho Machado!

Randy Vasquez – 6 1/3 IP, 3 ER, 7 baserunners, 5 Ks, ERA at 3.58. His peripherals are The Worst I’ve Seen From A Guy With A Sub-4 ERA Much Worse Than Paddack, which is also unfortunate.

Andrew Heaney – 5 IP, 5 ER, ERA at 3.41. I only start Heaney when he has a two-start week, so if he’s pitching on Monday, I’m starting him. I might need to reevaluate.

Eugenio Suarez – 1-for-3, 2 runs and his 15th homer. 35 homers since last All-Star Break; Bobby Witt Jr. has 21.

Ryne Nelson – 6 2/3 IP, 0 ER, 4 hits, zero walks, 4 Ks, ERA at 3.79. Tried to grab Nelson in every league this past week for this two-start week, but he’s also got some nice numbers cooking under the hood — 8.1 K/9, 2.6 BB/9, 3.37 xFIP. Bit more of a monocle than a grab in the shallowest of leagues, but I could see 12-teamers and deeper grabbing now.

Josh Naylor – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 6th homer, hitting .287. Can we take the humidors out of stadiums now? I’m gonna run on the campaign promise, “Let’s try dry air again.”

Adrian Houser – 6 IP, 0 ER, 4 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 0.00. “Hello, is this Orel Hershiser? Well, guess what buddy? Guess what the eff is up? Your consecutive scoreless inning record! It’s going down! This is Adrian Houser’s fantasy owner, that’s who?! Uh, 12 innings scoreless so far. Hello? Hello, are you still there?” Hmm, seems he hung up. Hold on, I’m gonna call him back. “Hello, is this Orel Hershiser? Guess what dipshit–Hello?” Hmm.

Clay Holmes – 5 2/3 IP, 1 ER, 7 baserunners, 3 Ks, ERA at 2.98. Clay Holmes as starter > Mariano Rivera as starter.

Michael Lorenzen – 5 IP, 6 ER, ERA at 4.33. Feel like when a guy has a good matchup and screws us, it’s because he personally hates us. I don’t think I did anything to him, but I know one of you did. Fess up now! You betrayed us! Step forward and accept your punishment!

Salvador Perez – 1-for-3, 2 RBIs and his 4th homer, hitting .226. Think someone found the painting of his younger knees in his attic and destroyed it.

Tyler Stephenson – 3-for-5, 3 RBIs and his 2nd homer, hitting .209. When you forget a guy plays baseball still, it’s not a good sign. He could get hot, but to say he’s been bad is insulting to ‘bad.’ Apologize to ‘bad’ right now.

Nick Martinez – 7 IP, 3 ER, 6 hits, zero walks, 2 Ks, ERA at 3.48. If you started him for a two-start week, one down, and the next one is going to be–Well, can you wish an IL stint on Martinez before his next start?

Pedro Pages – 1-for-3, 2 RBIs and his 4th homer, 2nd homer in five games. Between Herrera and Pages, the Contreras brothers, and whatever it is the Cubs are feeding their catchers, the NL Central has some productive catchers.

Erick Fedde – 5 IP, 3 ER, 8 baserunners, 5 Ks, ERA at 3.90 vs. Charlie Morton – 6 IP, 2 ER, 6 baserunners, 5 Ks, ERA at 7.09. This matchup was billed as, “Fedde/Usually whopped.”

Dylan Carlson – 2-for-4, 2 runs, 3 RBIs and a slam (2) and legs (1), 2nd homer in two games. Hot schmotato alert!

Porter Hodge – On the IL with an oblique injury, and Cubs said he’s currently in a holding pattern. Him and Nathan Fielder in The Rehearsal season 2. If you haven’t watched this, please begin immediately. You don’t need to watch the 1st season — you should, don’t get me wrong — but you can skip right to second season and have your mind blown.

Jameson Taillon – 6 1/3 IP, 1 ER, 4 hits, zero walks, 7 Ks, ERA at 3.86. The number on the Streamonator for Taillon’s call was $64.40. That might be the highest I’ve ever seen for a fairly meh starter. Facing the Suckies in a road game is the ideal matchup.

Mickey Moniak – 1-for-3 and his 5th homer, and 2nd homer in two games. In the land of Sammy Sosa’s corked bats, someone uncorked Moniak’s schmotato.

Orlando Arcia – Signed with the Rockies because Thairo Estrada was last seen on a milk carton in the Boulder, Colorado area. Anyone who knows the whereabouts of Thairo Estrada, please contact the authorities. The Suckies signing Arcia reminds me of the Angels signing guys no one else wants. Speaking of which…

Chris Taylor – 0-for-3, hitting .184, as he played center field after signing with the Angels. As I just said yesterday when they signed Oscar Colas, they’re named the Angels, but do they have to claim everyone who is left for dead? Angels peruse the DFAs of other teams like an antiquer who specializes in cuckoo clocks because it reminds them they’re mentally ill.

Zach Neto – 1-for-4 and his 9th homer, 2nd homer in a week. I’m brucely still in shock they signed Chris Taylor and started him immediately. Like he’s good.

Ryan Yarbrough – 6 IP, 1 ER, 3 baserunners, 7 Ks, ERA at 3.96. Welp, I have to look at what is going on here, huh? [opens his player page, eyes fall out of head in shock] Hey, anyone see my eyes? I saw Yarbough had a 8.9 K/9, 2.8 BB/9 and 3.74 xFIP and I lost my eyes. He gets Dodger Stadium next, which is a no-can-do, but I have to monocle, right after I locate my eyes.

Hayden Birdsong – 4 1/3 IP, 3 ER, ERA at 2.48. He’s not quite as good as his current ERA, but no one is, except maybe Skubal. Birdsong should have solid Ks, solid command, solid tunes if you’re a mockingbird. Clearly, yesterday wasn’t the best of days, but we persist.

Keider Montero – 5 IP, 0 ER, 1 hit, 2 walks, 3 Ks, ERA at 4.54. Would’ve been a nice stream, Streamonator hates his next one, and I don’t blame the robot.

Garrett Crochet – 6 2/3 IP, 2 ER, 7 baserunners, 11 Ks, ERA at 2.04. When I see 11 or more strikeouts — not 10, but 11 or more — I think, “That guy is an ace.” It can be Miles Mikolas or Crochet. If it’s Mikolas, then I stop thinking it, but it momentarily crosses my mind because there’s so few instances of 11 or more Ks. I might be miscounting, but I think it’s happened only 25 times this year (Vin will know for sure in the comments).

Jackson Chourio – 1-for-4 and his 8th homer, hitting .246. Been a bit of a disappointment so far this year, but through this time last year he was hitting .211 with five homers, and you drafted him this year for a reason, i.e., BUY!

Logan Henderson – Optioned to the minors. [sobs into a mirror as I smear lipstick up the sides of my lips, making a ghoulish smile] Brewers’ beat writer said, “DL Hall is up for his season debut after a lat injury. He joins Aaron Ashby as a multi-inning option out of the bullpen. Pat Murphy said they want to keep Logan Henderson preserved and on schedule as they anticipate the returns of Quintana and Woodruff.” And I said, sure, whatever you say, Pat Murphy, you Bourbon Street-sounding bar.

Chad Patrick – 4 2/3 IP, 0 ER, 6 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 2.97. I just made up a guy in my head that would pass Cy Young for most wins in MLB history. Comes in after a starter goes 4 2/3 IP in every game, and throws to one hitter. DL Hall (2 1/3, 1 ER, ERA at 3.86, and the WIN!) you can win 512 wins! In all seriousness (as if this is serious), if you were to designate a guy The Win Guy, and he only comes in at 4 2/3 IP in a winning game, he’d get to about 300 wins and MLB would suddenly see the stupidity of giving a guy the win for pitching to one batter. Sure, it would take 10 years of a guy winning 30 games a year, and ten-straight Cy Youngs, but eventually MLB will change the win. This is also the beginning of my Petition dot org titled Change The Win.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

253 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Flying High
Flying High
1 hour ago

How are you ranking these 2 start options for next week:

Max Meyer COL,TB
Brady Singer MILW,ARI
Shane Smith DET,KC
All are home games.
Thanks!

Dbreezyy
Dbreezyy
1 hour ago

Wynn or Marcelo?

SteveNZ
1 hour ago

Starting to feel slightly squeamish about my decision to trust the SON’s 60 rating for a QS from Severino @HOU tomorrow…

Matt
Matt
2 hours ago

Hey Grey! I think I know your answer to this but I’ll ask anyway.

10 team categories keep 4 up to 3 times. Try my Vlad (unkeepable) for their Soto (keep once round 1) or meh?

SteveNZ
2 hours ago

Uh-eovaldi…

Michael
Michael
4 hours ago

Who do you think I should bench today? (I have to bench one, 10-team h2h catagories league)

1. Wyatt Langford (vs Toronto Bowden Francis)
2. Cody Bellinger ( vs angels Tyler Anderson)
3. Vlad Guerrero jr. (Vs rangers Nathan Eovaldi)
4.james Wood (vs mariners Logan evans)

Norman Ginsberg
Norman Ginsberg
4 hours ago

Is Westburg ensured playing time when he’s ready. Both Arias (3B) and Holliday (2B) are playing well.

rhodyballer
rhodyballer
5 hours ago

Westburg or Luis Garcia Jr?

herschel
herschel
5 hours ago

was there any doubt orlando arcia would sign with the rockies?

Cohen
Cohen
5 hours ago

Please pick the one u prefer?
Mikolas at Baltimore
Roupp at Detroit
C.Schimdt at Angels
Jobe home vs SF
Cameron home vs Cincy

The Wild Card
The Wild Card
5 hours ago

Who’s the pickup with Kurtz going on th IL? Salvy Perez, Vargas, schanuel, Yandy or steer

The Wild Card
The Wild Card
Reply to  Grey
5 hours ago

thanks, Was kinda thinking salvy. Gonna see how those two hit tonight

SteveNZ
Reply to  Grey
5 hours ago

In the same way that Cal Raleigh is eating up?

SteveNZ
Reply to  Grey
5 hours ago

To be fair, I think being, ahem, broad in the beam, is probably pretty useful for a catcher.

Harry Reid
Harry Reid
6 hours ago

12 team, 6×6, holds. Best holds candidate:
Slaten, Uceta, Pierce Johnson, Lieter, Uceta, Manuel Rodriguez. Thanks

Yankee My Wanky!
Yankee My Wanky!
7 hours ago

Hello Grey and happy belated Memorial Day! Very good stuff as usual.

So in our Yahoo 10 Team H2H Points League, the first place team wants to trade me his JulRod and Vientos for my Vlad Jr. we like?

And for context, my shite bag team is in last place, so it probably doesn’t matter much.

Thanks Grey.

ROTO OVERLORD
ROTO OVERLORD
7 hours ago

When is Jac Cag getting the call? Would you drop a guy like stowers for him?

southpaw004
southpaw004
7 hours ago

12tm OBP – looking to replace Bregman’s absense at the hot corner. I’ve plugged in Cam Smith and Norby as waiver fillers.

Thoughts on trading Riley Greene for Isaac Paredes?
I have Teoscar/Ward/Soto/Soderstrom to round out my OF options
Waiver options like Friedl/Pages/Frelick/Carpenter/Springer/Mullins

Jah
Jah
7 hours ago

Are you staring Ranger Suarez today vs ATL?

Braves233
Braves233
7 hours ago

best pickup for Wednesday?
Roupp at tigers
bello at brewers
mikolas at orioles
lauer at rangers
schmidt at angels

Dirt McGirt
Dirt McGirt
7 hours ago

In a 16 team dynasty OPS league, would you be looking to buy, sell or hold Soto? Same for Austin Riley

Dirt McGirt
Dirt McGirt
Reply to  Grey
7 hours ago

Riley for Pete Alonso?

Dirt McGirt
Dirt McGirt
Reply to  Grey
6 hours ago

Thanks

toolshed
8 hours ago

So Megill has the White Sux tonight. Do I start him in a 10 team league witu qs? His problem is efficiency and walks. Horton is another one who is in a good spot vs Col, but he also can’t find the plate. These two look great on paper, but could ruin it. Who do you like more tonight? Thanks

Last edited 8 hours ago by toolshed
200 Proof
200 Proof
8 hours ago

Grey,

Thanks again for all you do!

  1. Who’s the drop between Baz, Eflin, Z Matthews, or Kirby?
  2. Keep waiting for Doyle to turn it around or pick up someone like J Pena, C Santana, B Lowe, G Sheets, or R O’Hearn?
  3. Already have a bench bat (don’t usually like them) but will have 2 when Buxton gets healthy. Adames or Buxton droppable or should I hold on to both of them because someone always seems to get hurt?

Thanks!

Joe Beisbol
Joe Beisbol
8 hours ago

Would you drop any of Burger, C.Holmes, or Perdomo for Weathers?

martinrostoker
8 hours ago

Good Morning. Grey,

1. At 2B: I have Brendon Lowe and Gleyber Torres. Would you waive one to get Gavin Williams? IF yes, who would you cut to get Williams?

2. Would you try and trade Rice and Baz to get Christopher Sanchez?

3. Would you start or sit Baz at Houston?

Thanks!!

Thank you!!

martinrostoker
Reply to  Grey
8 hours ago

Thank you so much!!!

Pauly bag of donuts
Pauly bag of donuts
8 hours ago

How about for 5 2/3 innings, maybe another Wet Dream or you got Blue Balled

foxman
foxman
Reply to  Grey
7 hours ago

How could it be called blue balled if these dudes were yanked too soon?

Mario
Mario
9 hours ago

Grey whats up chief?

Seems like you’re not in on pfaadt anymore. Is he more of a streamer in a 10 team league?
Who’s your guess fo closer on the rangers?

The Wild Card
The Wild Card
9 hours ago

need to drop one hitter and one pitcher to activate lugo and ragans this weekend.

moore, freidl, or vientos

springs or gavin williams

Homering Homers
Homering Homers
9 hours ago

I hate to ask, but are we playing safe and not starting Strider against Philly today? His start hurt me ratios pretty bad and maybe that’s my fault. Fool me again?

Homering Homers
Homering Homers
Reply to  Grey
8 hours ago

Yeah, maybe missing the good start hurts more than getting hit with a bad start. I’ll find out. Thanks :)

JohnnyToss
JohnnyToss
9 hours ago

Sheets, France or Busch for a plug and play 1B while Kurtz is out? Thank you!

leon
leon
9 hours ago

torkelson or westburg moving forward. both healthy 15 man

leon
leon
Reply to  Grey
9 hours ago

Oh really. i didnt expect that. Westburg was injured for a while, is it a coinflip?

J C
J C
9 hours ago

Please rank these under-performers for best chance to regain form please:
Altuve, Reynolds, Santander

Jeff
Jeff
10 hours ago

Who would you go with for a QS
Grant Holmes vs. BOS
Wacha vs. DET

Norman Ginsberg
Norman Ginsberg
10 hours ago

Albies or Westburg (when activated)?

Jason
Jason
10 hours ago

In a vaccuum – Semien vs. Aranda ROS in a pts lg

Norman Ginsberg
Norman Ginsberg
10 hours ago

2B: Albies or Holliday?

herschel
herschel
10 hours ago

@Grey: weekly roto. no word yet if kurtz is playing this week, but if he is, who do you like between kurtz and c walker?

walker – 2 vs a’s, 4 vs tb
kurtz – 2 @ hou, 4 @ tor

thanks!

Chucky
Chucky
Reply to  Grey
8 hours ago

10 day IL

Ant p
Ant p
10 hours ago

Sorry for Looooong winded ..
But in serious roster advice.

Very competive 13 team 5×5 roto keeper($260 auction with $5 raises after 3rd yr kept)
Unlimited IL, 1 minor 5 bench
Current roster
C- William conteras($1)
1b-W.Flores($2)
2b-Stott($9)
SS-M.Wynn ($5)
Mi-j.Polanco($2)
3b-J-caminero (8$)
Ci-D.moore ($1)
5 Of- Acuna($44),T Hernandez($33),R.Greene($9 raises coming next year),H.Ramos($2),J.Merril($9)
2 ut- Ozuna,($2 due for raise), M harris($2)

7sp Boyd($2),T.Bradley($2),M.Keller($9)
Kirby,($17),F.Valdez ($17),Z Eflin,W.Buehler($9l,Zebby($2)
2 Rp-N.martinez,Birdsong

And NOW my IL
Cole/Jones out for yr
Logan Gilbet/S.Mclanhan ($5 each)
M.King($17)

Bench M.Mayer,walcott,J.deluca

im in 11th place, up from last ..

We obviously punted saves, 2 teams kept 9 closers…

2nd in hitting,
Last in pitching (9pts)
Thoughts!!!

Sport
Sport
10 hours ago

Grey the White!

Thanks for all the write ups as usual. I refer to them and the comment section often!

You like Springs pitching in Toronto on Thursday?

Larry
Larry
10 hours ago

Would you drop Pfaadt to pick up Roupp?

jcindaville
jcindaville
10 hours ago

Good afternoon Grey!

Which one of these is a drop to add Ryan Weathers? Or do I hold?

N Pivetta
T Gonsolin
M Kelly
L Castillio
Will Warren
Z Elfin
T Mahle

as always, thank you for your opinions!

Todd Time
Todd Time
10 hours ago

Grey my OFers are:

-PCA
-Kyle Tucker
-Acuna Jr.
-Heliot Ramos
-Andy Pages

That seems good.

Todd Time
Todd Time
Reply to  Grey
10 hours ago

It Todd Time

-Todd Time

Shift Is Banned
Shift Is Banned
10 hours ago

Hey Grey. Your opinion on Framber or Pivetta in a 6×6 roto ( QS & W)?

John Starks
John Starks
11 hours ago

Warren or Lugo

benjaminred
benjaminred
11 hours ago

Good morning! You believe in Barger for 12 team mixed? Everything underneath is lovely, but results meh so far. Would you rather have him or Wallner?

Last edited 10 hours ago by benjaminred
simonsays1096@gmail.com
11 hours ago

Suarez V ATL or Pepiot @ HOU?

Keegan Aikan
Keegan Aikan
11 hours ago

Sal P or Herrera/Pfaadt ?

DeeJay
DeeJay
11 hours ago

7×7 Roto 12 teamer (AVG, OPS, K), keeper league
Someone just dropped Rice (8th rounder).

Potential cuts are Happ (13th) or A Ramirez (8th). Laaning towards Happ as the cut. I have enough depth to plug Rice in when he starts and bench on his off days. Worth it?

Steve
Steve
11 hours ago

Grey, what’s your favorite color? Not a trick question…

Gary C
11 hours ago

ESPN points, ROS only…please rank, position not relevant:

Westburg
Jung
Norby
Christian Walker

Thanks

Gary C
Reply to  Grey
11 hours ago

Thanks! what about Jung vs Norby?

Gary C
11 hours ago

ESPN points, deep league, have room for IL stash…thoughts on Kyle Bradish? (most others are taken)

uncle ernie
uncle ernie
11 hours ago

Keeper question $3 Chourio or $14 Vlads.

Joe Beisbol
Joe Beisbol
11 hours ago

We trusting Schmidt tomorrow @LAA in 12-teamers?

aardvark
aardvark
11 hours ago

Baty or durbin?

Ben
Ben
11 hours ago

Is Maikel Garcia a top 75 guy for next year? Top 100? A guy in my keeper league is selling and I am debating whether to throw in an offer. Thanks!

Chucky
Chucky
12 hours ago

Points redraft. Augustin or Carlos Narvaez?

Mangs
12 hours ago

Bot is down….FYI

3umgv3
Freedminds
Freedminds
12 hours ago

Chourio or Acuna Grey?

Little Jerry Seinfeld
Little Jerry Seinfeld
Reply to  Grey
11 hours ago

Grey is this just an injury concern that led to this answer or is Jackson just better?

FMFU
FMFU
12 hours ago

Eovaldi or Pablo ROS ?

Frank Rizzo
Frank Rizzo
12 hours ago

Is Kumar something to consider? Could he get a shot at closing or is it just kind of a joke?

Spencer
Spencer
12 hours ago

Spencer Steer was dropped to waivers, do I drop any of these players to add him?:

Luis Garcia jr
Doyle
Willi Castro

If so how much faab would you spend on him?

los locos
los locos
12 hours ago

Closer – Vest or J Martinez?

southpaw004
southpaw004
13 hours ago

Hope you enjoyed the long weekend! Always feels tougher coming back than it does waiting for Friday.

  1. Can you rank these 3 as bench bats in 12 team H2H OBP w/ base categories + std 5×5
  2. Ivan Herrera (Have Will Smith, so feels like the obvious cut but I like his production & fill-in when Smith sits)
  3. Taylor Ward
  4. TJ Friedl (Ranked 50 in our league)
  5. Are you holding Bryce Miller or should I cut bait for someone like Rasmussen?

Thanks!

FinsterGrinster
FinsterGrinster
13 hours ago

Good Morning Grey,

I currently have Hodge in my IL and roster Palencia in an NL-Only. With King going on the IL, Hodge is okay to drop, right?

FinsterGrinster
FinsterGrinster
Reply to  FinsterGrinster
12 hours ago

I went ahead and dropped Hodge for Kolek.

Frank Rizzo
Frank Rizzo
13 hours ago

Is Albies still the better play over Altuve ROS? Ozzie being moved down to 7th in the order is discouraging

Pwncomet
Pwncomet
Reply to  Frank Rizzo
11 hours ago

Albies has been coming around (11 game hit streak) and his year long stats stack up to Altuve’s . I’d give Ozzie a couple more weeks

Hesh
Hesh
13 hours ago

Hindsight being 50/50 or 20/20? Ryne Nelson was the stream this week, not Birdsong, at least in H2H. Pirates offense is historically bad right now. Makes losing King this week even more irritating. Was gonna offer Tyler Mahle for Parades. I know that deal is on my side, but Parades is blocked by Alonso, Freeman and Machado. Now I have King on the IL and not sure I can lose Mahle. He isn’t as good as his numbers suggest, but until he loses one at home to a meh lineup, he’s a good guy to have. That being said, would you offer that now before he pitches? My first base situation is Vientos, Sheets, Goodman, so Parades would be a big upgrade. If he says no thx, do I throw in Helsley, he just lost Alvarado. thx in advance.

Last edited 13 hours ago by Hesh
Chico Escuela
Chico Escuela
13 hours ago

Ola-
Ward or Hoskins?
tx

A hickie from Kenickie’s like a hallmark card.

Landon
Landon
13 hours ago

Hey Grey, pls rank these pitchers ROS.
Wheathers, Warren, Pfaadt, Liberatore, May. Thanks!

Landon
Landon
Reply to  Landon
13 hours ago

Weathers*

Matty
Matty
13 hours ago

Would you give up on Doyle for a flyer on Marcelo Mayer?
Doyle is buried on the bench, and Mayer will be fighting Dylan Moore and Westburg for playing time.
Thanks.

Last edited 13 hours ago by Matty
los locos
los locos
13 hours ago

Grey, I mentioned yesterday someone dropped Holiday and I saw someone dropped Weathers. I tried to clam both, but got Weathers and dropped Gavin. 6 BBs is crazy. Like he is afraid to pitch to people. I wanted both but I think I got the better guy. Jackson may be a great baseball players and avg fantasy contributor. Almost June single digit SBs and HRs.

sportivetricks
sportivetricks
13 hours ago

Hey to the Hey!!!!

Are we starting Megill v, White Sux (20.7)?

lurrrrrrrrves!!!

Acuña Machado Means No Worries
Acuña Machado Means No Worries
13 hours ago

Hey Grey- FYI- something is off with the player search bar at the top. It just reverts to the home page after you click on the player name, instead of taking you to the player’s page. I tried it on 2 devices so i don’t think it’s just a cookie issue.

Relatedly- got offered Lawrence Butler for George Kirby in a 6 player keeper. That’s a no, right?

mr baseball
mr baseball
13 hours ago

Adrian Houser has a new pitch – Its call luck

Scoboticus
Scoboticus
14 hours ago

Grey, handsome face, would you start Max Meyer @SD tonight?

mr baseball
mr baseball
14 hours ago

Mr Grey – general manager Dana Brown says that Blanco is seeking a second opinion you already know that the 1st opinion must suck that they need a second opinion

mr baseball
mr baseball
Reply to  mr baseball
14 hours ago

My  opinion looks like a drop
?

Jogon
Jogon
14 hours ago

Hi,
12 teams dynasty league :

I have Acuna, Carroll, Langford, Alvarez and Jazz at OF
I have Walker at 1B
Would you trade Alvarez for Naylor and Harris ?

The other owner also has Bellinger.

Thanks

Jogon

Chris
Chris
14 hours ago

Hey Grey,

good afternoon.

14 team league, 7 keepers, with OBP
Pitchers with k/9 and L, SV and HLDs

One team is selling for picks next year.
I’m interested in Bichette and either Pivetta or Flaherty.

What next year’s picks would you pay for each one, and which SP you prefer?
i’m leaning towards Pivetta.

thanks for your help.

Just in case, my roster is:
C – Stephenson
1b – Olson
2b – Stott
3b- Jorge Polanco
SS- Adames
OF – Tucker / Judge / Ozuna
UTL – O’Hearn / Grisham
BN – Lane Thomas (which i will soon drop)

SP – Kirby, Ranger Suarez, Cease, Gore, Bassitt, Boyd
RP – Pagan, Strahm, King, Romano, Justin Martinez

thanks!

michael
michael
14 hours ago

hey grey, my post disappeared? not sure exactly what happened, i’ll condense it!

Looking to sell maybe
Rank the keepers i’m targeting

team 1 – $ 11 crochet, $14 Kirby
team 2 – $11 Wood
team 3 – $16 skubal, $14 suzuki, $12 Rooker, $11 Ohtani (P), $8 Cole, $6 Luzardo

Mine are currently $28 Witt, $8 Crow-Armstrong, and maybe a $6 Roman Anthony. We can keep up to 5

Mylo
Mylo
14 hours ago

Drop Nick Martinez for Max Meyer?

Five-on-One
Five-on-One
14 hours ago

Happy Tuesday!

Couple of questions for 12-team, 5×5 league with weeky lineups:

1) Need help at 2B. I’ve been running McLain out there. Caballero, Meidroth, Durbin and IKF all available. Make a switch?

2) Also struggling at CI. Picked up Burger off the waiver wire, and v happy with that. But others are Aranda, Walker and Royce Lewis. Please rank those three (I tried). Replace any with Durbin, Toro, Caballero or Andujar?

3) Using Doyle and Sanchez in the OF. Don’t want to give up on Doyle, but he has been quite disappointing. Pick up any of Taveras, S.Marte, Caballero or Andujar?

4) Please rank these SPs for the week:

Liberatore @TEX
2-start Kolek vMIA and @SF
Gallen vPIT
Leiter VSTL

Thank you.

Five-on-One
Five-on-One
Reply to  Five-on-One
13 hours ago

Please add Noah Cameron (vCIN) to the list of SPs.

michael
michael
14 hours ago

hey Grey

I’m contemplating selling in my keeper league. I know its early but

I’m in 8th (out of 12)I’m 13 points out of 3rd (money back spot) and 25 points out of 2nd (1st and 2nd are way ahead this year)My estimate for max point increase I could get given the roto table at present is around 15. So I might get up into 3rd if everything breaks right.I only have 2 decent keepers out of a pool of 5its largely my pitching, Gilbert got hurt, Miller (also got hurt) and Bibee have been junk, so I’ve had to rely on back end guys and it just hasn’t gone well. I’m last in 2 pitching categories and 2nd last in another and have a total of 13 points.

Hence the thought process to sell. I’ve taken a look at all teams, and gauged interest in selling keepers from all owners. 2nd, 4th and 5th place teams have shown an interest in trading some keepers assets.

How would you rank the following keeper assets.

2nd place team has an $11 Crochet and a $14 Kirby. He is willing to part with both

4th place team has an $11 Wood and is willing to part with him. He also has a $30 Ohtani (B) but is not very open to trading him.

5th place team has a lot of stuff but I haven’t narrowed down what he is willing to sell. He has $16 Skubal, $14 Suzuki, $12 Rooker, $11 Ohtani (P), $8 Cole, $6 Luzardo

Obviously my targets would basically be entirely about next year if i am selling.

My keepers are currently $28 Witt, $8 Crow-Armstrong, and then maybe a $6 Roman Anthony

Thanks so much!

Last edited 14 hours ago by michael
michael
michael
Reply to  Grey
12 hours ago

excellent thank you! sorry for the double post

Franz Escobar
Franz Escobar
14 hours ago

Website question, are there supposed to be this many pop up ads when you’re on this site? I literally cannot click on a tab or page on this website without getting hit with pop ups.

foxman
foxman
15 hours ago

You highlight the 4 2/3 frustration for W leagues, but the dreaded 5 2/3 in QS leagues are painful. You got a term for those?
Ryan Weathers and Clay Holmes threw terrific games, but one out shy of Quality Starts

Pauly bag of donuts
Pauly bag of donuts
Reply to  foxman
8 hours ago

How about for 5 2/3 innings, maybe another Wet Dream or you got Blue Balled

Last edited 8 hours ago by Pauly bag of donuts
Jimmy
Jimmy
15 hours ago

Hey Grey,

Are we giving up on any of the players below in a 12 team redraft:

A)Nootbar
B) Turang
C) JH Lee
D) beck

tommybones
Reply to  Grey
11 hours ago

Beck’s been better away from Coors so far this season, for what it’s worth

flag
flag
15 hours ago

ugh, Nelson. Is it just me or do things often seem obvious after the fact even when you put a lot of thought into a decision beforehand? I replaced Nelson with Ryan (for sure one start) in my lineup because he’s a) not that good, and b) every site showed him losing his second start to Erod, back from the IL. Not only did Nelson throw a gem, now is back listed as the starter for a primo 2nd start against the Nationals. Should have known he’d be at least acceptable against the lowly Pirates and Erod starting Sunday was just speculation. That wearing a potato sack and wandering into traffic sounds good right now.

Dave
Dave
15 hours ago

My take on the Aranda cooling….the Rays have the fifth most PA against LHP this season, and Aranda (like Brandon Lowe) struggled against them. The difference between top and bottom of that list is amazing. Milwaukee 652 vs Houston 258. It’s an under-rated heat checker, in my opinion.

Travis Hafner
Travis Hafner
Reply to  Dave
14 hours ago

This is a great post

hondo
hondo
Reply to  Travis Hafner
10 hours ago

Definitely gives more minutia to keep track of. I wish I put this much effort into my portfolio.

Motown_Magic
Motown_Magic
15 hours ago

Happy Tuesday sir-
Roto 10 team redraft, OBP league:

Masyn Winn or Tovar ROS?
Luis Garcia Jr over one or both?

Thank you!

moneeman
moneeman
16 hours ago

12 team 5×5 roto- have Iglesias and Estevez as my closers – combo of Norby and Shaw at 3b. Was offered Junior for Estevez. Is Junior that big of an upgrade to more than offset the ground I will lose in saves?

Keith Hernandez' cat
Keith Hernandez' cat
16 hours ago

Stash Eury or Bubba?

Will the Thrill
Will the Thrill
16 hours ago

Rest of season- who’s more valuable- Trout or Junior Caminero?

Thanks!

Newbvic
Newbvic
Reply to  Grey
10 hours ago

Wrong thread sorry

Last edited 10 hours ago by newbvic10488
Cable
Cable
16 hours ago

12 team redraft h/h points

You can have two SPers off the Martins roster …..they would be

Weathers
Meyer
Sandy
Quantrill
Cabrera

Christian Russo
Christian Russo
16 hours ago

Coming from a pretty shallow league here – is Henderson a hold or could I drop and just continue to monitor his big league status?

I Am Not A Smart Man
17 hours ago

Morning Grey!

I guffawed at the “Bourbon Street- sounding bar” line. Well done.

Planning ahead, I’ve got 2 names on my IL that are likely getting activated in the next 2 weeks:

Reese Olson and Westburg

Not sure who my drops are and looking for guidance in my 12 team 5×5 (QS) league. Options below. I would probably lean towards dropping 1 bat and 1 SP or 2 bats.

Olson
Peterson
Bubba
Stowers
Tovar
Burger
Hays

Thank you in advance!

– IANASM

Newbvic
Newbvic
18 hours ago

Weathers or abbot?

Newbvic
Newbvic
Reply to  Grey
10 hours ago

Thank you

Chucky
Chucky
18 hours ago

At this point, isn’t Jordan Beck just a poor man’s version of Fernando Tatis?

Hutch
Hutch
19 hours ago

Thoughts on this trade…Cade Horton-Casey Mize and Randy Rodriguez for The Martian Libratore and Luke Jackson thank you!! 12 team dynasty 5×5….

VinWins
20 hours ago

It was the 27th time that a pitcher struck out 11 or more this season and the 7th time they did not earn a win. 21 different pitchers have accomplished the feat. Tarik Skubal has done it 4 times, including 3 this month:

05-25 vs CLE >W 5-0< 9 IP/13 K
05-09 vs TEX >W 2-1< 7 IP/12 K
04-27 vs BAL >W 7-0< 6 IP/11 K
05-14 vs BOS >W 6-5< 6.33 IP/11 K

Cole Ragans, Garrett Crochet, and MacKenzie Gore have each done it twice.

Washington and Baltimore have each been the victim 3 times.

VinWins
Reply to  Grey
10 hours ago

Through May 26, 2024, there were …27! Not sure about the number of games, but would be close to the same. Like this year, Crochet had 2, but Skubal only had 1.

toolshed
20 hours ago

Tatis is ice cold. Over his last 11 games he is hitting .133 with 1 run, 1 hr, 1 rbi. He has 1 sb over his last 22 games played. Maybe he could use a day off. Hopefully there’s nothing bothering him physically

Last edited 20 hours ago by toolshed
Chucky
Chucky
Reply to  toolshed
18 hours ago

Has two multi hit games in the month of May. The question is what are you willing to accept as a discount to trade him away? 90 cents, 80 cents, 50 cents on the dollar?

birrrdy
birrrdy
20 hours ago

True that on Chad Patrick and 4 2/3 innings. WTF? 79 pitches and a lead.

Feels like a contract issue or something….

Last edited 20 hours ago by birrrdy
VinWins
20 hours ago

Gausman makes his second straight appearance on the 100 Best Fantasy Starts list. The resurgence is obviously a result of me picking him up off waivers. Although, the team that dropped him probably claims that was the catalyst.

Last edited 20 hours ago by VinWins
toolshed
20 hours ago

Nelson made this 3rd start of the year. He’s gone at least 5 ip and given up no more than 1 run in back to back starts.

Going back to last year, Eduardo Rodriguez has done that 2 times in his 19 total starts with AZ.

Ante
Ante
20 hours ago

Grey!!

Awesome!!

Rodney Dangerfield quote of the day for May 27, 2025

My gay cousin, no respect. He was so disappointed when he went to London looking forward to seeing Big Ben only to find out that Big Ben was a clock.

Cheers,
Ante

Spencer
Spencer
21 hours ago

Is that a duma key reference on Salvy

Stumanji!
Stumanji!
21 hours ago

I’m here for the Logan Henderson Demotion Support Group.

crying-group
MarmosDad
Reply to  Stumanji!
16 hours ago

Emotional Damage!!!!!

martin rostoker
martin rostoker
21 hours ago

one additional trade question.

1. would you offer Ben Rice to get Jameson Taillon?

Thank you!

martin rostoker
martin rostoker
Reply to  Grey
11 hours ago

Really appreciate this common sense! Thank you!

Lala land
Lala land
22 hours ago

12 team RCL. Altuve/wells or goodman and vest?
Thanks

martin rostoker
martin rostoker
22 hours ago

Hope you had a chance to get a well deserved break over this hole weekend.

1. When I take a step back, and look at Chad Horton and Nick Martinez, then Michael Wacha seems like a keeper over these two? Do you agree?

2. Would you keep Wacha over Gavin Williams?

3. Do you have a guesstimate when Logan Henderson is returning to the major leagues?

4. Would you trade Ben Rice for Henderson?

Thanks!!!

Martin

martin rostoker
martin rostoker
Reply to  Grey
11 hours ago

Thanks so much for all your help!!!!