Is anyone struggling with pitching? I know there’s bad pitchers, but my word my pitching is good in just about every league. My hitting? Oh, that’s a mess in multiple leagues. Look at this insanity:
I am howling at how bad my hitting is. Gunnar, Yordan, Jazz, and Butler are my top bats. Strike through “top.” My actual top bats are Hunter Goodman and that’s it! I mention that league now because I dropped Will Warren in that league. In retrospect, it was a bad move, but I can only turn my pitching to 60. My thought was he didn’t pitch deep enough into games — right there — but I also thought he couldn’t command his pitches. That’s as wrong as banking on Yordan and Gunnar to win a league? Not entirely, but his command is good enough. Yesterday, Will Warren went 5 2/3 IP, 0 ER, 6 baserunners, 10 Ks, ERA at 4.05. His dazzlers were an 83 MPH sweeper that had a 42.9 WHIFF% and a 93 MPH 4-seamer with a 29.4 WHIFF%, but the proof’s in the pudding (a hilarious saying, unless Bill Cosby is saying it) is in the underlying numbers — 11.6 K/9, 3.5 BB/9, 2.96 xFIP, 20.8 K-BB%, and appears likely to compete for the 2nd straight Yankee pitcher to win ROY. If he could’ve also played 3rd and hit for power, I would’ve kept him on my fantasy team. Anyway, here’s what else I saw yesterday in fantasy baseball:
Aaron Judge – 2-for-4, 2 runs, 2 RBIs and a slam (16) and legs (4), hitting .402. How awkward is it gonna be when they defrost Ted Williams’s head to follow Judge around for his chase at .400? A Red Sox great’s head watching the Yanks every night? Oof, so awkward.
Ben Rice – 2-for-3, 2 RBIs and his 10th homer, hitting .259. This is the first non-Judge Yankee homer that wasn’t a leadoff homer.
Max Scherzer – Threw a 33-pitch session yesterday. At 32 pitches, he pounded his glove and screamed, “Let’s go!” After his 33rd pitch, he waved his hands and said, “I’m good.”
Jonah Heim – 2-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 6th homer, hitting .262. Even better, he made it possible for Luke Weaver to enter for the one-out save. I love that! Thank you, Heim! I even forgive you for Licorice Pizza.
Nick Martinez – 6 IP, 1 ER. 6 baserunners, 3 Ks, ERA at 3.43 vs. Bailey Falter – 7 IP, 0 ER, 4 hits, zero walks, 5 Ks, ERA at 3.50. They called this matchup, “Any pitcher in the NL Central could be the NL’s Seth Lugo.”
David Bednar – 1 IP, 0 ER, ERA at 5.02, and his 4th save. Pirates are really committed to the bit to keep going to Shit-the-Bednar when Santana has a 1.86 ERA right behind him.
Parker Meadows – Will begin a rehab assignment. That’s also the answer to, “Did Parker Meadows retire?”
Riley Greene – 3-for-4, 4 RBIs and his 12th homer, hitting .286. He’s around a top 10 outfielder on the Player Rater. Riley Greene feels like the Royce Lewis we were promised in the outfield.
Kerry Carpenter – 1-for-4 and his 10th homer. Since I was there for Greene, Carpenter is a top 20-ish outfielder on the Player Rater.
Tarik Skubal – 5 2/3 IP, 3 ER, 6 baserunners, 8 Ks, ERA at 2.87. In all my leagues where I’m doing well in pitching, I don’t have Skubal anywhere. Shrugs. Hunh. Weird.
Nolan Arenado – 2-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 5th homer, hitting .247. Bought some hay that Kenny Loggins actually chewed in the music video for Footloose. Here, let me show you by this open window–NOOOO!!! Torenado!
Chris Bassitt – 6 IP, 0 ER, 5 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 2.83. One of the more shocking Guys That Are Doing Well. Think a lot of people would think he’s a sell high. He’s not. He’s actually a buy high, if you’re into that sorta thing.
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. – 1-for-3 and his 6th homer. Let them eat Cake!
Anthony Santander – 1-for-3, 2 RBIs and his 6th homer, hitting .185. Oh my God, is that actual fog on the mirror under his nose?
Logan Henderson – 5 IP, 0 ER, 4 baserunners, 7 Ks, ERA at 1.69. I like Henderson a lot, so don’t take this the wrong way, but the Uh-O’s look as bad as the Rockies in away games. They moved Adley up in the order and Mountcastle down; Adley who absolutely sucks and Mountcastle who had a 12-game hitting streak, and is hitting around .400 in the last 25 games. Is Brandon Hyde’ing in the back of the dugout?
Brice Turang – 2-for-5 and his 4th homer, hitting .297. That gives a B. Rice two homers yesterday.
Sal Frelick – 1-for-2, 2 runs, 2 RBIs and a slam (3) and legs (9), 2nd homer in the last week and hitting .205 in May before yesterday and I thought I was leading somewhere good, then [raspberries lips]
Rhys Hoskins – 2-for-4, 2 runs and his 6th homer, hitting .297 (!), hitting near-.400 in the last two weeks and a schmotato if available.
Brandon Walter – 5 IP, 0 ER, 4 baserunners, 5 Ks, as he was called up. Damn shame that B. Walter’s not followed in the start by a Downs. Or a Jennings. Or a Behar! Walter was a lefty on the taxi squad. No, not with Randy Dobnak, that’s the Uber squad. Walter is incredibly meh (was released by the Red Sox, throws 91), but has good command, so maybe some AL-Only value.
Isaac Paredes – 1-for-4 and his 8th homer, 2nd homer in three games. Wonder if Paredes can march his ass over to Christian Walker to see if he has a pulse.
Zack Littell – 5 IP, 2 ER, 7 hits, zero walks, 6 Ks, ERA at 4.25. At the end of the podcast each week, BDon gives you some pitcher streamers, and he mentioned Littell, and I thought to myself, “In Big Stein, that’s bold,” but Bold is BDon’s name. Bold One, it’s a weird abbreviation.
Hayden Birdsong – 5 IP, 0 ER, 5 hits, zero walks, 4 Ks, ERA at 1.91. Rockin’ in the tree top all night long, rockin’ and boppin’ and singing that song, rockin’ Hayden, tweet-tweet. Don’t love his command, but that’s a small quibble for the sweet, sound of Birdsong’s Ks and lovely home nest park. If you asked me Roupp or Birdsong, I can’t answer, they’re all my children. Though, Roupp has a little more to like, but close. Birdsong is worth rostering, as well. Tweet-tweet.
Yoan Moncada – 2-for-5, 3 RBIs and his 4th homer, as he hits 3rd, which feels like one of those pitfalls a manager can fall into. Not metaphorically. I mean literally. If a manager puts Moncada in the three-hole, he should fall into a pit and never be heard from again.
Logan O’Hoppe – 2-for-5, 2 RBIs and his 11th homer. As Pharrell would sing, “Because I’m O’Hoppe.” I hope that song is now stuck in your head all day and you have to call the hospital asking if there’s a way to get a song out of your head.
J.T. Ginn – Hit the IL with a right quad strain, which prolly happened on an immunity challenge, because his name always makes me think he was on Survivor.
Gunnar Hoglund – 4 2/3 IP, 5 ER, ERA at 5.06. If you’re still trying to make Hoglund happen like he’s fetch, it doesn’t seem to be working.
Shea Langeliers – 2-for-4, 2 runs and his 9th homer. I don’t know if this is true, but it feels like it: There’s more good catchers than 1st basemen.
Jacob Wilson – Left the game after being hit on the forearm. Please, no fractures. Can we get a prayer triangle together?
Nick Kurtz – 2-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 2nd homer. Well, why didn’t you say you’d do that before I dropped you last week?
Gabriel Moreno – 1-for-3 and his 3rd homer, and 2nd homer in two games. Hot schmotato alert!
Corbin Carroll – 1-for-5, 2 RBIs and his 15th homer. In same breath as Ohtani, Judge and Schwarber. And he has 50-steal speed. Incredible.
Shelby Miller – 2/3 IP, 2 ER, ERA at 2.18, as he blew the game, after working Sunday, Monday and Tuesday. Wild guess, but maybe don’t pitch him every single game.
Yoshinobu Yamamoto – 7 IP, 0 ER, 1 hit, 2 walks, 9 Ks, ERA at 1.86, and 110 pitches. If only he had 111 in the tank. Sigh. Tanner Scott blew this one for him, and Yamamoto’s run support for his 10 starts is a whooping 14.
Spencer Strider – 4 1/3 IP, 4 ER, ERA at 5.79, as he was activated. Only really his second start of the year. Am I really biting my lip to not victory lap my preseason call to avoid him? Well, let’s just say if you heard me right now, I’d be calling him Spenther Thrider.
Matt Olson – 1-for-4 and his 10th homer, hitting .240. Way to go Olthon! Damn, still biting lip.
Dylan Crews – Hit his 7th homer, but left with a lower back issue and will be getting an MRI on it. I blame all y’all who ask about dropping him every single day, like he’s not capable of a top 20 outfielder season.
Robert Hassell III – Will be called up to replace the seemingly headed-to-the-IL Crews. No amount of prayer hexagons can fix this. The Third Hassell was a prized piece of the Soto trade, then everything went kablooey and he started hitting .189 in Single-A. Bobby Barrels does have speed, but his nickname seems sarcastic at this point, as he hit .241 last year in the minors, and makes a ton of weak, ground ball contact. Maybe he can figure it out, and remind people why they were once excited for this trilogy.
Adrian Houser– 6 IP, 0 ER, 5 baserunners, 2 Ks, as he was called up. Literally rolled out of bed and held the M’s scoreless. This is more of an indictment of the M’s than an endorsement of Houser.
Jesus Luzardo – 6 IP, 1 ER, 5 baserunners, 10 Ks, ERA at 1.95. Who turned the Coors humidor to 11?
Kyle Schwarber – 1-for-4, 2 runs and his 17th homer. Now on pace for around 60 homers, and we haven’t even reached his Mother Month when he nestles into the bosom of June and suckles at her teets.
Clay Holmes – 6 IP, 2 ER, 7 baserunners, 5 Ks, ERA at 3.13. Managing to have a remarkably solid season, that I did not expect from him. He did the Reverse Mariano. A so-so reliever who becomes a solid starter. A different path, to be sure. Or PATH, in this case.
Rafael Devers – 1-for-3 and his 10th homer. Now hitting around .450 with 10 homers since the last victory I took on him.
Carlos Narvaez – 1-for-3 and his 5th homer. Has been one of the hottest catchers in baseball (who is rostered in under 50% of leagues, which I know because I’m busy working on the Buy column for the Patreon.)
Walker Buehler – 2 1/3 IP, 0 ER, ERA at 4.00, as he was activated from the IL. He was ejected for calling a strike a strike, because baseball umpiring be dumb. His underlying stats look pretty awful, and I don’t think I’d start him in anything shallower than a 12-teamer, but you’re welcome to check the Streamonator. Hopefully, him and us get ABS sooner, in the landmark case of sooner vs. later.
Travis Bazzana – Will be sidelined for 8-10 weeks with a strained oblique. Ever since Australians discovered the oblique in 2022, there’s been an epidemic, as they’re unable to heal mid-muscles.
Ryan Weathers – 5 IP, 1 ER, 5 hits, zsero walks, 4 Ks, ERA at 1.80. Think it speaks higher of him than I could just by the simple fact that he held the Cubs to one run, then they destroyed lesser pitchers who followed him. We like Weathers. We is me.
Ian Happ – 1-for-6 as he was activated from the IL. Kevin from ESPN’s “Get Him In Your Lineup” Department said, “I told Pregnant Janet that I like the name Skaboosh, hope she listens.”
Kyle Tucker – 3-for-4, 2 runs and his 11th homer. Crazy how good the Cubs are this year, and it’s not just Tucker, but it is Tucker too, obviously. Seiya Suzuki (3-for-5, 3 runs, 4 RBIs) also hit his 12th Seiya!
Jameson Taillon – 7 IP, 1 ER, 7 baserunners, 2Ks, ERA at 4.13. Taillon’s not my fave, but the Streamonator loves his next one like I haven’t seen the robot love anything since its first TBS airing of Short Circuit.
Moises Ballesteros – Sent back down with Ian Happ’s activation. [lights an imaginary lighter, burns imaginary FAAB money that I spent on Ballesteros, then Moises Alou urinates imaginary pee onto it to put it out]
Hey Kemosabe – who am I dumping to pick up Hoskins?
Grisham or Adolis
Tx
Up against Megill. Sox need to put a stop to this nonsense.
Well alright then.
Haha
In a Yahoo points league, who would you choose ROS Bailey Ober or Logan Henderson?
thank you!!
Ober
Thank you!!!
No problem
I can’t stand pitching in fantasy baseball. Here’s megill doing well again at boston after everyone cut him. Pfaadt gets two wins and 2 qs against LAD in 2 out of his last 3 starts on my bench. I use him at sfg and he goes 4 innings amd destroys my ratios.
Haha I know
What’s good Grey? I’m currently the worst I’ve ever been over 23 years in my 12-team keeper league. Like 43 games under .500 or some shizz. I can look at the stats and my pitching is top 3, but my hitting is dead last by a long way. I got a lot of the players you were listing (i.e., Jazz, Yordan, Butler, Vlad, Chourio, etc.)
It’s depressing, but I don’t know what to do cause I feel like my dudes are good. Hi to Ted.
Ted says hi! They are good! They should be good! They’ve been good in the recent past!
Drop Berrios for Eflin, Rasmussen, or Max Meyer?
Rasmussen
Drop Campbell and Robert Jr for Meidroth and Hoskins?
Sure
12 team redraft categories league. I have been stashing Chandler for 2 weeks. Would you rather have Chandler or Roupp ROS.
As a Pirates fan, they have to bring Bubba soon, right?
Bubba
Top 2 – Doyle, Yelich or Ward for OF?
Not Ward
Hey Grey, 12 team keeper. Your thoughts on these guys for this year and possibly next? keep or drop? Cowser, Kurtz, Basallo, Festa? thanks
You can lose Festa and Basallo
Getting interest for a couple of my hitters. Being offered SP and could use your opinion.
Between these, who do you like for the long haul in a standard 5×5 roto:
Schwell, Pivetta, Bubic (already past his career high IP), Pablo, Framber
Thanks for your help.
Bubic is not near his career high in IP
Framber
Yes, was looking at the past few years. Hasn’t thrown 100 innings since 2022 or 2021.
ok
Max Meyer with the quality start today. Sunuvabench!
Damn
Baz or Horton ?
Horton
Semien or brooks lee
Semien
1. Anyone heard news on Bibee. Start pushed back a day initially and now another three days. Nervous time? He stinks but I got him for Nimmo after the big 9 RBI day so not invested.
2. RPs are the worst. I drafted two very late (Finnegan and L Jax). SAGNOF for life. Traded them both for Bautista to great applause here. Now Felix has pitched B2B games in non-save situations giving up runs in both. I guess not a question but an acknowledgement you just never know about relievers. Oh, Kyle has 15 saves just to rub it in lol.
1. I haven’t
where did you see another three days? i see him going tomorrow vs flaherty on mlb.com?
ESPN had him on Sunday earlier under the daily matchup but switched it back. Glad it was just an error.
Two offers for my PCA. Yamamoto and Paredes or Jarran Duran and Paredes. Which would you take and are they close?
Duran
When you pick up Varland to get a Hold and he’s brought in with the bases loaded. Thanks a lot! Didn’t help himself with the walk, but still!
Ha
So would you take a shot on Gavin williams putting it together or stick with a lower upside guy like Nick Martinez
Can try Gavin
Is Paddack the kinda guy you should hold on to in case he’s found something? And if not, would you rather have Megill vs White Sox over Paddack @ Rays?
No
Hi Grey,
I have some bad pitching at the bottom of my order.
Singer
Soriano (IL replacement for the man who got “fingered”, Reese Olson)
Ben Brown
Pfaadt
Roupp (faces WASH this week) and Springs (face the Phils this week) are available
I have Kirby coming off the DL so will definitely lose Brown when I activate. Do I drop Soriano or Singer or both for Roupp and/or Springs?
Thanks.
Singer for Roupp
Sorry. Do u mean drop Singer and pick up Roupp? You like Soriano more than Singer then?
Singer for Roupp sounds fine — I don’t like Soriano much, but he has a good next matchup
Run that Megill gave up (the fella who started the 10th at 2nd) is showing as earned. Can anyone explain that to me?
Stand down. Back to unearned.
Jung or Vientos ROS
Jung
danny palencia is the guy? fastball is 101. three marlins in a row missed game tying homers by a 1/4 inch off the barrel. anyhoo, got a share. shrug emoji
That’s the guy, bro!
built like a young bartolo colon
Lil’ Sexy
OBP league……..Albies or Hoerner…….
Nico
better question than the above please rank Albies, Hoerner, Bogaerts, Semien…..
Hoerner, Albies
Good afternoon, Grey,
10 team redraft OBP and QS H2H league.
At 2B: Gleyber or B. Lowe? Gleyber cooled off over the past week and Lowe is showing some life. Trade robot like Lowe per game but thinks Gleyber has more overall value playing more.
In the OF: top 2 out of Ward, Friedl, Doyle, and Edman.
Pitching: Ranger Suarez or Will Warren? IP/start is also a category on top of the QS cat.
Thanks for all your help oh wise Fantasy Master Lothario!
Gleyber — Doyle, Edman
Suarez
Is that Doyle and Edman over Ward?
Yes
HeyHeyHey!!!
Ignoring IL tags, in what order might you rank these guys for roster spots: Birdsong, Warren, Mize, Abbott, Lugo, Liberatore???
LURVE! YAS!
Abbott, Lugo, Lib
Woooooord. You have completed me. Once again.
Haha, lurves!
DeGrom or HBrown ros pts league?
RGreene or Langford?
Brown — Langford
Hunter Brown or Chris Sale?
Brown
I have been offered Joe Ryan for my Donovan. Ten hitting cats in our league so Donovan checks a lot of boxes. I like Ryan a lot but not sure how much I need him versus my need to hitting. My team:
Ivan
Vlad, Harper, Machado
Lindor, Donovan, Winn
Teoscar, Tucker, Santander, Ward, Scott
Util-Beck
Bench: Crone (who would slid in for Donovan if I traded Brendan). If not, I will drop Crone for a stream or RP (holds and saves league)
Wheeler, Crochet, Yamamoto, Bibee, Abbott, Ranger, L Henderson for now
Estevez, Iglesias, Bautista
IL – R Olson
1. Keep or trade away Donovan
2. Friedl owner trying to move him. Did I read correctly in the comments section that you prefer Friedl over Ward?
I’d take Ryan but not sure you need him…Friedl is better in points
This is a 12 team, H2H league so kinda assuming I will be in or near the six playoff teams come September. Donovan could hit .270 the rest of the year and it would be successful. So tempted to take Ryan and try to trade off my second tier arms for guys like Friedl, Mullins, Westburg in hopes they get better as the year progresses.
Ok
@Grey: weekly roto redraft. think nola can be serviceable whenever he is back? worth dropping roupp for him?
Drop
drop roupp? just checking….
I’d want Roupp
A dreaded catcher question! I have Salvador Perez, and am getting impatient. Logan O’Hoppe is available. Still too early to bail on Perez? 10-team 5×5 Roto.
Switch
Thanks, Grey! I appreciate you!
No problem
And Perez just homered mere hours after I dropped him. Glad I could provide some inspiration for him!
Ha, thanks!
But then O’Hoppe homered himself later tonight!
Felt so nice, he homered twice!
12 team redraft h/h points
Which side
O Cruz & E Suarez or Betts & Hoskins
Betts
Gleyber, Happ, Maikel, Schmidt – *drop* two
Gleyber, Schmidt
I picked up Blano and Olson after some of my other starters got hurt, and now these dudes are hurt. wth is going on with pitchers, brah???
Ugh I know
Please rank all so I know who to drop, W K ERA , thank you for all of your advice
Lib Pfaadt Pepiot Sandy MKelly Baz Roupp McCullers
Drop McCullers
I have Pfaadt Pepiot Sandy and Baz. Kelly Lib and Roupp are available, what would you recommend, thanks so much!
Lose Pfaadt, Sandy and Baz
Happy Wednesday.
Is L. Henderson a streamer or a hold in a 12-team roto? I could drop for N. Martinez (@KC,@CHC) or E. Fedde @BAL,@TEX
Also, are we holding Toglia or moving on for J. Smith, Muncy, Norby, Sheets, Vargas, Barger, Baty, Brooks Lee?
Thanks.
I’m hold him…move on, but when out of cord
lol Coors
Thx…who’s your preference on those CI?
Toglia in Coors
Right, thank you – your preference of any of those CI out of Coors?
Vargas I guess but could change by time Toglia leaves Coors
Any of these SP’s a drop to stash Eury Perez?
Pfaadt, Weathers, Libertore
Meh
13-team 6×6 with OPS and Holds
I traded Romano for Turang.
I wanted a set and forget 2B, and the prospects for Rafela seem questionable. (I also roster Brooks Lee but haven’t gotten much there yet.) My remaining closers are M. Miller, Hoffman, Megill, Bednar.
I feel although Turang is high on 2B rater, he’s kinda limited to runs and SBs. I expect regression in OPS (I had him last year). Maybe he helps in average, especially considering it against what I’ve been getting to date.
Thoughts?
I don’t know what you’re asking
Just wondering what your opinion is on the trade. Did I do well with this one, or would I have been better off to look at my rostered and FA options? Was Romano too much for a light-hitting 2B?
Sounds like a great trade that’s not very close
Okay. Closers are always hard to come by in this league, which it sounds like is working to my benefit. Thanks, and sorry for the bother.
No problem
Hey Grey,
I picked up Norby for my backup 2B. Colt Keith is now available but sits a lot. Who should I roster I an OBP league?
Thanks as always!
I need someone who plays since Philly benches Stott against lefthanders most of the time
Hold
Very deep AL only league, should I drop Luis Urias or Misner, both are short term fill-ins, thank you
Yes
which one would you rather keep? thanks
Herrera, Augustin or Diaz at catcher? Ikik catcher scabs. But the eyes have been wandering.
Agustin
Thank you
No problem
Categories league rest of season, Kim on Dodgers or Kristian Cambell for 2B Slot?
Campbell
@Grey: 12 team weekly roto. which of these two starters do you like for next week?
taillon – vs mia, vs cin
g williams – vs lad, vs laa
thanks!
Taillon
Vientos or Arrenado for the remainder of the season.
Vientos
I’ve been a nearly daily reader of you for 15 years. While your knowledge in both pitching and hitting are deep, I feel your instinct for pitching is better. I remember 5 years ago you said you had a feeling Zack Wheeler was going to be the best pitcher over the next 5 years. ‘Member that? I feel you are more objective on pitching whereas sometimes you get swept away by lover boy dreams when thinking about a hitter’s ceiling. Maybe its just tough luck and I’m totally wrong…cust kayin’
Maybe, what’s funny is hitting should be easier to predict
I feel you on the hitting woes, Grey! It’s been a miserable start with Yordan and Jazz on the IL, plus Chourio, Duran, Tovar, Volpe, and Robert are all either underperforming or absolutely stinking it up while healthy (looking at you, LuBob.) My best hitters per the player rater — Wilmer and Pages — were free off waivers! Soder might be only bat I drafted who’s worth a damn. And my overnight FAAB bid on Shaw (who I drafted and then dropped, ugh) came up way short. The best win of my season so far was recognizing the end of the line and trading away Marcus Semien for a hot ham sandwich (Pepiot).
Baseball is a long season, and I’ve managed to hang in just under .500 so far, but we’re going to need some sorching summer months to get back in it. Get healthy and hot, fellas! You’re making the boss look bad
I just need a healthy Yordan, Jazz, Gunnar and LFG!
@Grey: weekly roto redraft. how would you rank kurtz, manzardo, ohearn and vargas?
Manz, Kurtz
Would you drop Bibbee or Pfaadt to stash Misiorowski?
Nah
Could you rank the following?
S. Perez, Willison Contreras or Herrera.
Willson, Sal
i’ll tell you what, keep an eye on herrera. dude flat out rakes. oak jr has him on a team so been keeping an eye on his at bats and also his usage pattern. not sure he out ranks the other two but man can he hit.
I find it interesting that fantasy blurb writers say a team recalls a prospect, when they never played for the big club before.
Alas
12 team h/h points redraft
pick one
Doyle
Ward
Friedl
Friedl
Hi Grey,
Would you offer Rice and Yelich for Ober? I offered Yelich and it is clear that is not enough.
thanks!!!!
No
I needed that common sense approach. I can’t thank you enough for all your hard work. Your column brings such joy.
What are your thoughts on Nola and Max Scherzer?
1. Would you make changes to pick up either or hold?
My staff is:
Carlos Rodan
Max Fried
Merrill Kelly
Casey Mize IL
AJSS
will Warren
Wacha
Seth Lugo IL
Reese Olson IL
Shane Baz
Matt Liberatore
Shane McClalahan IL Slot
Thank you!!
No problem….Staff seems fine, don’t love Baz
Great input! You gave me a few ideas for potential trades involving Baz?
1.Would you offer Baz and Yelich for Logan Henderson?
2. Would you offer Baz and Yelich for Ryan Weathers?
3. Do you have possible trades involving Baz And Yelich for a pitcher?
Thank you!
Yelich is worth more than these guys on his own
Thanks. I wanted to review my logic in order to get your thoughts.
In LF, I have Ozuna as well as Kerry Carpenter as backup and Yelich. Yelich is only qualified to play only LF
In CF, I have Buxton (IL-7). With Buxton on IL, Carpenter is in CF
In RF, I have Kyle Stowers
Note: I have Manny Machado in DH since I have Austin R at 3B.
Therefore, I think that I could use Yelich to pick up a SP. Do you agree with approach?
If yes, what pitcher would you try and get for him?
Thanks so much!!
Sure, I don’t know who wants him in your league or what they have
I understand. Thank you!
No problem
Hi Grey,
I am so glad that I listened to you and started Warren. Thank you!!!
1. would you start Warren at CO?
2. I just cut Nick Martinez and picked up Wacha whose next two starts are at Minn and then home vs Detroit. Would you have made that move?
3. the Razz dollars are positive for Wacha’s next two starts at Minn and vs Detroit. would you start him in both?
thanks again!
1. sure 2. sure 3. yes
Thank you!!
No problem
12 team redraft h/h points start 5 SPers per week
staff
King
Schwellenbach
C Sanchez
Pepiot
Gilbert IL
C Schmidt
Mahle
Gonsolin
Mize IL
Zebby
wanted to move O Cruz for a SPer and slide Friedl into the Cruz OF spot …..Y/N ?
Sure
Zebby Matthews a drop to stream at that pos or hold?
Thanks!
Hold
my pitching stinks.
movie trivia…jimmy stewart was born in both indiana and pennsylvania
Jimmy Stewart was actually Jimmy & Stewart and combined later in his teens
I kid you not I am from Indiana, PA. We have a Jimmy Stewart museum, and his statue is in front of the courthouse ha ha. Small small world to see that referenced here!
love that!! strange coincidence.
I dropped Bibee instead of Rasmussen to activate Strider and then he did me a solid and continued delivering the kind of starts Bibee has been tossing all season! Thanks, Spence!
Ouch
12 team h2h dynasty league. ROS question.
My OF: Langford, Butler, Santander, Robert Jr., Arozarena, Jasson Dominguez.
1.) Drop Jasson for Ward?
2.) Pickup Grisham and drop, Robert or Arozarena?
(traded for Santander, like to give some more time, but he’s fair game to drop too)
Thankyou.
1. yes 2. Nah
Please rank; Ober Henderson Warren
Also drop Bautista when Martinez is activated ?
Ober, Warren
Felix? No
12 team h/h points redraft
you trading O Cruz for Webb or Cease
Sounds fair, I wouldn’t
Hey Grey,
What are your thoughts on Forrest Whitley? Is he worth a bullpen call up off IR in a daily 20 tm, H2H, cat dynasty? He’d be replacing Nick Mears specifically in my case.
Thanks for everything!
Meh, not yet
Yeah, I feel you. Thanks for your input as always!
No problem
The answer is probably “none of them?” but I’m still asking, how would you rank
Baz
Eflin
Giolito
You did
Steer or Beck, keep forever?
Steer
Last follow up to potential PCA deal. Offered Elly for PCA and Neto. Which side? ROS OBP/TB league.
Man, that’s tough, I’d take Elly
Thanks Grey.
No problem
Pirates are sending Mlodzinski down and calling up… drum rolllll…. Bbbbuuu…rrrows. Burrows? Sad trombone. Bubba still stuck in Super Two purgatory.
Haha
I finally get Greene and Mize back this weekend for my rotation, but struggling with who to drop for them. Mason Miller for Greene, I think, since I don’t need any non-elite RP in a 10-team points league. But then for Mize…..Sugano, pending his start today? Logan Henderson despite his hot start? Baez or Torres from my bench if they don’t pick it up these next few days? Buxton because who can trust his health?
Sugano
The notion of dropping Mason Miller is crazy to me.
If you could rate trade:
Gunnar and Austin Riley for Corbin Carroll and Jackson Holiday
Gunnar side, it’s fair
1. Would you rather roster Winn or Crone?
2. Would you trade Abbott and Beck for Joe Ryan?
3. Did Altuve and S Perez get old together?
Ten days ago everyone was saying hold or buy low on Altuve. Now everyone is out on him. Fantasy is kinda crazy that way.
4. Please rank: Warren, Abbott, L Henderson, Eflin. Thank you
1. Winn 2. Yes 3. Yes 4. Abbott, Warren
Follow up to my below question: got offered Teo for my PCA and Neto. Feels like I’m giving up too much. Does adding Luzardo make this more even as a 2:2 or are you ok with PCA amd Neto for Teo.
You’re giving up too much…Sure, Luzardo
As-s for Jordan Beck a reasonable offer? The other team needs pitching.
Sounds reasonable
Morning Grey,
Drop Giolito for Warren? I know Gio has some upside if he returns to form… that’s the only reason I have been holding.
Thanks!
-IANASM
Yes
I am curious of the difference in steal rates between AAA and MLB. Less green lights? Pitchers holding them better? (is the 2 pickoff rule in AAA?)
Meidroth over here acting like prime Whit Merrifield with the wheels of uh…not Whit Merrifield.
Priorities are likely different…A guy wants to avoid injuries maybe?
I just picked up Meidroth for Durbin. Could be low key SB difference maker esp in OBP leagues.
That 6 in hitting is magical.
NL-only keeper, in 1st place with no real category weaknesses, what kind of bid ($85/100 left) on Logan Henderson? (He probably wouldn’t make my keeper cut but could be trade bait.)
It’s incredible, right? Haha — $7
No room on IL and lagging behind in saves – is Porter Hodge worth hanging on to?
No
Grey,
If I post the rosters of all my teams, the league sizes and scoring setups, the waiver wire options, a breakdown of the other owners and their characteristics (active vs. inactive, “home” team, trade propensities, etc ), random thoughts from how my brain works, I mean, do you think you could take over and manage all my teams by proxy?
Also, ya think Goodman is a good pick up?
Ha, yes
12 team redraft h/h points
Moving O’Neil Cruz what two SPers would be a fair return for him
Sure
Looking to move Simpson as I think I can compete in steals without him in 12 team std 5×5 league starting 11 H. Given he can dominate the steals category, not sure what his value could be. Can you suggest a H and a P that I could trade for which could help me estimate the value. I have been offered Edman or Shawver.
I’d take Edman
Would me trading Vientos for Will Warren be a bad trade?
No
Also, Hodge went to the IL on my team, can you list the top 2 in order you would add in a saves/holds league out of these options for a relief pitcher?:
Yimi Garcia
Leiter Jr
Cole Sands
Ginkel
Jalen Beeks
Tinico
Speier
Daysbel Hernandez
Taylor Roger’s
Tim Herrin
I know not great options lol. Thanks for the help as always !
Ginkel, Sands
Hey Grey! Yes! Me! I’m struggling with pitching!! Well, it’s more that I have pitchers who have gotten rocked (Baz, B Brown, Roupp, Hodge, #AllMyStreamers) which cuts into the others who do well. Especially the relievers – ERA over 4.5 with SPs around 3.4. But, it’s early, so that’s gotta balance out at some pt… right?
Speaking of which – can drop Baz now, yes? (for another reliever who will break my heart… )
yes
Yep
Another question would you move jung hoo lee for ryan weathers?
No
Wells or O’Hoppe?
Are Vientos and Campbell droppable at this point in a 10T?
Logan
Sure
Looking to grab Will Warren to see what’s there.
Drop options are Bubba Chandler (burning a hole in a roster spot), Nick Martinez (kinda like his next start against the Royals on the road), and Pepiot (has the Jays up next).
I also have Pfaadt, who I don’t like but will try to use in a package deal after his next good start (since he’s more widely owned) and Reese Olson, but I’ll be able to move him to an IL slot shortly with Acuna and Buxton coming back.
Who’s the drop, if anyone?
Pepiot
Can you rank L Garcia, Edman, Shaw, Norby, Cronenworth ROS
Edman, Garcia
Any of these streamers worth adding today? If so could you rank the top 2 in order?
Gausman vs SD
Bradley vs Houston
Megill @ Boston
Heaney vs Reds
Paddack vs Cleveland
Horton @ Miami
Taj, Gausman
Drop Zebby for Max Meyer streamed start today?
Yes
Grey, trying to trade PCA. He’s ranked 5th overall in my league (OBP/TB 12 TM H2H), and feel like it might be time to cash in. Would you hold or go after a Schwarber or Teo type? Thanks Grey!
Either, Kyle or Teo
Grey, my offense has been pretty pathetic this year looking to change things up.
Did well in drafting my SPs, and was offered Bohm/Edman/Rice for my Framber/Baez/Vinny P
Worth it to pick up some points in the offensive categories ? 12 team mixed league 5×5
Framber side
Kim (Dodgers) and Vientos at 2B and 3B respectively… Is Meidroth worth adding to replace either of them? Vientos has been MEH and Kim might not play everyday going forward.
Sure, Vientos
Hi,
Can you rank those pitchers ROS :
Warren
Liberatore
Kelly
B.Miller
Lugo
Thanks
Jogon
Lugo, Lib, Warren
Would you trade butler for jazz or just avoid jazz at this point? My outfield is pretty deep with merrill, ozuna, lee, ward, stowers and simpson
I asked Grey about Butler or Jazz on the podcast this week… just saying.
Ill check it out! I usually tune in missed it this week of course haha
What BDon said
11 team. 5×5.
Drop Zebby or pfaadt (or both) for birdsong/ryan weathers?
Yes, both
Start Gavin Williams or Cade Horton today?
Sure
I was offered Bubic, Busch and Trevor Megill for Naylor and Flaherty. I’m planning on declining because I think the drop-off at 1B would be to big between Naylor and Busch. What are your thoughts?
Decline
Roupp or Bello?
Roupp
Would you bench any of these?
Eovaldi @ NYY
Suarez @ Col
Eflin @ Bos
Senga LA
Thanks
Eflin
I have a self proclaimed Red Sox homer in my keeper league who wants to trade me Elly de la Cruz for his Campbell and Roman Anthony. I currently have Abrams at SS. Season is already almost over for me at 1-5-1. Am I giving up too much or is 1 in the hand better really better than 2 in the bush?
I’d want Elly
Hi grey would you go shaw over lawler in a 10tm roto?
Shaw side
I have a self proclaimed Red Sox homer in my keeper league who wants to trade me Elly de la Cruz for Campbell and Roman Anthony. I am getting close to folding on the season. 1-5-1 so far ??. I have Abrams right now at SS. I have been going back and forth on this trade for a bit now. Am I giving up too much? Is 1 in the hand better than 2 in the bush?
Answered
Hi Grey,
Good morning.
Currently rocking Matt Chapman at 3rd Base.
Should I drop him and add Bohm, who has been hitting lately?
Thanks,
Chris
Nah
Which start you like better? Streamonator is even on them
Jake Irvin v SF
Tonel Blanco v SEA
Ronel
Bibee, Alcantara, B. Miller, Kirby. At least Strider and Kershaw are back. That will help replace Gil and Steele. SonOfaPitch!
Haha
Who would you rather have in a util spot in 12-team roto — Zach Neto or Matt Chapman? Thanks.
Neto
Good morning Grey!
Which one of these pitchers would you drop to add Will Warren if any?
N Pivetta
J DeGrom
T Gonsolin
Z Eflin
L Castillio
M Kelly
T Mahle
C Kershaw
Thanks as always for your input!
Probably Kershaw (did I say that?)….
Kershaw
Will Warren sonofabench! That at Colorado start is gonna cost a lot of weekly move folks the gem from last night.
Like Cary said, the ticker shock from Weathers was real too. Oh man. RIP Calvin Faucher for real.
Haha, poor Faucher
Guessing you also have Ronald Acuna
He’s only hitting .455/.647/1.091 in the minors.
Hes coming back this weekend to save the day. Bet the house, he says to his interpreter.
High five! Oh wait, not you Moises.
Fist bump
Nah, let’s just nod.
I have Acuna too
I don’t think anyone who drafted Strider was counting on him for THIS year…maybe a late post season push….my main rationale was I had extra picks and am in a keeper league, so it was good value moving forward. I am def. with you on tempering expectations for this season, though. If he gets right, I will gladly keep him in the 5th round next year (6th this year). Sucks bc I didn’t want to start him, but Reese Olson got ILed at the last second. UGH
I’d be very surprised if anyone who drafted Strider in a redraft league isn’t counting on him for this year
This made me laugh and laugh.
Hehe
Trade offer:
Paredes and either Mahle/Senga
For
Machado
Which side? Is it close? Machado only has 3 hrs.
Thanks
I don’t see the point if you’re going after Machado
I thought the same. Guy wants Senga and Paredes. Thought about selling high but don’t see much of a difference between Paredes and Machado. Thanks
No problem
Are you holding Moises Ballesteros in a dynasty league or dropping to fill my catcher spot?
Gavin Sheets would be the alternative player to drop for a catcher.
Thanks!
Drop Moises, I guess, but know nothing of your league
Rest of season- Burger or Paredes?
Thanks!
Paredes
I noticed the Tigers became winners last year when Parker Meadows got his 2nd call.
Worried about his injury that just popped up.
I see similarities between Parker and Neto last year. Similar 25-25 upside with possibilities of much more.
Expectations of PArker the rest of the way?
Maybe top 50 OF
Falter earned his second and Pittsburgh’s 5th entry on the 100 Best Fantasy Starts list:
08 Andrew Heaney Apr 23 @LAA
40 Paul Skenes Apr 2 @TB
62 Paul Skenes Apr 25 @LAD
72 Bailey Falter May 20 CIN
92 Bailey Falter Apr 16 WSH
Damn
Morning Grey,
Burger or Hoskins in OBP ROS?
Hoskins
Jack Leiter @ CWS
OR
Tylor Megill @ BOS
Who would you stream this week?
Leiter
Grey!!!
Rodney Dangerfield quote of the day for May 21, 2025
I went to a fight the other night and a hockey game broke out.
Cheers,
Ante
Today’s episode: neurotic comedian Richard Lewis calls in to a SiriusXM fantasy baseball call-in segment.
**\[SFX: Fantasy Sports Radio intro music fades out]**
**HOST:**
Alright, let’s go to the phones — we’ve got Richard from… uh, “a dark place.” What’s up, Richard?
**RICHARD LEWIS (frantic):**
Yeah, hi, thanks for taking my call, though I’m not sure why I’m doing this. I just watched a baseball game where a fight broke out — or maybe it was a fight where a baseball game broke out. Either way, Rodney Dangerfield’s ghost is laughing at me and I’m *not okay.*
**HOST (laughing):**
Alright, buddy, whatcha got for us?
**RICHARD:**
Who do I stream tonight?! Vásquez in Toronto? Heaney vs the Reds? Sugano? Every option is like choosing between a root canal, jury duty, and reading my ex’s wedding announcement. Heaney burned me so bad last week I had to apologize to my *therapist.*
And now someone dropped Brent Rooker! Do I grab him?! Drop Doyle or Butler?! I haven’t made a decision this hard since I picked a major in college — and I *still* don’t know what I picked!
Also — catcher help. Is it time to drop Yanier? Goodman’s out there hitting like he’s mad at me personally. But if I pick him up, I *know* Yanier’s gonna go full Johnny Bench the second I hit the button!
**HOST:**
Okay okay, deep breaths—
**RICHARD (spiraling):**
Deep breaths? I drafted Varsho. I haven’t *exhaled* since April. My entire life is a DFA. I’m ranking rest-of-season 1Bs like it’s a eulogy: “Vinnie P, you were good to me. Goldy, you hurt me. Hoskins… I never loved you, but I *believed* in you.”
I’ve got Friedl, Dylan Moore, Larnach, and Colt Keith all underperforming like it’s a union contract, and now I’m supposed to activate Happ and Mize?! I’m out of room — physically, emotionally, spiritually!
**HOST (laughing):**
Richard, hang in there, man.
**RICHARD:**
Hang in there?! I haven’t slept since the waiver wire opened! I’m one bad outing away from naming my ulcer “Logan Allen!”
Just one more thing. Whoever dropped Steer to grab Castellanos? I hope you sleep well tonight. Because I won’t. And that’s all I’ve got. I’m gonna go stare at my FAAB budget and weep. Thanks.
**\[SFX: Click. Line goes dead.]**
**HOST (grinning):**
Well. That was… passionate. We’ll be right back with more questions — and maybe a wellness checkup.
Are you ok?
A. Quite all right, thank you for asking.
B. Is anyone OK, existentially speaking?
C. There is no C.
Keep it up, B-Bard. Loving these!
You’re the one!
Ha
Devers kinda does this every year, but I’ve never been happy to have him in the second half. Just sayin’
I know
Matt Shaw got ganked right away in my 10-team. Who would you rank top of the consolation prizes ROS:
Josh Jung
Hays
Ward
Kurtz
Stowers
Ward, Stowers
I’m in 5 leagues 12 team leagues: my opponents own a variation of… in 5 leagues
Will WarrenX2
Walker BeuhlerX2
Jesus LuzardoX2 (I own him in 2, 2 of the 3 additional opponents own him)
Nick MartinezX2
Hayden Birdsong
Chris Bassitt
Clay Holmes
Michael Lorenzen
2 owned Sonny Gray..
Grey, what do you do! How is this even fucking possible dude.
Not to mention I have a total of… wait for it… 7 home runs in 5 leagues where you start 10 guys. One of my opponents had 5. One is starting 2 catchers.. one of those being Shea fucking Langilers that all of a sudden 5 tool
Stud has more stolen bases than all my teams combined
In my ONE points league I have the 2nd most points, including this week where did be wait g 10 of 11 teams except, you guessed it, the team I’m going against today who owns 5 of those above mentioned pitchers for like 260 points today.
This is my safe haven to bitch, but seriously, what do you do? Nothing right?
I’m on like a 4 year shitshow with fantasy sports. I don’t have a single day where my opponent gets lit and has 1 hit. It’s like an automatic .300/10/5/10/5 day for everyone of my opponents. Also, the other thing, I don’t think any of my opponents have had ERAs over 3.25 this season to WHIPS over 1.05. I’ll give you my password so you can waste your life dissecting how one human has that bad of luck.
Every Grisham homer this season has been against my teams too.
Godspeed brother.
I just looked, here’s my opponents ETAs and WHIPS this week:
2.32/1.06
0.53/0.65
0.59/0.78
1.89/1.05
I mean what the fuck dude.
Ha, ouch, gotta turn some time right?
Yamamoto has received poor run support, which is surprising. Even more shocking is that Glasnow faced a similar issue last year. I remember he had five consecutive starts where the Dodgers, failed to score a single run for him while he was pitching. LAD ranks third in runs scored per game this year and was second last year.
Weird
10 tm redraft
drop josh lowe or Lu-Ga-JR for M.Shaw?
I need sb and can use aranda @ 2b if matt shaw is terrible
appreciated…chefs kiss on the taylor ward buy by the by I look like a geneyus
Ok, if you need SBs, lose Garcia — nice!
I am struggling with pitching. I am last in whip, era and K. I ashamed to say it. Second in wins though. That makes sense. I picked all of the wrong mid tier guys w/o a true ace and had some reliever blowups. I’ve made all of the wrong sit vs start calls. I got nothing from bryce miller (1st pitcher drafted) and stubbornly have used baz. It still amazes me how bad Baz is doing with his stuff even with a crappy slider that he shouldn’t throw. I need to cut one: nick martinez or pfaadt. Qs league. Thanks
Ha, damn…Pfaadt