We at Razzball realize that exporting our views across the country has damaging consequences on the blogosphere. To help make amends, we are reaching out to leading team blogs and featuring their locally blogged answers to pressing 2011 fantasy baseball questions regarding their team. We feel this approach will be fresher, more sustainable, and require less energy consumption (for us anyway). The 2011 Pirates Fantasy Baseball Preview comes courtesy of Where Have You Gone, Andy Van Slyke.

1. Not sure how it happened but I’m actually excited about quite a few Pirate hitters this year.  Let’s do some over/under’s.  1) Andrew “The Dread Pirate” McCutchen:  20 homers, 40 steals.  3) Jose “Does My Last Name Rhyme With Ciabatta Or What?!” Tabata:  35 steals.  4) Pedro “The Arghuably Great Pirate Prospect” Alvarez:  25 homers.  5) Ronny “Hey, At Least I’m Not Jack Wilson” Cedeno:  .220 average, .221 OBP.

I hope you’re ready for some weasley politician-like equivocating, because that’s what I’m about to give you. I certainly think that Andrew McCutchen is capable of hitting both those numbers, but I think they’re probably the upper echelon of what he’ll do in 2011. He struggled a ton in July and some in August with a shoulder injury and that put a bit of a damper on his numbers last year, but 20 homers for a righty in PNC Park? Maybe, but I think he’s still a year away from where I’d feel comfortable guaranteeing that. I’m looking for more in the 15-17 range. And we all know the guy can fly, but he kind of put the breaks on last year after swiping 10 in April. What was that all about? Will it continue with Clint Hurdle? Honestly, I have no idea. I’d guess he’ll probably end up somewhere between 35-40 steals this year.

Likewise, Tabata can fly, but how often does he get the green light if he bats leadoff with McCutchen behind him? Or second with ‘Cutch already on base and Walker and Alvarez coming up? Tough question. I’d guess he comes up just a bit short of 35, but again, he’s definitely capable of it.

I feel better about saying Alvarez will go over 25 homers. They call the guy “El Toro” for a reason. He can absolutely crush the ball and when he’s on, he’s out of his mind. He’ll still strike out a ton this this year, but I’m hoping for just a bit more consistency and over a full season, I’ll say he clears 25.

For Ronny Cedeno, I’m creating a new statistic. I’m calling it, “Number of Roger Dorn Style Olés That Make Me Wonder if Ronny Cedeno Is Awake and Ask ‘How Bad Could Pedro Ciriaco Be?'” I’m putting the O/U at 12 NoRDSOTMWiRCIAaASHBCPCBs. I’m taking the over.

2. People look at James McDonald’s September (2.31 ERA, 30 Ks in 35 IP) and they get excited.  What do you expect of him this year?

Let’s be honest here; I’m a Pirate fan and I don’t get my hopes up for pitching. Kris Benson, Oliver Perez, Kip Wells, Ian Snell, Tom Gorzelanny, etc. etc. etc. I also want to point out that his HR/FB rate was awfully low with the Pirates for a guy that’s a generally a flyball pitcher and he’ll probably give up a few more longballs in 2011. That being said, it’s hard not to like the guy. His fastball/curveball is an excellent 1-2 punch and he had some success with his changeup in a few starts with the Pirates. Control is an issue worth keeping an eye on, but I think the strikeouts are real and I think the Pirates are on to something here.

3. Garrett Jones set the world aflame in 2009 with 21 homers and 10 steals in 2009.  Even garnered himself a nickname, Robot Jones.  Then 2010 happened and he hit .247 with 21 homers and 7 steals in almost twice the number of ABs and people scurried.  Or got scurred, if Chingy is reading this to you.  Can Robot, um, reboot in 2011 or is he not going to see any time vs. lefties, ceding to Matt Diaz?

Oh man, you guys call him Robot Jones? We call him Garrett F—-n’ Jones, or GFJ for short, which works both ways. When he was on his unreal tear in 2009 it was “Garrett F—-n’ Jones does it again!” and when he fell apart in the second half last year it was, “Oh man, Garrett F—-n’ Jones is up. We’re screwed.” But can he rebound in 2011? I don’t honestly think he’ll get a chance to and I’m OK with that. Even during his unreal 2009, his OPS against lefties was .698. Last year it was an abysmal .621. He’s going to platoon with Matt Diaz and I think that’s the way it should be. Jones isn’t awful, but he just shouldn’t be playing every day.

4. I purposely left Neil Walker off the over/under’s because I have other bones to pick with this young brother.  Let’s go into what I said in the top 20 2nd basemen for 2011 fantasy baseball post.  “…I don’t fully trust Walker and his BABIP was on the lucky side and his walks weren’t great and his Ks weren’t either…”  Run-on sentence aside, what’s your take on what I had to say?  Are you nervous Neil Walker’s 2011 is going to be a disappointment like Jones’ 2010?

I’m actually kind of optimistic that Walker will be able to avoid Jones’s slide, if only because he’s quite a bit younger at 25. He seemed to be figuring out Triple-A and generating a good walk rate and having good at-bats early in 2010 and he matured quite a bit as a hitter over the course of the season with the Pirates. Matt Bandi at Pittsburgh Lumber Company wrote quite a bit about this after the season. I’m not going to go out and predict that he won’t struggle at all in 2011, because I think he probably will at points, but I do think that the power that he flashed with the Pirates last year (29 doubles and 12 homers in 110 games) is legitimate. I don’t know that he’ll ever be a “walk ever 10 plate appearances” kind of guy, but I do think he has a chance to be a pretty good hitter, especially for a second baseman.

5. When you Google “Last Pirates Winning Season,” it asks you, “Did you mean Pirates Losing Seasons?”  Last year, they lost the third most games in a season for a Pirate club, trailing only the teams of 1952 and 1890, when I believe there were actual pirates playing on the Pirates.  So that brings me to my question, why not let the American League fans run the team?  The American League fans have managed a 12-1 record in the last thirteen All-Star games.  That’s better than the Pirates management!

Well, as you’ve mentioned, the Pirates do have a pretty interesting crop of young hitters right now and they have a lot of pitching talent in the minors, though much of it is on the lowest rungs. It seems weird to say since they’re coming off of a 105-loss season, but I think the Pirates are in a better place right now than they have been in quite some time. That said, it certainly looks like GM Neal Huntington is on the hot seat this year and for all I know ownership will fire him and bring someone in to enact an “Ed Wade Win Now” run and ruin everything. If that happens, I’ll probably start a Durham Bulls blog, or something.

  1. chata says:

    rotographs live chat on 3/18 :


    [Comment From GuestGuest: ]
    your favorite source, outside of this site, for fantasy baseball info?
    Friday March 18, 2011 1:31 Guest

    Brian Joura:
    I’ve got a lot of friends that write fantasy info and I hate to leave anyone out.
    Friday March 18, 2011 1:32 Brian Joura

    Brian Joura:
    But I love Razzball’s mix of wit and intelligence.

  2. Steve says:

    Fantasy Razzballers everywhere are on their knees praying that Cedeno gets to play every day.

  3. Joel says:

    Grey (and anyone else who wants to comment):

    First time playing FBB. My league is H2H, with 6 offense categories and 6 pitching categories. whoever wins the most categories for the week wins. Pitching categories are pretty basic: Ws, Ks, ERA, WHIP, SVs and least HRs allowed. MY QUESTION: I know that generally its not good to take pitchers early, but inthis H2H format, does it make sense to take a stud pitcher (or 2)early? What round should I target for my first pitcher?

  4. DonSlaughtOnslaught says:

    Oh those Battling Bucs.

    LOTS of Fantasy Razzball pitchers on this team.

  5. Nate Marcum says:

    Grey & Co., took place in the NFBC 12 team Live Event yesterday and came away pretty happy. Felt like it was definitely Grey/Rudy influenced. Thoughts

    C. Posada
    C. Salty
    1. Tex
    2. Utley (10th rd)/ Ackley/Theriot
    3. Wright
    SS. Andrus
    CI Dunn
    MI Asdrubal Cabrera
    O. Pence
    O. Ichiro
    O. Torii
    O. Raburn
    O. Tabata
    UT. Manny
    P. Kershaw
    P. Marcum
    P. Romero
    P. Gio
    P. M Minor
    P. Edwin Jackson
    P. Stauffer
    P. Mo Rivera
    P. Hanrahanrahan
    P. Frank Frank

    Bench….Aroldis, Meek, Johan, lorenzo Cain.

    Thanks guys. Good luck to all your drafts.

  6. Wilsonian says:

    These are from the previouis post:

    @Grey: and one more Espinosa question… like him over Chris Johnson for a bench spot when you have Hill at 2B and Raburn and Kendrick in the UTIL spots?

    Sorry, I know I’ve been on this Espinosa crap all day. I’ve been on the road and have been trying to catch up on my leagues via cellphone only for the past week. So many apologies.

  7. Wilsonian says:

    Also, if I wanted to use Rasmus to target a pitcher, who (or what tier) should I target?

  8. J says:

    I’m in an NL Keeper Auction (260) with the following keepers:
    I have excellent keepers – Lince, Kerhsaw, Tulo, JUp, Kemp, LoMo, CarGo and Krispie – all significantly undervalue.

    It is a deep league and we can keep 8. I have an offer on the table in which I give Krispie and get McGehee and Storen. I would trade Storen and keep McGehee. I’m considering this trade because there aren’t many 3B available in the draft (maybe Wright, Aramis, Sandoval, and then it drops off to Headley et al.) I would have McGehee for $14 as opposed to paying $40 + for Wright or $30 + for Aramis or Sandoval.

    Should I consider this trade? It would free up money for me to invest in closers….of which there will be few.

  9. mauledbypandas says:

    i’ve got McCutchen, Tabata, and Alvarez on one of my teams. Never thought I would be watching Pirates games with anything on the line. Should be interesting.

  10. @mauledbypandas – I thought the Pirates are only covered on Radio and have 162 game blackout on TV

  11. Kazmere says:

    12 tm mixed roto. I’ve had this happen in a couple of mock drafts, where I get Miggy in the first round, then have a choice between A-Rod or Kemp. Who would you rather have in the second round? I like the idea of getting a top 3B early, but Kemp is so tempting…

  12. wilsoniam says:

    grey, i know i posted before, but

    if i go into draft with miggy/longo/votto/agonz/heyward/hamels (1b, 3b, of, 2 util, sp)

    can you rank who would you draft in our 1st (which is actually 7th round?) meaning – given my players, who would you pick?

    scherzer, victorino, ellsbury, lind, hill, oswalt

    thanks man.

  13. wilsoniam says:

    lind has OF elig. thanks

  14. Wake Up says:

    Has anyone ever been to a Pirates game? Beautiful park, seriously.

    On the other hand, continuing a drunken conversation from last night with two good friends, at least I considered them good friends since I had just met them 20 minutes earlier and they were drunk and I was drunk, so we were best of friends. Anyway, it had to do with predictions, prognostications and projections, well I tried to include projections(baseball stats, not Freudian faults) because I am in complete fantasy baseball mode until my main draft is done and I believe that there is a way to work in fantasy baseball to every conversation. Some say that a prediction should be backed up with a sound argument, supporting facts and criteria, you know, basically build your case. I say, I don’t care about how you arrived at your prediction. If I am going to you to tell me what is going to happen, all I care about is, did it happen or not? It is not who built the best case at the beginning. It is who was right at the end! Thoughts?

  15. mauledbypandas says:

    @Mr Baseball: My schtick detector just blew up, so I dunno. If I cant watch with MLBTV I guess I wont be seeing them. Sometimes that is for the best though.

  16. mauledbypandas says:

    Also, I know it is just spring training, but maybe Beckett is worth a potential late-ish roung flyer? ESPN has him ranked horribly low.

  17. Sean A. says:

    @Grey: 12-team, 5×5 Rotisserie, pretty competitive league. What do you think?

    C Jarrod Saltalamacchia – Rd. 18 (209)
    C John Jaso – Rd. 22 (257)
    1B Carlos Peña – Rd. 11 (128)
    2B Brandon Phillips – Rd. 4 (41)
    3B Ryan Zimmerman – Rd. 2 (17)
    SS Rafael Furcal – Rd. 10 (113)
    CI Mark Reynolds – Rd. 8 (89)
    MI Howie Kendrick – Rd.13 (152)
    OF Ryan Braun – Rd. 1 (8)
    OF Justin Upton – Rd. 3 (32)
    OF Álex Ríos – Rd. 6 (65)
    OF Logan Morrison – Rd. 19 (224)
    OF Nyjer Morgan – Rd. 24 (281)
    Util Lance Berkman – Rd. 20 (233)
    SP Josh Johnson – Rd. 5 (56)
    SP Jered Weaver – Rd. 7 (80)
    RP Heath Bell – Rd. 9 (104)
    RP José Valverde – Rd. 12 (137)
    P Drew Storen – Rd. 17 (200)
    P Daniel Hudson – Rd. 14 (161)
    P Gio González – Rd. 15 (176)
    P Tim Hudson – Rd. 16 (185)
    P Edwin Jackson – Rd. 21 (248)
    BN Garrett Jones – Rd. 25 (296)
    BN Matt Capps – Rd. 26 (305)
    BN Carlos Zambrano – Rd. 23 (272)

    My opinion is: Low on average, possibly weak on power, but pretty nice pitching.

  18. Stephen says:

    I personally believe that GM Neal Huntington has done a fantastic job building his minors, much like Dayton Moore. Hard to see progress when the team was abysmal before he got there. If their pitching in the low minors can pull through, their farm system rankings will skyrocket.

  19. Grey

    Grey says:

    @chata: I always thought that Brian guy had good taste.

    @Steve: Ha!

    @Joel: I wouldn’t change my H2H strategy for that format.

    @DonSlaughtOnslaught: Yup

    @Nate Marcum: Team looks solid. As I’m sure you know neither of us are fans of Ichiro. Not even really sure why you would take him for that team either since you don’t have an abundance of average killers.

    @Wilsonian: Yeah

    @Wilsonian: I’d want a number one, say Hamels tier, but you’re probably not going to get that. He’s worth more to you.

    @J: I wouldn’t.

    @mauledbypandas: Yeah, no kidding.

    @Mr Baseball: Ha!

    @Kazmere: I have Kemp slightly above A-Rod, but it’s kinda tomato-tomahto. If you like filling your 3rd base spot, go for it.

    @wilsoniam: Ellsbury, Victorino, Hill… Can’t go wrong with any of them.

    @Wake Up: You sound like you’re still drunk. That’s okay, so am I. The beauty of this is you don’t know the end yet.

    @mauledbypandas: If you want to take a flyer with him as your 5th SP, go for it. I’m not touching him.

    @Sean A.: Your hitting is a bit of a mess because you took Bell and Weaver when you were fine with Johnson and waiting until Valverde. Average, power and speed is going to be poor.

  20. chata says:

    feliz is the scheduled starter , today , vs the mariners .
    how far will they let him go ?

  21. mauledbypandas says:

    @Grey: Once again your wisdom shines through. Just watched Beckett fall apart yet again. Still spring training, but I agree, I don’t want the junk in that trunk.

  22. mauledbypandas says:

    @chata: they said 5 innings i believe. Still think he ends up in the pen this year, but they are supposed to decide on a tentative rotation very soon.

  23. Wake Up says:

    @Grey: Ha. I was a little. But, I think you know what I’m talking about. If a Sabermetrician uses every stat in the book to forecast how well player X will be this year and player X bombs, I don’t care how sound the argument was. Player X bombed, that’s what I care about. And if the old one-eyed guy at the horse track tells me that he has a hunch that player Y is going to have a great year and he does. Then, I’m happy that he was right. I don’t care that he didn’t support it with facts. He was right. That’s what I care about.

  24. Wilsonian says:

    @Grey: thanks re: Espinosa.

    Re: Rasmus – there are 3 diehard STL fans in my league and I was thinking of making them an offer, but didn’t know what should be a legitimate target. Thanks, dood.

  25. Carl Spackler says:

    Grey, I know you have the man crush on Mike Minor, but do you like him better than Derek Holland?

  26. Wake Up says:

    @Wilsonian: Oswalt sounds about right

  27. Giant JJ says:

    This Pirate blog hasn’t been posted before? Obviously I’m Wrong or someone would have mentioned it here in the comments, but I could swear I read it like a month ago. In fact I wrote notes about it all over my body so I would remember.

  28. mauledbypandas says:

    Feliz’s line for todays game.

    5 IP | 4 H | 2 ER | 3 K | 2 BB | 72 pitches, 42 strikes

    Not terrible, still hope he stays in the pen this year.

  29. Joel says:

    Grey: thanks. I guess what I’m asking is, having read your stuff it looks like wait on a pitcher till the 5th round or so. Is that in both H2H and rotisserrie, or are pitchers really more valuable in H2H than Rot.?

  30. Steve says:

    Wilson has a strained oblique.

    Or something like that.

  31. Giant JJ says:

    20 team 5×5. I have more than enough average and I’m a little light on steals. Would you trade Ichiro and Masterson for Rajai Davis and Belt? Thanks a ton.

  32. Sean A. says:

    @Grey: I can live with that since the draft played out strangely. I agree on taking too many pitchers in the 7-9 rounds, but there were no hitters left that I liked that weren’t a huge reach at that point. Only real regret was not taking Krispie in Round 8 and/or Tabata in Rounds 11-14.
    Disagree with you that my speed will be bad, but Avg and Power are possible (at least the power has upside though, Average is just going to be a mess).

  33. Simply Fred

    simply fred says:

    @Carl Spackler: Grey says Minor COULD be top 20 SP by end of year. Holland unranked. Dude, what are you on?

  34. Simply Fred

    simply fred says:

    @simply fred: Sorry, hadn’t updated my browser and hadn’t seen Grey’s “yup.”

  35. Ricky Dempsey says:

    @Grey: Dude, I totally screwed myself at SS waiting till the very end to draft Alcides Escobar….Please Help!

    This is the lucky lot I could choose from:
    Tejada, Miguel
    Scutaro, Marco
    Escobar, Yunel
    Bartlett, Jason
    Peralta, Jhonny
    Cabrera, Asdrubal
    Theriot, Ryan
    Aybar, Erick
    Pennington, Cliff
    Cabrera, Orlando

    WWGD? Stick Alcides y/n?

  36. Matt S. says:

    Hey Grey,

    12 team 5 keeper league 6×6 with OBP, SLG and Holds

    We only do 15 rounds because the last 5 rounds stink, and waivers make them more fun.

    My keepers were Teix, McCann, Werth, and Krispie. I got a supplemental pick for my fifth keeper, which I turned into Hamels. I’m starting a little bit behind, but I think I did pretty well.

    C McCann
    1b Teixeira
    2b Aaron Hill
    SS Alcides Escobar
    3b Reynolds
    RF Werth
    CF Krispie
    LF Gardner
    OF Raburn
    CI Gaby Sanchez
    MI Chone Figgins
    Util Lance Berkman

    SP Hamels
    SP Oswalt
    SP Billingsley
    SP Hudson
    SP Gio Gonzalez
    RP Marmol
    RP Axford
    RP Nunez
    RP McGee

    Are there any weaknesses that you can see? Who should I target with my four remaining picks besides Mike Minor and middle relievers?

  37. vinko says:

    Johnny Cueto made another early exit from a start on Saturday.

  38. chata says:

    hey Chum , sorry for your loss (wainwright) .
    still , your keepers are elite .

  39. Joel says:

    here’s a good one: in our H2H league, on Yahoo, we have to pick not just 3 OFs, but a LF, CF and RF. Carlos Gonzalez is eligible at all three positions. How much does that flexibility ramp him up the rankings for my particular league? could it vault him into the top 3-5, above Braun who is just a LF?

  40. Nate Marcum says:


    Only reason I took Ichiro was pure value. Got him in the 8th round and wanted to offset Dunn. At the time is was the right move, IMO, but being able to get some of the players later (tabata, manny, etc) could have spent that pick on maybe a different OF. Thanks for the feedback. Lets hope Ichiro decides to start hitting bombs….

  41. manfromearth says:

    My latest “real”,,,uh, umm….”fake” team includes N.Walker, J.Tabata, A.McCutchen, and J.Hanrahan. Yes, I’m a 52 year old 47 year long Pirate fan. ESPN, 10 team 5×5 H2H. Am I doomed?
    Where should I look to improve? Thanks Grey. Love the site!
    C Napoli
    1B Mig Cabrera
    2B Weeks
    3B McGehee
    SS Reyes
    2B/SS NWalker
    1B/3B Fielder
    OF Kemp
    OF McCutchen
    OF Rasmus
    OF Swisher
    OF Raburn
    UTIL Tabata
    P Weaver
    P Gallardo
    P Billingsley
    P Buchholz
    P Dempster
    P Bumgarner
    P Marmol
    P Axford
    P Hanrahan
    BN De La Rosa
    BN McGee
    BN Swisher

  42. chata says:


    i think your team is very solid , and one that i would go to bat with .

    swisher twice …. typo (?)

  43. Wake Up says:

    re: Wilson… Can I interest anyone in a $12 salad? I will take the corn please the donkeycorn Perez (who will come with lettuce and cost $12 next season) but for now you can still get him for the price of corn.

    re: being hung…ice,milk,banana…blender…then, some honey…works like a charm

  44. Simply Fred

    simply fred says:

    The War Room snake drafts have been updated to the Top300.

    12_team: https://razzball.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/02/Fantasy_Baseball_War_Room_2011.xls

    13+_team: https://razzball.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/02/Fantasy_Baseball_War_Room_12_Plus_Teams.xls

    BTW: If you want to tabulate cat totals for your team, the War Room can do that quickly for you. Just go to the players tab. The owner’s column has team ‘a’ already available in the dropdowns. Just go to each player on your team and assign the ‘a’. Then if you go to the War Room page, you will see all of the cat totals.

    This is an easy way to change out individual players to ‘balance’ your team.

  45. Tom says:

    hey grey what do you think
    12 team H2H

    justin Morn
    brand phil
    Alexei ram
    david wright
    sean rod
    eric young jr
    bobby abreu
    bran allen
    dom brown
    cam maybin
    nate mcclouth

    chad billin
    roy oswalt
    jon niese
    ed volq
    neft feliz
    jj putz
    mike minor

  46. Trevor

    Trevor4G says:

    Black and yellow, black and yellow….

    Did you know that the ole buccos were one game under .500 at home last year? Wow… atleast they made some great acquistions this off season(sarcasm). Hey Bob…. thanks for Nutting :(

  47. Steve says:

    @Steve: Wilson in doubt for Opening Day. Now Putz has hurt his back and could miss the rest of ST.

  48. Steve says:

    What do you think about this 12 team H2H points

    C: Napoli
    1B: Howard
    2B: Roberts
    3B: Wright
    SS: Andrus
    MI: Furcal
    CI: Morneau
    OF: J. Upton
    OF: Heyward
    OF: Pence
    OF: Tabata
    OF: Beltran :o
    UTIL: M. Ramirez
    BN: Posada
    BN: Soriano
    BN: Kubel
    P: Liriano
    P: Gallardo
    P: Marmol
    P: Brett Anderson
    P: Valverde
    P: Gio Gonzalez
    P: Volquez
    P: Jackson
    P: Lidge

  49. vottomatic says:

    I’m kinda really liking Jose Lopez in Colorado and thinkin he could finally reach the potential of a couple years ago. Am I being to optimistic?

  50. Grey

    Grey says:

    @Ricky Dempsey: Alcides is fine for now.

    @Matt S.: Team should be competitive, you might be hurting a bit in power/SLG. Pitching looks fine.

    @vinko: Thanks for the heads up!

    @Joel: Above Kemp in my rankings, not above Braun.

    @manfromearth: Crazy that a team with that many Pirates looks good, but it does. You look just a tad too heavy on speed and light on power.

    @Wake Up: I need that smoothie bad.

    @Tom: Team looks too heavy on risk and upside. You’d do well with a less flashy name like Manny or Abreu.

    @Trevor4G: Ha

    @Steve: Damn, that’s not good.

    @Steve: Should be rule that Beltran needs to be followed by an emoticon. Team looks very solid, potential WHIP issues.

    @vottomatic: https://razzball.com/2nd-basemen-to-target-2011-fantasy-baseball/

  51. Steve says:

    40 mins til my 12-team H2H draft begins. I have the #3 pick…

  52. Eddy says:


    Good luck!

    Do you peg Romo to take over save opps? How about for the DBacks?

  53. Eddy says:

    Though we usually know who’s going to close on teams, there are some special cases where an official announcement goes a long way: Ozzie names Thornton the closer.

  54. Carl says:

    @Giant JJ:

    I had the same feeling. I remember (clearly not so well) it being quite humorous, at least more so than the other previews.
    I suppose it’s time to lay off the glaucoma medicine.

  55. Rick Dempsey says:

    @Grey: who’s set to back up Axford in MIL? is he good?

  56. thewiz says:

    hey grey what do you think of my team, its a 10 player standard espn roto league. Unfortunately there were two other razzballers in the league making it tougher to get the players i wanted.

    C-Miguel Montero
    1st- Votto
    1st/3rd- Fielder
    2nd/ss- Elvis
    of- Gardener
    Utl. Reynolds

    p-CJ Wilson
    p-E. Jackson
    p-Mike Minor

    rp-Leo Nunez

  57. KCC26 says:

    im sure its been asked often, but if youre drafting today, how early would you be willing to go on morneau?

  58. Ozzie says:

    Finally it is draft day!!!!! We were allowed to keep 16 people. Andrus was cut for some reason. I have Hanley, I have to take Andrus just to deal him right?

    Also, SP question. Extra Category K/BB. We start 6-7. I have:
    Hanson, Yovani, E Jackson, D Hudson.

    More or less agree with these available SP rankings? Anyone stand out to move up?

    W Davis
    Y Maya


  59. 18 teams ROTO – AUTO DRAFT – I had 17 draft spot
    number 2 on waiver wire – 18 team auto draft is a tought draft

    Looks like I am short on Holds – but anyway do I use my waiver spot – or wait and see what gets dropped – The league is solid so I am pretty much sure what is left will be taken on wiavers – or maybe I can come up with cheap Holds later – I would guess after waivers I would have around 12th spot if I use it

    Batters Stat Categories: Runs (R), Home Runs (HR), Runs Batted In (RBI), Stolen Bases (SB), Batting Average (AVG), On-base + Slugging Percentage (OPS)
    Pitchers Stat Categories: Wins (W), Saves (SV), Strikeouts (K), Holds (HLD), Earned Run Average (ERA), (Walks + Hits)/ Innings Pitched (WHIP)

    Prince Fielder (Mil – 1B)
    Tsuyoshi Nishioka (Min – 2B,SS)
    Chris Johnson (Hou – 3B)
    J.J. Hardy (Bal – SS)
    Chris Iannetta (Col – C)
    Jason Heyward (Atl – RF) – right field
    Josh Hamilton (Tex – LF,CF) – left field
    Chris Young (Ari – CF) – center field
    Jose Tabata (Pit – LF,CF) – ultility spot

    Justin Smoak (Sea – 1B) bench
    Ryan Kalish (Bos – LF,CF) – bench – drop ?
    Brad Emaus (NYM – 2B) – bad luck – drop

    Dan Haren (LAA – SP)
    Ted Lilly (LAD – SP)
    Jorge De La Rosa (Col – SP)
    Jhoulys Chacin (Col – SP,RP)
    Homer Bailey (Cin – SP)
    Kevin Slowey (Min – SP)

    John Axford (Mil – RP)
    Chris Pérez (Cle – RP)
    Craig Kimbrel (Atl – RP)
    Jordan Walden (LAA – RP)

    players on the waiver wire –

    Daric Barton
    Jeff Niemann
    Randy Wolf
    Mike Pelfrey
    Barry Enright
    Wade LeBlanc
    Kyle Drabek
    Chris Narveson
    Nick Blackburn

    Octavio Dotel
    Kerry Wood
    Michael González
    Casey Janssen
    Nick Masset
    Peter Moylan
    Ryan Perry

  60. Coco Crisp – I was looking into his numbers last year – his numbers were really nice for 290 AB’s – 32 steals – 51 runs and 38 rbi’s and was caught stealing only 3 times

  61. You know grey drafting CoCo Crisp is not like drafting the other The Notorious B.I.G – Hitter Josh Hamilton who is always hurt and is drafted in round 1 or 2 – CoCo comes really cheap and these are the players that you take a chance on for cheap speed that can make a difference – its not like he is a pitcher that might end up going to visit Dr Freeze this year

    come on grey – Men’s Health magazine interviews Coco Crisp this year that has to mean something – true story

    MH: You’ve missed a lot of time due to injury over the past two years—especially last year, when you sat out half the season. Are you finally healthy? And how have you prepared to bounce back with full strength this season?

    CC: Last year I had two shoulder surgeries leading into the offseason, and I didn’t even have the opportunity to have a normal workout. Even when I ran last year, my shoulders were sore. So it was strictly just rehabbing to make sure my shoulders were right enough to play during the first game of the season. And then these finger injuries happened. I still didn’t get a chance to really play hard during the season. But this year, I don’t have to worry about my shoulders or my pinky or anything else I’ve had in the past, so it’s a completely different story

    MH: I know you’re trying to hit for more power this season. How has that been reflected in your workouts?

    CC: I was able to put on a few more pounds this offseason through strength training. Now you don’t want to go too crazy with adding weight, because then you’ll lose some of your speed.

  62. Tony says:

    so whats the word on neftali? closer or starter?

  63. magicterp says:

    Just finished my money league auction. 10 team NL-Only 5×5 H2H

    Kinda uneasy about the team as a whole… punting saves – SAGNOF! Some great hitters but also some question-marks in my starting lineup. What is my achilles heel?

    C Rod Barajas
    1B Joey Votto
    2B Rickie Weeks
    3B Ryan Zimmerman
    SS Troy Tulowitzki
    IF Matt Dominguez
    OF Mike Stanton
    OF Andre Ethier
    OF Hunter Pence
    OF Mark DeRosa
    UTIL Orlando Hudson
    P Jorge De La Rosa
    P Travis Wood
    SP Zack Greinke
    SP Jhoulys Chacin
    SP Daniel Hudson
    RP Sergio Romo
    RP Evan Meek
    BE Tim Stauffer
    BE Juan Miranda
    BE Wade LeBlanc
    BE Gerardo Parra
    BE Sean Marshall

  64. Child Please says:

    10-team 5×5 roto league, non-keeper

    Which two draft picks would you target from 5-10?

  65. PMAC says:

    GREY, I started reading you this year, LOVE the site! I tried to draft my team based on your rankings! Whatcha think?

    C- J.P. Arencibia
    1B- A. Dunn
    2B- D. Uggla
    3B- K. Youkilis
    SS- T. Tulowitzki
    OF- R. Rayburn
    OF- C. Granderson
    OF- C. Rasmus
    OF- R. Ibanez
    MI- I. Desmond
    MI- B. Zobrist
    MI- D. Ackley
    MI- D. Valencia
    OI- G. Sanchez
    OI- G. Jones

    SP- D. Haren
    SP- F. Liriano
    SP- C. Billingsley
    SP- J. Beckett
    SP- E. Jackson
    SP- Mike Minor
    SP- Mike Pineda
    SP- J. Niese
    RP- Axford
    RP- Kimbrel

  66. royce! says:

    @Wake Up: I have to disagree, unless I’m misunderstanding what you mean by “caring about” the predictions. The value of predictions is their ability to be successful over time. If the predictions are right because the variables the predictive system considers are causal, then randomness has less power over the results than if the variables are not causal. Someone’s “gut feelings” could go through periods of great success, but they have no more likelihood of being successful in the future than a number coming up when I roll a die.

  67. Eddy says:

    Though this news is only relevant to deep- leaguers and NL-only managers, Brent Morel has won the 3B job for the White Sox. Those who punt CI until the very end could find this useful as well.

    Kind of an Ian Desmond lite. 50/12/60/270/5 looks like a reasonable line for 2011.

  68. Hennessey says:


    Razzball Commenter League #5 drafts tomorrow night at 9:30ET, and there is one spot that needs to be filled.

    Email me at [email protected] to fill the last spot!

  69. Grey

    Grey says:

    @Eddy: Jeremy Affeldt and Sergio Romo, situational… David Hernandez…

    @Rick Dempsey: Saito

    @thewiz: Too heavy on speed and light on power. Pitching looks better than it needs to be.

    @KCC26: 12 teams, 3rd to 4th…

    @Ozzie: Sure on Andrus, Minor and Zimmermann… Boo-ya.

    @Mr Baseball: Light on speed but the team looks solid. Pitching looks real nice. I’d hold right now with those waiver wire choices.

    @Mr Baseball: If Coco could definitely start 150 games, he’d be great.

    @Tony: Is there final word yet?

    @magicterp: Team’s hitting looks solid for NL-Only. Pitching looks solid. Don’t love punting anything.

    @Child Please: 9 or 10

    @PMAC: Thanks for the kind words! How many teams?

    @Eddy: Thanks for the heads up!

  70. Eng says:

    I don’t want to bore you fine people with my lineup, but I do have quick question for Grey; 12 team league just drafted, I have waiver 6….would you use it on Jon Rauch or hold onto it for later? (I think the Francisco owner will W him I wait for waivers to clear)

  71. Bill Lumbergh says:

    @Grey: What is the scale of your responses (“Ha!”, “hehe”, “Ha”, “Ha, that’s awesome!”, etc.) and is there a page on the site that references the scale? Thanks!

  72. Grey

    Grey says:

    @Eng: Great Rauch if you need saves.

    @Bill Lumbergh: Hehe, Ha, Ha!, Ha, that’s awesome… From weakest to strongest. I should do a page that explains commenting and how I don’t look at old comments and the hierarchy of Ha’s.

  73. Steve says:

    What is the closer situation in Toronto? Frank or Rauch?

  74. Grey

    Grey says:

    @Steve: It’s Francisco if he’s healthy, which he is not as of right now. Doesn’t sound serious but Rauch if a good handcuff. (Dotel is also ailing slightly.)

  75. royce! says:

    @Grey: I always thought “ha” was prior to “hehe”. “Ha” without an exclamation point just seems so sarcastic.

  76. Grey

    Grey says:

    @royce!: Hehe is patronizing, ha is okay, kinda funny but I’m not actually laughing…

  77. PMAC says:

    GREY – 12 teams, Head 2 Head Points

  78. royce! says:

    @Grey: Interesting. I thought of it as describing a true chuckle. But I do remember having seen you use hehe in situations which I didn’t think a chuckle was merited. I suppose I just wrote it off as you having questionable taste. Kidding!

    “Muhahaha” is still villainous, right? I hope to use that a lot this year, especially from the top of the standings in my RCL. Also in court.

  79. Grey

    Grey says:

    @PMAC: Your team is weak on hitting while not dominant in pitching. Better on pitching, just not dominant where you can spare SPs. Your weak on average and speed, which isn’t terrible. This is assuming you actually gave me your starting lineup, I have no idea if all 4 MIs are starting for your team.

  80. Grey

    Grey says:

    @royce!: Yeah, Muahahahaha is villainous, for sure.

  81. @ Grey
    I know I should reach for someone that I really want on my team this year. But how early is too early for Marcum? His ADP in Yahoo leagues is 117. I have seen him go as early as the 7th round and is usually gone by the 8th in most mocks I have done. Is there any value for him in these rounds?

  82. Don says:

    Hey Grey
    What do you do when selecting your first SP in a draftÉ (that E looking thing is supposed to be question mark, something wrong with my keyboard).
    Do you wait for a certain round and select best one available or do you have 1 or 2 you try and getÉ

  83. Don says:

    thanks for link :)

  84. royce! says:

    As a Padres fan, I am hesitant to write this, but this is good anecdotal evidence of both the weight of spring training numbers and the fickleness of AVG: Padres have the second highest AVG in baseball right now.

  85. Thanks Grey.

    Same question for Lester his ADP 39. Seen him go 30th overall. Value there?

  86. Howie Met Your Mother says:


    Last night I drafted at #5 in a 10 team standard ESPN league with guys from my work, I decided this will by my “Razzball” team. I drafted entirely based on your top 300 (modified based on ESPN’s ADP) and came up with a team I thought you could get behind.

    This is my first year doing an ESPN league, and I may have waited too long on my MIF slot, but here is the team that I ended up with, that ESPN projects to finish dead last (10/10) in the league. Is there something I’m missing? Any glaring weaknesses?

    C: Matt Weiters (14th Round)
    1B: Prince Fielder (3rd Round)
    2B: Brandon Phillips (5th Round)
    3B: Evan Longoria (1st Round)
    SS: Stephen Drew (11th Round)
    OF: Matt Holliday (2nd Round)
    OF: Andrew McCutchen (4th Round)
    OF: Hunter Pence (6th Round)
    OF: Drew Stubbs (10th Round)
    OF: Jose Tabta (21st Round)
    CIF: Pedro Alvarez (12th Round)
    MIF: Danny Espinoza (24th Round)
    Bench: Logan Morrison (25th Round)
    SP1: Zach Greinke (7th Round)
    SP2: Roy Oswalt (8th Round)
    SP3: Fracisco Liriano (9th Round)
    SP4: Brett Anderson (13th Round)
    SP5: Daniel Hudson (15th Round)
    SP5: Gio Gonzales (18th Round)
    SP6: Edinzon Volquez (19th Round)
    SP7: Jordan Zimmerman (22nd Round)
    SP8: Jake Peavy (23rd Round)
    RP: Jose Valverde (16th Round)
    RP: Huston Street (17th Round)
    RP: Craig Kimbrell (20th Round)

  87. Eddy says:

    Is “That’s hilarious” lower or above “Ha, that’s awesome”?

    Anyways, bad news: Peavy shut down for today for sure with what he believes as rotator cuff tendinitis.

    I got him on three teams so far, so it’s kind of a bummer.

  88. Joel says:

    @Grey: Please share some of your expert advice for keepers.
    I’m in a 5×5 13 team keeper league.

    Keeping so far:

    Miggy Cabrera
    C. Santana
    C. Bucholtz

    Which two from the following do you advice to keep:
    J. Nathan
    M. Napoli
    S. Marcum
    P. Hughes
    Raj. Davis
    S. Figgins


  89. Don says:

    Brent Morel won the starting 3B gig for the Chicago Whitesox. Watch list worthyÉ

  90. Grey

    Grey says:

    @Don: No problem.

    @royce!: Yeah, means nothing.

    @Chicago Mike: Nope

    @Howie Met Your Mother: You didn’t wait too long, Espinosa is a good flyer. Team looks really stacked overall, good balance of speed and power. Pitching looks great too, nice team.

    @Eddy: Bummer indeed. That’s hilarious is the best.

    @Joel: Marcum and Figgy, but your keepers aren’t great.

  91. Grey

    Grey says:

    @Don: Bleh

  92. PMAC says:

    My starting batting lineup consists of: C, 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, 4 OF, 1B/3B, 2B/SS, and Utility…. any suggestions?

  93. Child Please says:

    12-team 5×5 (QS instead of Wins) keeper league

    I do not have great hitting prospects, so would you pick up Desmond Jennings and stash him on your bench? I would lose a 27th round pick in the redraft if I kept him

  94. Child Please says:

    Forgot to post my team…btw, I would drop Murphy.

    C- Jorge Posada
    1B- Miguel Cabrera
    2B- Neil Walker
    3B- A-rod
    SS- Elvis Andrus
    MI- Reid Brignac
    CI- Carlos Pena
    OFx5- Jason Heyward, Rios, Granderson, Aubrey Huff (1B/OF), Manny Ramirez
    UTIL- Justin Smoak
    BEN-David Murphy

    SP- CC Sabathia, Yovani Gallardo, Roy Oswalt, Anderson, Hellickson, Gio, James McDonald
    RP- Kimbrel, Franklin, Francisco, Rodney, Fuentes, Farnsworth

  95. Wilsonian says:

    Peavy has elbow tendinitis, drop him for: Nolasco, DLR, Kennedy, Shields, Cecil, Minor, Burnett?

    Also drop E. Jackson for any of the above?

  96. Wilsonian says:

    @Wilsonian: sorry, rotator cuff tendonitis.

  97. Eddy says:

    Kendy will open the season on the DL, confirmed the Sciosciapath.

    Time to gets me some Trumbo.

  98. vottomatic says:

    What do you think about this team? 12 team mixed auction league.
    C- Salty
    1B- Votto
    2B- Aaron Hill
    3B- Sandoval
    SS- Ian Desmond
    CI- Kendrys Morales
    OF- CarGo
    OF- Kemp
    OF- Grady Sizemore
    OF- Travis Snider
    UT- Raburn
    SP- Liriano
    SP- Morrow
    SP- Scherzer
    SP-Javier Vasquez
    RP- Storen
    RP- Hanrahan
    B- Brian Roberts…….I got him for a dollar.
    B- Jose Lopez
    B- Mike Minor
    B- Tyler Colvin
    B- Freddie Freeman
    B- Brignac
    B- Brandon Webb
    B- Espinosa

    I left 44 dollars on the table and should have really went higher on McCutcheon but, I think this is a fairly solid team. Except, I have like 4 2nd basemen. Your thoughts?

  99. Schmohawks Bob says:

    Speaking of the Bucs, what’s the latest on Hanrahan/Meek closing situation? What’s your over/under on the number of saves Meek gets this year?

  100. giantJJ says:

    10 team 5×5 h2h. How many SP would you draft to fill the 5 backup rounds?

  101. Steve says:

    Interesting news for MR. Bs everywhere – Neshek has been claimed off waivers by the Padres…

  102. chata says:

    this from cbs sports :
    “Utley still not testing knee: Chase Utley took ground balls on Sunday, but he did so while sitting on a stool. While the Phillies’ second baseman told CSNPhilly.com that he is “moving in the right direction,” he is still not putting pressure on his injured right knee. Utley is trying to avoid surgery, treating his knee primarily though stretching and exercises. There is still no timetable for his return to game action.”

    no mention whether it was a 3-legged stool or 4 .
    but in utley’s case . perhaps more is better .

    the up-shot of this is that , with the start of baseball only 11 days away ,
    i’m forced to significantly down-grade ryan howard , to , perhaps , the
    7th or 8th best 1st bman … depending on dunn , and maybe even youk .

    i can’t afford to wait until after my drafts to make this determination .

    are you still ranking howard at # 4 ?

    that’s a pretty crapolancastic line-up that he has surrounding him .

  103. Bill Lumbergh says:

    Anyone know Lind has the 1B job in Toronto or will he be DH’ing every few games?

  104. Steve says:

    @Grey: Thanks for the update. He has a sore pec, but apparently is getting a second opinion from Dr Freeze…

  105. longbeachyo says:

    Grey! Love the obscure movie quotes. Keep them coming!
    I decided to take your advice… What do you think?

    C Brian McCann (Atl – C)
    1B Miguel Cabrera (Det – 1B)
    2B Aaron Hill (Tor – 2B)
    3B Pedro Alvarez (Pit – 3B)
    SS Mike Aviles (KC – 2B,SS)
    OF Shin-Soo Choo (Cle – OF)
    OF Chris Young (Ari – OF)
    OF Travis Snider (Tor – OF)
    Util Ryan Raburn (Det – 2B,OF)
    Util Cliff Pennington (Oak – SS)
    SP Félix Hernández (Sea – SP)
    SP Francisco Liriano (Min – SP)
    RP José Valverde (Det – RP)
    RP Matt Thornton (CWS – RP)
    P Brett Anderson (Oak – SP)
    P Madison Bumgarner (SF – SP)
    P Jordan Zimmermann (Was – SP)
    BN Jake Peavy (CWS – SP)
    BN Travis Wood (Cin – SP)
    BN Mike Minor (Atl – SP)
    BN James McDonald (Pit – SP)

    14 team league 6×6 H2H… I love pitching… Do I dump anyone for Holland? And what about F-Her and Hill for A-Gon???

    Thanks A bunch!

  106. anarchy burger says:

    help quick
    i have to make a choice by 7:00 est

    please rank- lidge- lyon- l nunez

  107. Grey

    Grey says:

    @Child Please: Doesn’t look like you have room.

    @Wilsonian: Pick up dlR and Kennedy…

    @Eddy: Thanks for the heads up!

    @vottomatic: Team looks solid, not sure what kind of competition you have when you can leave 44 dollars on the table and get that team though.

    @Schmohawks Bob: 12 saves for Meek over/under.

    @giantJJ: 3

    @Steve: Thanks for the heads up!

    @chata: I’m not changing him.

    @Bill Lumbergh: Primary DH

    @longbeachyo: This doesn’t seem like a team I’d advise you to draft so not sure what you mean. Hitting doesn’t look good and the pitching looks too good which is the opposite of what you want in H2H.

    @anarchy burger: You ranked them.

  108. Steve says:

    @Grey: Asked this in the forum in relation to my 12-team H2H league that counts holds. Would you drop Dotel for Ogando? Ogando seems likely to close if Feliz moves to the starting rotation. And even if Feliz stays in the ‘pen, Ogando would be getting Holds…

  109. anarchy burger says:

    wow. this site rules. i’m buying some daquiris

  110. Wilsonian says:

    @Grey: thanks! Is DLR healthy? I’d heard he had some kind of issue with his side or something? I’m kinda surprised you didn’t say Minor.

  111. Grey

    Grey says:

    @Steve: Answered there.

    @anarchy burger: Thanks!

    @Wilsonian: Not sure what you want me to say, none of these pitchers should be on waivers. You have my SP rankings. Is Minor above dlR?

  112. Steve says:

    @Grey: Consider yourself thanked here – and there.

  113. Wilsonian says:

    @Grey: tiny league (8 teams) which is why they’re there. I was mainly just wondering about DLR because I’d heard he was slightly injured and that is why I thought you’d say Minor over him. Many apologies.

  114. Chunk says:

    12 team 5×5 H2H, C,1b, 2b, 3b, SS, OFx3, Util and SPx4, RP, BNx5

    My first real drafts today, did two at the same time. More concerned with this team since I am new to 5×5 and H2H. Any apparent weaknesses??

    1. (1) Albert Pujols (StL – 1B)
    2. (24) Ryan Zimmerman (Was – 3B)
    3. (25) Matt Kemp (LAD – OF)
    4. (48) Yovani Gallardo (Mil – SP)
    5. (49) Brandon Phillips (Cin – 2B)
    6. (72) Chris Young (Ari – OF)
    7. (73) Francisco Liriano (Min – SP)
    8. (96) Elvis Andrus (Tex – SS)
    9. (97) Delmon Young (Min – OF)
    10. (120) Manny Ramírez (TB – OF)
    11. (121) Tim Hudson (Atl – SP)
    12. (144) Miguel Montero (Ari – C)
    13. (145) José Valverde (Det – RP)
    14. (168) Johnny Cueto (Cin – SP)
    15. (169) Carlos Beltrán (NYM – OF)
    16. (192) Edinson Vólquez (Cin – SP)
    17. (193) Huston Street (Col – RP)
    18. (216) Jhoulys Chacin (Col – SP,RP)
    19. (217) Craig Kimbrel (Atl – RP)

    My other league was 26 rounds with 16 teams so obviously I feel like this team is stacked. All opinions much appreciated!

  115. yanks4life says:

    Just finished up my 10-team keeper league and wanted to get some outside feedback on my team, I think i did pretty well thanks to this site. Any comments are greatly appreciated!

    C- Mike Napoli (14)
    1B- Joey Votto (keeper)
    2B- Robinson Cano (keeper)
    3B- Pedro Alvarez (10)
    SS- Troy Tulo (keeper)
    OF- Matt Kemp (keeper)
    OF- Jason Heyward (5th round)
    OF- Hunter Pence (6)
    Util-Chris Young (9)
    Util-Adam Lind (17)
    Bench- JOse Tabata (19)
    Bench- Carlos Pena (21)
    Bench- Travis Snider (22)
    Bench- Jorge Posada ( 24)

    P- YOvanni Gallardo (7)
    P- Francisco Liriano (8)
    SP- Brett Anderson (12)
    SP- Gio Gonzalez (16)
    SP-Edwin Jackson (20)
    RP-Andrew Bailey (15)
    RP- Jonathan Broxton (11)
    RP- Jose Valverde (13)
    Bench- Joel Hanrahanananan (23)
    Bench- Edison Volquez (18)

  116. Grey

    Grey says:

    @Wilsonian: No worries. dlR’s set to start the year, last I heard.

    @Chunk: I’d usually say the pitching is too strong here, but the hitting looks fine, so, yeah, the team oes look stacked. Well played.

    @yanks4life: Yeah, the team is stacked. Doesn’t hurt the keepers you have. You’ll definitely have a top hitting team

  117. Steve says:

    Utley Insuraance? Castillo set to sign with Phillies…

  118. Steve says:

    ‘insurance’, even.

  119. wilsoniam says:

    Grey i drafted logan morrison in a h2h as a bench OF….if im light on speed, keep him b/c hes valuable anyway? Or drop for borbon or coco crisp?

  120. Tony says:

    @grey: who is the closer in seattle?

    drafting now, thanks!!!

  121. Tony says:

    anyone? closer in seattle…..?

  122. Grey

    Grey says:

    @Steve: Makes sense.

    @wilsoniam: Keep him for now.

    @Tony: League’s filling in for Aardsma for the next month.

  123. Child Please says:

    12-team 7(H, K)x 6(H), non-keeper, 22 players per team, C, 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OFx3, 2 UTIL, 7P, 5 Bench

    How do you adjust your rankings to prepare for this draft? Is there a cut off for Ks where you could pair players like there is with WHIP?

  124. Tony says:

    what is up with aardsma if you can remember? if you have the option of one or the other who you taking? AARDSMA?

  125. Steve says:

    @Tony: Had hip surgery in January.

    If you want saves right away, League. Aardsma’s a decent DL stash/handcuff, obviously.

  126. Steve says:

    @Steve: And if you count Holds, League will go from contributing in one category to contributing in another once Aardsma comes back.

  127. Tony says:

    shit aardsma is gone, league is there, might be able to use then deal to an unknowing suspect….

  128. Tony says:

    no holds…. who has the TB job? not much left lol, reaching for nuggets here, mcgee?

  129. Steve says:

    @Tony: Probably Farnsworth and then McGee, but a lot of talk from Maddon about using a committee.

  130. Tony says:

    Grey and Steve: thanks for the help, most of those guys went right before i went to snag them anyways!

    Grey- can you check my squad out and comment, its in the forum, labeled “Trophy Tony’s draft” first section of the forums…… thanks man! So glad baseball is about to begin!

  131. Atomic says:

    Doing slow on-line draft (12 team, mix, keeper) and am up to the 9th round. I can get Utley, though I already have Phillips, so Utley would be Util. Should I take Utley, or go for a 3B (Reynolds, Young, McGehee, Alvarez) or 3rd OF (Rasmus, Granderson, BJ Upton, Gardner, Stubbs though some should get picked before my turn)? I am thinking take Utley in 9th and whoever is left at 3B in the 10th. Thoughts? Thanks.

  132. Wilsonian says:

    Here’s my Commenter league results, give it to me straight Dr. Grey:

    C – Wieters
    1B – Dunn
    2B – Zobrist
    SS – Hanley
    3B – Young
    1B/3B – Pedro
    2B/SS – Espinosa
    OF – McCutchen
    OF – Rasmus
    OF – Markakis
    OF – Raburn
    OF – Torres
    UTIL – Ibanez
    BN – Brandon Allen

    P – Kershaw
    P – Gallardo
    P – D. Hudson
    P – Vazquez
    P – Zambrano
    P – Axford
    P – Lyon
    P – Rodney
    P – Madson
    BN – Cecil
    BN – Niese

  133. Eddy says:


    What side do you want in an OBP league:

    Matt Kemp
    Justin Verlander
    Rd.10 pick


    Adam Lind
    Jake Peavy
    Ian Kennedy
    Rd.5 pick

    Is it fair or lopsided?

  134. Child Please says:

    @Grey: Is there a cut off for Ks where you could pair players like there is with the 1.25 WHIP?

  135. Child Please says:

    @Grey: Ks for Hitters*

  136. Eddy says:


    Btw, why the omission of the “Fucking your step-sister” term? Strong slang? Perhaps changing it to “Screwing..” would be better?

    That term was one all of us could relate with so well. I’d hate to see it gone forever.

  137. Grey

    Grey says:

    @Atomic: Too many good names on the board, wouldn’t take Utley there.

    @Wilsonian: You look pretty light on power. There’s a chance no one in your outfield tops 22 homers. And only one guy did it last year.

    @Eddy: It’s not fair.

    @Child Please: Nope

    @Eddy: Not sure what you mean. Is it no longer in the glossary?

  138. Wilsonian says:

    @Grey: yeah, I was thinking that, as well. I just kept finding myself without a power option. Took Hanley with the 2nd pick and it seemed like every time it got back to me, there wasn’t any power left (or it had just been drafted).

  139. Wilsonian says:

    @Grey: any other (big) issues you see?

  140. Eddy says:


    ‘Tis not.

    And are you leaning toward the Kemp side?

  141. Grey

    Grey says:

    @Wilsonian: No, but that’s a big issue. Kershaw would’ve been fine, you didn’t need Gallardo.

    @Eddy: Yeah, it’s not close.

  142. Wilsonian says:

    @Grey: yeah, hopefully I end up with a ton of 20+ HR guys and it can get me decent points. I’ll be the first to admit the Gallardo pick wasn’t great. I shoulda stopped at Kershaw.

  143. Steve says:

    Bit of a content management FAIL on Yahoo right now. In the ‘Top MLB Headlines’ section on my league homepage:

    # Peavy plans on being in White Sox rotation
    # White Sox RHP Peavy shut down, tendinitis likely


  144. Mike from Jersey says:

    I am pissed you gave credit to Big Jgke for the Biggie Smalls definition of fatguys with no power. i was looking thru the razz dictionary and realized that. if u look at the comments on ur post of asking wat guys like that shud be named, i clearly said biggie smalls.

  145. Kazmere says:

    I have the opportunity to grab Rauch. Drop any of these guys for him? Dotel, Arnoldis, Kuo, Hensley

  146. friar says:

    I have a keeper question. In my shallow (9 team MLB) keeper league I need to figure out who I want to keep (up to five) before our auction next week. At the auction, we each have $260 to spend minus the cost of our keepers. I know I should keep Kinsler at $6, Morneau at $10, and Mauer at $15 for a total of $31. After that, though, I don’t have any obvious bargains for the two remaining spots.

    I could keep J. Reyes for $26, but that seems unlikely to be much below auction value, if at all. I know that Longoria and Zimmerman will both be kept by other managers, so I’m tempted to keep Wright so I don’t get locked out of the good 3Bs, but at $36 I’m worried that would limit me too much in the auction. I could also keep some pitchers (an appealing option since many of the best pitchers – Felix, Lee, Halladay – will be unavailable), but my two best options (Lincecum at $25 and Lester at $21) are both a bit pricier than I’d like in a keeper. Who, if anyone, would you recommend keeping with my 4th and 5th keeper spots, or would I be better off saving my money for the auction?

  147. Long Bawls says:

    Interesting post as always, Grey. I’m a little surprised nobody mentioned Pirates’ management’s plans to hijack a freighter hauling Jeter bobbleheads from China off the Horn of Africa. As I understand, doing this was an integral part of their rebuilding program for this year.

  148. Mike from Jersey says:

    Thank you for the fix

  149. Bob says:

    Hey Grey,

    quick question:

    Ive received an offer:

    Aardsma & Cahill


    Beckett & Chris Perez (My team)

    What do you think? Should i pull the trigger? I originally offered Beckett for Cahill but this is a keeper league and my counterpart is not budging… Ive compared Aardsma and Perez and they seem similar however Aardsma is on DL uptill about May. I am getting rid of Beckett which I’m trying to do without having to just drop him. Any insight would be great! Thanks!!

Comments are closed.