One Cy Young next year, then two Cy Youngs, then three Cy Youngs in 2029 (by 2029 they’ll be giving out three Cy Youngs per year). Then the Hall of Fame chatter starts up, as he approaches 50 wins, the new benchmark for pitchers. I’m, of course, talking about Hunter Greene. Yesterday, he went 9 IP, 0 ER, 1 hit, 1 walk, 9 Ks, ERA at 2.74. The problem with Greene isn’t much different than other pitchers: Will he stay healthy? There’s no way of knowing. So, where does that get drafted next year? I’d guess in the top 15 starters. Maybe top 20 in more friends and family leagues. Maybe top 10 in March when he’s firing 5 IP, 10 Ks Spring Training starts, and people start getting amped. Ya know who he feels like? Another guy who pitched yesterday: Tarik Skubal. But not Skubal this year, but Skubal the year before it all came together. Remember, Skubal was a 5.63 ERA guy, then a 4.34 ERA guy, then a 3.52 ERA guy, then he threw 2.80 ERA but in only 80 1/3 IP, then Breakout City. That’s where Greene is, knocking on Breakout City’s door. Anyway, here’s what else I saw yesterday in fantasy baseball:
Colin Rea – 7 IP, 1 ER, 4 baserunners, 11 Ks, ERA at 4.10. Putting “Colin Rea struck out 11 batters” through my Make It Make Sense Translator and it spits back out, “Reds can’t make contact.”
Mickey Moniak – 2-for-5, 2 RBIs and his 24th homer, 2nd homer in two games, third homer in three games, fifth homer in four games, 78th homer in a week–He’s out of control! He’s a Moniak! Moniak! And he’s hitting like he’s never hit before! He’s a Moniak! Moniak! Dah, dah, dah, I forget the lyrics. Moniak won’t be in this afternoon’s Buy column, because on the 7-day Player Rater, he’s rostered in over 90% of leagues. If he’s not rostered in your league, then be my guest, be my guest, put something something to the test! I don’t know those lyrics either. I was just thinking, member before the internet and people actually didn’t know the lyrics for songs? Do kids know how lucky they are? We used to have to make up lyrics when we couldn’t decipher them. Here we are now…in containers!
Blaine Crim – 2-for-4 and his 2nd and 3rd homer. Who? Wait, what? Wait, no, who? Blaine Crim is not a person. Blaine Crim is the reason my mom gives for not going into the city anymore.
Yanquiel Fernandez – 2-for-3, 2 runs and his 4th homer. Fun fact! Rick Ankiel flamed out as a pitcher, then Ankiel flamed out as a hitter, and now he’s returned as a Yanquiel.
Otto Lopez – 1-for-5 and his 15th homer, hitting .245. Someone should pull him aside and be like, “Juan Soto stole almost as many bags in August as you have all year. Get it together and run more!”
Sandy Alcantara – 6 2/3 IP, 3 ER, 7 baserunners, 8 Ks, ERA at 5.48. It’s not lost on me how goofy it is that I’m streaming pitchers who are visiting Coors, and having more success than not.
Trevor Story – 2-for-4, 2 runs and his 25th homer. On Wednesday, he was caught stealing for the first time all season. (He has 31 steals). If you drafted Trevor Story and Byron Buxton this year, what’s it like to use your one wish on winning your fantasy league when you could’ve used it to win the lottery? The fantasy league is better? Hell yeah! That’s what I’m saying!
David Hamilton – 1-for-3 and his 5th homer. Only person who could get him out is Aaron Nola Burr.
Brayan Bello – 4 IP, 3 ER, ERA at 3.34. Bello’s September has been more like B.O. Crushed him with my words!
Brent Rooker – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 30th homer. Like a real sicko, I can’t wait to draft multiple SacTown A’s hitters next year. Give me all the Bing Bongs!
J.T. Ginn – 6 IP, 2 ER, 6 baserunners, 3 Ks, ERA at 4.57. Not bad for a guy who Just Throws. Streamonator is actually barely negative on his next start, but I wouldn’t go near him.
Max Fried – 7 IP, 0 ER, 4 baserunners, 13 Ks, ERA at 2.92. Naturally, he’s good, he’s my favorite starter of all-time. [looks around to see if anyone’s buying it, no one is] Fried took on the Sucky O’s, but he’s just lucky Gunnar Henderson isn’t playing this year!
Cade Povich – 5 IP, 3 ER, 9 baserunners (4 BBs), 5 Ks, ERA at 5.06. Ton of traffic on the basepaths, but thankfully he was facing the Yanks who beat you with small ball. Like hitting and running with Giancarlo. Of course, the hitting and running is when he’s on third and hopefully a hit to the gap gets him home, but nevertheless!
Chris Bassitt – 4 1/3 IP, 3 ER, ERA at 3.96 vs. Shane Baz – 5 IP, 0 ER, 3 baserunners, 4 Ks, ERA at 4.99. This matchup was billed as, “Shris Bazit, which sounds like what happens when a Zoomer names a kid.”
Carson Williams – 2-for-4, 2 runs and his 4th homer, hitting .186. Predictably can’t make contact. He hit .213 in Triple-A! Why is he in the majors? Has anyone put that question to the Rays? A team that usually drags their heels on prospects and heeeeeeeeeeere’s Carson making contact like his bat is four times divorced from the ball.
Tanner Bibee – 6 IP, 1 ER, 6 baserunners, 8 Ks, ERA at 4.34. In September, his ERA is 1.24 in 21 2/3 IP with 21 Ks, i.e., why couldn’t Pfaadt and Bibee do this in April, May, June–Well, you know the months! Bibee had a 6.15 ERA in August and July! Seriously, I am asking the Fantasy Baseball Overlord, “Why can’t pitching be normal?” Crickets!
Jose Ramirez – 2-for-5, 2 RBIs and his 29th homer. Went to look at the Player Rater to see where Jo-Jo-Ram was ranked (8th overall) and I spotted the guy right behind him at 9th overall, and I’ll admit to being surprised by him; his name rhymes with Rulio Jodriguez.
Jhonkensy Noel – 2-for-4 and his 5th homer, 2nd homer in three games, but the Guards have played many more games. Big Christmas facing only lefties makes some sense, after those stinking lefties had a War on Christmas!
Tarik Skubal – 6 IP, 1 ER, 9 baserunners, 9 Ks, ERA at 2.23. This start came after he left his last start grabbing at his side. Turns out he was grabbing at nothing, I guess. When one grabs at their side and it’s to show there’s nothing there, it means one thing…How great Ozempic works! This is a sponsored blurb.
Logan Webb – 7 IP, 1 ER, 5 baserunners, 5 Ks, ERA at 3.27. Webb gem!
Yoshinobu Yamamoto – 5 1/3 IP, 0 ER, 7 baserunners (6 BBs), 7 Ks, ERA at 2.58. Six walks to seven Ks? Aw, he was visited by the Ghost of Young Blake Snell and Tyler Glasnow.
Jonah Tong – 5 IP, 0 ER, 4 hits, 8 Ks, ERA at 5.94. Stick out your Tong and say AHHHHH, why couldn’t he do this last time? Sadly, after he demolished my shizz last time out (2/3 IP, 6 ER), I no longer trust him this year. If you want to get back in, you’re on your own.
Brandon Nimmo – 1-for-3, 3 RBIs and his 24th homer. Nimmo found one! (By the way, for those keeping track, Juan Soto (2-for-4, 1 RBI) stole his 33rd bag. Is anyone talking about how he’s so clearly going for a personal achievement? Ya know I love him, but his previous career high in steals was 12. He had 11 in August and has seven steals in September!)
Pete Alonso – 1-for-2, 2 runs, 2 RBIs and his 37th homer, and four homers in four games. Albombso!
Luis Rengifo – 1-for-4, 2 RBIs and his 9th homer, hitting .240. Kinda fitting that most hitters took yesterday off and one of the hitters who didn’t took the rest of the year off.
Yusei Kikuchi – 5 2/3 IP, 2 ER, 8 baserunners, 2 Ks, ERA at 4.05. Yusei having a 4+ ERA on the Angels is actually awesome. That means if he were on the Astros, he’d have a 2.50 ERA. Very impressive!
Quinn Priester – 5 2/3 IP, 2 ER, 5 baserunners, 10 Ks, ERA at 3.25. Just thinking about if the Brewers face the Mariners in the World Series, and we get to hear from Smoltz discussing Priester vs. the Big Keister. Chills. My one big takeaway from yesterday’s pitching performances is most guys check out on Thursdays because it’s getaway day, and guys really check out the next-to-last Thursday of the season.
Stephen Kolek – 7 1/3 IP, 1 ER, 3 baserunners, 8 Ks, ERA at 3.54. Royals’ hitting is anemic, but Streamonator sorta like Kolek’s next start and I do too. I kinda like all his starts, but don’t tell anyone.
Luis Castillo – 6 IP, 0 ER, 3 hits, zero walks, 3 Ks, ERA at 3.63. The Lou Castle got the Royals, a team that has a .298 OBP in September and a 17.2 K%, which seems almost impossible. Hey, if the Royals aren’t striking out or getting on base, is there a secret third thing? Oh, yeah, hitting grounders to 2nd base! The Royals before each game, “I see, I see, so…Just roll over it?” That’s a team meeting as Adam Frazier outlines a game plan on a chalkboard.
Clayton Kershaw – Announced he would retire at the season’s conclusion. 2014 NL MVP, 3x Cy Young, 11x All-Star, 2x World Series Champ, 5x ERA title, 2011 Triple Crown. Career 2.54 ERA is the lowest in the live-ball era for a starter with a minimum of 1,000 innings. I went to one World Series game in my life because they’re so expensive. It was 2017, Astros vs. the Dodgers, and it was Game 1. It happened to be the hottest World Series game in history (103 degrees) and it was the game Clayton Kershaw pitched that was one of the shortest games in World Series history. Also, the Astros were cheating! What a perfect game to spend two grand on! Anyway, he was one of the greatest lefties ever, and one of the greatest starters ever.
THERE’S A NEW POST FOR FOLLOWUPS FOR ME
I would love to hear your thoughts on these minor league guys. We are starting our first year player draft and I would have to drop guys from this list in order to draft new guys this. Do you have any thoughts on this list? Anyone stand out that you would move on from?
Anthony Gutierrez
Drew Gilbert
Cade Horton
Rhett Lowder
Bryce Eldridge
Jac Caglianone
Bryce Rainer
Vance Honeycutt
Tommy White
I don’t know anything about your league….There’s a new post for followups for me…repost this list with more specifics
So Paredes is returning today? I thought he was mulling surgery and his hamstring was basically hanging off of the bone. Funny how a Yordan injury moved up that time table
Ha, yup
h2h season on the line – pick 1 streamer:
Yu @ CHW ($8)
Springs @ PIT ($2)
Yu
Connelly Early
A 2026 top pitcher or forget about him
Could be a top 40 starter
Saw the comment below about Pedro Martinez. Kershaw’s stats are even more impressive when viewed in this light. As a huge fan, his winning % stands out, with fewer than 100 career losses. It’s a shame his playoff luck didn’t match his regular-season dominance. Comparing eras (not ERA) is tough, but unfortunately, discussions about his greatness will always face the “what about the playoffs?” question. That’s unfortunate because he was awesome.
I think the playoffs only stand out for him because he was so awesome…He was merely average in the playoffs…Playoffs also starts talking about small sample sizes etc
Yeah that’s a good point. The fact that he’s still pitching at a high level with an 88 mph fastball after suffering several big injuries is a testament to his greatness
Yeah, kinda remarkable he’s had injuries, but never returned and threw up a 4+ ERA for an extended period of time
Moniak or Adell?
Moniak
Hi Grey,
I always appreciate all your help and patience!
Re: 43 innings left in a 10 team Yahoo Points League
1. Are you still Ok with starting Sprout at Washington?
2. Would you confidently start or sit Rodon at Baltimore?
3. Would you start or sit Darvish at CWS?
4. Connelly Early at TB?
5. Schlittler at Baltimore?
Thanks!!
1. Yes 2. Start 3. Start 4. Start 5. Sit
How would you prioritize the above starts of Sprout, Rodon, Darvish and Early?
Who do you have any real favorites?
I so appreciate all your help!
Rodon, Sproat…Then Early….then Darvish
Hi Grey,
Re: Yahoo Points 10 teams.
I have moved up 3 slots. Thanks
much.
Although I am down to 43 innings, on the last day of the season, you should save one pitcher for the final day, you can go over in innings and get the points. Therefore it makes sense to have multiple pitchers. You can imagine that you get huge swings in both a positive and negative direction.
Which of these pitchers would you take off the WW?
1. Giolitio vs Det
2. Peterson at Miami
3. Jameson Taillon vs St. louis
4. Simeon Woods-Richardson at Phil
5. Michael McGreevy at CHC?
6.Shane Smith at Washington?
7. Ian Seymour at TB?
Thanks for being so hardworking!!
Who is Seymour facing
At TB.
thanks!!
Ian Seymour pitches for the Rays
sorry at Toronto. Great catch
Therefore for reviewing the above list and giving your recommendations!
Much appreciated!!
Stream 1 tomorrow Javier Assad or Logan Allen
Who are they facing?
Assad at Cincy Allen at Minnesota
Allen is safer of the two, neither are good
Hey Grey!
I am with you on Bibee and Pfaadt. ugh.I drafted both of them (using your writeup/advice of course). No worries though, you were just smarter than they were able to perform. They finally came around. lol.
Need your help, please. This is my 1st yr H2H (normally did Roto) and I have 3 days left for playoffs. We are tied 8-8 on pitching side (screenshot attached-I am on the bottom). Opponent has dumped most of his SP staff and loaded up on RP’s.
Hmmm…
10 TM H2H (no Keep)
Here is who they have: (They have 4 moves left)
RP: Chapman,Abreu,Santana,Strahm,Devin Williams,Koenig,Kittredge,Vodnik
SP: Skenes,Sale Yamamoto,Peralta
Of these Peralta is the only scheduled start on Sunday @STL
Here is who I have: (I have 1 move left)
RP:Mason Miller,Duran,Erceg,Akin
SP:
1) Rassmussen vs BOS (16.6) Start?
2) Pablo Lopez vs CLE (30.4) Start?
3) Lodolo vs CHC (9.0) Start?
4) Rodon @ BAL (34.4) obvious start, right?
5) McLean vs WSH (25.6) Start?
6) Sheehan vs SF (34.9) Start?
How do I play this??!!
?
Thanks!
1. Yes 2. Yes 3. Yes 4. Yes 5 yes 5. Yes, why would you sit anyone? I can’t see screenshots
That’s what I was thinking..Thanks! I thought maybe I was missing something and wondering why they went all RP’s…
1 more thing, . my lineup this weekend is
Goodman vs LAA
Pasketti vs TOR
Durbin @ STL
Devers @ LAD
Lindor vs WSH
Wood @ NYM
Arozarena @ HOU
Jeremiah Jackson vs NYY
Ohtani vs SF
since I have 1 move left..I was playing with the BOT (F-S) and it came up with
Tyler Freeman (of,2b) vs LAA
Luis Rengifro (2B,3B) @ COL
Joe Adell (of) @ COL
Would you swap any of these for Durbin or Jackson?
Thanks!
Rengifo over Durbin
Excellent! Thank you! Wish me luck..if this works out I owe you the fanciest Boba you want..lol
Good luck! Haha
Picked up all 3 of these guys over last week. Need to cut one. For what it’s worth, they all got much cooler once I added them. Lile, bader, hays, who goes? 9 games left for all 3. Thanks
Hays
I would have guessed that Pedro had a better career ERA than Kershaw, but it is not even close. Pedro was better during his years in Boston (2.52) but those seasons with the Mets and Phillies did some damage to the career stats.
Yeah, totally, I thought the same thing
12 team dynasty 5×5 was offered CJ Abrams and Jarren Duran for James Woods…thoughts…I have Adames at short now with Sebastian Walcott waiting in the wings… thank you!
Abrams side, it’s fair
Fried had a CSW of 48% last night. Incredible. I guess he still has one more start before his arm falls off? Day of Atonement is coming and someone can ask for forgiveness. He could be sitting next to you if it’s an off day. Nobody is like Sandy anymore.
Speaking of Dodger lefties, Clayton is not just one of the best pitchers in the game ever, but also one of the classiest to ever play the game.
Fried’s wheels i’m never going to fall off apparently
Greene’s top 5 gem gives Cincinnati 9 entries on the 100 Best Fantasy Starts list. Add Fried’s and September has seen 5 of the top 20!
4 Tanner Bibee (CLE) Sep 12 vs CHW
5 Hunter Greene (CIN) Sep 18 vs CHC
7 Kyle Freeland (COL) Sep 5 vs SD
9 Kevin Gausman (TOR) Sep 11 vs HOU
19 Max Fried (NYY) Sep 18 @BAL
Last year there were no top 20 starts in September (Brandon Pfaadt had #21 September 19 @MIL).
Incredible. Thanks for all your work Vin. Your comments are the best.
Thank you!
Top 5? Wow, I didn’t expect it to be that good, I figured they weren’t enough strikeouts…rea would’ve got the win, he would’ve made it somewhere in the top 100 right?
It would have been right around 100, because of the 1 earned run. A start with that line but 0 earned runs is #45.
Ah, gotcha!
Grey!!!!
Awesome!!
Have a great weekend!!!
Rodney Dangerfield quote of the day for September 19, 2025
You know what real class is? That’s when you’re alone and you fart and you say “Excuuuuse me.” That’s class.
Kids these so smart. Yesterday I told my son about the birds and the bees, he told me about my wife and the butcher! No respect.
– No Respect (1980)
Cheers,
Ante
Something seems oddly familiar about this one… REPOST!
ROFLROFLROFLROFLROFLRFO!!!
Live by the copy paste, die by the copy paste
LOL
Thanks! You too!
Ok so I’m down to my last two adds, and need a couple of starters for Sunday. The league championship could depend on them and they’re not great! Who ya got? It’s a QS league FWIW…
Holmes v WSH: 18.4 on the SON
Ed-Rod v SF: 10.9
Cantillo @ MIN: 0.2
Burrows v OAK: -2.9
Simeon W-R v CLE: -3.7
Latz v MIA: -6.5
Thanks!
(already grabbed Cantillo so need one more!)
Ok
Cantillo, Holmes
I thought we were doing Anthony’s Song for Moni-yak yak yak yak, you outta know by now.
Need Judge, Acuna, Elly, Wood, Kurtz to play like they are capable this weekend. 5 HR, 2SB, and a .350 OBP for this squad over a weekend used to be routine. Now it’s laughably unfathomable.
Baseball season is just too long for modern players. I think World Series should be wrapping up right now, for the good of the game, make Grey commish tomorrow.
Oh yeah! His name rhymes with every song, damn… I need to be the commissioner by tomorrow