LOGIN

There’s plenty more “exciting” names to talk about in this opening than Josh H. Smith. There’s plenty more exciting names to talk about without the scare quotes. Sometimes, we have to be mature adults when we’re playing fantasy baseball and eat our vegetables (vegetables we don’t enjoy, such as Brussels sprouts, and not good vegetables like potatoes). Josh H. Smith is a vegetable. A hearty piece of roughage that gives you runs. A sturdy legume that sticks to your ribbies. A leafy green that gives you energy for speed. Another leafy green that gives you power. Josh H. Smith is so boring he sounds like a Mormon. One love to the Mormons, but no one ever said, “You go to that rave last night at the Mormon Tabernacle Choir headquarters? They were giving out herbal ecstasy and magical underpants.” Josh H. Smith is a vegetable Mormon. Call him Jicama Smith. Jicama Smith has all the qualities you need for a healthy, balanced diet with magical underpants. Anyway, here’s some more players to Buy or Sell this week in fantasy baseball:

PSYCHE! This post was released a week early for Patreon members. It will be released all year early for Patreons, so if people are getting a jump on you, it’s because they paid the $10. Anyway, the Fantasy Baseball Buy/Sell:

BUY

Bo Naylor – Bo knows top catchers, so Bo doesn’t know thy self. Bo knows a Contreras and a Cal and maybe a Goodman. If Bo knows currently-hotter-than-they’ve-been catchers, then he’d know himself.

Ryan O’Hearn – The reality of the shituation is O’Hearn is very similar to Pavin Smith. You’re not gonna love rostering him all year, but he’s likely more valuable than most guys you get off waivers, while being very boring. By the by, remember when I said this for Pavin Smith, then he homered, and someone in the comments was like, “You’re dumb, Pavin is great, not boring,” and, yeah, that person disappeared because Pavin is very boring.

Carlos Santana – This is to pick up the singer, not the hitter–[finger to ear bud]–Haha, okay, like your hat, I have that backwards.

Romy Gonzalez – Looks like he’s getting some of those Casas Sweet Casas at-bats. Sorry, was just listening to Motley Crew’s Spanglish album, Teatro de Dolor. Could also be Abraham “The Bull” Toro.

David Hamilton – Maybe at-bats open for Hamilton too. He’s not gonna waste his shot! Plus, he has crazy speed.

Colt Keith – He’s done nothing but hit homers. That’s a bad thing now? We are against the almighty dong? Is this because of woke?

Hyeseong Kim – Dodgers seem unconvinced that Kim can succeed in the majors, maybe we should heed their warnings. Or at least consider him just a steals threat.

Luis Urias – He’s been about as hot as any player in the game, just don’t look at Urias’s Hard Hit%. Don’t look at his stats, actually. Have the person you met on OnlyFans blindfold you, then pick him up.

Jordan Lawlar – Don’t think the DBags are ever calling him up, but I like to see y’all get crazy for prospects. Get crazy for me, it brightens my day. What, you don’t want to see me happy?

Luisangel Acuña – Ya know what would be crazy? If Luisangel and Ronald were both juniors. Talk about a mind f*ck. For them, not me. My mind’s been f*cked, shizz ain’t getting more f*cked. This is officially the most times I’ve f*cked in one post. Apologies, I am a hoe. So, Luisangel has been stealing bases and that’s about it.

Jackson Holliday – Nearly made this JH the lede over the JH who I did, but my thinking was, A) Holliday is actually rostered in way more leagues, and might even be over 50% rostered threshold, so illegible for this post, technically, and I don’t want to get arrested. B) Smith has been way more valuable than Holliday, while being rostered in less leagues. C) There’s no C.

Geraldo Perdomo – Saw an article about him where he said, “Bet on me,” and I love that. Unless he was talking to Tucupita Marcano, specifically.

Javier Baez – Comatose Fantasy Baseballer groggily wakes, “I see Javier Baez in your Buy column, by any chance did I fall into a coma and wake in 2016?” CFB, you’re gonna find this hard to believe, but you were only in a coma for a week and a half.

Coby Mayo – Gave you my Coby Mayo fantasy. It was written while parasailing.

Trey Sweeney – Fun fact! If he says his first name in Jamaica, they put stuff on his head to carry.

Daniel Schneemann – Anyone who picks up and plays Schneemann earns the Dedicated Hot Schmotato Warrior pin for their vest.

Kyle Stowers – He’s around top 30 overall on the Player Rater. Not on the 7-day Player Rater. On the season-long Player Rater, and when I wrote this, he was as valuable as Tarik Skubal. One note about that, though. If you had two good weeks out of the first four, you’re gonna be ranked high on the Player Rater, so it’s something, but not everything.

Jake Meyers – “Ever notice how there’s no Meyers, but there’s a Breyer’s and Dreyer’s?” Kevin from ESPN’s “Get Him In Your Lineup” Department walking through the freezer section.

Dane Myers – “Or a Myers.” Meyers and Myers (sic) have been been crazy hot, and Myers has speed, and Meyers has, uh, an E. Not to shortchange, Myers either. We like speed. All types. Well, except when Michael J. Fox took speed to pass a test on Family Ties, then crashed hard.

Andy Pages – This is one of those weird ones where Pages is in a great lineup, was great in the minors, and no one seems to think much of him. If only Jasson Dominguez was doing what Pages is doing, he wouldn’t be benched for Trent Grisham.

Tyrone Taylor – As someone who’s rostered Taylor in one league for two years (NL-Only, don’t ask), he does have these two-week stretches where he’s valuable.

Edward Cabrera – This is a Streamonator call, like the call it makes to the laundromat.

Sandy Alcantara – Frankly, I think there’s a bigger thing going on with him and why he’s been so bad that a matchup can’t fix, but he’s vs. the White Sux and this is a Streamonator call. “It says you’re coin-operated machinery. My mother was coin-operated too. Wonder if you know her, Clean-Robot-er-4000.”

Kevin Ginkel – Is it Ginkel/Einhorn/Einhorn/Ginkel’s job yet in Arizona? MTV’s The Challenge Torey Lovullo seems to want it to be his job. There will be a a lot of saves here if you get the right guy who is getting the saves. Shelby Miller seemed to be that guy, but I have very little faith in him, almost as little as Lovullo, apparently.

Chad Green – This could be Yimi Garcia, or it could just continue to be Jeff Hoffman, but injuries often hassle the Hoff and he’s been so ineffective, that I wonder if he’s not already hurt.

Pierce Johnson – Weird, when I googled this guy, I found some interesting pictures and something about Prince Albert. Raisel is the Braves closer, but he’s been awful, and no one behind him is very good. This is more of an NL-Only stash on the outside chance there’s something going on with Raisel.

Zach Agnos – Standing on the top deck of Coors Field, dressed in corduroys and a Wilco concert tee, telling people how the Bible was written by man, cheering on Agnos, because we’re his cheering section, The Agnostics.

Justin Sterner – A’s took a petri dish of Chris Sale’s slider, injected it into Sterner’s right arm and said, “You know what you have to do,” and he asked, “Weren’t you supposed to take off the bacteria you grew on the glass dish and insert that into my arm, and not the entire glass,” and the scientist said, “Uh…” But so far the results have worked tremendously!

SELL

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. – On the podcast about two weeks ago, BDon and I had a realization in real time, as most realizations happen, don’t be pedantic. We realized that Teoscar and Vlad aka Cake Batter are basically the same thing. Teoscar has more power, Cake has more average, Teoscar has more ribbies, Cake has more, uh, average? Cake was drafted at 13th overall on average; Teoscar at 53 overall. Should we have drafted Teoscar instead? Well, yeah, dur! But that’s not coming back. Teoscar’s gonna miss two weeks with injury, return and still be more valuable than Vlad for the year. Any hoo! This is about what you can do with Cake since you already have him. Is it possible to get top 20 value for him still? Top 30? I think so, but I don’t know. His name does seem to conjure better fantasy value in one’s mind than reality. A true fantasy fantasy player. (Not a compliment.) I wouldn’t trade Vlad for a walk-on part on Teenjus, but I would go to the Fantasy Baseball Trade Analyzer and explore options.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

307 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
rhodyballer
rhodyballer
13 days ago

Lawlar , Tovar or Bichette ROS?

Last edited 13 days ago by rhodyballer
Licketty Splits
Licketty Splits
13 days ago

10 Team NL only league with QS, SVHD & OBP
Team with a lot of injuries open to trading Ohtani & wants a SP & has made offers for Sasaki already but also wants 2 or 3 good players
Per Trade Analyzer this deal would be fair
Ohtani ($49 to keep next season) & Morejon ($5) for Sasaki ($22), Hays ($9) & R Suarez ($18)
Seems maybe a bit light but is it a good opening offer?? My offer has potentially decent prices for next season for him. Ohtani side wins?

Norman Ginsberg
Norman Ginsberg
13 days ago

2 catcher league. I have Agustine — drop for Tyler Stephenson?

Matthew Perovich
Matthew Perovich
13 days ago

Skenes or Crochet? Thanks!

Sinner Man
Sinner Man
13 days ago

I effing held Bryce all week for this redemption home start against a garbage offense. Sorry pal, fool me thrice… I’m literally setting my phone alarm for 3:05 am so I can rage drop him and go back to bed happy and content for once.

Herschel
Herschel
13 days ago

@Grey: weekly roto redraft. How do you rank H Ramos, J Dominguez, Friedl and Bleday. Thanks!

Herschel
Herschel
Reply to  Herschel
13 days ago

Oh, and Josh Smith.

P K
P K
13 days ago

Bud Black into the abyss!

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  P K
13 days ago

I cant believe they did it. I think it is kind of ironic that if they had been typically miserably bad but maybe 24th-26th they would have been fine. Epically bad just drew too much heat and getting embarrassed yesterday was too much. GM is next.

harry reid
harry reid
13 days ago

Hey Grey, 12 team, H2H, 6×6, Keeper. How do you rank Mountcastle, Croneworth, Morel? Thanks

Long Bawls
Long Bawls
13 days ago

“Pierce Johnson? Scott Blewett! And I think we’re gonna need a ballboy.” Even the Regression Fairies were like, “Hey, cool it with the entendres, we’re trying to be respectable now,” after visiting the Atlanta bullpen.

Daze
Daze
13 days ago

Grey
This may sound crazy but in a 10 team roto would you drop Flaherty for
Gonsolin
Cade Horton
AJ Shawver
Liberator
Reese Olson
Wacha
Ranger Suarez
If so who would be your top 2 to target

Daze
Daze
Reply to  Grey
13 days ago

Anyone else in case I can’t get him

Sinner Man
Sinner Man
Reply to  Daze
13 days ago

Ranger looked good yesterday and he’s at home vs the Pirates this week

Dancin Homer
13 days ago

Afternoon & Happy Twilight Zone Day… seems appropriate.

I have an open IL spot and looking for a stash, which of these scrubs you think has the best shot to breakout?

  • Walker Buehler
  • Eury Pérez
  • Sean Manaea

Thanks as always!

Matthew Perovich
Matthew Perovich
13 days ago

Hey Grey, which side: Raleigh, Abrams; or, William Contreras, Vlad?

Matthew Perovich
Matthew Perovich
Reply to  Matthew Perovich
13 days ago

Also; Skenes or Vlad? Apples/oranges I know…

Lets play two
Lets play two
13 days ago

Soderstrom or Ozuna standard roto? Need is HR/RBI.

Dude
Dude
13 days ago

Keeper league
Baty or Evan Carter?
I also have Vientos, if that matters.

Norman Ginsberg
Norman Ginsberg
13 days ago

Keep 2: Pagan; Megill; Shelby Miller; Hodge

Roupp; Francis; Jobe.

  • Pick1
  • Keeper league – same answer?
Perfect Game
Perfect Game
13 days ago

Which side – Machado or Ketel? Or is it a sideways move? At least Machado steal bases.

If I moved Machado my 3B would be Maikel.

Perfect Game
Perfect Game
Reply to  Perfect Game
13 days ago

I also have Suarez to play 3B too.

On another note, why do managers need to give players days off right after they come back from an injury when the IL period and minor league assignments are for recovering and getting timing back? This is the 2nd time Ketel has been given a day off since missing a month.

Adam
Adam
13 days ago

Hey Grey,

I belong to a 5X5, 20 team rotisserie (on Yahoo). Very deep. Remainder of the year, would you rather have Jonah Heim/Kyle Higashioka as your C tandem or Carson Kelly/Miguel Amaya?

Last edited 13 days ago by Adam
aintlifegrand
aintlifegrand
13 days ago

Happy Sunday!

We still holding Doyle through this icy patch? Stowers and The Martian are available. 10 team redraft OBP league. Thanks!

SteveNZ
Reply to  Grey
13 days ago

Would you prefer Stowers to JH Lee? OBP 12er.

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  aintlifegrand
13 days ago

I think Doyle’s head is out of it. That unfortunate stuff in personal life, then playing on an epically bad team, not really something to take his mind off things when you go to work wondering how bad you gonna get hammered.

Bad Mother Tucker
Bad Mother Tucker
13 days ago

12 team, 5×5 roto

Replacement for Altuve – Luis Garcia Jr. or Gabriel Arias?

nr baseball
nr baseball
13 days ago

Stephen Kolek – should I place a waiver bid on him – 2 good starts – are there more

nr baseball
nr baseball
Reply to  nr baseball
13 days ago

16 team league

nr baseball
nr baseball
Reply to  nr baseball
13 days ago

Chad Patrick is also on waivers

Matthew Perovich
Matthew Perovich
13 days ago

Hey Grey – Vlad for Ketel and Pivetta. Or should I try for more for Vlad? Thanks!

Matthew Perovich
Matthew Perovich
Reply to  Matthew Perovich
13 days ago

Trying to move Vlad for a week now. Other option would be like Langford and Devers.

Nobody’s Fool
Nobody’s Fool
13 days ago

Mitch Keller,Drew Rasmussen, Gavin Williams,Merrill Kelly,Cade Horton and Brady Singer all available. Who is the grab ROS? Thanks !

Spencer
Spencer
13 days ago

Thoughts on buying low on Gunnar and trying to trade for him? Do you think if I offer my Suzuki and Rodon it’s too much?

Michael
Michael
13 days ago

Would you drop Jorge Polanco For Jose Altuve? (10-team, h2h catagories league)

hal_incandenza
14 days ago

13 team 6×6 with OPS and Holds, QS instead of Wins. Daily lineups.

Who’s the drop to activate Eflin?

Durbin (I’d be down to only having Rafela for 2B, but Durbin hasn’t done squat)
Jac Caglianone stash
Bubba Chandler stash
Reese Olson (recently added)
Eflin

JFish
JFish
14 days ago

Ginkel or Bednar?

Larry
Larry
14 days ago

Is it time to move on from Sasaki? Wa ha is available.

Braves233
Braves233
14 days ago

PCA hitting leadoff, would be great if that continued.

Long Bawls
Long Bawls
14 days ago

Hereafter known as Fernando Bruise.

Cohen
Cohen
14 days ago

Is Roman Anthony call up imminent or no idea?

J.R.
J.R.
14 days ago

I swear my hitters wont take a walk and being Michael Jordan in Space Jam.

3-0 count…don’t swing…don’t swing he cant hit the zone he has 1 ball in the zone his last 14 pitches.

*My player proceeds to chase, foul, strikeout swinging.*

Come on guys.

While we are on the subject, why are we still pitching to Judge like he is Michael Jordan playing baseball? Another 2 HR for him today so far.

Norman Ginsberg
Norman Ginsberg
14 days ago

Baty is now starting against some Righties (because Vientos continues struggling). Willi Castro is also not a world beater (but he does have roster flexibility. And because of having a better supporting lineup, Vientos probably more potential for counting stats.

Who’s my cut – Vietos or Castro?

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Norman Ginsberg
14 days ago

Baty is still a thing…ugggg…I need to withdraw my Vientos trade offer now. Was trying to buy low.

aajones
aajones
14 days ago

K. Schwarber or R. Green? 5 player keeper league. Next season costs: Schwarber $26 & Green $17

aajones
aajones
Reply to  Grey
14 days ago

Thank you!

aardvark
aardvark
14 days ago

Drop Jordan hicks or Landon roupp?

aardvark
aardvark
Reply to  aardvark
14 days ago

Nevermind. I see the same question below

aardvark
aardvark
14 days ago

Ryan McMahon or Brett Baty?

Nathan Ducharme
Nathan Ducharme
14 days ago

Yerg Alert!!! Jordan Beck went yard and we must talk about how he’s not universally owned on your bench. Is he Charlie Blackmon? no. Is he Charles Whitesox, yes! He will give you up to 30 hrs, 10SBs, 270 avg and 80 runs or RBIs, Book it, bet it, bank it!

Moving on to Betty Crocker! Vlad trade value, Witt, Soto, Tatis… good luck. Lol.

Nerd Alert time!!!!

Barrel % (14.2%), HardHit% (53.1%), and Average Exit Velo (93.0 mph) all rank well above league average.
His xBA (.313), xSLG (.514), and xwOBA (.394) are elite (top 10–15% of MLB), suggesting his actual production may underperform his quality of contact — meaning positive regression is possible.
K% (19.2%) and BB% (12.6%) show a disciplined hitter with good swing decisions.
Bat Speed (94th percentile) backs up his power ceiling — the underlying tools are elite.
His 2025 barrel rate (14.2%) is a career high and better than his standout 2021 season.
Consistent improvements in walk rate and decreased strikeout rate show he’s refining his approach.

Yerg is the opposite of Grey. I love my creator, but I must say BUY, and enjoy the re-birth Cake Batter…. The Cake is a cometh!

IMG_0790
Perfect Game
Perfect Game
14 days ago

Standard roto with 9 teams. Near bottom in home runs and RBI. Have Ozuna U only eligible in our league. He hasn’t gotten hot yet. Wondering if his hip is the reason. Would you take Ketel for him and is it fair?

Russ
Russ
14 days ago

Best bet for a QS

Verlander vs. ARI
Rea vs. MIA
Schmidt @SEA

J.R.
J.R.
14 days ago

Devers got a talking to in the principals office. Owner and all the big wigs flew out to discuss things with him.

Last edited 14 days ago by J.R.
Cohen
Cohen
14 days ago

Please pick one
T.Anderson home vs Baltimoe
Canning home vs Cubs
Gonsolin at Arizona

Johnny Tsunami
Johnny Tsunami
14 days ago

Horton starting tonight, start him at NYM?

J C
J C
14 days ago

15runs, 12RBI, 6 HR . 296 average. Plus 3 triples which is a cat in our league.
Last 30 days for Jordan Beck since he became an everyday starter. Just can’t quit him yet lol.

Saint
Saint
14 days ago

Gotta drop one of Roupp, Hicks, or Soriano to activate Eflin tomorrow.

Who be gone?

Thanks!

fausto
fausto
14 days ago

10tm head to head redraft would you lose aranda or K.Campbell for Lourdes G. Jr? he’s hot and I need counting stats this week?

also would you lose K.Jansen or iglesias for will vest? I know vest is a timeshare but ratio on iglesias are terrible and Jansen rarely gets an opp at a save I have Hoffman, pagan, iglesias, and Jansen. none feel safe…

appeciate input there
cheers.

Mike Honcho
Mike Honcho
14 days ago

Suzuki for Rodon? Trade Analyzer shows it even, but gut says otherwise. Thoughts?

Perfect Game
Perfect Game
14 days ago

Pfaadt or Flaherty?

Bad Mother Tucker
Bad Mother Tucker
14 days ago

12 team, 5×5 roto. Saves only.

Would you trade my Bellinger, Eovaldi & Jose Alvarado for Jarren Duran and Mason Miller?

I have too much pitching, trying to consolidate into better players. Here’s the squad:

C- Goodman
1B- Naylor
2B- Altuve
3B- Riley
SS- Gunnar
OF- Carroll
OF- Cruz
OF- Rooker
UTIL- Doyle
BN- Bellinger

SP- King, Woo, Eovaldi, Ray, Lugo, Liberatore, Abbott

RP- Fairbanks, Alvarado, Vest, Ginkle

IL- Justin Martinez

Torpedo Bat Flip
Torpedo Bat Flip
14 days ago

ROS in a 6×6 roto with W & QS:

Senga or Gore?

Torpedo Bat Flip
Torpedo Bat Flip
Reply to  Torpedo Bat Flip
14 days ago

Senga’s FIP is 3.03 and SIERRA 4.26.

SpecialFNK
SpecialFNK
14 days ago

16 team keeper league, yahoo, roto, 5×5.

give- Jonathan India, Hyeseaong Kim
get- Colt Keith, Shane Baz

?

clamotta@mac.com
14 days ago

Hey Grey

16 team auction league with 9 keepers with BA OPS HR R RBI SB OBP. I finished in 2nd last year and am currently in 2nd. Would you drop Rengifo or Norby for Tim Elko? Both those guys are killing me but I know it’s still early. I could also drop Hoskins or Kepler. Thanks

Chris Lamotta
Chris Lamotta
Reply to  Grey
14 days ago

Ok thanks

martin rostoker
martin rostoker
14 days ago

Hope you’re are having a great weekend!!!

1. Would you start or sit Atlanta’s AJ Smith-Shawver at Pittsburgh?

2. Would you start or sit Reese Olson vs Texas at home vs Texas?

3. Among the following do you have a favorite or all no’s. Who are the top two?

A. Will Warren whose next starts are at Seattle and home vs Texas and then home again vs COL or LAA

*WW pitched well against A’s

B. Gavin Williams vs Phil and Milwaukee at home

C. Ryan Gusto vs KC at home and then on the road at KC

Thanks again!!!

martin rostoker
martin rostoker
Reply to  Grey
14 days ago

Thanks! appreciate all your help!

martin rostoker
martin rostoker
Reply to  martin rostoker
14 days ago

Would you drop Max Myers or Wacha to get Warren?

Thank you!

Snacks
Snacks
14 days ago

Would you consider Soder or PCA sell high candidates? Thanks!

Snacks
Snacks
Reply to  Grey
14 days ago

Your up early today! Thanks, loving the Podcast.

Torpedo Bat Flip
Torpedo Bat Flip
Reply to  Grey
14 days ago

Would you sell PCA or do you feel good about him going forward and maintaining his production?

rudy
rudy
14 days ago

Love the sell on Vladdy.

Trade advice! keepers league.

He is offering Ronald Acuna, Freddy Peralta, Hunter Greene, and George Kirby

for

My Yordan Alvarez.

what do you think?

SteveNZ
14 days ago

Being a Ginkel and a Yimi owner, I can only assume that Ginkel paid for what Yimi got away with.

J.R.
J.R.
15 days ago

Bobblehead from today’s game. It feels very shoehorned in there.

I’d rather just do “Rebel Pilot Colt Keith” or something. Feels very awkward.

Tarik Skubal is a more Star Wars-y name imo.

Screenshot_20250509-210148
J.R.
J.R.
15 days ago

What…why….you…just….I….dont understand.

“The Reds acquired outfielder Connor Joe from the Padres for minor league reliever Andrew Moore and cash considerations, the teams announced. Cincinnati transferred Tyler Callihan to the 60-day injured list to create a spot on the 40-man roster. San Diego’s roster count falls to 38.”

Youd rather have Conner Joe play than a Benson or Hinds or someone else in the minors?

Screenshot_20250509-205007
J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Grey
15 days ago

Maybe they can trade for Kelenic and Suwinski just to add more chaos. You would think a team would call up Oakland for an OF but they’d rather pay Conner a cool million for uhhh….. maybe 8 HR and .240?

Ironically this reminded me my dynasty league where someone tried to give him to me. I am guessing looking at the stats it was 2021, because he had a .280ish avg and 5-6 HR at end of April and guy was trying to convince me he was a breakout happening before my eyes. I passed on it. Im sure you can hear the lack of regret I have on that as I type this. I didnt even realize he was on the Padres.

Last edited 15 days ago by J.R.
tinstaapp
tinstaapp
15 days ago

You would absolutely trade Vladito for a walk on part in Teenjus, Grey. And so would I.

Man, I’m gonna miss that show.

SteveNZ
15 days ago

Good grief.

IMG_5842
J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  SteveNZ
15 days ago

It was so bad it blended in with his shoes until I zoomed in.

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  SteveNZ
15 days ago

Ump in Rockies game just trying to expedite the end of it.

Screenshot_20250509-211906
TarmanGotHim
TarmanGotHim
15 days ago

When you blurb and burn Max Meyers start, it wasn’t as bad as the final stat line will look. Guy throws 3 strikes to Andrew Vaughn but he somehow homered on a 2-1 count then struck out the next 2 batters. Then his 3 and 4 hits were back to back on the 7th, well, because it’s the Marlins and bad is contagious. Then he missed a bunt hy Amaya which I laughed at. Only a former Marlin hitting .088 could do that to the Marlins.

TarmanGotHim
TarmanGotHim
Reply to  TarmanGotHim
15 days ago

As I post this the ump calls ball 4 on a strike to walk in a batter. Are they that against the Marlins? It’s been like this since 1993.

J.R.
J.R.
15 days ago

I would have started Dobbins if I had known India had switched teams to be on Boston.

https://mlb-cuts-diamond.mlb.com/FORGE/2025/2025-05/09/c1ea3fca-0e3a287e-fd15be85-csvm-diamondgcp-asset_1280x720_59_4000K.mp4

fausto
fausto
15 days ago

I grabbed Dane myers bc he was a schmotato. now I need to drop someone to add a catcher looking at I. Herrera(4hr 21abs hitting .300 hoping he can replicate what C .Kelly is doing in chicago) of these OF who would you drop?

Harris2
Wilyer Abreu
K.Campbell
Castelllanos
L.Butler or
Dane Meyers?…I’d think that was a no brainer Dropping Dane Meyers but I’m considering Campbell since I need SB and have Lu-Ga-JR and Aranda I can slot at 2b.

appreciated as always

Scoboticus
Scoboticus
15 days ago

Greyfather, I’m out of il slots. Do i drop Wesneski or Arrighetti?

Rotorooter
Rotorooter
15 days ago

Hyeseong Kim or Gavin Sheets, dynasty league bench bat,

Thanks!

J.R.
J.R.
15 days ago

Tigers are going to fall into their own delusion. Hitters are scrappy, but they only have 2-3 decent hitters. Their pitching is very good though.

No way that group of hitters should be leading league in average, 2nd in runs, 6th HR, and somehow are dead last in SB.

I want to believe they are that good, but no way in hell I believe it. Beating on the Angels bullpen and Rockies doesnt make me believe that McKinstry is a .290 hitter and Keith suddenly can hit for power or that Greene needs new legs.

Scoboticus
Scoboticus
15 days ago

Gray the Elder, Need a stream for tomorrow:
A-S-S @Pit
EdCab @WhiteSux
Kyle Gibson @LAA

Norman Ginsberg
Norman Ginsberg
15 days ago

RE: Devers.

Contreras was told by StL to put away his glove — he was to be their full-time DH. I notice that today he is tarting at 1B.

J.R.
J.R.
15 days ago

Cash really out there making the most nonsensical lineups possible.

Screenshot_20250509-181557
chairmanguy
chairmanguy
Reply to  Grey
15 days ago

I love and hate being a rays fan.

Jt
Jt
15 days ago

Holiday or Durbin

J.R.
J.R.
15 days ago

Seager out a 2nd game in a row. Im getting awful nervous. Id be happy with some food poisoning or some illness.

aardvark
aardvark
15 days ago

Grey. Dynasty question. Got offered Kirby and Soderstrom for my Duran. What do you think? Points league

aardvark
aardvark
Reply to  Grey
15 days ago

What about Torkelson instead of soder?

topclass
topclass
15 days ago

Schmidt or roupp a drop for wesneski ?

Norman Ginsberg
Norman Ginsberg
Reply to  Grey
15 days ago

Wesneski on IL.

TarmanGotHim
TarmanGotHim
15 days ago

Am I crazy I consider the following:

My Gunnar and Wood

For

Vlad, Abrams, Acuna?

Also was offered this in another league:

X Edwards and Bednar for Alvarado

Thank you!!

Rene
Rene
15 days ago

Hunter Goodman or Ivan Herrera?

Dancin Homer
15 days ago

You dropping Friedl or Kurtz for Grisham?

12-team, 6×6 OBP league

Thank you

Dancin Homer
Reply to  Grey
15 days ago

Thanks as always!

Steveshu
Steveshu
15 days ago

Been offered a trade in my 12 team roto OBP league with QS… Since I need another pitcher until McClanahan comes back, if ever, would you do Luzardo for Jeremy Pena? I have Lindor and Arias eligible at SS.

Yeesh
Yeesh
15 days ago

You like Taj or Pepiot better ROS and would you drop either for Luis Garcia Jr if you needed a 2B?

brunswickbp
brunswickbp
15 days ago

Happy weekend Grey! 12-team deep roster dynasty with OBP and SLG.

Are there a top 3-4 you prioritize roster out of: Pavin, Rengifo, Durbin, Norby, Kepler, Urias, Schneeman, Sweeney, D. Myers? Or are they pretty much all the same?

Norman Ginsberg
Norman Ginsberg
15 days ago

Bo Naylor or Tyler Stephenson?

toolshed
15 days ago

Mayo sent back to minors. You can strike him from the list. His call up didn’t even last a week. I know he didn’t do anything but did he really even have a chance? He was benched a few times. He doesn’t seem like he is in their plans. Watch him eventually qualify as a minor league fa. Maybe that’s one way to get out of Baltimore. We will never find out if he is any good. They are too dumb to trade

Last edited 15 days ago by toolshed
J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  toolshed
15 days ago

Beat me to it. The callup was only due to injuries. Even when Westburg went down they turned to Rivera. Just silliness. Oneill back and Westburg soon and only giving him 1/2 the reps he had 0 chance even if he hit 4 HR.

Os are so dumb like you said, I bet they do something just as dumb and trade to save their jobs …after it is too late. Hell it might be too late right now.

Feel bad for Mayo and it is a bad look for the Os with everyone noticing now.

Last edited 15 days ago by J.R.
toolshed
Reply to  J.R.
15 days ago

Yeah i dont get it. Trade him or give him a chance. They are so poorly run.

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  toolshed
15 days ago

You win the game when you have the biggest collection of highest rated prospects. Right?

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  toolshed
15 days ago

Also they are batting a hot .130 with RISP as a team for the past few weeks

Screenshot_20250509-173921
J C
J C
15 days ago

Simpson on the WW is one of my leagues. I own him in one and traded him away in another based on needs. So obviously conflicted. When Lowe and Mangum rejoin the Rays, what happens with Simpson?. Platoon? Pinch runner and spot at bats? Having a hard time with the Rays. Love the speed, but ….

Mike Honcho
Mike Honcho
15 days ago

Libertore or Verlander ROS in a 12 teamer??

CENTRALCOASTCALI
CENTRALCOASTCALI
15 days ago

Master Gray Junior:),

Thank you, my father is a Junior but he’s called by a different name than my grandfather so that’s kinda F’d but not as F’d as you being F’d in the mind because F’n baseball’s f’n fantasy and all, but who really gives an F?!!

A) Is Bellinger going to be blahblahbell all year?

B) Ward over O’Hearn?

C) There is no F’n C

ccccccccccc, oops, got some food stuck in the keyboard:). Thank you Junior Gray, your marvels as a finger typer are extraordinary. It’s s’posed to be 94 here tomorrow, I’m to old for the heat:), have a great weekend, the Olive and Lavender festival is tomorrow with plenty of shade and plenty of wineries around??????

CCC

CENTRALCOASTCALI
CENTRALCOASTCALI
Reply to  Grey
15 days ago

I’m a Senior, senior citizen, I just added to your, Master Fantasy Lothario legendary name. Taylor Dayne, you’re not that old, that song must have been on the ‘B’ side of, “Tell It To My Heart”:):):).

Robert Blake
Robert Blake
15 days ago

Gonsolin or Abbott ROS

Robert Blake
Robert Blake
Reply to  Grey
15 days ago

Thank you ‘Stache Master!

Scrapski
Scrapski
15 days ago

Grey,
Who is the drop for Strider?
Peterson, Boyd, T Myers, Lodolo
Thanks

Rojo
Rojo
15 days ago

*Ohtani reading that quote from Perdomo:
“You can do that?”

toolshed
15 days ago

How do you rank these guys: eflin, gonsolin, wacha. Qs format.

mrcatcher22
mrcatcher22
15 days ago

Thanks Grey. Catcher question…ROS rankings for Langeliers, Ramirez, Wells, Goodman?

Stl Squat Cobblers
Stl Squat Cobblers
15 days ago

Is Schanuel one of these worst two-hole hitters for fantasy? I will call him…Sore-Bung!

I guess this is more about how I feel!

toolshed
Reply to  Grey
15 days ago

The correct answer is probably Gunnar Henderson. I know nobody wants to say it. It has to get better, right?

toolshed
Reply to  Grey
15 days ago

We’ve hit rock bottom. I keep waiting like many of us. I am critical but continue to have hope. The other concern i have is how healthy is he? We will never know. He is hitting the ball hard. Too bad that isn’t a fantasy stat

Last edited 15 days ago by toolshed
Gordeon
Gordeon
15 days ago
Dan
Dan
15 days ago

Jake myers, sweeney, or gabriel arias ??

Spencer
Spencer
15 days ago

Have Ivan Herrera and Austin Hays getting activated off the IL. First off should I drop Sean Murphy for Herrera to be activated? Can also hold onto both and use one of them as a bench/utility bat. But here’s my list of players I can drop for either of Hays or Herrera/Murphy (not in need of stolen bags if that makes the choices easier):

Jesus Sanchez
Connor Norby
Heliot Ramos
Brenton Doyle
Luis Garcia Jr
Willi Castro

Spencer
Spencer
Reply to  Spencer
15 days ago

And I know you’ve told me to drop Ramos multiple times, but ended up holding him for his 4-5 game and dropped durbin because I thought he was more valuable for certain categories

Spencer
Spencer
Reply to  Grey
15 days ago

Thanks appreciate the advice as always !

James
James
15 days ago

NL 5×5 only please rank ROS and next year:

Jordan Hicks, Kevin Leahy, Luis Mey.

the latter two are CIW

James
James
Reply to  James
15 days ago

And Add Romano to the mix. He seems to have relighted the ship to some degree in Phillie.

Joe Shlabotnik
Joe Shlabotnik
15 days ago

Just to mention, lotta people writing him off- Vladito hit .229 in April last year
Sometime in May, his bat woke up and he was tremendous the rest of the year, top 10 hitter…

Dave
Dave
15 days ago

I have been trying to figure out why Vlad’s nickname is Cake Batter. I give up.

Johnny Doh!
Johnny Doh!
Reply to  Dave
15 days ago

James Brown will tell you: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8OyYrD0cVsI

JDB
JDB
Reply to  Grey
15 days ago

I often use the Razz nicknames in my leagues, especially Cake and Captain Woo, and my league mates have no effin idea what I’m talking about. Lurve!!

hondo
hondo
Reply to  Grey
15 days ago

Invented Languages: Klingon and Beyond (The University of Texas at Austin)

Alex
Alex
15 days ago

Haha the Agnos blurb looked me in the eye. I picked him up this morning, and I’m seeing Wilco tomorrow night.

Alex
Alex
Reply to  Alex
15 days ago

Diamondbacks closer situation… you don’t see Martinez reclaiming that role?

J.R.
J.R.
15 days ago

Would you do Burnes, Bibee, Rooker, Mayo for Acuna and Painter in an 18 team cat dynasty? Rooker is stuck at DH only and needs 15 games in LF (2)/CF (0)/RF (2) for this season and 20 for next to keep it.

I am paying too much to jettison Burnes? Oh I want to jettison oh so bad.

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Grey
15 days ago

You got it. Firing that offer on the pony express.

Coconut Willie
Coconut Willie
15 days ago

Urias
Pages
Kim

Who’s odd man out?

14 team weekly 6×6

JKM
JKM
15 days ago

If Andres hits the IL (quad), you keeping him or Tyler Fitzgerald in the IL slot?

Joe Shlabotnik
Joe Shlabotnik
15 days ago

Save+Holds league
Who’s the drop?
Brazoban, Kerkering, Varland
thanks, peace out

Joe Shlabotnik
Joe Shlabotnik
Reply to  Grey
15 days ago

if I could only keep one- Brazo or Kerk?

Smitty
15 days ago

2 big names that have disappointed – Yordy and Cake
Who ya got ROS? Trade analyzer favors Batter

Chucky
Chucky
Reply to  Smitty
15 days ago

I’m 4-1 in a points redraft with those two as my 1-2 picks at the turn. Just sayin’….

Braves233
Braves233
15 days ago

Alcantara vs white Sox or Rasmussen against brewers?

Braves233
Braves233
Reply to  Grey
15 days ago

Or Abbott at astros

Jimmy
Jimmy
15 days ago

Hi Grey – has the past 2 max meyer starts ruined the hope that he could be breaking out this year?

Jimmy
Jimmy
Reply to  Grey
15 days ago

does this mean he is both unstartable @CWS and unrosterable in 12 team redraft leagues?

toolshed
Reply to  Grey
15 days ago

I can think of two FA acquisitions for the O’s who will make you think twice about that

Harley Earl
Harley Earl
15 days ago

I know this, I totally loved how you described Pavin Smith as boring, even posted how you were dead on right about him. And, this time, I’m saying the same about Ryan O’Hearn. I’ve rostered them both off and on due to injury situations over the last couple years and, boy, are they boring! But they do offer some value and that’s why I’ve stuck with them.

You nailed Pavin and you’re 100 percent correct about O’Hearn, too. Carry on!

Wendell T. Montgomery
Wendell T. Montgomery
15 days ago

Quick buy/sell question for you: are you buying or selling the Evanescence theory from episode 3 of the Rehearsal?

FMFU
FMFU
15 days ago

Sold Cake Batter a few weeks ago for Matt Chapman/CJ Abrams in a league where I needed the speed, ahead of the curve !

Feel he just isn’t a great fantasy player, but you know in 2026 he’ll be going in the first round again HA

Joe Shlabotnik
Joe Shlabotnik
15 days ago

Which is my best bet…
Bubic, Ray, Ober, Abbott, or stash Kershaw?

Tx, happy friday

Harley Earl
Harley Earl
Reply to  Joe Shlabotnik
15 days ago

Good choices to pick from. I’d go Bubic but I could see Ober for consistency’s sake.

Steveshu
Steveshu
17 days ago

Trade Lindor for Skenes straight up in 12 team Roto with QS and OBP?

Would Acuna be a better match for Skenes in a two for two where Acuna and Brandon Lowe for Skenes and Westburg

Tom Flanagan
Tom Flanagan
17 days ago

Replacing Edman. Perdomo, Josh Smith? Also Maikel Garcia avail. Thanks!

birrrdy
birrrdy
17 days ago

Agnostics. Love it!

Bleacher Bard
Bleacher Bard
Reply to  birrrdy
15 days ago

I’m unsure about it

alecleamas
17 days ago

Josh Smith or Vientos ROS?

Suzanne Vega or Lisa Loeb?

Three root canals on the same day, make out with Carol Burnett (she’s 92) or listen to John Smoltz call a ball game?

Anodyne
Anodyne
17 days ago

Which one of these are you rostering at this time?

David Hamilton
Daniel Schneemann
Marcus Semien
Trey Sweeney
Tyrone Taylor

Last edited 17 days ago by Anodyne
Anodyne
Anodyne
Reply to  Grey
17 days ago

Ha ha! Yeah, I’ve been holding him all season, and he is so so boring. I won’t drop him yet for a schmotato, but I am tempted.

Harley Earl
Harley Earl
Reply to  Anodyne
15 days ago

I let Semien go in my keeper league this year before we drafted after keeping him the previous 8 years. Haven’t regretted that decision one bit. The team that drafted him has, though, lol.

Gregg Jeffries, Future Star
Gregg Jeffries, Future Star
17 days ago

Drop Winn for Josh H?