LOGIN

Click here to see the Top 25 Prospects For 2024 Dynasty Fantasy Baseball.

Click here to see #26-50 in the Top 50 Prospects For 2024 Dynasty Fantasy Baseball.

51. Cubs 1B Michael Busch | 26 | MLB | 2024

Please clap for Busch’s slash line of .323/.431/.618 with 27 home runs across 98 Triple-A games in 2023. Now that he’s out of Los Angeles and being all but handed the first base gig in Chicago, he can finally stop faking second base and fully flower as a hitter. Or so goes the thinking that led the Cubs to acquire him, anyway. 

52. Padres SS Leodalis De Vries | 17 | NA | 2028

A switch hitter with power, speed and polish on both sides of the ball, De Vries signed for $4.2 million as the most hyped international teenage signing since Jasson Dominguez. He’s listed at 6’2” 183 lbs and should be able to avoid some of the body problems that pepper conversations circling Dominguez. He’s been selected 18th, 16th and 10th in the first-year-player drafts I’ve done this winter. Two of those picks (16,10) were my own.

53. Mariners SS Colt Emerson | 18 | A | 2027

After the success of Cole Young, the Mariners went for a similar prospect at the 22 spot in the 2023 draft: Colt Emerson is a left-handed hitting middle infielder at 6’1” 195 lbs with excellent hands in the batter’s box. In 24 games across two levels, he slashed .379/.496/.549 with two home runs, ten doubles, 20 strikeouts and 17 walks. He went ninth overall in the Razz30 Supplemental Draft that just got underway. 

54. Cubs LHP Shota Imanaga | 30 | NPB | 2024

A classic crafty, composed lefty who’s been great since 2018, Imanaga will make a nice gift for dynasty contenders seeking innings near the back of their drafts partly because I think he’ll be a contributor in the increasingly difficult wins category. 

55. Rays RHP Shane Baz | 24 | MLB | 2021 

I’m not sure where to put Baz, who’s been gone so long I totally forgot about him while doing Tampa’s top ten prospects. He was great for 13 innings (three starts) at the end of 2021 then bad for 27 innings (six starts) in 2022. He hasn’t pitched since July 10th of that year. He technically burned through his rookie eligibility that year on time served, but he’s at 40.1 career major league innings, so he’s under our cutoff of 50. He’s been mostly a fastball-slider guy to this point but mixes in the occasional curve and change. When he’s right, his main offerings are easily plus and his side dishes are at least average. Tampa, and the game itself, is in a different place now than it was just two years ago, so it’ll be fascinating to see if Baz comes back looking like he did when he left. He’s too low here if he’s 100 percent healthy heading into the season, but it’d be presumptuous to predict that. 

56. Diamondbacks OF Druw Jones | 20 | A | 2026

A shoulder injury has limited Jones to just 41 games since he was drafted 2nd overall in 2022, but he started making good late in the summer, slashing .339/.438/.500 with two home runs and six steals over his final 16 games. Don’t let him fall too far down your lists this winter, particularly if you’re in a startup draft. Feels like he’ll be a real value in those this year.

57. Yankees C Austin Wells | 24 | MLB | 2023 

A thick lefty bat who lifts the ball with ease, Wells is a nice fit for his home ballpark. Teams are going to test him on the base paths, but Wells isn’t a total pushover back there and should get plenty of time to improve as long as his bat makes him a viable option. He’s a nice option in OBP leagues after popping four home runs in 19 MLB games in 2023 and recording walk rates better than ten percent for most of his baseball life.

58. Rays SS Carson Williams | 20 | AAA | 2024

If Caminero can’t handle the six on defense and Walls can’t clear the bar on offense, Carson Williams will be waiting in the wings. He was sent to Triple-A after just six games in Double-A but could open the year back there considering he hit .077 with a 40 percent strikeout rate during his four games in Durham. He’d struck out at a 31.8 percent clip in 105 High-A games, so the swing and miss comes as no surprise. Making consistent contact is the only thing Williams hasn’t done on a ball field, where his double-plus defense and easy power will make him a starter sooner than later. He hit 23 homers and stole 17 bags in those 105 High-A games and might even make a run at the job in spring training if he can keep improving the plate skills that were on an upward trajectory in 2023. 

59. Rays 3B Curtis Mead | 23 | MLB | 2023

Mead can help the fanbase forget some old infielders if he plays in the majors like he did in Triple-A in 2023, slashing .294/.385/.515 with nine home runs and four stolen bases in 61 games. His calling card has been plate skills, and that held true at the top minor league level with a 12.6-to-17.3 walk-to-strikeout rate. It’s not easy to see how he fits into the lineup early this year outside of a short-side platoon, but if he hits in small doses, something will probably pour his way. 

60. Twins SS Brooks Lee | 23 | AAA | 2024

A high-floor switch-hitter with a lot of college experience, Lee went eighth overall in the 2022 draft and played his way to Double-A in his draft season. He played just two games there last year and another 87 this year, slashing .292/.365/.476 with 11 home runs and six steals. With Jorge Polanco out of town, Lee gets an up-arrow next to his name even though the move more directly benefits Edouard Julien.  

61. Braves RHP Hurston Waldrep | 22 | AAA | 2024

With the name of a 19th century oil baron and the arsenal of a high-end big league pitcher, Hurston Waldrep represented a nice windfall for Atlanta with the 24th overall pick in this summer’s draft. His delivery borders on relievery, but a double-plus fastball/split-change combo helped him carve his way to Triple-A in half a minor league season. Atlanta has been rushing its young arms for a while as they try to supplement their world-beating offense, so Waldrep should be on the shortlist for an early promotion. Might even have a shot to make the team in spring training. He signed for a few hundred thousand under his draft slot value, and you know this team loves that.

62. Cubs OF Kevin Alcantara | 21 | AA | 2024

Played 95 games with High-A South Bend, slashing .286/.341/.466 with 12 home runs and 15 stolen bases then continued to produce in Double-A and the fall league, where he’s tied for third in the league with five home runs. At 6’6” with plus power and speed, the possibility of him actualizing in his early twenties is enticing. Wouldn’t be surprised to see him get traded. If Crow-Armstrong looks like a long-term solution and the club re-signs Cody Bellinger, that’s the outfield as long as they have Seiya Suzuki.

63. Rays OF Jonny DeLuca | 25 | MLB | 2023

One thing you can say about the Tyler Glasnow (and Manny Margot) trade: it should work out better than that slapdick Blake Snell trade for Francisco Mejia, Xavier Edwards, Blake Hunt, and Luis Patiño. Having multiple outs did not help that time, but it should help to have Jonny DeLuca along with Ryan Pepiot this time around. A 5’11” 196 lb right handed hitter, DeLuca controls the zone well and has never struck out more than 20 percent of the time in eight stints across six leagues and has typically walked at roughly a ten percent clip. In addition to the plate skills, DeLuca has always produced power and speed. He hit 19 home runs and stole 13 bases in 97 games across three levels in 2023 and will be a fantasy factor if he can crack this lineup. 

64. Mariners SS Cole Young | 20 | A+ | 2025

A left-handed hitter with middle-infield athleticism on defense and a plus hit tool on offense, Young was selected 21st overall in 2022 and has cruised through three levels in 143 games since, slashing .286/.402/.456 with 13 home runs and 26 steals. He’s an easy eval on the eyes as it doesn’t take much to see his swing and think “oh that looks good.” Also has the arm to make up for a split second here or there on defense.  

65. Diamondbacks OF Kristian Robinson | 23 | AA | 2024

If I’m being honest with my bedroom mirror, Robinson is my favorite prospect right now. I liked him a lot the first time I saw him swing and run, but my allegiance now is mostly due to the road he’s walked to get here. Legal and mental troubles cost him three full seasons of work, but he returned to the field this year looking much like his former self, flashing impressive power (14 HR in 65 G) and speed (23 SB) across four levels, peaking with a deep Double-A playoff push that saw him homering on an almost daily basis. There’s extreme upside here as he’s finally got the runway to focus on his game all winter so he can start fast in spring.

66. Mariners C Harry Ford | 21 | A+ | 2025

The 12th overall pick in 2021, Ford has moved through the minor league assembly line with ease, posting an on base percentage of .400 or better at every level. His High-A slash line of .257/.410/.430 across 118 games isn’t the most impressive card-back we’ve seen, but he was young for the level and got better throughout the season after a slow start. His primary appeal for our game might be unique speed catcher. He’s swiped 23 and 24 bases the past two seasons, respectively, and has wheels enough to lose a step or two and remain a threat. In that same Razz30 Supp Draft, Ford got traded for the 22nd pick, which was used to select Chase Davis. I prefer Ford by a pretty wide margin there. 

67. Red Sox C Kyle Teel | 22 | AA | 2024

You may remember Kyle Teel from such draft picks as The Royals’ in 2023, when they passed on the college-tested shade of blue for high school catcher Blake Mitchell, who they could sign for a million dollars below slot value. While Mitchell was hitting .143 in 13 games on the complex, Teel was proving to be the real deal, burning through Boston’s system w wRC+ outcomes of 246, 166 and 167 in short stints in the complex than at High-A and Double-A. What he doesn’t offer in speed and topside for the dynasty game he makes up for in proximity and predictability. Teel really knows himself as a hitter and might look like a major league option in spring training because he controls the zone so well.

68. Orioles OF Colton Cowser | 24 | MLB | 2024

Cowser saw 77 plate appearances in 26 major league games in 2023 and looked thoroughly overmatched, slashing .115/.286/.148 with a 28.6 percent strikeout rate. I’ve never been on board with Cowser for our game relative to the field, so I’ve never come anywhere near having him on a fantasy team, but he simply can’t be that bad if given some real runway. He struggled to adjust to Triple-A the first time through (.219 batting average in 27 games) but slashed .300/.417/.520 with 17 home runs and nine stolen bases in 87 games there in 2023. A lefty swinger at 6-3 195 lbs, Cowser should be a nice fit for that ballpark and feels like a decent buy low for redraft leagues. I still won’t have him anywhere, for what it’s Weurtz. Little bit of a confirmation bias thing. Little bit of a front-foot swinger thing. Baltimore doesn’t seem to mind that type, but I tend to look past those guys because I think hip-snap efficacy and repeatability are among the biggest deciders of major league success. They’ve been working on his base, and maybe he’ll find something that works for him. I just don’t like how it looked last year. 

69. Guardians RHP Daniel Espino | 23 | AA | 2024

Talent is not a question here. Espino’s stuff is top shelf. Trouble is he threw just 18.1 innings in 2022 before injuries (knee and shoulder) ended his season. The shoulder injury did not go away, and Espino did not throw a pitch in 2023 after a March surgery to repair his anterior capsule. That sounds tricky, but just last week I saw a video of Espino throwing, and I’m excited all over again despite myself. Real Songs of Innocence and Experience situation. Better not chisel any projections for Espino into metal. 

70. Cubs LHP Jordan Wicks | 24 | MLB | 2023

An unorthodox marksman with a slow heartbeat, Jordan Wicks is penciled into the rotation now that Marcus Stroman has opted out of his contract. Even if they sign a starter or two, Wicks should get his fair share of shots in 2024. His stuff isn’t dominant, but a plus changeup and balanced repertoire give him a Jordan Montgomery type upside. 

71. Padres OF Jakob Marsee | 22 | AA | 2024

Even before the Juan Soto trade, we were likely to see the 6-foot 180-pound Marsee in the major leagues at some point in 2024. He played his way to Double-A during the 2023 season and ended it with an MVP month in the Arizona Fall League. In 24 AFL games, Marsee slashed .391/.508/.707 with five home runs and 16 stolen bases. He has played just 16 games at in Double-A, but AJ Preller has always played by his own rulebook when it comes to prospect promotions, so I’m not sure his lack of upper-minors experience will push his debut into the summertime, especially with Trent Grisham tailing Juan Soto out of town. 

72. White Sox LHP Noah Schultz | 20 | A | 2026

At 6’9” 220 lbs with a low-three-quarters release, Schultz brings a unique look that helped him dominate across short outings in Low-A. His 30.8 percent strikeout-minus-walk rate and 0.85 WHIP suggested he was ready for a new challenge when his season ended with a left shoulder impingement.

73. Twins OF Emmanuel Rodriguez | 21 | A+ | 2025

Produced a 145 wRC+ in 99 High-A games despite striking out 29.5 percent of the time. He hit 16 home runs, stole 20 bases and slashed .240/.400/.463 with a 20.2 percent walk rate. Power, speed and patience will play in the real game and ours as long as a guy plays decent defense (he does) and makes enough contact, which will have to be Rodriguez’s focus moving forward. Even if he can’t bring the strikeout rate down, he should be a force in OBP leagues.

74. Mets OF Drew Gilbert | 23 | AA | 2024

A smallish prospect at 5’9” 195 lbs, Gilbert was the 28th overall pick by Houston in 2022 coming off a superstar season at Clemson. A left handed hitter with functional in-game power, he should be a better fit for his home environment in New York than he would’ve been with the big right-center gap in Houston. He had struggled a bit at Double-A before the trade but slashed .325/.423/.561 in 35 games after coming to the Big Apple in a package for Justin Verlander. The Brandon Nimmo contract squeezes Gilbert to a corner, but he should hit enough to hold down a corner spot anyway. 

75. Braves RHP AJ Smith-Shawver | 21 | MLB | 2023 

Took a turn as perhaps fantasy’s most overrated prospect for a stretch in 2023. No fault of his own, really. The echo chamber was just excited to see him open the year with 21 scoreless innings across the two lower levels and then jump Triple-A entirely. The hype has settled some, but Smith-Shawver remains a special talent with a dynamic fastball and slider who will be part of the club’s plan in 2024.

Thanks for reading!

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

36 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Krista Koch Taylor
Krista Koch Taylor
1 month ago

You’ve got a broken link- I go to look at 2024 Dynasty Rankings, 75-51 and get top 75 Prospects

Grey
Admin
Reply to  Krista Koch Taylor
1 month ago

fixed

Anodyne
Anodyne
1 month ago

I see you’ve got Cole Young and Colt Emerson flipped from your rankings of those two players on your Mariners top prospects list. Thoughts on how this two compare to each other if both are available in my upcoming dynasty draft around the time when I’d be picking?

Donnie
Donnie
1 month ago

Hey Itch, just great stuff as always. Anything on Sea SS Felnin Celestin?

Harley Earl
Harley Earl
1 month ago

Excellent breakdown on Cowser. I’m officially out on him now!

Hey, got a question though. What happened to Matt Mervis? I loved him last year. Now I don’t even see his name mentioned anywhere. Obviously, he got exposed during his call-up. What were his issues?

Last edited 1 month ago by Harley Earl
Smitty
1 month ago

Didn’t realize the obstacles Robinson has had to overcome. Your update has renewed my interest in his potential, nice work Itch

ajhirsch
ajhirsch
1 month ago

Hi Itch!

A year removed from prospect status but with Frelick taking reps at 2B/3B this spring along with his OF reps, do you think that signals they’re trying to get him in the lineup every day? I’d be really intrigued if that is the case given his skillset. Was offered Arenado and Frelick for Gleyber (I’d be trading Gleyber) and am really considering given this news!

Thanks as always Itch and best of luck in your drafts!

fivepoundbass
fivepoundbass
1 month ago

Good stuff Itch, thanks for everything. Semi-related Cubs questions – if they do sign Bellinger long-term (which I don’t think they will), what do they look like going forward? Happ or Busch to 3B, and hope everything gets hit up the middle? PCA becomes high-end trade bait? Why is Busch a better bet than Mervis? Inquiring minds want to know. Or, my mind, at least.

junior56
junior56
1 month ago

Good morning Itch! Thanks for your top 75 looking forward to the top 100!

Andrew Vaughn… Is there any more upside in that bat? Or is it what you see is what you get?

I recently joined a 20 team Dynasty league 8×8 with 29 regulars-12 bench-35 minor spots. Can you offer any advice on Roster construction? Just finished an orphan draft I would gauge my roster somewhere between 10-12 and I need to get more prospects to try and build my roster up.

Thanks in advance

Lower the Jolly Roger
Lower the Jolly Roger
1 month ago

Itch my guy…. 12 teamer …. Keep 10 & 12 farm/stash

on my farm…. Who’s the drop?

Mervis
Bliss
Hence
Vivas
Aranda
Caballero
Westburg
Vargas
Busch
Blaze Jordan
Rojas
Matos
Harrison

Thank You as always

toolshed
1 month ago

Hi Itch, I have been trying to trim my roster down for a 5 rd draft. I have 30+ and need to get to 25. Would you rather hold druw jones because of his upside over someone like m vargas who is blocked? Or someone like matos who may play a little more. Keep in mind I could get the guy I cut back in the draft. I am competing this year. This is more like a keeper league rather than a full dynasty. Thanks

BigEasy
BigEasy
1 month ago

Hey Itch. Few questions for you. 14 team dynasty.

Won the league last year and have an abundance of OF, but only one closer. Nothing on the waiver wire. Too much to give up Bellinger for Clase?

Pick a side: Bellinger and schwarber for Clase and Albies

Tyler Black is on the waiver wire. What’s a realistic fantasy floor for him?

Thanks!

Dom Cobb
Dom Cobb
1 month ago

Mornin’ Itch, man K-Rob has great upside if he can stay healthy and avoid the off-the-field issues. You see his ETA around midseason? On a side note, Interesting that the manager has committed to Perdomo at short so early

tyler
tyler
1 month ago

Posted in the top 50 stream as well…ignore that one and if you please reply here:
We have an unlimited minors roster, but only get two a year….I seem to have chased a ton of losers…. here is the current state of my minor league players (20 team league)
Any of them in your top 100 if you were to make one? Any at all promising other than collier i suppose?
Heriberto Hernandez C -TB
Seth Beer 1B -PIT
Nick Gonzales 2B -PIT
Cam Collier 3B -CIN
Lazaro Armenteros LF -OAK
Hedbert Perez LF,CF -MIL
Jay Allen CF -CIN
Miguel Bleis CF -BOS
Erick Pena CF -KC

Dr Sauce
Dr Sauce
1 month ago

Thanks Itch, as always, lots of valuable information!
12 team, ESPN, 5×5, head to head, keep any 6 (no limits).
Keepers: Acuna, Carroll, Tucker, Tatis, Betts and Chourio …owe many thanks to you and the razzball team for these keepers!
One challenge: 5 OF keepers (we do start 5)
Trade Possibility: I give Carroll and a 5th round pick (with keepers 11th round overall) and I get back Bobby Witt jr and a 9th round pick (15th round overall).
I have flipped-flopped on this several times … obviously realizing they are both building blocks, who would you rather have moving forward (Carroll or Witt jr)? And if possible, please share a quick explanation. Thanks Itch!

Daniel Plainview
Daniel Plainview
1 month ago

You misspelled “oil baron.”

bigbear
bigbear
1 month ago

What’s the difference between Busch and Norby? Same age stats looks very similar. Difference is pedigree bias IMO. Neither are strong defenders, though Not by may actually be an ML 2B (even if not on the O’s). Both have intriguing bats with limited upside.

Lots of exciting pitchers in this part of the list!

Gordeon
Gordeon
1 month ago

Itch, Gotta disagree on your Baz was bad take in 2022. His first start was terrible, his next next 4 were oustanding (3 ERs in 4 starts, 26Ks:6BB) and then his 7th start he was obviously injured causing the bad stat line.

Gordeon
Gordeon
Reply to  Gordeon
1 month ago

*6th start not 7th

jimmy
jimmy
1 month ago

You rock itch! Always got great info! 18 team dynasty 6×6 Kristian Robinson is available..we get 7 minor league spots…I would have to drop one of these guys…Jackson Merrill…Tyler Black…Jacob Marsee…Thomas Saggese…Victor Scott II….Drew Thorpe or Chayce McDermott thoughts? Thank you!!

John Feehan
John Feehan
Reply to  The Itch
1 month ago

Man Victor Scott is a base stealing freak, and he is hitting for an impressive average. Had to add him to my list….. Absolutely crazy how many names there are to know. Thank God for Exel.