Dynasty Catcher Rankings for 2021 Fantasy Baseball

1. The Murphys come as a package deal in every rankings

   Bold ranking on Cervelli

   • Best pair of Murphys since Eddie and Miss Brown made the 1980s laugh.

     And thanks RE Frank Cervo!

     Almost left him off but was feeling flavorful.

     • Cervelli in a Marvin the Martian helmet could hit 3 HRs easily

       • *across 800 at-bats

   • It’s called Murphy’s Law

2. 800 AB’s good one. Got that Luis Castillo power!

3. You think Rutschman is gonna jump the Chance?

   • In 2021, he gets that chance

4. Itch, thanks for the report.

   A question on Rutschman. Any comparison to any of the past catcher greats?

   • Maybe Posey with more power.

5. Fantasy…gimmie Gary Sanchez in the NY lineup. Easily the best power/rbi threat at Catcher. Eventually he will avoid a month long slump and be great for an entire season. Hoping this season.

   He sucked in Spring training, but hey, at least he sucked early on.

   • I had him higher early in the process, but his average risk has gotten bad enough that he’s a 2-category player on draft day because he doesn’t score enough runs to keep up with JT Real, who outpaced him by 30 in the R category. Maybe even a 1.5 category player if you ding him for hurting in batting average.

     I agree he could be Catcher #1 in any season but won’t be paying for the possibility until he makes more consistent contact and pops up a bit less.

6. was offered Groshan for Pearson.

   Also offered ($0) Bruajn and ($18) montas for ($29) giolito

   thoughts?

   • I’d do the Brujan deal but hold Pearson

     • oh sorry, just a little confused because i didnt say who had who.

       I had Groshan for his pearson

       and My brujan and Montas for his giolito

       • In which case, I’d hold Brujan and buy Pearson

7. So glad to see you publish these rankings, Itch!! Really a subject I need help with!

   So for several years I was blessed with the bat of Jonathan Lucroy and I never even worried about catcher. Then, all of a sudden, Lucroy got terrible and he was even terrible in Colorado. I held on to him as long as I could, then finally moved on. Since then I’ve been a desperate man, searching beneath rocks and between the cracks of fat women for a catcher hiding in the shadows. The more I look, the more I long for the days of Lucroy in his prime. I really did not know how fortunate I was then.

   And that brings me to present day in which my starter is Travis D’Arnaud. I only added him because Atlanta signed him. Not because I believe in him. Honestly, I don’t believe. Yuck.

   I do, however, have one catching prospect on my roster. Ivan Hererra (STL). I’m hoping he’s Yadi’s heir to the thrown. I don’t expect miracles from Hererra. I’m just hoping he’s has a good enough stick that I don’t have to worry about having a black hole in my lineup every day. What do you say? Will Ivan be the answer to my catching woes prayers?

8. Itch! I love seeing my boy Mitch Garver in that 3 spot.

Comments are closed.