For the 2026 fantasy baseball season, it’s one game down and 2,429 more to go after the Yankees and Giants squared off on Wednesday night. Since that one game isn’t nearly enough to draw any conclusions, we will spend our first post of the season looking at the risers and fallers from Spring Training performances.
Even over a long Spring Training, four weeks of production is not a lot of information to use when evaluating players for the rest of the season. That’s why it’s also important to look at usage, lineup placement, platoon splits, and other factors when trying to determine what to do with tough player choices.
This piece will look at some MLB fantasy assets that have seen their fantasy value rise and fall over the last few weeks. This will hopefully give us an idea of what to do with these players moving forward.
Spring Training Risers
Luke Keaschall (2B), Minnesota Twins
If Matt McLain weren’t taking over the headlines with his ridiculous Spring Training line, we would all be talking about another Central division second baseman – Luke Keaschall. All Keaschall has done is hit .377/.411/.717 with three homers and two steals in 54 plate appearances. In addition, he only struck out twice all spring. He is about ready to take the next step up for the Twins as a 23-year-old in his first full season. In case you forgot what Keaschall can do, take a look at his production in just 49 games last season.
He hit .302/.382/.445 with four home runs and 14 steals in just 207 plate appearances. Can Keaschall prorate that out to 12 home runs and 45 steals? I don’t see why not. He was above a 12% walk rate at all minor league stops, so his eye is excellent. And his sprint speed is in the 85th percentile among all players.
Cole Young (2B), Seattle Mariners
Over the course of Spring Training, only two players had more plate appearances than Cole Young. The Seattle Mariners wanted to give him a loooooong look in March to make sure he was ready to take over second base after a poor showing in his 77 games as a rookie. Last year, he hit .211/.302/.305 with four home runs in 257 plate appearances. This Spring? He was on fire.
Young hit .281/.349/.667 with six home runs, 18 RBI, and three steals. Add in nine doubles, and you have a guy who looks ready to be the next power-speed stud at second base. And he is only 22 years old. Young has a first-round pedigree and an excellent eye.
If he is still available in your league after the draft, go right now and put in the claim.
Mick Abel (SP), Minnesota Twins
Mick Abel beat out Zebby Matthews for the final spot in the Minnesota Twins rotation after an absolutely unbelievable spring. Abel, only 24 years old, had a 2.05 ERA and a 0.86 WHIP across 22 innings. He added 27 strikeouts while only walking four batters in his 22 innings. After that kind of stretch, he earned a spot in the rotation, and now he will have to prove he can do it every fifth day in the regular season.
Abel, acquired in a trade with Philadelphia last season, was drafted in the first round in 2020 and put up some eye-popping strikeout numbers in the minor leagues. After a bumpy debut last season where he secured a 6.23 ERA, Abel is back to prove he is one of the best young pitching prospects in the game. Walks have always been his struggle, and if he can keep those down this season, the sky is the limit.
Spring Training Fallers
Garrett Mitchell (OF), Milwaukee Brewers
There are over 1,000 players who got a plate appearance in some kind of Spring Training game this season. Only five had more strikeouts than Garrett Mitchell’s 20. Each of those other players had at least 48 at-bats. Mitchell had 37. Could this be a very small sample size? Sure, it could. But it’s hard not to look at .081/.190/.216 from the spring and not be worried. This is, of course, the spring after he hit just .206/.286/.394 in an injury-filled 2025 that held him to 25 games. Should we be worried?
Mitchell was on the 60-day IL last year with a terrible oblique strain. A couple of things could be happening here. One is Mitchell just needs more time to get his swing and mechanics back. The other is: Mitchell is overcompensating and trying to make sure he doesn’t suffer the injury again. Either way, it could be a while before we see the player who had a mini breakout in 2024 before injuries got the best of him.
Kyle Manzardo (1B), Cleveland Guardians
Kyle Manzardo is looking for a breakout season as the primary first baseman of the Cleveland Guardians in 2026. If Spring Training was any kind of harbinger, he may still be looking for it far into the future. Manzardo is hitting .182/.237/.345 as the season opens, and he is one of the few players with more strikeouts than Garrett Mitchell (21). He has more than a 5:1 strikeout-to-walk ratio this spring, which is troubling after back-to-back seasons with a strikeout rate over 25%.
Manzardo has extraordinary power, but he has not been able to maintain the walk rates and pitch selectivity he had in the minor leagues. Entering his age-25 season, now is the time if Manzardo wants to put it all together. We won’t hold 50 at-bats up against him as predictive of what is to come, but Manzardo is still clearly in “show me” mode as the season begins.
Roki Sasaki (SP), Los Angeles Dodgers
I think the Dodgers wanted to give Roki Sasaki more than 8.2 innings this spring, since they’ll need him in their rotation to start the season, but he just couldn’t locate his pitches and looked absolutely dreadful. He finished Spring Training with a 15.58 ERA and a 2.27 WHIP. He gave up 15 walks to just 12 strikeouts. With Blake Snell sidelined to start 2026, the Dodgers have no other choice, but Sasaki looks like the weak link in the pitching rotation for a team that’s otherwise a juggernaut.
Projections for Sasaki aren’t terrible, as most show him with a 4.2 ERA and eight strikeouts per nine innings. He will certainly receive plenty of run support, but considering he only started eight games in 2025, we can’t count on him to give us 25 starts in 2026. The pitcher who struck out 12 batters per game and had an ERA under 3.00 every year in Korea has not emerged yet. Perhaps he still will, but this spring showed he has a long way to go.
Hi CBS,
Appreciate your insight. Below is my team.
2.My bench is now all OFs (Abreu,Varsho and Trout). Would you make any changes?
3.Would you offer Abreu and Chapman to get Riley to upgrade my 3B?
4.Who would you offer to get Riley from the team below or stay the course?
C: William Contreras
1B: Pete Alonso
2B: Jose Altuve
3B: Matt Chapman
SS: Gunnar Henderson
LF: Kyle Stowers (DTD)
CF: Jackson Merrill
RF: Ronald Acuna
DH: Freddie Freeman
Bench:
Daulton Varsho (LF,CF)
Wilyer Abreu (LF,CF,RF)
Max Muncy (2B,3B,SS)
Stanton (LF,RF)
Trout (CF, RF)
SP:
Logan Gilbert
Jacob deGrom
Framber Valdez
Cam Schlitter
MacKenzie Gore
Tatduya Imai
Shane Baz
Parker Messick
Mich Abel
Carlos Rodon IL
RP: Griffen Jax
I am so grateful for your support.
I would flip Abreu and Chapman for Riley and start Trout. You can hold onto Stowers on the IL and he could be a potential replacement for Trout when/if he gets injured later in the year
Hi,
I always enjoy your column!
Would you start or sit Matthew Liberatore of St Louis at home vs TB with Rasmussen on the mound for the Rays? What is your confidence level?
Thanks!!
I would probably make that start, with the understanding that he is likely not going more than four innings. If you are in an innings cap league, it’s probably not necessary