LOGIN

If you say “Daylen Lile fast,” I say, “He is.” If you pronounce “Daylen Lile” fast, I say, “Don’t do that, you sound kinda racist.” If you say “Daylen Lile is strong,” I say, “He is compared to me.” If you say, “How strong are you?” I’ll say, “Not very.” If you say “Daylen Lile can hit for a great average,” I say, “This is true.” If you say “Daylen Lile makes great contact,” I say, “Yes, yes, yes!” If you say “Daylen Lile” when you walk into an Asian restaurant, I say, “What are you saying, man? I already told you, you have to say his name slow. Do you want the Cancel Police to arrest you?” If you say “Daylen Lile” to most people who played fantasy baseball this year, but were eliminated and are now only paying attention to fantasy football, they’ll say, “Who? Day’s Inn? Is that what you’re saying?” If you say “Daylen Lile is now hitting cleanup for the Nats, and one of the top outfielders in the last month for average and doing a little bit of everything, i.e., hitting for power and stealing bags,” I say, “Yes, and he has a 15% strikeout rate across just about every level and looks neutrally like a .275+ hitter with a 10/30 type capability in the big picture, but this isn’t about the big picture, this is about what he can do the final couple of weeks, and he can hit in that time.” If you say, “That’s a lot, can you just tell me to pick him up,” I say, “Pick him up.” Anyway, here’s some more players to Buy or Sell this week in fantasy baseball:

PSYCHE! This post was released a week early for Patreon members. It will be released all year early for Patreons, so if people are getting a jump on you, it’s because they paid the $10. Anyway, the Fantasy Baseball Buy/Sell:

BUY

Patrick Bailey – I write this post up by using mostly the 7-Day Player Rater, but I consult with the 30-Day Player Rater, and I did for Bailey and, well, he’s been good for the last week, but not at all for the three weeks prior.

Kyle Teel – Polar opposite of Patrick Bailey. Teel’s been great all 2nd half, though likely rostered in most leagues by now. Teel looks like he could be a top five catcher, as soon as next year. If you have Teel in a dynasty league, your leaguemates might be–don’t say it don’t say it don’t say it–green with envy!–ugh, he said it.

Jake Burger – Nomnomnomnom Burger! Nomnomnomnom hot schmotato!

Josh Bell – From Burger to Bell, the story of me walking across the street from Burger King to Taco Bell.

Jake Bauers – Not entirely sure of his playing time, but the Brewers could turn a baseball glove rested on top of a mop into a worthwhile cornerman. Or starter. Or outfielder. Okay, the Brewers are the best coached team in MLB.

Jared Triolo – He has some speed and power and has been somewhat hot, so don’t take this the wrong way, but he makes a lot of contact, and it is such awful contact his BABIP and average are that of a guy with, like, a 30% strikeout rate who is molasses slow. Just hideous stuff.

Brett Baty – At some point, Baty and Vientos are going to both breakout. One will be on the Padres and one on the Dodgers. I kid. I think.

Brayan Rocchio – One word here, ownership numbers are over the cutoff for this post for guys like Otto Lopez, Matt McLain and Luis Garcia, but if they’re around, by all means, pick them up.

Andrew Benintendi – His family came through Ellis Island and was given that last name, because his great-grandfather, Benin, was hogging all the Ellis Island cafeteria chicken tenders. I’m just a trivia buff.

Austin Hays – His career stats year over year show one thing that is undeniable. If he’s in 150 games or 100, he’s going to go 16/5/.270-ish every single year. How does one “ish” but “every single year” since the nature of “ish” is a vague hedge that isn’t concrete? Um, what was the question again?

Harrison Bader – With Treat Urner out, Bader was moved up to the leadoff spot and with that great responsibility comes great power–Well, not great power, but more runs and he’s hitting for a good average over the last week.

JJ Bleday – I could point out how he was a preseason sleeper, but that’s only embarrassing for both of us. Me because I wrote it, and you because you believed me. Let’s move on!

Jung Hoo Lee – Starting to become apparent that Lee is only good in April and September. In the biz, we call that Lion Lambless. “In like a lion” but without the “out like a lamb.” Okay, no one calls it Lion Lambless, but I’m trying to make it happen. Call him Lion Lambless!

Parker Meadows – I won’t write another sleeper post for him this offseason, but I will be strongly thinking it.

Brandon Marsh – Mentioned this a couple weeks ago, but there’s only so many tidbits to talk about with Marsh. It’s either his beard or this: It’s so fascinating how he’s a top five BABIP guy in the history of baseball for guys with 2,000+ plate appearances.

Max Kepler – Phils are coming off a great series vs. the Mets, where they hit well, up and down the order. From Bader to the Max!

Michael Helman – Did you know Helman’s just an emulsification? It’s trivia. Tell someone you want to annoy.

Jeremiah Jackson – Just gave you my Jeremiah Jackson fantasy. It was written while going marshmallow digging in a box of Lucky Charms.

Parker Messick – This is a Streamonator call like the call it makes to the law firm handling the liquidation of Bed, Bath and Beyond.

Slade Cecconi – This is also a Streamonator call. “Was wondering if you knew where the toasters were they used to carry. No, I don’t need a toaster. I need a button, my nipple fell off.”

Brad Keller – This could also be Andrew Kittredge for Cubs’ saves or even, God forbid, Porter Hodge. If it’s Hodge, the Cubs are trying to up their draft pick for next year.

Andrew Saalfrank – I keep highlighting Saalfrank and saves in the desert keep going to like Woodford or whoever else is in the bullpen coach’s eye line when the phone rings.

Ryan Walker – Giants have been winning and Walker has been getting the bulk of save opportunities. Notice how I didn’t say the bulk of the saves. [parrot on shoulder nods head] Polly, understand!

JoJo Romero – Cards’ saves could also be Riley O’Brien aka ROB, and if he were friends with Jac Caglianone or J.D. Davis, they’d tell him to call himself Rob O’Brien.

SELL

Jackson Merrill – This guy sucks. I don’t know what his deal is. You trust him for next year? You’re a more trusting fellow than I, I say in weird English. I don’t think I can get back in. This isn’t about next year though. This is about what this schmohawk is doing this year and it’s a lot of nothing. Yo, Jackson Merrill, guess what? Bryan Reynolds called and said the House of Yawns is all filled, we don’t need you! Though, if this were a dynasty league, I wouldn’t trade Jackson Merrill for a ride on the Mad Hatter Tea Cups right after someone got sick, but I would go to the Fantasy Baseball Trade Analyzer and analyze some trades.

Oneil Cruz – Yet another schmohawk that we need to make waste! “Make waste” is such a badass thing to say, unless used as, “I’m going to MAKE WASTE,” he loudly announced to the entire Taco Bell as he walked into the restroom. Oneil Cruz is another one where I’m not sure what to think for next year. I needs to do some soul searching, soul sista, but one thing that is clear, you can find better guys on waivers in just about every league because of how bad Cruz has been for over a month-plus. Though, if this were a dynasty league, I wouldn’t trade Oneil Cruz for a sign to hang on my bathroom that reads “Make Waste Room,” but I would go to the Fantasy Baseball Trade Analyzer and analyze some trades.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

131 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Sad Keanu
Sad Keanu
1 month ago

Would you bench either suzuki or pca for lile the final week?

Larry
Larry
1 month ago

McLean vs. Washington, Sheehan vs. Philly or Ranger Suarez at Dodgers. Who gets demoted this week?

Fred Garvin MP
1 month ago

Hoping McLean reins in his control/command. He looked like Cease in the first.

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Fred Garvin MP
1 month ago

Something I noticed about Cease last night was when he got 2 strikes batters would dare him to throw a 3rd. It seemed to be the strategy against him and he would get a 1-2 count and end up with a full one (and he would get a K at the end). I hope Cease gets a new pitching coach or starts listening if he isnt. That team swung at everything Sears threw the night before.

J.R.
J.R.
1 month ago

Oneil Cruz flashing that MLB glove

https://bdata-producedclips.mlb.com/d667434f-2b7f-4361-868b-c32450e0eef5.mp4

*not an error per official scorer*

hondo
hondo
Reply to  J.R.
1 month ago

The worst is when it actually hits them dead center in the glove and they drop it, and it’s still called a hit under the new Manfred/Vegas official scoring system.

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  hondo
1 month ago

I still dont get that one. I swear it was an error as a kid.

Turning Point
Turning Point
1 month ago

Who would you drop among Adolis,McLain or Tovar? Thanks!

j c
j c
1 month ago

…and of course a holds question!
Please pick one for championship week:
Keller 7 games (at Pitts, at Cincy)
Santillian 7 games (at StL, vs Cubs)
Cleavenger 7 games (vs Tor, vs Bost)
Morejon, Koenig are the other faves but have six games

j c
j c
1 month ago

I appreciate that managers are shuffling their lineups and rotations especially at this time of year. Makes it hard to stream when matchups change. ESPN had a story about Misi’s start moving up a day to Saturday but when you click on the game in their app they still had him starting Sunday. They are awful.
Ok, now that that is over, is there a better site, platform to use to gain insights in to starting pitching schedules? I don’t need them a week in advance since they change so much but two days out would be nice.

hondo
hondo
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Batphone?

J.R.
J.R.
1 month ago

Man Ryan lasted 4IP (only 2ER) but 93 pitches !!!! Nelson at 46 pitches in the same 4.

How many of these batters you think will be on an MLB roster next year? I cant believe how bad this group is.

Screenshot_20250913-193020
J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Speaking of ridiculous; Angels manager(s). I swear every game I tune in on it is them letting their SP get deep into trouble and knocking themselves out of a game. Farris 4IP in a 2-3 game. 72 pitches in 4IP but crazy wild. Send him for 5th, let him load bases by walks, ans then pull him.

In Oakland somehow Butler has 3 SB in 4 innings

Last edited 1 month ago by J.R.
SteveNZ
1 month ago

My guys out there giving it their all…

IMG_6243
SteveNZ
Reply to  SteveNZ
1 month ago

.

IMG_6244
SteveNZ
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Er no. And Varsho has just done it again!

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  SteveNZ
1 month ago

I feel you! My team has treaded water to move on last two weeks. They hit .198 last week and .207 this week…..a roster that hit .259 on the year and has only 1 person hitting under .240, Adames. Not sure how it is possible! Then I tune in and see my guys doing god awful swings and I turn it off.

SteveNZ
1 month ago

Never picking up Josh Lowe again. Apparently he can’t hit right-handed pitching either.

Big Dog
Big Dog
1 month ago

Hey Grey: Would you stream Scherzer today at home versus Baltimore?

Big Dog
Big Dog
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Thank you very much. I wasn’t as confident as SON so I wanted to get your blessing.

J.R.
J.R.
1 month ago

Seager update from Bochy, “Seager is able to rotate his body.”

…..why do they make it sound like he fell out of a helicopter from 50 feet vs getting his appendix removed? I had to double check what he went on the IL for when I heard that.

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Hahahaha

Well Skubal they said his MRI came back negative on his oblique. I am not sure what that means as I assume there would be some kind of…image if he hurt it even if just a minor?

Or is this the he is okay and they throw him out there game 1 and they go oh jeez it was the arm all along. Someone should have looked at that too.

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Me too! Bad enough where he felt like he couldnt keep pitching because of discomfort to today they said he might be a go for his next start? They said they have already cleared him. Not that I want anything bad to happen, but at least tell me he pulled a muscle or had to take a crap idk. lol

This whole leave game but not hurt has me side-eyeing the docs/testing/reporting. Volpe been hurt since May (!), Tucker, etc.

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Maybe Tigers front office is as delusional as some of their fans?

Mid-summer I had a discussion with some guys at a bar (and this sentiment echoed online) how THIS was the best Tigers team they had seen in their lifetime. They were mid-40s. Im like uhhh, better than a lineup with MIGUEL FRICKING CABRERA, Prince Fielder, VMart, JD Martinez?

A rotation of Verlander, Scherzer, Anibal Sanchez, Fister, Porcello? When we had 3 pitchers with 200Ks in the same rotation!?!?!

I get it is exciting they are winning and it sure as hell beats losing but the rotation is Skubal & Friends and the lineup is a patchwork of 3 decent hitters and the rest praying to the BABIP gods.

If they dont bubble wrap Skubal for the playoffs on a team with an 8 game lead in their division with 14 games left I dont know what to say.

Plus, imo, Cy Young repeat is safe so what is the the push to make him start next go around?

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

So I looked at the schedule. The Guardians are 6.5 back and the Tigers play them 6 times in the games they have remaining. Im suddenly nervous.

Honey Nut Chourios
1 month ago

12 team, 5×5 roto. 1250 Max IP. 93 Innings Remaining (+16.1). Wins and WHIP are most important categories at the moment.

Start Bello v. NYY? (Fried) ($0.5)

the old professor
the old professor
1 month ago

Noelvi Marte a breakout candidate ( cheap last round keeper) in 2026?

Braves233
Braves233
1 month ago

Choose 2 between Mize at marlins, darvish vs Rockies, cecconi vs white Sox

MartinRostoker@aol.com
1 month ago

Manny Machado is struggling. Would you pick up Burger, Chapman or Vientos to play until Machado starts to hit or hold?

would you believe that 14 points separate 6, 7, 8 and 9 positions in my Yahoo points league?

Thanks again!!

martinrostoker@aol.com
1 month ago

I started Tong – need I say more. Would you start Sproat?

Do you have confidence on starting Darvish at home vs CO?

Do you have confidence in starting Messick at home vs CWS?

Have a great weekend!

martinrostoker@aol.com
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Thank you! Your patience and help is much appreciated!!

j c
j c
1 month ago

1. Bednar or Kitterage next week? Both have 7 games on the road. Bednar at Twins and Orioles. Kitterage at Pirates and Reds. Saves and holds both welcomed as the Cubs situation may be fluid?
2. Schlitterer and Yanks solid favorites next week as he faces Zebby at Twins. Quintana not been as good I think but good home matchup vs Angels and Hendricks. Only 7 moves per week. Which one? Or both if I can swing it?

Mike
Mike
1 month ago

Overall strategy question.

Daily H2H points, K’s 2.5, SVS 8, HLDS 5, WIN 3 but blown save situation -6, ER -2, hit -.5, BB -1, and loss -2.

So a good relief appearance can be really nice! A bad one can spiral out.

Would you rather carry a bench batt into the semi-finals, like a Royce Lewis for example, and plug him in if one of the regulars ride pine, or pickup Tanner Scott, a guy who can sit in a pitcher spot all week.

Feels like a classic risk/reward type situation.

SteveNZ
1 month ago

Fernando Cruz in the game. Prayer circle time!

J.R.
J.R.
1 month ago

Cruz just plays like he doesnt care. It sucks you stuck there but come on dude at least look likey you are trying.

https://mlb-cuts-diamond.mlb.com/FORGE/2025/2025-09/12/cbdda07c-ab43d1b3-56004367-csvm-diamondgcp-asset-4000K.mp4

Chucky
Chucky
1 month ago

Finals week, sentiments notwithstanding, Mookie a better option at SS than Elly and Gunder, who just might be Fantasy’s biggest disappointment?

Chucky
Chucky
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Elly is t doing any better with his 627 OPS since the ASB

J.R.
J.R.
1 month ago

Skubal and deaperation start Tong have given up 9 ER. All the other teams in the league have given up 7 runs combined. Kill me now.

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Skubal hurt and removed. Unclear what it is but arm related id assume.

Also, his ERA is like double when Rogers catches him vs Dingler. Guess who was catching him tonight?

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Yeah hopefully nothing long term. I cant really see that team going deep in the playoffs even with him. Just an uneven squad design where I dont see them as very threatening.

Schmohawks Bob
Schmohawks Bob
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

It’s been reported that way. So great it’s not an arm or shoulder.

The Wild Card
The Wild Card
1 month ago

Who you bench tonight Acuna vs Houston bullpen, teo vs verlander or soderstrom vs singer

The Wild Card
The Wild Card
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Thx. I just can’t bring myself to bench acuna even if he is 4 for his last 37

foxman
foxman
Reply to  The Wild Card
1 month ago

Acuna HR
He’s alive!!!!

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  The Wild Card
1 month ago

Soderstrom is hurt now :(

Life of Brian
Life of Brian
1 month ago

Redraft, 12 team, standard 5×5 roto.

1. 3B: Hold Durbin, or drop for 1 of: Barger, Clement, Caballero, Burger, Kemp, Moncada?

2. Acuna Jr. has sucked long enough to finally come off of Yahoo’s Can’t Cut list. Anyway, OF: Hold Acuna and Butler, or drop for 1 or 2 of: Teoscar, Bauers, Kepler, Kemp, Helman, Bleday, Benintendi?

Thank you.

MJ888
MJ888
1 month ago

Hey Grey – I’m confused on the Merrill sarcasm. Do you like him for next year or not? Our league has center field as a position, and it’s typically hard to find a good centerfielder! I am being offered Merrill for Tatis. I’m leaning towards doing it as I am pretty sick of Tatis at this point.

Bob Burda
Bob Burda
1 month ago

I cut Cruz yesterday after waiting a year and a half for his raw skills to translate into actual results. He just seems disinterested.
I agree with you that Merrill is beginning to approach Bryan Reynolds in the all-boringness department. Glad I cut him last year just before he started sucking.

Dirt McGirt
Dirt McGirt
1 month ago

Playoff matchup, OPS, AVG, STL league. Start One:

Altuve @ ATL (Waldrep)
L. Sosa @ CLE (Bibee)

toolshed
1 month ago

So are the Rays waiting for Baz’s arm to fall off before they shut him down? Same goes with Rasmussen who they were pulling at 3 innings earlier and is now going 6 ip more often than not. I don’t get it.

Honey Nut Chourios
1 month ago

12 team, 5×5 roto. 1250 Max IP. 106 innings remaining (+11)

Start Bassitt v. BAL? ($23)

chairmanguy
chairmanguy
1 month ago

I just saw that Woodruff is getting bumped to Wednesday. Terrific. I guess I go to the waiver wire for some help this week.

Malicious Phenoms
Malicious Phenoms
1 month ago

As I get older my health continues to be an issue. Diagnosed with nonop Prostrate cancer

Malicious Phenoms
Malicious Phenoms
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Thanks man

Keith Hernandez' cat
Keith Hernandez' cat
Reply to  Malicious Phenoms
1 month ago

Prostate cancer survivor here. Follow all the medical recommendations. 99.8% chance you’ll die of something else. If we had 99.8% odds on anything in fantasy, we’d take it, right? God bless

Troy
Troy
1 month ago

Both Elly and O’neal have been poor for a while…Elly at least contributing some, but not like the first half. No HR in over a month!

JKM
JKM
1 month ago

Dropping the ice cold Harris II for the likes of Wallner or O’Neill (just activated) in 12 team redrafts?

JKM
JKM
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Yeah, agree… thx!

lets play 2
lets play 2
1 month ago

Okay, follow-up from my question this morning after this buy and sell post: drop Josh Lowe for Meadows or Bell.

lets play 2
lets play 2
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Got it. Thanks! Enjoy the weekend!

It Burnes when I Imanaga
1 month ago

Need a streamer for Saturday:
Elder v. Houston
Davis Martin @ CLE
Farris @ Seattle
Corbin @ Mets
Alvarez v. PIT

Thanks!

It Burnes when I Imanaga
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Thanks Grey!

Who would be your next 2 options?
In the last 2 days of a 2 week H2H playoff and may need to accumulate some counting stats.

It Burnes when I Imanaga
Reply to  Grey
1 month ago

Thanks!

Turning Point
Turning Point
1 month ago

What are your thoughts on stashing Gerrit Cole as a two year keeper?

McLain or Ozuna for 2026?

Thanks!

Dancin Homer
1 month ago

Just read that Chase Burns was activated from the IL, Woo Hoo! …. wait, activated to be used in a relief role.. (stupid Flanders!)

I assume there’s no reason to hold for this season, right?

Larry
Larry
1 month ago

Teel or Augustin Ramirez?

martinrostoker@aol.com
1 month ago

test- having problems posting. might be on my end.