Every time I see J. Jackson in the Orioles’ lineup, I have to do one thing. Do you know what I do? This is like a Buzzfeed Quiz, How Well Do You Know Grey? If you guessed I see J. Jackson and start yelling like Joe Jackson, “You’ll never amount to anything!” at my life-sized Michael Jackson Captain EO cut-out. No, that’s wrong. If you guessed I see J. Jackson and immediately have to watch clips of Joshua Jackson on Dawson’s Creek. You’re warmer, but still wrong. I see J. Jackson, and I have to put on Steppin’ Out! Look and dry your eyes! triangle, triangle, keyboard, triangle! Into the light, into the light! You babe, steppin’ out! So, Jeremiah Jackson has a lot to live up to, clearly. You, babe, better be steppin’ out. I don’t think the Orioles know what they’re doing with their prospects. I say that to immediately squash any hesitation because they left Jackson in the minors for as long as they did — he’s been there since 2018! Granted, a lot of that time was in the Angels’ system, another team that is clueless, Cher. All through the minors, Jackson’s had power and speed, but has struggled with average. I don’t anticipate that to change, but he’s currently hot, hitting 2nd and playing every day. At some point, the average will bottom out, but by that point you can step out. Anyway, here’s some more players to Buy or Sell this week in fantasy baseball:
PSYCHE! This post was released a week early for Patreon members. It will be released all year early for Patreons, so if people are getting a jump on you, it’s because they paid the $10. Anyway, the Fantasy Baseball Buy/Sell:
BUY
Kyle Higashioka – On this week’s podcast, you catch me in real-time tackling the last name Higashioka, and I add only five extra syllables, a beautiful feat, as Tarantino might say.
Kyle Manzardo – This is the all-Kyle Buy column, huh? Well, Kyle Farmer might be better than Kyle Tucker at this point, and Kyle Teel is hot and as valuable as Kyle Higashioka, and better than Kyle Karros. Sorry, Kyle Isbel, you’re an unrated Kyle, and no Kyle Schwarber? He’s over 50% rostered by a country Kyle.
Blaze Alexander – He’s been solid — great even — so don’t take this the wrong way, but him getting everyday at-bats for a team going nowhere and Jordan Lawlar only facing lefties is plenty absurd. I know Lawlar has struggled, but who cares if you’re the DBags? They’re playing for next year.
Michael Helman – With Evan Carter out, the Rangers made centerfield Helman’s domain, not to be confused with Coby Mayo. Helman is a schmotato, Quad-A player, who actually has been better in two weeks than Evan Carter has been in two years, but alas.
Zack Gelof – Likely should’ve went with Gelof for the lede, but you wanted Steppin’ Out jokes over ten forced Live Aid jokes.
Caleb Durbin – He’s got 2026 sleeper written all over him. He hit double digit homers as a rookie, and he has 40-steal speed with a 10-ish K%? Oh, yeah, get ready for the winter of Durbin.
Josh Jung – Here’s one guy I promise you won’t get a sleeper post from this offseason. I secretly hate Jung, and might hate the Rangers — their hitters at least. It’s just such a crappy hitters’ park. I can’t hate Evan Carter more, don’t really love Langford like others, despise Seager; used to like Adolis, but that ship’s sailed and can’t have a ship sailing without Semien. Say it with me now, but Jung has been hot.
Royce Lewis – I’ll admit to stretching the limits of eligibility for this post when a position is a little dry, i.e., there weren’t that many 3B to pick up this week, so I ignored Lewis and Jung were above 50% rostered. You’ll forgive me in that big heart if yours.
Drew Gilbert – If I were running a team, the first rule I would institute: You cannot bring up a prospect and only play him vs. lefties. Second rule is you really can’t do that with a lefty hitter. Not entirely sure of Gilbert’s playing time, because he’s a lefty, but he’s not playing vs. righties? He’s a 15/10/.260 hitter who was called up by the Giants, and he’s hit in limited time, but not sure of playing time.
Harrison Bader – Saw Bader’s season-long stats and thought he might’ve been more valuable this year than I remembered, but I was wrong. Or maybe I was initially right. Either way, he’s been hot recently, but not really season-long on the Player Rater.
Andrew Benintendi – You know you’re in September Baseball, when you see Benintendi in the Buy column, and you’re thinking, “Should I go with him over PCA?”
Mike Yastrzemski – Carl’s Jr. Jr. eating sliders and taking names, like a terrible fast-order cook. First, you take names, then you serve sliders! How hard is this?
Nolan Jones – He’s been hot recently, so take what I’m about to say with a grain of NaCl: Watching Jones hit is one of the least pleasurable experiences you can have watching baseball. He’s like a dropped infield fly, but as a hitter. I have no idea how he hit 20/20/.297 in 2023. That is one of the most improbable lines in retrospect.
Yanquiel Fernandez – See my rules in Drew Gilbert’s blurb, but add in the Rockies just have no rhyme or reason to any of their moves, and trying to figure out the Rockies is the way to madness.
Luis Morales – This is a Streamonator call, like the call it makes to its local sandwich shop.
Luis Garcia – This is also a Streamonator call. “Do you have a number three? No, not the sandwich, the number button on your cash register.”
Abner Uribe – Should be rostered, clearly. Also, wanted to mention, in the last few weeks I stopped giving you middle relievers to grab. That was on purpose, because at this point you should be roster-maxxing your team and I don’t think you have room for middle relievers, who aren’t getting saves in September (and 2nd half of August).
Jake Woodford – Prefer Saalfrank, and not just because it’s a contraction of “Sup y’all, Frank,” but because he’s actually better. Who’s better matters nil, zilch, synonym, and the DBags seem to prefer Woodford.
JoJo Romero – We only have time for saves, so I don’t care either way, but, if this were April, I’d be pointing out how there’s better options than Romero in the Cards’ pen.
Cole Sands – He might be the new Twins closer, to which you might say, “So?” And I’ll say, “Buttons.” And you’ll say, “Juvenile.” And I’ll say, “Back that azz up.”
SELL
Dylan Cease – I’ve limited the Sells (drops) to hitters the last few weeks, because at this point it should be Streamonator or bust for everyone and you should know this, but I just wanted to single out Cease as he singled out my fantasy teams for destruction. Was hoping to conquer my frenemies when I drafted a Cease’r, but that turned out to be more like watching an Apple TV show with photosensitive light sequences.
Seiya Suzuki – There’s very few guys who have been as miserable as Seiya in the 2nd half. He had a 1st half to make up for it when you look at his season-long numbers, but, when I say all those numbers are 1st half, they are so hilariously exactly that. He’s become Kevin Newman in the 2nd half. Daniel Schneemann is motorboating his stats. If this were a keeper, I wouldn’t say see ya to Seiya for a Triscuit found under Cal Raleigh’s couch cushion, but I would go to the Fantasy Baseball Trade Analyzer and analyze some trades
I have Abreu,Jansen and Walker as closers in a 12 roto keeper league. Would you replace one with Hoffman for this year or as keeper?
Same league…My SP has been a mess with bad luck but still a shot. Would you add Sheehan over Tong,Peterson or Bibee? I have Bibee at a keeper value if he returns to 2024 form.
I think time to part with Ozuna. Should I add McLain,Manzardo, Gleyber or Beck? McLain has been better lately and Beck’s stats are not as bad as I thought.
Thanks!
Hoffman over Walker
Sheehan over Bibee
Manzardo
How did Sproat look? Worth a hold? Looks line he’d get the Rangers or Padres at home next time out…
Just saw he took a no-no into the 6th – must have looked pretty good I guess!
Meh, but those matchups seem ok
Hmmm. Doesn’t sound like a must-hold. I guess if I drop him now there would still be enough time to pick him up again for his next start if necessary.
Elsewhere, The Real JB is pimping Ryan Weathers v WAS this week – any interest there? Might not go long enough for a QS?
The Real JB? I’m trying to pick up Weathers in one league, yeah…might not go 6 IP tho
The Real Joey Bart! You think Cavallli might be a better bet for a QS? He’s @ MIA and v PIT this week, by the looks…
Haha, gotcha — Cavalli is terrible, lol…I’d go Weathers before him
Grabbed ’em both – LFG!
How do you feel about Strider v CHC? SON lurrrrves him, but he’s been pretty bad…
Eh, forget it. Strider’s gone.
Would’ve said meh anyway
Ok cool. One more – am I crazy for thinking that Manzardo might give me more than Bryce for the next (hopefully) two weeks? OBP league so wouldn’t be cutting Bryce specifically for him, but self-evidently, Manzardo has been real good…
Redraft, standard 5×5 roto. 2 spots avail to stream SPs.
1. 9/9: stream Littel @ SD?
2. 9/10: top 2: Wacha @ CLE, Tolle @ A’s, Holmes @ PHI, Bieber vs. HOU
3. 9/11: stream P. Lopez @ AZ and/or Seymour @ CWS?
Thanks.
Wacha, Bieber
In an NL Only 5×5 dynasty league, where I am building for next year, what is a $ amount I can bid on Sal.. that I can keep him at next year? For reference the last 2 Mets pitchers went for $11 and $15. Each team starts the year with a $60 FA pot, with $5 min. bid. Most contenders have used up their cash after the trade deadline with players coming over from AL.
Who?
Stewart
Also, with Palencia going down.. I think Hodge is the choice.. he’s looked good since coming back
Meh
$7
What about Kim.. Atl ? Same scenario
Seems about same
Thanks! At least my Fantasy Football team is winning!
Nice!
Wins, Losses, HR Allowed, Ks, WHIP, ERA are our SP cats.
Quintana at Rangers (undecided)
Junk home Nats (Cavalli)
Sheehan home vs Rockies and hope he starts a game during Rockies series.
None seem great with Quintana on the road but good ballpark and Rangers can’t hit.
Junk coming off “elbow issue” but had a solid AAA rehab start. And Sheehan is a Dodger so we don’t know their plans.
Thoughts?
Quintana seems safest but kinda meh, Sheehan seems most upside…I’d go Sheehan as I’d be shocked the Dodgers don’t use him
Would you play Bader over Doyle this week? Colorado has seven games but they’re all on the road.
Yes Bader
Redraft, 12 team, H2H. Tuesday-Sunday, which closer you prefer:
C. Smith (3 vs. KC, 3 vs. CWS) or D. Santana (3 @ BAL, 3 @ WAS)?
Thanks.
Smith
Desperation play to try to advance in my H2H pts league. Need 1:
Lorenzen vs Minn
Corbin vs Hou
Martin @ Det
Teng @ Stl
Lorenzen
any inside info on who the dodgers are throwing vs col? im starting my playoff monday and trying to figure out if sheehan is going to get a start…love that the playoffs come down to weeks where no one seems to know wtf is going on including the actual teams…
Dodgers are very noncommittal, so it’s risky…my guess is he will start vs Rockies
Evening Grey,
An insight into what’s going on with Xavier Edwards? sitting 2 games in a row now.
You still holding in hopes he plays one of these days or cutting bait?
thanks as always!
Resting him because he’s slumping bad, don’t see any reason to hold if you have better options
Thank you. I have 1 roster move left this week. If he’s not playing, he’s off the island!
In another league, the below bats are all available. Would you cut Payton Tolle for a bench one of these bats?
Thanks again for all your help!!!
Simpson
thank you!
No problem
LA is wild. Dodgers go from a no hitter to losing. Their SP gives up 1 run and they dont let me finish off the last out. The pen did not get that out.
Meanwhile the other team in LA, 2nd day in a row the Angels have a pitcher who clearly cant hit the zone, walks, almost hitting guys, and they let the other team hang 7-8 runs on him before sending him to the showers.
Yeah, insane, saw….Their pen is awful…you’d think they would’ve added someone besides Brock Stewart
@Grey: weekly roto. Need to start one of these guys next week. Who do you like? Or start an extra reliever?
Zebby – @ laa
Taj – @ laa
Cecconi – vs kc, vs cws
M Parker – @ Mia, vs pit
Thanks!
Salde
Have my roster mostly set for semis match up beginning Monday. I can make one more move before 9am PST Sunday. Questions, WW and team below:
WW: Teoscar, Teel, Polanco, Varsho (platoon tho?), Sheehan if starting vs Colorado?
Agustin
Vlad, JoRam, Machado
Lindor, Altuve, B Lowe
Tucker (hopefully), Bux, Soto, Belli, Laureano
Util- Doyle
2 Starts: Crochet, Kirby
1Start: Ras, Ranger, Kershaw, Bergert/streamer spot
RP – Saves Munoz, R Walker, Armstrong (19 games vs my opponent’s 12)
RP – Holds Strahm, Brash (14 games vs my opponent’s 12)
1. Agustin pretty meh lately but has 7 games and seems to play all the time. Steals a bonus. Teel’s been good.
2. Kershaw is not projected to pitch until Sunday (vs Webb ugh). Blasphemy for sure but I could drop him for a bat for Monday and in case Tucker is still out or I could drop Clayton for Sheehan if Emmett faces Rockies Monday or Tuesday. If I did drop him I could try to claim him back later in the week as well…I have second position order. Makes me sick to drop Clayton but it’s the playoffs.
3. Any other ideas? Areas of concern?
4. Make a move or hold?
2. So Sheehan is going on Monday or Tuesday vs the Rockies? You’re telling me this, if that’s the case, go with Sheehan…if not I’d pick up a backup for Tucker
I am leaning the same way. Drop Kershaw and grab Emmett if confirmed as an early week SP. if not, I could grab Polanco or Teo and light a candle.
Makes sense, will do!
Please provide top 8 for 2026 keepers. Note: 12-team 30 roster selections ($260 budget).
Wyatt Langford $21
Jordan Westburg $14
Paul Skenes $13 (obvious)
Junior Caminero $13 (obvious)
Sam Bassalo $9
Agustin Ramirez $7
Luke Keaschall $7
Luis Gil $7
Tyler Soderstrom $7
Luis Gil $7
Quinn Preister $6
Jack Leiter $6
Jacob Marsee $6
Isaac Collins $6
Dylan Beavers $6
Jacob Misioroski $6
Pablo Lopez $6
Andrew Abbott $6
Nolan McLean $6
Trevor Rogers $6
Emmet Sheehan $6
Quinn Preister $6
Jack Leiter $6
Wyatt Langford $21
Paul Skenes $13 (obvious)
Junior Caminero $13 (obvious)
Westburg
Agustin Ramirez $7
Trevor Rogers $6
Miz
Soder
Abbott
Keaschall
these are a bit of a mess
Redraft, 12 team H2H playoffs starting Monday. Prefer to only carry 1 catcher.
Monday-Thursday series: stick with Yanier Diaz (@TOR-Berrios, Bieber, Gausman), or drop for 1 of:
Rice (vs. DET-TBD,Mize,Flaherty)
Baldwin (vs. CHC-Imanaga,Horton,Assad)
Teel (vs. TB-Houser,Pepiot,Seymour)
Hold
Albies has looked good past few weeks. Wondering if he might be a cheap 2026 keeper.
On a 1-10 scale, what chance that Albies was just a 1-2 season anomaly and he’ll be near elite next year?
5
FML Grey!
Setting my pitching rotation for next week, semi finals, QS and IP/start as categories, start 5, having a time making the final choices.
Robot has my options as follows:
Start:
Webb vs LAD, vs AZ
Sheehan vs COL
Joe Ryan vs AZ
Bradish vs PIT
Sandy Alcantara vs WAS
Bench:
Ranger vs Mets
Framber @TOR (and maybe @ATL)
McLean @PHI
Trevor Rogers @TOR
The Rogers matchup is shaky but can I really bench him though with the run he’s on? Bradish only went 4 innings last time so it’s hard to be confident starting him too despite a favorable matchup and the robot blessing. McLean has been a stud and handled the Phils last time though was at home then. What a conundrum.
Just gut instinct, I’m leaning these 5:
Webb, Sandy, Ryan, Rogers, Sheehan
…but curious which way you’d go. Thanks again!
Can’t bench Rogers…yes, those 5
McLean now set up for a 2 start, @PHI, vs TEX. The Robot now has him 3rd of my options-
Webb, Sheehan, McLean, Ryan, Bradish
But I still want to get Rogers in, so would swap Rogers for Bradish. Stick with Sheehan too or bring in Sandy?
Thanks again!
Try having a squad with Seiya, and he isn’t close to your biggest second half disappointment. Elly, Acuna, Barger, round out the horrible stretch run.
I’d rather have a roster full of ineffective list dudes than this squad, because no one on waivers/FA will possess the skills of these super slumpers.
Hope they are just saving it for the playoffs
James Wood too!
Thanks for the reminder Grey
Yes, I also roster James Wood on that squad
And Josh Naylor
All these slumping hitters and yet pitchers seem to be giving up a ton of runs. Who is hitting?
Jeremiah Jackson!
Haha, brutal!
Need two “holds guys” for next week’s playoffs. Choices are:
Brash (7 home games, 3 Cards, 4 Angels)
Speier (same as above obviously)
Cleavenger ( 6 games – 3 at CWS, 3 vs Cubs)
Strahm (7 home games – 4 Mets, 3 Royals)
I have Munoz as part of my saves RPs, so the Seattle Stack is enticing given they should be favored in all 7 games. Not a big Brash fan but opponents seem ripe. Cleavenger has been so dominant with crazy strikeout momentum… 6 games though. I like Strahm but Mets can erupt at any time. I can wait until Saturday night to execute this perhaps seeing how the next two games go but I am always leery of another team grabbing them.
What say you?
Brash, Strahm
Thanks! As timing would have it, Koenig just hit the wire. He has six games next week, three at Rangers and three vs Cards. Still Strahm and Brash due to extra game or ?
Appreciate the extra answer!
Extra game is better
Simple math wins again! Thank you.
Need Tucker to get back now so we can get rolling.
Haha, same
Luis Garcia at Texas or
Alcantara home vs Philly ?
Sandy
Hey Grey!
Championship week in my h2h league. Which streams are your favorite?
s Smith @ DET
Tong @ Cin
Verlander @ STL
sproat @ cin
L Garcia @ TEX
Verlander
Good afternoon Grey. Would you drop Will Smith for S Perez or Kirk in consideration of Smith s injury ? Thanks
Afternoon! Smith
Sorry, for Perez
Oh great Grey,
Top two 1B ros??
B.Lowe
Manzardo
Mountcastle
Triolo
Sheets
Soderstrom
Torkelson
Yandy
Lowe, Manzardo
WTF happened to Michael Busch? Since his 3HR game on the Fourth of July, he’s been utterly useless.
Ha, yup…guess who traded for him the day after his 3-homer game?
Grey, It’s ugly in my NL only league, and I’m trying everything including spit and duct tape to hold it together and crawl out of 4th and into the money. My pitching makes me ill. Need 2 of the following for next week:
Eury – 2 at home vs. Wash and Det
Pederson – @ Philly
Wentz – 2 at home vs Cubs and Stros
Thank you!
Eury, Wentz
Thank you, sir! If I can pick him up, do you like Oviedo @ BALT better than either of them?
and are you watching Peacemaker? The Season 2 opener was NUTS (literally) – full frontal everywhere!
I’m not — hahaha, well in that case!
Nah
Hey Grey! Happy weekend! I’ve got deep OF in OBP league – start all of Marsee, Yaz Jr Jr, Collins, and J-Lowe over Seiya at this point? Focus on Runs, RBIs, SBs.
Absolutely
Looking for a QS in a 14 team Cat league where both teams ratios are out the window so don’t worry about those. Who are your three best bets of these sad options for a QS.
Lorenzen vs. MIN
Strider vs. SEA
Morton vs. CHW
M. Perez @DET
Verlander @STL (121 pitches last time out, maybe won’t go too deep this one)
Messick @TB
L. Garcia @TEX
Strider, Verlander, Morton
Hey Grey,
I’ve got a few injured guys that means I may have to dip into the wire for a Util bat. Can you let me know who your short term favorites are? I’ll give you the matchups for next week in case it helps, but some of these guys literally just got called up (and at least one of them I hadn’t heard of until this column).
Kevin Alcantara (6, TB, @ATL)
Helman (6, MIL, @NYM)
Wenceel Perez (6, @NYY, @MIA)
Nolan Jones (7, KC, CHW)
Robles (7, STL, LAA)
Wenceel
Thanks Grey! Safe to say Lugo is OK to drop for him?
Yup drop
Michael Busch is absolutely KILLING me (and Olson isn’t much better – or any better at all!). Was hoping this column might have a hidden gem 1B, but no luck.
I probably don’t really have much choice but to keep rolling these guys out there? I have Schanuel who is both meh and hurt, and the best 1B available on waivers are guys like Wagaman, Caratini, Kody Clemens, Triolo and Tellez. Yikes!
I’d try Triolo
Hey Grey, I asked yesterday if it might be worth picking up Rengifo or Gorman to start in place of Gimenez. You less-than-enthusiastically said maybe Gorman, but wondering if next week’s matchups matter in that decision given that there are only 3 weeks left:
Gimenez (6, HOU, BAL)
Gorman (6, @SEA, @MIL)
Rengifo (7, MIN, @SEA)
There’s also Nick Yorke (6, @BAL, @WAS), but who the hell really knows if he’ll even play.
I’d go Rengifo
I’ll give it a whirl. Do you think Bogaertz is likely done? That’s probably who I would have to drop (unless I just drop Gimenez).
I think so
Ooof. I have both Cease and Suzuki.
Yeah, but could you do worse looking elsewhere?
I guess not? Cease has Colorado for the next 2 games…Should I try one of these pitchers for next week instead of Cease? Tong @ Tex, Messick @ Chicago, or maybe a closer like Palencia?
Palencia sounds better to me
12T points league
I’d stick with Cease
I’m in first place with a decent lead, but there are lots of categories up in the air. For pitching, it’s very close in ERA, WIP and Wins, a little less so in K’s. So tonight I have the following FIVE SPs starting…
Glasnow (@BAL)
Sanchez (@MIA)
Tolle (@ARI)
Williams (@TB)
Flaherty (CHW)
Not really asking anything – just please tell me everything will be OK…
Everyone will be ok!
Everything too!
Glasnow scratched from his start for undisclosed reasons. Not a good start!!! Everything is not OK!!!
That’s not ok!
Hey Grey! Need a C with Willson beginning his now 4-game suspension. Teel or Kirk?
Have a great weekend!
Teel
Same issue for me, Grey.
Teel or Augustin?
Agustin
Andrew Alvarez worth an add
Sure in some leagues
Cut Darvish for Alvarez
6×6 roto league
Yup
I need a third baseman; pick up Baty or Lewis?
Lewis
Hey Grey!
I am in 10TM H2H and losing playoff rnd 1. (getting rocked)
Currently have OF: Seiya, Arozarena, Yordan Alvarez,Wood
Would you drop Suzuki or any for Jeremiah Jackson (He has OF elig)?
Yes, Seiya for Jackson
Wow! Excellent. Thanks!
No problem
Seiya what the hell happened? I know he will hit as soon as I cut him.
I also am testing my theory about adding a guy to see if it ends his hot streak. Keep an eye on Polanco. I made the move on wed
Haha yeah it’s always how it happens
Last month, I postulated Seiya as a 2026 keeper. And this week, I am hoping to claim Jackson (and drop Seiya). Glad Grey agrees.
Haha yup
2 hr in 2nd half. Brutal.
Keeping Keachall over PCA actually crossed my mind recently…lol how far we’ve fallen
Brutal