Michael Cuddyer to the DL with his hamstring injury. I love these Monday DL calls right after weekly fantasy lineups lock. Turr…iffic! You don’t care about our fantasy teams at all, Walt Weiss, do you? Last year it was Josh Rutledge, this year it’s Corey Dickerson. I wonder if he holds a secret grudge against fantasy baseball because it never rewarded his defensive prowess while he was playing. “Have you ever thought of adding fielding percentage to your fantasy league?” That was Walt Weiss disguised as a waiter at a Cheesecake Factory waiting on Dan Okrent’s table. Weiss then released bumblebees into Okrent’s suite at The Plaza while he read box scores in his robe. Walt is just bitter because the teacher he had a crush on never gave him the time of day. No, this isn’t the plot of Rushmore; the teacher was Carney Lansford. Ginger ’til he dies! So, with Cuddyer out, this could give Corey Dickerson a chance to show why he should be an everyday outfielder on all mixed league teams. Yesterday, Dickerson had the slam & legs and is capable of more. If you need a fifth outfielder, I’d give him a whirl. Anyway, here’s what else I saw yesterday in fantasy baseball:
Charlie Blackmon – 2-for-4 and his 3rd and 4th homers. I wonder what Jimmy ‘The Greek” would say about Blackmon.
Nolan Arenado – 2-for-5 and his 3rd homer. Get hot, you sumsabeech!
Clay Buchholz – 2 1/3 IP, 6 ER. In Boston Marathon terms, he made it to mile one when his nipples started bleeding and he had diarrhea trickling down his leg.
Mike Napoli – 1-for-5, 2 RBIs and his 4th homer. After the game, Napoli ran the last mile of the marathon.
Adam Jones – 1-for-4, 1 run, 1 RBI. The O’s scored 7 runs and not one player drove in more than 1 RBI. Like one giant ticker tease.
Bobby Abreu – Mets called him up. On his rotary phone? His flip phone? Oh, they called him up to play with the team! Oh, Mets, you are a silly, misguided, poorly-managed organization. The Mets should put on a staged adaption of Simple Jack. “I ain’t got a g-g-good brain.”
Jenrry Mejia – 6 2/3 IP, 0 ER, 7 baserunners, 7 Ks. Was dealing with a blister coming into this game, was facing the Cards and…dah, sonavabench!
Kyle Farnsworth – 1 IP, 0 ER and got the save. Here’s what it’s like owning Farnsworth. Hey, here he comes! Cool, I’m going to turn to a different game now.
Tyler Lyons – 6 IP, 2 ER, 10 baserunners, 7 Ks. Meanwhile, a fantasy owner somewhere picked up Lyons and dropped him for Carlos Martinez just to prove a point.
Dan Straily – 5 IP, 3 ER, 8 baserunners, 6 Ks, 5.40 ERA on the year. If he didn’t lead the minor leagues in strikeouts once upon a time, I’m not even sure if anyone would know who he was or if anyone in any mixed leagues would own him.
Coco Crisp – 3-for-4, 2 RBIs and two steals, his fifth and sixth. He seems to miss every third day yet still gets his stats.
Shin-Soo Choo – 1-for-3 and his 2nd homer, hitting .314, but left early after turning his ankle. Not to poo-poo, Soo Choo, but he was crazy hot last April too-too.
Yu Darvish – 6 IP, 3 ER, 12 baserunners, 6 Ks and his ERA is still at 1.61. Not a great sign when his WHIP (1.11) is so close to his ERA, but if anyone can pull it off, Yu can. Too bad this isn’t an audio book, that would’ve been downright life-affirming.
Andrelton Simmons – 2-for-4, 2 runs and his 3rd homer as he bats .299. Imagine what he could do if Fredi Gonzalez wasn’t such a Matt Williams and put Simmons in the two hole and moved B.J. the hell out of there. Yes, I’m down on B.J. (no homo).
Julio Teheran – 7 IP, 1 ER, 6 baserunners, 8 Ks vs. the Marlins. Nice to see the Ks reappear and the Marlins haven’t been a cakewalk in the early going, ranking in the top five in several offensive categories. Will Teheran’s ERA remain at 1.80. Prolly not, guys and four girl readers. Can he up his Ks and still be a number one. Yes, over-the-internet friends.
Craig Kimbrel – 1 IP, 1 ER and the blown save. I wish they would just send him to the DL already. Oh, and name only one pitcher to replace him. Not a committee, please! I have Carpenter and Walden in separate leagues, so I don’t care who they name.
Evan Gattis – 2-for-4, 2 RBIs and the game-winning homer, his 5th. Gattis is as cool as the other side of a discarded baked potato that he was using as a pillow!
Tom Koehler – 6 1/3 IP, 2 ER, 7 baserunners, 8 Ks. Move over, Eovaldi, I got a new Marlin pitcher heartthrob! Damn, Koehler looked good yesterday, and I don’t think it was purely due to the fact that four Braves hitters are on pace for 200 Ks and he struck out Teheran twice. Through six innings, Koehler looked better than Teheran. Stream-o-Nator hates his next start, but I’d definitely consider him in mixed leagues.
Christian Yelich – 2-for-5 and his 4th steal as he bats .338. He dedicated that steal to his grandfather who fought in Operation Desert Storm. Marlins may look tizzerrible at some point this year, but they really don’t right now.
Wandy Rodriguez – Hit the Disgraceful List. Appropriate since the man behind the Wandy Line, one of the most asinine arbitrary cut-offs in fantasy sports, Matthew Berry, also hit the Disgraceful List this year. Only his undoing was making too many terrible predictions.
Ike Davis – 2-for-4, 4 RBIs and his 2nd homer. How crazy does Dan Pants’s 40-homer prediction seem now?! Less pants-less? More panted? Shirtless with pants?
Francisco Liriano – 7 IP, 4 ER, 9 baserunners, 4 Ks. Looked better than the line because the Pirates sent him back out for an 8th inning where he didn’t record an out, left two runners on for Justin Wilson to surrender. This just in, Wilson sucks! Jesus Guzman, why did Liriano even go back out there?! C’mon, I got a fantasy team dependent on you stunods!
Andrew McCutchen – 3-for-3 and his 2nd homer. The Dread Pirate owes us three more homers before April’s out. Tally ho! Which is pirate for I’m tallying your homers.
Neil Walker – 3-for-4, 1 run, 1 RBI. No, it won’t last, but, yes, I wish I owned him everywhere right now.
Devin Mesoraco – 3-for-4, 1 run, 1 RBI and hitting .541. Okay, I’ll give you another week on my team. By the by, isn’t Devin the big-breasted girl from Real World: Brooklyn who has proved herself to be completely inept on The Challenge? Devin makes Aneesa look like an Olympic athlete (and not only if stripping is made an Olympic event). Oh, and I love how Dustin is like, “I can’t hook up on this show because I made a pact with my ex.” Then hooks up with two girls within 24 hours and doesn’t even mention that he feels bad. Classic.
Brandon Phillips – 3-for-5, 2 runs, 1 RBI. I don’t own him, but I got a bunch of comments about dropping him, so I assumed his roses were really smelling like poo-oo-ooo. He’s hitting third in a powerful lineup, good stadium and hitting .291.
Jason Giambi – 0-for-4 as he was activated by the Indians from the DL. The Yankees immediately sent out scouts to watch him.
Lonnie Chisenhall – 2-for-4, hitting .455. Things have hit rock bottom for the pockmarked guitarist-slash-third baseman-slash-catcher-slash-DH, Carlos Santana when Chisenhall is not only playing in front of him, but it makes sense.
Michael Brantley – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 4th homer. Ever heard the story about how I tried to get people to draft Brantley and no one did? Real page turner! Maybe I’ll sell the rights to my novella, The Talented Mr. Brantley, to Anthony Mingella and then we’ll have discussions about casting and decide Matt Damon is too short and instead send offers to Bradley Cooper.
Jason Kipnis – 2-for-4, 2 runs, 2 RBIs and his 3rd homer. Not having a terrible early season (3 SBs, .246), but not as good as you want it since he takes July thru September off.
Zach McAllister – 6 IP, 2 ER, 7 baserunners, 2 Ks, year ERA at 2.28, and he’s been obscenely lucky so far. He does go to San Francisco next and the Stream-o-Nator has some unkind things to say about it, but I don’t hate it.
Clayton Kershaw – Will start a rehab assignment on Friday and is targeting a mid-May return. Or in Spanish, Kershaw queso en Mayo. Um, delicious!
Bronson Arroyo – 5 1/3 IP, 5 ER. Too bad he doesn’t play the guitar good enough for the blues.
Travis Wood – 7 IP, 1 ER, 6 baserunners, 9 Ks as he pitchslapped Arroyo. At a lesbian bar, A-Rod leans over and tells someone that he was the first one to do that to Brandon Arroyo.
Ryan Vogelsong – 1 1/3 IP, 5 ER. Maybe him and Arroyo can do a duet.
Garrett Richards – 6 IP, 1 ER, 5 baserunners (4 BBs), 6 Ks. On one hand, I dropped him prior to this start in the one league where I could because I don’t trust him, and four walks in six innings doesn’t give me much confidence. On the other hand, one hit shows the kind of stuff he can throw. On a third hand that is a cut-out box of Hamburger Helper pasted onto a suction cup and spring to make a really cheap waving hand car window sign, I’d gamble on Richards if I needed to take a risk.
Ernesto Frieri – 1 IP, 1 ER and the save. If you turn the station when Farnsworth comes into a game because you own him, when Frieri enters a game you smash a coconut across your head Roddy Piper-style and hope you wake up to good news.
Erick Aybar – 3-for-4, 1 run, 1 RBI and hitting .209. He’s not a .209 hitter. He’s not even really a bad average hitter, so he has some going up to do. “He has some going up to do?” I speak good!
Tanner Roark – 6 2/3 IP, 0 ER, 9 baserunners, 5 Ks. Almost exact opposite of Richards’s stuff, but might have better outcomes. I.e., Roark isn’t that upsidey, but is safer.
Ryan Howard – 2-for-5, 2 RBIs and his 5th homer. In 2006, before the economy collapsed, that would’ve been 12 homers. Thanks, Greenspan!
Carlos Ruiz – 3-for-4, 2 runs, 4 RBIs and his 1st homer. Okay, so I bring some of these catcher questions on myself.
Cliff Lee – 8 IP, 0 ER, 4 baserunners, 10 Ks. So, what you’re telling me is The Adverb isn’t done?
Chris Sale – First it was announced that he would miss his Tuesday start with general soreness, then it turned out he was visited by Major Pain, and now he’s on the DL with a muscle strain. Maybe it wasn’t the smartest thing for Robin Ventura to send him out there for 127 pitches in his last start. Robin, pennants aren’t won in April, but they can be lost. Sale could miss a while.
Matt Lindstrom – 1 IP, 0 ER and the save. Okay, if you turn the station with Farnsworth and Rowdy smash a coconut across your noggin with Frieri, with Lindstrom you kick over a line-up of motorcycles at a bike bar while doing Tequila just to distract yourself.
John Danks – 6 1/3 IP, 1 ER, 9 baserunners, 1 K, ERA is at 2.84. Danks, but no Danks.
Jean Segura – 2-for-4 and his 4th steal as he was dropped to 7th in the order. Ah, remember when a two-hit, one steal game meant two runs? Those were the days! Don’t panic, this is merely a tool to motivate– OH, GOD, WHY?! Sorry, I panicked. *breathe in, breathe out, try to find meaning in life with Segura hitting 7th, jumps out first story window* I feel good, I was just cutting onions, that’s what these tears are. *sniffles* I need a nap. *shoots up in bed* Ah! I just had a dream Nick The Podcast Host was tweaking his own nipples. I’m tortured!
Scooter Gennett – 2-for-3, 1 run, 1 RBI as he moved up to Segura’s spot. Just keepin’ the two-hole warm. That’s what she said! Huh?
Wily Peralta – 6 1/3 IP, 2 ER, 7 baserunners, 6 Ks. The nearly one K per inning is a nice sign. Of course, this was against the Padres. Then again he gets the Cubs next. Wily, you’ve sold me on a replacement for the low man on my staff!
Chris Denorfia – 1-for-3 and his 1st homer, hitting .308. He was going to be my batty call today, but now I might’ve just fell in love for lack of better options.
Scott Feldman – To the DL with biceps tendinitis. Feldman’s bubbie asked him, “Why aren’t you more like that nice Jewish boy with the sore thumb?”
Matt Dominguez – 2-for-3, 3 RBIs and his 3rd homer. Ever think about how if his name was Dominquez it would look like an R&B singer? No, okay, maybe it’s me.
James Paxton – The Mariners announced that Paxton wouldn’t return for a while. When asked to clarify by moving their fingers closer or further apart, they opened their arms wide.
Brad Miller – 0-for-3 as he was dropped to ninth in the order. Ugh, there’s Nick tweaking his nipples again! Okay, I’m ready for your scorn, you can drop him now in most mixed leagues.
Nice write up
@Dave: Thanks!
I thought what Dustin did was great. Now he is at a resort with that brunette chick. White teeth has gotta be pissed.
@MB: Ha, totally
sweet crap that gattis joke rules.
@Balmy Tundrastein:Agreed.
Grey — Have you ever been a professional comedy writer?
Is that like being an Official Bikini Inspector?
@Balmy Tundrastein: Thanks!
Yahoo 6×6 OPS league with 3OF, 2 UT
Have Belt, Ortiz, J Up, Bautista, Pagan, Yelich, Rajai, A Gordon (and polanco coming soon). Have Seager dead at 3B. I platoon rajai vs lefties and yelich vs R, need their speed.
How would you rank these three trades for me?
A Gordon for C Santana
Yelich for Rendon
Gordon for Arenado
Totally willing to overpay to get another 3B
Thank you
@John: Yelich trade
@ Grey :
“He has some going up to do?” I speak good!
what school you went ?
@costaricanchata: Good work.
@Cram It:
my father , who carried the mantra of
” too young for W.W. I , and too old for W.W. II ”
used to tell people that he went to the
Sam Houston Institute of Technology ,
though , in actuality , he never got past the 8th grade .
@costaricanchata: BU
After 85 pitches or so, Anibal Sanchez seems to fall apart with the focus and intensity normally reserved for success. As an Anibal Sanchez owner and a Tigers fan, it is making me double crazy.
@Filkarri: Ha
16 teams. Pick up Koehler? I only have 22 more waiver moves so there needs to be a reasonable expectation that he will remain worth holding. Thx!!!
@2 Giant rings:
reasonable expectation is about a 2-1 k/bb rate ,
and a 4.25 e.r.a.
jacob turner to return to rotation soon , and if one is
marginally better than the other , it’s anybody guess .
turner should replace brad hand , however .
the real threat to koehler’s spot in the rotation
will come from andrew heaney .
heaney , who is currently burning it up in AA , (jacksonville)
may get a stop-over at AAA (new orleans) before being called up .
BUT , it’s the marlins .
who can tell ? … with any degree of rational confidence .
@2 Giant rings: Hold your moves
@Grey: please bring me some heaney to my NL only land. or montero, syndergaard, etc.
Hi Grey! So tonight is Salazar’s last shot with my team before he joins Gallardo on my syphilis wish list. What are your predictions for tonight…..Please don’t say PAIN. Thank You!
@Brooke: that’s a very specific kind of wish list. damn.
@Brooke: after going on another Grey-inspired tangent through Roddy to Mr T, I approve of this comment.
@Brooke:
Have faith. Tonight might just work out for the young journeyman. Anything but the syphilist.
Is it okay if I hate Kyle Seager. I have to dump him for frazier right? League has chris johnson on the wire too
Gracias
@Alex: Frazier. You should have lost him for Frazier a couple of weeks ago. Just my two cents.
@Moscowitz: correction. A week ago.
@Moscowitz: Why is someone like Gyorko a hold, but Seager isn’t? They are basically having the exact same year right now.
@Principal Blackman:
Why are you asking me this question?! I never said Gyorko is a hold per se and for ever. We are talking about Frazier and Seager though and in my opinion Frazier is very well able to put up Seager numbers and probably even much more.
@Moscowitz: Sorry, it was less directed at you and more at the general razzball community. I should have deleted the href. It’s just what popped into my head after reading that Seager was a drop.
@Principal Blackman: that is good question, in a fairly pertinent spot, just maybe make sure it’s not directed at Moscowitz
@goodfold2: Yeah, heard. And, again, I inadvertently singled out Moscowitz, but I meant it more generally and speculatively… and I didn’t mean to sin so egregiously against the community.
@Alex: Frazier
Trade McCutchen for Bruce and Shields? 10 team
My SP:
Darvish
Sale(DL)
Minor(DL
Walker(DL)
Tillman
Liriano
Chavez
Martin
My OF:
Mccutchen
Holliday
Myers
Craig
@Juliana: Gotta get more for Cutch
@Alan: Would you give Bruce and Shields for Cutch? I wouldn’t.
I read every one of these, and this one was your best, HILARIOUS … but you knew that, but still — third hand hamburger helper? queso en mayo? And totally feel ya about watching shiz closers.
@Alan: Thanks!
Do you think Jim Johnson will be in the saves mix any time soon for Oakland? Have him stashed but Strop is out there and thinking of making that move. Any opinion on the better choice of these terrible options?
@ryan: I’d hold Johnson
@Grey: Now that’s funny.
@ryan:
johnson is getting paid 6.5 mil $$ ,
making him the 2nd highest player on the A ‘s payroll .
(crisp gets 7.0 mil )
@ryan:
tough to get a read. Probably the most interesting comment from Melvin was that “right now (the bullpen) is a feel thing.” And he seems to feel most confident with Luke Greg. Gregerson throws strikes, induces groundballs, avoids HRs, doesn’t have extreme left right splits, though lefties do hit him a little better. He also works fast and is pitching with confidence. Every time he goes out and gets a save you kind of get the feel that Melvin will continue to use him. I think Melvin is the kind of manager who will go to Johnson and be willing to say, “you’re a match up guy now. Go out and pitch great and we’ll see what happens.”
In the same vein, I think Abad is really close to cresting Doolittle in the pecking order. Doolittle’s problem is that his slider is still “show me” only and his fastball has no tilt. He comes from 3/4 arm so the ball is on a very consistent vertical plane. There is horizontal movement, but the flatness of it makes it easy to track. When he locates on the corners or up down in the strike zone he’s still tough to hit because he does hide the ball and is throwing 95. But when he misses over the plate there’s a high percentage of damage done. They just signed him to a long term deal so he’ll have some leash but his two year trend is not towards elite level reliever.
@OaktownSteve:
I appreciate your detailed analysis. I learn something each time I read your posts. Keep up the excellent work!
@Dr. Sauce:
My pleasure. I’ll talk A’s all day.
@OaktownSteve: Hey, man! Also appreciate your posts! Would I be crazy to start sonny gray for his two road starts next week. One start options include: Cole (vs. Morrow), Lester (vs. Milone), Salazar (TBA), ASanchez (Shields). Thanks, man!
I was offered a trade let me know what you guys think please.
Clayton Kershaw Brandon Belt
shelby Miller FOR Alex Gordon
Angel Pagan Matt Kemp
Casey Jannsen
IT would wipe my pitching as i would be left with the likes of salazar, kazmir,latos-who knows- and streaming ive been riding harang and vargas..?
@Shane: You’d be getting 3 OF’s? Do you currently have zero OF’s?
@Cram It: No read the folloing commennt it was supposed to read belt, gorodon, jansenn, kemp FOR kershaw miller and pagan
@Shane: I wouldn’t do it, you’re decimating your pitching.without getting a plus player in return.
that was supposed to post as Clayton kershaw, Shelby miller, angel pagan FOR Brandon belt, alexgordon, matt kemp, and casey jannsen sorry guys.
OMG Grey, I think I just made a critical mistake. My pitching sucks so bad that I just accepted a trade offer in which I gave away my 3B, who is really good, for Zack Greinke. I’m embarrassed to mention his name. My hitters are all awesome and my pitchers are miserable so I did it but now I’m getting agita everytime I think about it. Please tell me that you feel better about Zack Greinke now, than you did in pre season….
@Brooke: You blew it.
@Brooke: Well aside from the fact that we are talking about a done deal with no chance to change the realities; how can someone evaluate your point when you dont even tell him the name of that 3B player you just gave away?! Whatever Grey tell you now, it doesnt change anything about the facts and facts are that you now own Greinke. You gotta make the best out of your current situation.
@Moscowitz: Has to be Wright or Longo
@Fungazi: ..and he/she still has to deal with the facts. in fact, who he/she gave up for Greinke doesnt matter anymore.
Hello Mr. Moscowitz. Like most men you don’t pay attention to detail. I never asked Grey to evaluate my trade, I asked him if his pre season opinion on Greinke has changed since he’s looked pretty good so far. But you guys start with your immature comments and I can’t even get responded to, so thanks for that.
If you must know, and since you want to evaluate the trade I already know that I blew, here you go. I refuse to say his name anymore so I just refer to him as………
RABI TEADENLR
@Brooke: I feel your pain. I feel depressed for making a deal to send away Rios for Cole. Wasn’t a homerun but no means but it’s not exactly a total strikeout. .. More like a long fly caught at the warning track
@Brooke: Is Brooke one of the four girls here?
@Fireball Feliz: from the waist up…
@Wake Up: Who isn’t?
Yes I am, and Mr. Wakeup is one of our 2,000…. Bald, Overweight, Single, Dbag men here.
@Brooke: Give that woman a Kewpie doll! You’ve just described 99.9% of the swinging dicks on the internet… like shooting dongs in a barrel.
@Principal Blackman: always love/hate the brooke comments section. could’ve been beltre she’s talking about.
@goodfold2: Beltre was my guess as well.
@Brooke: LMAO
Great as always. Deep 15 tm 5×5 with OBP instead of AVG. I need OF badly. I have original Cargo and Hamilton on DL. How would you rank these players. Some I have and a few are FA.
Thanks!
Bradley Jr – own
Duda – own
Maybin – own
Fowler – own
Corey Dickerson – own
A.Almonte – FA
Shuck – FA
Parra – FA
Would you keep who I have or swap 1 or 2 for the available Parra and/or Almonte.
Also, Bonifacio was surprisingly released, which would you drop for him? I’m leaning towards Lake.
Thank you!!
@Bertchr22: Almonte over Maybin, Bonifacio over Duda if you need speed
11 team NL only, am i better off with Petit or Maholm, thinking it’s not too long till Petit takes Vogel’s job. and Maholm doesn’t get K’s (but does get walks, oh yes)
@Montezuma’s Revenge… right now: literally the only 2 unowned active players that count as SP in this league are detweiler and petit.
@Montezuma’s Revenge… right now: oh yeah, K to BB in play here.
tony cigriani was dropped on my league
i have plenty of OF
Kemp
Crawford
Puig
Norichika
springer
Leonys martín
and my starters are these
Anibal
Eovaldi
Wacha
Danny salazar
Minor
would you recommend to drop anyone of those OF’s/SP’s for Cigriani… Whom?
@tony: i would think you’d need more than 5 SP (esp with one of those being hurt, Minor). it is nice to have all of puig/kemp/crawford (i have 2 of those in NL only) as you have yr own ass covered when one of them has an off day (which for at least one of them is everyday)
@tony:
Drop Crawford. Unless your Magic Johnson with $18 billion you can’t have the entire Dodgers OF.
@tony: Definitely ditch Crawford…. Why would somebody drop Cingrani?
@Principal Blackman: they also (the guys in my league) dropped latos, R. zimmerman, colby rasmus, brett lawrie, clay bucholz, hosmer…
a lot of good players dropped just in the last week, the guy who dropped latos, had room for him on DL spot, and the zimmerman former owner dropped him for solarte. WTF
i picked up Minor from waivers a couple of days ago was dropped.
I have the chance to get Cobb, Werth, and either Martin Perez or Ventura for Justin Upton. 1. Would you do it, and 2. Would you go for Perez or Ventura?
@C.O.C:
Yes. Please. And Thank You.
Take Yordano.
12Team- H2H-R, H, HR, RBI, SB, BB, TB, AVG, OPS, XBH
Chris Carter, Dayan Viciedo, Grady Sizemore, Corey Hart. Please rank them.
Usually I follow the great rankings, but my lineup is terribly cold and I’m panic now. Thanks in advance!
@Quintero: EDIT: please add Ike Davis to the ranking list
@Quintero: Hart
Trade question. 5×5 12 team keeper. Can make 2 different trades. (need power haven 5 closers)
Give Boneface+Soria or Frieri for Alvarez
Give Soria or Frieri for Montero or Mesoraco (in my 2 catcher league I have the A’ tandem and Santana)
Would u make any of these trades?
Alvarez will be my corner guy. Right now have Smoak/Headley rotating.
Thanks!!
@Bas: Boneface and Frieri for Alvarez
With 2 guys (middlebrooks/fister) already on the dl… Is Feldman worth holding onto or is he a drop at this point?
@Bostondirtdogs:
No. He can be returned to the thrift store.
16 team espn H2H OPS/total bases (so double counting bases) league where i punted C. now stuck with Pierzyn and his terrible homers/OPS/avg/total bases and counting stats. any of these better? grandal (good ratios, but really bad runs/rbi’s and playing time)/castillo/navarro (best counting stats, due to best offense)
@goodfold2: navarro not listed in catcher rankings, might be due to him not having that job preseason.
@goodfold2: Mike Z for Seattle gone?
@Birdmann: yep, if he was there i wouldn’t even have asked.
Grey some mope just grabbed mesoraco, i’m stuck with sal perez
1. would you grab j castro or just keep taking the pain?
2. you mentioned you liked alcides better than Espinosa but what if you had sal and AG would you still grab alcides?
Alcides, Cozart, Espinosa, or hold onto Brad Miller?
@Rico: I just faced a similar set of options, but with Owings available as well and I went with Alcides.
@Rico: Alcides
@Grey: you like alcides more than espinoza for MI?
Yes
@Grey: trade agon for will myers? or hold?
Yes, trade
@Tony Cingrani’s Ego: posey at C or abreu at ci who holds more value?
Abreu
Wow I hate closers. Who decided that Saves needed to be a real stat and then a category for fantasy? Constant irritation.
@Miles: Ha, yup
I see that Machado has started rehab games, what do you expect from him ROS ?
@Russell James: Bogaertsy-Prado-ish this year
@Russell James: 12 HRs, 4 steals, .280
5×5 with OBP league, Abreu or Hosmer? Thoughts appreciated.
@Wilson: Hosmer
@Grey: Thanks Grey, Hosmer seems struggle and no HR so far. Two simple questions,
1. Any worry about Homser this year?
2. If let you rank Hosmer and Rizzo for this year again, still Hosmer over Rizzo?
Thanks.
No, yes
@Grey: Thanks. Luckily I got Hosmer from waiver.
No problem
Chisenhall, morneau, Ike Davis ROS
@Will: Justin, Ike, Chis in that order due to playing time and home parks.
Chris Sale, Alex Cobb, and Salazar??? Is this God’s punishment for all the “sinning” i did during my teenage angst?
@Enrique: @The Thumb:
Sounds like a good time to return to that “sinning” for a well needed distraction.
… We’re talking about porn, right???
@Fish: In what world is porn a sin?
@Birdmann: The world where your wife catches you with your shorts around the ankles sitting in front of the computer at 3am.
@Lville Jim: in what world do “sins” exist at all?
@Crapshoot Kershaw:
Razzball: Where readers come for the fantasy, but stay for the existentialism.
Broxton or gregorson ROS??
Need saves
Thanks!
@Steve: Gregerson
@Grey: Gregerson’s basically the girl you thought was cute at the bar… then you swear off tequila after seeing her the next morning…
and then the next night you’re right back at the bar with Jose and Senor Sauza like it never happened.
Ha!
I one of the impatient owners of Miggy. 16 team keeper league. I have Cabrera in the 1st of a 3 year contract.
5 X 4 League: Usual categories, no WHIP so pitching is devalued. Weekly lineup.
Am I being impatient? My team is slumping right now……
Here is the offer:
I send M. Cabrera DET, Belt SF (walk year) & Salazar CLE (own for 2 years cheap) plus a scrub
I get McCutchen PIT (final year w/ matching rights), Headley SD(cheap, last year), Latos SD(final year), & Abreu CHW (own for 2 years cheap)
Here is my line up ( I am deep because I had my full salary available & a ton of early picks due to trades last season):
C: Gomes CLE
1B: Belt SF
2B: Utley PHI
SS: H. Ramirez LAD
3B: M. Cabrera Det
UTL: Donaldson Oak
OF (3): Choo Tex, Bruce Cin, & Marte Pit
Bench: Simmons SS, Arcia CHW, Calhoun LAA, Hart Sea, Kenderick LAA, Baez CHC
SPers (start 4): Bumgarner SF, Gray Oak, Fister Was, Minor ATL, Masterson CLE, Kluber CLE, Estrada Mil, Porcello Det, Walker Sea
RPers (start 2): Romo SF & Reed Ari, Storen Was
Again, does this trade make sense for my team? Cabrera loses a little value next year not playing 3rd.
Any input would be greatly appreciated.
@Hewhohesitates…is LOST.: I would bet Mig keeps 3B next year due to interleague. He already has 4 games & 2 GS at 3B and not even done April.
@Hewhohesitates…is LOST.:
Hard to quit swiggy.
I do like the flexibility it gives you to use mccutch at utility, Donaldson 3b, abreu at first. Can you combine headley and Latos into something slightly stronger?
@seph meier:
Fungazi: Good point about his potential to nab 3B for next year.
seph meier: Latos & Headely need to be a part of the trade to make the $$$ work (we have a weird formula).
I am back & forth on whether this trade is really going to help me. I like have Abreu next year, but might miss Salazar & Walker on the cheap.
Thanks to both of you.
Nick the Podcast Host tweeking his nipples is going to be a classic. Maybe that should be the gif for each shirt in the razzball store. Good thing you don’t sell shorts!
@Slim: Razzball shorts!
@Ra’zball Al Ghul: only is Stubbies still makes shorts. Only brand of shorts I rocked when I was a kid.
@Slim: Haha
20 moves left….grab Brantley or Ike for my util spot over Smoak? (Ops, Slg)
@Nightpandas: Brantley
@Nightpandas: I’d hold the moves
Mesoraco is one creepy looking dude. He looks like Kane from the WWE
@BitchesBeShoppach: Totally!
Drop Granderson for Brantley?
@Benjy: I know you aren’t asking me, but I watch every Mets game. Grandy has hit three balls to right that would all have been out in the Bronx. All barely reached the track. He can’t hit lefty’s at all, and the fans are booing him as he walks to the plate. He really could be in for a horrific season.
@Benjy: yup
Hey!
12 team mixed league, current staff:
Wainwright, Alex wood, Salazar, liriano, kluber, Estrada, mejia, Chavez, Beckett
Rp: uehara, josh johnson (vomit)
Was offered farnsworth for kluber. Worth it?
Thanks!
@KCC26:
Sounds like you could use the Saves.
SAGNOF! (Except when it’s a goggled-wonder (Gregg, Farnsworth). Then it has a face. And it’s hilarious.)
@KCC26: Go for it
@Grey: haha, thanks…i think the idea of owning farnsworth would carry more appeal if I weren’t a Mets fan.
Hilarious! Best ever!
@phil: Thanks!
Are you holding Sal Perez in an OBP league while Mesoroco and Gattis are on waivers?
@2 Cups 1 Braun: Gattis
Would ya’ll trade kershaw, Shalby Miller and Angel Pagan FOR Matt Kemp, Brandon Belt, Alex Gordon and Casey Janssen? Its a 12 team Yahoo league 6×6 w/ OPS My offense is weak and my pitching staff was my strength. I started the season with
Clayton kershaw
Gerrit Cole
Shelby Miller
Mat Latos
Danny Salazar
Scott Kazmir
Relief
Huston Street and Sergio Santos
Our stats are R, Hr, RBI,SB,AVG,OPS and W,S,QS,ERA,k/9 and WHIP
I just traded away Gerrit Cole for offense(Cole and V-mart for billy butler and josh donadlson) and with Latos and Kershaw on my bench ive been streaming pitching (ive used Vargas and Harang) for the past two weeks coupled with Salazar and Kazmir and it hasnt worked out too bad, I know streaming will have mixed results I just really feel like offense is hard to come, especially in a keeper league.
@Smitty: No
Add Brantley or aoki? Think its safe to drop Paxton in my non keeper and hold him in keeper? Thanks in advance.
@Wboggs: Cliff Brant Lee
@Wboggs: Lose Paxton, Brantley, depends on needs
That Liriano game pissed me off. Yeah so the bullpen was taxed due to the extra inning game before, but with two guys who Liriano couldn’t get out during the game leading off, you’d figure they could do better than run him back out there. Then he gets yanked when a lefty comes up.
So instead of letting the lousy relievers start with a clean inning at least, they bring in the lousy reliever with 2nd and 3rd and no outs.
Then I decided to start Morse @ Coors vs. a lefty instead of Moss vs. Yu. I knew Moss had very good career numbers against Yu but I was like, well, it is effing Coors boss…
Well Morse goes 0 for 4 and Moss hits a batting practice first pitch FB out.
Last 2 times on bench, homers. When in lineup, almost nothing.
One of those days…
@papasmurf: I feel your pain…sounds like my luck with Will freaging Myers this year, I bench him once out of 3 weeks, and he goes off,,,,pffff f him!
@papasmurf: Damn!
That third hand does seem helpful
@Yescheese: It is!
I think that was Dan Pants playing the part pf Pinocchio in that AFLAC commercial and Ike Davis sitting in the audience.
@nyydj2: Haha
Beltran and Adrian Gonzalez for Prince? Who comes out better?
@Ray: Hey yo Adrian will have the best season methinks
@Ray: I’d want Prince
@Ray: Prince, but it’s fair
As soon as I saw Liriano come out for the 8th, I knew my nice tidy QS with a possible W was gone. At least it didn’t turn into an L. As for Ike, he broke his bat on that homerun. At Citi Field its a flyout to right field. Maybe in that ballpark without the unbearably negative Mets fan base on this guy constantly, he has a good year. He still has that ugly hitch though. That’s stadium proof.
@Harris: Ha, yup
Worth dropping Asche for Ike? Love Asche, but my MI in a deep league needs some help
@Kyle: Go for it
@Kyle:
not feeling the love for asche .
seems over-matched by big-league pitching .
@costaricanchata: wasn’t terrible last year
Hey Grey! I know that you physically watch these players more than I do, so stats aside, who do you start this week out of Arenado, Dee, and Gyorko? Arenado and Gordon are playing a little over their heads right now, but they’re producing. Gyorko has a .205 BABIP, but does he look like he’s going to normalize soon, or is he worth benching until he figures it out? Thanks in advance!
@Nico: Grey physically watches you too, Nico
@Ra’zball Al Ghul: I’m taping over the web cam on my laptop!
@Nico: Arenado
@Grey: Thanks!
No problem
Up 4-3 going into the 8th, I was really hoping Liriano wouldn’t come back out.
I really enjoyed the Road Rules reference though I havnt watched in a few years. I still laugh when I think about Mark and Eric retiring to host one season. I still think about those two every time I see a Scion on the road. My guess is they each have three to four. That being said, TJ was the best host. I’ve transitioned from MTV reality to Bravo. If you havnt watched Southern Charm you should give it a shot.
@Jamiehov: Ha, I haven’t seen it, but will look for it…
I need to choose an infielder to replace Brad Miller. My choices are Mini-Donkey, Colabello, Callaspo, Ike Davis, or A. Escobar?
You guys kick @ss Grey!
Thanks,
@BringDaRuckus: Alcides, thanks!
Thank you stream-o-nator for giving me the Wood, Richards combo last night, I really hope their second starts are just as good.
I have Brad MIller, and he is making me angry, such a good first week, and now nothing, you said he is dropable in most mixed leagues. We have a 14 team league, with no MI, just SS and 2B. What would be your best option for a filler 2B, here are some of the top available.
Ackley
Semien
LeMahieu
Infante
So now you can see about who would be available.
@Grant: Wow, those are some weak alternatives. I’d go with Ackley, followed by Infante. But in a league where those are the best options it might also be good to try to stash Miller for when (or in case) he turns things around. His ceiling is much higher than whoever you’d pick up.
@Grant: They are weak, I’d hold for now
I have kinsler, so can aaron hill be dropped?
@los locos: I guess
Hey Grey,
Axford or Frieri ROS? Axford doesnt seem to be all that terrible. He however gets the job done and looks better than Frieri. I own Frieri but the Indians seem to give Axford more save opportunities. He already has 6 saves and in my 10 teams league he is on waivers right now.
@Moscowitz: Schmotato/Schmotahtoh. I like Frieri better for his Ks, but they will both WHIP you into submission.
@Principal Blackman: So it comes down to who gets more save opportunities over the whole season.
@Moscowitz: Hard to say… There may be a large disparity now (CLE’s 10 SVOs to LAA’s 5), but last year they had virtually the same number of SVOs over the course of the full season. Over the last 3 seasons Cleveland has 12 less SVOs, not that those numbers are indicative of anything.
@Principal Blackman: frieri’s era will likely be worse (more K’s though), with all those homers. i have both of those in 10 team with deep benches. somebody dropped axford in that league 2 weeks ago. i had nate jones at the time. it felt better.
Hayward and J Upton too much for Harper in a keeper league?
@joe: I wonder what Matt Williams thinks of this deal?
@joe: Bit much, not bad
@Grey: h2h league, wins count big…ask for ishakawa, j. Paxton, Salazar or bigger like pence?
Pence
Grey
I thought I recall reading in a comment that you weren’t a fan of quality starts. What’s the reasoning? Do you still like QS over wins? Just curious because it was discussed in our league.
@Hans: I have no idea what Grey’s stance on QSs is, but I like them over Ws for two reasons, (1) your pitcher’s offense has no bearing on the stat and (2) relievers cannot vulture a QS.
@Hans:
quality starts … 4.50 e.r.a
maybe it they changed the qualification
to 3 runs or less in 7 innings , it would become
a useful measure of effective performance .
@costaricanchata: This is valid, but that said, the W (5ips and less runs allowed than the other team) is not “a useful measure of effective performance” either.
@Principal Blackman: Wins less useful for sure.
I’d like to drop Miller…but for who? In a league that uses OBP and Errors + 4 normal ones, let’s say all of the following are in MLB. Rank them with Miller – Escobar, Crawford, Baez, Drew
@Jack: Throw Jeter in there too.
@Jack: In a 10 teamer i dropped him for Neil Walker for MI. In your case though i would try to stash him for a couple of weeks to see if he can turn things around. Your alternatives are…well..no real alternatives :)
@Jack: Alcides Escobar. Miller sucks. And if he picks it back up, he’ll still be sitting there for your to pick back up
@Jack: Alcides
Grey — Just curious: how many different leagues are you personally in?
My question: Noting Eovaldi’s potential but based on what we’ve seen so far, if tomorrow’s start @ATL doesn’t show much would consider dropping him for Skaggs, Roark, Hector Santiago, Mike Leake, Vargas, McAlistair, Quintana, Vargas, or Koehler? Or is it best to give him a couple of starts to get on track?
And a couple of quickies:
You’re sitting Salazar tonight vs. KC, right?
And among Melky, Leonys, or Aoki who’d be a good buy low offer if I want to get Wil Myers? Any of those guys you wouldn’t trade away?
Thanks!
@Enrique: I would not drop Eovaldi for any of those guys you mentioned above. what track do you expect him to get on btw?! He has been on the right track from day one. Just keep him, he is pitching constantly well.
@Enrique: Those are all streamers…Sitting Salazar, yes… Those guys aren’t getting Wil Myers
Brad Milla, just like Josh Rutledge. You can’t win em all Grey, even god-like bushy mustaches such as yourself can’t hit 1.000
@Fireball Feliz: Miller is way better than Rutty though, the Mariners are just ice cold right now
@Fireball Feliz: Ha
In a keeper I take Cargo, Justin Upton, and Matt Carpenter for Ryan Braun, Jose Abreu, Dee Gordon, and Marvel Ozuna and run with it, don’t I?
@P-bird: the rest of my team for reference: C Castro 1B Freeman 2B Gyorko 3B Encarnacion SS Segura IF Abreu OF Braun OF Marte OF Alex Gordon OF Ozuna Util Adams Util Dee Gordon BN Brad Miller BN A Hill
@P-bird: also keep top 4 guys so likely I’d be keeping cargo only, maybe Upton
@P-bird: but… Braun’s been mashing while Cargo’s knee thing worries me
@P-bird: It’s fair, doesn’t seem like a slam dunk…
Is Oscar Tarvares getting the call in a week or two? Worth stashing right now?
Already stashing Polanco, but if I nab Oscar that could give me an outfield of Choo, Hamilton, Marte, Polanco, Tavares, Ozuna, Brantley once June rolls around here.
Insanely lucky pitching other than Tanaka and Felix has me in 3rd place of a 12 team mixed roto. Give it a shot?
@The Big Stank: Okay
@Grey: “lucky” pitching huh, i’m guessing you’ve streamed then kept kelly/mcallister/harang/simon/thornberg/vargas/t.wood, or at least 2-3 or those guys.
Which pitcher would you drop first, Bucholz or Kluber? And is Kolten Wong worth holding onto at middle infield? he’s starting to split time and it’s hard to say it but alcides escobar and espinosa are looking better
@Ian:
what SP are available instead of Buchholz/Kluber?
@danny almonte: escobar
Hi Grey, I have Ortiz for only one UTIL spot (no DH), so I can’t put other players here.
Other options are Carlos Beltran or Jose Abreu.
You think who the best choice is to put in UTIL? Thanks.
@Wilson: Trade them for parts needed…. Abreu
@Grey: Will try to trade them. Thanks.
Double confirm, Abreu is the best choice at UTIL over Ortiz & Beltran from your advice, right ?
Yes
@Grey: Is it because Abreu younger and upside possibility? Thanks.
(Otherwise Ortiz & Beltran seems with better AVG and similar power.)
Yup
I like how you hid the Miller blurb at the bottom. Damn you Grey, DAMN YOU!!!
@T-Bone: I will mention Jean Segura too…not going well for. Greys reccomendations so far!
Brantley or Ozuna for the rest of the season?
@KarlJ:
Good question! Hopefully both! They could potentially both be strong #3 of’s
@KarlJ: Brantley
Who would you drop C.Buchholz or T.Wood? The pitching categories in my league are: QS, K, BAA, ERA, WHIP, K/BB. Thanks! And as always, great write ups.
@Yardwork: own Travis Wood and don’t be afraid of matchups. the dude just knows how to pitch. he’s a cheaper version of Mike Minor or a Cliff Lee Lite
@Yardwork: Buchholz
dallas keuchel and his 2.86 xfip need a post! dare i pick up an astros starter?
@stonepie: Blech
2B Dozier or Bonifacio…EB average and SB fit my all power team better but…..
@John: Bonifacio
Get ready for a big week from Lindstrom (a.k.a. I benched Lindstrom this week).
@L-Boogie: Hope so
Would you trade Salazar and Springer for Cain in a H2H points league.
Here’s my staff (we start 4): Felix, Greinke, Anibal, Gray, Shelby Miller, Gerrit Cole, Salazar, Bauer, Carlos Martinez and Bundy.
My outfield is (we start 4): Braun, Jones, Gordon, Cespedes, Springer, Calhoun, Moss, Prado and Khris Davis
@malamoney: Sure
Should I own Dickerson or Wong instead of Owings for bench depth?
@Sniff Test:
not wong .
especially with your commenter name .
@Sniff Test: Dickerson
Hunter = 5
The Field = 1
@Wake Up: Here comes the field!
Hoping the Braves are going to roll with Walden if and when Kimbrel lands on the dl with lingering shoulder stiffness. Did the pre-emptive pick up in a couple leagues three days ago.
@Lville Jim: One things for sure, they shouldnt go to Carpenter. Holding Walden and hoping Kimbrel is hurt, if he is Waldens gotta be el hombre.
@Lville Jim: I picked up Walden in all four of my leagues where he was available. They had better not go with Carpenter because I don’t want to put any of my eggs into that basket.
@Principal Blackman: a lot of managers shy away from using all the time lefties.
@Aubrey Plaza’s Pillow: Aren’t Carpenter and Walden both right-handed?
@Principal Blackman: yr right, for some reason i thought walden was lefty. opps.
Scott Feldman – To the DL with biceps tendinitis. Feldman’s bubbie asked him, “Why aren’t you more like that nice Jewish boy with the sore thumb?”
If you lean in and listen reaaaallly closely you can probably hear Feldman’s bubble bursting. :: pop::
There it goes.
@Hawk: Ha
Where are you on M Perez, is he a start each time out grad in a 10 teamer yet? Or if still a streamer, would you pitch him tommorow vs Oaktown.
@Swfcdan: Yes
@Grey: out of perez, vargas, d haren, a simon who do you like best?
Perez
BRAD “&*$?!/*&#$_)()_&*(?!6?!*&%$!” MILLER!!!
@Ron: Ha
Who are you higher on in H2H Dynasty format?
Profar or Baez
Altuve or Rendon
@tagman: Baez, Altuve
Lost Sale to the DL. Which of these options you like the best to fill in:
Travis Wood, Tyler Skaags, Garrett Richards, Dillon Gee, AJ Burnett, Tom Koehler, Kyle Lohse
Or would you just look to stream?
Mejia also available
@Janssen with the Stars: (1) stream WW based on matchups; (2) stream with those pitchers based on matchups; (3) use SON.
drop venable to pick up dickerson?
@b-dubya: Sure, in a shallow league
This reminds me…If Nick could possibly spare some of his Giant’s Milk…please feed a shot or two of it to Bwad Milla…
@Wake Up: Ha!
“Remember that game where Brad Miller hit 2 HR’s! It was almost as memorable as that game I walked 3 times!!!” That’s Jackie Bradley Jr. talking to no one.
@Fish: Haha
@Grey: brad miller has now had 3 different 2 homer games.
@Aubrey Plaza’s Pillow:
Now you made Jackie Bradley Jr. sad. He only has 2 games with 3 walks.
@Fish: what’ll make him sadder is when he looks back at his career and notices he never had a 2 homer game.
Well since Sale and Latos are my 1 and 2 in the nfbc, looks like my season is done. Have fun y’all, see ya next year!
@Cole: Dont jump off a cliff!
@Cole: Football season come early for ya this year?
@Principal Blackman: ha yeah. In my mind I’m already drafting spiller and burying my head in my hands as Fred Jackson gets the goal line carries.
Totally took Grey’s advice and picked up Dave Carpenter yesterday. As Kimbrel continues to struggle that is looking more and more like amazing forecasting.
Grey skies ahead! Good looking out, kid.
@Allen: Hopefully
Just heard what was up Buchholz…he slept with John Lackey…at Fenway…the night before…
@Wake Up: Hey, that’s not the Pesky Pole!
I was offered George Springer for my Yordano Ventura.
My other starters are Sonny Gray, Justin Masterson, Francisco Liriano, Julio Teheran, and Alex Cobb.
Thoughts?
@Cheese: Sounds fair
Who do you like better ROS in a standard Roto non keeper:
Anibal or Teheran?
Thanks.
@Stoopid: Teheran’s got them WMDs
@Stoopid: Anibal
Morning! Re: my comment on the last thread- the bar survived a rough winter and seems to be thriving. The first night we were there they shot a music video in the parking lot that ended with a motorcycle on fire- rebel country!
So I missed out on Ike (someone paid $10 for him). Duda or Fowler?
@royce!: Haha… Duke boys show up? Fowler, but apples and oranges with Duda
@Grey: Haha, basically. Hard to tell the hipsters from the real thing, though.
My friend there has a neighbor who actually goes by “Hillbilly,” and from what he’s told me, it’s not ironic.
HA… I wonder if it’s Hillbilly Jim from 80s WWF… Then again he’s probably dead
Poor babyface Yelich!
Pick a side, any side (standard RCL league):
Fielder + Harper or Goldschmidt + Cespedes
@Beastman: Oh that’s big time right there. Looks like our league.
Hard to turn away Goldy, especially with Harper and Fielder slumping. Tough call. Since I’m in the league, I will abstain.
@Beastman: I love Goldy, but Fielder/Harper is maybe too good to pass up.
@Beastman: Fielder, Harper
@Grey: That’s my guy call too. Just wish my first 2 picks weren’t sinking my team so quickly.
Two questions:
1) Pick up Lindstrom or Veras over Broxton or Jim Johnson?
2) Play either Springer @ Erasmo or Pedro v. Cueto today?
H2H – H, R, HR, RBI, SB, AVG, OB+SLUG, W, QS, SV, KS, KS/9, ERA, WHIP
@Wilsonian: Lindstrom over Broxton…. Pedro
So I got offered Machado, Dee Gordon & Abreu for Miggy (mind you the guy already has Trout) He said I thought you needed some speed, I rejected the trade with just one word “SAGNOF” he sent me a email and was like what the effin is “SAGNOF” ?!?
@Teddy Heater: Ha!
@Grey: Yahoo is blasting Teheran! I love it because now I can roster him on the 1 team I’m missing him on.
Ha
“They” all laughed when I picked Ike as my preseason sleeper.
Guess who’s laughing now?
(It’s still them. They won’t get off my patio.)
@Mike: Who are they? Do you need Nick to chase them away?
ha! yes! and bring Blake for the extra muscle
Haha
@Mike: @Grey: I’ll muscle punks for you Mike
Jack’s got my back…internet high five
@Mike: followed by a fist bump
Need 2 backend starters for points league. Who are the top two from this bunch for ROS?
Travis Wood, Koehler, Robbie Ross, Volquez, Kluber, Odorizzi
Thanks.
@Ron: Wood, Volquez, these are streamers
Morneau or Howard
@Booty: Howard
Speculative pickups, choose 2 of 3 that you’d want for saves this year.
Daniel Webb
Danny Farquhar
Rex Brothers
@Shake N Bacon: Brothers, Webb
@Grey: Gracias!
De nada
I was offered Tulo for Sonny Gray & Sterling Castro in a 10 Team H2H with added OBP,SLG,
Rest of Rotation is Fernadez, Sale, Teheran, Iwakuma, Cole, Cingrani, Pineda, Ventura & Chavez
Should I take it?
@Kevin: Take Tulo
Gray,
You starting Salazar tonight vs KC? No inning limit in my league
@Brett: No
Is Brad Miller droppable in 10 team 5×5?
@Shitty Bill Butler: Read the post
Tied in Runs, RBIs, HRs, and SBs so far in my H2H league this week. Who should be the odd man out for my roster today: Matt Adams, Springer, Billy Hamilton, or Puig?
Hitter-Tron is a little too close to call b/w Hamilton and Puig. I’m actually surprised Billy’s ranked so high.
@Corey: Sidebar: Do you put any stock in Yahoo’s matchup ratings? Tonight for Puig: “Slugging .546 in 119 ABs against other top-tier, right-handed pitchers since last season.”
@Corey: @Kevin: Eh, those things are nice to have but I doubt the science behind it is as accurate as Hittertron or Streamonator.
@Corey: Yahoo’s “star” rating, no. The cold, hard statistic, yes.
@Cram It: Such as the above with Puig vs RHP? I find those things so very vague… If it said, “Puig is slugging .546 in 12 ABs vs AJ Burnett” then that’s one thing. Do you count generalized statements such as “Pitcher X typically struggles against hitters like Hitter Y” to be cold and hard? I suspect not, but I’m also trying to talk myself into plugging Billy Ham into my lineup.
@Corey: Ummm, yes that’s what I’m referring to, the statistic that says he’s awesome. I don’t sit Puig. I don’t know what the other matchups are but I’d start Puig over any of those guys, regardless what any machine says. It’s your team, start Hamilton.
@Cram It: Thanks. Stupid outfield logjam created when Springer got the call: Stanton, Puig, D Brown, Billy Hamilton, Springer. Sir Domonic is an easy bench most days, but that’s still 4 OFs for three spots plus Utility, but I often keep Matt Adams there.
@Corey: Springer…No credence to Yahoo matchups
@Grey: Thanks Grey. Your power commenting never ceases to amaze.
No problem
12 team 5×5 h2h. would you drop straily for any of drew hutchinson, brandon morrow, or robbie ross jr?
@jaw: They’re streamers
Khris Davis or Eovaldi. Which side wins in a 5×5? Thanks Grey!
@hankp: Apples and oranges…Davis
Pick 2:
Ryan Howard, Neil Walker, Aaron Hill, Everth Cabrera, Brad Miller and Khris Davis
Pick 1:
Jim Johnson, Broxton or Farnsworth
@malamoney: Hill, Everth…. Farnsworth
Grey, you forgot to mention the Monday Edwin Encarnacion had. E5 had one of his best games of the year so far last night!!
@Moronymous Lohse: Cool
Okay, Grey. I drafted Miller as my SS and it’s really hard not to take you up on that scorn-vitation you buried at the bottom of today’s column.
Biting tongue, hurts, tasting blood.
Okay, so any ideas on lightly owned SS with upside that I might want to plug in until I can find something in a trade? So far it has been a carousel of Villar, Avilles (yuck and yuck) and A. Escobar (who I am more optimistic on).
@Greg: Villar
Safe to drop Kelley now since Robertson was activated today? or hold to see how Rob does? Thanks
@Greyismyhero: Always hold when a guy just gets off the DL.
@Cram It: the most likely time to get injured is when you’re just “off” being injured.
Deeeeep H2H-Points League. Need pitching help. Who are your top 2 from this yawnstipating list?
W-Y Chen
Miguel Gonzalez
Tanner Roark
Tom Koehler
Tyler Lyons
Taylor Jordan
@Commish Cauda: Roark, Koehler
Offered a trade in 10-team H2H ESPN league:
My side – Sending Adrian Gonzales and Michael Cuddyer for Carlos Gonzales and Carl Crawford.
I have Rizzo and Jose Abreu as backup 1B, along with Puig, Coco Crisp, Braun and Choo as other OF.
Do I make the deal?
@nucappy: Yes
Was offered Justin Upton for My Teheran. I’ve got Trout, Puig, Cespedes in the OF with Ortiz and Moss in UT.
My rotation is Greinke, Teheran, Liriano, Gray, Ventura, Martin Perez, Taijuan Walker (DL), Mat Latos (DL).
Take Upton or will my pitching hurt? 12 Team H2H, K/9
@Scarecrow Greinke: Take Upton
Hey Grey – you still like Granderson over Rasmus ???
@Big League Wood:
aka Kurtis and Kolby..
@Big League Wood: Nah
Grey, I know you have wishful thinking that Kimbrel is going to the DL, but wouldn’t you think that the Braves wouldn’t have let him throw 30 pitches in the inning if he was that hurt?
@Hans: Why did Sale throw 127 pitches and hurt himself?
@Hans: The Braves have been notorious for running their pitchers into the ground (look at Jonny Venters, Eric O’Flaherty, Kris Medlen, etc.).
Love ya. Which side:
Pujols Nelson Cruz porcello vs. rios b.phillips cingrani masterson
I’m leaning pujols side. You?
@G-Money: Pujols
@Grey: the idiot just cancelled saying it was too much. Now he’s proposing pujols prado porcello for rios Phillips cingrani and masterson.
I want pujols but is this too much?
Sounds fine
@Grey: I countered 1 more time swapping pagan for prado. I think he will be better assuming he stays healthy. But thanks for the help. Pujols look like vintage pujols.
No problem
@Grey: pujols! Nothing better than trading for someone and he hits a jack his first at bat.
Nice
@Grey: he just hit another! Gray you’re the man!
Oh, yeah!
Just chiming in to say I’m STILL laughing at “Heartspark Stealsign.”
Ike Davis: Are we believing? He hit over 30 HRs once. Then again he’s in a platoon. Then again he may soon be hitting cleanup on a good team. Then again he’s Ike Davis, given up on by the METS. Then again, he was given up on by the METS, and there’s nothing more METS than giving up on a guy who becomes a star elsewhere.
I dropped Jim Henderson to pick him up is what I’m saying.
@Baron Von Vulturewins: Ha… I think he’s in the platoon is what really sticks out for me… Maybe if he can hit both sides by the ASB there might be something there for all leagues…Worth a flyer though to see…
@Grey: Wait was that “ha” for your own EverCab joke? Not even a “ha!” ?
Tough room.
It was for mine… Ha…HA!
Drop Clay Buchholz? I could use the spot for streaming or pick up a saves speculative add like Kyle Farnsworth. I could also pick up a backup catcher like Mesoraco or Martin (currently have Rosario as my only Catcher).
@Brendan: Farnsy’s not speculative, he’s closing
@Cram It:
Then should I drop Buchholz and pick up Farnsworth?
Hey @Grey, Do I start Danny Salazaar today against KC? I know he has great potential but he has been killing me… What do you think??
@Eddie: Sit him
@Eddie: No, bench him till he tosses a good game or 2
Trade Jay Bruce for Upton? Pick up Frazier or Middlebrooks?
@Jay One: Hold Bruce…. Frazier
I’m not even sure Dan Straily is MediOAKer…
@supra: Ha, he’s not
Jofer & Howard for Mad Bum & Bruce. Who wins? Also Blackmon is #1 on the RCL player rater? WTF is up wit dat mayneeee!
@Bi-Felicia: Bruce side
Wong , walker or Ackley at 2B while Gyorko figures some things out
@Will: Walker
Gattis or Weiters ROS?
@skinny tires: Wieters
Seriously? Drop Miller? Would you drop him for Owings?
What about Schoop?
@Austen Beamus: No, I wouldn’t
Great write up as always!
With Sale going on the DL, would you rather lose Crain or Janssen to clear a DL spot for him?
@Spring Blake: Janssen
Dozier or bonifacio in a ten team mixed league. I picked up bonifacio dropped brad miller But someone just dropped dozier.
Seager is also annoying right now too. So I can drop him for dozier and play both bonifacio at 3 and dozier at 2
@Ulysses: Bonifacio
@Grey: drop seager for dozier?
Hold
Thoughts on Kolten Wong now that Ellis is back? Matheny has been playing Ellis over him a lot, even against right handed pitching. If it continues who do you like to replace him? Dietrich, Espinosa, Lemahieu?
@wOBA the Hutt:
dietrich … as he could also see time at SS .
Grey,
Question about Brad Miller…
1. He is my backup 2B/SS on a lot of teams. As a backup, do I wait him out? Or is Nick Franklin taking his job soon?
2. The pickings are slim for a 2B replacement. Do any of this make sense as an actual upgrade/replacement?
Dustin Ackley
Kelly Johnson
Kolten Wong
Omar Infante
Thanks…
Mike.
@Mike: 1. You can wait out a backup 2. Nope
@Grey: Thanks Grey!
Mike.
No problem
I was offered Teheran for Bruce. My outfield is stacked (Braun, Giancarlo, JUpton, Myers, & Gordon) and our point system favors pitching. I’m also in dire need of starting arms. Take the deal?
@JK Smiles: Let’s recap: Your OF is stacked, the points system favors pitching AND you’re in dire need of pitching. I think you answered your own question.
Are we still waiting on Panda to turn it around at 3B or is it time to move to Frazier or Reynolds?
Thanks!
@splartch: Frazier
Trade rizzo and Ross for E5?
C Molina
1b goldy
2b hill
SS segura
3b gyorko
Of cutch Bautista jup
Util heyward rizzo
Sp – MadBum iwakuma cole Salazar Ross Chavez peralta
@Oppo Taco: Sure
Would you trade kris bryant dom brown lee for mccutchen in a dynasty league? Is this too much to offer or is this a fair deal? Thanks!
@Ryan: Yup
@Grey: thanks! Just worries trading bryant might be something I will regret later down the road.
No problem
@Ryan: Cutch will be something you won’t regret right now.
Start Salazar today? I wasn’t going to but then I saw he has KC
@Vottomatic: Sit
Coco bruised his ribs last night diving for Martin’s bloop double. Guessing he gets the night off. Gentry is a decent steals stream so far this year and should get the start if Coco is in fact out…for all you steals streamers out there.
@OaktownSteve: True
dynasty H2H
McCann, Gattis, Mesoraco
Keep 2
@McGaMe: Not Mesoraco
@Grey: really, even though he’s so much younger than mccann?
Morning Grey… Nice work as always!
Drop Asche for Schoop or Olt in a 20 Team 5×5 yahoo? have Middlebrooks on DL too…
@Big W: Schoop
Dynasty league question again.
Am i crazy for wanting more then Jfer/Altuve/daniel webb for Goldy?
Or am i passing up on the best young pitcher ever?
@Amicrazy: Not crazy
Hey Grey,
I love it when you can sneek a 80’s wraaaslin’ nod that brings a good laugh.
Need some advice. 4×4 NL 8-team Keeper $260 ($3/yr extension cost)
I won last year but lost CarGo/CLee/JUpton/MadBam/Gio Gonzales back to free agency. So I drafted a slew of MiLB pitchers to restock a very bare fridge and plan on having what my beloved MN Twins call a “Rebuilding” year….. decade……s**t man it been too long since 1991. AnytheWho!
I knew I would drop someone(two) after the 1st month but I am not sure who is the best value/upside. Can you rant the following?
Jon Gray $4
Noah Syndergaard $8
Lucas Gioloto $1
Archie Bradly $8
Thanks from Warm and Sunny Fargo
-Parrot
@ParrotheadFargo: Thanks! Bradley, Noah, Gray
Grey, I dropped Chris Carter for Ike Davis yesterday morning. Turned out to be a good move! You think Ike will breakout or just too small of a sample?
@Def Clippard: Too small
Odd thing where April 19 was a key date for Jon Singleton in the Astros org. Having kept him in AAA past they delayed his free agency by a year to 2020. He’s got 7 homers, .349 avg and 1.500 OPS at AAA right now. Might be a good time for a speculative stash in deep leagues. Could see a call up within the week, possibly two.
@OaktownSteve: Yeah, I hear ya
@Grey: Yeah – he just hit another HR a few minutes ago. :)
Nice!
Wheeler and Masterson are my worst two starters and have been extremely meh for me…. Jesse Chavez and Alfredo Simon are still on waivers.
IMPREGNATE MY BRAIN WITH YOUR KNOWLEDGE
@Humberto Sanchez: Chavez over Wheeler
Hey Grey, great stuff as usual.
Need to pick someone up with Sale on the DL. Please rank:
Robbie Ross
Kyle Gibson
Zach McAllister
Wily Peralta
Edinson Volquez
Also, thinking of dropping Straily for one of the above. Would you do that and for whom?
Thanks in advance.
@kidbr9: Wily
Trade hunter pence for the adverb? I could use the starter. I know what Aaliyah said but I’m still a little worried?
@Steve d: Ha… Take Lee
JJ Hardy was just dropped. Thoughts on Hardy? My shortstop is Alcides Escobar
He’s decent for power
need to drop 1
Leonys Martin
Yelich
Victorino
@tg: H2H Dynasty.
Victorino
Guy I’ll be looking at tonight is Edison Volquez. Pirates got some credit for rebuilding Liriano last year. Volquez has 2 or fewer earned in first four starts. The K/9 is way, way down. The BB/9 are way way down. Reds provide a good test tonight. Be interesting to see how he approaches them with their patience and if he continues a pitch to contact trend.
@OaktownSteve: yeah, I’m giving it tonight to see if the Pirates magic works on this guy. Hard to believe it’s been 6 years since his 207 K outburst. If he keeps his walks down and picks up a few more Ks, he could be a sneaky great grab in the shallowest of leagues.
Agreed, glad I have him in two leagues this far but he’s not out of the woods yet
Im rostering now and startng eovaldi and T ROss tomo but looking SON likes Smyly and odorizzi much better. Looking for one more start I was thinking Simon SON says NOOOO.
Odorizzi
Smyly
Simon
Smyly
April 22nd. Chris Davis has more steals than homeruns. That is all.
Ha
Just wanted to give a shout out to Past/Future Grey who called the Kershaw and Sale injuries….last year. Temporal displacement for future Grey!!!!!
Haha
Hey Grey! wicked post as per the yuge.
Think I should stream Tommy Milone today? SON loves him ($17), two start post (Pete Nice) says stay-away. Its in OAK vs. TEX.
And if you could – Miller out for Dozier or Dee Gordon?
I wouldn’t start Milone in most leagues… Gordon
Hey Grey,
Drop Santos for Axford? ROS
Sure
What are your thoughts on Andrew Heaney of Miami? He’s tearing it up in the minors right now. Any guesses on when he might get the call?
Maybe June
I need you to reconfirm your love for Gyorko.
@EuroKrytyk: To be honest i am starting to need it too…
Drop Headley for Ike for CI depth?
Small sample, but doesn’t it always seems like guys do their best to make the Mets look like idiots for trading them?
Okay
@Grey: Another option would be to drop McGahee for Ike. Might be grasping at straws, but trying to justify my drafting of Headley with hopes of the monster contract year that’s never gonna happen.
Go for it
Plan on dropping erasmo but should I start him vs the stros first?
Eh
Koehler, Perez, Simon or peralta?
Perez
I was going to say that gyorko may be greys “Rutledge” this year but him and Miller are still currently fighting over who takes that prize.
I suggest a tag team cage match between amarista/gyorko and Miller/Franklin to decide the final outcome. The only rule – One team must dress like the legion of doom and the other like the Hart foundation.
Better SP stash – Andrew Heaney or Trevor Bauer?
Bauer
Great rundown!
Some folks in my league drop folks quick–Cobb is on waivers, wanting to grab him to stash. Ventura or Tillman droppable for him? (I have Sale, Hamels, Price, Shields, Tanaka, Fister too so can afford to stash a starter a bit–figure he will be trade bait later).
Secondly, Springer for real? Would you rather have him or Young, Ozuna, Yelich type? Or Allen Craig (just dropped)?
Thanks! He’ll be your third DL’d SP? I’ve gone over Springer before…
@Grey: yeah, I know–but with the rest healthy, Including Hamels, and our leagues tight inning cap–I’d think Price, Shields, Hamels, Tanaka, Ventura/Tillman are still a lethal rotation for a month?
Yeah, I know everyone likes Springer, but as much as those others named? Namely Craig.. What about Hosmer for Craig (Abreu is my main 1b right now, craig atleast has OF eligiblity).
Rotation sounds fine… Hosmer
@Grey: so you’d pass on Cobb?
For now
Going to drop Miller who would you grab?
Kendrick or Walker
ugh.
Walker
im in a 12 team H2H league. Ive been offered a trade of McCutchen and Josh Donaldson for Matt Carpenter and Matt Holiday. I know these are the 3b for 3b and OF for OF but do you think I am getting the better side of the deal with andrew and Josh coming back to me. I have Frazier on the bench at 3b and Jed lowrie backing up altuve at 2b. This would give me a OF of Elbury,McCutchen and dom Brown. I guess mainly worried about donaldson holding his own against matt carpenter by the end of the year. If he will be close in #’s. Thanks for all your insite. Btw 1st time writing the site and I love your info.
Thanks! I’d want McCutchen
Carpenter or Walden? I would need to drop Morneau, Ozuna, Jim Henderson, or Salazar
Worth a gamble or just hold what I have?
Walden…Lose henderson
Jon Singleton just hit his 8th HR for the Houston Astros AAA team. Something in my head said that he probably has more HRs than all of the Astros combined. Nope. The Astros as a team have already hit 22 HRs. That is tied for sixth in all of baseball. Surprising. But here’s something probably MORE surprising.
The KC Royals, as a team, only have SIX.
SIX freakin’ homeruns!! ALL YEAR!!
I had no idea. Probably because I don’t own any Royals. But that is brutal! Suckass had almost that many during the Spring alone.
Other teams with none-too-many bombs:
Orioles with 10
Cards, Pards, and Tards (Cardinals, Padres, Mets) with 12.
Royals don’t face Triple-A pitching…
@Grey: True. But the Royals have faced White Sox*, Astros and Twins pitching in 12 of the 17 games they’ve played. The good news is they’re 7 and 5 in those games. Was just surprised in their lack of power. Every year coming out of spring they look great and then…nothing.
*Chris Sale didn’t pitch in the series.
Yup, agreed
Masterson just dropped in one of my leagues … who’s the drop; Wily Peralta, Martin Perez, Rick Porcello, Tijaun Walker? Or hold?? I
Walker
Oscar Taveras’s ankle is acting the fool again. I’m officially done waiting for that kid.
Yup
Silver lining — left ankle issue. surgery was to right ankle last season.
@ashtray: Absolutely been one of the most frustrating prospects to own in dynasty leagues.
Who would you out of stash Polanco, Singleton or Peterson?
@ashtray: er.. “who would you stash out of”
Singleton
@ashtray: Surprised you mentioned Peterson given how he’s hitting right now. Solid prospect, but Polanco and Singleton are currently on a different level.
I have Wil Myers, Rizzo and Matt Adams for three spots in a 12-team 5×5. I also have Brad Miller and Kyle Seager (sigh). Wire is bleak. I see you like Alcides but I am going to wait a little on that one. Any ideas for my shit storm? Thanks!
@JAL: for two spots***
Myers, Rizzo
@Grey: Thanks for the quick response and sorry for being vague. Any SS or 3B targets with using Adams as bait?
Depends who needs Adams… Maybe Andrus
@Grey: That is exactly who I am targeting. Thanks
Thanks for the post Grey! If could pick your brain or mustache for a bit…
16T H2H w/ 3 add per week max. Obviously making streaming a challenge.
Pitching stats — K, QS, W, SV, HLD, ERA, WHIP, K/9, K/BB
Reading the comments above on benching Salazar today, wondering if I can afford to do the same?
Feel like I surrender (potentially) a few stats in hoping he doesn’t wreck my ERA & WHIP.
No problem… I’d bench him
Have Sandoval, Dee Gordon, Castro, and Arenado. Would you drop any of them for:
Yelich
Dickerson
Ike
Frazier
Castro for Frazier
Walden over Cody Allen, D. Webb or Broxton?
Webb
Lost Sale and Feldman yesterday in 14 team mixed league. Thoughts on Kyle Gibson and Skaggs as potential replacements?
Sure
For all you Farnswroth guys : Kyle Farnsworth was spotted hunched over in the tunnel to the clubhouse and shaking his forearm after converting a save Monday night against the Cardinals, but the Mets say that he is “fine.”
Farnsworth acknowledged after the game that he was shaky his forearm, but he merely chalked it up to him being “old.” It doesn’t sound like a big deal, but it wouldn’t be surprising if he gets a night off Tuesday.
Old, ha!
In a limited moves (I’ve got a good amount left) 10 team H2H league with OBP and SLG instead of AVG, drop Brad Miller for Alcides, Solarte, Infante, Espinosa or Villar?
Keeping in mind that I’m stashing Javier Baez.
Thanks in advance.
Villar
Grey – what do you think of this trade. I just got offered.
Carlos Santana, Aaron Hill, Prince Fielder for Jonathan Lucroy,Jason Kipnis, Jay Bruce
Who wins?
Fielder side, it’s fair
Grey,
how many more weeks would you wait for Gyorko to start hitting??
He has pretty cool last name, but I can be OK with more ordinary one like Walker or something.
Which would you add in a holds league: Walden, Allen, Ottavino, Cecil, Thornburg?
In a saves league, too early to drop Axford to gamble on Walden?
Walden… Don’t drop Axford
@Grey: verlander, Ryu, minor, archer, porcello, Pineda, Martin Perez…Reed, Perkins, Papelbon, Cishek… Perez the drop for a middle relief?
Sure
@Grey: wow, doesn’t Axford lead MLB in saves currently? i need to sell you guys some stocks for all that money you have in your hands.
Who’s buying Axford?
@Grey: battle of sleepers was asking about dropping him for a guy who might have a short term closing job.
Hill v Hammell or Lowrie v Martinez?
Hitter-tron has them ranked pretty similarly.
Hill
Salazar and Dozier for Gyorko and a stream spot until I can take Minor off the DL?
H2H – H, R, HR, RBI, SB, AVG, OB+SLUG, W, QS, SV, KS, KS/9, ERA, WHIP
Gyorko
Are you worried about Chris Sale Grey?
Yes
I’ve watched nearly every Brewer game this year & was @ the game last night & I can say that is the hardest I’ve seen Segura hit the ball all year. Outside of a base running error …again… he looked good. Also despite the report he is batting 7th, it was actually 6th as they made a late lineup change.
Scooter is also hitting the ball hard & until Segura is clearly better, he may not see the 2 hole for a bit ….unless Segura leads off when Gomez gets suspended.
Peralta also had more heat then Cashner by a bit (96-97mph vs 94-95), Cashner was really hit hard in the 3rd inning ….line drive after line drive. I would have to say I am pleased to have Peralta so far, I think he pitched better then his stat line for the game showed …although yes it was the Padres.
Nice breakdown
@Grey: he’s pitched better than his stats and MUCH better than SON says so far. i’ve got him in at least 6 places now.
I’m streaming Moustakas tonight. Mostly because I feel a Gallardo regression fest in the making. But I took a look at Moose’s peripherals. Some funky stuff going on.
He’s got a 6% LD rate. Pretty putrid. Only AJ Pollock and Brett Lawrie are worse. His BB rate is up 3% from the last couple of years. His FB% is at 52% which can have positive effect on power numbers though it hasn’t translated yet. His BABIP is at .125 which must correct. The lowest season long BABIP among qualified players was .225. Unless he has historically bad luck he’s going to see an uptick here pretty soon I’d say at least in getting some balls to drop in.
Part of his profile that has been no good has been his propensity to pop up. Most in the majors over the last two years (17.2% IFB). So far this year just 3.8% pop ups.
I think a lot depends upon how hard the fly ball contact has been as far as projecting him. If he’s just taken those pop ups and moved them slightly from the infield to the outfield but both his spray chart and his batted ball distance say no. The distance is actually pretty interesting. Avg distance last year 270 feet, 231st among tracked players to 294 feet this year, 45th over all.
So I’d say some reason for optimism. Usually the manager and the hitting coach know if a guy is hitting in bad luck and I’ve heard Yost in MLB radio say as much and say that he feels like it’s just a matter of time. Not saying there’s necessarily a huge break out waiting to happen, but I feel at least a warming trend.
I’ve locked him into my 3rd slot until Middlebrooks returns simply hoping he comes around…
Ok, gotcha. Dump Moustakas and pick up Brad Miller. What pitchers are you starting/benching tonight and tomorrow?
Hey c’mon!
Ha, well… I’m giving Miller another game or 2. He’s not showing any signs, but at least he’s up against crap pitching the next couple games! If you can’t make it work against a Houston spot-starter and Cosart…
I hear ya…
Gibson has been lights out so far this year. Can you see him outpitching Price tonight or stay away?
No
Skaggs only a 5.8 on SON tonight at Washington. Rolling with him in 12 teamer or sitting him?
Also, Gonzalez at Toronto or Martinez at Oakland worth a stream today?
Skaggs worth the slot no idea what else you’re asking
@Grey:
Want 1 or 2 streamers tonight. Options are:
Skaggs at Nationals
M Gonzalez at Blue Jays
Nick Martinez at Athletics
Pick up 1 or 2 or none of them?
Skaggs
@Grey: 5 x 5 weekly roto. drop any of peralta, eovaldi, kluber or chavez for porcello?
Kluber
Bruce for jofer or Strasburg?
My other of are: Bautista, Beltran aoki and Brantley
H2h league
Thanks!
Bruce for Strasburg
ROTO OPS League. Lawrie or Fraizer?
Thanks as always!
Frazier
Sit Kennedy tonight?
What does SON say?
I didn’t draft Brantley but was able to waiver him in the champions league a week ago and he’s given me a line of 6/4/9/2. Way to go fellas, you’re making champions sound like sarcasm….that’s not sarcasm.
Snap!
@Grey: *takes shirt off slaps own chest*
Why are you slapping your chest?
@Grey: like the Iron Shiek
That should modify every sentence… Like a fortune cookie with ‘in bed’…
@Grey: duly noted
I actually DID draft Brantley, dropped him before a game was even played so I could stash Baez, saw another guy in the league grab Brantley off waivers a couple days later and am looking up at his team while my offense is the worst in the league. Yeah – I suck at this sh*t! But hey, I later dropped Baez for Joaquin Benoit so it worked itself out…damn I really do suck at this.
Haha
@Moronymous Lohse: I drafted him, dropped him after a slow start, picked him back up on a short day, dropped him again, and then no one paid attention to him and I picked him back up. I think I’ll quit pressing my luck and hang on to him for a little while.
Grey – thoughts on Alex Wood (ATL)? I really need some pitching help where my top starters are Alex Cobb (DL), Mike Minor (DL), Justin Masterson, and Homer Bailey. 12 tm 5×5.
I can possibly trade Justin Morneau or Fatt Adams for him.
Trade Morneau for him
@Grey: Would you consider Fatt Adams for him if he won’t take Morneau? I have Goldy and Rizzo as 1b and 1b/3b.
Sure
@Grey: Thanks Grey! Just want to give a shout out to the Razzball Staff for all the great work. Ha, Razzball Staff…
Ha, thanks
Have Phillips,Dozier,Elvis,Segura and Gyorko to fill 2B,SS,MI.
Drop Gyorko for Brantley for UTIL/Bench or hold?
Hold
Keeper league where one of my 6 keepers is a minor league project. Getting frustrated with Taveras – drop for Polanco or Singleton. More the long term gain instead of this year although this year is the tiebreaker if close.
Singleton
Which ONE sits on the bench tonight
Puig vs Burnett
Mccutch vs Cueto
Springer vs Erasmo
Bruce vs Volquez
Abreu vs verlander
pujols vs jordan
my first thought is abreu or springer
What does Hitter-Tron say?
@Grey: puig I believe. But I like to hear what you say since yesterday hittertron had jay bruce ranked at 281 and you picked him over someone ranked higher and it worked out for me ;-)
Nevermind it actually has Bruce ranked way lower than Puig. Bruce starting up a hot streak going against Volquez with a career .571 avg ain’t sittin
Springer
10 teamer. I have Cobb and Taijuan injured and have no DL, but 2 “extra” bench spots. Worth dropping either for Jesse Chavez, Travis Wood, or Martin Perez? Rest of my rotation looks like this: Teheran, Gray, Kazmir, Pineda, Archer, Burnett.
Taijuan for Perez
Drop Gyorko for Fraizer? ROS as always.
Thanks a lot
Hold
@Grey:
Ok, i have another question if you dont mind grey. My only bench bat is Matt Adams. I feel like i have to bench Gyorko until he wakes up but i cant right now.
My closers are Balfour, Papelbon, Santos and Frieri. Axford and Hunter are on waivers in my 10 teamer league.
My most expandable starter is Eovaldi but i wouldnt want to drop him.
Would you drop Santos to add Fraizer?
Nope
@Grey:
Ok thanks a bunch
Offer JUpton/M.Perez for McCutchen?
McCutchen
Who is worth starting: gyorko or prado?
Gyorko
Loaded at 1B (Votto, Abreu, VMart) and looking to buy Allen Craig low….
Adrian Gonzalez for Allen Craig?
If not, who are some OF’s to target for AGon? (10 team H2H)
Gordon?
Been a while Grey,
Ryu & Chavez for Rodney?
Need closer help or is this to much?
Hey, long time no hear from! It’s a bit much, but take Rodney if you need him
12t 7×7 H2H keeper (OBP/XBH + QS/IP)
1) MI/CI is a fuggin’ cesspool for me right now.. would you drop Miller, Seager, or Villar for – C. Johnson, Dietrich, Duda, LeMahieu, Callaspo, Gillaspie, Ike, Espinosa, Hechavarria..
2) Trade Villar/Cruz/Perkins for Utley/Rodney ? or Villar/Jennings/Perkins for Utley/Rodney?
I’ve got Machado Man coming back in a few weeks…. hopefully. It’s a miracle I’m above .500 (20-18-4) to start the season. Might throw some more trades at you later, muchos gracias as always!
1) No 2) Nope
Beltran/Bautista, Abreu and Pineda for Ellsbury and JoFer?
Bautista
@Grey: sorry, is that Bautista side of the trade or to do that trade if Bautista is in it? I am the Bautista owner.
Bautista side is better
Trade my Altuve for his Bogaerts and Niese?
If possible to get K-Rod instead of Niese does that sweeten the deal more?
Hold
@Grey: Even if its K-Rod and Bogey?
Yup
@Grey: Hitters
Lucroy
Goldschmidt
Arenado
Segura
Ozuna
Bruce
Yelich
Moss
J. Peralta
Kubel
Myers
Bonifacio
Dozier
Zimmerman
Pitchers
Gray
Peavy
Rodney
Germen
Masterson
Salazar
Vargas
Cueto
Porcello
Paxton
Sale
Advice?
Yet another great article. Thanks for the great information and entertainment.
Just traded my Profar/Bogaerts for his W. Myers/H. Bailey.
Was offered Matt Cain for my Choo.
Should I do it?
Thanks
R, HR, RBI, SB, BB, OPS
K, ERA, WHIP, K/BB, QS, SV+H
12 team Yahoo roto
Dynasty league (17 keepers next year, 20 the following)
C Travis d’Arnaud
1B Paul Goldschmidt
2B Jedd Gyorko
3B Miguel Cabrera
SS Xander Bogaerts
IF Brandon Belt
OF Andrew McCutchen
OF Adam Jones
OF Jay Bruce
OF Shin-Soo Choo
Util Starling Marte
Util Wil Myers
BN Marcell Ozuna
BN Kolten Wong
BN Manny Machado
BN Salvador Perez
P Homer Bailey, Jordan Zimmermann, Gerrit Cole, Yordano Ventura, Martín Pérez, Danny Salazar, Archie Bradley
DL Doug Fister
RP Joakim Soria
RP Matt Lindstrom
RP Luke Gregerson
Forgot to edit but my SS is Alcides Escobar now not Bogaerts.
Hold
@Thank you senor,
was thinking of asking for Hosmer/Gray for Choo/Salazar/d’Arnaud. Too much?
Sounds fine
Need pitching help. My current lineup looks like this
Mesoraco, Devin
Goldschmidt, Paul
Gyorko, Jedd
Segura, Jean
Frazier, Todd
Bautista, Jose
Harper, Bryce
Jones, Adam
Pujols, Albert
Bench
Zimmerman, Ryan
Belt, Brandon
Pitching
Bailey, Homer
Cingrani, Tony
Ventura, Yordano
Perez, Martin
Ross, Tyson
Street, Huston
Tillman, Chris
Bench:
Cobb, Alex
Farnsworth, Kyle
Paxton, James
Walker, Taijuan
Strasburg, Holland(RP), Price and Shields are on the block…would you trade Harper for any of them or a combination of them?
I would not trade Bryce Harper for a pitcher
@Grey:
Out of my current lineup who do you think I should offer and who should I target out of Strasburg, Holland(RP), Price and Shields ?
How deep is this league?
@Grey:
10 team league
@Earlycoff: But that is how ugly things seem to be turning in Washington. Harper is my prized keeper but something just doesn’t seem right. I’m considering trading him away too. And it isn’t just the slow start. I’d want a nice piece, certainly. He’s the sort of guy most managers would probably trade anyone to get short of a Trout, Goldschmidt, McCutcheon type. Harper no longer seems a nice piece but rather the piece to GET a nice piece.
Then you don’t need to trade for pitching, you need to do better with matchups and waivers
@Grey:
I took the SON’s advice this week and started Maholm…guess its one week but I started to lose faith in working the waivers for matchups
@Earlycoff: Too early for that, first look for skills then go to SON and look for matchup. In a 10 tm you dont need to start Maholms unless hes on fire. Skills first then SON then pick out 2 starts and do little research, read few articles.
I wouldn’t trade Harper. Maybe move Belt for a SP. You have 3 first basemen.
Great read as always man, would you consider dropping Dom Brown or Hosmer for Ike Davis? Hosmer has sucked and Dom Brown is currently on my bench as he’s been bad and my other ofs are Cutch, Trout and Brantley. Thanks man keep up the good work.
I wouldn’t. If Dom Brown is on your bench, wouldn’t Davis be there if swapped? I would not cut Hosmer.
Nope
Should I drop Seager for Hart? Need some offense and already have Laroche and Rizzo at 1B, but he will eventually get OF eligibility in Yahoo!
Hold
you think Petit gets job over Vogelsong. i’ve got Maholm, and the only thing he’s got over petit is innings, for now. (NL only problems)
Yea, I’d assume so
check this out, might speed up the hanrahananan or torres talk. from rotoworld:”
Kyle Farnsworth was spotted hunched over in the tunnel to the clubhouse and shaking his forearm after converting a save Monday night against the Cardinals, but the Mets say that he is “fine.”
Farnsworth acknowledged after the game that he was shaky his forearm, but he merely chalked it up to him being “old.” It doesn’t sound like a big deal, but it wouldn’t be surprising if he gets a night off Tuesday. “
Yeah, heard above
@Grey: really, i somehow missed that. when i posted this i hadn’t read all of them.
@Montezuma’s Revenge… right now: i found it.
12 team non keeper, yahoo, roto, 5×5.
yesterday I was offered Encarnacion and De Aza for Harper and Gyorko. I rejected that. we went back and forth, and this was proposed today..
give- Bryce Harper, Jedd Gyorko.
get- Edwin Encarnacion, Alejandro De Aza, Oscar Taveras.
he’s throwing in Taveras. Taveras injured his ankle last night, but is only listed as day to day.
I have to drop someone, and that would be Shawn Kelley now that Robertson is back to closer.
MY TEAM
CA- Rosario. 1B- Abreu. 2B- Pedroia. 3B- Frazier. SS- Andrus. CI-Gyorko. MI- Rollins.
OF- Harper. OF- Bruce. OF- Gardner. OF- Viciedo. OF- Swisher. UT- Reddick
BN- IDavis, Gillaspie, Parra. NA- Morales.
SP- Darvish. SP- Shields. RP-Nathan. RP- Janssen (DL).
P- Allen. P- Fields. P- Kelley. P- Farquhar.
BN- ESantana, Cashner, Ross, Kennedy. DL- Hamels. DL- Crain.
Not good
Which side you like in a H2H points league that is -1 for K’s.
Miggy/Holliday or Longo/J. Upton
Miggy
Need a bench OF.. Drop Bogaerts for Ozuna?
Sure
i can only start 1: skaggs @ washington tonite, or smyly vs chi sox tomorrow?
thanks
What does SON say?
@Grey: son LOVES smyly. $15.6 to skaggs’ $5.8. but can smyly be trusted after that last start? just looking for an extra opinion
I’d go Smyly
@Grey: thanks
No problem
Arenado v. Bum
Rizzo v. McCarthy
Alvarez v. Cueto
Who gets the pine? Arenado is there now.
H2H – H, R, HR, RBI, SB, AVG, OB+SLUG
Sure, leave Arenado
Gray
What’s your thoughts on gennett in mil he is batting 2nd now would you replace miller with him?
Thanks
You have a replacement for him if he sits for Weeks?
@Grey: Weeks is barely getting any playing time & looks totally lost at the plate. Scooter looks to be a lock for the majority of playing time @ 2nd with Ricky being used as a pinch hitter. I suppose Ricky could get some starts vs LHP but don’t be surprised if if he doesn’t. Looking more & more like Scooter is the 2B.
@henncoop: still listed as platoon.
Hitting .412 vs. lefties and .411 overall, # 1 or 2 on player raters, coming off a 2 HR night and starting OF Cuddyer off to the DL, and you have to sit for Drew Frickin .212 hitting Stubbs? What’s a Blackmon have to do?
Haha
For all you E5 owners:
He has averaged 517 ABs over the last three years.
In his last 207 ABs (including last year) he has 51 hits for a .246 AVG with 7 HRs.
207 ABs is 40% of a seasons worth of his average 517 ABs.
The good news is he also sucked most of LAST April. By the 21st he was hitting just .197 with 2 HRs, 8RBI and 7 Runs scored. It was April 22nd – tonight – where he turned it around. He went on to hit 7 homers over the next eight days. See if history repeats!!
Hopefully!
@Moronymous Lohse:
May you prove to be like the prophet Moronymous. He’s one of the one’s in the back of the Old Testament somewhere.
espn 16 team H2H with total bases and OPS (so double counting bases) i punted C and now have Pierzynski. these others are available navarro (best playing time/lineup spot/counting stats), castillo (best homers, worst team)/grandal (best ratios and skill, but bad lineup and playing time). I know the preseason rankings but Navarro might not have been listed due to not having his current job then.
Hold
@Grey: guessing it’s grandal if/when his fixed knee/leg allows him to play enough though?
Sure
…Trumbo not in tonight’s lineup, the night after producing Zona’s only run by doing exactly what he’s there to do, two nights after being batted 7th for two games.
Gibby be gibberin’.
Haha
Grey,
got offered E5 for Pujols…
in light of E5’s struggles and Pujols’s recent resurgence, what do you think?
(I do need a 3B)
Take it if you need a 3rd baseman
I picked up Mesoraco while he’s hot. Ok to drop Castro in the meantime or will Castro be the better option down the line?
Thanks!
I’d prefer Castro
@Grey: Thanks
No problem
I was offered David Wright and Zach Greinke for WIl Myers, Charlie Blackmon, Yordano Ventura and Sonny Gray. I accepted it because I have Kershaw and Iwakuma due back soon. This is in a 12 team H2H league. Im frustrated because this trade has been vetoed twice now. A. getting too much, am i giving up too much, are my leaguemates assholes??? Somone tell me!!!!
@Matt: I think your giving way too much and apparently so does the rest of your league. Really bad trade on your part but I don’t like vetoes.
@nyydj2: Upon further thinking about it, it’s not REAL far off, I guess. I’d rather have Gray & Ventura behind Kershaw and Company than Greinke, so I guess it;s Myers and Blackmon for Wright. Myers has started slow but you have to dismiss that, he’s a stud in the making and if Blackmon even half continues what he’s done production wise, you may regret trading them basically for David Wright, someone I have avoided drafting at his price for years now.
@nyydj2: I love gray and ventura but i have them in other leagues. so the way i looked at it was gray and ventura for grienke. (which in all honesty i still like those two better but the numbers work out.) and blackmon and wil myers for david wright should be a steal! COnsidering pedro alvarez is my only 3rd baseman and i still have gian carlo stanton, michael cuddyer, george springer and gerg polanco waiting to come up. I was feeling good. especially since there are still productive people in free agency to pick up while i wait on kershaw and iwakuma. I dont think it is a vetoable trade.
@Matt: What do you think about gray and blackmon for wright then? The guy im trading with wanted to do that originally.
@Matt: yr leaguemates certainly are assholes.
Trade looks fair
aoki or springer tonight only? crisp is most certainly back in lineup, but neither aoki nor springer has done much (lately in aoki’s case). Hitter T likes Springer a lot more.
I’d go Aoki
Just dropped Asche for Gentry (thanks Oaktown Steve) for a temp roster move, The plan would then be to pick up Fowler for Gentry off waivers
Is Fowler a worth while grab off waivers?
Also picked up Dyson for RP Torres for some short term help with steals.
Would you suggest adding Cain to my DL if I had to drop either Tex SP Harrison or Holland? which one?
I’d go with Fowler… Sure, Holland
@henncoop:
Hey hencoop…Gentry is not in. Coco is going to tough it out. Sorry if that hoses you. I did say IF Coco was out. Was looking 50/50
@OaktownSteve: not a problem …keep up the good work
Wheeler or T Ross?
Frazier or Seager?
Thanks !
Ross at home, they are streamers… Frazier
Jose Abreu or Anthony Rizzo?
Rizzo
local radio station in NY, WFAN mike francessa, just said he couldn’t believe Harvey would do something that stupid. but he did not clarify what “it” was. I’ve looked around and I can;t find anything? Any one hear anything on this?
@Jay: ok so apparently thisis about HArey’s twitter picture and him flipping the bird…
nothing else to talk about in NY sports today? wtf….
Oh…Ha, that is stupid
Possibly coming back this year
Gyorko/heyward or carpenter/Napoli. What side do you prefer? Close? Thanks
Heyward
So I have Everth and Middlebrooks as bench bats (tulo and Arenado are the starters) would you drop either of them for a prospective Singleton/Polanco/Archie add? Everth has been terrible but owning Tulo makes me worry about dropping him. Points league.
@The Wickler: Isnt middlebrooks hurt?? Drop him for archie! or polanco. I like singleton but he scares me a little….
No
Ozuna or Aoki 10 team 5×5?
@Shitty Bill Butler:
Also Matt Napoli is on waivers, add him over Hosmer, Matt Adams, or Arenado?
@Grey
My bad forgot also drop Buchholz for Jenrry Mejia or Harangatang ?
@Grey or Travis wood
Mejia
Who’s Matt Napoli? Hold
Aoki
@Grey:
Alright thanks, the first baseman on Redsox
No problem
In a keeper league…I have Jose Abreu ($12), E5 is $9
What are your thoughts on a Abreu for E5 + Tyson Ross ($9).
I hate the fact that E5 is 31 and Abreu is 27, but fair?
Sounds decent
Who’s starting Salazar today? *sarcasm*
Gee v cards today in a 14-teamer? What do we think? SON doesn’t think much of it, but Gee seems to thumb his nose at the SON on a regular basis…
I’d start him
@SteveNZ: cardinals hitting like poo lately
Am I buying into Jesse Chavez or am I selling him high for a SS like Drel Simmons to chill while I wait for Segura to get his groove back?
You have Segura? You don’t need Simmons then
Clean MRI for Sale. Clean underwear for Oaktown Steve.
Ha
@OaktownSteve: can you unslit a wrist?
@OaktownSteve: That makes two of us
@Big Magoo: duct tape. (michael weston’s fixall)
hey grey, thoughts on harper so far/rest of the season? you had him in top 10 to start off, do you still think he puts it together and puts up top 20 numbers? would you deal him for carlos gomez, yasiel puig, adam jones, ryan braun, rios or jacoby ells bury?
also, if springer and matt holliday are platooning your final outfield spot, is it ok to deal springer for bogaerts to help out at SS, i’m very weak there.
thanks man
I’d deal him for Jones or CarGo… Sure, Boagerts hasn’t been good though
@Grey:
CarGo as in Lil CarGo, Gomez, correct? I know i didn’t put Gonzalez in that list but just wanted to make sure haha
Yes
@Grey:
thanks!
No problem
Barrett is BACK! deep leaguer announcement
Cano or melky/kinsler?
Also still like ogres more than Pence ros?
Cano
Hencoop if you’re about…Coco is in the lineup tonight per Rotogrinders. No Gentry. Hope it’s a reversable transaction. Go with a rare Tony Campana start for steals stream. Getting the start and leading off for Azi.
Gennet, b Miller, or e aybar?
@DomMattingly: Scooter
@Carter: thanks!
Scooter
Grey…monster deal in the works for me
giving up: Scherzer, Braun, Gyorko, J. Abreu
getting: Strasburg, Encanarcion, Kipnis, and Rizzo…
This is a sweetheart of a deal, is it not?
Nope
Following up on your Phillips blurb. He drove in over 100 RBI last year (as a 2nd Baseman!), and now he’s batting 3rd in that lineup with Hamilton and Votto batting ahead of him!
I acquired him last week for Masterson straight up.
Nice
One more bad Salazar start and are we dropping him?
Depends on how bad… I imagine if it’s horrific, the Indians will do the job for us and DL him, claiming something is wrong… Which it might be…
Better buy low for Brantley and a closer: pence or gordon?
Pence
What is the deal with Cardinals first baseman? No matter who they put there the guy hits .300+ with 25+ homers….they have some voodoo working going on there. They lose pujols and they havent skipped a beat.
Ha, seriously…
Pujols!
Pujols!
Grey, 5×5 NL only keeper. My Romo/B.J.Upton/F.Morales for his D.Gordon/YoGa/Colon ?
Gordon side
Should I drop gyorko for howard kendrick? I want to wait, but I don’t think kendrick will last on waivers long. 10-team h2h
I’d hold for now
For fun I went and looked up team ERA since 2012. The Twins have the second worst ERA in the MLB during that stretch with only the Rockies being worse. So, who keeps trying to implement pitch to contact and when will their job be open? Worst…pitching…philosophy…ever…
@Sky: Are you referring to Kyle Gibson? Kirk would not pump his fist to this
@Grey: Oh but he would as he trotted around the basepaths on a Hughes pitch to contact fatty over the middle.
Ha
What’s the over/under on “Drop Gyoko?” questions for this week?
1600
Should I be trading FOR Miggy?
I have Longo, Gyorko and R. Zimmerman (DL) and would need to give up Longo.
I’d take Miggy…
@Grey: jesus, what a difference 3 weeks makes. Longo for Swiggy str up?! Better do it quick though, Swiggy had a good day today.
Could you give me some pitching advice for the week: sit/start?
Eovaldi @ ATL
Kuroda vs LAA
Peavy @ TOR
Chavez @ HOU
Cashner @ WAS
Thanks!
I’d start them all in some leagues
Trade got vetoed in my league. I gave Braun, Trumbo, Cingrani and Soria for McCutchen, Votto, and Chapman. Points league HR are worth 8 points. Do you guys think it should have been vetoed? Thanks. I have asked a couple of your cohorts already just trying to get as many opinions as possible. The cutch side is the side that everyone says is too much. Basically Braun and crap for Cutch, votto, and chapman
Trade got vetoed in my league. I gave Braun, Trumbo, Cingrani and Soria for McCutchen, Votto, and Chapman. Points league HR are worth 8 points. Do you guys think it should have been vetoed? Thanks. I have asked a couple of your cohorts already just trying to get as many opinions as possible. The cutch side is the side that everyone says is too much. Basically Braun and crap for Cutch, votto, and chapman
Nope
@Nicholas Pieroni: Nope
offered his miggy for my longo segura? thoughts. Thanks
It’s fair, bit rich