LOGIN

Bubba Chandler is ready. When the Pirates will call him up is your guess = my guess. Jac Cannoli is ready and the Royals could use hitting, but where is he going to play? I don’t know. Roman Anthony is ready, but he’s more “Where is he going to play” than Cannoli. At least Jac Mambo-Italiano can DH. By the by, Jac Caglianone is the second coming of J.D. Davis. Not in any way other than his name uses his last name for his first name, which always cracks me up. The D in J.D. Davis is for Davis. So, it’s Jonathan Davis Davis. Jac Caglianone is the same; Jac is actually an abbreviation of Jeffrey Alan Caglianone. So, it’s Jeffrey Alan Caglianone Caglianone. The more you know (about things you didn’t want to know). And this post isn’t even about Jac Caglianone! (Though, if he were called up tomorrow, I’d say grab him in all leagues.) This is about the Red Sox losing Casas, asking Devers to play 1st base, Devers saying, “Thanks, but no thanks.” Devers should’ve said, “If I play 1st, I’m going to throw every grounder to third base, because I’m dyslexic,” that would’ve actually been a reason. Any hoo! Not re-litigating that! After Devers said he wasn’t playing 1st, they started Kristian Campbell taking grounders at 1st, he said, “Whatever it takes for the team to win,” ooh, burn, Devers, and now Marcelo Mayer is next up, leapfrogging Roman Anthony. I think! This is all very convoluted. Oh, and Trevor Story has sucked for, well, how long has he been in Boston? So, why isn’t Story playing 1st and Mayer playing his natural position? I told you, confusing! Mayer is a power-first middle infielder, who has some speed, and shouldn’t kill you in average. Think what we thought we were getting from Ozzie Albies, who seemingly retired after the 2023 season. Roman Anthony’s tools are louder than Mayer, Jeffrey Alan Caglianone Caglianone will get the papers papers and the power power more, but Marcelo Mayer appears next up, and is no slouch. Literally, he missed half of last year with a lumbar strain. Anyway, here’s some more players to Buy or Sell this week in fantasy baseball:

PSYCHE! This post was released a week early for Patreon members. It will be released all year early for Patreons, so if people are getting a jump on you, it’s because they paid the $10. Anyway, the Fantasy Baseball Buy/Sell:

BUY

Drake Baldwin – We’re witnessing history in Atlanta. Snitker, who is the most set it and forget manager in baseball, sometimes penciling in a player who no longer plays for them, because he doesn’t want to change the lineup, is actually toying with Baldwin becoming the starter over Sean Murphy.

Carlos Narvaez – When I was perusing catchers to put in here, I saw Alfredo Duno, and I was more like, “Alfredo Dunno,” and I laughed at myself for 45 minutes until the authorities had to have Cougs sign a paper to take me away.

Gabriel Moreno – Got hot this week and that tracks since Gabby is a hot girl name.

Wilmer Flores – Wanna hear something crazy? Listen to the P. Diddy trial. Wanna hear something crazy about fantasy baseball? I’ve had Flores for almost the entire year in my RCL, and he’s been a top five 1st baseman overall. Almost as good as Pete Alonso. In case you’re not picking up what I’m putting down, Flores has been good, and the 1st basemen are very bad. And not like “a bunch of baddies,” like your niece would say.

Nolan SchanuelHitter-Tron loves to stick its dipstick into electrical outlets and Schanuel.

Kody Clemens – We were so close to losing Baldelli forever, but the Twins had to rattle off 13 straight wins and now The Baldelli Platoons are here to stay for at least another year. Right now, Clemens is platooning out of DH. Wonder if Fernando Tatis Sr. reached out to Roger Clemens and was like, “You should train your boy like I trained mine, wink, wink, nudge, nudge, kazoo. Needle in the butt!”

Chase Meidroth – I before E, except for a contact-first middle infielder on the White Sux. He looks like a neutral .280 hitter, as a 23-year-old rookie, which is good, and he could steal 20 bags, while hitting five-ish homers. (And getting 45 runs in 500 ABs out of leadoff.)

Hyeseong Kim – In any other lineup, Kim would be a leadoff hitter and starting every day. In the Dodgers’ lineup, he might only start three times a week in the nine-hole.

David Hamilton – This is more of a short-term buy for steals, because Hamilton should be a bench guy on the Red Sox at best, if Mayer and Campbell are doing what they’re supposed to do. Unless Story has the decency to strain a hamstring.

Matt Shaw – Already gave you my Matt Shaw fantasy. It was written while out gallivanting with the boys.

Jake Burger – Gave you my Jake Burger fantasy. It was written while drinking a Celsius and buzzing around a room.

Miguel Vargas – Wanted to depress myself so I looked at when I dropped Vargas — in a league where I need hitting — and it was about a month ago, then I went to look at where Vargas was on the 30-day Player Rater. Around top 50! Perfection!

Will Benson – It’s not too late in the year for a random Reds outfielder to come out of nowhere and have his one huge season, as told by the prophecy of Scott Schebler.

Ramon Laureano – His Chase% has plummeted (a good thing) and he was a worthwhile outfielder at one point in his career. It was pre-PEDs suspension — pre-susPEDsion? — but still.

Robert Hassell III – Here’s what I said the other day, “Will be called up to replace Crews. The Third Hassell was a prized piece of the Soto trade, then everything went kablooey and he started hitting .189 in Single-A. Bobby Barrels does have speed, but his nickname seems sarcastic at this point, as he hit .241 last year in the minors, and makes a ton of weak, ground ball contact. Maybe he can figure it out, and remind people why they were once excited for this trilogy.” And that’s me quoting me!

Matthew Lugo – Been meaning to go over Lugo for some time now (a few days at best). He has 25/25 abilities, and hit .212 this year in Triple-A, which is so hilarious. How inept are the Angels at developing players when they have a guy who can barely hit over .200 in the minors, and they call him up. By the way, he hit .242 with a 27.6 K% in Double-A in 2023, and promoted him to Triple-A after that!

Jordan Beck – Saw Taylor Ward at only 56% rostered, which is above where he needs to be to be included in this post, but, guess what, Jordan Beck is also at 56% rostered, so sue me! (“Sue me” is a colloquial phrase and is not binding contract for you to sue me.)

Michael Soroka – This is a Streamonator call, like the call it makes to a hardware shop.

Jose Soriano – This is also a Streamonator call. “I saw you had a sign in your window, so you have Nuts N. Bolts? No, I’m sorry. I was talking about a guy I went to high school with.”

Jordan Romano – If it makes you feel any better about rostering Romano, A) He was acquired to be the closer. No idea what was going on in April. B) Outside of his ERA, his stats don’t look much different than his last great year when he saved 36 games. C) There’s no C.

Will Vest – Should’ve been the closer for the whole season, but, in fairness, Tommy Kahnle has been as excellent. They’re both worth rostering.

Shelby Miller – Unlike the Tigers’ pen situation, the DBacks’ closer should’ve been Miller for the last few weeks, and he might not even get the next save. Though, that’s because Justin Martinez might be healthy again.

Daniel Palencia – There’s no easy fix for the Cubs pen’s troubles, and his name isn’t Daniel Panacea. Also, in the Cubs’ pen is Brad Keller and Drew Pomeranz, two guys who attended Mariano Rivera’s winter seminar at the Parsippany, New Jersey Ramada titled, “Hey, Failed Starters? Kickstart Your Bullpen Careers!”

Griffin Jax – His 5+ ERA is clouding the good stuff under the hood. Jax loox spextactular. His Contact% is 66.7. Tarik Skubal is 65.8% and is the only starter with a better Contact%. Jax not allowing any contax! Zoinx!

SELL

Kodai Senga – Some of these Sells are harder than others because I have the player. This one is super easy since I don’t have Senga anywhere. Haha, suckers! Though, if being honest, that causes me to be extra careful because I don’t want to tell you to sell a player simply because I want them to be worse, since I don’t have them. I don’t think that’s what’s going on here. His underlying numbers are very meh — 8.4 K/9, 3.9 BB/9, velocity down a mile on his fastball, chase rate is incredible meh, about the same as Luis Severino. If Senga had a 4+ ERA, I’d say he’s pitching about that well. That he has a 1-something ERA is goofy. I wouldn’t sell Kodai Senga for a ride in a horse-drawn pedicab after the horse ate Taco Bell, but I would go to the Fantasy Baseball Trade Analyzer and explore options.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

257 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Johnny Tsunami
Johnny Tsunami
1 hour ago

With Finnegan gone do you think Cole Henry might see saves? Ferrer and lopez are trash right?

Coconut Willie
Coconut Willie
2 hours ago

Mayer or Norby? I just dropped Vientos for Norby

Thanks much

Spencer
Spencer
3 hours ago

Would you drop either of Luis Garcia jr or Ryan mountcastle for Mayer or Kody Clemens? If so, how much would you bid on each of them with a $816 of a $1000 salary?

Thanks as always for the advice my team has been turning the corner lately!

Little Jerry Seinfeld
Little Jerry Seinfeld
3 hours ago

Glossary term for when your starter gives up 3 runs in the first inning but still ends up with a quality start?

J.R.
J.R.
4 hours ago

Last place in AL and 2nd to last in all of MLB yourrrrrrrr Baltimore Orioles!

(That’s right CWS are now ahead of them! *cries in corner*)

Last edited 4 hours ago by J.R.
Bestsella
Bestsella
5 hours ago

Need your trade advice. Would you trade Springer and Wacha for Gunner and Littell? Thank you as always for your insight

J C
J C
5 hours ago

Couple of options here:
1. Would you trade for B Reynolds giving up C Estevez? Bryan getting a few hits lately. But Carlos by far my most consistent RP.
I have Bautista, Iglesias, Vest too.
My OF is Tucker, Teoscar, Scott (must have a CF), Ward and Beck.
Utility is Santander.
2. Abbott or Pages? A Pages on the WW. I have Crochet, Wheeler, Yamamoto, Bibee, Ranger, Abbott and Henderson on my staff.
3. Which of these two do you prefer if any as I can only do one

Larry
Larry
5 hours ago

Noot or Jasson Dominguez?

Cohen
Cohen
7 hours ago

G.Williams home vs Dodgers or
Bibee home vs Dodgers?

hal_incandenza
8 hours ago

Sorry Wacha owners. My bad.

CharlesHustler
CharlesHustler
8 hours ago

Hey Grey Happy Memorial Day weekend!!

12 team 5×5 1 C league

Would you drop Jeffers for Narvaez, Baldwin or Keibert? Also Ruiz and Stephenson FA

I am thinking just add the hottest guy every 4-5 days but I may miss out on the annual Jeffers HR binge LOL

Hal
Hal
9 hours ago

Please rank Mayer, Beck, and Doyle.

The Judge
The Judge
9 hours ago

Kurtz,Mayer or Vientos? Can only roster 1. Thanks!

Hal
Hal
9 hours ago

What sort of numbers are you expecting from Mayer?

Steven33
Steven33
9 hours ago

Would you start Senga vs LAD?

Herschel
Herschel
9 hours ago

@Grey: is their a glossary term for when you nail the Buy call up? Well done! $134 of $250 FAAB remaining and starting Ozzie at 2b. How much to drop to get him?

J.R.
J.R.
10 hours ago

Mayer is getting the call!

Duda Want to Build a Snowman?
Duda Want to Build a Snowman?
10 hours ago

Hey Grey! What are your thoughts on Robert Suarez compared to Will Vest?

Other team is trying to get my Suarez for his Will Vest plus Baez Wilson or Tork. Thoughts?

Only other closer is Megill

Thanks!

Duda Want to Build a Snowman?
Duda Want to Build a Snowman?
Reply to  Grey
9 hours ago

I need HR and rbi but in theory have that a bit from Yordan and Westburg whenever they decide to return…

Duda Want to Build a Snowman?
Duda Want to Build a Snowman?
Reply to  Grey
9 hours ago

Thanks!

J C
J C
10 hours ago

I have four RPs in our H2H league….Iglesias, Bautista, Estevez, Vest. I prefer to carry three and trying to look at this list long term since the playoffs are months away. Should I hold since I am near the top of the standings and am not pushed to make a move or drop one for Pages, Simpson, B Lowe? These would be my only bench bat at this time. BTW, I only drafted one of these RPs and wished I did not draft any. Back to SAGNOF

J C
J C
Reply to  Grey
9 hours ago

Good. I obviously was leaning that way. I’d rather package one with a SP or lighter bat for a better bat. Or just wait a few weeks and see where we are. The Dodgers would have had Bautista and Iglesias on IL a week ago.

tommybones
10 hours ago

Standard Roto ROS: Bryan Reynolds or Andy Pages?

hondo
hondo
12 hours ago

Your comment to someone else the other day about holding the letter button down on your phone to get the tilde was a rare valuable real life lesson learned from Razzball.
Do you know how to get dried grout off of bathroom tile?

Kitt Yerg, Esq.
Reply to  hondo
11 hours ago

Commerical grout haze remover, Zep Grout Cleaner and Brightner

Daze
Daze
12 hours ago

Grey
I know I asked this of you a couple of weeks ago. But sorry I am asking again to see if you are changing your answer.
10 team league.
Would you drop Adolis Garcia for Austin Hays.
Thanks again.

martin rostoker
martin rostoker
12 hours ago

Thanks for working on Memorial Day!

Would you start or sit Wacha on the road at Minn?

Have a great day!

martin rostoker
martin rostoker
Reply to  Grey
11 hours ago

Thank you!

Dancin Homer
12 hours ago

Morning & Happy National Asparagus Day!

Let’s make our pee stink!!!

Speaking of, due to some IL activations, I’ll need to expel someone from the roster b/c 3 bench bats is too many. Full roster below, who gets tossed down the drain? (6×6, OPS/QS):

C: William Contreras
1B: C. Walker
2B: K. Marte
3B: Shaw
SS: Tovar
IF: Goldschmidt
OF: Soto, Tatis, Heliot
UTL: Happ, Stott
BN: Gleybar, Vientos, Nootbaar

SP: M. King, B. Miller, Schwellenbach, Taj Bradley, Flaherty, Kirby, ASS, M. Meyer, Olson (IL)

RP: Duran, Hoffman, Romano, Iglesias

IL (3 slots): Ohtani (P), Seager, Bryce Miller

Thanks as always!

Dancin Homer
Reply to  Grey
11 hours ago

Thanks.

What’s the deal with Vientos too? I had high hopes for him this season and he’s basically just been stinky pee!

Also, thoughts on Nootbaar ROS – worth holding or can be cut for a hot schmotato?

Thanks again!!

Hebrew Hammer
Hebrew Hammer
12 hours ago

14 team h2h hlds/svh league.

My RPs: Hader, J Adams, Hoffman, Tyler Rogers, Alvarado (dropped).

Need to fill SVH void. I picked up Dylan Lee after Iglasis blew third straight save, but Braves using Pierce for saves, Daysbel Hernandez in mix.

Options on wire:

Strahm
J. Bird
Daysbel
Sands
Leasure
Mason Montgomery

Also, would you drop Pepiot and/orPfadt for: N Cameron, Rea, Irvin or Slade?

Thankyou

Draft Dodgers
Draft Dodgers
12 hours ago

Is there a phrase for a guy who doesn’t go on IL but sits every other day? Santander is borderline anyway but not going on the IL hurts more. Need him to go so I can get a player in there.

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Draft Dodgers
11 hours ago

Being a Brave.

For all my fellow owners of Riley last year.

jcindaville
jcindaville
12 hours ago

Would you start Elfin at Boston today?

Bad Mother Tucker
Bad Mother Tucker
13 hours ago

12 team, 5×5 roto

SON doesn’t love them today, but we are starting right?

Liberatore v. ARI (-$8.8)
Abbott v CHC (-$16.8)

Dbrezzy
Dbrezzy
13 hours ago

Drop Roupp to activate mize? Or hold

Bad Mother Tucker
Bad Mother Tucker
13 hours ago

12 team, 5×5 roto

Would you trade Josh Naylor and Doyle for one of Harper/Alonso/Soderstrom? That order?

C- Goodman
1B- Naylor
2B- Luis Garcia
3B- Riley
SS- Gunnar
OF- Carroll
OF- Duran
OF- Cruz
UTIL- Rooker
BN- Altuve, Doyle, Kurtz

Homering Homers
Homering Homers
13 hours ago

I have Jackson Holliday and Maikel Garcia, would I be crazy to drop Ozzie Albies? He’s been my worst player and the stats back that up. Seems like a different player than the 2023 version.

Homering Homers
Homering Homers
14 hours ago

How would you rank ROS please. Need to cut some:

Sheets
Kerry Carpenter
Nootbaar
Andy Pages

Yerg
14 hours ago

Has your fantasy roster suffered emotional distress?

Did Grey say Jordan Beck shouldn’t be mentioned in polite roto society?

Did he publicly question Robert Hassell III’s trilogy arc like it was The Rise of Skywalker?

I’m Kitt Yerg, Attorney at Law, and I won’t rest until every underdog outfielder gets their day in court.

Taylor Ward? Irrelevant.

“Sue me”? I just might.

“Bobby Barrels”? Sounds like actionable sarcasm.

If your team has been victimized by reckless player evaluations, offhand slander, or unsolicited nicknames…

Don’t suffer in silence.

Call me.

988-SUE-GREY!!!!

Because fantasy injustice is not a game.
(Except when it is. And even then, I’m winning.)

IMG_1001
Sad Keanu
Sad Keanu
14 hours ago

Hoping for more at 1B over Christian Walker. Some available options for next week: Kurtz, Hoskins, Pasquantino, Flores …

Yerg
Reply to  Sad Keanu
14 hours ago

I like Pasqui, Hoskins, Kurtz, and Flores in that order… YERG!!!

Cohen
Cohen
14 hours ago

Buehler home vs Baltimore or
Bassitt at Tampa or neither?

I Am Not A Smart Man
15 hours ago

Morning G!

About to catch you on Sports Grid. Hyped!

Thoughts on starting Warren at Colorado? The robot HATES it! …but it’s the Rockies?

Hope the rest of your weekend is excellent!

-IANASM

Yerg
Reply to  I Am Not A Smart Man
14 hours ago

Will Warren’s pitching today? Against the Rockies?!
Don’t you put that mound magic on us, Yankees fans!
This ain’t your average stream—it’s a one-way ticket to a 12.46 ERA.

Let me tell you something:
The Rockies are gonna treat Will Warren like a piñata full of meatballs.
By the third inning, he’s gonna be looking at the dugout like,
“I don’t know what happened. I used to have command. I used to have dreams. I used to have LEGS!”

But the Rockies?
They’re gonna swing like they’ve never seen humidity before.
Jordan Beck’s gonna hit a ball so hard Statcast files a restraining order.
And Hunter Goodman? He’s lacing doubles like he’s making breakfast toast—clean, hot, and with extra jam.

If you’re thinking of streaming Will Warren today…
Just remember what Ricky Bobby said:
“With all due respect… that’s a dumb move, and you’re gonna lose your ratios.”

This warning brought to you by Kitt Yerg, Attorney at Law—defending fantasy managers from reckless streaming decisions since 2024.

IMG_1002
I Am Not A Smart Man
Reply to  Yerg
13 hours ago

Hmm

IMG_6887
The Judge
The Judge
15 hours ago

Currently have Yainer and Goodman at C but Agustin is available. Any change to be made to the position? Thank you and Happy Memorial Day!

The Judge
The Judge
15 hours ago

Please rank Kurtz,Burger and Vientos ROS? Thanks!

Cornchips
Cornchips
15 hours ago

Rice or Kurtz ROS? Thanks grey

Bigdadyb58
Bigdadyb58
16 hours ago

Mornin’ Grey. 10T 5×5 Category OBP Keeper League

Currently rostering these OF/bench bats: L. Nootbaar, T. Soderstrom, K. Campbell (keeper?) and L. Butler.

Would you switch any out for J. Lowe, C. Cowser (coming back soon), G. Sheets or D. Varsho?

Thanks and have a good Memorial Day/Weekend!

Bigdadyb58
Bigdadyb58
Reply to  Grey
15 hours ago

Thanks! If I drop Campbell for Sheets, who is the next drop for Cowser?

Mike
Mike
16 hours ago

Drop Mullins for Benson? 5×5 12 team roto. Thank you Grey

Last edited 16 hours ago by Mike
Mike
Mike
20 hours ago

Drop Mullins for Benson? 5×5 roto, 12 teams. Thank you

Scott
Scott
23 hours ago

Which side…Yordan or Merrill and Doval (holds league)? Thank you

foxman
foxman
Reply to  Scott
15 hours ago

Yordan hand thing seems like a problem
I’m concerned this could be an issue all season, but gotta admit my crystal ball is actually a bong, so the future is hazy.

hondo
hondo
Reply to  foxman
11 hours ago

mk2 mega globe

rolliefingers
rolliefingers
23 hours ago

Despite the sexy Statcast page, Ben Rice is relegated to a part-time role (not even a platoon at this point). Would you trade him for someone like Max Meyer, Ober, Gallen, or Gausman…or would you rather hold and hope either Grisham or Dominguez falls out of favor?

Jon
Jon
1 day ago

Which SP would you want give up for Clase ($21)? Pivetta ($12), Ober ($12), or Lodolo ($19)

Jon
Jon
Reply to  Jon
1 day ago

Dynasty league, by the way.

J.R.
J.R.
1 day ago

Rockies tied suprisingly with the Yankees in the top of the 5th 1-1. You have two outs and Judge comes to the plate. No one on.

You set to pitch. You a career 7.69 ERA pitcher. Judge batting a meager .400.

You throw a ball wide by a mile. 1-0 count. You set for the next pitch. You smile to yourself as you debate where to throw it.

Do you throw middle of the plate, or do you throw middle middle so perfectly that it is impossible to tell who’s side you are on? Hey, Judge hasnt homered at Coors yet. You smile to yourself as you prepare to become part of history and then throw your shitty changeup with a gift basket to the plate. Walking guys is for pussies. You aint no pussy. You earned that ERA damn it!

*You wind up and throw….

https://bdata-producedclips.mlb.com/a3301cb3-0cfe-4d24-b0af-65c865efa67e.mp4

Long Bawls
Long Bawls
1 day ago

I dub him Raccooña, because he has stolen my heart.

Scoboticus
Scoboticus
1 day ago

I need Kody to back up Vientos who is hurt. Drop which schmotato, Will Benson or Andy Pages?

uncle wighty
uncle wighty
1 day ago

Noot or beck?

uncle wighty
uncle wighty
Reply to  uncle wighty
1 day ago

Or sheets! Thanks grey

rhodyballer
rhodyballer
1 day ago

Lose Toglia for Sheets ROS?

Eric
Eric
1 day ago

Grey – Thanks as always.
I have Adely and Murphy in a 2C 10 teamer.
Drop Murphy for Baldwin? Or look at adding Dingler or Ramirez instead?

J.R.
J.R.
1 day ago

AGarcia and Semien batting 8 and 9. I probably should have streamed Burke against them. Most expensive player batting 9th?

Oh wait, Tigers have Baez batting 9th behind…Baddoo and his .125 BA and .325 OPS. They finally get to Cecconi and get two on the corners….Baddoo down in 3 swinging pitches not near the zone. He had a better shot at a wild pitch than a hit.

Hinch is a good smart manager but the guy things because he is smart his idea is good. Got that dumb play yesterday where 3-0 game and 2 on so he pinch hits Malloy for Carpenter…and he gets a single. So then next hitter is Ibanez and PH him for Baddoo.

Screenshot_20250523-192130
J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Grey
1 day ago

Oh man. I knew it was bad. I didnt realize HOW bad. I also didnt realize this is the midpoint of it. Yikes.

Screenshot_20250523-193824
stevie
stevie
1 day ago

Tildaddy!! First pitch! Let’s go!!

OaktownSteve
OaktownSteve
Reply to  stevie
1 day ago

epic

foxman
foxman
Reply to  OaktownSteve
1 day ago

My man!!!!!
Let’s Go!!!!!

Norman Ginsberg
Norman Ginsberg
1 day ago

Jackson Holliday has actually been playing well.

Please rank: Albies; Holliday; Westburg (when activated)

J.R.
J.R.
1 day ago

That JD Davis/Jac thing blew my mind. Or maybe I am not dumb and they are. If you went by your initials, a guy on our football team we called JET, Jaden E something Tradarious or Traydarius. Everyone butchered his last name and too long to put on a piece of tap on the helmet. Thus, JET. Ironic because he was sllllllow even for a LB.

Now you got me looking at players and not trusting their names. Who else is living a lie? You made me go check RA Dickey who is sensibly Robert Allen Dickey….even has cool initials RAD. Not RD Dickey…or RAD Dickey….fricking JD D AVIS. I hope he works for a car company now.

Now I dont want JAC on my team.

(because the owner wont trade and totally not sour grapes.)

Norman Ginsberg
Norman Ginsberg
1 day ago

Pick 3:

Clay Holmes CWS
Brandon Pfaadt WSH
Max Meyer @SD
Andrew Abbott @CHC
Matthew Liberatore @TEX
Jack Leiter STL
Casey Mize @KC
Will Warren @LAD

Lower the Jolly Roger
Lower the Jolly Roger
1 day ago

12 team keep up to 10…. Jazz or Duran ? Thank You Always!

J.R.
J.R.
1 day ago

Quite the list of names today either needing surgery, DFA’d, or optioned.

Lively, Dollander (?), Bleday, Brown, Elko, Vaughn, Arcia, Renfroe, Stratton, Payamps.

More surprised teams are somewhat aggressively moving the above vs riding out the year with their .217 14 HR batting or 4.84 ERA in the pen.

Chucky
Chucky
1 day ago

Matthew Boyd to the IL with some phantom injury aka suckitis

Hank
Hank
1 day ago

Is it time to move on from Albies and Caminero? I don’t have a good waiver option at 2B (Shaw? Moore?) but Burger is still available. Should I drop Junior for Burger in a 12-team, 5×5 OBP league?

Big Dog
Big Dog
1 day ago

Hey Grey! I know you mentioned the other day that you picked up Bohm for the series at Coors. You also said you were considering holding on to him if he played well. I picked him up as well and he was fine. Therefore, I am wondering if you are holding on to him for the upcoming series at the Bing Bong?

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  Big Dog
1 day ago

.322 BA last 30 days with 3 HR. .276 career hitter and in prime so I dont see why he cant replicate a .280 15 HR season. They need to move him up if he is going to reach 97 RBI again.

He talked about his swing the other day and how he was overthinking it and trying to pull stuff too much instead of pulling what came to him.

hal_incandenza
1 day ago

With the Bregman injury, prepare for some 3B questions. Here’s one to get you started: Why did I trade Paredes?

J.R.
J.R.
Reply to  hal_incandenza
1 day ago

I traded him and some other stuff for Luis Robert in March. Not feeling good about it now.

hal_incandenza
Reply to  J.R.
1 day ago

Ouch. I traded him for Noot, which I don’t really regret, but suddenly that 3B depth would be more useful. Oh well.

Think I’ll try Barger, as featured in last week’s buy. I assume Bregman misses at least a couple of days.

t k
t k
1 day ago

I’ve seen multiple folks suggest that Mayer gets the call before Roman Anthony because the Red Sox need improvement at SS and don’t wanna lose their OF guys…but Ceddanne Rafaela played 82 games at SS last year…wouldn’t that be the more likely fix and get Anthony into the OF? Wondering if I missed something, Ceddanne’s fielding at SS wasn’t that bad, was it?

hal_incandenza
Reply to  t k
1 day ago

In 2024, Rafaela’s 2024 Outs Above Replacement at SS was -7 and in CF +5. This year in CF he’s +7. For comparison’s sake, PCA is +8 this year.

Story is -3 at SS so far this year.

Coconut Willie
Coconut Willie
1 day ago

So now Vientos hits the splinters as late scratch. Time to drop him for Baty or Norby?

Much appreciated

Draft Dodgers
Draft Dodgers
1 day ago

The smugness I felt in April has been replaced with another feeling…. I drafted Machado over Devers.

Draft Dodgers
Draft Dodgers
Reply to  Grey
1 day ago

He heard you! Let’s try it again….Vlad is my worst draft pick. Fingers crossed

Alex
Alex
1 day ago

Sit or start Canning at home vs. LA? Is this a situation where you say “you’re asking me about starting a guy with a 2.47 era”?

Johnny Tsunami
Johnny Tsunami
1 day ago

better DL stash Santander or Crews?

aardvark
aardvark
1 day ago

Drop Hoglund or Paddack?

Chucky
Chucky
1 day ago

Drop Agustin for Baldwin in a Points/Redraft?

Johnny Tsunami
Johnny Tsunami
1 day ago

Haggerty viable for 10 team? looks like Rangers are shaking things up batting him 1 for awhile?

Dude
Dude
1 day ago

QS, Keep 13 forever
I need to activate Kirby and would you add Hassell over any of these, if so Who would be the two drops?

C- Langeliers
1B- Alonso
2B- Turang Kim
3B- Paredes
SS- Lindor
2B/SS- Volpe
1B/3B- Burger
LF- Duran
CF- Merrill
RF- Goodman
OF- Beck
UTIL- Bellinger
UTIL- Rooker
Bench: Butler, Kim, Luis Garcia, Vientos
IL: Yordan, CES, Noelvi, Westburg

SP: Cease, Flaherty, Freddy P, Henderson, Abbott, Zebby, Bubba, Pfaadt, Weathers and Miz
IL: Kirby

Dude
Dude
Reply to  Grey
1 day ago

Man….I traded PCA for Vientos and Porter Hodge earlier in the season. That has worked out great for me. I guess I was gonna ride Vientos all season lol. Just curious, who would be your next choice? (face palm)

Dbreezyy
Dbreezyy
1 day ago

I have soto, Sonny gray, Austin Riley, yimi

He offered Kyle Tucker and Hoffman

martinrostoker
1 day ago

would you offer Yelich and Shane Baz for George Kirby?

Thanks!

Big Dog
Big Dog
1 day ago

Hey Grey! What are your thoughts on Schwellenbach? Are you disappointed with the low number of strikeouts (49 in 61 IP) and the past month and a half of meh results? Are you still bullish on him for the rest of the season?

Do you think me offering Lodolo and Horton for him is fair?

Finally, do you have any hope for Woodruff this year?

Thank you and have a great holiday weekend.

aardvark
aardvark
1 day ago

Jordan Walker or hassell ?

What's a Drexl?
What's a Drexl?
Reply to  aardvark
1 day ago

gonna vary massively but i’d expect any league where there are players with at bats in FA hassell here. if say non dynasty redraft even up to 30’ers. walker will be out there if hassell’s only up for a little bit.

aardvark
aardvark
Reply to  What's a Drexl?
1 day ago

It’s a 12 team dynasty. I picked Walker up last week

What's a Drexl?
What's a Drexl?
Reply to  aardvark
1 day ago

yeah, so hassell in case he does well, esp to the extent you need steals.

aardvark
aardvark
Reply to  What's a Drexl?
1 day ago

Good assessment. Thx

What's a Drexl?
What's a Drexl?
1 day ago

you don’t often see all 9 hitters have 2 at bats in same inning, BAL pitching though… (and morton’s up in the night game, can we dream on record runs against in a day here…, and somehow NONE of this was due to povich at all (nice))

What's a Drexl?
What's a Drexl?
Reply to  Grey
1 day ago

when did the onion (or here) buy baseball prospectus, from a link that came out recently (can’t read it of course, paywalled): https://www.baseballprospectus.com/news/article/98626/slopball-firing-derek-shelton-was-the-last-piece-of-the-pirates-puzzle/?mc_cid=0dbae91f98

Xcoaste
Xcoaste
1 day ago

Still holding Santander? I know he is a slow starter each April and May….

Don't be a Hader
Don't be a Hader
1 day ago

12 teamer add priority??
J.Meyers
Varsho
Barger
Meadows

The Dude
The Dude
1 day ago

My Seth Lugo for his Jack Flaherty?

Db
Db
1 day ago

Bellinger, Austin Riley, flahtery for Jose Ramirez?

Jon
Jon
1 day ago

Would you deal Lodolo for Clase in a league where I need bullpen help? Keeper costs are negligible, $21 for Clase vs $19 for Lodolo.

Trishul
Trishul
1 day ago

Hey Grey!

Is it time to drop Semien or McLain? I know Semien starts slow and might get hot but its been a drag.

I have Aranda in my 2B spot while i wait for someone to get hot.

Butler is on the wire – who should i drop between Semien, McLain and Aranda for him?

thanks!

schoolboy p
schoolboy p
1 day ago

Luis Garcia or Wilmer Flores for the open Util spot

Butter Rum
Butter Rum
1 day ago

Been rolling with C. Wong as C2 – clearly I dropped the wrong BOS catcher as i had Narvaez while Wong was out. Oops!

Trade J. Ortiz for E. Quero in a deep standard 5×5 roto? Quero neither hits for power or steals bags and the avg may be suspect…

chairmanguy
chairmanguy
1 day ago

Fingers crossed the Rays send Baz down to figure out what’s wrong. I know I should drop him…but I think the Rays pitching staff has the chops to help him figure it out. If they don’t do anything though, I may have to part ways sooner than I want.

Jeff
Jeff
1 day ago

Having a hard time deciding who the cut should be to get Acuna in the lineup? Tovar or Pages

Big Ticket
Big Ticket
1 day ago

Drop Tyler Stephenson for Drake?

Coconut Willie
Coconut Willie
1 day ago

Not sure my playing Rice for 3 games/week is cutting it. I also have O’Hearn – Schanuel is available.

Keep 2 of these guys or just one – which guy(s) to keep?

14 team 6x 6 weekly

Much appreciated

Lindorphins
Lindorphins
1 day ago

Happy early Memorial Day! Where will you slot Parker Meadows as an overall rank when he returns? Or who would he comp to?

Lindorphins
Lindorphins
Reply to  Lindorphins
1 day ago

Nvm, just saw you said top 50 OF in the 5/20 column comments. Enjoy your holiday weekend!

chairmanguy
chairmanguy
Reply to  Grey
1 day ago

Tossing a life buoy, eephus style, compliments of Greinke.

chairmanguy
chairmanguy
Reply to  Grey
1 day ago

haha, that means I awkwardly threw that buoy very late. Oh well. I tried.

Lindorphins
Lindorphins
Reply to  Grey
1 day ago

Glad this all worked out. I also have 100% nearly drowned trying to swim butterfly.

Actual different question now – have your thoughts changed much on Caminero from the preseason? Thinking about trying to buy low on him in a keeper league. Do you think Cam Smith + Jasson Dominguez is a good offer?

Lindorphins
Lindorphins
Reply to  Grey
1 day ago

Thanks man. Have a great weekend.

Hesh
Hesh
1 day ago

Would you start Narvaez over Hunter Goodman or Yanier Diaz? I was very impressed by Diaz. Thats the less talented of the Navarez catching brothers btw. Omar was here Narvaez might still be hanging around somewhere.

Last edited 1 day ago by Hesh
Jammer McSlam
Jammer McSlam
1 day ago

Ward is available in a 10 team H2H, but who is my drop? Altuve, Shaw (have at 2nd), or soderstrom?

Helios Ramos is also available. 2 drops?

OaktownSteve
OaktownSteve
1 day ago

You’ve pre-schadenfreudered Kodai like 3 times now. You’re like Cezanne obsessively painting Mont Sainte-Victoire over and over.

tangential thought. i bet kodai is a popular name for japanese dogs.

Travis Hafner
Travis Hafner
1 day ago

How close is Neto to Vlad and Harper? I’m looking to add some speed and I think I can easily flip 1 for 1, just not sure how *high* we should be looking at Neto.

Travis Hafner
Travis Hafner
Reply to  Grey
1 day ago

Overall value?

J C
J C
1 day ago

Love this for both the info and cuz I was right! Let’s celebrate. A month ago I called the Baldwin move since they liked his defense so much. He’s been great. Murphy to the Giants I tell ya. Been rockin’ Vargas in my debut RCl league so happy to read that as well.
My arm hurts from the back patting but will switch hands for my question:
Dodger Pages, Simpson, Vargas? (Different league…H2H 10 hitting cats

Rob
Rob
1 day ago

Flores over Naylor ROS?
Wouldn’t think so but it’s close so far this year and I think I have more faith in Josh.

Rob
Rob
Reply to  Grey
1 day ago

Thanks again!

Dbreezy
Dbreezy
1 day ago

I think Brendon little needs some reliever love 6% owned

Db
Db
1 day ago

Zebby, Horton or mize

The Wild Card
The Wild Card
1 day ago

Are you starting springs at bing bong stadium today vs Philly

buddens126
buddens126
1 day ago

Asked an ohtani question already but offer got declined and the guy countered with

I give him butler merrill riley and darvish for ohtani. Which side?

buddens126
buddens126
Reply to  Grey
1 day ago

Yea i said that to him i swapped butler for simpson and he took it. Its a 12 teamer. I now have witt and ohtani rostered. Was able to keep butler. These are my current hitters now as it stands.

Herrera, arraez, meidroth, paredes, witt, ozuna, lee, ward, butler, ohtani, neto, stowers, westburg

Last edited 1 day ago by buddens126
Fungazi 2.0
Fungazi 2.0
1 day ago

Just saw a review of the Soto to Padres deal on MLB today. Along with Hassell, they gave up Abrams, Wood and Gore. Veto or no veto?

What's a Drexl?
What's a Drexl?
Reply to  Fungazi 2.0
1 day ago

forgot that might end up looking worse than the ozuna (for 1 injured/1 healthy good year) for gallen + sandy STL/MIA trade. soto was only there for 1.33 years (had they signed soto to long term it’d be probably pretty decent though).