LOGIN

Last year, Fantasy Pros said I had the best fantasy baseball rankings for the previous year.

I did not do well in my leagues the year I had the best rankings. I don’t know how well my fantasy baseball rankings did last year comparatively to other ‘perts, because Fantasy Pros hasn’t announced it yet, but I know how well I did in my fantasy baseball leagues, which was very good. Won LABR, won an NFBC league, was competitive it in almost all my leagues (except Tout where I did a dumb strategy). Rudy won Tout and LABR last year and did well in all his leagues too. It would not shock me to find out I didn’t do well for rankings, according to Fantasy Pros. This is why I say rankings are only going to get you so far.

Drafted Aaron Judge last year in a lot of leagues, which worked out like me at LA Fitness once per year, but I could’ve easily drafted Kyle Tucker, who I liked more, and who wasn’t nearly as good, due to an unfortunate injury. I just didn’t draft Tucker because I wasn’t in position to do that, due to my draft slot. See, so you can have great rankings, but there’s still a ton of luck. If 12 people drafted off the same sheet, and that sheet was “the best fantasy baseball rankings,” there would still be 11 losers. Though, one of the 11 losers would be wearing a Sergio Tacchini tracksuit and gold chains, so would not be a loser at all. They would actually be very cool. With that said, I will scientifically give you some guys who are higher and lower in my rankings than ESPN’s fantasy baseball rankings.

Going to list players in a handy chart. The Thank You’s have it. It being good value from my rankings vs. ESPN’s. The No Thank You’s don’t have it. They’re bad people. Meh, they might be okay people, but they’re likely not ending up on any of my ESPN drafted teams. For this, I’ll be using my 2025 fantasy baseball rankings (go figure!) and ESPN’s 2025 fantasy baseball rankings (crazy, right?). Note: I wrote this the other day, so if the numbers aren’t exactly right, it’s because they heard my footsteps.

THANK YOU

Player Grey’s Ranking ESPN’s Ranking Overall Difference
Overall Overall
Ronald Acuña Jr. 13 29 16
Jazz Chisholm Jr. 21 54 33
Oneil Cruz 28 55 27
James Wood 35 87 52
Lawrence Butler 60 99 39
Riley Greene 64 122 58
Spencer Schwellenbach
66 126 60
Pete Crow-Armstrong
109 173 64
Parker Meadows 102 222 120
Spencer Arrighetti 183 229 46
Wilyer Abreu 215 NR NA
Jacob Young 271 NR NA
Jo Adell 252 NR NA
Jordan Walker 255 NR NA
Michael Wacha 228 NR NA
Jackson Jobe 257 NR NA
Nick Lodolo 262 NR NA
Tomoyuki Sugano 264 NR NA
Andrew Painter 390 NR NA

NO THANK YOU

Player Grey’s Ranking ESPN’s Ranking Overall Difference
Overall Overall
Freddie Freeman
41 18 23
Rafael Devers 42 21 21
Corbin Burnes
71 24 47
Chris Sale
70 31 39
Marcell Ozuna 79 36 43
Gerrit Cole
72 39 33
Kevin Gausman
199 67 132
Aaron Nola 139 63 76
Adley Rutschman 146 72 74
Jackson Holliday 192 131 61
Tanner Houck 227 133 94
Matt Shaw 240 146 94
Michael Busch 247 181 66
Lucas Erceg 297 203 94
Griffin Jax 289 207 82
Justin Verlander 456 238 218
Spencer Horwitz 393 234 159
Bryan De La Cruz 460 243 217
A.J. Puk 358 251 107
Max Scherzer 453 240 213