LOGIN

Slider just goes bye-bye. Breaking balls just going oofie-doofie. Fastballs sitting 97 on the paint. Comes back with the slider. Then the oofie-doofie then the bye-bye paint. I think the Mets might regret not waiting on Kumar Rocker (4 IP, 1 ER, 5 baserunners, 7 Ks). The mechanics are a little histrionic, so I don’t know how long he can stay healthy. As I was saying on this week’s podcast, he might be a Mason Miller-type — great, nasty, always injured, then made a reliever and what a relief for his arm. We’ll see, and it’s way too early to give that future to Rocker, but the results yesterday were especially promising for a rookie debut, as he made major league hitters sitting on the dock of bay watching fastballs and breaking balls go away. His 17 swing-and-misses were the most by a Rangers’ pitcher making his debut ever (only tracked since 2009). Not to be a stick in the mud, he is a rookie, so I’d treat him like every other streamer. I was impressed and am already salivating for next year. I love oofie-doofies and bye-bye paint. People know this about me. Anyway, here’s what else I saw yesterday in fantasy baseball:

Corey Seager – Will have season-ending surgery on his hernia. Oh nuts!

Josh Jung – 1-for-4 and his 7th homer. A’la the Village People, Josh Jung! No need to be rude! I said John Jung! What, it’s catchy.

Nathaniel Lowe – 2-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 13th homer, which matches his letter count in his name. One more and he can keep Nathaniel!

Marcus Semien – 2-for-4 and his 21st homer. Waiting until I give up on him to get going? Semien’s such a sour spurt!

Bryce Miller – 6 IP, 1 ER, 6 baserunners, 7 Ks, ERA at 3.12. [whispers] Kumar looked better than Miller when they were both in the game.

Justin Turner – 1-for-4 and his 10th homer. Really lengthening the Mariners’ lineup. Oh wait, that was supposed to be Randy Arozarena. Well, at least they got Robles. Not sarcasm. He’s been really good! Two more steals last night, batting .300.

Byron Buxton – Activated from the IL. He said, “Did everyone see Bermudez? I found him in the Bermuda Triangle. Cool, right?”

Derek Bender – Twins’ minor league catcher, who was their 6th round pick this year, was caught tipping his opponents the pitches so he could go home.

“Here comes the Bender”
“The curve?”
“No, the guy who tells me the pitch.”

Tarik Skubal – 6 IP, 1 ER, 4 hits, 6 Ks, ERA at 2.50. Much like Joe Exotic, the Tigers’ pen cost Skubal big-time. Was a long shot, but yesterday’s pen incompetence likely cost him a chance to get his 20th win.

Jordan Beck – 1-for-3 and his 3rd homer. Bud Black pinch-hit for Beck with Jake Cave. Oh, wow, that eye roll allowed me to see the bottom of my brain! Very cool!

Darren McCaughan – 5 IP, 3 ER, 8 baserunners, 1 K, ERA at 7.06. Darren McCaughan sounds like a Lilith Fair artist. Where have all the cowboys gone? I don’t know, Darren McCaughan, you tell me.

Jesus Tinoco – 2 IP, 0 ER, ERA at 3.15, and his 1st save. Marlins have so many great relievers and no actual starters–Light bulb!–What if they just use all relievers? From the 1st inning on? Am I — How do they say it? — Brilliant? Tinoco could be the Marlins’ closer, or one of half dozen guys.

Mitchell Parker – 6 1/3 IP, 0 ER, 3 hits, zero walks, 5 Ks, ERA at 4.24. Did you have the pants nuggs to start him? I know I didn’t, but I wish I did. Bad nuggs!

Danny Jansen – 1-for-2 and his 9th homer. Yankees fans saw this DJ go deep and started having flashbacks, screaming, “LeMahNOOOOOOO!”

Cooper Criswell – 5 1/3 IP, 1 ER, 7 baserunners, 4 Ks, ERA at 3.98. Somehow he made Yankee Stadium look big with deep fly ball outs to all parts of the park.

Nestor Cortes – 5 IP, 1 ER, 6 baserunners, 9 Ks, ERA at 3.90. Watched a lot of this game — on mute, because Smoltz is like a perfectly awful mix of Charlie Brown’s teacher and nails on a chalkboard — and Nestor looked as good as Devers looked bad. Nestor didn’t have his best command, but was baffling the Yanks. Devers? He needs to be shut down. He’s 10-seconds late on every swing and grimacing. My favorite was Smoltz being like, “Devers is not complaining, just up there gutting it out,” and then you see Devers grimace, like that’s not a complaint.

Gleyber Torres – 1-for-5, 2 runs and his 13th homer. There’s gonna be people next year who say things like, “Once Gleyber was moved to the leadoff spot, he was great! Give me all the shares,” and they are either gaslighting or pretending to forget how awful he was for almost five months.

Ryan Pepiot – 2 IP, 2 ER, ERA at 3.76. Uh, what’s that? A short start or a long open?

Brandon Lowe – 1-for-5 and his 18th homer, 2nd homer in four games. Won’t be in this afternoon’s Buy column, but has been hitting for power for an Urban Dictionary minute.

Gavin Williams – 5 1/3 IP, 3 ER, 9 baserunners, 5 Ks, ERA at 5.23. Feels like one of those guys who can have a solid 2025, and we can just go ahead and ignore everything he did this year. Baby Gavin, Baby Gavin’s bathwater, all goodbye.

Alex Cobb – Hit the IL with a blister. [shudders] A Cobb blister is the worst.

Frankie Montas – 6 IP, 0 ER, 4 baserunners, 8 Ks, ERA at 4.49. Everyone jokes about how the Rays make pitchers better. Do people joke about the Brewers? Because they have a lab over there churning out great pitchers.

Jackson Chourio – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 20th homer. Everyone’s like, “Ooh, Skenes gonna get that NL ROY,” and he might, but, damn, Chourio is gonna be robbed. Chourio should get MVP votes too!

Hayden Birdsong – 5 IP, 0 ER, 3 baserunners, 4 Ks, ERA at 4.74. Stop chirping Hayden! We get it!

Tyler Fitzgerald – Left the game with lower back tightness. That actually reminds me, he hasn’t hit a homer in almost a month.

Jose Altuve – Out with an oblique injury the team doesn’t think is serious. So, will only linger until the 2nd round of the playoffs. Gotcha.

Framber Valdez – 6 1/3 IP, 1 ER, 6 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 2.91. ‘Member when Dusty Baker said Framber was the Predator because he regrew elbow tendons? We laughed. Chortled, even! Tell that to the guy who is on pace for 175+ IP in the regular season.

Jason Heyward – 1-for-3, 2 RBIs and his 7th homer. Meh, who cares, what I would like to say quickly while on the Astros: Kyle Tucker (2-for-4, 1 run) hit a double, and it was the first game back where he seemed a little better. Still, if a guy is having shin pain, can he drive the ball as well? I don’t know, I’m merely asking questions.

Brent Rooker – 1-for-4 and a slam (36) and legs (9). Not bad for a guy who has roughly two bad months and four great ones. If Rooker has an April next year like this year, do you have the patience to hold him? I know what I think and it rhymes with know whey. I have too much experience to think people are going to draft Rooker next year and not be moaning they want to drop him by the third week of the season, if he starts next year like this.

Mitch Spence – 7 IP, 2 ER, 7 hits, zero walks, 2 Ks, ERA at 4.33. He gets the Cubs next, which is technically a safer start, but the Streamonator doesn’t like it, and I tend to agree.

Jakob Junis – 5 IP, 1 ER, 3 hits, zero walks, 3 Ks, ERA at 2.73. Ya know what’s funny (not funny), if Junis was pitching this well in April, he’d be having articles written about him. I might’ve even put him in the lede. Junis Priest, This Guy Is Good! Instead, it’s September and it’s all about matchups. His incredibly solid command does pique my interest beyond the next few weeks, but he is mostly a long reliever.

Sonny Gray – 6 IP, 1 ER, 4 baserunners, 9 Ks, ERA at 3.75. As soon as games no longer matter, Gray does well. [thinking to myself] Hey!

Masyn Winn – 2-for-5, 2 runs and his 13th homer. He’s gonna be shortlisted for a sleeper post for next year, because he has 30+ steal speed and can hit 15+ HRs with great contact. Oh God, I just thought of my Sal Frelick sleeper. Forget it.

Brendan Donovan – 1-for-1, 2 RBIs and his 12th homer, hitting .272. Don’t usually mention pinch-hit homers, unless I can make a broader point. Here I’d like to say he pinch-hit for Jordan Walker. It worked out fine, but the previous game, Walker had the fastest swing of any player (81.3 MPH), fastest throw (84.3) and fastest sprint speed (30 ft/sec). At what point do they let Walker sink or swim? You can’t instill confidence in a guy if you’re just pinch-hitting for him in every tight spot. Listen, I know Walker has sucked, but you’re losing the war to win a battle. Cards are not playing for anything; they absolutely can let Walker face every pitcher. They are so badly Mr. Bungling Walker; it’s making me sick. I am nauseous at the vomitorium.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

79 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
schloofy
schloofy
19 days ago

Hi Grey,

Streamonator says Cabrera at Nats is okay? Should I bench him? Trying to accumulate Ks in my H2H 5×5 10-teamer playoffs, but don’t want to destroy my WHIP and ERA.

Thanks!

Gordeon
Gordeon
19 days ago

Ozuna is also closing in on a month since his last HR. Very, very, very pleased that I traded Ozuna for Pete and TFitzy for JJones.?

Dingo37
Dingo37
19 days ago

Gotta drop one OF. Buxton, Wood, or Dominguez?

The Wild Card
The Wild Card
19 days ago

best chance for a save this weekend

chad green vs STL
Hunter strikland vs HOU
Manny Rodriguez at Cle

Smitty
19 days ago

Enjoying this 2024 ride while wondering where all the high profile players that have been hurt (or under-performed) are gonna fall in 2025. Next year is shaping up to be quite the ranking challenge, seeing far more “bargains” than usual I think. Always interested in your takes and will be paying attention.

Question for next week:

Baz vs BOS
or
D. Peterson vs WASH

Smitty
Reply to  Grey
19 days ago

Have a great day!

jcindaville
jcindaville
19 days ago

Hey Grey, need your help please.

Struggling with who to start. Championship week 7 cat R-H-2B-HR-RBI-SB-OBP.
Right now i can likely forget SB. All the rest are in play.
Catcher only have one.
1st base Vlad & Christian Walker
2nd K Marte & Giminez
3rd Gunnar
SS B Witt & D Swanson. Dansby at Colorado and facing a lefty 2 very good things
OF K Tucker, Schwarber, Doyle, Greene, Armstrong, Dominguez,
Utility anyone listed above ( other than 3 OF)

Cant sit Witt, normally put walker or vlad at first and the other at utility, but Walker is 0-9 vs Peralta and Dansby hits lefties and is in Colorado.
Struggling with OF, like them all, Help!

LittleJerrySeinfeld
LittleJerrySeinfeld
19 days ago

Hey Grey, who would you go with of the two A’s rookies?
Mainly looking for QS and W second

Brady Basso@CHW(Crotchet) (somehow the sox are even a little worse against LHP)
Last start vsDET: 6IP,3H,0ER,1BB,6K (85 pitches & his first start of the season)
Seems to have better control numbers than Ginn throughout their minor league careers, with a very similar K/9.

J.T. Ginn@CHW(Flexen)
Last start vsDET: 5IP,7H,3ER,1BB,5K (83 pitches & his third start of the season)

Yes I definitely devoted too much time and did too much research on two Oakland A’s streamers, so what? haha

LittleJerrySeinfeld
LittleJerrySeinfeld
Reply to  Grey
19 days ago

Any rational behind it or just going with the gut?

toolshed
19 days ago

Rafael Devers, remember him? He was a perennial 30 hr, 100 rbi 3b for Bos. Where did he go? Have you seem him? Can we get that guy back instead of the lump who is playing 3b the Red Sox now?

Sept: 11 games, 46 PA’s, .195 ba, .220 slg, .480 ops. 1 rbi, 1 xbh.

toolshed
Reply to  Grey
19 days ago

An IL stint would have been better. He might have been be ok now or it would have forced me to add someone else.

Dirt McGirt
Dirt McGirt
19 days ago

Start J. Cantillo @TBR and/or C Povich @DET this weekend? (QS, K/9)

kcc26
kcc26
19 days ago

12 team H2H keeper (keep 6). Seager is sitting in my IL spot right now. He would cost a 3rd round pick to keep next year. Hold him or swap in any of the following injury stash options:

Felix Bautista (16th round)
Kodai Senga (16th round)
Christian Yelich (4th round)
Willson Contreras (17th)

Thanks!

Five-on-One
Five-on-One
19 days ago

Available SP’s for next week:

Detmers @HOU (picked up for this week’s start against the White Sox. Drop?)
Gore @CHC
Lively @STL (also picked up for his start against CHW. Got all of 2 IP. Sigh.)
Peralta vARI (sounds dangerous)
Rodon @OAK (I kind of like this one. Although a lefty @OAK?)
Buehler vCOL (tempting, despite how bad Buehler has been)
Knack @MIA
Canning vWSOX

  1. Can you rank top 4?
  2. Any worth starting in a 11-team 5×5 league?
Five-on-One
Five-on-One
19 days ago

Potential 2-starters next week:

Criswell @TB, @TOR
Megill vWAS, vPHI
GWilliams vMIN @STL

1) Please rank.

2) Any worth starting in 11-team 5×5 league?

RotoMoto
RotoMoto
19 days ago

Freddy P – start or sit against Arizona tonight?

Wins, Ks, ERA, and WHIP among the top 3 teams is desperately close with the innings limit approaching.

Play Ball
Play Ball
19 days ago

I’m in a tight race for the HR category. Eugenio Suarez has been on fire (as has the D- packs offense) and Devers has been ice.

Who do you like for the remainder of the season for HR – only 15 games left.

Five-on-One
Five-on-One
19 days ago

Bobby Miller has two juicy start next week (@MIA and vCOL), but he has been pretty darn bad since he came back from the IL over a month ago (25 IP, 23 ER, 23 Ks). Risk it in an 11-team 5×5 league where W’s and K’s and WHIP are still tight?

Dirt McGirt
Dirt McGirt
19 days ago

Best streamer for today, QS K/9 league: Basso @CHW, E. Caberra @WSH, Knack @ATL, Houck @NYY

Gee
Gee
19 days ago
  1. In championship week and my hitters are killing me. Ive had Buxton on the IL and have a good problem with him and Wood on my bench. Thoughts on starting either over JuRod or Butler
  2. How would you rank these streamers for rest of weekend (not much to pick from): Scherzer (@Seattle, Gilbert), Lowder (@Minn, Festa), Gore (vs. Miami, Oller)

Thanks as always

Alan
Alan
19 days ago

How can you believe Altuve’s prognosis when Tucker bruised his shin for 3 months and was due back any time?

renfield
renfield
19 days ago

Sonny Gray splits by catcher;
Contreras: 7 g, 2.89 era
Herrera: 9 g, 2.10 era
Pagés: 11 g, 5.62 era

But that may just be due to who has started with him on the road:
Home: 15 g, 5 hr
Road: 12 g, 16 hr

Buuut the multi-hr game that Conteras started actually looks like a good game – Gray allowed 4 hr at atl on July 20, but stl scored early and he was throwing all strikes (7 ip on just 87 pitches, 5r, 10 k, 0 bb, win).

With Contreras, Gray had 55 k, 6 bb. Pagés is a rookie with just 49 starts at catcher – if there was an issue with Gray and Pagés as a tandem, its reasonable to expect they will be better together next year. This has me thinking that Gray could be undervalued next year – note his k/bb has been far and away the best of his career (5.0, next highest was last year at 3.3).

lets play 2
lets play 2
Reply to  Grey
19 days ago

Cubs pitchers often comment on how Amaya calls good games for them, so I think he’s calling the pitches at least some of the time, but who knows. Imanaga even said once that Amaya called for a pitch and he wanted to throw something else but he trusted Amaya and it worked out.

lets play 2
lets play 2
Reply to  Grey
19 days ago

Agreed.

matt
matt
19 days ago

hi grey!

i have 8 starts [+ add] and opponent has 6 starts [+2 adds]

W [up 1], K [up 15], ERA [way down], WHIP [up .17], QS [up 3], SVH [tied]

he has 5 RP to my 3

would you add a SP (Martinez/Ginn) or a RP (Vesia, Ginkel, Kittredge, Ferguson, Megill)? do you think a RP could help me more in the cats i need most at this point and also maybe snag me a W? i’m down but close in 5/6 hitting cats.

sorry for asking again but thing’s changed a little and i thought maybe you’d agree

also: desperate for HR’s – which 2 of Devers, Buxton and Jazz would you start? can’t imagine doing it but Devers seems sore and slumping bad

thank you!

matt
matt
Reply to  matt
19 days ago

4 of my starts are today. another option is to wait and see how today goes. think both SP will likely be gone though and i lose a day of RP ofc.

thanks, again!

luckiest man on the face of the earth
19 days ago

It would be wise to drop Mitch Keller and Hunter Brown for Albert Suarez and Tylor Megill during this period according to Streamonator. I already picked up the best available (according to Streamonator) FA in Bobby Miller to start him.

My clicky finger hesitates to drop Keller and Brown for Suarez and Megill.

Tell me to do it, Grey….or tell me I’m stupid for considering it.

luckiest man on the face of the earth
Reply to  Grey
19 days ago

Done.

images
J.R.
J.R.
19 days ago

Is when the catcher gives away a sign tipping? I always thought that was on the pitcher. Baserunner is sign stealing. Catcher is ???

Got to love that story. Especially how the other team had such integrity to rat on him AFTER they won.

“Charlie, here comes the duece. And when you speak of me, speak well.”

Pops
Pops
Reply to  J.R.
19 days ago

Bull Durham conditioned me to assume that his pitcher was pissing him off. Incredible that he didn’t want them to make the playoffs because he wanted to go home. He’ll have plenty of time at home now

lets play 2
lets play 2
19 days ago

I need to bench one hitter today, so is Devers the guy to sit then? Other likely options are Torres or Adames or J. Naylor.

lets play 2
lets play 2
Reply to  Grey
19 days ago

Thanks! Have a good weekend!

alecleamas
alecleamas
19 days ago

Spot-on about the Cards and Walker. Too scared to trade him but no patience/guts to give 300-400 ABs. This is what happens when the GM will never be fired and that GM hires knuckleheads and insouciant cronies throughout the organization.

Jason Morgan
Jason Morgan
19 days ago

Do you expect Rocker to pitch at least 5 innings in any start or are we looking at 75 pitch outings this season? And is there room in the rotation with both Scherzer and deGrom returning?

alecleamas
alecleamas
20 days ago

Bender, a sixth-round draft pick out of Coastal Carolina in July, was playing for the Fort Myers Mighty Mussels, the Twins’ Single-A affiliate. Bender spent the final two games of the season, which the Mussels won, in the team’s bullpen instead of his typical place in the dugout. Maybe the White Sox can sign him…

teddybb
teddybb
20 days ago

Grey, would you start Houck tonight against the Yankees?
My team is ahead in wins, WHIP & K’s vs my H2H opponent, but losing in ERA.
Thanks!

Nord
Nord
20 days ago

Altuve Out with an oblique injury the team doesn’t think is serious. So, will only linger until the 2nd round of the playoffs 2025. I fixed for you. It’s really a broken spine or just a “bruised” spine! (eye roll)

Kumar looked good and gave me a great excuse to turn off the Dolphins for his start!

galica1234
galica1234
20 days ago

Grey!!!

Awesome!!!

a. Start any of these in my roto dynasty (no IP limits, need W)?

1 Schwellenbach at home Dodgers (Knack)
2 Bibee at home Rays (Littell)
3 Herz at home Miami (Cabrera)

b. Start any of these in my RCL (need all pitching cats)?

1 Schwellenbach at home Dodgers (Knack)
2 Basso at CHW (Crochet)

c. Have a nice weekend!

d. Special Norm MacDonald (RIP) quote of the day for September 13, 2024

The most restrictive smoking bans have taken over NYC and immediately the town gained 9000 pounds.

e. Chris Rock quote of the day for September 13, 2024

You know what GED stands for? Good Enough Diploma.

Cheers,
Ante

Chuckles Tiddlesworth
Chuckles Tiddlesworth
Reply to  galica1234
20 days ago

I always hate to see the fantasy baseball season end, but at least we’ll be done with Chris Rock.

galica1234
galica1234
Reply to  Chuckles Tiddlesworth
19 days ago

Chuckles!

Like the what the ol’ Jamaican man says at the bus stop when you ask when the next bus is coming…

‘Soon come, mon. Soon come.’

Cheers,
Ante

Nima
Nima
20 days ago

Agree, Smoltz is so bad. Can’t stand him on the broadcast. The new Buck, he’ll be doing every World Series unfortunately for who knows how long.