When the Netherlands landed on the ABC islands in the Caribbean, the Dutch made three requirements of all people, when farting in bed, pin the sheet tightly to the bed surface to not let any smell emit; all restaurant checks must be split in half with all attending parties, and, finally, all names must have some random J in the middle of it and end in ‘stad.’ This is how I know Heston Kjerstad is A) Meticulously tight-sheeted bed farter. B) A tipper on only half the bill. C) There’s no C. I also know Heston Kjerstad is going to get more playing time now that Colton Cowser is persona non-thumba. Kjerstad has big-time power — think 35+ homer power if he had a full-time job for the year, and possibly no worse than a .255 hitter, i.e., he strikes out, but not that much for a power hitter. He also could have the next two months of runway since Cowser is wincing every time a child sings, “Where is thumbkin?” It’s in a gee-dee cast, kid! Anyway, here’s some more players to Buy or Sell this week in fantasy baseball:
BUY
Ivan Herrera – Only because I’m not going to tell you Hunter Goodman every week, but when I’m saying “Ivan Herrera,” I’m really saying, “Hunter Goodman every week,” but also Ivan Herrera but not just Ivan Hererra as in “Hunter Goodman every week.” Finally, just gave you an Ivan Herrera fantasy.
Dillon Dingler – Yes, I am dressed as a poop emoji in the Dingler Danglers’ Fan Club section of Comerica, but you don’t need to take what I’m about to say with a grain of salt: He went 17/5/.308 in Triple-A last year in only 263 ABs.
Gavin Sheets – If I were Gavin Sheets, I’d still have a duvet. Ya feel me? Stop. No, seriously, it’s weird, stop feeling me. Gavin Sheets is not just what you call the male housekeeper at the Ramada, it’s also a hot schmotato.
Wilmer Flores – You know we love Wilmer here, for crying out loud!
Otto Lopez – Nearly made Otto the lede Buy this week. No “but.” Otto Lopez is the co-lede. He’s Ed Norotton to Timothéejer Chalamestad. He’s Martin Shotto to Stevejer Martinstad. He’s Otto Preminger to Williamjer Holdenstad. Otto could be breaking outto. Is he a three-homer per month hitter or a three-homer in the month of April and zero homers in May, June and July? We don’t know that. We do know Otto has speed and is worth rostering based on that alone.
Jose Caballero – Josh Lowe’s eh-bees gotta go somewhere, or as Vinny from the Jersey Shore would tell Pauly, Jose Cab’s here!
Gavin Lux – Big week for Gavins. I be Gavin you guys every week, but what you be Gavin me? Huh? Think it over and reply at your earliest conevnience.
Ryan Bliss – SAGNOF is pure Bliss.
Kyren Paris – Players have to be hot to appear in this post. They might be one week hot, or full season hot. At this point in the season, we don’t know. I have a general sense of how good a player should be and where they should rostered, but, say, someone like Kyren Paris. He is an AL-Only right now, for sure, but could be a 15-teamer or a 12-teamer if he continues. I don’t think he’ll continue, but you never know.
Jacob Wilson – Pretty intrigued by this guy. He has Luis Arraez-type contact, and might have 15+ homer power. If he hits 15/.290, that plays everywhere. Prior to this season, he was making weak contact though, so if he’s more 10/.260, that plays barely anywhere. There’s a fine line between usable and boring, as your wedding vows should never say.
Max Muncy – No, not that one. Though, that one for power. Wait, which one am I talking about? I’ve confused myself. The A’s Muncy — in fact, I think I’m gonna start calling him Ma’s Muncy. It’s not clean, but it’s better than going through this every time. Ma’s Muncy has some power, and likely still only AL-Only, but I did grab him in one 15-teamer where I’m trying to fill in for Thairo, while I wait for Brett Baty to get eligibility. Oh, yeah, Brett Baty is a buy too.
Josh H. Smith – With Jung being injured — a first for everything! — Josh Hellboy Smith should get at-bats.
Miguel Vargas – As I look for hitters who are available in under 50% of leagues and who are playing every day and in the middle of lineups and, well, there’s Miguel Vargas.
Jake Mangum – Here’s what I said the other day, “Rays be making up players. They put a Dirty Harry DVD on top of a radiator and out popped Jake Mangum. In Triple-A last year, he had 20 steals and he makes good contact, but he’s also 29 with three MLB games of experience. Then again, it’s the Rays, so maybe he was ready five years ago and the Rays dragged their heels so they wouldn’t have to pay him. He should be nothing, but maybe he surprises pitchers. At the worst: Hot schmotato.” And that’s me quoting me!
Andrew Benintendi – Listen, I can’t choose who gets hot or when. I wish I could, and I have been taking a Power of Suggestion course at my local Ramada to try.
Dane Myers – It’s early, but Myers has speed and looks to be growing into an everyday job. For playing time, Myers still has to fight off Hill like your Volkswagen, and Sanoja, who I believe was an American Idol contestant.
Kameron Misner – Again, about Rays making up players, they put a brochure for Mizner Park’s newest ice cream shoppe on a carburetor and here we are.
AJ Smith-Shawver – This is a Streamonator call like the call it makes to your place of work.
Eduardo Rodriguez – This is also a Streamonator call. “Hello, yes, I would like to speak to his boss. Why? Because he won’t be my friend!”
Luke Jackson – This guy sounds like a country singer. So, if I have to choose, I’m going Chris Martin, but only begrudgingly. If we’re talking closers, who I’d go with doesn’t matter. Bochy seems to prefer Luke “Yeehaw” Jackson.
Jose Alvarado – Here’s what I said this morning, “I don’t know what Rob Thomson is doing. I don’t know what Rob Thomas is doing either. I have zero knowledge of Robs! My brain’s been Rob’d! My guess is Alvarado is in lead for saves, but maybe just at 70/30. It could be Romano for the next save though. All of this will be repeated this afternoon in my Buy column. You can hardly wait! No, you!” And that’s me quoting me telling you what to expect!
Emilio Pagan – Reds saves are: When does Alexis Diaz return? That’s what my gut is saying. I did just eat Taco Bell, though, so I have chalupa brain. Reds saves could be Pagan or Tony Santillan in the mean’s while.
Tyler Holton – Tigers saves are: How much do you need saves? Holton’s been fine, but zero opportunities, so there’s that.
Dennis Santana – Pirates saves are: Thank God Derek Shelton figured out David is Shit-the-Bednar.
Cade Smith – This is my middle reliever call of the week. Every week I give you a guy who should be rostered even if you don’t have Holds in your league and he doesn’t get saves. With that said. Dot dot dot.
SELL
Emmanuel Clase – As I mentioned the other day and on this week’s podcast, Rudy said Clase was his Bust of the Year, and I said I don’t believe in drafting top closers, but if I did, I wouldn’t be drafting Clase. So, none of you should have Clase, but, of course, some of you have Clase, so here we are. He was a mess last postseason. Doesn’t matter now? Sure, no, it doesn’t but his velocity is down too. He never was a strikeout reliever either — relieither? Yes, relieither! Can’t fight the relieither (relieither)! Can’t fight the relieither (relieither)! Veruca Salt wants a goose egg, and Clase’s not putting them up. Guards also have a ton of options. Not saying to trade Clase for a baby monkey that grows into an adult monkey that bites your face off, but I would go to the Fantasy Baseball Trade Analyzer and explore options.
Grant Holmes, Megill or springs?
Springs or Megill?
“Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic reports that the Rockies plan to promote top outfield prospect Zac Veen from Triple-A Albuquerque on Monday.
The 23-year-old outfielder was off to a sizzling start at Triple-A, hitting .387 (12-for-31) with a homer, eight RBI and a stolen base through his first eight games. Rosenthal notes that he’s expected to play in the corner outfield spots for the Rockies, which could cut into the playing time of Nick Martini and Mickey Moniak. Jordan Beck is expected to be optioned to Triple-A in a corresponding move. The Rockies aren’t promoting Veen to sit on the bench, so he’s immediately worthy of an addition in any fantasy leagues“
You know, like, if you’re into that sort of thing.
Foley doing well at AAA if I am reading this correctly. 3.2IP, zero walks or hits. Maybe back soon?
Looks like a broken arm or wrist for Victor Robles.
Not good. You never wanna see that.
Also, Giants are eight and one. Wilmer Flores comes off the bench, see one pitch and it’s game over. LFG!!!
Yeah, didn’t look good
Since the shift was banned, Schwarbs may no longer be an average liability and projection systems need to take notice. Last season he hit .248 with a .256 xBA. Look at his Statcast so far this season.
Yeah
Okay, for 2B I have Lux or Ceddanne, with Gorman on the IL.
Drop Ceddanne for Paris’s heat? Edmundo Sosa seeing a similar rise in ownership but would seem to have PT issues.
Yes
Togs is killing me, man. At least he’s made *some* contact I suppose.
He looks awful
Thankfully I don’t *have* to start him (tho I did today), but jeez.
Yeah
I need to drop one of these guys: Burleson (looks like he’s a platoon player this year), CES, or Toglia.
You’re starting all of these? If so, Burleson
I have both Mullins and Yelich. Need to move one for a SP. Who should I KEEP? It’s a 6×6 roto redraft OBP and AVG.
Yelich
After todays start would u drop Ober for Bubic?
you have no one else to drop? it’s fine if that’s what you have
I got King,Schwellenbach,Imanaga and Woo
Pena or Story for MI?
Pena
A lot of non-error errors today. This is still ruled a base hit. Cruz might be a DH only. I dont know how a guy so talented can get so high and look this awkwardly bad on basic fundementals.
https://mlb-cuts-diamond.mlb.com/FORGE/2025/2025-04/06/36fc03f8-d874a403-4ecfa18f-csvm-diamondgcp-asset_1280x720_59_4000K.mp4
How was that not an error
No clue. Even announcers…”should be a single with a two base error…..but as it stands it is a triple.”
Worst part is Cruz didnt turn around and hustle for the ball. Just gives up on the play.
https://mlb-cuts-diamond.mlb.com/FORGE/2025/2025-04/06/ba027205-b57d6696-4d3414f8-csvm-diamondgcp-asset-4000K.mp4
This one had me go what are you doing Mullins, then I remembered it was Mateo. None of these ruled errors.
Makes me feel like a cranky grandpa, “well in my day that was an error! You dont whiff on a catch and then not hustle. You dont point at the ball by the fence and act like you cant grab it. Bunch of pansies! Now put on Matlock!”
Cruz went to the OF and forgot how to field grounders
Dude played it like cricket, wait maybe im thinking of jai lai (sp???)? The one with the giant scoop on your arm? Dude just swiped at it like his glove was 5x larger.
Haha the irony of the one thing he should be better than the avg CF, grounders, balls popping up on weird bounced, and he looks like a baby deer out there. Should have been error #4..in 10 games.
Meanwhile Heaney went 7IP 5H 1ER 10K. Dude is probably motivated to get traded at the deadline. “If I play good, they will think they have to pay me more, so they will get rid of me.”. *finger tap to head*
Heaney is one of 3 good pitchers in baseball
I’ve gotten pretty high in my day. I’m just saying, never underestimate…
Shohei strikes out 3 more times today and been striking out more than he seems to normally…I could be wrong about that.
He’s either not seeing the ball well or that shoulder is affecting his swing more than we know.
Gotcha
For long term this season on a weekly roto-
Ward or W. Abreu?
Ward
Abreu or Castellanos? Cast was dropped in my league.
Cast
soto and adames vs elly and santander?
Elly
Bleday or Wilyer?
Or both and drop Wacha?
QS, OBP, 200 GS limit, keeper.
Pitching staff:
Cease
Flaherty
Freddy P
Pfaadt
Ray
Wacha
IL:
Kirby
Tobias Myers
Schmidt
Kutter
Bleday…meh, hold Wacha
I am over the Diamondbacks and Carroll in particular. They need to crack the whip on his scoring errors they dont mark as errors. He had the Ryne Nelson in glove drop a few games back. Naylor had the toss over Burnes head oops. Now Carroll in RF acts like he has never played baseball before. WTF dude?!?
https://bdata-producedclips.mlb.com/ba545f34-f898-4494-b80b-874a5addf7fe.mp4
Guy looks like he is trying to tackle a shifty RB. Forward, then flicks hips left, then right, then is completely lost. Good lord man just catch the ball instead of turning this into an adventure.
Haha
Story or Perdomo?
Story
Hey man in the questionarium do you prefer when A) people get straight to the point and ask the question B) Butter you up about how big brained at fantasy you are and then ask a question or C) make up pointless nonsense like this and then ask a question?
I hope you enjoy my stupidity… I want to ask which 2 would you start out of Flaherty vs NYY, Araghetti vs LAA, Meyer @NYM, Olson @ twins, and Pfaadt vs Baltimore
I used too many moves and now I am stuck with these options. I got all jump the gunny. I should have saved some to use coolwhips options I like them better. I’m so stupid brotherman.
C, ha…Flaherty, then coin flip, I guess Arrighetti
I just post some shit, share a laugh & move on.
Why butter up Grey? He’s not gonna blow you. lol
some guys like being buttered doggy ;)
and some people like being butt kissers
Glasnow or Eovaldi ros?
Glasnow
Roman Anthony worth stashing 10 team?
Sure
12 Team H2H 6×6 OPS QS
1) Need to drop one. Who gets the boot?
Roupp, G. Holmes, Kelly, Mahle, Fitts, Gavin
2) Please rank the top 3 bench bats, position does not matter
Perdomo, Wilson, Scott, Grisham, Turang, Conforto, J. Walker
Thank you
1. Holmes 2. Scott, Turang, Walker
Traded away Edman picked up Frelick. Another post-hype that might be ready
Nice
What did you get for Edman?
took a chance on A. Riley figuring it out
Nestor Cortes to DL. Grant Wolfram called up. I bet you are licking your lips at the play on his name possibilities. You got wolfram itself. You have the fact it is another name Tungsten. Has the highest melting point of elements, so if he is left in a game and already given up 9+ runs we know why. I hope he wears 74 for the atomic number.
Brewers bringing that A game meme names when they calling people up. Chad Patrick. Grant Wolfram. Also have Robert Gasser on IL.
Haha, think he’s a reliever no?
Dang it! I looked and you are right. He is taking Conner Thomas spot in pen so Thomas can start. BOOOOOO!
I enjoy how they try to downplay Cortes injury even though he was hurting BEFORE the start.
“Brewers assistant GM Matt Kleine told reporters (including Curt Hogg of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel) that Cortes was feeling some elbow discomfort leading up to his last start, though Cortes still delivered six innings of shutout ball against the Reds on April 3. Kleine doesn’t think the flexor strain is a “long-term issue,” and Cortes himself told Hogg and company that his concern level is “pretty low.” A previous round of scans cleared Cortes to pitch three days ago, but Cortes said he’ll seek out a second opinion just out of due diligence.”
Always ends well these types of things. On another note, they have robbed us of Holderman becoming Closerman, as he hit the IL 20 mins ago. Making the Pirates even less interesting.
Yup
Hi Grey,
Need another OF bat. Drop Springer for J. Walker, V. Scott, Grisham, or Benitendi?
Thanks!
Scott
10 team holds added Sp Gilbert, Woo, Bryce Miller, Steele, Pivetta, would you drop Steele or Pivetta for a holds guy and or stream?
Pivetta
One more question, ros in a 10 team pts league with saves which Ranger rp would you want, L. Jackson or C. Martin. Thank you FML!!
Jackson
Perfect, thank you.
No problem
Hey Grey,
10-tm H2H categories keeper league (keep 10) (balanced stats – Bats [9] Rm H, HR, RBI, SB, BB, AVG, OPS, XBH vs Pit [8] W, CG, SV, K, GIDP, ERA, WHIP, QS), Max 40 moves per season (max 3 per week).
Our league drafted on Friday and we have a bunch of new managers this year. It was a very unusual draft and I’m finding many guys on the wire that I feel like should be rostered in this type of league. So I would like to capitalize on the availability of talent, what would be your top 3 moves ?
Wire:
Bats – L. Nootbaar, S. Torkelson, T. Soderstrom, B. Rice, G. Springer, M. Conforto, J. H. Lee, J. Wilson, L. O’Hoppe (c), N. Lowe, V. Scott, O. Lopez, L. Robert, JT. Realmuto (c), R. Lewis (IL10), L. Garcia, I. Paredes, C Cowser (IL10), M. Muncy (LAD), K. Carpenter, H. Goodman (c),
SP’s – Y. Kikuchi, B. Pfaadt, N. Lodolo, T. Houck, R. Blanco, T. Bradley, J. Jobe, J. Springs, B. Singer, C. Schmidt (IL15), M. Scherzer (IL15), D. May, C. Bassit, R. Suarez (IL15), N. Cortes, Bubba Chandler (stash)
RP’s – P. Fairbanks, K. Jasen, K. Finnegan, A. Chapman, C. Holmes
My Team:
C – S. Langeliers
1B- C. Bellinger *DTD
2B- M. Betts
SS- C. Seager
3B- J. Chisholm
CI- J. Westburg
MI- A. Ginenez
LF- Y. Alvarez
CF- C. Mullins
RF- R. Greene
Util- P. C. Armstrong
BN- Y. Diaz
BN – R. Anthoney (N/A) stash
SP- J. Steele
SP- B. Woo
SP- J. Flaherty
RP- A. Munoz (RP)
RP- T. Megill (RP)
P – P. Lopez
P – R. Ray
BN- R. Pepiot
BN- M. Gore
BN- G. Williams
BN- S. Arrighetti
IL – G. Kirby (IL15)
thanks,
Marv
Noot, Taj over Arrighetti and Y. Diaz
Keep forever, PCA or Soderstrom?
PCA
Thank you. I feel a little better now. I offered my Soderstrom for his PCA and the other owner hit accept so fast that I immediately questioned my offer. I literally hit submit trade and got a pop up from my email saying that a trade had been accepted before I even closed my offer lol
No problem
Morning Grey and RB nation! I’m noting Dave D’s comment below on A’s OF and Nick Kurtz. I could really use some more CI power in OBP league – how soon would folks suggest stashing Kurtz?
Do you have the space now? I assume this a deep redraft league?
Thx good Qs. Keepers league. It would be in place of bench bat / SP streamer.
I have him in one league
Would you drop Cam Smith for Arenado in an OBP league?
Sure
Was offered T. Edman for M.Mclain in a 10 team pts league. What do you think? Thank you.
Works for me, take Edman
Who is the add for a reliever out of these guys?
Uceta
Dennis Santana
Halvorsen
Slaten
Jojo Romero
Bender
Reed Garrett
Dylan Lee
You can list top 2 just in case others try to add some of these arms, thanks for the insight as always!
For what? Saves? Dennis and Halvorsen
Sorry, it’s saves/holds
someone dropped butler in a 12 tm. drop george springer for him asap right? I need sb.
Yep
I’ll never understand why people draft a guy in the top 12 rounds then drop them after a week of baseball.
Fantasy football syndrome. A guy can be useless after week 1. Bleeds over into baseball with guys who dont know better.
Exactly, so true
Conforto or Lourdes gurriel 10 team ops league
Lourdes
Don’t look now, but the Giants might be… good?
Who knew.
Jung Hoo Lee is a nice player – the double then immediate SB to 3rd, scores on a Chappy double – good or not this is a fun team to watch.
Lee is nice, I don’t know if the Giants are tho
7-1
.958 winning %
That seems kinda good. Long season for sure, but they can put runs on the board. Pitching needs to live up to the hype.
Yeah
The Athletics need to get Rooker in the OF. Seth Brown .091BA/.466 OPS. Meanwhile Nick Kurtz .462 BA/1.423 OPS with 11 RBI in 6 games. I wonder how much longer they play this charade. Meanwhile, Jacob Wilson has gone 32 ABs to open the season without striking out.
Agreed!
What the hell is with the Angels tearing apart Bibee. He is my most owned pitcher. Somebody please remind them they suck. Also, tell Bibee he’s a #1 starter, not throwing BP to a AAA team.
I know, brutal
Wilson up to 5th in lineup behind Soderstrom today. I guess they don’t see him as slap hitter anymore…
Hopefully
Well, one of my Gladiator teams had the top overall offense for week two. The pitching needs to catch up. Kinda blew it on my closers unless Hodge, Erceg, Holton get sone SVs at some point.
Wow, damn, nice
You see this nonsense?
https://thecomeback.com/mlb/roberto-clemente-jr-pirates-remove-father-tribute.html#google_vignette
The Pirates are an embarrassment.
I did
Dynasty with Mervis stashed.
4pm – Why did I buy into this bum? .133 no power nothing. Should I drop him?
9pm – 3-4 2HR game batting .263. I can see the upside for sure. Definitely want to hold on.
For all you guys panicking over this season and all you need is 1 decent game to completely alter a guys season line.
HAHA, me and you might be the only two people with Matt Mervis
Elly not running. Reminds me of his 2nd half last season when the SB slowed way down.
He might not steal as much but not sure he has any opportunity. On base twice today. Guy got thrown out while he was AB. Walks. Then a hit and he comes around to score. Second time a double with a guy ahead of him on 3rd.
Oh yeah
Wacha over Tylor Megill?
Depends on the matchup, prolly go Megill for upside
https://mlb-cuts-diamond.mlb.com/FORGE/2025/2025-04/05/170f8975-bd113c83-d0d99409-csvm-diamondgcp-asset-4000K.mp4
One or my early year favorite for the announcers.
*excited play by play guy*
*Deadpan: No way.*
There, in fact, was not a way.
Hahahaha
Say what you will, the regression fairies never miss.
Started the day with a 2.06 ERA, with a whopping 104 IP.
Today I rolled out Spaghetti, Taj, and Pivetta. Holy %#!¥£#!
Brutal
Brought my ERA up to 2.80! (WHIP still somehow .089)
Curses!
lol
Damn!
Witt is off the MF’n Schnied!!!!!!!
LFG!
on his way to .314 *snicker*
Couldn’t let Wacha get one more out? Come on man.
Yeah that worked out real well. Clowns.
Haha
Throw Arrighetti and Smith-Shawver in there and it has not been a day to remember.
Now Miller giving up walks. Tied to the WHIP-ping post!
Ouch
Sasaki calmed down on off days looks good, LFG Grey!
Better!
12 outs… I hate drafting 2026 All-Stars in 2025
I know
I think I should’ve gone Judge with the #1 pick.
Ohtani has just 3 RBI (2 curtesy of solo shots) and seems to be striking out more so than his usual.
Gotcha
Grey
forgetting matchups who would you rather have on your team
Arrighetti
Jordan Hicks
Max Mayer
Kris Bubic
Hicks
I like it. I guess as long as he stays healthy
What are your thoughts on Bubic
Looks solid
I think K. Carpenter is heating up for a solid season – should i dump W. Abreu, or heliot ramos for him ?
Abreu
(1) OF. Steer or Toglia?
(2) SP. Megill (NYM) or Max Meyer (Mia)?
Steer
Megill
More like Arrggghhhhhhhrigetti amiright
Ugh
+1
I guess we need to hold for a bit longer. Give him a chance to get his act together?
Yeah if you can
Cam Smith, Kjer, Conforto or J. Wilson for my utility spot?
Manzardo also available
Kjer
Curious about your thinking of why Baty and Vargas are buys, both look lost at the plate. Good sticks against minor league pitching, can’t hit major league pitching.
it’s a week
Sure, but they both look like they are mirroring last year’s major league efforts. Maybe you have different info…
I don’t, not all leagues are made the same…in an AL or NL Only at-bats matter
Nice, I see how you turned this question around to a statement that is correct lol, but you’re still wrong on the 2 players.
Am I buying Kjerstad and dropping Robert who is looking like last years A double dollar sign version ? Or should I hold ( 14 team points h2h weekly lineup)
Someone will buy in a keeper even for 50 cents on the dollar. Just say you are out in league chat and will sell to highest bidder. Could get something semi-decent im sure.
Hold
Can we get the Astros torpedo bats AND a trash can? Braves west over here with talent and no production.
*Yordan, Paredes, or Diaz owner across multiple leagues*
I’d take it
Stupid Padres. “Merrill is hitting .429, we started him in the 3-hole. Ok we’ll move him to cleanup. Oh hey, I’d rather bat Arrez 2nd since he’s hitting .129, so let’s drop Merrill to 6th.”
Yep, makes perfect sense.
Haha
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zQZwsHKZER0
i miss this damn show
Same
Was offered Hunter Brown for my Christopher Sanchez. Don’t know why. They seem like a coin flip. Who do you like more? It’s both wins and quality starts. I car mostly about ratios. Have plenty of K’s.
Hold
Peterson home vs Toronto or
Bubic home vs Baltimore?
Both? Bubic
Ketel to IL.
2B options – Maikel, A. Jimenez, Campbell and Nico. Who should I try and get? It’s an average and OBP league.
Kristian
Drop Rengifo and pick up Kyren Paris?
Nah
Would you give up Burnes for Neto and Grayson Rodriguez in a dynasty league?
Sure
Thanks!
No problem
Best bet (bat) Kepler, Kjerstad or Frelick?
Kjerstad
Ugh, Ketel Marte to the IL. Sounds like it’ll be a couple weeks at a minimum.
Too many injuries this early in the season.
I got 4 players (Ketel, Kirby, Ohtani – P, & Ranger Suarez) on the IL and only 3 spots.
Would you hold all 4 or cut Ranger?
Lose Ranger
Manaea or Tylor Megill?
Sean Murphy over Wong?
Megill
Murphy
So, Ben rice… what’s going on, and is it sustainable? Rice or Yandy Diaz?
Maybe, seems doubtful, but we know what Yandy is, so you can try Rice
Him numbers in minors indicated he was better than what he showed last year. He was a .282 guy in minors and hit almost .300 at AAA before callup. I have a hard time believing a hitter like that is a sub .200 hitter. The power is the question as he added it later in minors. I dont think he is this good, but I dont think he was as bad as his numbers were last year. A .240ish 25 HR type doesnt seem unreasonable. A .350 60 HR mini Judge is a tad unreasonable.
Start sugano @ royals
Or boyd vs padres
?
Boyd
Fantasy isn’t fun when your team is too good lol
Ha
Also, not for nuthin, my farmers market neighbor uses a mobile point of sale system that plays the *exact* same sound as Yahoo’s on the clock sound effect, and it’s so totally triggering. He just made a sale & I got that panicky feeling like I’m about to miss a pick.
Gah!
HAHA
Sorry about Witt Jr. y’all. I took him 1.01, and this is my fault.
I killed Bo Bichette last year by taking him in the 3rd over Gunnar. My hubris strikes again.
Anyway, my bad.
He’ll be fine
On pace for 0 home runs.
I’ve been offered A. Riley for Edman, Austin in big time funk but…..whadya think?
Riley
Welcome aboard Austin!
Haha
He’ll come around. He’s too good to stay in the funk. They dropped him to 6th – I think he was pressing. He’ll get comfortable again.
Paris.
Small and shallow 6×6 using AVG, OBP.
Yelich or Campbell?
I don’t want to lose SB. The season before last, Yelich raked (106/19/76/28/.278/.370) and was raking last season before he decided on back surgery.
I like Campbell, but he doesn’t lift the ball. Extreme GB% at least right now.
Yelich, but it’s close
Morning Grey, starters with RP eligibility are a bit of a cheat code in my H2H league with QS.
Any of these guys intrigue you? Top 2-3?
Pallante
Liberatore
Gillispie
C Spiers
Bido
L Ortiz
Have a great weekend!
Only guy I have watched is Bido who has good stuff but never knows where it is going. He has been wild but not bad. Idk how much you can trust that. I have him in 18 team dynasty but short leash.
Someone to eyeball would be Nelson. He has 2 RP appearances and could be back in rotation by May.
Thanks for insight JR!
No problem. Sorry I wasnt more helpful. Im sure Grey will have better info.
Not really…Look at matchups…I guess Bido
What order would you have these SP:
Luzardo, C. Sanchez, Bibee, Ray
The Lizard is available on waivers and I have both Bibee and Ray. Looking to possibly trade for Sanchez.
….Luzardo is leading league in Ks, a top 5 SP at the moment in my league, and he is on waivers? Shallow league? Do you not have someone bad you can drop immediately for him?
I do, but It’s more of a trust thing with Luzardo. He’s looked brilliant before for a few starts and then falls apart blowing up ratios.
Is there a move limit? Im not a Luzardo guy either way, but I would be adding and not contemplating in my league. He was a good pitcher in 2023, 3.5 ERA 178IP 208K.
Not like he is Blanco out of nowhere.
Unless you got a 4 man bench and have to drop someone you think of equal talent.
You can drop him if he starts blowing up, but for now he’s doing what was expected of him last year so ride it!
That’s my two cents, but they’re actually pesos.
I would snag Luzardo asap, like him the best of those 4 then Bibee.
Bibee, Ray, Sanchez
Sorry drop Masyn Winn or Kjersted for Paris? Need speed
Winn if really are desperate
Are you concerned about William Contreras or is it just an early season funk? Statcast looks horrible. All the Brew Crew hitters look bad. Losing Adames could be a big deal.
You dont go from one of the best hitting catchers to the worst overnight. Barring some sort of injury or mental issue (vertigo, his fam got kidnapped and stressed, kid has cancer, etc.)
You dont worry about top talent until May. Too many variables right now. For example, someone was talking about statcast and a Rockies player. Who is going to remember who the Rockies played early, the weather being cold, and at least one of those played literally while snowing? Im pretty sure everyones statcast takes a hit when it is freezing.
Sure Contreras could decline, but no way he is a 1/5 of the player he was 7 months ago. Compare his 2024 statcast to this years.
Just going to have to wait it out. Unless you arent a believer in general, have a backup ready, and someone will pay 95-100% last years value on him right now.
It’s one week
Drop Masyn Winn for Paris? Need speed
No
NL-only 2C, Murphy coming back in the next few days. Do you prefer him or Goodman?
Goodman
Kjersted or Toglia 12 man
Toglia
1. Walker 2. Sure
Please rank 3B:
Vientos, Burger
Morning Grey,
Vientos was droppped in my league, would you drop any of Bleday, Robles, Bubic Anthony (stash) for him?
Over Anthony
Morning Grey! Sasaki bid day today, let us pray….
Hey I am in a work league today. 12 Team 5×5 redraft. No CI or MI, 3 OF and 2 U, 8 P spots
What guys would you be moving way up/down the draft board vs opening day rankings?
I’m praying man…I’d be moving Roki down…Moving Oneil Cruz up…Moving Edman up…Moving down Crews
Kjerstad or Jordan Walker? 6×6 OPS. Thanks!
Walker
Clase for Yelich a fair deal?
Clase, I’d want more
Yelich for Jhoan Duran?
Duran, it’s fair, coin flip
Thoughts on dropping Ryan Jeffers for Ivan Herrrera?
Sure
Sac Max!
Haha
Great call in the preseason on Schwellenbach! I snagged him up everywhere.
Looks amazing!
Misunderstood the prompt (and the phrase Bust of the Year) and am now desperately trying to move my grade-B VHS copy of Emmanuelle in Space before wrist problems make that impossible.
HA!
Who is the drop to activate Gunnar? My primary 1B is Casas and 2B is Westburg
1B – Burleson, Soderstrom
SS – Stott (only back up 2B/SS
SP – Meyer, Lodolo, Sasaki
Leaning Burleson due to potential platoon.
Sure, Burleson
1. I missed the Angels game so seeing Soriano’s results left me puzzled. Nine k’s in 5.1 seems juicy. 5 ERs does not. Worth holding on a 12 teamer or streamer?
2. You rolling out Hicks at home vs Mariners/Woo Sunday?
1. Streamer 2. Sure
J-Bam-Bam!
Bam.
HAHA
Just picked up Victor Scott over Heston in a redraft H2H points league that dings -1 for Ks. Am I a moron?
Nope
Ronel blanco worth the hold?? Or sell now?
Depends what you’re getting
In a 12-teamer, do you like MR’s like C.Smith, or M.Montgomery, or J.Estrada better than Verlander or J.Soriano?
Cade over Verlander
Have we anointed luzardo to matchup proof? Sonofabench!
Also, are you a packaging Gavin sheets and Grayson Rodriguez for Michael Toglia or Matt Olsen? Feel like I need a more reliable 1B and Gavin is likely smoke and mirrors.
Any interest in Ricky tiedemann in a dynasty?
10 team league 40 man rosters (with minor league spots)
Great to have baseball back!
Ha, yeah…I’d take Olson…
Grey! Which two would you start at UT in OBP league? Steer, Crews, Rengifo.
Is steer starting? Him
And Rengifo…I don’t know if Steer is starting tho
Would you grab Kjerstad over Bleday?
Would you accept a trade of CJ Abrams and Casey Mize for my Drew Rasmussen, Zac Gallen and Andres Gimenez?
Thanks!
No…I’d want CJ
RE: Wilson, hit his 2nd homer already after 4 this spring. Given he’s 6’2” and added 20 pounds of muscle over the offseason, I’d say the new power is no fluke. Hopefully it makes him more durable too since he got hurt last year right after call up. I’m loving the teams where I drafted him and Campbell.
Loving both of them so far!
What are your thoughts on chase dollander? Getting the call up
Allow me to assist.
Wouldn’t touch him in mixed leagues
Goldy and Luzardo for Matt Olson?
Which side
Olson
Grey – thoughts on my Yelich for his Bibbee. Was offered Luzardo for Yelich but not sure about that one. Any thoughts would be helpful. Thanks!
I’d want Bibee, but it’s fair…think I’d take Luzardo first but pretty close
Thanks!
No problem
Wood and sandy
Or flahtery, schwarber , caminero
Caminero
Sorry, starting over. 12 team keeper. MI stacked, hoerner, Turner, Campbell, jiminez, Lawler,coarnge juice, Outfield sucks. Langford for Campbell? Both $0 or what caliber OF range OF he compare?
Langford
Thanks for the reassurance!
No problem
Hunter Brown or Christopher Sanchez? QS and W league.
Sanchez
@Grey: weekly roto redraft. not looking to trade him but was offered duran and skubal for elly?
What does your SS situation look like? Id be leaning yes here but maybe a tad situational. Weekly makes it a tad different.
Sounds decent if you need that
Tyler Megill or Fedde over Schmidt?
Cam Smith or Toglia?
Megill…toglia
Pfaadt is ONE STRIKE from a QS…
Was
That’s what I meant.
Haha ugh
Thanks grey for all you do. Thoughts on selling high on Campbell or maybe he is who we hope he is?
I’m looking outfield
Redraft? Dynasty? What OF is being offered?
Langford for Campbell is one I’m contemplating
I’d take Langford
Thanks so much, I’m new to discussion and will be more specific.
Keeper but want to win, wondering caliber, of range
He doesn’t have OF elig.?
No and seems he won’t
I’d hold, but depends what you’re getting I guess
I have been conditioned to expect an offer like Campbell for Marte instead of a pretty even could go either way deal.
Puk or Holton for saves?
Flip a coin…Puk
Traded Sale for Gunnar. You like? It’s a small and shallow 6×6 roto. I’m happy with it, but I love a good Sale.
I do!
Love it!
Look at Brad with the big brain! Benched Jesus… jesus.
Ha
Max Meyer, however, … I got ALL of that!
Now That’s Not Quite A Guy You Can’t Hit, But It’s Almost A Guy You Can’t Hit.”
Haha
H/H POINTS ..12 team redraft
Nootbaar is available in more than a few ….I like him better than all of the above
I do too, but he’s over 50% rostered which is the cutoff for this post
Ketel Marte hurt. Pulled up lame rounding second on an easy triple. Subbed out. Looked to be in pain.
Garret Hampson subbed in. Who, I still mix up with Sam Hilliard mentally. I think is an okay mistake.
Yeah, didn’t look good
Pfaadt ugh. Come on man. Home runs again. Lefties killing him
Marte left game too.
Own both of those fellas. Strong start to the game!
Me too. My pitchers give up runs by the boatload.
Brutal
Why is Baty a buy?
Cuz
So Judge just homered and is now tied Babe Ruth for Hr in first 1000 games. Amazing.
That is truly incredible
Yeah I know. Great call out yesterday in your writeup. I forgot to mention it
Yup
Great fact writeup yesterday for mentioning it
I mean Mayza likes to be apart of this. He gave Judge his 61st too.
This is such garbage. Glad they still tied it but they might be winning.
https://bdata-producedclips.mlb.com/95c21940-e067-4110-b7d5-9ec458ef0981.mp4
I know, how ya gonna raise your hands on that
I love how easily he got it when he decided to play baseball.
Amazing
Why does he raise his hands? Is it to indicate he thinks it’s gone out of play?
I dont quite understand the rule itself. It is supposed to be out of play or unplayable, like wedged between something or stuck in a fence.
This is a classic if you have never seen it. I love the umps reaction.
https://youtu.be/by7eLzyCns0?feature=shared
That’s awesome. I might try that the next time I get in trouble with my wife. Just raise my hands and refuse to carry on.
I CANT SEE IT!?! WHERE IS IT!?! I CAN ONLY LOOK STRAIGHT AHEAD!!!! DOWN IS NOT AN OPTION!
I say I dont understand the rule, because…I have no idea the difference between that play and Rockies today. He even threw the ball back today so I cant understand it being unplayable.
It was a bad call
@Grey: weekly roto redraft. would you drop rengifo for either of willi castro or brendan donovan? bdon seems to be hitting 3rd fairly consistantly?
Sure, BDon
Thanks. BDon over Polanco? He seems to be a shmotato as well….
10 team 5×5 dynasty – would you drop bubba chandler for kjerstad as a bench bat?
No
No. No. No. Dynasty?!?! Hellllllno bro.
What do you think of these trades offers I have gotten. Try not to laugh.
Today: Cavilli, Cam Smith, Hjerbe for my Paredes.
With the comment: I could include Andrew Vaughn for either Toglia or Soderstrom. Considering I just gave up D. Williams+Sal Perez for Lodolo+Soderstrom in February….I dont think I will take it.
Soroka and Sproat for Mom’s Spaghetti OR Conforto and Sproat.
Youd think in a $250 dynasty 18 teamer 6×6 would tone down the goofy stuff. Prospects have high variance in value even with pro scouts. But those MLB guys are trash.
One of those things I love about Fantrax is looking at a players league transactions and you can go years back. I look at last year and he acquired Vaughn by giving up Malloy and Yastremski.
Ha, people trying to chump dump ya
Thanks, Grey! I expect you have an extra level of roofie category for a rookie Rockies pitcher, but I want to give you the chance to say it out loud. Any interest in Dollander?
God no
Love the extra stank.
Lots of stank needed
Love the Rockies. 2 runs on 10 hits. Mets 5 runs 4 hits.
Rockies have what, 2 fantasy SP in their history youd want on your roster?
3 runs now! Haha
The Pirates hitting is a joke. Cruz is going go 40/30/50. That’s 40 runs, 30 hr, 50 sb. What a waste of some very good players. They may lead the league in steals but can’t score any runs because they can’t get any damn hits after the 3 hole hitter. Shelton is terrible as you mention frequently. Nutting and Cherrington are worse
Haha, they are truly the worst
While I am on the Pirates, I saw the name Keston. I immediately thought of Hiura. He was good when he came up with Mil until his hitting coach Andy Haines who joined mil in 2019 spent time with him. I’m convinced he broke Hiura. Haines was the hitttng coach for Pit for the last couple of years, 2021-2024. He left his indelible mark on some young guys like Hayes, Henry Davis, suwinski, etc. They all turned to $hit once he spent time with them. Those guys who had potential are now likely broken forever.
Ooh, member him? That was my best bold prediction, saying he’d be demoted and he was
He is also going to have 70 errors at this rate.
Agree with you on lineup points. As much grief as I give the Rockies for being dumb, Moniak, etc, at least it feels like they try no matter how inept they are. Pirates just do nothing until the big news of another star leaving.
HAHA
How is he so bad out there
They don’t care about winning. The stars they have do their “time” and leave. They don’t add to try to win. It’s embarrassing as a fan.
Explains the sell the team chant by the fans…
Yeah
It’s so embarrassing
“There I was facing down Judge. I knew I would catch him off guard throwing right down the middle….”
lolol
This this Wilyur Abreu for real or just a schmotato?
Schmotato
Rice and Judge out here stealing bases like it is nothing.
Are the shoes juiced like the ball? Naylor and Rice leading my team here with 4.
The Nationals have 6 as a team!
They got torpedo shoes
New Nikes dropped.
HAHA
Grey,
Is it time to move on from Robles and/or Mitchell?
Please rank V. Scott, Robles, Mitchell.
Thanks!!
That ranking
Hey grey! I’ve got manzardo in my utl spot… Ben rice available. Ten team h2h league. I’ve got jazz and Austin wells if that matters
Hold
I hate the Blue Jays. Im ready to fire the team into the sun because their manager and their GM are a bunch of short bus seat warmers.
Gausman gave up 3 hits and leads off with a flyout, then a 4 pitch walk of Lindor. Soto coming to bat. Fine, you want to pull Gausman at 87 pitches? Dont. Put. In. Some. Trash. Rookie. WHOSNAMESOUNDSLIKETHEYCANTSPELL FLAHERTY. FLUHARTY.
DOUBLE. IBB. DOUBLE.
NO OUTS. NICE! THANKS FOR RUINING GAUSMANS NIGHT.
WHO BRINGS IN A GUY WITH 1 CAREER INNING PITCHED TO FACE SOTO? OH AND HE HAS A BLOWN SAVE IN HIS 1IP BEFORE TODAY. I hate this stupid team for being so stupid. Clowns. All of them.
Haha, that was a clown move
10-team 5×5 Roto: Bailey Ober was dropped. I know it’s just one game, but his first start has me a little hesitant to add him. Would you pick up Ober over Brandon Pfaadt or Bowden Francis?
Over Bowden
Thanks, Grey!
Regarding differentiating the Max Muncy’s: How about Sac Muncy for the new guy? MLB should have forced him to use a middle initial FFS. They even share the same birthday of August 25th.
Ma’s Muncy! What about Max and Min Muncy
That’s a good one too! 215lbs for the Dodger, 180lbs for the Athletic, so it checks out.
Haha
Major Muncy and Minor Muncy.
Veruca Salt doing Seether in Glastonbury 1995 is EPIC!
HAHA
James wood
Or schwarber and flahtery
Wood
Who’s ready for a Ryan Pressly meltdown?
Noooooo
sooooo close. threw about 30 pitches. stranded 2nd and 3rd. looked awful. just a matter of time. you can’t lose ’em all.
Just your standard reverse jinx here! thank you!
Cheerio or schwarber, eovaldi, caminero
Chourio
I was offered Bautista for my Finnegan and Luke Jax. H2H league so I can be patient but TJ surgery an issue obviously.
I would have Iglesias, Bautista and Estevez as closers and would pick up a holds guy such as Hodge with the vacant spot. Worth the risk?
Bautista side
Thank you. Done. I had him throw in Robert Garcia for holds in case I miss on Hodge who is not eligible for claim until Sunday. Saves and holds are separate cats. Here are the best available annd my squad. Any more moves?
Steer, Benny, Lane Thomas,
Rasmussen, Hicks,
Alvarado, Hodge, Vesia
Will Contreras
Vlad, Machado, Casas
Altuve, Lindor, Campbell
Tucker, Suzuki, V Scott, Nimmo, Cast
Util either Otto or Donovan
Shota, Yamamoto, Eovaldi, Eflin, Steele
Bautista, Iglesias, Estevez, Rob Garcia
Hold
Should I drop Jung Ho Lee to roster HRHRHRerra? Ironically currently have Willson at catcher who’s stinking it up but rather keep.
Nah
I’m good with this. Thanks, Grey!
No problem
Little Oak drafted otto in nfbc. loves him. been talking him up all year.
i also had clase as a bust this year. the end of year and the reliever falling off the cliff thing.
although, have you looked at kenley jansen’s score card. go look at his bbr page and check out the saves by year especially. damn.
Think I have to make Little Oak co-manager of my auction team and see if he can help me…Kenley’s due for 25 saves…
I will say it again the balls look bouncy this year. Hr are up. It is early but I am seeing opposite field shots. Opposite field hr is one good way to guage if somethitng is different. A lot of fly balls seem to be carrying that would never have gone out in the tungsten ball era.
It does seem that way
Interesting match ups:
1. Do you start or sit Max Myer of Miami at Atlanta?
2. Following pitchers on waiver wire:
Hayden. Wasneski
Justin Verlander
Grant Holmes
Are they all streamers or any must adds?
Thanks again!!
I’m not 2. I like wesneski not sure who you’re dropping tho
I would drop Wandy Peralta to get Wesneski. Would you make that move?
Thanks again so much!!
Sure
Thank you!!
No problem
Hi Grey, would you trade acuna for either caminero/albies or roman anthony/albies? 20 team keep forever. Thanks.
Re: worried if acuna maintains his value
They sound fair
Ivan HRHRHRera. I loved that by the way.
I’m so excited, and I just can’t hide it I’m about to lose control, and I think I like it.
I am dropping a Pointer Sisters reference and I don’t even listen to that kind of music. What’s gotten into me?
Hahaha
Excuse me hrhrhra
2nd week in a row…
I guess I’ll wait and see with Toglia, but now Wong is being a big fat dong… hold that one too?
Thanks
Nah
Ok then, which instead of Wong? This order about right?
Kirk
Heim
Dingler
Carson Kelly
I’d want Wong
Wilmer Flores over Toglia
Or not yet?
I’d hold for another week
Veruca Salt – so good lol!
That song (with that edit) is going to be in my head all weekend, and I can’t decide if I hate you or love you for it.
Haha, hate
Seager is usually the one who puts that song in my head.
Haha
You leery at all about Wacha at home to BAL tomorrow? SON numbers are solid. Ed-Rod is an option for me too.
I’d start Wacha
Saves + holds league
Would you go of any of cade Smith, Blake Treinin, Doval, Kirby Yates, Ben Joyce, cano over Puk?
Meh, Yates, Treinen or Smith is likely better
Yeah I figured they were all close. There’s an owner with us that punts the position every year. So plenty of options
Gotcha
Should I burn waiver priority on a Catcher in a 1 catcher 6×6 Roto? I would be dropping Wong for Goodman.
Nah
Should I be dropping Wong for Goodman or Herrera?
Goodman
Who would you guess is next in the Guardians pecking order if Clase loses the gig?
Smith
This isn’t really about him losing the job tho, just Clase being overrated
I did draft Clase and now wondering what range of starter, or reliever, should I be targeting with him? It’s a points league so it doesn’t matter whether it’s starter or reliever really
A #1 OF or SP…can’t trade him for an RP
Got ya thanks!
No problem