Was between Ryan Pepiot (8 IP, 1 ER, 6 baserunners, 11 Ks, ERA at 3.11) and Ohtani for the lede and I went with the “eating your vegetables” vs. “dessert as every meal” lede. I mean, which would you have chosen? Dessert? [eyes your waistline] You don’t say. So, Pepiot’s numbers look promising, and the Rays will be done playing nearly every game of their season in that rinky-dink Big Stein Stadium shortly, which is either good or bad, depending on your perspective. Shame the Rays weren’t inspired by Steinbrenner and fired Cash. Or tried to find dirt on Caminero by using a mafia guy, which backfired and had Stu Sternberg suspended. Or had Stu fight a drunk Kevin Cash in the clubhouse while the Bronx cops tried to find the Son of Sam. Am I now smashing baseball knowledge with Spike Lee films? Yeah, maybe. So, Pepiot had 18 whiffs with an elite 95 MPH fastball (47% whiff) and a nasty 86 MPH change (40% whiff). Also, mixed in a cutter and slider, which were fine and dandy. It doesn’t lift Pepiot to ace status, but he’s about as solid a number two as you’re gonna find — 3.29 ERA in 298 career innings and a 9.2 K/9. He’s basically what you were hoping to get from Zac Gallen or what you would’ve taken from Michael King. Now, if only we could get the Ghost of Billy Martin drunk and drive Kevin Cash insane until he quits. Oxford comma missing, or is it? Anyway, here’s what else I saw yesterday in fantasy baseball:
Zach Eflin – 5 IP, 7 ER, ERA at 4.81. He’s pitching fairly mediocrely, but the good news is there’s nothing indicating he should be pitching better, so expectations are in check!
Adley Rutschman – 1-for-4 and his 8th homer. Why do I think he’ll still be drafted high next year? Something about a hyped catcher that never tires drafters.
Brandon Lowe – 2-for-5, 2 RBIs and his 14th homer. He’s nearly reached the top of the 2nd basemen on the Player Rater, i.e., the world’s tallest midget. With apologies to Altuve.
Josh Lowe – 1-for-3, 2 runs and his 4th homer. Elias Sports Bureau said, “The Lowe’s double homer means the Lowe’s near you will be selling patio furniture for 20% off.”
Lance McCullers Jr. – Hit the IL with a foot sprain. I’m sure someone has floated the idea, but I just thought of something, why not: Lance McCullers, shutdown reliever?
Ryan Gusto – 5 IP, 1 ER, 4 baserunners, 8 Ks, ERA at 4.31. Some days the A’s look like the 1927 A’s and some days they look like A’ss. Yesterday, Gusto avoided the gusto winds in Bing Bong and pitched well on four days rest. Baseball, guys and four girl readers, there’s no rhyme or reason sometimes.
Jose Altuve – 1-for-4 and his 11th homer. His homer went 447 feet. Or 894 of Altuve’s feet. (Tiny Altuve jokes are especially funny when you think about the person typing them is the same height as him.)
JJ Bleday – 1-for-3 and his 8th homer, hitting .199. Crazy thing (maybe not crazy), I thought (maybe I’m dumb) Bleday would hit for a decent average this year.
Nick Kurtz – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 7th homer, 2nd homer in two games. This one was a walk-off homer. SacTown hasn’t been this excited for sports since [guy who has never heard of the NBA] ever!
Mitch Spence – 5 IP, 1 ER, 8 baserunners, 2 Ks, ERA at 3.50. Mitch don’t kill my vibe, but Mitch also doesn’t ignite the under-loins with his 7.8 K/9, 2.7 BB/9 and–sorry, I fell asleep, what was I saying?
Giancarlo Stanton – 2-for-4 as he was activated from the IL. I greeted him in his first day back with breakfast in bed, then was chased out of his house. Not my fault the 2nd floor window by the giant elm was so easily pried open.
Clarke Schmidt – 7 2/3 IP, 0 ER, 4 hits, zero walks, 3 Ks, ERA at 3.16. Schmidt happens (congratulatory). Clarke Schmidt since the start of 2024: 2.99 ERA in 147 1/3 IP in 27 games started. Zoinks.
Jose Soriano – 7 IP, 0 ER, 7 baserunners, 6 Ks, ERA at 3.54. If you started him in Yankee Stadium, your pants grapes might be bigger than your brains, but God Bless Them Grapes! Streamonator likes his next one, so things should get easier next time out, which is me attempting a jinx. Ooh, he’s a nasty, nasty boy, that Grey Albright, Fantasy Master Lothario (don’t abbreviate it).
Michael Toglia – 1-for-4, 1 RBI as he was recalled. In 11 minor league games, Toglia had a 29.4 K%, so, yeah, he’s totally fixed. Good stuff, Rockies.
Hunter Goodman – 2-for-4, 3 RBIs and his 12th and 13th homer, hitting .287. Sucks he has to suck next year, but that’s just the deal the Rockies made with the devil. Ask Brenton Doyle or Nolan Jones or find a guy named Nolan Doyle and ask him.
Mickey Moniak – 2-for-4, 2 runs, 2 RBIs and his 8th homer. And he’s tradin’ in his Chevy for a Mickey Moniak (ack-ack-ack-ack-ack).
Jake Irvin – 6 IP, 3 ER, 6 baserunners, 5 Ks, ERA at 4.23. Streamonator liked this one, hates his next. And we move!
Kyle Finnegan – 1 IP, 3 ER, ERA at 3.12, and the massive blown save, costing me my Irvin win. You bastard! That’s okay, Finnegan’ll still be traded in July to become a set-up man, then sign in the offseason back in Washington to become their closer again.
James Wood – 2-for-3, 2 RBIs and his 18th homer, hitting .284. A 22-year-old is on pace for a 40/20 season. Do we talk enough about this? I don’t know if we do. Let’s talk more about Wood, he said while raising one eyebrow.
Daylen Lile – 1-for-3 and his 1st homer. Was recalled before the game with Robert Hassell III being sent down. One too many Hassell’s from that Robert guy. Lile was up previously, hit .194, and was sent down. He does have 50-steal speed, though, so we monocle in mixed leagues, and aggressive attack in NL-Only.
Max Kepler – 1-for-4 and his 9th homer, and 2nd homer in three games, third homer in a week, and I grabbed him in my RCL last week because the hot schmotato is burning bright.
Trea Turner – 3-for-5, 2 RBIs and his 8th homer, hitting .306. Treat Urner showing he’s got that dog in him.
Mick Abel – 5 IP, 1 ER, 4 baserunners, 3 Ks, ERA at 2.21. Only 20 1/3 IP, but the numbers are encouraging if odd — 7.5 K/9, 1.8 BB/9, 3.63 xFIP, after having a 4.1 BB/9 in Triple-A. Sometimes we see a guy with poor command come up and dominant early because hitters are unfamiliar with his stuff and/or don’t know to sit on certain pitches. Doesn’t mean I’m out on Mick, but I am hesitant to give a full-throated endorsement — that’s what she said!
Orion Kerkering – 1 IP, 0 ER, ERA at 2.54, and his 1st save. Had it been a month already? Ya know, because once a month the Phils change their closer. Don’t worry, mid-July to August it will be Kyle Finnegan, then mid-August to September it will be Taijuan Walker finally it will be playoff-time and “all hands on deck.” I guess Romano is out, Strahm remains in the 8th and Kerkering is the new Phils closer. Subject to change!
Sandy Alcantara – 5 IP, 2 ER, 6 baserunners, 5 Ks, ERA at 6.88. Glass is half full: This is a solid start for 2025 Sandy. Half empty: He was out-pitched by Mick Abel. Glass realistically full with enough water to drink: His next start is not liked on the Streamonator, and I still don’t trust him.
Logan Gilbert – 5 IP, 2 ER, 4 baserunners, 10 Ks, ERA at 2.55 as he was activated from the IL, where he missed roughly two months with a flexor strain in his elbow. Now begins the game of chicken: Logan Gilbert’s pitching vs. his elbow.
Roman Anthony – 1-for-4 and his 1st major league homer, as he hit third. You’re the face of the franchise now. No presh!
Lucas Giolito – 6 IP, 0 ER, 4 baserunners, 10 Ks, ERA at 4.73, but back-to-back solid starts, and I actually picked him up for this two-start week, because I got brains in my ass. Streamonator doesn’t like his next, and can’t say I do either, but I’m starting him: Wheeeeeeeee….
Justin Verlander – Will return on Wednesday. He’ll be following the Opener Rafael Devers, who said he’ll do whatever the Giants want, even pitch.
Dylan Cease – 5 IP, 6 ER, ERA at 4.69. “He should be better,” he says as he walks into the ocean. If you have an Appearances category in your league, call up your league commissioner and see if that means Cease appears better than he’s been and if that gets you points.
Manny Machado – 1-for-3, 2 RBIs and his 11th homer, hitting .317. Still thinking about Dylan Cease getting on the mound with a polished fastball and deciding to polish a freakin’ turd!
Shohei Ohtani – 1 IP, 1 ER, as he returned to the mound. Oh, he also went 2-for-4, 2 RBIs. I don’t mind this Ohtani usage from a fantasy standpoint, because you have to be completely bonkers to ever start him as a pitcher. A loose cannon whose friends make the “Cuckoo-cuckoo” sound when they leave the room. A person whose own parents once said, “They’re sweet, but I think they were dropped on the hospital floor when they plopped from Ma’s hoo-ha.” I say I don’t mind this because there’s zero temptation to start him as a pitcher, and that’s how I like my shizz: Zippo Temptation. Would it be nicer if he threw 7 IP, 0 ER, 12 Ks every time out? Sure, but you’re not getting that. I’d be surprised if he’s doing that before August. For now, just start him as a hitter and watch his 1-3 IP pitcher highlights as a fan. You remember what it’s like to be that, right?
O Cruz and M Vargas or Ward and Donovan?
How is Forest Whitley not the lead?!?! Rays lowed his ERA by 1.5 and his WHIP by .25! BOOM! STUD! Wait until they lower his ERA by another 7 runs and his whip by .5.
Pretty cool to see Cease play down to Jacob Lopez’s level the past month.
IDK what I will with him next year with no OF elig but right now living the good life with Goodman at the moment. Getting that Carpenter production with almost .100 ops added on.
I started Soriano but also benched Gusto.
In a dynasty would you rather target Cease or Bubic? Both on block in my league.
Leiter a good start @home vs royals?
Should we be stashing bubba or burns?
Burns
Would you drop Romano for any of the following? Palencia, L. Jackson, R. Garcia, Kerkering, Strahm, Kahnle
Which SP on IL would you pick up for the ROS? Beiber, Scherzer, R. Lopez, Verlander, Hicks, McClanahan?
Thanks!
Palencia
Verlander
Yoooo grey great call on giolito!
You starting littel vs orioles?
I am not
12-team H2H. Jose Soriano or Wacha? Pasquantino or Kurtz? Thank you!
Wacha
Kurtz
Carpenter over Grisham?
Yes
Would you move Gilbert for an underperformer like Cease ? Feel the elbow could call out at any moment
Meh, trading headaches
10 team h2h redraft league: CES or Kurtz ROS?
Kurtz
Need to add a starter and the wire is thin. Who do you like among Soroka, Horton, Roupp?
QS league
Horton
Harper or Oneil Cruz?
Oneil
That James W blurb is begging for a “Do you respect Wood?” Larry David quote
HAHA
Is Gusto a guy to hold on to in a deep dynasty, or is he more of a “trade him immediately after he’s pitched well against the White Sox and A’s” ?
Trade him
who do we want:
EuryP, Alcantara, Lugo,
Or just Whitlock for ratios and what-not (Sv +Hld league)
thxxxx
Lugo
Why is DJ Lemathieu still in the Yankees lineup, or any teams lineup for that matter. He’s probably the lest dangerous hitter in baseball right now, and I watch a lot of it. Question for you, in a points league, how many Devers starts this week is worth starting him over Riley Greene or Mikael Garcia, and if the answer is start one of them, which one. Thank you for your consideration.
Haha, good question on DJ — I imagine Devers will start every game
Ozzie Albies droppable for Trevor Story? 5×5 roto
Nah
Altuve! Being a Dodger, I hate him. But drafted him cuz he is good at baseball. Only to trade him and a SP after his bad start which I was happy about since I got Harper. How has that turned out?
We were all wrong about Altuve being washed weren’t we?
Semi-happy ending: I backfilled 2B with B Lowe. So there is that.
Altuve’s been about as good as Jung Hoo Lee who hasn’t hit in 6 weeks
Good Morning Grey,
10-TM, NL, H2H, OBP
My SP is in bad shape with loss of Reynaldo and King along with drafting the crappy duo of Gallen and Pfaadt.
SPs: Gallen, Megill, Roupp, Pfaadt, Cabrera, Burrows, Gomber (streamer, will swap)
RPs: E. Diaz, Palencia, Santillan
A) Please Rank: Gray, Freddy P., Luzardo, Pivetta, Ranger Suarez
B) Any from A you would NOT trade Yelich for? I need pitching pretty badly, so desperate times…
C)
D) Toglia for Abbott fair? Trade Analyzer hasn’t updated Toglia yet for ROS $, but they are close in the $/game.
E) Try Lile over Scott II as a 2nd bench bat? Thairo is my bench INF bat.
I appreciate your thoughts.
A. Freddy, Luz, Gray, Ranger B. sounds fine D. I’d want Abbott, it’s not close E. No
Ryan Pressly or Kerkering?
Orion
Starting festa @reds?
Doesn’t sound good
Hey Hey to the Hey Hey, Grey!!!
First off, sorry if I missed any discussion of this, but have you seen Roman Anthony’s sister, Lia? Hubba hubbba.
Also, would you go with Warren v LAA (14.1) for a streamer today? Other choice would be Lib @CWS, but bot no likey (-3.6).
Lurrrrrrrrrrves
I’d go with Warren…Lurves
And Lia?
Ha
Cags or Kurtz?
Eury or Sandy?
Thanks!
Kurtz
Eury
Morning Grey,
Take flier on Eury or Sandy ROS?
Meadows or Frelick in 5×5 Roto?
Thank ya!
-IANASM
Eury
Meadows
Dynasty Points league. I’ve received two trade offers:
1. My Woo for Dominguez and Cade Horton
2. My Woo and Colt Emerson for Dominguez and Royce
Do you like either of these? Would be nice to get the pitcher back but Royce is always tempting
Woo in both they’re fair
Can’t believe I’m asking this but in a 10 teamer is Ozzie Albies droppable? I have Jazz, Westburg, and Wynn to fill in a 2B and/or SS slot. I’d be dropping him for a UTL bat or a hitting streamer. Guy has STUNK this year
Yes, droppable
Trade question:
10 team keeper
Crochet 1yr remaining after this year $10 or Acuna 2 yrs $38
Acuna
Kinda figured you’d go that way. Is that because of a general lack of trust in pitching? The $10 gave me pause but I guess you’re saying I’m overthinking.
Thanks
Feels overthinking
Why is it I only over think in fantasy!
Haha
AVG isn’t showing it yet but Kurtz feels on the verge of finding his rhythm.
Had the exact same thought about Goodman when he hit those 2 dongs. He’s about to be the next Doyle…
He seemed to be finding it right before his injury, so yeah hopefully
James Wood is in need of a nickname, any thoughts?
Morning Wood
Ha
True, will need to work on it
Hey Grey,
Good morning and thanks for all your work.
20 team h2h cat dynasty
Bullpens matter.
My end game currently features: D. Palencia, J. Estrada, R. Suarez
Can you pleas rank the following guys from top to bottom as keepers: Brad Keller, Gabe Speier, Grant Taylor, P. Hodge
Thank you!
Taylor, Hodge, Gabe
That Soriano start convinced me I know nothing about fantasy baseball anymore.
i’ll second that and add that seeing those last two starts on my bench after the garbage he’s heaped on my ratios makes me want to quit forever and take up a new hobby like maybe making dog clothing out of dryer lint.
I played in my first fantasy baseball league back in 1993 when we got our stats from the Wednesday USA Today and relied on Baseball Tonight for up-to-date information. And over the intervening baseball seasons I feel like I know less and less about just about everything, especially these past 2-3 seasons. I used to have a knack for spotting solid SPs. Not any more. I’m utterly clueless.
*I still love baseball but mostly I participate in fantasy baseball to occupy my mind and divert my thoughts from climate catastrophe, gun violence, our crumbling democracy and the petty bickering that passes for political discourse.
very similar story here. i started in 1985 and we had to wait for a weekly sporting news to come in the mail for stats. used to be much better with pitching but it’s been not great for a few years now.
this year i am less bothered by my bad teams because most of my enjoyment now comes with playing along with my son. he’s 13, which is a great age for him to get into it. every night he’s got 3 storylines from our teams and we do a post-game show style recap. absolutely love it.
Awesome!
Soft and extremely flammable… You might be on to something
HAHA
HA
You trading SPers…Gilbert (give) for Cease
( get )
Meh
For some reason I always read his name as Onion Kerkering.
More people should name their kid Onion.
i hope one of his teammates calls him onion. maybe schwarbs.
More folks should name their kids Onion, what a great name
Boston Seattle game. 54 outs and 27(1/2) outs were strikeouts
Incredible hitting from Seattle, always
Spencer Steer suck I gather, but he’s playing.
Does he lose playing time as the Reds get healthy? Is he even worth holding onto in a deep league say if Toglia is available?
Steer>Toglia
Grey!!!!
Amazing!
Rodney Dangerfield quote of the day for June 17, 2025
My wife can’t cook, no respect. The other day she made chocolate mousse with antlers in it.
Cheers,
Ante
Thanks!
Pepiot and Giolito each earned their first entry on the 100 Best Fantasy Starts list. The Rays appear 5 times; the Red Sox 3. All of Boston’s occurred on the road while all of Tampa’s were at home:
08 Garrett Crochet Apr 13 @CHW
34 Shane Baz Apr 14 vs BOS
39 Garrett Crochet Apr 2 @BAL
52 Drew Rasmussen Jun 3 vs TEX
54 Ryan Pepiot Jun 16 vs BAL
63 Lucas Giolito Jun 16 @SEA
88 Drew Rasmussen May 28 vs MIN
100 Joe Boyle Apr 13 vs ATL
Ha, nice (for me on Gio)…Thanks, Vin!
Did Strider’s most recent start make it into the top 5 Vin ?
WHAT? Win Ben Stein’s Stadium?? I’d watch that!
Slowly getting over the fact that The Sho didn’t don the pitching cap that Kike wears. Opportunity lost because that would’ve been hilarous. Not as hilarious as a 45 mph curve being thrown in the MLB, but close enough.
That sounds awesome! I wanna see that now too!
Hi Gray –
Otto Lopez or Meidroth RoS?
Kurtz or ELC?
Saves chase: Detmers, Kerkering, D Lee or Grant Taylor?
Many thanks —
Lopez
I don’t know what ELC is
Orion
Hey Grey,
12 team 5×5 obp league
Which 1B ROS?
Kurtz
Busch
O’Hearn
and do you think Doyle bounces back or should I drop for one of Meadows or Otto Lopez?
Thanks !
Forgot to add Jake Meyers to the mix, so basically:
Meyers
Doyle
Meadows
or Otto Lopez ROS
Busch
Drop, Lopez