Giants lied to us. They said they weren’t calling up Bryce Eldridge (0-for-3) this year. Just thought about the Lilliputian who read, “Giants lied to us,” stopped reading and started running through town, screaming bloody murder. Come back, wee friends! I’m talking about the San Francisco Giants! One Lilliputian who was planning on visiting San Fran this fall, “There’s Giants in San Francisco? Egads!” Welp, now that I’m just talking to regular-sized humans, the Giants lost Dom Smith, and had an opening at 1st base for Bryce Eldridge, so Frank Voila! Here he is! Kinda wild that Dom Smith would block anyone. Is that the Dom Smith who had one good game in 2019? That Dom Smith? Okay! So, Bryce Eldridge was 12th on the top 50 fantasy baseball prospects that Itch just gave you this Sunday. Eldridge went 25/1/.260 in the minors this year in 384 ABs with a 29.3 K%, and 30.8% in Triple-A. Think he’ll be as good as advertised at some point — 40+ HRs, .260 — think Pete Alonso in San Fran. Call him Effete Alonso. — but right now he’s 20 years old, and strikes out way too much. If you want to take a flier, go for it, but he seems like he’s set up to be as good as, say, Jac Caglianone this year. Nothing for pitchers to fear this year, even wee ones. Anyway, here’s what else I saw yesterday in fantasy baseball:
Kai-Wei Teng – 4 IP, 0 ER, ERA at 6.41 vs. Zac Gallen – 6 IP, 1 ER, 3 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 4.73. This matchup was billed as, “A cowboy you don’t want to sit behind at the movies. Ya know, starting with his Teng/Gallen.”
James McCann – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 5th homer, and 2nd homer in two games. If your keeper league team’s name is Anal Retentive, then congrats on having Raleigh and McCann.
Elly De La Cruz – 1-for-3, 1 run as he was dropped to 7th in the order. Only because they couldn’t drop him to 17th.
Sal Stewart – 3-for-5, 3 runs, 2 RBIs and his 4th homer, 2nd homer in two games, and third homer in a week and he’s only played in 11 games. Not sure if you’ve watched Stewart, but I have. Easy power. Ease. E. Pow. Ur. Nothing to it.
Zack Littell – 5 2/3 IP, 4 ER, 5 hits, zero walks, 3 Ks, ERA at 3.86 vs. Matthew Liberatore – 6 IP, 2 ER, 5 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 4.30. This matchup was billed as, “Streamonator is telling you to start neither, but you’re in a H2H matchup and you need every start you can get so you’re starting both of these guys with your hands over your eyes.”
Nolan Arenado – 2-for-4 as he was activated from the IL. Cards’ season saved!
Bo Bichette – Visiting a specialist for a 2nd opinion on his PCL sprain. The specialist’s name is Dr. Bobert Donald, but his friends call him BDon and he’s going to tell Bichette to retire.
Orelvis Martinez – Jays released him. He was a top prospect, but he was hitting .176 in Triple-A. In other words, he will be backing up Isiah Kiner-Falefa and Adam Frazier in Pittsburgh next year.
Trey Yesavage – 5 IP, 1 ER, 5 baserunners, 9 Ks, as he was called up. Ye Olde Savage was just gone over in my Trey Yesavage fantasy yesterday. tl;dr, I like him, but I don’t know how much he’ll pitch this year. In keepers, yummers. Yesterday, he looked fantastic. He had nine Ks in 69 pitches. Nice. Ye Olde Savage has a devastating splitter, my favorite pitch that I want every pitcher to throw. In the last few weeks, we’ve received a bounty of young starters. It’s like the universe is saying, “Don’t worry, prematurely balding man, you don’t have to worry about rostering Ober and Bibee next year.”
Joe Boyle – 6 IP, 0 ER, 3 hits, zero walks, 5 Ks, ERA at 4.64. as he was recalled by the Rays. I’m still uncontrollably excited about Boyle for next year. For this year? Stream.
Simeon Woods Richardson – 6 IP, 0 ER, 5 baserunners, 11 Ks, ERA at 4.31. I streamed him because everyone else was taken. Let’s hear it for lack of options!
Brooks Lee – 2-for-4, 2 runs, 2 RBIs and his 15th homer. Sonavabench! I sat him for Carson Williams. Let’s here it for too many options! (Same league as SWR too.)
Colton Cowser – 1-for-4, 3 RBIs and his 15th homer, and 2nd homer in two games. Hot schmotato alert!
Kyle Bradish – 5 IP, 1 ER, 8 baserunners (4 BBs), 9 Ks, ERA at 2.45. His peripherals since his return: 12.3 K/9, 3.3 BB/9, 2.98 xFIP. Stop talking dirty to me!
Daylen Lile – 2-for-3 and his 6th homer. He’s been great, was last week’s lede Buy, but you’re not ready for that conversation. [fingers to earbud] Hearing you are ready. Okay. My bad.
Spencer Strider – 7 IP, 1 ER, 6 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 4.64. And with that…Shut him down. I’m sorry if you need him for fantasy but please let him rest.
Matt Olson – 4-for-5, 2 runs, 4 RBIs and his 26th homer, three homers in three games. The Atlanta Dead Cat Bounces.
Ronald Acuña Jr. – 2-for-4, 2 runs and his 17th homer. It’s a low-key massive bummer that he looks like a shell of the pre-six-knee-surgeries Acuña.
Drake Baldwin – 3-for-5, 4 RBIs and his 16th homer. If you’re drafting Adley Rutschman next year before Drake Baldwin, then you know the reflex hammer that doctors use to hit your knee? They should use that to hit your head.
Kyle Schwarber – 1-for-3 and his 53rd homer, 3rd homer in three games. Kyle Schwarber’s 22 HR vs. LHP as a LHH this season are tied for the most in MLB history. He ties Matt Olson (2021) and Stan Musial (1949). Hopefully Schwarber has a better 31-year-old season than Olson did this year. (It’s a joke; Schwarber’s older; don’t make me ‘splain shizz.)
Bryce Harper – 1-for-3 and his 27th homer. Kinda wild how a 30/12/.265 season is going to feel boring from Harper, when it really shouldn’t.
Emmet Sheehan – 5 2/3 IP, 1 ER, 4 baserunners, 7 Ks, ERA at 3.17. As he followed Anthony Banda (1/3 IP, 1 ER), for what I can only describe as Dave Roberts trying to pretend he’s smart.
Max Muncy – 1-for-5 and his 18th homer. Max is the Munciest!
Andy Pages – 3-for-4, 2 runs and his 25th homer, hitting .276. If you didn’t know any better, you’d think there was an actual reason Pages was hitting 8th, behind Alex Call, Miguel Rojas, Muncy, Freeman, Teoscar, Betts, well, being behind everyone but Ohtani makes zero sense.
Mookie Betts – 1-for-3, 3 RBIs and his 19th homer. Mookie Best!
Pete Crow-Armstrong – 2-for-4, 2 runs and a slam (29) and legs (35). I’ll be honest, I thought he had 29 homers and 35 steals back in July. [looking up his stats] Actually, not far off.
Michael Busch – 1-for-5 and his 28th homer, 2nd homer in three games. Looks like I made a smart move trading Lawrence Butler for Busch at the All-Star Break! [blows on knuckles, wipes knuckles on shirt, sees knuckles had ketchup on them and it’s now on my shirt] Damn! I am being faux braggadocios, don’t come for me. Busch has been barely startable most of the 2nd half. Butler’s been awful, and maybe slightly better.
Jameson Taillon – 6 IP, 0 ER, 4 baserunners, 3 Ks, ERA at 3.93. Fun fact! I’m half-I-Taillon. Less fun fact! He’s a Streamonator call.
Jack Leiter – 6 2/3 IP, 3 ER, 6 baserunners, 4 Ks, ERA at 3.82. Final line looks better than reality where he gave up another three unearned runs for the ticker shock. I am not a Leiter fan. Oddly enough, zippo interest.
Josh Jung – 2-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 14th homer. If Josh Smith (1-for-3, 1 RBI) and Josh Jung merged into one giant Josh, who hit their combined 25 HRs and .250, I’d still have very little interest in Joshmongous.
Jason Alexander – 4 2/3 IP, 1 ER, ERA at 4.04. Not even five innings for Jason Alexander? Oh, I know, it was shrinkage.
Yordan Alvarez – Slipped on home plate, and had to be helped into the clubhouse. They diagnosed him with a left ankle sprain and it looked bad. Freeman had a similar injury last year, so if the Astros and Padres make the World Series, Yordan has a chance to do the funniest thing ever if the Padres bring in Nestor in relief.
.
Geez. Shittlererererer could get one more out. Wild as F
Haha, I know
Ed-Rod you prick. Or maybe I am for streaming him. Either way, a shit-show.
HAHA
Chip Caray just said, “I imagine McGreevy and Sal Stewart hooked up in the minors.”
Hello!
MY Andrew Abbott does not work as advertised. SMH
Haha
Same 20 team league, what about Springer for R Olson, Bogaerts and Burleson? I was just given this offer.
Btw this is for next season and going forward. I don’t have a chance of winning this year but have a competitive team. Will probably finish 4th out of 20. We can keep 20 major league players and 10 minor leaguers.
Yeah, gotcha
Sounds fair, I’d want more
Marlins at coors. Are you still starting weathers in 12 team roto? He pitches tomorrow.
Eury Perez goes today, I assume you are still holding on a no here as well for Perez ros. Thanks
Eury looks done, but I’d start Weathers
Can we all agree that the HR Derby broke James Wood? He hasn’t been nearly the same since …
Brutally yes
It’s been tragic. I was pro Washington this year. I got Abrams too. Broke or busted means a few things for him.
Yeah, not great!
20 team league roto keeper (20)
A few days ago you said you would want more for Springer when offered R Olson and J Jackson. What about Olson and Santander? Maybe hope for a dead cat bounce next season? Or maybe Burleson or Bogaerts? Any of those tickle your fancy?
These are terrible
nl only, waldrep @ wsh or peterson vs sd?
Peterson
McGreevy vCIN or S Smith vBAL?
Smith
McGreevy. LFG!
Haha
Hey Grey! I kind of like Joey Cantillo tonight, but the SON hates it. Are you streaming him tonight at Detroit?
Also, what are your thoughts on Shane Smith tonight at home against Baltimore and Casey Mize at home against Cleveland?
Thank you!
I am streaming Cantillo…I’d stream Smith and Mize
Top 3 for Saves plus holds ROS
Strahm, Robertson, Akin, Thompson, F Cruz, Raley, Theilbar, Jax, Baker, Morejon
Thanks!
Strahm, Robertson, Morejon
Hey Grey, pick two to start this week…
Connoly Early vs ATH/@ TB, Ginn @ BOS, Pivetta @ NYM, Flaherty vs CLE and King @NYM/@CWS
Thanks
Flaherty, King
Like any of these SP for a QS tomorrow: Martin Perez vs BAL, Luis Gil @ MIN, Christian Javier vs TEX, Oviedo vs CHC, Brad Lord vs ATL
Not really…how desperate? Guess Javier or Oviedo if desperate
Not completely desperate yet but I do have some openings for starter tomorrow. Thanks as always!
No problem
Bryce Eldridge or Sal Stewart? Who is better for the next two weeks? And separately, who is better for next year?
Sal
Sal I think next year too, tougher to say…Bryce has K issues
Thanks!
No problem
12 team, 5×5 roto. 1250 Max IP. 79 Remaining (+10.2).
Start Eduardo Rodriguez v. SF? ($15.3)
I wouldn’t mess with him
Guess who would?!! Even picked him up on my 1 good team.
Haha, good luck!
Right there with you – LFG!
Haha
Gunnar has to be better next year no? Please say its so.
Can’t be worse?
Thats what Mets fans say every year.
Haha
Grey, what are your early thoughts on PCA for next year? I have him at $4 in my keeper auction league (OBP instead of AVG), so I am certain I am keeping him, but seems to me that there’s a wide range of outcomes for him next year. He’s young, so maybe he will mature in his plate approach (i.e. stop swinging at everything outside the zone and take some walks) or maybe pitchers will figure him out and maybe next year will be this August for six months. What do you think?
He’s easily worth $4
Would you start Gore today vs Atlanta? Luzardo tomorrow at LAD? Thanks!
No and no
Top 3 ROS (h2h) from among: Adell, Caballero, Clemens, Marsee, Laureano, S.Stewart.
Adell, Stewart, Marsee
Any concerns about CJ Abrams becoming a 1st half only guy? This is two years in a row with a massive drop-off in performance after he calendar flips to July.
Yeah, it’s troubling
Need a Yordan a replacement for the next two weeks of finals matchup. OPS, AVG, RBI, HR, SB, R
Otto Kemp: 2@LAD, 3@ARZ, 3 vs MIA, 3 vsMIN
Sal Stewart: 2@STL, 3 vs Cubs, 3 vs PIT, 2 @MIL
Daylen Lile: 3 vs ATL, 3 @NYM, 3 @ATL, 3 vs CHW
Jeremiah Jackson: 2@CHW 3vs NYY, 3 vs TB, 3 @NYY
Otto Lopez: 3 @COL, 3 @TEX, 3 @PHI, 3 vs NYM
Romy Gonzalez: 3 vs ATH, 3 @TB, 3 @TOR, 3 vs DET
Lile
Thought you would say Stewart
I almost did but 2 extra games is a lot
Good point! Thanks
No problem
Grey
1)Who would you prefer for the remaining 2 weeks
2) Who would you potentially keep for next year
Durbn
Sal Stewart
Meidroth
Otto Kemp
Parker Meadows
1. Stewart 2. Meadows
Where’s the hockey guy Viz at?
He starts Friday, I believe
Hi Grey!
crap! Crap! CRAP! <doesnt even close computer, just jumps out of window>
6 days left in my playoffs for 1st place and Yordo ‘slips on Home Plate!?”
Lemme see if I got this: I drafted him in the 2nd round-He plays til May then goes IL. I hold him for 3 months hoping for a nice ‘redemption’ surge at the end, but not with my luck—he comes back for 19 games to f’ing slip on Home Plate!!! RU kidding me. Ugh! the worst! what a LOSER!
Soo..some advice, please. 10TM H2H (no keep) 6 more days in playoffs.
1) I currently have Jeremiah Jackson on BCH to spot in for Yordo. Do you think I can ride him out, or should I go to 7day hitter projection and find the best OF on waivers? current lineup: C Goodman, 1B Pasketti, 2B Caleb Durbin, 3B Devers, SS Lindor, OF Wood, Arozarena, Jeremiah Jackson?, DH Ohtani
2) Should I start Ohtani today vs PHI, or keep him in DH (which would go empty if I started). (I was planning on Starting him) NOTE: I have Pepiot staring today as well)
3) I only have 4 moves left and need to stream. Which 4 best would you choose?
a) Ed Rod vs SF (15.3)
b) Christian Javier vs TEX (9.3)
c) Pfaadt vs SF (12.4)
d) Tolle vs ATH (2.0)
e) McLean vs WSH (25.5)
f) Ober vs CLE (24.3)
g) Bradish @ CHW (21.3)
h) Holmes vs WSH (18.2)
i) Gallen vs SF (24.7)
j) Eury Perez @ TEX (14.0)
Thanks!
Lose Yordan 2. Use as hitter 3. McLean, Gallen, Ober and Pfaadt
Thanks!
Just to be clear, you said Pfaadt, right? You trust him ?
Also, sorry– CORRECTIONS:
Bradish @NYY (22.2)
and Gallen vs PHI (14.3)
not sure what hppened, I used Streamonator and it got glitchy..
Still same opinion?
No I don’t trust Pfaadt but I trust the other guys less…That Bradish start doesn’t seem nearly as good, Gallen seems fine
I just looked at the Streamonator because what you posted didn’t ring true, Bradish is not in New York
Thank you SOO much, and for the extra effort.
I will roll with Pfaadt, McLena, Ober and Gallen.
Thanks again, Grey!
No problem
What is goin on here? I am so confused..hahahaha
That’s home, not at NYY, massive difference than @NYY
ugh.. yeah.. sorry.. apparently not reading correctly with all the tears in my eyes!
Haha, No problem — just saying Bradish at home doesn’t sound bad
Yeah..I agree. I think I will take him instead of Pfaadt. I drafted Pfaadt with high hopes and dropped him in June. Never go back to an ex—you left them for a reason. lol
That makes sense
Championship week… as a general rule, do you cut a struggling star (looking at you Gunnar, PCA, Wood etc) and pick up a hot hitter (Moniak, Polanco)? Or do you ride or die hoping for the law of averages to kick in?
Lose Gunnar for Moniak
Hi Grey,
so sorry- could not find previous response.
I have 66 innings left.
Would you confidently start:
1. Schlittler at Minn?
2. Sprout vs Washington at home?
3.Connelly Early vs A’s at home?
4. Kelly at Houston?
5. Messick at Minn?
5. Was going to sit Valdez at home vs Houston. Would you?
Thanks so much for all your help!!
1 no 2 yes 3 no 4 no 5. No 6 Sure
Thank you!!
No problem
Grey Gray-
Thanks for an awesome season. Unfortunately, my team pooped the bed the first week of the playoffs and was one and done. Trying to decide on next year keepers in 12 team H2H (5×5) forever keeper league with no keeper limits.
Keep 6
Judge and Lindor are my definites
Who are my other 4 out of the following:
Olson
Jarren Duran
Soderstrom
Langeliers
Ben Rice
Campbell
Hunter Brown
Misiorowski
Kirby
Ohtani (the Pitcher)
I really can’t keep a catcher but the 30/8 Langeliers line is juicy.
Soderstrom/Olson seem to have identical numbers this year but Soderstrom is younger and steals.
In a forever keeper league, Campbell is really enticing, especially since he might be 1B/2B/OF eligible.
I hate pitchers especially after getting Kirby-stomped this year but I let him go and its a guarantee he wins Cy Young next year.
Brown is awesome (as Mis can be) but pitchers always one pitch way from blowing arm out.
As always, thank you.
Brown, Duran are also no brainers… then I guess Olson and Ohtani
Brandon Lowe has been pretty ice cold for a while now. He’s just a bench bat for me at the moment. Stick with him or make a swap for other MI/CI like Meidroth, Norby, Moniak, or Cowser?
Moniak
If you don’t really care about strikeouts but care about ratios and W-L, which of these are you more comfortable with this week. Thanks!
Bradish vNYY
Schlittler @MIN, @BAL
Bradish
No Top 100 starts yesterday, so here’s a look at who has the most Top 500 (of 4506) starts (and also how many times they have been on the losing side):
TOP 500 ( OPP )
34 PHI ( 10 )
25 DET ( 17 )
23 MIL ( 12 )
23 SEA ( 11 )
22 BOS ( 12 )
22 TEX ( 16 )
21 NYY ( 18 )
20 CHC ( 12 )
19 ARI ( 10 )
19 CIN ( 20 )
19 SD ( 19 )
19 TB ( 16 )
17 LAD ( 15 )
17 MIA ( 15 )
17 PIT ( 22 )
17 STL ( 14 )
17 TOR ( 9 )
16 ATL ( 15 )
16 MIN ( 14 )
14 CLE ( 21 )
13 BAL ( 21 )
13 KC ( 16 )
13 LAA ( 18 )
12 ATH ( 16 )
12 HOU ( 19 )
11 SF ( 22 )
11 WAS ( 21 )
9 CHW( 23 )
9 NYM ( 14 )
3 COL ( 35 )
Here are the individuals with the most top 500 starts (and how many bottom 500 starts they’ve thrown):
9 Tarik Skubal ( 0 )
9 Zack Wheeler ( 0 )
8 Bryan Woo ( 0 )
8 Carlos Rodon ( 0 )
8 Paul Skenes ( 0 )
8 Zac Gallen ( 1 )
7 Garrett Crochet ( 0 )
7 Jesus Luzardo ( 3 )
7 Joe Ryan ( 1 )
7 Kevin Gausman ( 2 )
7 Lucas Giolito ( 4 )
7 Nathan Eovaldi ( 0 )
7 Nick Pivetta ( 3 )
7 Ranger Suarez ( 3 )
7 Yoshinobu Yamamoto ( 3 )
Luzardo! Haha I never would’ve guessed Rodon that high…
This is awesome, Vin! Thanks so much!
A couple of questions today
1. I am currently using Doyle, Ramos, Seiya and Josh Bell. Guys like Otto Kemp, Sal Stewart, Lile, Kody Clemens, Beck, Norby are available. Make any switches?
2. Please Rank the following SPs:
2-start Freeland vMIA vLAA
Weathers @COL
Bibee vMIN
Latz vMIA
TWells @CHW
Cecconi @MIN
Thank you.
Seiya for Lile; Bell for Stewart 2 wells, Bibee, Weathers
Thoughts on Jonathon Aranda for next year…looked great until the wrist injury…also do you think Kyle Stowers break out is real? Thank you another great year! You guys are the best!
Thanks! I like both of them but real to a point, Aranda and Stowers have their limits… more category fillers than future stars
My first auction draft in a deep weekly 14 teamer. Spent big early on Yordan and Jackson Merrill. I want to feel Weightless Again.
Hahaha
Grey!!!!
Awesome!!
Rodney Dangerfield quote of the day for September 16, 2025
You know you’re drunk when you take a leak and your fly’s still up..
– No Respect (1980)
Cheers,
Ante
I think we’ve all been there, amirite? LMFOALMFAOLMOFA
Thanks!