Yesterday, Adley Rutschman (2-for-4, 3 runs) hit his 10th and 11th homer, as he returned to Camden for the first time since his trade. He hit that 2nd home run and you know he was like, “Yeah, former sugar daddy, this is what you’re not getting no more!” Then as he rounded the bases, he touched his rear with his fingers, made a sizzle sound and said, “Kiss my grits!” While the O’s were like, “Does he know we got top pitching prospects for him and just acquired Luis Robert Jr. for cash and he has the same number of homers as him?” Snap! They’re snapping back and forth. Keep things fresh. Also, fresh as in the fresh-faced, Roman Anthony (1-for-4) who hit his 3rd homer, and 2nd homer in two games. He’s come back from the IL smoking hot, and I am talking about his hitting. I said the other day Trevor Story *could be* as good as Roman Anthony in a month. I merely meant it’s possible, because there’s not a lot of time left in the season, so don’t inflate value in Roman Anthony. Ya know, the guy with three homers on the year while Adley had two in one game. Snap! People are still snapping! But, remember, don’t have them filming an episode of the show, Snapped, of you being mad at a fantasy baseball blog. Anyway, here’s what else I saw yesterday in fantasy baseball:
Jake Bennett – 6 IP, 3 ER, 5 hits, zero walks, 7 Ks, ERA at 3.34. [not washing my hair for five years so I can pull off a white man with dreads] Ja-Be! Ja-Be! I hope you like Ja-Be too!
Nick Sogard – 1-for-3, 2 RBIs and his 4th homer, 2nd homer in a week. Fun fact! A basketball team can have a shooting or point Sogard. Awkward Segue Alert! Our preseason fantasy basketball is getting going. Think you can sign up for the RazzJam now if you like.
Luis Robert Jr. – 1-for-3 and his 11th homer. LouBob paying immediate dividends like this 401K! (401K is the number of strikeouts I banked on for my first pitcher drafted, Hunter Brown. He’s still got 308 in him in his remaining five starts, right?)
Pete Alonso – 1-for-3, 2 RBIs and his 33rd homer. Albombso!
Brandon Young – 6 2/3 IP, 3 ER, 6 baserunners, 7 Ks, ERA at 3.42. I let the day’s performances dictate the opening, and there was a brief moment yesterday when I thought B. Young was going to B. Lede, and all I could think, “What on earth am I going to talk about with this boring guy?” Anyhoo! Streamonator.
Christian Encarnacion-Strand – 2-for-3, 2 RBIs and his 8th homer. Grabbed him for the O’s stint in Colorado, where they made all the Rockies’ pitchers look like [trying to think of a good Rockies’ pitcher]…uh, Jeff Francis, but I held CES for one more day, and now he homers. Lucky > Good.
Pete Crow-Armstrong – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 39th homer. Mentioned this on the podcast the other day, but, eff it, let’s do a rehash! If PCA gets to 40 homers, which I imagine he will, he will get a 40/40 season. If he hit 50 homers, he’d get a 50/50 season. It’s sorta like how Juan Soto started stealing like crazy last September. When players approach significant milestones, they suddenly turn it on. If PCA only needs a handful of steals, you better believe he’s getting them. No one in his position will get, say, 42 homers and hunker down at, like, 38 steals.
Kevin Gausman – 7 IP, 1 ER, 6 baserunners, 9 Ks, ERA at 4.38. Sonavabench! Oh well. Honestly, he’s lucky it wasn’t a sonavadrop in all my leagues and that I still have him on teams is more about the depth of my leagues vs. him doing anything worthwhile. Yes, I said he was lucky I didn’t drop him. That’s right; earn hundreds of millions of dollars playing a game, but what players really care about is whether I’ve dropped them in my league.
Ryan Rolison – 1 IP, 0 ER, ERA at 2.93, as he got his 2nd save with Jacob Webb sidelined. Not sure how long Webb’s out for, but Palencia is unusable, so Ryan Rolison could get some saves, but he’s a lefty, so maybe Trent Thornton or Zeferjahn. No, Zeferjahn isn’t an arcane musical instrument.
Logan Henderson – 7 IP, 2 ER, 3 hits, zero walks 7 Ks, ERA at 2.48. After what the 1927 Cubs did to Harrison and Misiorowski, this feels like a huge victory, even if he took the loss. Wrigley is such an impossible place to trust starters because one moment it’s a pitchers’ park and the next it’s Whirly Field with 95-MPH winds.
Andrew Vaughn – 1-for-4 and his 6th homer. Brucely, I think it’s kinda cute if a 1st baseman has less homers than Vlad Jr. Quaint, really. Nostalgic. Of another time! Like of April when Vlad Jr. wasn’t dead-last in power for 1st baseman with 125 games played or more.
Heriberto Hernandez – 1-for-4 and his 23rd homer, 2nd homer in a week. Want to believe fully in Heriberto and how he’s on a 27/15/.230 pace for his first full season, but I also remember being burned by Kyle Stowers this year. The HardHit% is nice for Heriberto, and, yup, that was solid for Stowers too.
Agustin Ramirez – 1-for-4 and his 3rd homer. Comatose Grey, “I just drafted Agustin in March as my 1st catcher in two-catcher leagues and I don’t think anything could make me happier than seeing him go 25/15. Maybe 30/20! Psyched! So, he just hit his third homer on Thursday, what is it, April 5th? 2nd week of the season? Was I Conk City for a week or two? Hey, why is everyone tiptoeing out of my hospital room?”
Sandy Alcantara – 6 IP, 4 ER, 7 baserunners, 2 Ks, ERA at 3.54. Sandy vs. the Royals is a tale as old as me in 3rd grade where I coronated Sandy Duncan and made her a Queen of my diorama. What, only me?
Carter Jensen – 3-for-4, 3 runs, 3 RBIs and his 22nd homer, and 3rd homer in two games, and 4th homer in a week. Carter didn’t say, “Anybody want a peanut,” that was Andre the Giant. He did say he’s hot. Or I did, about him. Don’t get caught in semantics.
Cal Quantrill – 7 IP, 0 ER, 4 baserunners, 5 Ks, ERA at 2.79. In LABR, I’m in fourth place, and might be able to get to 2nd. Anyway, I had a one in WHIP, and now I have a two. Thank you, Cal Quantrill!
Corey Seager – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 14th homer. Before or after 200th overall in 2027 drafts? Before 200? Oh, you’re doing that thing where you spin your nose on the handle of a bat and try to run, only you’re not trying to run but you’re trying to answer questions.
Shane McClanahan – 5 IP, 4 ER, 7 baserunners, 3 Ks, ERA at 3.36. He threw only 72 pitches, which usually would send me to Twitter to see if I missed an injury, but I know with McClanahananananananan it’s just a short leash, and on Twitter I’ll just read how some people want to hogtie Shane for making them lose their bet.
Kade Anderson – 5 IP, 4 ER, 9 baserunners, 3 Ks, ERA at 5.40. Glad I dropped him prior to this start. Kade can be an ace, but he’s a rookie and on a pitch count, so [raspberries lips].
Zack Gelof – 2-for-5, 2 runs and a slam (16) and legs (11), and 2nd homer in two games, and he’s not even in Bing Bong. Think I’m drafting Gelof in all leagues next year. I got too much love to give!
Blade Tidwell – 5 IP, 2 ER, 2 hits, 5 walks, 5 Ks, ERA at 4.43. Congrats on only giving up two earned runs while allowing five walks. Blade’d, I suppose.
Konnor Griffin – Could be activated today. He won’t be in this afternoon’s Buy column, because I assume he’s rostered everywhere, but, if he’s not, grab Konnor.
Tanner Bibee – 4 IP, 5 ER, ERA at 4.06. Early games yesterday went like this: Bad pitching and no good hitting. Weird afternoon of games. A slate of yuck and meh.
Anthony Santander – Jays manager, John Schneider, said Santander started hitting off live pitching. Not sure why he’s giving updates for players who retired three years ago.
Jose Soriano – 4 2/3 IP, 3 ER, ERA at 3.52. Jo-So so-so. Streamonator says Soriano gets Bing Bong next, which is a start I would be very hesitant about. That leaves you with some tough options if you’re in a H2H playoff. At a certain point, you have to go for guy with a great matchup vs. a solid starter who got you here but has a terrible matchup.
Brett Bateman – 3-for-5, 1 run, hitting .330. Again, that’s .330 in 91 at-bats. He’ll be in this afternoon’s Buy column. [a baseball bat spins out, large font on the screen SPLAT!] Bateman!
Shohei Ohtani – Wasn’t in the lineup because he grimaces after every swing. Do you have a grimace category? Did you draft all Mets thinking it was a Grimace category but turned out to be a grimace as in a wince category?
Tarik Skubal – 5 2/3 IP, 2 ER, 11 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 2.86 as he was out-pitched by Quinn Matthews – 5 IP, 1 ER, 8 baserunners, 4 Ks, ERA at 4.38. Great stuff from Skubal. An emoji that awkwardly salutes then high-fives itself.
Hunter Brown – 6 IP, 2 ER, 8 baserunners, 7 Ks, ERA at 3.31. Because it was a short schedule and not that many day games, I checked out Brown’s stats. I know he’s likely injured, but I thought maybe he’d have decent underlying stats. Um, ha. What is going on in Houston that they haven’t shut him down and sent him for the surgery he clearly needs? His stats? Let’s see, how about a 4.8 BB/9. Oh, yeah, that’s great! Definitely nothing odd there for a guy who had a 2.8 BB/9 last year. He’s basically out there ruining his arm with each start, and no one’s doing anything. Can you bet on whether someone will need surgery during Spring Training next year? Because if so, put a five spot on Brown.
Jose Altuve – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 15th homer. At 200 overall, are you in on Altuve in 2027? You are? You’re crazy. Little Joe Flow, as I started calling him in my mind, is done-zo. As the kids say, he is cooked, no cap. He’s a good yardstick to measure children for a rollercoaster, but otherwise nothing here.
Luis Castillo – 4 IP, 6 ER, ERA at 5.57. Wonder if the White Sox could’ve traded for Reid Detmers at the deadline, because whatever this is with Luis Castillo isn’t working. It was never going to work either. They should piggyback him with a fox who wants to take him across a river.
THERE’S A NEW POST FOR FOLLOWUPS FOR ME
I strained over it awhile, and it kind of pained me, but I finally dropped Dingler for Big Dumper. I figured if I can’t win my fantasy league I can at least gun for the cover of Proctology Today.
HAHA
Yohandy Morales or Ty France
Ty
Haha, The Flo reference from Alice was classic!!!
Haha
what about the question below? LA Muncy or Brooks Lee ros in a 12 teamer? Thanks!
Lee
got it, thank you.
No problem
Would you take Brooks Lee over a slumping (LA) Max Muncy? I am in a dogfight for first in a 12 team roto 5×5. Thanks, hope you and Cougs and Ted have a great weekend!
Hi Grey! For the stretch run, would you recommend dropping any of Bichette, Okamoto, or Pasquantino, for Ty France. Or, meh; stick with who brought you to the dance. Thanks!
Bichette
Dynasty Francisco Alvarez or Leo Bernal?
Bernal
hi grey, i currently have liam hicks, but feel like he sits a lot of games so im looking tonget a back up catcher. would you prefer jensen, gasper, perez, kirk or basallo? and would any of these guys get the starting role over hicks?
Jensen
Ok- I think somebody slipped me some crazy pills. The robot has Eury at $27.9 vs NYM Monday and one of your competitors just put out a glowing article on him. Has there been a secret fantasy writers convention for the last week or so where y’all didn’t have access to games?
TLDR- Would you really open a playoff week with Eury Monday vs NYM?
Yes
OK- Thanks. I guess I can hedge things by buying stock in whatever company makes Pepto Bismol.
Haha
Hey Grey! Awesome writeup!
Getting into the home stretch for my 5×5 roto (OBP and Sv+H) league. It is a 3 way battle at the top! Its a limited move league and i have 4 left.
squad:
C: Herrera
1B: Devers
2B: Arraez
SS: Elly
3B: Sal Stewart
OF: Schwarber, Chourio, Carroll, Jenkins
UTIL: Witt Jr
Bench: Springer, CES
SP: Skubal, Glasnow, Henderson, Tolle, Melton, Jared Jones, Eury Perez, Kade Anderson
RP: Varland, Latz, O’Brien, Webb
IL: Holderman, wetherholt, Max Meyer and Devin Williams
1)With Holderman on the IL I have an open roster spot and need pitching. Who do you like between: Painter, Clay Homes, Ian Seymour
2) Would you use a second move to drop any of my SP’s (i assume Kade) for any of the WW pitchers i mentioned outside of the one you picked in question 1?
3) I need RBI/HR – would you drop any hitter for one of these WW options: Bolte, Spencer Jones, France, Heriberto Hernadez, Hector Rodriguez – this would be a third of my 4 moves left
Thanks so much!
1. Holmes 2. Seymour 3. no, hold your moves
Hi Grey,
Would you cut Rafaela and pick up Luke Keaschall?
Thanks!
Yes
Thank you!
No problem
should I start either today:
Lowder V Mil or
Javier V Ariz
Protecting a small lead . H2H pts
Nah
I need to pick up a starter for tomorrow in my H2H pts league:
Bassit V Bos
Scherzer @ KC
Kikuchi @ Pitt
Gusto V Cubs
Abbott V Mil
Yuck, I guess Bassitt
With Pallante off the IL and starting tonight, drop Mize to activate? …or since it’s @COL should I not activate/start Pallante just yet?
Thanks!
I wouldn’t start him in Coors
Good morning. Sorry, lots of questions today. Redraft, 12 team, standard 5×5.
Thank you!
1. Marte, Keaschall, Seager 2. Keaschall, Anthony, Montes 3. Seymour, Harrison, Taj 4. I don’t know I’d look up current news for who’s back fastest, maybe Pages 5. Arias, again, who’s ever up, maybe King
Happy Friday, Grey!
Out of the running for top 2 in an NL H2H keeper, but getting Konnor back is a boost in morale for next year (barring a full lockout) as well as a much better INF option during our playoffs than Freeland/Nuñez combo covering for an injured Wetherholt.
Also, I currently have Weaver, Morillo, Ed. Henriquez, and Smith (SF) as my RPs. Would you drop any of them for one of the NATs Tolman/Ribalta?
Thank you!!
Nah
NL keeper league. Who would you rather have for 2027: Adael Amador or Jared Young?
Neither? Adael
Would you drop Conine or MClark, or as a bench bat are they so close it doesn’t matter, thank you
Conine
Per MLB Rumors: Rutschman is the first player with a two-homer game for two different teams against each other in the same season.
Wow, that’s random
The current top 40 on the PLAYER RATER with their change since the ASB:
RANK+/- ………….. $+/-
5 Pete Crow-Armstrong $12.40
-1 Jacob Misiorowski -$4.60
1 Yordan Alvarez -$2.10
1 Jordan Walker -$0.60
4 CJ Abrams $4.20
-3 Ben Rice -$7.70
1 Cam Schlittler $1.20
22 Sal Stewart $8.60
3 Junior Caminero $1.80
-8 James Wood -$15.60
-4 Hunter Goodman -$2.90
25 Pete Alonso $7.80
-3 Shohei Ohtani DH -$0.20
18 Chris Sale $5.70
77 Fernando Tatis Jr. $15.50
0 Cristopher Sanchez $1.00
3 Matt Olson $1.90
30 Dylan Cease $8.30
2 Miguel Vargas $0.80
7 Yoshinobu Yamamoto $2.20
13 Randy Arozarena $2.90
-8 Mason Miller -$2.80
-8 Kyle Schwarber -$2.50
51 Drew Rasmussen $9.00
13 Bryce Harper $3.10
30 Alec Burleson $6.00
54 Jesus Luzardo $10.20
-15 Otto Lopez -$3.60
-10 Bobby Witt Jr. -$2.30
6 Louis Varland $1.60
31 Drake Baldwin $5.60
31 Elly De La Cruz $5.00
26 Michael Harris II $4.60
-12 Chase Burns -$2.50
16 Parker Messick $3.70
-12 Dillon Dingler -$2.70
13 Yandy Diaz $3.00
22 Gavin Williams $3.50
-4 Luis Garcia Jr. -$0.90
30 Jake McCarthy $4.10
Great stuff, Vin!
Biggest gains in $ Value on the PLAYER RATER since the ASB:
$18.40 Logan Henderson
$18.30 Alex Bregman
$16.90 Cade Cavalli
$15.50 Fernando Tatis Jr.
$14.90 Jacob Lopez
$14.70 Mason Montgomery
$14.50 Andrew Painter
$14.30 Shane Bieber
$14.00 Gerrit Cole
$13.90 Emilio Pagan
$13.30 Tyler Mahle
$13.20 Jeff McNeil
$13.10 Noah Cameron
$12.70 Andres Chaparro
$12.50 Rafael Flores Jr.
$12.40 Brandon Pfaadt
$12.40 Pete Crow-Armstrong
$12.30 Spencer Jones
$12.20 Jackson Merrill
$11.40 Ty France
$11.40 Lawrence Butler
$10.90 Blake Snell
$10.80 Cal Quantrill
$10.80 Francisco Lindor
$10.60 Seiya Suzuki
$10.30 Daylen Lile
$10.30 Jac Caglianone
$10.30 Bryan Abreu
$10.20 Jesus Luzardo
$10.20 Tyrone Taylor
$10.20 Paul Blackburn
$10.20 Randy Vasquez
$10.10 Hunter Brown
$10.10 Tim Tawa
$10.10 Jeremy Pena
$9.80 Will Dion
$9.80 David Peterson
$9.70 Steven Kwan
$9.70 Brayan Bello
$9.70 Kyle Freeland
$9.50 Josh Hader
$9.40 George Springer
$9.40 Yuki Matsui
$9.40 Pedro Ramirez
Andres Chaparro! This is awesome, a fascinating list of 2nd half players
Biggest drops in $ Value on the PLAYER RATER since the ASB:
-$15.60 James Wood
-$15.40 Nick Kurtz
-$14.60 Byron Buxton
-$14.00 Zack Wheeler
-$13.10 Joe Ryan
-$12.10 Ryan O’Hearn
-$12.00 Andrew Velazquez
-$11.80 Juan Soto
-$11.50 Aaron Judge
-$11.30 Bryce Miller
-$11.10 Samuel Basallo
-$10.90 Konnor Griffin
-$10.80 Shohei Ohtani SP
-$10.70 Max Meyer
-$10.40 Josh Jung
-$10.30 Justin Wrobleski
-$10.20 Shea Langeliers
-$10.20 Casey Schmitt
-$10.10 Paul Sewald
-$9.80 Spencer Steer
-$9.60 John King
-$9.40 Brayan Rocchio
-$9.40 Spencer Horwitz
-$9.30 Kerry Carpenter
-$9.10 Davis Martin
-$8.80 Blaze Alexander
-$8.70 Jeremiah Jackson
-$8.70 Brandon Marsh
-$8.70 Michael Soroka
-$8.50 Paul Skenes
-$8.50 Curtis Mead
-$8.30 Bryan Reynolds
-$8.30 Matt Chapman
-$8.30 Tyler Freeman
-$8.20 Owen Caissie
-$8.10 Oswald Peraza
-$7.80 Victor Caratini
-$7.70 Antonio Senzatela
-$7.70 Taylor Ward
-$7.70 Ben Rice
Ugh, don’t like this list, ha
I have a ton of guys on this particular list, but hardly ever on the good Vin lists!
Haha, I know, brutal
PLAYER RATER rank of first 20 players unranked at the ASB:
398 Hayden Wesneski
483 Alex McFarlane
558 Nate Lavender
575 Hagen Smith
580 Gerardo Carrillo
609 Elieser Hernandez
636 Scott Blewett
647 Ben Joyce
658 Khristian Curtis
683 Wyatt Olds
692 Erik Tolman
693 Jared Simpson
704 Anthony Gose
707 Jason Foley
717 Justin Martinez
725 Dedniel Nunez
730 Quinn Mathews
733 Mason Adams
737 Jackson Jobe
745 Justin Hagenman
Wyatt Olds, don’t I knows it
Just added Sagesse as a shmotato and now at Coors so plan to start him next few days. But that means leaving two of these remaining three on my bench: Muncy, Trout, Canzone. So basically which two would you start among Sagesee, Trout, Muncy, Canzone for rest of week if need homers, rbi, runs?
I don’t know their matchups outside of Saggesee since you told me…I guess Canzone
Grey
in an 11 team roto keeper league. I am currently in 1st place. My pitching is overall good
Would you drop
Kade Anderson for
Jacob Lopez
Anderson has been a disappointment and would cost $6 if I were to keep him next year
Not sure he would even be worth that
Thoughts?
Thanks
$6 doesn’t sound bad, but I don’t know your keeper situation
I can keep as many players for up to 3 years with $5, $10, $15 increase for year 1, 2 and 3
I have no problem holding, I am curious how he does in his next start at home vs Texas
Are you thinking hold for now
I’d think hold
Then I shall
Thanks
No problem
I grabbed CES for the Rocks and he sat two of the 3 games. He’s gonna start against these Boston lefty’s though. Big homer last night off Chapman. One of those, happen to put the game on not knowing it was on national tv in NY for some reason, right for CES’s at bat.
Ha, yeah
Hey Grey!
Sonofabench! (Henderson). crap. I had McClanahanahanahan also starting so thought that would make up for not starting Logan. (10tm H2H). Lost 3 points on that yesterday. damn!
You are right in that you cant trust Wrigley.
Guess we wont have to worry about that when they move to Indiana! <chuckle, as a Crew fan>
Well, If I get booted I at least look forward to dropping VladJr on the last day, cause ya know: SPITE
He’s got Sale and Fried tonight. and I got “no one.” Would you stream Jared Jones? BOT super likes him, but I think he’s too risky.
Vs. LAA? Sounds fine
Haha
Frothing over Henderson next year! Not looking forward though to keeper decisions like $4 Henderson or $12 Skenes though….
Tough call!
You think your fans are going to let that Roman Anthony revisionist history stand? I’ve been a Razzball reader forever, and I like your big takes. Here’s what you said about Anthony:
“Roman Anthony – 2-for-4 as he was activated from the IL. I’m not a fan. Honestly, I’m not even sure what the attraction is. I’m pretty sure if he looked like Devin Mesoraco, no one would care. I’m not even joking. . . .
Trevor Story – 2-for-3, 1 run as he was activated from the IL. So, he, unlike Roman, could be valuable for a month of games.”
Definitely not “Trevor Story *could be* as good as Roman Anthony in a month.”
This is the fun part… own that opinion and let’s see how Anthony does moving forward.
Not sure what I’m not owning. I have said since February of this year I was not a fan of Roman Anthony — https://razzball.com/roman-anthony-2026-fantasy-schmohawk/ — I’ve also said I’m open to liking him in the future just like I was open to liking PCA who I didn’t like in the preseason, and now I’ve seen him demonstrate he can be great for a full season. It’s about price vs. value. Trevor Story is free and has had full seasons where he’s been great including last year
Who do you like more for ROS Jensen or Raleigh?
Cal
Thanks. I checked out Cal’s schedule the week after this one and he gets Bing Bong and Coors, too. I’ll let my catcher scab heal now.
Haha
You’ll deny it but I know you scrubbed your “2007 Starters to Target: Jeff Francis” post from the site.
Haha, the price was good at the time!
At first I missed note about Kade, so now this comment is no longer valid lol.
Alas