LOGIN

Hello everyone, welcome back to another edition of my positional dynasty rankings.

This week the spotlight shines on the top 50 dynasty third basemen for 2027 fantasy baseball. I have tackled a number of positions already, and if you missed a post, please look at the list at the bottom and catch up.

Unlike some of the previous positions I have talked about, third base is a pretty interesting position because there is elite, young talent at the top of the rankings like Junior Caminero and Kevin McGonigle but there are a host of older players, such as Jose Ramirez, Manny Machado, Alex Bregman, etc.,  who are still big contributors to a dynasty team. That makes this position one of the deepest in dynasty baseball.

If you are in a win-now mode, the older players are going to help you and should continue to produce for another three years. If you are rebuilding, the ceiling for a lot of the young players is exceptionally high. So if you value winning now just as much as adding as many future stars as possible, this position allows you do that.

When breaking down the position, it is heavy with power, especially at the top of the rankings and there is a ton of solid depth. If you miss out on a Tier 1 player, there are still very good players in Tier 2 and Tier 3 that will help you win now and especially in the future. The bottom line is this: third base is one of the stronger positions in dynasty baseball. It probably doesn’t quite match shortstop or outfield as a whole, but it stacks up well with first base.

The appeal of this position is the mix of high-end power, proven veterans and young players who can help win now without sacrificing long-term value.

Now, let’s get on with the rankings.

Just Missing The Cut

  • Jose Fernandez, Diamondbacks
  • Blaze Alexander, Orioles
  • Blaze Jordan, Cardinals
  • David Hamilton, Brewers

Jose Fernandez had a solid debut season with Arizona with three homers, 30 RBI and nine steals in 73 games. The speed is what gives him extra value as a corner infield player.

Blaze Alexander appeared in 93 games this past season, with 56 coming at third, 21 at second, 12 at short, eight in center and left and six in right. That is great versatility from a player who also slashed .303/.358/.414 with four homers, 31 RBI and 10 steals. The slash line is way above his career average, but the fact he can play all over the field gives him value in really deep leagues.

Blaze Jordan had three homers and 28 RBI in 186 at-bats with the Cardinals. His minor league numbers suggest he has the potential to hit for power, but he is a player to stash and hope he develops, not a player to count on this upcoming season.

As for David Hamilton, I talked about him in my shortstop rankings. If you need speed, Hamilton is a player to look at. Otherwise he just offers depth as a multi-position guy.

NOTE: There were 178 players who appeared in at least one game at third base and 99 players who appeared in at least 10 games at the position. To be ranked, you have to appear in at least 10 games at third base. So you will not see any prospects ranked below unless they have appeared in 10 major league games at shortstop. Dynasty leagues are all different in how they treat prospects, so comparing a prospect’s value to a major leaguer’s value is something I don’t do here. If you need to know about prospects, please check out the great material Itch is producing.

Tier 5

*Age as of March 1, 2027

RANK PLAYER 2026 TEAM AGE
50 Hao-Yu Lee DET 24
49 Brett Baty NYM 27
48 Jose Caballero NYY 30
47 Vaughn Grissom LAA 26
46 J.P. Crawford SEA 32
45 Luis Rengifo SD 30
44 Ernie Clement TOR 30
43 Connor Norby COL 26
42 Eugenio Suarez CIN 35
41 Joey Ortiz MIL 28

Sneaky Good Season

I’ll admit, since I don’t catch a lot of Tigers games, I was kind of surprised by just how good of a season Hao-Yu Lee had. In 114 games he had 10 homers and 46 RBI to go with a .264/.322/.424 slash line while getting in time at second and third to qualify for both positions. Lee has not shown a lot of upside in the steals department and he hasn’t shown tremendous power in the minors before joining the Tigers, but he is young and his skillset can still greatly improve.

The Steady Vets

With the Mariners going younger up the middle, J.P. Crawford saw action at third base in 33 games. While he isn’t getting any younger, the fact he has now added third base to his repertoire helps his value. He is also pretty steady at the plate – he isn’t going to carry your offense, but he won’t be a huge hole if you need him to fill in for your normal starter. 

Like Crawford, Ernie Clement can play multiple positions (second, third, and short) and is decent enough at the plate that he is not going to kill you when slotted into the lineup. Over the last three seasons he has hit 12, nine and nine homers and driven in 51, 50 and 48 runs. That is pretty steady production.

OK, I Like Norby

Connor Norby makes his third appearance in my rankings as he was also in my first base and second base rankings. After being traded to the Rockies from Miami he slashed .302/.457/.844 with three homers and 18 RBI in 40 games overall (.205/.313/.325-4-16 with Miami in 65 games). Norby is a player who can provide both power and speed and he will be given every chance to grab a starting spot on the field – though where on the field is the question

Tier 4

RANK PLAYER 2026 TEAM AGE
40 Bryson Stott PHI 29
39 Royce Lewis MIN 27
38 Christian Encarnacion-Strand BAL 27
37 Nick Gonzales PIT 27
36 Willi Castro COL 29
35 Brendan Donovan SEA 30
34 Nolan Arenado ARI 35
33 Max Muncy LAD 36
32 Max Muncy A’s 24
31 Kyle Karros COL 24

Is He Back?

Christian Encarnacion-Strand (CES) burst onto the scene in 2023 when he hit 13 homers and drove in 37 runs in 63 games for the Reds. But then basically disappeared as he appeared in only 29 games in 2024 and 36 in 2025. CES resurfaced with the Orioles this past season and in 58 games he slashed .277/.325/.513 with 11 homers and 39 RBI. His 162-game average is a very nice 28 homers and 97 RBI. The problem is will he actually come close to playing in 162 games? That is the million dollar question, and since I don’t know the answer, he is ranked in this tier.

A Lost Season

Brendan Donovan was part of a three-team trade that sent him to Seattle ahead of the 2026 season, and the Mariners were counting on him to be a key part of the offense. Instead, Donovan had three different stints on the IL and played in only 39 games. His career slash line is .282/.362/.409 and he has shown in the past he can play multiple positions, though entering the 2027 season he is only eligible to be a third baseman. When healthy he provides a consistent bat and value as a bench player.

The Younger Muncy

Max Muncy of the Athletics has a nice long-term dynasty profile as he is young and offers power potential. But the potential has been just that. Over the past two seasons he has appeared in a combined 145 games, slashing .223/.280/.387 with 18 homer and 53 RBI. I like the power upside, but his slash line needs to greatly improve in order to be a consistent fantasy contributor. 

The Younger Karros

Kyle Karros, the son of former major leaguer Eric Karros, is coming off a season in which he slashed .253/.347/.414 with 13 homers and 49 RBI. That is a tremendous improvement over his 43-game stint with the Rockies in 2025 where he hit one homer and drove in nine while slashing .226/.308/.277. He doesn’t have great raw power, but his .463 career SLG in the minors was built thanks to his ability to hit lots of doubles to go with his home runs. He may not be an immediate help to your lineup, but he has long-term upside.

Tier 3

RANK PLAYER 2026 TEAM AGE
30 Matt Shaw CHC 25
29 Alec Bohm PHI 30
28 Carlos Correa HOU 32
27 Jordan Westburg BAL 28
26 Brady House WSH 23
25 Casey Schmitt SF 27
24 Matt Chapman SF 33
23 Ezequiel Duran TEX 27
22 Curtis Mead WSH 26
21 Colt Keith DET 25

OK, He’s Kind Of A Third Baseman

I am cheating by ranking Matt Shaw here at third base as he appeared in only nine games at the position compared to 14 at second base and 30 in right field out of the 77 games he played in. Perhaps he stays in right, perhaps he plays more at second, but I think he should get in at least 10 games at third this upcoming season when Alex Bregman is taking a day off or at DH. In his 77 games this season he slashed .237/.327/.410 with five homers, 24 RBI and four steals. He is only 25 and I like his long-term potential, but not knowing exactly where he fits in as far as future position makes ranking him higher than here tough to do.

The Upside Players

Like Bo Bichette, Jordan Westburg is one of my favorite players, and he has certainly let me down so far in his career as injuries have consistently sidelined him. In 85 games last year he hit 17 homers and drove in 41 and his 162-game average is 24 homers and 79 RBI with a .264/.312/.456 slash line. He hits for power, has a solid slash line and can play multiple positions. If he can stay on the field, he can be a huge part of your dynasty offense.

Brady House is a former first-round draft pick who can become a middle-of-the-order player as he has amazing raw power, though it has not easily translated into games. In 320 at-bats for the Nationals this year he hit 10 homers and drove in 46. Making contact has also been an issue with House as his Chase% ranked in the 23rd percentile, his Whiff% was in the 18th percentile and his K% was in the 23rd percentile. The talent is there, but it may take a while for it to come out.

Colt Keith has yet to have a breakout season, but he is young, can play multiple positions and offers a solid bat with upside to give him a lot of dynasty potential. This past year he slashed .258/.322/.406 with 10 homers and 36 RBI in 140 games. I still think there is a lot of upside in Keith and that he will see better power numbers over the next few seasons.

Tier 2

RANK PLAYER 2026 TEAM AGE
20 Colt Emerson SEA 21
19 Zack Gelof ATH 27
18 Bo Bichette NYM 28
17 Javier Sanoja MIA 24
16 Caleb Durbin BOS 27
15 Coby Mayo BAL 25
14 Josh Jung TEX 29
13 Austin Riley ATL 29
12 Kazuma Okamoto TOR 30
11 Brooks Lee MIN 26

Hoping The Hype Is Real

Colt Emerson appeared in my shortstop rankings at No. 33, but I like him more as a third baseman and I am being very aggressive by ranking him at No. 20 here. The previous sentence was written and right before submitting this post, the news of the Maikel Garcia trade to Seattle broke. That trade affects Emerson’s ranking as a third baseman because the chances of him now taking over the full-time role at third are pretty much gone.

Emerson entered the 2026 season as a top 15 prospect according to Baseball America, MLB and Baseball Prospectus. However, his 69-game debut with the Mariners did not go well as he slashed .190/.246/.335 with eight homers and 23 RBI. The tools are there for him to be a 20 to 25 homer player with 10 or so steals, and that would make him a top third baseman. But with Garcia now playing at third, Emerson’s hopes of maintaining position eligibility there will only happen if he fills in for Garcia.

Multi-positional Value

Zack Gelof added a lot of value to his fantasy status by playing multiple positions this year. From 2023-25 he played all of his MLB games at second base. But this year he played 16 or more games third base, second base, left field and center field while hitting 22 homers with 55 RBI and 16 steals in 111 games. That is solid production to be able to plug into multiple positions for at least one season. And if he goes back to being only a second baseman, then you have a pretty good second baseman. 

Bo Bichette also previously appeared in my rankings as he was my 18th-ranked shortstop. He only turns 29 on March 5 and is coming off a year in which he slashed .260/.312/.390 one season after slashing .311/.357/.483. His 2024 season was a dud, but take away that season and his OPS+ from 2019 through 2025 (minus 2024) was 126. He is not going to steal a lot of bags, but I think there is still a lot of production left in him at the plate.

Speed Adds Value

Caleb Durbin had 11 homers, 53 RBI and 18 steals in 2025 with Milwaukee in 445 at-bats. This year with Boston he had 13 homers, 64 RBI and 20 steals in 508 at-bats. So I think when it comes to Durbin, we know what we are getting in the counting stats. The speed he brings to the third base position is valuable. He is entering the prime of his career, so his power numbers may increase a little, but right now just count on what he has done in the past.

Love The Power Potential

Coby Mayo was my 19th ranked first baseman and here he is as my 20th ranked third baseman. This is what I wrote about him previously: Not even 25 years old, Mayo hit 24 homers with 63 RBI in 132 games for the Orioles this season. His 162-game average is 35 homers and 91 RBI. I’m not a huge fan of his career slash line of .216/.292/.461, but in the second half (58 games) he slashed .270/.337/.540 with 12 homers and 29 RBI. In the first half (74 games) those numbers were .193/.264/.395-12-34. I really believe those second half numbers can be replicated for the next five years, making Mayo a prime candidate to move up these rankings and being a steal for 2027.

Just Stay Healthy!

When you look at the 162-game average for Josh Jung, you see a player with a .266/.315/.435 slash line with 23 homers and 77 RBI. Those are really good numbers. The problem with Jung is he has never played in 162 games, or 152 games, or 142 games. In fact, his career high is 131 games played. Jung is a legit middle-of-the-order hitter, but injuries have prevented him from ever actually reaching that potential. But he is only 29, and while his long-term value is not great, I think he hits his stride in 2027 and maintains it for the next three to four years.

Is His Run Over?

From 2021-2023 Austin Riley averaged 159 games played with 36 homers and 99 RBI with a .286/.354/.525 slash line. Those numbers made him one of the top third basemen in the game. Then came 2024 and 2025. Over those two years he averaged 106 games, 18 homers and 55 RBI with a .258/.316/.445 slash line. He bounced back to play in 159 this past season, but he hit only 19 homers with 72 RBI with a .219/.290/.364 slash line.

So that has left me wondering who Riley is now as a fantasy third baseman. Is he the player we have seen the last three years or the player he was from 2021-23? He doesn’t turn 30 until April and the power is still there, I believe. He may not be the player he was when hitting 30 bombs per year, but he is better than what we have seen the past three seasons.

Nice MLB Debut

Kazuma Okamoto came over from Japan and in his first season in Toronto he hit 33 homers to go with 92 RBI. His slash line of .232/.310/.452 could be better, and he had four months in which his batting average was under .220 and his OBP was under .304. But I think he will improve on these numbers in 2027 and the power and RBI will still show up. His overall dynasty value is shorter than others in these rankings, but it is hard to ignore those homers and RBI.

Solid Production

Brooks Lee spent the majority of the season at third base but he appeared in 48 games at short, and that makes him a valuable player to add thanks to the versatility to go with his skill. Lee hit 24 homers with 83 RBI while slashing .253/.300/.428. At a position where power drops off quickly the deeper you get into the position, Lee’s 24 dingers ranked ninth at the position as did his RBI total. He may not have as high of a ceiling compared to other third baseman, but he has a very high floor, and that makes him a valuable player.

Tier 1

RANK PLAYER 2026 TEAM AGE
10 Colson Montgomery CWS 25
9 Alex Bregman CHC 32
8 Manny Machado SD 34
7 Isaac Paredes HOU 28
6 Maikel Garcia KC 26
5 Jose Ramirez CLE 34
4 Kevin McGonigle DET 22
3 Miguel Vargas CWS 27
2 Sal Stewart CIN 23
1 Junior Caminero TB 23

Top 10 Again

For the second straight week, Colson Montgomery appears in the top 10 of my rankings as he is my No. 10 shortstop. What I said about Montgomery last week applies here. Montgomery slashed .197/.282/.403 this season with a massive 35.6% strikeout rate. That is pretty horrid. But Montgomery also does one thing very, very well – hit homers. And his power is why he lands in this tier. In 71 games as a rookie in 2025, he hit 21 homers and drove in 55 runs. This year he walloped 31 homers and drove in 87 runs. Overall, his 162-game average is 38 homers and 103 RBI. That is hard to pass up.

Yes, he has to at least return to his 2025 slash line of .239/.311/.529 to justify this ranking. But the power is there and is not going to go away, and that is the biggest reason for him being ranked 10th.

The Steady Veterans

Alex Bregman will be 32 when the season begins, but he doesn’t show any signs of slowing down at the plate. In his first season in the Windy City he hit 28 homers and drove in 93 runs while slashing .265/.355/.464. Additionally, he still has a great understanding of the strike zone. He ranked in the 86th percentile or higher in K%, Whiff% and Chase% while ranking in the 94th percentile in Squared-Up%.

Manny Machado is two years older than Bregman, but like his counterpart in Chicago, the Padres third baseman still produces at the plate. He hit 30 homers this year and drove in 91 runs and since turning 30 in 2023 his average season is 29 homers, 96 RBI and a .256/.321/.450 slash line. His slash line took a nosedive this past year, coming in at .217/.303/.407, but from July 1 through the end of the season he slashed .247/.333/.417 with 14 homers and 45 RBI in 76 games. The slash line may not reach previous levels, but if he just matches his second half numbers from here on out then he is a top third baseman.

Since being traded to the Houston Astros before the start of the 2025 season, Isaac Paredes has appeared in 257 games and hit 45 homers, driven in 147 runs and slashed .259/.356/.451. His 162-game average with the Astros is 28 homers and 93 RBI. Basically, he has done exactly what was expected of him – pull the ball to left field for homers, spray the ball to right field to drive in runs and get on base thanks to his high walk rate. He is only 28 and should continue to provide production for years to come.

Rebound Seasons Coming

Maikel Garcia, who just got traded to Seattle, doesn’t get a lot of love when it comes to talking about the top third basemen, but he should. His 2026 season was derailed by injuries as he appeared in only 82 games thanks to a hand muscle strain suffered in June and a hamstring strain he suffered in August days after returning to the lineup. When healthy, Garcia had a solid slash line but hit only three homers after hitting 16 in 2025. Garcia does a great job of squaring up the ball, not chasing pitches and has speed to hurt opponents on the bases. I think the lack of power was a blip on the radar screen this season, allowing him to return to at least his 2025 production in the power department while also bringing in steals.

Did Jose Ramirez have his best season in 2026? No. Not when you see a .235/.320/.368 slash line (career is .276/.320/.368 with only 12 homers and 53 RBI in 125 games. But Ramirez still stole 37 bases. I don’t think the decline in his stats is the start of a downward trend for Ramirez, despite the fact he is 34. He offers the rare combination of speed and power at a position that rarely sees that combination.

Is He A Shortstop? A Third Baseman? Who Cares?

Kevin McGonigle is yet another multi-positional stud. McGonigle earned the AL ROY award after slashing .278/.376/.430 with 18 homers, 72 RBI and 12 steals. He had a 7.1 WAR and an OPS+ of 126. His chase percentage of 19.6 ranked in the 98th percentile while his Whiff% and K% ranked in the 89th and 88 percentile while his BB% ranked in the 94th percentile. Playing in Comerica Park doesn’t help his power, but he should hit more homers as he develops a little more strength. And while he is young and still has a lot of growth in his game, he will help a contending team win now or be a key player for a rebuilding team.

Heck Of A Breakout Season

Over the final 45 games of his 2025 season, Miguel Vargas slashed .267/.354/.436 with six homers and 25 RBI, giving a glimpse of what was to come in 2026. All he did this past season was smash 33 homers, drive in 93 runs and steal 22 bases while slashing .250/.363/.474 enroute to finishing sixth in the AL MVP race. When you look at his Statcast numbers, a lot of red stands out as he ranked in the 88th percentile in Barrel% and in the 93rd percentile or higher in xwOBA, xSLG, LA Sweet-Spot%, Chase% and BB%. All of that adds up to a great season. There is the chance he falls back a bit next year, but Vargas offers a great power-speed package and should for many more years as he is just entering his prime.

The NL Rookie Of The Year

Sal Stewart gave baseball fans a quick glimpse of what he can do at the plate when he hit five homers in 18 games for the Reds in 2025. Stewart followed that up with a 32 homer, 112 RBI season with a .263/.330/.457 slash line to win the NL ROY award. Stewart is eligible at both first and third, giving him great value, and while he struggled in September, I’m not concerned about that at all. Only 23, he can easily develop into a cornerstone player to build your team around.

All Hail Junior!

Looking for a third baseman who can mash the ball? You want Junior Caminero. Looking for a young player to build your team around. You want Junior Caminero. Want a future MVP? You want Junior Caminero.

If you have not gotten the point, Junior Caminero is a player you really, really, really want on your team. In 2025 he finished ninth in the MVP voting after slashing .264/.311/.535 with 45 homers and 110 RBI. All he did this season was finish second in the MVP voting after hitting 42 homers with 101 RBI with a .276/.360/.524 slash line while playing in all 162 games (after playing in 154 in 2025).

Caminero is a difference maker, and he is not just the top third baseman in baseball, he is one of the top players overall.

Thank You

Whether you agree with my rankings or don’t agree, that is OK. I just want to say thanks for reading. Come back again next week when I unveil the Top 50 Dynasty Left Fielders for 2027 Fantasy Baseball.

If you missed my previous posts, you can find them here:

Top 50 Dynasty Relievers for 2027 Fantasy Baseball
Top 100 Dynasty Starting Pitchers for 2027 Fantasy Baseball
Top 50 Dynasty Catchers for 2027 Fantasy Baseball
Top 50 Dynasty First Basemen for 2027 Fantasy Baseball
Top 50 Dynasty Second Basemen for 2027 Fantasy Baseball
Top 50 Dynasty Shortstops for 2027 Fantasy Baseball

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted