Martha,
I hope this letter finds you well. I’m stationed in SacTown. Currently, I’m sweating and having a fight with myself in a mirror when I receive a telegram from a young Harrison Ford. I have to get Kurtz out of the jungle. No, not Vietnam, I said SacTown. That is literally this city’s name. He has to be extradited out of the jungle of the Rainforest Cafe in Vegas. I’ll tell you why. He’s hitting like .350 with a home run every other game and he’s walled himself off in a cave where he’s begun to mix the DNA of different species to create a whole new animal, like there’s a raccoon and squirrel he calls a raquirrel. Whoever heard of a raqurriel? Even a squiraccoon is ridiculous, if you ask me. I have stop Kurtz and bring him back to SacTown. Thank you, and send me some of those jammies you make with peanut butter cookies.
Sincerely yours,
Grey
Am I confusing Apocalypse Now, Dr. Moreau and Nick Kurtz‘s hero journey to the majors? Yes, maybe I am, but what’s more confusing is when the A’s plan on calling him up. I’m not being coy or purposely daft, he could be up tomorrow or in September. My guess is in two weeks, as they’ve started to shift players around, so Kurtz can slip in as a 1st baseman. As I told Martha, he’s hitting well with a bazillion and one homers. I’d stash him now if you have room because he’s more than ready, now it’s just up to the A’s. Hurry before Kurtz merges a zebra and a rooster. No one wants a zooster! Anyway, here’s some more players to Buy or Sell this week in fantasy baseball:
PSYCHE! This post was released a week early for Patreon members. It will be released all year early for Patreons, so if people are getting a jump on you, it’s because they paid the $10. Anyway, the Fantasy Baseball Buy/Sell:
BUY
Miguel Amaya – Cubs have been getting production from literally everyone (well, except Matt Shaw), even a backup catcher, but this backup catcher might be the starter if Kelly can’t swing a bat. How much you’re rooting for that might have to do with whether you have Kelly, who also has been hot in his own right. All Cubs are hot. (Except Shaw still.)
Danny Jansen – Bit of a slow week for catcher pickups. I could’ve said Sean Murphy again, but since last week he’s gone over 50% rostered, so ineligible for this post, except he was eligible for me to say he’s been hot. Jansen’s been a bit hot, but also long-term I like him in Big Stein, until he gets hurt, at least.
Pavin Smith – So many guys’ stats look like this: .500 BABIP, .303 average, 31 K%. It’s goofy stats time (GST, which is two hours behind us on regression). So, Pavin, while not really good, has been hot.
Ryan O’Hearn – He’s Pavin Smith, but Irish. Call him Pavin O’Smith.
Rhys Hoskins – Hot hitting that would make a giant animated rabbit horny for Hoskins.
Jonathan Aranda – With what I just said about goofy stats? Well, Aranda looks promising in the big picture. Not a .400 hitter, obviously, but maybe 20+ HRs and .270. That’s got some value.
Matt Mervis – And we’re back on GST. Mervis’s stats look like a guy who is Quad-A, got hot and is generating a lot of Maas Appeal.
Ty France – For two weeks, it was Kyren Paris who generated all the goodwill. Now it’s France. I don’t know if the Orioles give him a chance, and he’s only in Single-A, but I’m watching closely Jose Arrondissement. Also, Joe De Vivre, guy’s got a lot of life on his bat.
Christopher Morel – One thing you can’t argue is what this guy brings to parties. Morel is a fun guy! High five me! Right now! No? Okay. Morel is also a .190 hitter with power, but, you guessed it, hot.
Luke Keaschall – Here’s what I said this morning, “Being called up by the Twins. Should be Keasch’all, but I will let slide, y’all. In Itch’s 1st prospect stash list of the season, he listed Luke, saying, “Minnesota has been playing Edouard Julien at second base, and he’s been fine so far, but Keaschall gives them a right-handed option who strikes out quite a bit less than Julien. He’s typically been under 20 percent throughout his pro career, whereas Julien lives in the 30 percent neighborhood. Keaschall is slashing .291/.415/.419 with a 19.5 percent strikeout rate through ten games. Brooks Lee and Royce Lewis are complicating factors, but Keaschall’s bat can clear its own path, and put Grey under the path.” C’mon, man! Keaschall is interesting, 15/23/.303 last year, but Baldelli has to platoon every gee-dee guy, so I’d think 15-team mixed leagues, until we see more.” And that’s me quoting me quoting Itch!
Jose Caballero – Some guys get their stats whether they’re playing full-time or not, and Caballero feels like that for speed. Whether he gets 300, 400 or 500 ABs, he’s getting 40 steals.
Gabriel Arias – A lot of the guys in this post are hot (most are, actually), but some are hot with iffy playing time. Arias looks locked into playing time, has been hot, and somehow has 17 HRs combined in four seasons. So, he must be Ozzie Smith with his glove. He supposedly has power, so maybe this year it’s blossoming. I’ve just made him a blossoming-power Ozzie Smith. Call him Blozzie Smith.
Edouard Julien – He sounds like a French technique for cutting vegetables. “Oui, you can take your leeks and julienne them or you can Edouard Julien them, which is julienning while hitting leadoff for the Twins.”
Dylan Moore – Lately, on a scale of 1-10, he’s been a 10, just studly Moore.
Adael Amador – Here’s Itch, “A switch-hitter at 6’0” 200 lbs, Amador got his first look at the show this season but couldn’t find his footing, slashing .171/.194/.200 in 36 plate appearances. Could’ve probably predicted as much considering he wasn’t thriving in Double-A, where he ended the season slashing .230/.343/.376 with 14 home runs and 35 stolen bases. The fantasy appeal is clear, and there’s plenty of upside in the frame given his solid plate skills from both sides. Just might take a while for him to settle into his true skill level at the top level. Grey’s skill level is toilet.” What? Amador is incredibly exciting for NL-Only and unrosterable in mixed, until we see more playing time.
Hyeseong Kim – As MF DOOM might’ve called him, “The Sofa Kim,” and he’s been Sofa Kim hot in the minors.
Brooks Lee – Don’t really like Lee, but I need to give you some AL-Only guys and Lee’s been hot, but, in AL-Only leagues, Lee is rostered and in AL-Only leagues guys on waivers are more like DaShawn Keirsey Jr. Not a made-up name!
Nasim Nunez – Dude’s crazy fast and maybe gets some playing time while Corange Juice Abrams is on the shelf and/or at the casino.
Tyler Fitzgerald – Started to get dropped in leagues, and, honestly, I understand it. Hitting at the bottom of any lineup is fantasy death, but the Giants lineup had places to move him up to if he started hitting, and he even moved up to the six-hole yesterday.
Ben Williamson – Here’s what I said the other day, “Williamson could be a .280 hitter with 30 steals, and they’re going to start Mastrobuoni? Forget mixed leagues, I can’t even say Mastrobuoni aloud in mixed company.” And that’s me quoting me!
Caleb Durbin – Just gave you my Caleb Durbin fantasy. It was written while stretching in yoga pants.
Kameron Misner – This is what it feels like with the Rays’ hitters: They come out of nowhere, get unbelievably hot, have a solid month or two, then disappear to never be heard from again. Misner has an odd stat page. He struggled with a 30 K% in the minors, and now is making great contact in the majors. He also went 17/30 in Triple-A, so, while I do think he’ll disappear, there might be something here longer-ish term.
Mike Yastrzemski – Carl’s Jr. Jr.’s biggest takeaway is giving you the Burger you want, and not the Jake Burger you’re getting.
Austin Hays – He’s in The Scheblers, let him ride around town on the back of Scooter Gennett.
Kyle Stowers – One final guy on GST. Wake me when guys no longer have a .400 BABIP and tell me what they’re hitting then.
Landen Roupp – What’s Rouppdog? I don’t know but I like Roupp in the big picture, but this is a Streamonator call like the call it makes to an arcade.
Hayden Wesneski – Another guy I like in general, but Streamonator. “Do you have a Ms. Pac-Man game? I was having a lovely conversation with her the other day, and I’d like to continue chatting.”
Calvin Faucher – We all know Justin Martinez and A period J period Puk and Jose Alvarado and Kahnle and maybe Pagan but maybe Diaz are getting saves (for now, maybe some of them), but who might be getting saves tomorrow? Well, none of the guys in this post, maybe, who knows, saves are super arbitrary.
Abner Uribe – Trevor Megill is Trevor My-guy-ill. Huh?! Did I pull it off?! No? You are 100% correct. I did not. Can Uribe pull it off and replace him? Uribe likely could’ve been the closer for two of the last three years, so, yes, absolutely. Last year was technically iffy and icky from Abner. (By the way, Abner reminded me of Lil’ Abner, which reminded me of Andy Capps Hot Fries, which reminded me of Wise Cheez Waffies and that sent me down a 45-minute google-spiral of what the hell happened to those delicious things and I’m happy to report, they’re back! Bad news update! They’re impossible to find. Are they just in Georgia? Does Ted Turner make them? I need Cheez Waffies! This is not a sponsored post, but, Wise, call me, let’s work out something. Does Wise even exist anymore? This feels like more of a philosophical question.)
Yennier Cano – If I were the O’s GM, I’d trade Bautista for a starter and let Cano close. [reading business card] “Grey Albright, not the Orioles GM.” Hmm…
SELL
Fernando Tatis Jr. – Last couple weeks it was Sell Low Guys and, as much as I think you have to get out quickly on SLGs (first time that acronym’s ever been used for baseball), there’s also something about timing it right on a Sell High Guy. SLGs give you that SELL!!! that’s like FIRE!!! in a theater. A SHG is more like musical chairs. You don’t have to sit immediately, you can walk around a little and enjoy that stroll around chairs while Tony! Toni! Toné!’s Feels Good plays, but, when Feels Good stops, you better have sat or else you’re going to be SOL with your SHG and Tatis is going to randomly hit the IL with a quad injury that turns out to be that he was actually parasailing while on a motorcycle and he’s gonna miss three months. This is not a SLG issue, I wouldn’t sell Tatis for a walking tour of Chernobyl, but I would go to the Fantasy Baseball Trade Analyzer and explore options.
drop springs for liberatore?
Mitch Keller over Wacha, Eflin, Mize or hold?
NL Only- Saves only 5×5..
Lost both Puk and Treinen.. who should I speculate on saves .. ot at least someone who won’t kill my ratios..
S.Miller, az, Beeks, az ? If J-Mart continues to pitch when needed most in the late-innings.. does either step into Puk’s role?
Kinley, Dreyer, Tinoco (picking up an extra innings save)
Garrett.. those are the few available
Thanks. Happy 4/20
Goodman or A. Ramirez?
Ive got too many outfielders
Which 2 should i drop?
Hjerstad
Bleday
Crews
Grisham
Dominguez
Ramos
Noot
Veen
Burnes and Bibee for F Peralta and Ryan in dynasty 6×6?
@Grey: weekly roto redraft. Who do you like between Friedl and Hays?
Thanks!
Hays
Veen or durbin?
This coming week,who would you start?
Taj Bradley @AZ
Chris Sale. @AZ
Thanks!
Both
Carlos Correa or Dylan Moore?
Jake Burger or Rhys Hoskins or Connor Norby?
Thanks!
Moore
Hoskins
How would you rank Burleson, Josh jung and Noelvi marte?
Jung, Burle
Pavin, Friedl, or Frelick?
Thanks
Pavin
Roupp over either of the Holmes pitchers, right?
Sure
Stream M. Boyd home vs LAD or Wesneski @ KC – Happy Easter!
Wesneski– happy Easter!
Roupp and Mahle are available. I have Alcantara Pepiot Ryan Baz. What possible moves do you recommend, thank you
Roupp over Pepiot
Desperate need of a 2B
H2H 5×5 OBP
Andres Gimenez
Brandon Lowe
Connor Norby
Gavin Lux
Jonathan India (who I currently have)
Are the best choices, who would you choose between the 5
Andres
Veen has a pulse! Him or Cam Smith?
Ha, Veen
Bednar or Kahnle?
Bednar
Drop Holliday for Hays?
yes
1. Which 2b should I pickup for Kyren Paris: Kristian Campbell, Gleyber torres, Maikel Garcia, Gabriel Arias, Luis Garcia Jr. Bryson Stott, Tyler Fitzgerald, Luisangel Acuna, Jackson Holliday, Christopher Morel
2. Would you drop Texas closer Luke Jackson for Trevor Megill, David Bednar, or keep Jackson
3. Some good starters are available, are any of these guys I should add immediately? Sandy Alcantara, Tyler Mahl, Bowden Francis, Drew Rasmussen, Brandon woodruff, Jackson Jobe, Andrew Abbot
1. Campbell 2. no 3. Mahle, Rasmuss, Bowden
Brewers gotta go for the record. 7 steals in 1.2 innings right now. Gotta be like halfway there with 3/4 of the game to go.
HAHA, insane
Grey,
I’m in a 10 team H2H mixed league. I’m interested in boith Landen Roupp and Nick Kurtz.
Please check out my team below, and advise if I should make a move, and if so, who to drop.
Thank you!
My Team:
C : Yainer Diaz
1B : Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
2B : Brendan Donovan
3B : Alex Bregman
SS : Elly De La Cruz
OF : Taylor Ward
OF : Lawrence Butler
OF : Michael Harris II
UTIL : Ben Rice
Bench: Cody Bellinger (1B,OF)
Bench: Trevor Story (SS)
Bench: Jason Dominguez (OF)
IL : Ketel Marte
SP : Garrett Crochet
SP : Machenzie Gore
SP : Drew Rasmussen
SP : Jackson Jobe
SP : Bowden rancis
SP : Taj Bradley
SP : Bryce Miller
SP : Brandon Pfaadt
SP : Ryan Pepiot
SP : Andrew Abbott
SP : Andrew Heaney
IL : Shonei Ohtani
IL : Luis Gil
IL : Ranger Suarez
Roupp and Kurtz over Pepiot and Dominguez
18 teamer dynasty 6×6 and *I thought* I was primed to have it covered.
Jacob Young – bench filler SB helper done nothing
Rengifo – hammy injury. maybe the reason?
Gelof – out for a few months
Doyle – slow start on bases but good otherwise.
Robles – crash dummied to IL
M. Garcia – 37 SB 2 CS. This year 2 SB and 2 CS. He gave up stealing for lent I guess.
Went from #2 last year to #16 right now. Even my SB PR specialist Blanco got hurt. I have Mangum with 8 steals, Naylor with 4, and the rest of the team with 3.
Top WW steals are Berti, Walls, Keirsey, Hill, and Mateo.
I attempted a trade to the Simpson owner a month ago and he was a hard no then. Basically Mangum is carrying the whole category for me and who knows how long that lasts.
Think I need to make some moves for SB or you think the above will bounce back to at least middle of the pack for the league?
If trade, any low key steals guys youd target? Someone has Rojas PHI on block. Another has Fraley. Maybe I am more desperate than I should be.
Seems like you have a lot of steals already, or plenty, at least
Razzball Nation never takes a day off! Connor Norby or Jake Burger ROS? Time to grab Bednar as a potential closer? In a 12 team, is it time to move on from Gallen or hold for a few more starts on my bench? Thank you!
BUrger…yes on Bednar…I wouldn’t start Gallen anywhere, but I’d hold for now
How does Robbie Ray not have an ass-related nickname? Baffling.
Pants
Langford is back LFG!!’
Haha
This morning they listed him as off IL but not in the lineup. Then they said F it and put him in. I can’t imagine they were seriously debating keeping Joc in the 3-hole. Madness.
Hahaha
Mize or pffadt?
Pfaadt
starting flahtery vs SD?
Sure
@Grey: weekly roto redraft. Bleday or Friedl? Also, one of O’Hoppe, Murphy or Goodman?
Thanks!
Bleday…Goodman
Please rank
Rasmussen,Roupp,Francis
Ras, Bow
Hey Grey, would you drop burleson for keashall by the seashore ?
Sure
Drop Soler for Hays?
Tovar for Dansby?
Meh…yes
T. Meyers or Erod?
Erod
Happy Easter. What’s Roupp dog? His he legit or streamer?
Erod Heaney and roupp dog avail. Drop jung?
I have zebby and chandler but holding.
Roupp looks legit — drop Jung for him
Happy Easter Grey! Gotta couple questions for ya this morning:
1. Start or sit Framber today vs Padres?
2. Got outbid on Mountcastle, but someone dropped Rhys Hoskins now. How much FAAB out my 931$ out of 1000$ salary should I bid on him?
Easter! 1. Start 2. $13
perdomo, crews or stott?
Stott
Mariners and Blue Jays was damn entertaining.
Berrios got into it with Raleigh because he thought he was signaling pitches. Of course he says it as Raleigh is walking towards his dugout then says keep walking….. *eyeroll*
https://mlb-cuts-diamond.mlb.com/FORGE/2025/2025-04/19/5d1a0692-b9a1c6b9-9cdaf9e0-csvm-diamondgcp-asset_1280x720_59_4000K.mp4
Rowdy Tellez with the WWE move
https://mlb-cuts-diamond.mlb.com/FORGE/2025/2025-04/19/ccda3c3b-e92970d2-ca6356b6-csvm-diamondgcp-asset_1280x720_59_4000K.mp4
and of course finishes the game off with a grand slam
https://mlb-cuts-diamond.mlb.com/FORGE/2025/2025-04/19/f695e361-ac322c06-80ef7e94-csvm-diamondgcp-asset_1280x720_59_4000K.mp4
Raleigh kills the Blue Jays. Something like .293 BA vs them for his career. HOF if he hit against them each year.
If Raleigh is Big Dumper would Tellez be Big Thumper? Smash Bros? The less sexy, off brand, Bash Bros knock offs?
Sounds like Raleigh was stealing signs on 2nd base
Raleigh stealing my heart with ANOTHER BOMB. Guy destroys Toronto.
Love it
Drop one of Clay Holmes, Heaney, Abbott In 10 team h2h leagues…
Holmes
12 team, 5×5 roto.
Last night I traded my Hoerner, Hoffman and Gallen for Altuve and Riley. What do you think? Here’s the new team:
C- Ruiz
1B- Bellinger
2B- Altuve
3B- Riley
SS- Gunnar
OF- Carroll
OF- Rooker
OF- Cruz
UTIL- Nootbaar
BN- Doyle, Vientos
SP- King, Woo, Eovaldi, Schmidt, streamer, streamer
RP- Fairbanks, Alvarado, Justin Martinez, Luke Jackson
Sounds awesome, team looks solid!
Happy Eastahhhh to those who celebrate.
In a 12-teamer, are we grabbing/holding Roupp, Abbott, Liberatore or are they just streamers and use SON for matchups?
Easter! I have Roupp on my team
Bleday vs Heliot ros ops?
Heliot
Morning & Happy Easter all!
Got 1 move left this week and looking to stream one of the below. Who do you like best today?
Thanks in advance!
Happy Easter! None? I guess Holmes
Ha, guess I could always just try to steal a save with Weaver in NYY or Faucher in MIA instead…
You like either guy at all?
Thanks again!
Weaver
Thank you.
I was just offered a trade for Fairbanks (12-team, 6×6, OPS).
I get: Fairbanks
I give: Heliot Ramos
My other OF-ers are: Soto, Tatis, Happ (and Moore is OF eligible).
Would you pull the trigger?
Sounds fair if you need saves
Was just offered J. Naylor for T. Soderstrom in a 10 team pts league. What do you think?
Hold
Got it, thank you!
No problem
Drop Fairbanks foe Alexis Diaz?
Nah
Good morning. Please rank top 3 prospect stashes for redraft, of: OF Roman Anthony, SP Painter, OF E. Rodriguez, 2B Bazzana. Thank you.
You did
8:10 AM PT game tomorrow. Set your alarm clock!
Ugh!
Would you start Mahle at home agains the Dodgers in a 10 team pts league? Thank you.
Yes
I look over at tonights matchup and didnt realize Hendricks is still pitching.
Of course it is almost time for some. Well you know. You know.
Grab a cold beer and watch some Rouppdog.
Haha
Love grabbing some decent pitching from fellas bobbing around on the wire. Who provides more long term goodness – Abbot or Liberatore? Pretty good start from The Liberator today…
Liberatore
I think you might have missed my question a couple below. Thanks ahead of time Grey!
sorry, answered
Can we get another clean one out of the Wes?
Please
Gah – let the man pitch!
Haha
Saves only league. With Alexis Diaz back would you still hold onto Pagan or pick up Abner Urine? Don’t under why he isn’t closing for the Brew Crew.
Uribe
So if it was you, drop Pagan for Uribe with A. Diaz back? Just want to make sure, cuz I had a bunch of typos and didn’t think my question was super clear. Sorry.
I’d wait to see a save from Diaz
12 team, 5×5 roto.
1) How would you rank these 1B now? Alonso, Soderstrom, Olson
2) Would you trade Bellinger and Luke Jackson for those 1B above?
I have 5 closers and am looking to upgrade my hitting with one. Here’s squad:
C- Ruiz
1B- Bellinger
2B- Hoerner
3B- Vientos
SS- Gunnar
OF- Carroll
OF- Rooker
OF- Cruz
UTIL- Nootbaar
BN- Doyle, Norby
RP- Hoffman, Fairbanks, Alvarado, Justin Martinez, Luke Jackson
1. you ranked them 2. yes, any
Grisham or Mervis?
Grisham
hey homie. I have one roster decision to make… between Vientos Casas Westburg my 1st 2nd and 3b has been blah!
1) Vientos is now hurt. Who am I starting at 3b Westburg who’s slumped or cam smith?
2) Paris, Aranda (or if cam smith is 3b I can use westB at 2B
3) my worst pitchers are Mize and mahle would you swap either for abbot?
If no would u dropa bats for Abbot? Could be cam smith slash like I picked up Crews right now after seeing him homer twice today and can use him at UT. I donno if dropping Casas is correct either for the long run.
sorry this is a lot to ask :) appreciate
If anything is confusing my current team If and UT is
c: Murphy
1b: Busch
2b: Paris aranda or westB
ss: Gunnar
3b westB or cam
UT: T oneal
UT: Crews or one of the other infielders
and by one roster decision I mean many bahaha
Westburg 2. Can you wait to see how injured aranda is?
ya I was just wondering if I should drop anyone for Abbot. Either a player or pitcher for him, but it depends on if I need all these bats.
Is Abbot worth it? Or should I drop one of those pitchers for him? Weekly league things. I can’t just stream multiple pitchers a week n such
If they’re bench bats, you can lose one for Abbott
which Bat u dropping then between Cam Smith, Paris, Aranda, Crews or Casas in OBP instead of avg. I’m guessing Smith?
Smith
I have a rule to grab pitchers that punch 10ks or more haha
It’s a good rule
Puk out. Is Conforto for AZ’s Justin Martinez fair? Which side?
…And Justin Martinez or Fairbanks (three a clunker today)?
Martinez
Martinez
Im not trying to kink shame my silly labrador retriever, but, does it mean anything other than being playfully when he bite a little?
Because Jazz biting his hitting coach in the same way, and I am now very confused.
Hahaha
Stealing the baby’s socks.
Somebody’s been bad
Basically. Wishing ill of any kind normally works.
Liam hendriks coming off of IL, would you add him over Dennis Santana in a saves/Holds league?
Sure
Please rank
Abbott,Rasmussen,Woo
Woo, Rasmussen
Would you drop Sasaki or Bibee for Andrew abbot?
Bibee
QS against the Dodgers? Please and thank-you.
Nice!
“Here’s what I said the other day, “Williamson could be a .280 hitter with 30 steals, and they’re going to start Mastrobuoni? Forget mixed leagues, I can’t even say Mastrobuoni aloud in mixed company.” And that’s me quoting me!”
Well if you are so smart Mr. Fancy Fantasy Guy, why wouldnt you mention Williamson can hit HR too?!?! Cuz he just launched a rocket and still has no steals while batting .294. I thought he could only bunt and that is why the Mariners werent playing him. That is the correct conclusion right? I mean TB had Simpson leading off with .800+ OPS at bottom of order so the Ms must have some really stout hitters slowing down Williamson? Hello?! Hellllo?!
https://mlb-cuts-diamond.mlb.com/FORGE/2025/2025-04/19/4d871d44-f8e534e4-ec271d81-csvm-diamondgcp-asset_1280x720_59_4000K.mp4
Pretty solid jack btw
Haha, I didn’t want to do spoilers
Redraft
Add Simpson and drop victor Scott or hold?
Go for it
No. That doesnt makes sense unless something happened to Scott? He is slumping but still getting steals.
Pretty crazy TB let Simpson lead off when they have Mangum hitting .300 who seems to also be all speed and no power and Misner with a 1.128 OPS.
Drop someone else to get Simpson to add speed makes sense, but dumping speed to hope new speed is better is a sideways move.
Doubles are a category along with triples . Was thinking Simpson might do better in those cats as well as hits ,avg, runs.
Ooooh gotcha gotcha. I only use Scott as a speed guy but moved him in a trade when I snagged Mangum. I just need them for steals basically not other cats.
He looks decent enough. PT will likely be there as I think Morel is guy out of the mix. Until whoever got hurt comes back son Plagueis or whatever his name is and Simpson might just hold on to.
Plagueis is out for 4-6 weeks at the soonest, maybe the year. Looks like Chandler will have a long leash.
He lasted one day on roster before back to IL.
What about Deluca?
Kyle with his first bomb as a Ranger off Sasaki.
Ha
I see I have made a huge mistake building my OF around Doyle, Santander,and Crews. The obvious choice of Edman, Mullins, and Grisham got past me.
Hahaha ugh
I wish KC had some arms to give, okay maybe they do considering how dumb BAL was last year with Stowers and Norby, because they could use a whole new OF and BAL has two entire ones just lying around. Exaggerating. Mostly. I think.
Hahaha makes too much sense
Cam Smith, Bleday or Jordan Walker?
Bleday
Feel bad for Marlins pitchers. Clearly overmatched vs Phillies. That said, the Phillies are stealing at will. That messes with you as a pitcher because you overthink it, know you cant count on that DP ball.
Liam Hicks has a .195 BA no defense.
Before today allowed 14 SB 1 CS. Phillies 5 for 5 with guys like Schwarber and Harper stealing for giggles.
19 SB 1 CS aint gonna play anywhere.
Oh wait! That is inline with his career minors numbers where he allowed 149 SB and 31 CS, 17% of base stealers he caught.
How can a guy throwing out nobody be a backstop in the majors? Just so dumb.
Yeah, totally
He must have heard you.
Did he throw someone out?
Homered.
Good for him but homie still cant play C. His stick is fine in the minors, a .275ish type, you cant have 90% of steals be successful and be a MLB C. Too many guys got their D knocked with far better #s. Its the Marlins, but at some point move him to LF or whatever instead if the bat is MLB capable. Plus the Marlins have a bunch of C prospects.
Oh not disparaging the take at all. More an honouring of the (my?) Razzball tradition of remarking upon the ongoing effectiveness of the reverse jinx.
In that case, please let Rice, Kjerdtad, and Vientos be completely not okay and have to hit the IL.
*crosses fingers*
Is that how this works?
Carroll plays like a little leaguer in the OF. Has to be the 3rd screw up Ive seen and he never ever gets charged errors even when it hits him in the glove. Thanks for putting Gallen in a hole dickwad.
https://bdata-producedclips.mlb.com/3eb655a6-fcc6-401f-89e0-743033a3621a.mp4
He learned from Oneil
Who in LF for best talent + most error team? Maybe slide Carroll there? CF Oneil. RF hmmm tough. Use Gunnar at 3B Elly at SS Gleyber 2B ???? 1B idk pretty much any terrible fielder. Not sure how Vlad got that Gold Glove. C ….maybe just assume Sod or Rice would make most errors?
Hahaha, yeah
Torkelson baby! Greatest pickup ever! Didn’t have a 1 2 or 4 rd pick this year and been whomping that Ace.
So thought of Abbott. Worth owning or monocle?
Hjhersted, butcher that last name. Break out? He’s top 55 player in last 7 days.
Own
Over Ben Brown, Bibee, or Boyd?
Probably Brown? IDK but I see he is at 73 pitches in 2.2 IP so far today.
Boyd
He just got hit in the elbow and removed from the game soooo might want to hold on a minute. Usually this happens when he starts to get hurt. They hit him.
Austin Hays, Pavin Smith, Taylor Ward OPS league whos the odd man out?
Ward
“You can’t talk to me like that. I’m somebody’s B**ch!”
— Seth Lugo, after the Torkelson AB
Good for Tork but as a Lugo owner what an awful pitch. Not to mention Tork is batting second and *checks notes* McKinstry is behind him.
https://bdata-producedclips.mlb.com/7336a03d-86f2-4d2f-915c-945a7820d246.mp4
Only gave up hits to Baez and Dingler before that but maaaaan, that is a slow ass pitch over the middle of the plate.
My heart sank watching that pitch sail towards the plate.
I’ve got tork & my opponent has Lugo. That pitch was absolutely magnificent middle middle. Perfect. No notes, 10/10. Lmao
The most amazing thing is it was on a 1-2 count where Tork was swinging at everything in the zone. He could have at least tried another pitch out of the zone – didn’t have to come near the plate, much less throw that meatball.
Crazy thing is that Tork struggles, or at least did last year vs fastballs. He hit better vs breaking than fastball which…is…pretty hard to do. Was like a .40-50 on his BA.
Maybe he tweaked something to fix it but I see him crushing these breaking pitches and wondering why they arent daring him with heat.
Like you said all breaking outside zone and one heater neck high. 4 of 5 were breaking balls and then you know, when ahead in the count you gotta throw a meatball. Shows dominance. Or something.
Yeah, he said in the spring he’d made adjustments to his swing. He had a kind of long loopy swing before. Looks like it’s a shorter, quicker now, which would help to hit heaters better.
Whatever it was, it’s working. Dude’s a beast in the early going.
Haha
Its happening!!!!!!!
Hide your wife, kids, and ratios!
HAHA
In a keeper league would you trade Snell and Kikuchi for Adames and Bohm?
If no, would you move just Snell for both and a mid-draft pick?
Bohm he is trying to move but I really have no interest. He has Adames behind Witt so only can use as UT. He threw the above offer at me but im meh on it.
Snell for both sounds fair
Thanks. Trade analyzer doesnt do that large of leagues but the 15×15 favored the Adames side.
Im not a fan of Snell or Adames so my annoyance with both made a “fair” offer tough in my head.
I don’t love Adames and Snell…well who knows how long he’s out for or how serious it is
3 Questions for THE mentor:
Which is best DH for next week?
Hoskins 7 (@ SF / @ STL)
Paredes 6 (3 vs TOR / 3 @ KC)
Busch 5 at Home (vs LAD / PHI)
Which SP sits next week?
Wesneski @ KC
Boyd vs LAD
Heaney @ LAA
Drop India / stash Hyeseong?
Thanks Brother man, Happy Easter
Paredes
Heaney
Yes on India
you too!
So glad you are out on India, can’t stomach that guy (even as a reserve)
He’s out – now watch him get hot LOL but like Hyeseong’s potential
Thanks bruddah
Haha, No problem
Heliot Ramos or Tyler Fitzgerald for keeper league? H2H Category OBP/BB/K scoring in addition to the standard categories
Ramos
Trade Perdomo for Kurtz?
Sure
Fairbanks or KC’s Esteves?
Estevez
Sorry to interrupt your weekend. I have a 10 team draft Monday. Where would you target Kurtz in the draft? Thank you Grey!
Around 120
Morning & Happy Husband Appreciation Day!
Told my wife this and she told me to get coffee…
Anyway, we still holding onto Victor Scott in 12 team leagues? I love the speed & he started off great but has come back to earth as of late.
Other available OF-ers I could swap with:
Thoughts? & Thank you!
Haha, perfect…lose him for Smith
Dang it! Twins missed by a few days with their male order Bride from the Marlins!
Need to sit one. Aranda vs. Carrasco, Pavin vs. Ben Brown, Bellinger vs. Baz, Campbell vs. Shane Smith. Any thoughts?
Belli
Kristian
Seager on a heater right now my goodness. 1K in last 25 AB. 3K in last 35 AB. He had 10K in first
31 AB.
12 hits last 22 AB. 6 game hitting streak.
On April 7: BA .161, SLG .235, OBP .238
On April 19: BA .318, SLG .375, OBP .530
Dude seems locked in. Would be nice if someone got on base for him because he has 4 HR and 6 RBI.
Haha, yup!
In a 12tm H2H with Sv+Hld would u drop Jax to pick up either J.Estrada or L.Weaver?
Weaver
H2H pts league scores +7 IP +2 K -2 Hit -3 BB -12 HR
Need to start 1 next week:
Bryce Miller @ Bos
Gavin Williams vs Yankees
Taj @ Ari
Fedde @ Atl
Yuck…I guess Taj
Was outbid on Durbin, Mountcastle was dropped on waivers. Would you drop Burleson to add him?
Sure
12 team mixed keeper league, are you taking C. Walker or Hyeseong Kim (2B) for next yet? Or too soon to say but could be close? Thanks!
Walker
Who’s the drop to activate Langford, Buxton or Victor Scott? Thanks!
Bux
12 team, H2H points. Awesome buy, trying to get the sell high going below…
Trade Tatis/Boyd for Butler/Skubal?
That works for me
Cam Smith, Roman Anthony, Zebby Matthews – how would you order them for expected value this season? Thanks!
You did
Currently in fifth place in head to head 12 teamer. Best WW options are: Rengifo,, Crews, Cam, France, Yaz, Pagan, Meyers, K Ruiz, Caballero, Woodruff, J Leiter, Schmidt, Yates, ERod, Festa. Any swaps?
(Saves and holds separate cats. Ten hitting cats so guys who get any kind of hits are valuable)
Murphy
Vlad, Machado, N Lowe
Lindor, Altuve, Campbell
Tucker, Suzuki, V Scott, Donovan, Cast
Util-Schanuel
Yamamoto, Shota, Bibee, Eflin, Eovaldi
Bautista, Iglesias, Estevez, Kahnle, Strahm
IL Kirby
I also have Kurtz as my bench
Eflin for ERod, Cam over Schanuel
Lord of Grey…..please help me select the correct third basemen to pick up. Ke’Bryan (stupid name) has got to go!
Vientos, maikel Garcia, Norby, McKinstry, polanco
Vientos
12 team, 5×5 roto. 1250 Max IP.
1) Which of these pitchers would you start today?
2) Who are your top 3 ranked out of these players – Nootbaar, Wilyer, Nimmo, Lane Thomas, Crews, Heliot, Heston?
3) Would you roll with Keibert Ruiz or Sean Murphy at C?
Have a great Saturday!
Eovaldi 2. Noot, Heliot, Nimmo 3. Murphy
Thoughts on this trade?
Tatis
Pagan
Slaten
For
Edwin Diaz
Adames
Kirby
I have Tatis
Tatis side
So think I should keep Tatis or go through with the trade?
He meant keep Tatis.
Keep Tatis if that’s the deal
What if the other side adds a walking tour of Chernobyl?
Haha
Are you starting Lugo vs Detroit or Weneski vs SD?
Lugo
Streaming MIL Chad Patrick vs Athletics for Sat, figured it’s not in Sacramento so that helps. For Sunday, insanely limited pickings:
COL Senzatela vs Nationals
TOR Lucas vs Mariners
My gut instinct says Lucas to lock down the weekend, but not by much- agreed?
Happy Easter to you and yours Grey!
Lucas, they’re terrible options…Happy Easter
Id avoid Senzatela for three reasons. Too many baserunners. Nats love to run. Rockies C is weird and im not sure any are good defensively.
Weekly opponent scooped Lucas with his final add, guess I’m taking Senzatela for whatever he is worth unless there’s a more worthwhile streamer to take towards week 4 with my final add and hope things goes well for the current matchup.
Projections for a win are less than 20 pts
Yikes
In need of Runs, RBIs, and HRs for my team. Who would you drop out of Otto Lopez, Connor Norby, Jesus Sanchez, Burleson, and Veen? You can say more then 1 if you’d drop multiple, here are the options I have for waivers:
Durbin
Manzardo
Correa
India
Chandler Simpson
Ty France
Garret Mitchell
Benintendi
Lane Thomas
Keaschall
Andujar
Brooks Lee
Kyle Farmer
Toglia
Roman Anthony
I know not great options, sorry for the long list just thought I’d give you my main options, thanks!
Burleson for Durbin
Thanks, only reason I’ve held onto Burleson is because he may get 1B eligibility here soon and I don’t have a backup for Casas which could be concerning. Plus the waivers are pretty bad for 1st basemen. Would you still go with Burleson to drop or would you go with someone like Otto? I have Nico hoerner, Willi Castro, and Luis Garcia already for 2B eligibility
Oh ok, lose Lopez
1. Murphy or Keibery?
2. I dropped Cam Smith yesterday to stash Kurtz. Timing is everything. Is Kurtz worth holding over Arias, Caballeros, Crews, Eugenio or, ahem, Cam?
3. H2H league so being patient with injured folks…Kirby, Eflin. Eflin over Boyd, Schmidt, Heaney?
1. Murphy 2. hold 3. No, Schmidt
Paris has cooled off considerably since his hot start. Give him a little more time or drop him and pick up Durbin or Keaschall?
Neto is back, but Tim Anderson sucks! ….Funny how a guy can be great off the bench, and flop as an everyday guy. Some regression was to be expected though. I dropped him. Thanks for the great production, while Norby was on IL.
Durbin
Hey grey,
As a bench bat, would you drop ward for Neto? I’m loaded at OF.
Sure
Grey, that was brilliant. Thank you.
No problem
Time to add Cam Smith over Noot, Veen, Mount?
Over Veen
Need steals and AVG.
1) Go for Simpson, Durbin, or Caballero on wire?
2) How much FAAB (Veen went for 6%)?
1. Durbin and Simpson 2. 6% sounds about right if you need steals…between 4-6
Bednar seems to have figured it out…..when recalled does he slot back into the closers role? Thanks in advance!
I’d guess so, yeah
Paddack with two good starts in a row. 5IP 3H 1ER 1BB 6K.
Last two starts 10IP 5H 2ER 3BB 11K
Ain’t gonna be me
One of my Gladiator teams was doing very well until I had 3 pitchers combine to give up 16 ER in 5.1 IP. Talk about a ratio killer…
That’s brutal.
That sucks. All RP or SP mixed in?
Both. When Griffin Jax, someone to stabilize ratios, allows 4ER in .1 IP you know you’re in trouble. Ragans and Hodge both annihilated too.
Ah, I recognize a fellow porter Hodge owner anywhere
Yeouch
Reynolds! Turns out all I had to do was bench him.
Nice!
Pickup A Hays or JJ?
Bleday
Durbin 1/1!
:)
Batting 9th
:(
Chopper to 3rd he outran for a base hit. Fits the mold of that infield haha.
HA
Rooker DHing….gonna be ASB before he gets position eligible.
The Athletics seem to be giving him one day in OF alternating with one at DH over the past week. They will probably figure out how much OF Rooker can handle and take it from there. Kurtz is probably close to being a better hitter than Rooker already, but is probably not going to play any OF. So, Rooker will need to hit well and that still probably wont keep Kurtz down much longer. Rooker will probably need to do the glove long term if Soderstrom keeps it up, Kurtz hits anything like it seems he will.
Are you joking dude? Rooker hit .293 (11th), 39 HR (5th), 112 RBI (4th), and an OPS of .927 (8th) last year.
In. The. Majors.
You talking like Rooker is some scrub. You sure you didnt mix up Rooker with IDK, MAYBE Seth Brown?
Better hitter than Rooker with 0 MLB AB. Rooker isnt the one keeping Kurtz down, it is Soderstrom’s breakout.
How about we make a bet now that Kurtz will wind up higher on Razzball player rater in 2026 than Rooker? You take Rooker, and I take Kurtz?
I would take Rook over rookie for this year, but dang, Kurtz looks like a can’t miss-top 50 player next year……A’s got good fast! Now for the pitching!
Gladly.
Kurtz is a very good prospect who should be a stalwart at 1B. The fact he had a really good college career is nice but lots of guys do. He has 114 minor league ABs so far, and nothing I see there says to me he is a better hitter than a guy who was maybe an IL stint away from going .300 40HR 120 RBI 10SB in M.L.B.
The power has always been there for Kurtz but I am surprised no one is talking about his .400+ BABIP in minors, the raising K rate and plummeting walk rate, and the incredibly small sample size. He has a minors career ISO of .380. Judge has a MLB ISO of .317.
Maybe that was Rooker’s peak last year and his arm is not as good after the surgery, but to casually say some guy on a heater in minors is better than him coming off that season that happened LAST year, and not 3-4 years ago, is just insane to me.
You can rope me into better than a Seth Brown, or Blejay, but better than a guy who was in the top 10 in every major offensive category and top 5 in quite a few is bonkers.
Rooker was basically Soto with fewer walks last year. In a 100 fewer PA. Without Judge hitting behind him. Oh, and with an injury that wouldnt let him play the field after May.
Ok, we will see. Kurtz was by most accounts the best bat in the 2024. He is impressive in his approach and is a mature hitter. He can command the zone well, makes good swinging decisions, and has power to all fields. This is no knock on Rooker, he’s awesome. I think Kurtz could very well be like early career Todd Helton (40/120/.320) soon, whereas Rooker is more the classic slugger (35/105/.250). That may seem too optmistic to many, but I am looking at his high end upside potential. More possible than probable, but he has as good a chance as any young hitters to be a top 15 bat within 2-3 years.
It is a knock on Rooker though. Above you said he is close to being a better hitter than Rooker already. You do realize Rooker, despite his non-linear way of getting to the majors, had a stellar NCAA career that includes being named the player of the year nationally as well as for the SEC?
I love Painter as a prospect but I wouldnt go say he was better than Nola and closing in on Wheeler when he only has experience in the minors.
Im not sure how Kurtz is HOFer Todd Helton but your comp of Rooker is below his own stat line of last year.
You say Kurtz has a chance to be a top 15 bat in 2-3 years….and Rooker was that last year. He is that now again if he repeats it. He was a top 5-10 bat last season.
I hope Kurtz crushes it but again, he has no MLB ABs yet. Every player has to adjust. Every player has a slump. It seems like he hasnt had to do that yet.
The league is littered with the corpses of guys who crushed lower levels and couldnt make it in the show. Stewart, Hermida, Young, Dom Brown, etc.
He seems to be on the road to success and the As give out PT like candy, which seems to work, and I prefer vs the Os be 30 with a mortgage and a minivan before you get youe cup of coffee.
Ugh
Need a bench bat Xavier Edwards, Vientos, Gurriel, Neto, durbin, Mountcastle
I like the upside of Vientos, he is heating up.
Vientos
Rodon baby! Now get him out of there!
Haha
Raise your hand if you started Woo but benched Francis!
If you need me I’ll be in the corner playing the saddest of trombones.
Why bench Francis? As an owner I wasnt scared of one Big Dumper and a bunch of crap. Besides, they benched Moore their hottest hitter for guys I wont even bother to lookup.
(Im middle of pack in pitching this week so I am still eyeing matchups vs down so much I throw anyone out there)
Narrow leads in both ERA & WHIP, neither of which Francis has been good for.
And I had more SP left than my opponent. Except I just lost a start. Doh.
Anyway the reason is because I overmanaged my squad instead of starting everyone and letting nature sort it out. Obviously.
You gotta manage. This is one where I wouldnt have been too scared because well it is the Ms. Doesnt mean they couldnt have lit him up. I almost, logically, benched Burnes because he sucks + Wrigley that turned out decent because I got lucky and no RP lived to tell the tale.
Yeah it felt like the safer play at the time. Also I didn’t have a chance to see the SEA lineup before setting mine.
Mariners I ignore JRod because who knows what he is going to do, see if Raleigh playing, and if any “hot” player is in. The rarely have more than one. Seems to work for me pretty well.
I benched Francis because I didn’t like his trending, so I ended up in the same boat as you in one league.
Curious what mean by trending. Im a Francis owner but by happenstance they true love. You thought the matchup was bad or he was due for a blowup or?
Im only asking because I dont believe it is something I look at and am wondering if I should be.
Just the v BAL ERA, but thought Woo would out pitch him anyhow… and I was wrong.
I thought Franics had another hiccup but I must be relating another pitcher with him. The 1.5 WHIP in the game before last wasn’t what I was looking for either.
Oops
This is the title of my autobiography if I ever write one.
HAHA
My boy Ragans needs to work on his efficiency.
Meh
Miserable damn effort, Ks aside.
Yeah giving up hits to Nido, Jfc
He looked great!
Signed,
My opponent has him.
Your take on the O’s being the worst run franchise ever is also spot on. The guys they are playing vs the prospects they have in their system or on the big team makes me scratch my head. They won’t trade any of those guys who are rotting in the minors either. Like they are hoarding them or something. They needed pitching and didn’t address it. They could trade for it but haven’t. Now Grayson Rodriguez is getting a second opinion on that shoulder. Yikes.
Remeber the Marlins had all of these pitchers who were good and healthy at one time. They didn’t move any of them while their hitting was terrible. So many of those pitchers got hurt and may never see anything close to that peak value again.
Coby Mayo’s been in AAA for 3 years, that’s nuts
Could you imagine if Butler, Soderstrom, Muncy, Wilson, and Kurtz where in the Orioles system?
“The Orioles called up Soderstrom today and this is his first MLB at bat. The 28 year old is making his first appearance in the majors and has spent the past decade in the minors.”
“Well it only took an injury to Eddie Rosario to get him up. Il bet he is disappointed he wasnt traded in that package last year.”
“Oh man, yeah that was quite the disappointment for the Os. Trading for a 40 year old Gausman and giving up Butler, Beavers, and Muncy didnt turn out all that well for the Orioles.”
“No it did not. As we all recall, Gausman’s arm detached on his 3rd pitch in an O’s uniform and he was carted off the field.”
“Well at least him and his arm were reunited before Ohtani’s robo-dog Decoy-800 got a hold of it. 2-1 pitch to Soderstrom…”
Speaking of the Os, is there some stat somewhere that keeps track of a player breaking up no hitters/perfect games? Mullins broke up a perfect game two nights ago I believe it was. Right now Os have 1 hit and 1 run courtesy of Mullins again.
Gotta start Mateo and his .067 BA at 2B though.
Let’s draft all hitters and no pitching, and see what happens. Then, we will refuse to trade for pitching, and never make a legit run. It will be epic!
12 Team H2H 6×6 OPS
Looking to add a multi positional bench bat from the following options:
Who’s your top 2 guys?
Maikel, Morel, G. Arias, Pavin, Fitz, Durbin
Thank you
Fitz, Durbin
50/50 if my kid came up with a batting lineup it would biggest #s or smallest #s in order.
Hinch in his infinite wisdom came up with this.
Yeah saw that lineup and thought who in their right mind would bat Ibanez cleanup LOL
Hinch overemphasizing that Ibanez does well vs lefties. Makes no sense with Tork doing well and Carp. Have him bat 6th or maybe let Torres leadoff and Ibanez at 2 if you reaaaally believe. Greene has been trash too and shouls be 5 or 6 as well. IDK why youd want those guys getting more ABs than Tork or Carp. Not sure why Malloy is leading off with McKinstry at 9 with a .150+ OPS advantage.
Tigers on board though because Tork walk, wild pitch, 2 out single for Nido. Just like they planned im sure.
Haha
Hinch better play the lotto. Ibanez goes 1-2 and then Ragans gets pulled so he puts in Sweeney who is hitting barely .200 and he goes 1-1. Odds of your two hitters who combine for like a .190 BA hitting .667 has got to be pretty out there.
That was painful to watch
Tigers BABIPing Royals to death. Hinch even PH .184 Malloy for .182 Keith who flied out. Guy is the “idk how to play roulette” but keeps winning in Vegas.
I watched it, it was a BABIP fiasco
Hi Grey…in a 12 team roto I have Alonso,Caminero and Vientos at my CI spots and Ozuna at DH. Do you see anyway I get Kurtz in the lineup short of injury or trade? Thanks!
No
12 team 5×5, is Chandler Simpson worth 5% FAB? $0 allowed
Not starving for speed but damn the hit took and speed are sick!!
Sounds fine
Why does Scheblers remind me of Stacy Keibler?
Pouring one out for my homey, Grayson…
Haha
wait, did they say something on Grayson?
He didn’t like what the first opinion said…
Another for Oneil. I think he enjoys hitting lead off
Indeed
Nice touch on the Kevin Maas reference. I also like the random Reds players throwback here and in your earlier post. Shout out to Austin Kearns too. The GST, two hours behind us on regression was classic. That’s brilliant!
Maas Appeal!
Kearns is a good one too!
I’ll consider us even for the Maas Appeal! :)
Ha
Luke Keaschall was just brought up by Minn — starting tonite at DH.F
Cool
May and Victor Scott for Sale in RCL format?
Sale
Would you add Moore if the only drop was Stott?
For more context I have Gimenez and Stott to fill My 2b. Can also drop Mountcastle for Moore. I have Alonso and Sodestrom to hold 1b
No
It doesn’t matter… he just went 7-14 with 4 RBI 2 HR and 2 SB over the last 3 games and is benched for the series opener…
Did you see what the penguin from Madagascar did when Wash pulled him? 72 pitches, 1 on first, 2 outs. Not the best outing but not sure anyone wants to be pulled there.
https://x.com/AnaheimSports1/status/1913045955546632391
Damn
What’s your take on Story? Is he back, or will he regress dramatically?
He won’t make it to May 15th
Ok, I have Story on my bench. I’ll drop him for a flier on Kurtz. I don’t want to drop Rice just yet..
ok
Heya Grey – want to add speedy Chandler Simpson and drop one of these 4 arms in a 14 team 5×5 roto:
– Jeffrey Springs
– E-Rod
– Wacha
– Mize
Thanks!
Springs
At least Simpson is up — Kurtz or Simpson?
Kurtz if both up
Since I have my Weekly waiver tomorrow, Kurtz or Simpson? Speed a bigger concern now, but obviously ~ 90% of season remains.
Simpson
Juan Soto or Tatis?
Soto
Carson Kelly is out of control! Hot start or just a random great catcher season? Kelly or Sean Murphy ros?
Hot start
Thanks!
No problem
In AL-only, would you rather have Miles Mastrobuoni or Jo Adell?
Ouch…Adell
I know. More of a bench bat, but still.
Yeah
I’m in a 10 team H2H league.
I have Bregman (3B), Guerrero (1B/3B), and Ben Rice (1B).
Rice has been on fire, but do you expect that Kurtz > Rice this year?
I have other players I can drop to pick up Kurtz.. I’m just not sure if its worth it.
Please advise.
Thank you Grey!
Kurtz>Rice
Weird – weather maps indicating it was blowing out at Wrigley but the box score said it was blowing in…
It was blowing out, I think!
Ha yeah, it would appear that it was!
https://swishanalytics.com/mlb/weather
And blowing out hard in a lot of other parks as well by the looks!
Yeah
Two useless guys — Luis Robert or Toglia?
Robert
Love that show
Grey, looking for some closure. Last week I traded Ben rice and Bubic for Michael Harris in my 12 team dynasty league. Did I F up? It seemed like a no brainer to me
Sounds fine
Sweet thanks
No problem
Carson K over YanierD?
Yainer
So I see bunch of game with really strong wind later. Would you bench any if your pitchers (relievers) if you have daily lineups. I didn’t realize how widespread this wind issue was
Depends on the pitchers and matchups
12 Team 6×6 ROTO (includes standard + .OPS for batters)
Just love your sense of humor, Grey!
With Simpson called up, would he look better in my OF over Burleson?
Thanks! He’d be better for SBs, but not sure how much Simpson plays
Gotcha, I tend to like the shiny new toys, but this helps with my decision, since Burleson covers other categories. Thank you el patrón!
No problem, I am el jefe
Haha! Noted. Your stache made me think of this el jefe
Very happy to read this. I just traded Tatis and Kahnle for skenes and Jung Ho Lee.
How do you rate that return for tatis?
That’s solid
Up against Kelly, Gurriel, & Suarez, so that’s… fun?
AZ / Cubs – like thanksgiving dinner… just putting balls on the middle of the plate.
Wait, what?
My opponent was 1/8. In the next 4 AB he’s 5/13 with 4 HR, 6 R & 12 RBI.
No lead is safe with these dogshit bullpens. Fortunately I’ve got 14 HR this week already, but that turned a 6 HR, 22 RBI lead into a 4 HR/10 RBI lead in a hurry.
Just unreal.
Ouch
I took a smoke break and happy Burnes got through 6th. I walk out of work wondering how he got demolished in 7th and apparently the entire pen just sucks. IDK if that makes me feel a little better about Burnes vs the same lineup or not.
Pressly randomly got the win
Are you taking Carson Kelly or Pedro Pages ROS? Sorry for the catcher question. Carson has had an incredible start, but Pages seems to play more and hasn’t been bad.
Is it close?
Thanks!
Kelly
I have Trevor Megill, so thinking of picking up Uribe as a safeguard. Worth dropping Kerkering for Uribe?
Also, Kikuchi is on the wire in my 12-team league. Worth dropping any of my lower SPs for him: Baz, Sasaki, Bradley (other SPs are Imanaga, Bibee, Ober, Framber). Thanks!
Yes
Nah, maybe Bibee after his next start
Okay, thanks! Have a great weekend!
1B help for league w/ positions of 1B, 1B/3B, and UT. I rostered Nick Kurtz, but have Christian Walker, Triston Casas, and Rhys Hoskins filling the positions listed. When Kurtz is available to play, who do I drop? Alternatively, who do I offer in trade? My thinking was to offer Walker for a better 2B than I have rostered (Matt McLain), but I can be persuaded to think differently.
Casas or Hoskins…can trade Walker maybe, none of these guys have any value to trade
Thanks for the unvarnished truth!
No problem
Who is impacted more by Simpson’s promotion – Wisner or Mangum?
Morel
Maybe Mangum
Not quite Tinkers to Evans to Chance, but Misner to Morel to Mangum does have some half baseball half legal firm ring to it.
HAHA
From reading the questions, I learned Simpson is being recalled (and Cash implies he will occasionally start). This really impacts my weekly plan (derived from many questions on your site).
12 team FAAB. I had decided to claim Misner (3%) with backup plan for 1% bids on Mangum; Kepler; and Bader.
(1) But will Simpson impact Wisner PT? and/or Mangum PT?
(2) How would you rate the FAABs: Simpson, Wiisner, Kepler, Bader?
(3) Would Simpson be worth a 2nd FAAB? — would mean cutting Toglia.
1. Yes 2. That order 3. Sure
Relief pitching not providing much, er, relief in Wrigley.
Yeah
18 runs in the last two innings!
just went thru every league of mine to get some sweet schadenfreude on Porter Hodge and he was benched in almost every league
Merryweather is the arm to own in that Cubby pen. And yes, I have Hodge in this week’s lineup. Although to be totally fair, Workman ole’d a ground ball to third Ruled a double. Cubs back in front Tucker two run bomb. Bears 12 Cardinals 11
It’s Merryweather, indeed, not Julian tho
Seiya in on the act now! Just as well – 0-5 in amongst that carnage wouldn’t have been a good look!
[lather self up to look at what dansby swanson’s done for my fantasy team] 1-for-5, infield single
@Grey: is simpson a must grab in 12 redraft roto leagues?
Yes
Wait a minute. Doyle on the bereavement list now? I call BS. What is he Tyreek Hill or covering up a leg injury? *checking notes* Oh wait. His was wife is expecting. Sorry. Carry on.
Hahaha
Really? Wait did they lose the child? :(((
@Grey: any concerns with Trea Turner in general? His statcast looks pretty blue. I know its still early, but would you be looking to buy low or stay away?
Seems like he’s on pace for his usual 20/20…maybe he hits .260 vs. .280
16 team keeper league, keep 5, yahoo, roto, 5×5.
give- Jasson Dominguez, Luke Jackson
get- Jake Burger, Sal Frelick
MY TEAM
CA- Pages. 1B- Mountcastle. 2B- Westburg. 3B- Jung. SS- Tovar. IN- India.
OF- Soto. OF- Harris. OF- Dominguez. OF- PvSmith. UT- Busch.
BN- Shaw, LAcuna, Saggese, Durbin, HyeKim, Amador, DeLuca.
IL- Herrera.
SP- Glasnow, King, Gray, Lodolo. IL- Rodriguez. IL- Cortes. IL- Myers
RP- Hoffman, Jackson, Kahnle, Santana, Pagan.
Sounds fair
Carson Kelly my goodness. What has gotten into him. I better pick him up to put a quick stop to this nonsense
Haha
Tatis for Kurtz/Crochett?
Which side?
Thanks!
Tatis, but could work out
Hey to the Hey!!!
Looked at The Heart of Darkness’s MiLB and college stats . . . dude’s never compiled a set of at bats with an average lower that .306. Yes please, I am gonna stash the shit out of you!
Also, what do you think about Francis tonight v SEA? SoN seems to be down at the moment.
LurrrrrrrvesyaS!
Hahahahaha, lurves! I’d go with Bowden there, SON seems fine
Thank ya thank ya!! And yes, bot seems to be working again for me now, too.
Commented on a comment on a comment below, but I picked up Caleb this morning (need steals along with everything else and love the multi-position), but that would be my spot for Simpson. Make the switch, or hold?
LURURURURURURUURURURURURVEAAAAAAAAA!
I’d go Caleb, lurver
Consider me complete. Because you.
No, you
Time to drop Shane McClanahan in 12 team roto league?
(1) Minimum risk that I miss a recovery — please rate: Veen; Toglia; Crews?
Note. Since I paid the most, I’m leaning on keeping Crews.
Veen, Crews
Lindor/bellinger/flahtery or tucker?
Tucker
Beliinger/flahtery or wood?
Wood
Drop Austin Wells for Carson Kelly?
Yes
HeyGrey,
Plz rank:
Lodolo, Boyd, T Myers
Thank you!
Myers, Boyd
Chandler Simpson called up. Drop Hyeseong Kim for him? Keep 13 forever.
Yes
Damn, I was too slow. Kim or Durbin keeper?
Durbin
1. Busch or Aranda? I think Aranda is a strong side platoon and Busch is playing everyday.
2. Which side ROS – Gunnar or Mookie in a 6×6 roto (Avg and OBP)?
Busch 2. Gunnar
CasASS out of lineup again today. I am getting more worried about him. Taking this this to DEFCON 2 now.
Yeah he stinks
I never want to drop a guy this early, but he is testing me. K’S are up. Frequently out of lineup. Sitting vs lhp now. I jave kurtz stashed. Would you cut casas in an obp format if kurtz is ever called up? I have manzardo in my ci spot now. I was high on casas for a couple of years but now I am wondering why. Outside of good 2nd half in 2023, what as he done?
Yeah, don’t disagree
As I’ve repeatedly said, Casas had a rib injury last year that doctors said was due to his hard swing. IMO, not easily corrected. He would have been a minimal keeper but I dropped him.
Yeah
Durbin or Otto Lopez?
Durbin
Chandler simpson being called up. Can he get on base? Will he play?
Maybe and maybe
Fair. You are the oracle so I had to ask. I need steals so bad right now .
Yeah, same
Sell the fun jewels? No way. Don’t say that!
Haha
I bought him last year he got hurt. Luckily I traded damaged goods
Would you rather add or Fitz or Kim? Any word on when Kim might get called up?
Fitz
Chandler Simpson a must add in 12 teams?
Not really sure where he even plays or how he gets in the lineup regularly other than pinch running. Could be a Blanco type situation with a couple starts a week. I thought the Rays sitatuion was bad before.
No idea where he plays but worth it for steals
Haha, needed Grey translating for me there. I def meant a couple steals a week not starts, though he might get those too. Would be weird to comp Blanco if I thought he would be starting.
Yeah
Yeah
Ditch a hours-ago-added Caleb for him?
Fantasy Master Lothario ! (Not abbreviated) I need a fill in for Doyle in a 10 team pts league. I can snag R. Greene or K. Carpenter. What say the leader of the fantasy baseballers??
Carp
Thank you
No problem
Austin Hayes expected HRs in Cincinnati over at Baseball Savant got me drooling like Pepe Le Pieu over a cat with a white stripe.
Haha
NL-only 10 teams roto
What’s your over/under on Jordan Romano saves in his 2025?
Would you drop since Alvarado seems to be the closer and Romano is not even next in line anymore it seems?
4, yeah drop
Kurtz or Mountcastle utl spot? H2H redraft pts. TIA
Kurtz if up
Kurtz or Mountcastle utl spot H2H redraft pts. TIA
Hey Grey. 12 team, H2H, 6×6 keeper. Drafted these guys as hold/keepers but might have to cut one or two. Please rate as keepers this year and next: Kurtz, Bassallo and Mayo? Thanks
You ranked them
Would you pull the trigger on a trade of my M.Miller for Clase and K. Campbell? I realize Clase comes with some concern so far this year. Current 2B options are Ceddanne and Otto (you may recall I essentially punted 2B in draft).
Alternatively, I could see if he’d part with Westburg instead of Campbell first.
13 team 6×6 with OPS and Holds
Sounds fair
Dude. Not Tatis. I know he’s an injury concern but he’s also showing out as a superstar right now. I’ll start looking for options but begrudgingly.
Last year I tried multiple times to sell Judge because I was sure he would get hurt. Nobody bit on offers and I’m sure glad they didn’t because he won me a championship
Help me understand listing him in the preseason top 10 knowing he’s an injury risk only to mention him as a sell a few weeks into the season
I hear ya
“a 10, just studly Moore” is the kind of thing I’m here for. Thank you, sir.
AND an MF Doom reference? Is this heaven?
Haha
Ha, No problem
A walking tour of Chernobyl sounds lovely! And who doesn’t love the static-y harmonies of the radiation detector!
By the way, did you see the movie on HBO? Good stuff! Also, maybe next time there is a nuclear disaster, they should alert (and evacuate?) the large city nearby. Just a tip from your Uncle Lar!
I did watch the series on it…it was great
I’ll watch anything with Jared Harris and/or Stellan Skarsgaard. Really need a smoldering, noirish detective series on some premium streaming service with those two. Maybe Emily Watson plays their overworked, cynical, world-weary boss. Yeah, that’s what we need. Harris is terrific in The Expanse. And Skarsgaard steals every scene in Andor. So maybe they can team up in again in some dystopian sc-fi caper.
Anyway, thanks for nudging me to sign Gabriel Arias. He’s 2B/3B/SS eligible in Yahoo. Blozzie Smith to the moon!
Blozzie to the moon!
Ok what am I looking to get out of Tatis?
Here is my roster. It’s a ten team points league
C- Murphy
1B Harper
2B McClain
3B Jazz
SS Gunnar
OF Tatis
OF Julio Rod.
OF Duran
SS/OF O’Neil Cruz
OF Doyle
Pitching
Imanaga
DeGrom
Bailey Ober
Soriano
Bryce Miller
Woo
Sasaki
IL
Kirby
Pablo Lopez
Eflin
And I have Fairbanks
You don’t have to get out
Oh just hold him? Yeah my offense is pretty stacked even for a ten team. Some wild picks were made in this league. One guy took Rutschman as his 2nd pick
I would sell him but for what matters
There are two teams who I could probably trade with
Sal Perez
Alonso
Paris
Chapman
London
Tesocar
Boot war
Juan Soto
Soderstrom
Luis Castillo
Clase
Mangle Ragans
Ray
Tanner Scott
Logan Webb
Fallen
Glasgow
Mize
Leiter
Snell
Team 2:
Langeliers
Freeman
Altuve
Machado
Adames
Yordan
Campbell
Edman
Ohtani
Goldschmidt
Flaherty
Kenley
Easton Lucas
Peterson
Pivetta
Rasmussen
Wesneski
Taj Bradley
Dollander
Gallen not Fallen
I don’t know what you need but you should be getting a top 10 bat, or top 20 and another piece…Tatis was a consensus top 10 bat
Got ya thanks!
No problem
Thank you as always! A couple rapid fire if i may?
SV/HLD league rest of season: Holton or Ashcraft?Is Semien worth keepin on the bench hoping for a reach, i mean turnaround? or just toss him?
bonus: when im swimming thru the joint i put my funk on hold. Why?
1. Holton 2. i don’t like Semien, but I wouldn’t drop him…I don’t know why do you put your funk on hold?
thanks!
cuz if ya dont you see the bubbles come up
hahaha…Thanks, actionpants!