Brewers called up Caleb Durbin. What? No, not Dyler Turban. Hey, first rule of Vindaloo Club is don’t talk about the Pakistani Brad Pitt playing Dyler Turban in the Bollywood movie, Vindaloo Club. Second rule, same as the first, stop talking about it! The third rule of Vindaloo Club, don’t ask for mild. It’s curry, it’s supposed to be hot! So, Vinny “It’s A Wonderful Life” Capra, Oliver “I Been” Dunne, Isaac “Bartender” Collins and Joey “Roo The Day” Ortiz are some of the names that the Brewers have bandied about to play 3rd base for them. It’s too bad they didn’t have a 3rd baseman to start the year for them. A guy who had a 14.5 K% in Spring Training with two homers and 10 steals in only 54 ABs. A guy who went 10/31/.275 last year in the minors in 335 ABs. A 25-year-old guy! Teams, man, they be dumb. So, they finally called up Caleb Durbin who looks like he was ready since 2023. Guess there’s a worry that, while he makes a lot of contact — 8.6 K% in minors this year — he makes a lot of weak contact, so he might do something like 5/20/.230, which is legit bleh, but he has excellent speed, so he’s worth the grab for steals, if nothing else. Just don’t talk about Vindaloo Club! It’s the 1st two rules! Anyway, here’s what else I saw yesterday in fantasy baseball:
Oneil Cruz – 1-for-3 and a slam (4) and legs (9), and 2nd homer in two games. Oneil’s gonna do what I thought he’d do last year and be this year’s Elly and this year Elly’s gonna be last year’s Oneil, and next year I’m gonna draft Oneil and he’s gonna be Elly this year and Elly this year is gonna be this year’s Oneil. Why can’t I get my years right?
Andrew Heaney – 7 1/3 IP, 0 ER, 7 baserunners, 4 Ks, ERA at 2.13. Picked up Heaney — thanks, Streamonator! — and now I’m struggling to drop him and I’m absolutely falling for the ol’ banana in the ol’ tailpipe, right?
Grayson Rodriguez – Shut down with shoulder pain. Bummer, thought he’d be the first pitcher ever to return from elbow pain.
Tanner Bibee – 5 2/3 IP, 6 ER, ERA at 5.85. Start counting down the days until we hear he’s hitting the IL with an arm injury. Or maybe we get the always fun, “I’ve been pitching through a dead arm.” Yeah, and now I have a dead fantasy team.
Daniel Schneemann – 2-for-4 and his 2nd homer. It’s the Schneemann! What’s up, Schneemann? Long time, no Schneemann!
Gunnar Henderson – 2-for-4, 2 runs and his 1st homer. “I tried to stuff him into my garbage disposal and it’s backing up all over my kitchen–Hold on! He’s moving! Gunnar’s alive!”
Ryan O’Hearn – 2-for-3, 3 RBIs and his 3rd homer, 2nd homer in as many games. Him or Pavin Smith? A true Sophie’s Choice.
Heston Kjerstad – 1-for-2, 2 RBIs and his 2nd homer. Member when he was a thing like 12 days ago? I don’t, I recently hit my head.
Tomoyuki Sugano – 7 IP, 2 ER, 5 hits, zero walks, 3 Ks, ERA at 3.43. The 1st time an O’s starter made it through seven innings this year. They have Coby Mayo going on his third year in Triple-A. Any hoo! Sugano looked like the best I think we’re going to get from him. It’s not bad, but it’s kinda zippo Ks and bleh. His ERA is exactly the same as his K/9. As Tarantino says about his exes, not a great feat!
Reese Olson – 5 IP, 0 ER, 6 baserunners, 5 Ks, ERA at 4.50. This was a day of great streamers on the Streamonator, but not great starters for shallower leagues, and solid starters for deeper leagues.
Will Warren – 1 2/3 IP, 1 ER, ERA at 5.17. Will stink of ass? Sure, on occasion! After the gym? Yes! After becoming a durian farmer? Right! But, no, this is a statement! Will stink of ass. I dropped Warren in one league where I had him (12 team), and I don’t think you can start him until you see something decent.
Oswaldo Cabrera – 2-for-3, 2 runs and his 1st homer. Thank God, for my sanity, Gunnar homered before Cabrera.
Taj Bradley – 5 1/3 IP, 6 ER, ERA at 5.24. I get it, but the stuff is too good to abandon. You weather tough matchups and bask like a cheesecake in a Spanish deli window for the good matchups.
Junior Caminero – 2-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 5th homer, as he batted fifth. Kevin Cash Needs To Stop is a graphic novel where R. Crumb depicts me flying to Tampa/St. Pete/wherever the hell they are, and stopping Kevin Cash.
Griffin Canning – 6 IP, 1 ER, 5 baserunners, 8 Ks, ERA at 3.43. Glad I was in a weekly league where I started Canning, before hearing he wasn’t going, and now seeing he did go. Is it a sign of how bad my team is that I need Canning? Stop starter shaming me!
Mark Vientos – 1-for-4 and his 1st homer. “Instead of aluminum cans tied to your bumper to celebrate your nuptials, look what I tied to it–Oh crap! He moved! Vientos is alive!”
Matt Wallner – Hit the IL with a hamstring strain. More like Matt Wailner. Freakin’ got his ass.
Luke Keaschall – Being called up by the Twins. Should be Keasch’all, but I will let slide, y’all. In Itch’s 1st prospect stash list of the season, he listed Luke, saying, “Minnesota has been playing Edouard Julien at second base, and he’s been fine so far, but Keaschall gives them a right-handed option who strikes out quite a bit less than Julien. He’s typically been under 20 percent throughout his pro career, whereas Julien lives in the 30 percent neighborhood. Keaschall is slashing .291/.415/.419 with a 19.5 percent strikeout rate through ten games. Brooks Lee and Royce Lewis are complicating factors, but Keaschall’s bat can clear its own path, and put Grey under the path.” C’mon, man! Keaschall is interesting, 15/23/.303 last year, but Baldelli has to platoon every gee-dee guy, so I’d think 15-team mixed leagues, until we see more.
Christian Encarnacion-Strand – Hit the IL with back inflammation and Noelvi Marte was recalled from the minors. Shame that Noelvi is acquiring more Greyhound points than fantasy value. In related news, Spencer Steer supposedly could be playing 1st base soon.
Emilio Pagan – 1 IP, 2 ER, ERA at 2.89, as he blew the save. Bit of trivia for you: His full name is Emilio Pumpkinagain. He shortened so no one would know he’d turn into one. Sneaky, p to the erhaps, but you have to use all the tools you have to close MLB games. Pagan’s leash just shortened a bit, and the other end of the leash is Diaz.
Brady Singer – 4 1/3 IP, 2 ER, ERA at 3.38. Streamonator liked this start and I did too, but he was victim of some shoddy defense. Francona must be thinking, “What is so great about this Elly guy?” That’s if Francona is thinking the same as me.
Austin Hays – 1-for-5, 2 RBIs and his 2nd homer in his 3rd game back. Before Hays first game with the Reds, he attended a secret society meeting called The Scheblers, founded by Scott Schebler, for random Reds outfielders who had one great season. Hays shook hands with Ryan Ludwick and accepted a ride around the grounds on the back of Scooter Gennett.
Jake Fraley – 3-for-5, 4 RBIs and his 1st homer, hitting .234. For s’s and g’s, I checked the Player Rater for Fraley — he was at 581! I lol that.
Emerson Hancock – 5 IP, 2 ER, 5 hits, zero walks, 4 Ks, ERA at 12.71. Fun fact! The Emerson Hancock Building has a Legal Seafood on the 1st floor.
Randy Arozarena – 2-for-4, 2 runs, 3 RBIs and his 4th homer, hitting .212. Truly concerned for the time during this season when he’s not hitting homers, because then it’s gonna be [raspberries lips]
Luke Raley – 1-for-2, 2 RBIs and his 2nd homer, hitting .163. Elias Sports Bureau said, “In this game, Raley and Fraley homered, which is Raley Fo’raley true.” Thinking Elias Sports Bureau might be phoning it in a bit.
Cal Raleigh – 1-for-5 and a slam (8) and legs (3), three homers in two games. It’s not completely fair they call it a steal when he can be standing on 1st and plopping his butt on 2nd.
JJ Bleday – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 2nd homer. Don’t let him get hot because, if he does, you’re gonna hear a lot about how I wrote a sleeper for him.
Brent Rooker – 3-for-5, 2 runs, 2 RBIs and his 5th homer, hitting .232. On pace for 45 homers, and we haven’t even seen yet how Bing Bong Stadium plays in 110-degree heat.
Tyler Soderstrom – 1-for-5 and his 9th homer. Sparkling Water with the Excitement Facial!
Lawrence Butler – 2-for-5, 2 runs and his 2nd homer. Personally, I’d like to see Butler get insanely hot. That’s my Ted Talk. It’s over. Go home.
JP Sears – 6 IP, 0 ER, 5 baserunners, 2 Ks, ERA at 3.13. This was vs. White Sux or rather, Sears vs. Sears filing for bankruptcy.
Jordan Hicks – 7 IP, 5 ER, 10 baserunners, 5 Ks, ERA at 6.04. While watching Verlander the other day, I thought about how we may never see a bad outing like 7 IP, 4+ ER again, because guys get pulled so fast. Well, lo and behold, Jordan Hicks!
Matt Chapman – 2-for-4, 3 RBIs and his 3rd homer, hitting .239. He’s sporting a mustache this year, so he’s good. You’ve come to the right place for hard hitting analysis!
Tyler Fitzgerald – 1-for-4 and his 2nd homer, and 2nd homer this week, and will be in this afternoon’s Buy column, but why wait for that?
Cristopher Sanchez – 7 IP, 2 ER, 5 baserunners, 12 Ks, ERA at 2.96. If you’re throwing a 96 MPH sinker setting up an unhittable change, you’re basically a top 20 starter, until your arm falls off.
Zach Neto – Supposedly returning today. But I have Tyler Fitzgerald replacing him now!
Kumar Rocker – 7 IP, 3 ER, 5 hits, zero walks, 8 Ks, ERA at 6.38. Don’t fully trust him yet. Why? He has a 6.38 ERA! This was an easier matchup than usual, and his next one looks awful as he goes to Bing Bong.
Adolis Garcia – 1-for-3, 2 RBIs and his 3rd homer, hitting .226. At least he’s not Joc Pederson (0-for-4, .060), who actually is hitting so poorly, the official scorer went back and took a hit away from him from last year.
Corey Seager – 2-for-3 and his 4th homer, hitting .306. Sorry, one more thing about Joc Pederson, who, yes, is hitting .060. He hit third yesterday!
Alex Verdugo – Called up by the Braves, as they sent down Bryan De La Cruz. This is like me seeing my Gunnar Henderson/Yordan fantasy team and thinking Elias Diaz at catcher is the issue. In Triple-A, Verdugo was hitting .207, so, yeah, he’s gonna fix things.
Pavin Smith – 2-for-3, 2 RBIs and a slam (3) and legs (1), and 2nd homer in two games. He will be in this afternoon’s Buy column, but you prolly could’ve figured that out since he’s been in the last couple.
Josh Naylor – 1-for-4 and his 4th homer, and 3rd straight game with a homer. About to let him rock me in his arms if he keeps this up.
Eduardo Rodriguez – 5 1/3 IP, 1 ER, 10 hits, zero walks, 9 Ks, ERA at 4.09. EdRod is actually an interesting one. I picked him up in one league and sorta fell in love after his first few starts, and my heart grew two sizes with each additional start. The ERA is telling lies. His peripherals: 11.9 K/9, 2.5 BB/9 and 2.36 xFIP is the best he’s ever looked. By a lot! And he’s had some usable seasons. If he can give 150+ IP of 3.50 ERA and huge Ks? Don’t spare me your EdRod.
A.J. Puk – 1 IP, 0 ER, ERA at 3.38. Seems to be pulling away with the closer job, when The Challenge’s Torey Lovullo is using Ju-Ma for one batter in the 7th, as he did yesterday.
Edward Cabrera – 4 IP, 5 ER, ERA at 6.52. EdCab is so bad he’d give me second thoughts about EdUber.
Connor Norby – 1-for-5 as he was activated from the IL. That’s 25 after 20’s fantasy baseball sleeper, Connor Norby! Here’s that Connor Norby sleeper.
Eric Wagaman – 1-for-3, 1 run, 1 RBI, as he played over Mervis. Who Wants to Be a Millionaire question, “Wagaman’s is A) Eric’s family B) A Florida supermarket–” B!!! Damn, I should’ve waited for the last two options. By the by, Who Wants to Be a Millionaire? Um, everyone? Is you dumb? Speaking of dumb, there should be a trapdoor in MLB dugouts. If a manager does a move like, say, “Bench their top hitter for Eric Wagaman,” then the trapdoor opens and they slide back to managing Triple-A. Would also help us not have to remember Clayton McCullough is the Marlins’ manager, a fact that refuses to stay in my mind. I’m gonna call him 2025 Marlins Manager all year.
THERE’S A NEW POST FOR FOLLOWUPS FOR ME
Hey grey thanks for all the great advice all the time!
This speedster chandler simpson got called… I’ve got toglia, Tovar, Buxton, norby that I could drop to make the move. Drop one or hold?
Ten team h2h
Hey Grey,
Ok to drop Gavin Williams for Mitchell Parker?
If you had to redraft who you taking
Lindor, Gunnar, or Witt
Witt
If I may …… Get ready for some Zach Neto fun he’s on his way this weekend, might be eased in but the player is going to be a top 5 SS ROS
Nice
12 team redraft h/h points ….
Elly or Oneil … ROS
Elly
Good afternoon. East coast afternoon. Great lines today on yesterday’s performances. You keep us entertained as well as great advice. *10 team roto. Waiting on news of Ozuna. Been streaming last couple of days. Even w/o Ozuna could use bench bat.
On wire: Happ, Misner, Buxton, W Abreu, Victor Scott.
Pretty sure you’ll say Happ but don’t mind buying a lottery ticket,
Current 3 outfielders Alvarez, Jasson D, & Ozuna.
Thanks
Thanks! Happ is clearly the best…Misner
best streamer for tomorrow?
liberatore at mets
roupp at angels
walker home vs Miami
Walker
keeper league: Paris on waivers, drop Holliday? Who has value ROS and a better fantasy future?
Hold
Would you bench any of these?
Alcantara @ PHI
Lugo @ DET
Senga vs STL
Eovaldi vs LAD
Sandy seems meh
Please rank
Mize Boyd Mahle Francis
Mahle, Boyd
Is Ragans too much to give up for Julio Rodriguez? 12-team 6×6 OBP,SLG and IP, QS, keeper
Nope
Catcher question that’s probably been answered. Rank Ruiz, Kelly, Murphy, Wells.
Thanks
Murphy
Why is Luis Robert so high on trade analyzer?
question for rudy
he’s had a rough first two weeks. he’s got a long track record.
If it makes you feel any better, Dusty would have Caminero batting 6th for the next 3 years
Ha
Burnes vs Cubs? One of the hottest offenses in baseball?
Maybe it is opposite day and that is why I am tempted.
Can’t imagine drafting Burnes then not starting him, but I wouldn’t have drafted him
Your honor, in my defense I have not drafted Burnes in any redraft league since 2022.
The only league I own him is in my dynasty where I acquired him in our first draft. I have been attempting to unload him since last July to no avail.
See evidence A, submitted below.
That’s pretty good! ha
Grey
ROS
M.Boyd or Y. Kikuchi
T.Casas or Y.Diaz
L.Robert or I.Happ
Boyd
Yandy
Happ
Liberatore or wesneski?
Wes
Would you start Rasmussen at “home” against the Yanks tonight in a 10 team pts league? Already down 40 in this weeks matchup. Trying to catch up. Thanks!
Sure
Treinen or Enilio Pagan in a league where a hold is worth half a save?
Pagan
Grey are you starting Woo in Toronto tonight?
Sounds fine
I am.
Elmo shrug emoji
Got downvoted for tryna help a guy. I see how y’all are.
Fitzgerald or Jordan Walker
Megill or Luke Jackson
Happy Easter
Fitz
Jackson
Easter!
Easter isn’t until Sunday, this is Passover erasure.
Haha
Taj Bradley or Gavin Williams ROS?
Taj
hey Grey, need a close BAD! Only have 1
12 TM 5×5 was offered Pagan/Nola for Matt Mcclain
My backup 2B is Stott and India :\
Pretty bad
Been hot with the red cross from hell across the roster and with full dyno that is not really a concern for long term. I grabbed Jose Soriano and Lodo early and thinking about another – maybe between Max M and Wesnezzki? Having Eury, Kirby, McClannnannnahan & JJones on IL sucks but also that Cease and Burnes are off to rufff starts! So Max or Wes or even Parker worth a grab?
Thanks as always Super G!
Happy Easter too yo!
Wes
You too!
How would you rank the following for Util slot (12 team redraft):
Lane Thomas, Heston, Manzardo
Lane, Manz
I received two offers, which do you think?:
1) His Alonso for my M. King + Naylor
2) His Alonso for my Gilbert + C. Walker
3) None of the above
12 team mixed keeper league, looking towards next year. Leaning towards option 3 but wanted a second opinion.
Thanks!
2
Thanks! Your responsiveness is a model for us all.
No problem
Pickup Aranda for either of these three? Josh Jung, Triston Casas, Cam Smith
Sure, over Smith
Hi Grey! Please be my tiebreaker: J. Jobe (v KC, Ragan) or B. Francis (v. SEA, Woo) for a spot start today in a RCL type league? Thanks!
Bowden
Thanks! Hopefully Vlad hits his 2nd (maybe even 3rd!) HR today …
Haha
Thanks! Hopefully Vlad hits his 2nd (maybe even 3rd) HR today …
Indeed
Hey Grey! How would you rank Durbin, Meidroth, and Amador for my sad MI spot? Thanks!
You did
Start Semien or Jung tonight against the Dodgers?
Semien
Stott or Fitzgerald ROS. Choose your fighter.
Stott
I have to choose 1. Do you prefer Gallen @CHC (Brown) or Mize vs KC (Lugo)? SON has them extremely close. Thanks!
Mize
How would you rank the following guys to stash in a 12 team keeper league:
Zebby Matthews
Nick Kurtz
David Festa
Bubba Chandler
Landon Roupp
Thanks and have a great weekend!
Kurtz, Roupp, Bubba
Funny thing yesterday reading your column. I was thinking, Grey is so right about Pavin Smith. He’s so boring. I just kinda shrugged and agreed and kept reading but took note of how spot on you were. I put Pavin in two different lineups daily, kinda yawn and don’t really think about it again until the next day.
Then Pavin went out and showed us how boring he is lol. Still, your assessments holds true my friend.
Haha, yeah
What should I do about Bibee? Is it reasonable to hold and will he improve, or is he finished?
Hold on bench, I guess
I think ima bench him for a start or two (3?) AND DEN drop if no signs of life
Happy Friday, Grey. Which two of the following would you start at 2B and MI: Luis Garcia, Andres Gimenez, Connor Norby, Dylan Moore, or Caleb Durbin?
Andres, Moore
Before the season, the optimal choice would have been Lu Gar and An Gim. Still early yet so I’d still say those two
We holding or giving up on Heliot in 12 teamers?
Guys like mervis, Schanuel, Heston, Jake Meyers on the wire…
Can lose him
Heliot has been fine?
I’d hold Heliot and find a way to add Mervis
Happy Easter Grey. Am i holding zebby another week or drop for
Gusto(vs sd at home today ugh )
Dobbins vs w sux today
Logan Henderson at home vs athletics
Or a 2 start week next week with Q. Prestier ??
Easter! — I don’t know Priester’s matchups
Priester gets sf(ray) and st.l (liberatore)
Home? Sounds fine
would you deal Altuve for Hoffman? or go for someone better?
No, trade someone lesser for a lesser RP
ok thanks, what are some guys you’d go after if you needed a closer?
Finnegan?
16 team h2h weekly with a ton of scoring categories for pitchers:
Innings Pitched (IP)
Earned Runs (ER) †
Strikeouts (K)
Quality Starts (QS)
Wins (W)
Losses (L) †
Saves (SV)
Holds (HD)
Earned Run Average (ERA) †
Walks plus Hits Per Innings Pitched (WHIP) †
Strikeouts per 9 Innings (K/9) †
We have 7 transactions allowed per week.
Daily lineup changes
2 P spots
5 SP spots
2 RP spots
Currently have
2 Ps – Pressly, Bautista
2 RPs – Ryan Walker, Ju Ma
Those 4 basically stay in their roster spots, unless there is a day off for one of them, and I have Treinen who I throw in.
Rest of the pitching roster is
Senga, B. Francis, Nick Martinez, Schwellenbach, Shane Smith, Logan Henderson, Jose Quintana, and Ben Casparius (sits in a SP every day to get some ratios and ks, with the occasional hold whenever he pitches.
Waiver wire is pretty light….
1) Thoughts on general strategy for that deep of league wtih that many categories? Better to have some pitchers with SP eligibility that work in relief?
2) Thoughts on waiver wire guys like Bido, Logan Allen, Hicks, Gillespie and if they have any value?
3) How to handle the 7 transaction max each week…streaming as often as possible or hold out for decent matchups, or hold most of the guys on the roster?
Thanks!
1. Yes 2. I wouldn’t mess with Hicks right now, or Gillaspie ever, but Bido and Allen seem ok 3. in a 16 teamer, i can’t imagien you’re streaming that many guys, so streaming one or two at end of roster…I like Henderson but I’d be streaming out of his spot
Thanks, appreciate the wisdom.
Agree with the thought on Henderson generally, but it is a keeper wtih 12 keepers mandatory, and young SPs and rookie were either kept or drafted way earlier than I expected (my first year in this league, took over for a manager that abandoned the team last year). But that is the reason I have him rostered right now. He may be the casualty to stream though….
No problem — gotcha on Henderson
Nick Martinez has been pretty bad….thoughts on dropping him for Bido or Allen, or using that spot to stream? Is he the low man on my pitching roster at this point (other than Henderson)?
Drop him for stream
12 team ROTO
A: McClain / Pfaadt
B: Rice / Nola
McLain
Good morning Grey,
Tyler Fitzgerald or Jeremy Pena in a 16 team weekly h2h categories (1 W or L per week for the matchup) with a ton of scoring categories:
At Bats (AB)
Hits (H)
Runs Scored (R)
Home Runs (HR)
Runs Batted In (RBI)
Walks (BB)
Stolen Bases (SB)
Batting Average (AVG)
On Base Pct (OBP)
Slugging Pct (SLG)
Fielding Pct (FPCT)
Pena
Happy Friday. Drop Luis Garcia, Friedl, W. Abreu or Story to pick up Roman Anthony?
Getting impatient with Garcia sitting on my bench and seems like there are other options for 15/15 or so guys.
Thanks!
Friday! Wilyer, but I guess if you’re not playing Garcia
Wondering just how long Ron Washington can milk the last bit of PT away from Zach Neto, who by all accounts is ready, in favor of Tim Anderson. Let’s go!
Neto and Tim Anderson platooning is going to turn me into the joker
How the Angels can continue to employ Washington as their manager is complete beyond me. I’m not expecting a response.
Haha
I can always count on Washington on finding a way to slow down the Angels.
Happy Good Friday
we starting Alcantara against the Phils?
Christian Walker… he had no spring training, so gotta give him long leash no? He’s too good to be this bad, especially in that park.
Edgar Martinez needs to show up at 4am and grab JRod by the ear, “Let’s go kid, we got stuff to do.”
Happy Good Friday! I’m starting Sandy, but I don’t owe him — I hear ya on Walker
No disrespect to Edgar… J Rod so far has doubled his BB%, kept k% about the same, and is on pace for 25-40. Babip is .224, the BA will be heading up. Buy low!
Nimmo, Durbin, hays, or Moore for bench bat
My team is solid on power, weaker on steals
Durbin
Wait, a Robert Crumb reference? Just a couple weeks ago I pondered what to do with a VHS copy of Fritz the Cat.
HA
Give it to me
(don’t give it to me)
(ebay?)
Start or sit Rodon today @ Rays?
Start
Morning Grey,
1. Bellinger or Christian Walker ROS?
2. Would you drop Crews for Hays or Bleday?
Cody
2. Bleday
Who would you add for you last Bench spot Kurtz or Mountcastle? Basically who has more upside ROS Kurtz or Mountcastle?
Kurtz
Thanks!
No problem
Good Morning Grey,
NL H2H (OBP) keeper ($280 cap)
What are your thoughts for CES ($10) ROS if/when his back heals up? I can hold him in an IL spot for now, and then see how Cincy plans to use him.
Thank you!
He’s been horrible almost his entire career
He has been for sure. Was just wondering if you thought his back might be causing his poor performance this year, and if we should give him a shot.
If you have room, I have no hope for him at this point
Is Naylor a sell high right now while Vlad Jr is a buy low?
Can Caminero hit 35+?
If you’re trading Naylor for Vlad, sure
Yes
As a Seager owner, defender, and all around lover *points to Seager in underwear poster on wall above bed* I didnt even realize he had magically risen, like Jesus. Made., his BA to .300+.
*looks at gamelogs* Oh….so in 6 games from April 11 to 17 he went from .205 to .306.
Bibee I am blaming on the cold because I dont want to look deeper.
Is there some kind of virus in the Rangers locker room? Something Semien has and is spreading to teammates that makes everyone absolutely suck at batting that they acquire? ATL seems to have something similar where talent cant hit. HOU, TEX, ATL are 25, 26, 27 with 66, 63, and 61 runs. Pitt has 67. Marlins have 75! Only teams worse that that trio are KC, CWS, and COL.
Can TB please make some trades so that we dont have 5 AAAA OFs running around that are indistinguisable from each other?
Will BAL realize that GRod is doneso so time to move the 5 surplus players at AAA for something? Beavers is up to AAA at 23 and an OF. Meaning he is blocked until 2030. Basallo there too. Bradfield Jr at AA also crushing it and an OF. Mayo is doing fine too, .242 4 HR 1 SB.
Maybe MIA is waiting for one good start from E. Cabrera and they can trade him and Alcantara for the entire AAA roster of BAL. How is Trevor Rogers doing these days?
MIA just sent a male order Bride to MIN, maybe they can send Wagaman for cash considerations as well after the Twins lose the other half of their roster to injury.
I will never understand or like WAR as a stat. Apparently, Vlad is x2 the player of Naylor since 2022. Since 2023, it still holds that he is roughly x2 better. The stats are pretty dang close though.
Since 2022:
2023 to present
They should be closer there…WAR — HUH! — what is it good for
Vlad and Naylor feel like they’re way closer than WAR indicates, but Vlad has had seasons where he’s #1 on the Player Rater and Naylor never has, so…Trevor Rogers, wow, that is a name from the past
Love ya, love your show. Bibee’s fastball and sinker velocity are fine but he’s not throwing the slider as much and it’s 4 mph lower than last season. Buy low?
I lost Steele so I need SP help. H2H, Pts league. Would you go Bohm for any of Woo, Joe Ryan, or Peralta? Do you rank them today the same as you did preseason?
Thanks! 4 MPH slower? That’s a lot…His numbers do not look like buy low numbers…I’d take Woo, Ryan or Peralta, you’ll never get them with Bohm is my guess
Is there any context on the slider? If it is a lot slower than other pitches maybe it is getting picked up more easily.
Trying to be positive on Bibee.
Morning Grey,
Going back and forth with a guy in my 12 team 5×5 league for a possible trade.
Thinking of countering the latest with his Yordan and Cristopher Sanchez for my Jazz and Senga. What say you?
Thank ya,
IANASM
Take it and run
13-team OBP league with deep rosters…Trade Dustin May for Victor Scott II?
Thanks for all you do for humanity!
Sure, if you need SBs
Mahle or C Holmes for Sunday?
I don’t know their matchups
Maple dodgers
Holmes cardinals
I have to cut one of Norby, N.Lowe, E. Suarez. This is a H2H league, and all of these guys are backups to guys who are supposed to be good players. Devers, Vientos, Altuve. I also have T.Fitz who Is eligible everywhere. Basic counting stats points league. Norby is a guy I liked last year. (That could be a line in summer show on Netflix for HS kids). Maybe I was smitten. Suarez isn’t fun when he’s doing this, but he can hit 5 homers in a week which is a big deal in H2H. Anyway, have a nice weekend and thank you for all the help.
Lowe
12 team roto, 2 U spots. Drop Schanuel for Kjerstad?
Sure
Rest of the season- Tyler Fitzgerald or Brandon Lowe?
Thanks!
Fitz
Grey, your vindaloo chatter is making me hungry, and it’s only seven in the morning! Maybe a samosa breakfast to tide me over until an early lunch …
HA!
Vindaloo Chatter should be an RCL team name
Have Casas, Goldy and Soderstrom. Drop Casas or Goldy for Kurtz and roster two A’s first basemen!? Thanks!
12 tm H2H Cats 6×6 with OPS
Casas
In one league, I picked up Zebby as a speculative add and dropped ERod. Should I reverse that transaction or hold on to Zebby?
Also, Durbin over Veen or hold? Thanks!
Meh, hold for now
I’d take ERod
Hey, Grey! Mahle or EdRod in a QS league?
ERod
You just jinxed my Dirty Sanchez, didn’t you Grey?!?!
I might’ve
So Grey when people ask you to drop people do you talk them off the ledge or do you talk them OFF the ledge? Have seen you do both I think.
Not sure what you’re asking
Made sense in my head. Are you 100% serious when your telling people
to make certain drops or is it based on how dumb the question basically
I’ve never read a dumb question
Challenge accepted.
Haha
Phew!
Hey Grey,
What is up with Trea Turner? Is stat cast looks dreadful…is he in decline? I need MI, and very dep at SP and am thinking of offering Strider for him, but…..eh.
What do you think? Would you do it?
I’d take Trea
Peralta vs Oak
Rodon vs TB
Yanamoto vs Texas
You starting all 3?
I’d start all 3
Adames or Neto std 5 x 5 RoS
Adames
Thanks, Grey. Have a great weekend!
You too!
1 question, 1 observation:
Daily lineup: Christian Walker vs. SD (Hart) or Busch vs. Ari (Burnes)
Observation: there were a lot of lefties at the bottom of the Marlins lineup which may have played into the Puk 9th inning call.
Busch
re: Puk, Ju-Ma pitched for one out in the 7th…they didn’t know what hitters he was going to face
Ju-ma came in at the 2nd hitter with one reliever needed in the 8th inning. Unless one of them royally blows it (and Ju-Ma doesn’t do that), Puk’s going to be likely facing the bottom.
ok
Great stuff! Are you starting Luis Ortiz in Pittsburgh? Thank you! Dude has burned me before!!
Sure
Hey Grey, need to make room, who’s the drop, Jeffrey Springs or Gavin Williams?
Both? Gavin
Hey Grey! I added Durbin as a bench bat and MI backup, like the contact skills but like you say, let’s see if that translates in the majors. Can’t steal first base and all. D-backs face RHP starters in next six games, and 8 of next 9, so let it ride w Pavin “Slam and Legs” Smith!
Yep!
Shallow 10 team HtH league…
Drop Vinnie P for Ben Rice, Aranda or Tork or hold for now?
Who you like better at 2b, Nico or Christian Campbell?
Hold
Campbell
What would you expect from Campbell ROS? I could trade M. Miller for Clase and Campbell.
20/20-ish
Would you pull the trigger on this deal of my M.Miller for Clase and Campbell? I realize Clase comes with some concern so far this year.
Alternatively, I could see if he’d part with Westburg instead of Campbell first.
This is a redraft 6×6 with OPS and Holds
Grey
Amazing report!
a. Meh on EdRod, saw the game and the Marlins had a runner on every inning but batted 2/17 w/RISP. So I guess victory to EdRod!
b. Rodney Dangerfield quote of the day for April 18, 2025
My wife! She’s something, she was afraid of the dog, then she saw me naked. Now she’s afraid of the light.
Cheers,
Ante
Thanks! A. Boo! Haha…
Is it is time for me to move off Warren?
Three possible options:
1. Pick up Eduardo Rodriguez
2. Pick up Kumar Rocker who had a great night and his next start is vs the A’s.
3. Pick up Ben Rice. I do have Josh Naylor at 1B and Manny Machado at DH. I would be picking him for any potential trade value
4. Hold
Thanks for your ongoing help!!
Do we believe Vientos is just getting the rust off and this HR is the start of something? Or are we looking at his statcast and saying he sucks? I’’m contemplating trading him and Skenes for Jose Ramirez. However, if we still think Vientos is a 70/25/70 guy, then I’d prefer to keep Skenes on the team and ride Vientos out.
He is currently sporting a 5 game hit streak. So maybe?? Shrugging shoulders emoji
I’m buying into Vientos at the moment fwiw. I think Grey has advised people to Hold so far
I’d be buying Vientos…
Laugh-out-loud funny, especially the Austin Hays blurb!
Happy Easter to you and all the Razzball staff
Thanks! Happy Easter!
Who to drop between Wesneski, Pfaadt and ERod.
Also, I’m looking to invest in the Bada Bing and wonder if me trading Jazz/Gray for either Rooker or Soderstrom is an over buy.
ERod — That’s an overpay
Thank You. Bing Bong in the summer gives a guy crazy ideas.
HAHA
Love your blurbs and I have loved them for many years. Your projections have helped me win championships several times over the past decade. One major request as I get too old and don’t want to visit too many websites. Can you PLEASE give the team and main position of the player you mention. PLEASE.
If you won championships you should know already
If you click any player’s name you don’t know, you’re brought to their player page where it has all the info you need
Yes. I do know that. This a “me” problem. I always print your column and read it while I’m out, so I can’t click the player’s name and I just mark it and look it up after I get back home. Oh well.. the problems of being a dinosaur. Thanks Grey!
Ha, No problem