LOGIN

This Buzzfeed quiz will tell you which Pixar character you’re most like, whether it’s the old man from Up, the dad from The Incredibles, Buzz Lightyear, Anxiety from Inside Out, one of those fishes they lost, that character voiced by Billy Crystal or Pete Crow-Armstrong. Okay, here goes! Question 1) You currently have a low BABIP for your speed with an excellent strikeout rate for a rookie. You don’t walk a ton, but you are starting to appear way more like a .250 hitter, at worst. Question 2) You’re not actually a Pixar character but the outfielder for the Cubs, who has 50-steal speed and is around the top outfielder on the 7-Day Player Rater and almost as high on the 30-day Player Rater. In the last 30 days, you’re hitting near-.300 and showing a 162-game pace of 25/50, which gives me a Buzz, is Incredible, makes my Anxiety go Up if I don’t roster Pete Crow-Armstrong, but don’t worry all fish is not lost, ya filthy Monster. Question 3) There’s no Question 3. [adds up the answers to the Quiz] Says here I’m Brandon Nimmo. Did I forget to carry a one somewhere? Well, whatever the case, grab Pete Crow-Armstrong. Now, this week’s other picks are…. Anyway, here’s some more players to Buy or Sell this week in fantasy baseball:

SIKE! This post was released on Wednesday for Patreon members. It will be released all year early for Patreons, so if people are getting a jump on you, it’s because they paid the $10. Anyway, the Fantasy Baseball Buy/Sell:

BUY

Miguel Amaya – Promise this week’s Buy column won’t be all Cubs. Though, I can’t promise you a Panda either. Wistful, “I wish I could twitch my nose and make Pablo Sandoval appear.” Any hoo! Amaya’s been hot, but I looked at his MLB numbers so far in his career and you don’t need to release the hounds to let out a woof.

Jhonkensy Noel – This December I might give you a Jhonkensy Noel sleeper every day of the month. Like an advent calendar of sleepers. Like any self-hating Jew, I love Big XMas!

Spencer Torkelson – In 2022, he had a 110-game season with eight homers and this year he might end up with possibly less homers. And you’re wondering why I’m not excited about him, in general!

Geraldo Perdomo – Here’s a thing that is 100% true: Once the DBags lost Christian Walker then Ketel Marte, they became the 1927 DBags and scored 17 runs per game, so everyone became valuable.

Connor Norby – What’s interesting (to me), Norby went from the O’s to the Marlins and people seemed to have cooled on Norby completely. Edwards is hurt, and Norby is leading off and hot. If he were leading off and hot for the O’s, people would be insane for him, so what’s the difference? In the last 30 days, Marlins are .245/.314/.405 as a team, and the O’s are .252/.324/.426. So, what are you missing with Norby on Marlins vs. O’s? Three runs and five RBIs? Wow.

Zach McKinstry – Grabbing him off waivers with DJ LeMahieu and renaming my team McKinstry of Sound as I come in 11th out of 12 teams.

Spencer Horwitz – Between Horwitz and Clement, the Jays are going for the most bleh contact in baseball. Just killing it with 88 MPH plops over the 2nd baseman’s head.

Ernie Clement – If Hard Contact% is tomatoes, then Clement’s weak contact is gonna ketchup to him.

Daniel Schneemann – From Horwitz to Ernie to Schneemann is the Tinker to Evers to Chance in a softball league with all actuaries.

Addison Barger – ACKSUALLY a Jays’ hitter who isn’t all weak-sauce contact that would be clocked in a school zone for going too slow. Barger looks interesting for this week, and in dynasty, if you’re thinking that way.

MJ Melendez – Michael Jordan Melendez sounds like someone just naming current events in the early 90’s. Like if AJ Puk was short for Azerbai Jan Pukindependence.

Matt Wallner – I may never write a Twins sleeper post, because they’re all excellent but for only 20 games at a time. Twins’ hitting is like one giant relay race.

JJ Bleday – Just gave you a Lawrence Butler and JJ Bleday fantasy. A sumptuous post for the intellectuals.

Trevor Larnach – Twins are the exact opposite of the Jays’ hitters in this post. They’re all Hard Contact guys who might not be playing by Sunday.

Grant McCray – Never seen a team like the Giants. Every week, they cryogenically unfreeze Ted Williams’s head, screw it onto a prospect no one has heard of, and make them a star.

Parker Meadows – 15-ish homers, 30-ish steals and around a .250 average if you combine his Triple-A and MLB numbers this year when all is said and done. You’re gonna make me do silly things next year, aren’t you?

Jonny DeLuca – He’s been hot, good for speed, so this isn’t about that. Went to look at his offensive WAR and he’s a -10, which, as you can imagine, is not good. So that got me curious: Who were the worst this year? That list is pretty hilariously bad: Verdugo, Benintendi, Heim, but one interesting one: Bryan De La Cruz. Guess having a ~.280 OBP can hurt your value a smidge.

Joey Loperfido – Is there something in the air in Canada that makes the ball stop traveling forward? Another guy with a bunch of 88 MPH exit velocity doinkers. Too young to write him off, but [readies pen and pad] he’s 25, so let’s go, time’s a-wastin’!

Matthew Boyd – This is a Streamonator call, like the call it makes to the deli.

Cody Bradford – This is also a Streamonator call. “I’m calling to speak to the meat slicer. No, not the person slicing the meat.”

Tyler Holton – Could be in-line for Tigers saves, and a new elbow tendon. Just went to look at Holton’s stats and my arm hurt for him. He had 85 1/3 IP last year in 59 appearances and 75 2/3 IP this year in 52. He should join Scott Proctor’s class action lawsuit.

Michael Kopech – If you were to ask Dave Roberts who his closer is, he might say Kopech or Phillips or say some combo of both, but in reality what is going on his head is: [tumbleweed rolls through]

Porter Hodge – Two things: Hodge rocks in his own right and he absolutely might not get saves. Sadly, the first thing is affecting the 2nd. Because he’s so good, the Cubs are not giving him every opportunity so his arbitration price doesn’t go up. Great system MLB’s got figured out here. Teams are incentivized to not use their best players.

Edwin Uceta – Good news is Uceta is a free agent, so not sure it matters if he gets saves as far as his price for the Rays goes. Bad news, Kevin Cash has never committed any role to any player ever. He’s had Siri for three years and he’s still not sure what to do with him. Sometimes he presses his head and asks him the nearest place to get an oil change.

SELL

Kyle Tucker – On this day in 1775, a man was hit by musket fire and lost his leg. He returned to action faster than Kyle Tucker. This is what happened to Tucker in layman’s terms: You bump into the edge of your coffee table and miss the next three months of work. Earth to Kyle Tucker, do you still exist? If Tucker magically appears again, what are you going to get from him in the final month if he is reinstated from the IL? 3 HRs, .260? You can get that from most of the guys in this post. If he returns from the IL (that “if” is the size of Antartica), that’ll be when you’re gonna need to drop him. If you’re in a dynasty league, then I wouldn’t trade Tucker for “the hottest panang curry you have” at a Thai restaurant, but I would go to our Fantasy Baseball Trade Analyzer and explore options.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

161 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
subs81
subs81
1 month ago

NL 260 Deep league. $5 raise yearly so these are 2025 salaries.
Playing for next year and beyond.
Should I Trade away $20 P.Skenes, ( TOP PITCHER usually GOES FOR LOW 30’s- 29ish), for a $2 Crews ?

J.R.
J.R.
1 month ago

Gotta love a league im in.

Guy offers me BRodgers + Cubs bullpen arm circus Lopez I think (wasnt Porter) for Doyle.

I counter with J. Smith + OHearn for BRod + some prospect (just has cool name not highly touted).

He declines with comment.”I only want Doyle”.

I say well then send a real offer for him.

He then goes on a rant saying how it was an opener and if I wanted him I would have sent a big counter. …….but he sent the initial offer for Doyle. Why would I send a big counter if I have the better side?!

Now he is ranting in our league chat how I am a jerk and how people dont send fair offers and dont want to listen to him talk.

I feel like a car salesman who was told by a prospective costumer that I can keep the car. Uh…okay?

Screenshot_20240901-195850
sll
sll
1 month ago

Please rank: Ward, Fitzgerald, and Wallner

sll
sll
Reply to  sll
1 month ago

Also Perdomo

Braves123
Braves123
1 month ago

Vientos or Tena?

Braves123
Braves123
Reply to  Braves123
1 month ago

Or camineiro

Brownie
Brownie
1 month ago

Lane Thomas or Gurriel ROS. Need HR, runs and rbi

Jamie
Jamie
1 month ago

Looking for final FAAB tomorrow. Need RBI and runs. Please rank Brandon Marsh, Ramon Laureano and Derek HIll ROS.

Dancin Homer
1 month ago

Morning & Happy National No Rhyme Nor Reason Day!

You still holding onto Bednar in a 12-team 6×6 (QS & OPS) league that doesn’t count holds?

If dropped, I could either grab Hodge or stream a SP. My only other closers are Devin Williams & Joyce.

Thanks as always

Herschel
Herschel
1 month ago

@Grey: weekly roto redraft. Need wins and k’s most. Need to start two of the following. Who do you like?

Bido – vs sea, vs det
Wacha – cvs cle, can min
H Brown – @ cin
Woo – @ oak
Francis – vs phi

Thanks!

Bad Mother Tucker
Bad Mother Tucker
1 month ago

12 team, 5×5 roto.

Which stream do you prefer?

Gore @Mia ($17.3)
C. Sanchez @Tor ($8.7)
Rea v. Stl ($4.1)

VinWins
VinWins
1 month ago
VinWins
VinWins
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Haha, nice. 3 more than 2nd best. You also had 70 home runs, which was top 10.

VinWins
VinWins
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

No, you were runner-up for Team of the Month. You beat out 526 teams!

VinWins
VinWins
1 month ago

Jose Berrios almost became the first pitcher this season to have 5 straight 7+ IP with 2 or fewer ERs. But with the big lead, the Jays pulled him after 6.

granvillehouston
granvillehouston
1 month ago

Hi Grey,

No strategy questions today.

I was thinking about closers still playing w potential hall of fame careers.

Hanley Jansen and Aroldis Chapman—would you vote either in?

LittleJerrySeinfeld
LittleJerrySeinfeld
Reply to  granvillehouston
1 month ago

Kimbrel

granvillehouston
granvillehouston
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Dodgers fan here. Hanley has his supporters. Chapman from afar seemed a problem.

granvillehouston
granvillehouston
Reply to  granvillehouston
1 month ago

Really important is that I didn’t play fantasy baseball five yrs ago except once, but ten years ago. Pure tv fan whatever was on

Last edited 1 month ago by granvillehouston
J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  granvillehouston
1 month ago

Clase has 151 saves at 26. 1.73 ERA and sub 1 WHIP.

Has half the saves of Chapman and 1/3 of Jansen.

VinWins
VinWins
1 month ago

Nice numbers from your Streamonator calls: 13 IP/8 BR(0 BB)/3 ER/16 K.

VinWins
VinWins
1 month ago

Zebby 5 Ks in 2 IP!!

Dude
Dude
Reply to  VinWins
1 month ago

Way to be positive!

J.R.
J.R.
1 month ago

Give up Bregman + Vierling or J. Smith + Caissie for Steer? Dynasty 18 teamer 6×6

Last edited 1 month ago by J.R.
Scott
Scott
1 month ago

Grey,

I have Wheeler and Froed going head to head for me. Do i start them both? Sit both? Start only one? Thasnks as always

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Scott
1 month ago

Why not both? How are you doing this week? Format?

Scott
Scott
Reply to  J.R.
1 month ago

i made my innings and winning this week 17-12-1 but trail a couple of pitching categories ( QS and ERA ). I have wheeler in, but am on the fence with Fried

Scott
Scott
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

ok thanks

hondo
hondo
1 month ago

Looks like they’re resting Muncie against LHP.
Mayo getting called up tomorrow.
Which do you prefer?

hondo
hondo
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

TY

Lets Play Two
Lets Play Two
1 month ago

Saves + Holds league

Uceta or Jax

daze
daze
1 month ago

Grey
1) Which SP for next week
Bido @ home vs Seattle, @ home Detroit
Bello @ Mets, Home vs CHW
Festa @ TB, @ KC
2) Abreu or Melendez

Bat Flip
Bat Flip
1 month ago

Was looking for a big game from Kirby against Angels and blew it.

Curious…Your Mariners SP rankings for last month?

Gilbert
Miller
Woo
Kirby

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

what happened to Kirby? I had his as 1A to Gilbert 1B and now he is a 1D or something in that rotation. Also, was spared 11 ER that one game.

Perfect Game
Perfect Game
1 month ago

Which side ROS

1. Julio or Fitz
2. Seager or Devers (shoulders)
3. Seager or Harper (power and RBI non-existent last month

I need both HR and SB

Perfect Game
Perfect Game
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Tha is Grey.

Would you rank Devers above or below Harper?

RATManfred
RATManfred
1 month ago

Time to eat your Juli-O’s. He’s back baby!

VinWins
VinWins
1 month ago

Willson Contreras is still a top 12 catcher on the Player Rater:

RANK………………………….(ADP)
18 William Contreras MIL (121)
32 Salvador Perez KC (192)
68 Yainer Diaz HOU (167)
87 Cal Raleigh SEA (204)
103 Adley Rutschman BAL(58)
130 Tyler Stephenson CIN (2 DRAFTS)

153 Will Smith LAD (103)
164 Ryan Jeffers MIN (ND)
177 Shea Langeliers OAK (ND)
185 Connor Wong BOS (ND)
215 Logan O’Hoppe LAA (223)
250 Willson Contreras STL (241)

ADP is from RCL drafts March 17 – 27.
4 of the 12 were drafted in 2 or fewer leagues.

VinWins
VinWins
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Yeah, must be nice choosing a catcher in the 22nd round that you can ride all the way. As for Jeffers, that’s your fault. You didn’t rank him high enough!

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  VinWins
1 month ago

Yeah I know, cool story bro incoming shut up I know.

For whatever reason my league has a negative attitude to C. Prevailing attitude is why pay for it when I can get it for free. I get it. However they stick to their “guy” because all the same and just wait until he gets hurt or SO awful they pick someone up.

So in 18 team dynasty I had Raleigh and Diaz. I moved Silseth+Raleigh after early heater in April for Neto+W. Castro.

I then go pick up Langeliers because I guess the sub .200 avg scared them? He was riding the Campusano train until it derailed. Need a CF and trade for Vierling. Meh trade but gave up nothing really.

Traded with a guy who had Stephenson on bench behind Rutschmann and this was June I think so Stephenson was hitting .230ish with 6 HR. I send him Donovan + Castro for Stephenson + M. Parker.

Stephenson gets hot in 2nd half and guy lost his C so I moved him at beginning of month for Happ because lost my LF.

TL;DR my league has a market inefficiency on C. Will laugh in your face on offers, then when theirs gets hurt or really sucks they will happily pay for an upgrade. Before season best offer I got on Raleigh was Drury or Beintendi.

VinWins
VinWins
Reply to  J.R.
1 month ago

In the shallow RCLs, lots of us drop a catcher whenever he’s out of the lineup. Though, when everyone was dropping Willson Contreras when he was injured I added him everywhere and just kept him until he got injured again. Much different than an 18-team league though.

Smell The Glove
Smell The Glove
1 month ago

I am in 10 team league. 5×5 and in 1st place in HR, RBI, Runs and 2nd in SB thanks to your advice.

I have Neto, Witt, Turang, Semien and Rafaela at 2B, SS and MI.

Am I crazy to consider dropping Semien for Josh Lowe for remainder of season and play him at Util since Semien doesn’t have a spot any longer on my active roster?

Chucky
Chucky
1 month ago

Haven’t heard much MVP chatter from the Gunnar Henderson fan club. Quite possibly I might have been absent that day?

J.R.
J.R.
1 month ago

Josh Naylor added to Tucker barrel roll me to 1st squad. Just Marte’d his ankle.

https://bdata-producedclips.mlb.com/abc75f7d-94fa-4d75-9dc5-fb1bf2523584.mp4

matt
matt
1 month ago

is there a world where it makes sense to move Yainer to 1B and pick up Wells for C?

other 1B options are Busch, Toglia, Paredes, Jones, N Lowe

trying to fill in for Vin P

6×6 OPS

thanks Grey!

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  matt
1 month ago

Id rather have Diaz at C and Toglia at 1B. Im biased having both.

matt
matt
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

thank you both!

RATManfred
RATManfred
1 month ago

10 team H2H keeper league SP question. Bryce Miller, G. Crochet, or S. Strider?

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  RATManfred
1 month ago

to keep? just one?

RATManfred
RATManfred
Reply to  J.R.
1 month ago

Yes, just one. My tenth keeper; keep ten.

Last edited 1 month ago by RATManfred
RATManfred
RATManfred
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Thank you

J.R.
J.R.
1 month ago

I really cant stand the Diamondbacks logo or color scheme. At least one felt unique. Then again I liked the black and teal Marlins ones too. Always feels like stole a 1/3 from 3 different teams and put together. Plus MLB.com loves to put it next to the Angels logo for some reason.

Screenshot_20240830-190640
J.R.
J.R.
1 month ago

Hinds with 0 starts even with a doubleheader and 1 pinch hit AB. Makes 0 sense.

Last edited 1 month ago by J.R.
Play Ball
Play Ball
1 month ago

Gunnar in CO or Fitzgerald @ home against MIA.

Neither has been hitting that great the last couple weeks. I need HR & SB.

Lets Play Two
Lets Play Two
1 month ago

Please list these in order – 6×6 Roto redraft league using average and on base %.

PCA, Fitz, Butler

J.R.
J.R.
1 month ago

“Each day, perhaps for the rest of the season, Astros manager Joe Espada is going to make multiple lineups: One will have Alex Bregman playing third base, another will have him at designated hitter and another will have him at first base – a position he hasn’t played since summer ball in high school.

Which lineup Espada decides to hand over to the umpire will depend on how Bregman tells him he’s feeling earlier in the day.”

*Looks for Bregman at third, first, DH, and then sees Bregman not in lineup tonight.* Hey that wasnt an option!

Last edited 1 month ago by J.R.
J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Lmao then he dumps after contact and tells him to barrel roll to 1st.

J.R.
J.R.
1 month ago

What do you think of Kim + Keller + Peterson for Salvy + J. Smith (TX) + McCarthy?

18 teamer dynasty 6×6

Last edited 1 month ago by J.R.
J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Thanks! Been sitting on it and agree with you just needed a nudge to hit accept.

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Would you then flip J Smith for B Lowe?

Duda Want to Build a Snowman?
Duda Want to Build a Snowman?
1 month ago

Batty call for tonight – Fitzgerald against a terrible MIA 5.23 ERA pitcher (but down to 6th spot) or Soler v Ranger Suarez?

Need any/all production but especially obp, ops, runs, HR and SB (everything besides rbi)

Weird Fishes
Weird Fishes
1 month ago

In a single category that counts saves and hold equally, who do you like to get the most saves or holds this weekend – Faucher (@SF) or either Garrett or Maton (@CHW). FWIW, relievonator likes Garrett. Do you go with relievonator for these kinds of decisions? Thanks!

toolshed
1 month ago

Lugo at Houston? 12 team roto? Why can’t he get the white Sox? HIs matchups in aug have been awful.

random boners
random boners
1 month ago

Marmol says Walker is gonna play everyday……Sure he is.

Russ
Russ
1 month ago

Hey Grey, I have a bye locked up for the upcoming week, who’s the cut for a streaming spot?

Arrighetti
Francis
Verlander
Schwellenbach

Matchups, or is there a clear cut?

Thanks!

martinrostoker
martinrostoker
1 month ago

Great follow up question about number of starts

How would you prioritize this list if you had to pick 5 starts. How you prioritize the five?

1. Zach Wheeler at home vs Atlanta
2. Cole Ragans at Hou
3. DJ Hertz at home vs CHC
4. Cortes at home vs St. louis
5. Manaea at CWS
6. Jack Flaherty at AZ
7. Schwellenbach at Phil

I so appreciate all your help!

Have a great weekend!

martinrostoker
martinrostoker
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Thanks so much!

Tom
Tom
1 month ago

Safe to assume you like PCA over Wallner? H2H categories, so I’m looking for overall contribution.

toolshed
1 month ago

Kyle tucker? Never heard of him

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

You guys are so pessemistic! Negative Nancys! Look at this report. He has worked up to being able to write encouraging text messages! Might be able to write a novel about how he lost the ability to walk.

“Tucker did not accompany the Astros on this two-city, seven-game road trip. On Sunday afternoon, manager Joe Espada said “there is nothing new to report” about Tucker’s progress back in Houston.

“He actually sent me a very long, long, long text message and it was full of a lot of positive notes,” Espada added, “so that was very encouraging.”

September starts in six days. On Sunday, Espada confirmed Tucker is still not sprinting at full speed, nor has he tested himself running the bases. Until he does, a minor-league rehab assignment won’t be realistic.

Brown has already said Tucker will have to manage some amount of pain upon his return. That Tucker continues to take batting practice and throw without issues is encouraging, perhaps prompting wonder if Tucker could return sooner in a more limited capacity.”

Last edited 1 month ago by J.R.
J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

“just help me get upright in batter’s box. oh and you can have a pinch runner from the box right? A ghost runner like in extras? Great! I am 100%!”

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

“Roll like a barrel or roll like sonic the hedgehog?”

Last edited 1 month ago by J.R.
Ben Shelley
Ben Shelley
1 month ago

Need to cut 1 to activate IL sp….
Bido
Krawford
Francis

Thinking Cutter Krawford is the cut. At 155+ innings but worried Bido or Francis get shut down?

Last edited 1 month ago by Ben Shelley
BBBHHI
BBBHHI
1 month ago

Grey,

ROS: Pepiot or Verlander

Thank you! Happy Labor Day!

Curt C
Curt C
1 month ago

Pick up Jordan Walker in a 6×6 for Jung, the Detroit one?

Curt C
Curt C
Reply to  Curt C
1 month ago

Dynasty league

Coconut Willie
Coconut Willie
1 month ago

IKF or Norby 12 team weekly 6×6

Coconut Willie
Coconut Willie
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

I was too slow… how about McKinstry instead for IKF?

patdaddy1985
patdaddy1985
1 month ago

Ok dropping abrams for pca shallow points?

Steven
Steven
1 month ago

Start or sit them today?

Gausman @Min

Lugo @HOU

Steven
Steven
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Which one do you think is more likely to get a QS? Really the only pitching stat I need.

Steven
Steven
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Ok thanks grey!

The Wild Card
The Wild Card
1 month ago

Would you add McKinstry, Horwitz, or Schneemann over Semien at 2B?

Which would you cut out of Burger or Vientos for a SP?

Josh Freeman
Josh Freeman
1 month ago

Oh great Grey,

I can only start 2 of these. Based on these match-ups, who ya got?

Bassitt PHI; NYM; STL
Bibee @KC; @Chw; TB
Kirby @Oak; SD; TX
Morton COL; CIN; LAD
Rodon @TX; KC; BOS

granvillehouston
granvillehouston
1 month ago

Happ or Armstrong ROS?

10 team league that counts R, HR, RBI, SB, K, OBP, SLG.