The National League Central, the division that cannot be won unless you have a C in the name. Let’s see, the Chicago Cubs won in 2016 and 2017, the Cardinals won from 2013-2015, and Cincinnati won in 2012. A glitch in the Matrix occurred in 2012, when the Brewers took home the crown. Other than the Houston Astros, who won four division titles (1997, 1998, 1999, 2001) before getting the boot to the American League West in 2010, it’s been all Cincinnati, Cardinals, and Cubs. Pittsburgh. Where you at? Ah, it’s good to have baseball back. Each week, I will go through the position battles for each division. Let’s take a look at the NL Central.


CHICAGO CUBS – 92-70 record in 2017

Willson Contreras, Anthony Rizzo, and Kris Bryant are locked into their respective positions of catcher, first base, and third base. The rest? Even Joe Maddon doesn’t know because the the puzzle is always morphing and Maddon is always moving with it.

ShortstopAddison Russell is the guy….for now. He’s only 24 years old and plays good defense, but… a career .240 hitter, missed 52 games last season due to injury, is under contract for only one year and $3.2 million, was put on the trading block in the offseason, and the Cubs have someone on the roster that many believe is better. Maddon likes Russell, “I really think this is kind of like his year to really blossom. He’s so athletic. He’s so gifted. As a shortstop, he’s so fundamentally sound.” Since being called up in 2015, Maddon has played Russell when he’s been up with the big club (142 games in 2015 and 151 gams in 2016), despite the offensive struggles at the plate. Chili Davis, who was Russell’s first hitting coach with Oakland, is in Chicago now, so that should breed some comfort. With all that said, I think it would be prudent to at least think of scenarios in which Russell isn’t the guy. He could get traded or, if he doesn’t improve at the plate, Maddon could shake things up and replace him with the next guy I will talk about.

Second baseJavier Baez. Athletic. Sexy. Light-tower power. Strikes out a lot, but whatever. Played 73 games at shortstop last season, so if the Cubs decide to move on from Russell, Baez is more than capable. Whatever Maddon decides to do, Baez should be relatively safe for playing time. He’s received 450 and 508 plate appearances in each of the past two seasons. Last year, he played one game in the outfield, four games at first base, eight games at third base, 73 at shortstop, and 80 at second base. If Baez were to take over at shortstop, that would open up things for Ben Zobrist and possibly Ian Happ. Zobrist played 81 games, while Happ played 44 games at second base last year. Zobrist is 36 years old and kind of sucks now. He batted .232 last season and only had 496 plate appearances. Now, he’s dealing with a back issue. Happ, on the other hand, would be very intriguing if given consistent playing time. He’s a switch hitter that clubbed 24 home runs and stole eight bases last season. He hit for a higher average against LHP, but most of the power was against RHP.

OutfieldJason Heyward looks to be locked in at one of the corner outfield spots. Even if he struggles hitting, he’s a high OBP guy, doesn’t strikeout often, and plays good defense in the outfield. Kyle Schwarber is IN THE BEST SHAPE OF HIS LIFE!!!! All the talk has been about his new physique after losing 20 pounds. I’m not sure that’s going to help with his 30% strikeout rate, but you never know. It could help with his ability to patrol left field on defense, which could allow him to stay in the game more often. If that’s the case, then we definitely have to take notice because, let’s not forget that, Schwarber clubbed 30 home runs in 486 plate appearances last season. Zobrist will probably back up the two, but isn’t a threat to supplant either. The main “battle” looks to be in center field. Albert Almora Jr. is slated to start. The 23-year-old received 323 plate appearances last season and batted .298 with 8 home runs and 1 stolen base. He crushed LHP to the tune of a .342 average, while he batted .271 against RHP. Happ has been mentioned as a potential contender, but I’d imagine Maddon would keep Happ in a utility role due to his defensive versatility. I’ve also heard that Almora and Happ would form a platoon, as Almora is weaker against RHP. It kind of makes sense, as Happ is a switch hitter, but he batted .243 against RHP last season.


MILWAUKEE BREWERS – 86-76 record in 2017

The Brewers said enough of the C dominance in the division. They made moves in the offseason to remind the world that B is still higher on the grading scale, as they acquired Christian Yelich and Lorenzo Cain. Sorry Keon Broxton and Domingo Santana owners. Now that I think about it, the Brewers joined the C revolution by trading for Christian and Cain. If you can’t beat ’em, join em.

Second baseJonathan Villar vs. Eric Sogard. The quintessential battle between good vs evil, bunt vs swing, parlay vs. cash out, and lay up vs. go for it. Villar has the tantalizing upside of 20 home runs and 60 stolen bases. He also has the downside of striking out 30% of the time and batting .240. Sogard, on the other hand, walks more than he strikes out, will hit around .270 and probably won’t approach 10/10 for the season. Outside of the deepest leagues, Sogard has no fantasy relevance. What he could potentially be is a cock blocker. Now that I think about it, everything is on Villar, so if he doesn’t perform, then he will be cock blocking himself. Last season, Villar had an ADP in the 30-40 overall range. Now, according to NFBC data, he has an ADP of 184. Buy low, sell high. Warren Buffet put it best, “Be fearful when others are greedy and greedy when others are fearful.” The risk/reward profile is favorable for Villar going into 2018.


ST. LOUIS CARDINALS – 83-79 record in 2017

The Cardinals thought the moves the Brewers made in the offseason were Cute. They made a move themselves in acquiring MarcellC ball, hit ball” Ozuna, who locks down left field. There isn’t any competition in the other outfield spots, as Tommy Pham will patrol centerfield, while Dexter Fowler slots in at right field. The infield is set as well, as Yadier Molina is a catcher, Kolten Wong is at second base, and Paul DeJong mans shortstop. The only two questions would be at first base and third base. There really isn’t any kind of battle at either position, but both Matt Carpenter and Jedd Gyorko are older players and have experienced injuries in the past. Carpenter is likely to man first base, but when Gyorko needs a day off, he would presumably slide over the third base and Jose Martinez would take over at first. Martinez is an intriguing player. He hit .309 last season with 14 home runs and 4 stolen bases. He walked 10% and only struck out 19% of the time. The ISO was .210. There’s always a but…..the BABIP was .350 and he only received 307 plate appearances. He’s someone to keep in mind later in the drafts, as he has multi-eligibility. If one of Gyorko or Carpenter goes down for an extended period of time, that’s some potential fantasy goodness right there. Currently, NFBC ADP has him going at pick 270.


PITTSBURGH PIRATES – 75-87 record in 2017

Will be the first season since 2008 that Andrew McCutchen won’t be in the starting lineup for the Pirates. So, how’s that Le’Veon Bell contract extension coming along?

Left field –

  • Adam Frazier – Looks to be the front runner for the starting job. The 26-year-old batted .276 last season with 6 home runs and 9 stolen bases in 454 plate appearances. He had an impressive 12.6% strikeout rate with a 7.9% walk rate. Frazier bats from the left side and hit .271 against RHP and .304 against LHP (63 plate appearances).
  • Jordan Luplow – The 24-year-old received 87 plate appearances in the big show last season and hit. 205 with 3 home runs. There’s talk that he could platoon with Frazier, as Luplow bats from the right side while Frazier the left side, but Luplow hit .154 in 29 plate appearances last season. Small sample size, I know, but Frazier is a career .338 (89 plate appearances) against LHP. With that said, the Pirates have never won a NL Central crown so…..
  • Daniel Nava – Didn’t know he was still in the league. The 34-year-old did have some success in Philadelphia last season batting .301 with 4 home runs and 1 stolen base in 214 plate appearances. He walked 12% and only struck out 17.8% of the time. He is a switch hitter, which could offer some versatility. Unfortunatley, he’s a career .211 hitter against LHP.
  • Sean Rodriguez – Too valuable as a super-utility guy to start in left field. Played 20 games in the outfield, 12 games at second base, six games at shortstop, and 14 games at third base.


CINCINNATI REDS – 68-94 record in 2017

Outfield – Right now, Billy Hamilton is set to patrol center field, while Scott Schebler and Adam Duvall take care of the corners. Due to Hamilton’s speed and defense, he’s locked in to start. The corners are where things get interesting because of the presence of Jesse Winker. The 24-year-old, left-handed power bat hit .298 with 7 home runs and 1 stolen base in 137 plate appearances last season. The ISO was .231, while the walk rate was 10.9% and the strikeout rate only 17.5%. The Cincinnati Enquirer’s Zach Buchanan reported that the Redsplan to use a four-man rotation in the outfield this season.” When the Reds wants to stack against a RHP, Winker would probably take over left field for Duvall. More than likely, though, most of the plate appearances will come at the expense of Schebler.

Shortstop – With the departure of Zach Cozart, Jose Peraza is slated to start at shortstop. Peraza possesses blazing speed. Unfortunately, he’s allergic to walking (3.9% walk rate and .297 OBP last season). His defense? No bueno. Now there’s talk that Nick Senzel is nearly ready for the big leagues. From Ralph aka ProspectJesus, “Owner of arguably the best hit tool in the minors, Senzel gets consistent 70 grades on the bat from scouts. His power is above average, and started to translate more in the over the fence variety once he hit the Southern League. At present Senzel is an above average runner capable of double digit steals, but I could see that disappearing over time. The combination of opportunity and a friendly home hitting environment make an immediate impact from Senzel all the more likely. Draws a lot of David Wright comps, and it’s not a stretch. The Reds are trying him at every position but first base. In the off-season, he was voted the minor league’s best defensive third baseman. Remember what I said about Peraza’s defense above? The Reds have said that Senzel won’t make the team unless he starts. With the holes that Peraza has in his game, there’s definitely an opportunity here.

  1. Dan says:

    Is domingo santana going to be worthy of keeping in my keeper league where we keep 6 ? I have santana,pham,eddie rosario to decide on.

    • Son

      Son says:

      @Dan: If it’s between those theee, gotta go with Pham

  2. turd ferguson says:

    Just want to point out that Russell is arbitration eligible for the next 3 offseasons. Won’t hit free agency until 2022. While he could potentially receive salary increases, there is still plenty of team control there. Seemed to be worded as if he was in the final year, but that is far from the case

    • Son

      Son says:

      @turd ferguson: Appreciate that. Yeah, I did see that he was arb eligible. Definitely should’ve worded things better.

      • Better Call Limehouse says:

        @Son: @Son: and with his hitting he’ll likely not get too much in arb.

        • Son

          Son says:

          @Better Call Limehouse: Gotta produce to get paid. Hopefully, he does well. I’ve always liked him

Comments are closed.