(NOTE: THIS POST WAS RELEASED EARLY THIS WEEK ON OUR PATREON. IT’S $10/MONTH)
Giants’ President Farhan Zaidi puts some soil on top of a newspaper clipping of Jonathan Villar’s DFA’ing. Waters it every day for five weeks straight, then what slowly crops up from it is David Villar. Do they have to now feed and take care of David Villar or does he take care of himself? Are there rules to caring for a newly sprouted David Villar? I don’t know, but there’s nothing Farhan Zaidi can’t do. Zaidi is the original Zaddy, amiright? What is a Zaddy? I have no idea. In order to give you some cold hard facts (facts that I place in an Igloo at the foot of my bed), I went to look at the Giants’ lineup to make sure David Villar was an everyday starter, and that team is so hilariously bad. Their lineup is, “What happens when reasonably thought-out platoons go very bad.” Joc Pederson should be in a platoon? Okay, and so should Lewis Brinson. LaMonte Wade Jr.? He’s gotta be in a platoon, and so should Austin Dean! J.D. Davis? Oh, he must be in a platoon. Great, because Wilmer Flores has to be in a platoon too! The only problem? One of these platoons would be fine, but to have seven of them? Ha, my gawd, bro. That’s awful. Someone said they could have an entire lineup of platoons, and no one asked if they should. So, is David Villar in a platoon? I don’t think so. He seems to be the only one not in a platoon. Of course, the only reason any of this matters is because he’s been crazy hot, and has big-time power. In 84 games in Triple-A, he hit 27 homers, and .275. In the majors, his average is likely not going to ever be that high, but the ball off his bat might. Bam! Hashtag nailed it! Anyway, here’s some more players to Buy or Sell this week in fantasy baseball:
BUY
Eric Haase – What a guy has done, or Haase done, as the case may be, over the course of the season, doesn’t matter at this point. If a guy was good in April, it’s irrelevant at this point. With that said (Grey’s about to turn this ship around!), I was just looking at Eric Haase on the Player Rater, and it’s not great, by any means, but he’s above Dylan Carlson, and, that’s a big woof at the moon, what on earth happened to Carlson? That guy’s career got so derailed.
Danny Jansen – Putting on MC Hammer pants and doing the Hammer Dance while singing, “Dancing Machine” to the name “Danny Jansen” and spraining a quad muscle, falling into a heap and screaming for the wife to pick up Danny Jansen for me.
Kyle Farmer – Reds have Buck Farmer and Kyle Farmer, and the biggest Reds’ fan, Willie Nelson, smoking a doob, telling the guy next to him at Panera Bread about Farm Aid. That’s an unbeatable combo, like turkey dipped into cheddar-broccoli soup.
Triston Casas – Already gave you my Triston Casas fantasy. It was written while saying, “Wow wee, wee wow.”
Dermis Garcia – He got included late. Ya know, by the Dermis of his teeth. He has 17 homers in only 89 pro games this year…*mumbles under breath*…and a 41% strikeout rate in the majors.
Garrett Cooper – Marlins’ offense with Garrett and Brian Anderson doesn’t sound fearsome on paper, because they have freakin’ Anderson/Cooper. What’s next a linebacker named Wolf who is a blitzer? Anderson/Cooper? Terrible, if you have no New Year’s plans, even worse if you’re hoping to get some power into your fantasy lineup, but they’ve been hot.
Joey Meneses – Told you about grabbing Meneses so long ago, that your fantasy team’s going through menopause.
Edmundo Sosa – Grabbed Sosa in one league, while wearing a McGwire jersey and hugged myself in the mirror for all the 1998 feels.
Tony Kemp – Just thought of something, is it possible to do a shift next year by putting Tony Kemp, or any tiny player, in a Baby Bjorn, and affixing them to another infielder’s chest? Will be writing the league office about possible loopholes!
Elvis Andrus – To illustrate how dumb I am, I just googled, “What does ‘Elvis has left the building’ mean?” Turns out it means he’s left the building. Just out here winning with a giant-sized brain!
Isiah Kiner-Falefa – Yo, this Israeli Diner-Falafel is hotter than chickpea! *Cancel Police break down the doors* Please! I’m sorry! Before dragging me away, can I use the bathroom? Please, I have to tinkle!
Rodolfo Castro – Been so impressed by this guy’s power, which brings me to a separate point: Why are the Pirates the only team with early games? I don’t want to watch the Pirates every day!
Yoan Moncada – Went to the 30-day Player Rater, expecting to find some Moncada numbers that were so great over the last month, and instead I found he had one amazing game about a week ago. Meh, 3rd base gets the gas face, so I added him here.
Mark Mathias – Who? I haven’t the foggiest idea, but he’s hot. He’s on pace for a 35-homer, 18-steal, .300 season, which is funnier than anything else Mr. Prorater could come up with.
Brendan Donovan – Going off the last blurb, and Donovan has actually been much better than Moncada over the last month. By the way, if you’re going off of “Guys who have been better than Moncada for longer than a month,” you better make room, because it’s “everyone.”
Josh Jung – Already gave you my Josh Jung fantasy. It had no idea what was to come.
Mark Vientos – Already gave you my Mark Vientos fantasy. It was singing Taylor Swift, but when asked what was it singing, it said, “Nothing.”
Jordan Groshans – Here’s what I said the other day, “Marlins called him up. Groshans sounds like a supermarket that you can’t afford. ‘I want to Groshans for some cereal and it cost me sixteen dollars for Honey Nut Cheerios. Next time I’m going to Whole Foods.’ Groshans, besides being a total rip-off for produce, was the piece the Marlins got for Zach Pop and Anthony Bass. By the way, I understand a lot of music “the kids” like, but I’ll never get into Pop and Bass. Sounds awful. Any hoo! Groshans is a high-contact, .300 hitter-type, who’s got light speed and some power that hasn’t shown up yet. He was in the top 30 3rd base prospects by Itch, and he’s an NL-Only pickup for now.” And that’s me quoting me!
Aristides Aquino – Me during a Q&A, repeating a question back to the person in the crowd, “‘Do I regret giving the nickname, The Greatest GOAT of all-time aka GGOATOAT to Aquino?'” I thoughtfully consider this, then, “No, not at all. Though, when he retires, I can give it to someone else.” The person asking the question rips off his mask, revealing it is Aquino, “I will never retire! Muahahahahahaha!”
Lane Thomas – “Lawrence of Arabia, British Beatlemania, Lane Thomas, John Glenn, Liston beats Patterson…” Oh, but Billy Joel isn’t the greatest songwriter of all-time. Okay, tell that to Olivia Rodrigo.
A.J. Pollock – On this week’s podcast, I came up with an elegant solution for the White Sox and La Russa. Have every White Sox hitter take swings, then move La Russa one step closer with each swing. When their swings get worse, that’s the closest La Russa is allowed to the field. He can manage from wherever he is. Parking lot? Sure, there’s cellphones.
Oscar Gonzalez – Surprised to see this O.G. so high up on the 7-day Player Rater, not because he hasn’t been hot, he has, but he’s at best a four-category guy, and that value butts up against a glass ceiling of fantasy value. Also, for those who googled “Butts up fantasy,” and found us, welcome! We won’t judge!
Bubba Thompson – A steals guy named Bubba? What’s next, a singles-hitter named Just Dong?
Zach McKinstry – Taken over the leadoff spot on the Cubs, and, I’m trying to figure out more positives…Hmm, he’s got a little speed, little power, and, um, a good glove? I got nothing else.
Andrew Heaney – This is a Streamonator call, like the call it makes to the nearest 7/11.
Josiah Gray – This is also a Streamonator call. “I was just wondering if your store clerk would like some company late at night, since I never have to sleep.”
Jose Leclerc – This is funny in an unfunny way. I kept saying the Rangers remove closers for no reason, in regards to Joe Barlow, but I was sorta joking. They just seemed to replace him with Jonathan Hernandez for no real reason. Barlow’s injured now, but he wasn’t then. Any hoo! It was a goof, I was kinda joking, then the Rangers did the same thing with Leclerc, removing Hernandez! Jonathan Hernandez had a 1.69 ERA, blew one game, and was removed from the closer role. Just like that!
Carl Edwards Jr. – Hard to find a guy who less looks like a burger-eater than Carl Jr., though, if you’re ever eaten at Carl’s Jr., I wouldn’t eat a burger either. Maybe a shake. Finnegan should be out as Nats’ closer, but I don’t know if he is, necessarily. He just “should” be. Also, I wouldn’t chase two deep in the Nats’ pen unless incredibly desperate.
John Schreiber – Red Sox, unlike the Rangers, change their closer once a month, but it’s because their guys overstay their welcome. By the way, a team is not “avoiding naming a closer” or “using guys situationally” if you just throw a guy to the 9th repeatedly until they’re not good anymore. That’s just burning through guys.
Seranthony Dominguez – If I’m Seranthony, I would walk out to the mound to close games with a Corgi on a leash, while wearing a crown. Though, he could be walking to the mound, Corgi in tow, crown on head, to work the 8th inning, which is just embarrassing.
SELL
Trevor Story – How the Story ends, “Clearing the shortstop shelves, putting away the once-promising for the cold, dark winter. Hibernation isn’t just a country filled with people named Hiber. It’s time to turn the page, like a person with very sticky fingers in a library. Poetic, I know. Trevor Story makes me feel that, for what we should’ve had, and ended up with instead. Fin, but not as in a dolphin, but as in the end.” Okay, on the reals, I just looked at Story’s stats and I would move on in shallower leagues, if there was better options, but I’m kinda already interested in that Story for next year.
Wander Franco – Just don’t think he’s healthy, and not sure he’s been that way for a while. Allow me to put on the Semisonic song, Closing Time. You don’t have to go home, and if you’re healthy next spring, you might be able to come back in, but you can’t stay here anymore. If it’s a keeper, I wouldn’t trade Wander Franco for a flannel shirt from the Property Brothers collection at the Gap, but I would go to our Fantasy Baseball Trade Analyzer and explore options.
One more for you
H2H week. Would you start Luis Garcia @ Tampa
Do you think it’s a trend where Heaney only goes 4-5 innings. Is he a drop in QS league. I have J. Gray and H. Greene in IL that I need to active
Thanks
Pick up Taylor ward, Peña, or Rodolfo? Thanks grey
Or Blackmon
You didn’t know what “Elvis has left the building” means or where it came about? It’s because fans refused to leave Elvis concerts until they heard the announcement because they thought he’d come back out and sing another song!
Damn I must be old.
Haha, didn’t know but yeah it makes sense now
Need a U for the week. Cats by priority for me are BA/R/RBI/SB/HR. Which one should play: Daza (7 at Coors), Kwan ($17 Hittertron), Taylor Ward (deep stats call, he’s starting to hit and walk again), Rengifo (hot, hitting leadoff)?
Rengifo
Hulk Rengifo – two dingers today. As I previously commented, Rengifo is a palindrome of Ferigno.
I went to look at what I’ve actually gotten from him, i.e. stats when he has been in my active lineup, and. . . zero steals? I know I’ve missed some when he been on the bench but over 123 ABs I’d have guessed for some legs in there.
An updated view of a previous comment when comparing Walker and Soto’s active production on my team:
Player | H/AB AVG R HR RBI SB OPS GP
Walker 76/283 .269 49 19 51 1 .864 78
Soto 68/294 .231 57 16 41 2 .851 88
This may have ruined Soto for me.
Haha, that is so sad
re: Soto
Must be getting other stats tho…are you starting him for SBs?
I don’t always have him in but sometimes. Honestly, there are times I’ve been tempted to play him over Soto.
What I’ve gotten from Rengifo:
Player | H/AB AVG R HR RBI SB OPS GP
Rengifo 36/125 .288 15 7 19 0 .835 30
Thought we were going to get another pitcher pulled while allowing no hits. But then Strider gave up that HR.
Yeah, same!
I need someone to replace Kirk for at least this coming week. Heim is available but Diaz plays all week in Colorado. Bart is also an option with 4 games in Colorado. What do you think?
Diaz
Should I worry about starting Heaney @ SF $19 or Springs vs. Tex $29.6 today? Need WHIP and W’s in a starts limit league where I’m currently on pace to hit the limit by the end of the season.
I’d start both
It seems a silly question, but I cannot begin to tell you the dogshit luck I have had in my super shallow home league over the past few years. I’m currently trying to stave off an implosion against a 2nd place team that has little idea what they’re doing.
My SP, spanning 4 starts this week, has given up 13 ER in 21 1/3 to the A’s alone. Anyway, thanks as always for your input.
Haha, been there! Dropped Grissom to activate Albies-type luck
Oof. See, you get me.
It’s the classic, “I have a strong, but not unassailable lead. All I need is for a bunch of things not to go wrong in the next 3 weeks.”
*Week 1 of 3, most everything proceeds to go wrong*
Haha, the unassailable will forever be the assailable in fantasy baseball
Especially the shallower the league.
Oh completely
Rodolfo or Lane Thomas?
Rodolfo
Hey Grey! Looking good in my 10 team h2h semifinal. Thanks for all your help!
I will have 4 moves next week for the final.
For my first move, I am looking at adding Ed Cabrera for two starts and dropping Taijuan. He clears waivers tomorrow.
Wondering if this second move is worth it or hold Fraley
I’ve got Fraley (6 vs bos &mil) and some options for next week.
Andrus – 6 vs cle, vs det
Joc- @col 4, @ ari 3
Haniger (dtd back but available sat off bench) – 7 gm @LAA, @oak, @kc
Thoughts?
I’d go Joc in COL
Thanks!
No problem
Hudson and Quintana for the Cards today:
16 IP/0 ER/11 K
Hey man. Your Yordan and Tucker recommendations have worked wonders in my H2H league.
Albies fractured finger
Oh my god are you serious
You were serious, oh man
Always!
Been carrying Haniger during my bye-looking to maybe drop for:
Pederson 4 @ Coors & 3 @ Az,
Gunner 3 vs Det & 4 vs Hou
Daza 4 vs SF and 3 vs Sd
McMahon same as Daza
Rengifo 1 @ Sea, 3 @ Tex & 3 @ Min
Would you drop Mitch and pick up one of these or hold. If he’s a drop who do you prefer as his replacement.
Thanks
Pederson at Coors sounds good
Look into your crystal ball, Grey, and see if any of these dudes will be worth a $10 bid in a 14-team 5×5 roto OBP league next March …
(I can grab these FAs now and use them in a keeper league)
Luis Rengifo, Ramon Urias, AJ Pollock, Trent Grisham, Tyrone Taylor, Jace Peterson, Austin Slater, Nick Gordon, Raimel Tapia, Lars Nootbaar, Eric Hosmer, Chas McCormick, David Villar, Mark Mathias, Rodolfo Castro, Tony Kemp, Romy Gonzalez, Dermis Garcia, Akil Baddoo, Michael Conforto, Brandon Crawford, or Wil Myers.
No…Not no I wouldn’t look, I did and they won’t be worth $10…Maybe Rengifo, but prolly not
that’s what I was afraid of….thanks
Is Grissom a drop now? Should I replace him with Rodolfo Castro?
Yes, go with Castro
Grissom is a regular once again after Ozzie broke his finger.
Please pick one
Miley at Miami
Jose Suarez home vs Sea
Rogers at Wash
Suarez
Starting Carroll against musgrove or olson against nola?
What’s the opposite of a batty call? A MOlson Golden? What an anchor he’s been
Haha yeah indeed…
Corbin
drop hoerner for lane thomas or garrett cooper?
or Villar
thanks grey
Villar
Thomas
Another bad Clay Holmes outing. Holmes or Fairbanks?
Fairbanks
Latest Shadows season was disappointing!
I liked Colin and the Djinn
Hi Grey,
1. i was going to sit Brady Singer on the road at Boston. Do you agree?
2. i have a chance for five double headers and was going to start all of the following.
Brendan Donovan at St. louis
Andres Gimenez at Minn
Kyle Farmer at St. louis
TJ Friedl at St. louis
Jake Fraley at St. louis
Would you start all of these five?
thanks
martin
1. Yes 2. Yes
Thanks!
No problem
Carlson back; O’Neill to the IL.
Aw geez
Mornin’!!
Looks like Hunter Greene coming off the IL today for the am game for Cincy @ STL.
you activating/ starting him or is he more of a “wait & see”?
I’d need to drop someone to activate (roster below):
12-team, 6×6 (OBP/QS), H2H, Redraft league
C: W. Smith
1B: J. Bell
2B: B. Rodgers
3B: J. Ramirez
SS: W. Franco
OF: Yordan, Teoscar, Julio Rodriguez
UTL: O. Cruz, Cronenworth
BN: Grissom, McMahon
SP: DeGrom, L. Webb, Manoah, Kirby, Carrasco, J. Ryan, P. Lopez, Jon Gray.
RP: Hader, Bautista, Montero
IL: Bednar, H. Greene
I wouldn’t activate him
If you want to tho, I’d lose Jon Gray
Thanks. Keeping him on the IL since Gray is starting today and has a nice matchup according to SON.
Thanks again!
Cool makes sense
I’m thinking of dropping Stanton or Grissom to pick up Aquino or Villar for this week and next of playoffs. It’s a keep 6 but I think I would keep Trout, Alvarez, Rutschman, Henderson, Devers, and Story over them.
Grissom for Villar…I guess on Giancarlo if you need to
Which of these weekend matchups would you start? 12-team roto, need QS’s and K’s but have to watch innings.
Jon Gray (@ TB)
Singer (@ BOS)
Rogers (@ WAS)
Springs (vs TEX)
Springs
Missed Hunter Greene from the list the other day of pitchers pulled during a no-hitter. This was the game the Reds lost despite throwing a no-hitter.
May 15 Greene @PIT 7.1 IP/9 K/118 pitches
Apr 13 Kershaw 7 IP/13 K/80 pitches
Jun 25 Javier 7 IP/13 K/115 pitches
Aug 23 Verlander 6 IP/10 K/91 pitches
Sep 13 Ryan 7 IP/9 K/106 pitches
Apr 8 Manaea 7 IP/7 K/88 pitches
Sep 16 Verlander 5 IP/9 K/79 pitches
Sep 16 D. May 5 IP/4 K/69 pitches
I guess I may have missed others where the stats were not impressive.
Pretty happy with Dustin May’s start, even if it was less than some others
Yes, Better than I was expecting. Combined with Keller, Stroman, Walker, Wacha, and Helsley for a 3 Win/1 Save/27 K/1.89/0.75 night! Somehow, didn’t undo the first 5 months of bad stats, though.
HAHA, nice tho!
Two more SPs removed with no-hitters yesterday! Verlander now is holding 5 spots on the Best 100 Starts list, while Dustin May still has none. I guess his low strikeout total left him just outside the top 100.
Sep 16 vs OAK Verlander 5 IP/9 K/79 pitches
Sep 16 @SFG D. May 5 IP/4 K/69 pitches
12 Justin Verlander Aug 23 MIN 6 IP/0 BR/10 K
38 Justin Verlander Apr 16 @SEA 8 IP/3 BR/8 K
70 Justin Verlander Jun 29 @NYM 8 IP/3 BR/6 K
85 Justin Verlander May 10 @MIN 8 IP/3 BR/5 K
90 Justin Verlander Sep 16 OAK 5 IP/1 BR/9 K
Verlander so ridiculous this year, absolutely amazing
Hey Grey! Happy weekend. Playoff matchup 10 team h2h. One move left. Down two Ws and close in whip. Tied at 1 sb.
Would you rather stream Quintana vs cin, [email protected], Kopech @det, or roll the dice on bubba to take sb?
Got Carroll, varsho, goldy, Teoscar for some potential at sb
Quintana
Atlanta and TB both give lots of Save opportunities.
.. Iglesius (heir apparent if Atlanta decides to change from Jansen)
.. Pete Fairbanks has been flawless (but that doesn’t mean Cash uses him)
Pete Fairbanks or Iglesius?
Fairbanks
In the title game next week and my OF is in shambles. It’s a H2H points league, with 3 OF spots and 1 Utility spot to fill.
OF:
Jake Fraley
Oscar Gonzalez
Teoscar Hernandez
Jon Berti
Joey Meneses
Utility:
Any of the guys above and these additional options:
Wander Franco
KeBryan Hayes
Thank you.
Jake Fraley
Oscar Gonzalez
Teoscar Hernandez
Ke’Bryan
Thank you.
No problem
Need a catcher for the weekend
Haase vs Giolito, Cueto and Kopech
William Contreras vs. Ranger, Nola and Falter
Thanks
Haase
SF is like an extremist group with the platoons. They don’t care if it means defense in the OF or parts of the infield suffer. How has it worked for them?
4 of their 5 starters have era’s higher than fip. Webb is the only one who has been unscathed or has got lucky with babip and fielding. They are 3rd worst in runs saved and defense efficiency (not sure there is a good way to measure team defense better than watching them play). It has been painful to watch and to have owned cobb for most of the year.
Haha, yeah, it’s so wild whatever it is they’re doing and it’s clearly not working in any way
Agreed on Franco. I don’t think he’s been healthy since April if you look at how he has done since what appeared to be the start of a good year.
Yeah, it’s not encouraging for final few weeks
Villar or India?
Villar
Need hits and walks today. No need for steals. Who sits?
Eduardo Escobar home vs Keller
Nick Gordon home vs Tristan
Farmer at Flaherty
Gordon
Thanks! He hits RHP pretty well but Tristan has been so tough.
Yup
Would you drop MJ Melendez for either of those catchers?I like that MJ bats leadoff and plays every day but he has cooled lately.
I’d hold
Ok thanks!
No problem
Lux,Donovan,or Escobar ROS? Dodgers have 8 home games next week.
Carson Kelly or Langeliers ROS?
Jung or Torkelson this season? Keeper?
Heaney,Luzardo or Snell ROS?
Floro, Hughes or Kimbrel?
Thanks!
Escobar — Langeliers — Jung — Heaney — Kimbrel
Ryan McMahon or Villar?
McMahon
10 team standard 5×5 NL only roto league. Who are you starting this weekend vs NYY – A. McCutchen or J. Peterson? Could use help across all the categories.
Thanks.
McCutchen
Swap kirk for jansen?
Sure
Slightly different questions than elsewhere in thread.
1) ROS. Rengifo or Villar?
2) ROS. Gunnar or Villar?
Rengifo…Gunnar…but constantly evolving due to matchups
7 games in Colorado next week, including Giants (Villar, Joc, Crawford, Yaz to name a few). Feels like a trap. What to do?!?!? Go all in on Coors?
Go all in!
gotcha!! Love HTH playoffs!!
Good luck!
Mea culpa. I didn’t realize SF Villar wasn’t Jonathan Villar.
I want an infield bat. I see Villar plays every day; and Diaz (has hit in both games he’s been back from IR) also generally plays. But I’m unsure about Grissom.
Villar; Grissom, or Amadyus Diaz?
Villar
Rengifo or David Villar in a keeper?
Rengifo
So we have a 30/30 guy (Adolis), a 20/30 guy (Rice-a-Rena) and a 30/15 guy (Stumpy Popeye Doyle O’Neill) …and we moved Dylan in a shrewd trade for pitching help??? Man, me Cards are stacked!
-Guy waking from a 4 year coma
HAHAHA
Amazing
Hey Grey!
ROS: Jung or Villar?
Hmm…Tough call, prolly go Jung, but coin flip
hmm, ok. how about ROS: Villar or Gunnar?
Wait! lol.. CORRECTION?
who would you drop ROS: Villar, Gunnar, Adames, Lindor,Torres.
Lindor, Gleyber, Gunnar, Villar
Sorry, I ranked…Who to drop? Adames
More comes down to how much you want upside and risk…Villar has been better than all of these guys recently…So, Villar is best, hottest…But Gunnar and Jung are upside plays…I’d prolly go upside
yeah…tough call..But,I have been looking for a reason to drop Adames…maybe I found a reason: to pick up Villar..
Sound good?
Thanks!
Yeah, that works for me