Format = Position Player | Age on 4/1/2027 | Highest Level Played | Estimated Time of Arrival
1. OF Yostin Pena | 19 | A | 2030
A smooth right-handed uppercut makes Pena an exciting visual evaluation, especially considering he jumped straight from the Dominican Summer League to Low-A and thoroughly dominated for a month (24 games) as an 18-year-old facing much older pitchers at a time of year when college draftees are getting funneled into their organizations. He hit six home runs, stole ten bases and slashed .323/.389/.552 with a 14.8 percent strikeout rate, which is probably the most impressive number in the context of a 6’4” 200 pound teenager who’s also hitting for power and taking his walks. Real rocket ship potential here.
2. SS Dax Kilby | 20 | A | 2030
The 39th overall pick in the 2025 draft, Kilby signed for $2,797,500 out of high school and went straight to Low-A, where he slashed .353/.457/.441 with 11 strikeouts and 13 walks in 18 games. It’s tough to fake plate skills like that against pro pitchers, even for three weeks, and Kilby continued to control the zone in his return trip to the level in 2026, drawing 39 walks against 31 strikeouts while reaching base almost half the time (44.8%) in 32 games during a season interrupted by hamstring issues. At 6’2” 190 pounds from the left side, he’s got the frame to add strength and would be an ideal fit in that ballpark.
3. RHP Elmer Rodriguez | 23 | MLB | 2026
A spindly fireballer at 6’4” 177 pounds, Rodriguez has been excellent in New York’s system, earning himself an up-and-down role as a seventh-starter type in his debut season, and while things didn’t go his way in the majors (5.40 ERA in 26.2 IP), he recorded a 2.45 ERA and 105 strikeouts in 106.1 Triple-A innings. The WHIP was less enticing at 1.31 because his walk rate was 12.1 percent (4.57 BB/9), but he avoided barrels and kept the ball in the yard. In fact, he’s allowed just ten home runs in his last two seasons covering 283 innings across four levels, including his stint in the MLB, where his HR/9 of 0.68 would be a plus if he could cut walks while suppressing impact at a similar level. His curveball was especially effective in the majors, surrendering just one single in 73 pitches. His sinker and changeup got hit around a bit, but a solid four-seamer and sweeper give him weapons against both sides of the plate when he’s hitting his spots. The Yankees are great at maximizing their young arms, so there’s a lot of reasons to like Rodriguez.
4. RHP Carlos Lagrange | 22 | AAA | 2027
Lagrange is a 6’7” 248 pound metahuman who throws 102 miles per hour. The Yankees signed him for $10,000 in February of 2022. Now he’s on the cusp of the majors, perhaps as a late-inning weapon after developing as a starter throughout his career. He moved to the Triple-A bullpen at the beginning of June after struggling to consistently find the strike zone and suffered a right shoulder sprain in July. He returned to the mound for one inning in late September and looked good, striking out two hitters without allowing a walk. One inning big whoop, of course, but it’s nice to see the shoulder thing didn’t carry over into the winter. He’s hard to evaluate for fantasy because the Yankees are still saying he’ll be a starter, and we’ve got reasons to trust their read on a pitching prospect, but the value of nightmare relievers keeps climbing, and it might take Lagrange years to find the command required to face a lineup multiple times in a game.
5. SS Stiven Marinez | 19 | DSL | 2031
After losing out on the Roki Sasaki sweepstakes of 2024, the Yankees had money to move and sent $1.65 million of it to Marinez: a left-handed hitting shortstop with speed and power at 5’10” 175 pounds. In 54 DSL games, he slashed .315/.444/.545 with eight home runs, 39 stolen bases and a 12.4 percent strikeout rate. He’ll make his stateside debut in 2027 and would get a big perceived-value boost if he got off to a fast start.
6. 3B Alfred Ciriaco | 20 | DSL | 2031
A 5’11” switch-hitter who signed for $1.65 million in 2024, Ciriaco has played just 52 games as a professional so far, but he was coming on strong in the DSL this season, slashing .333/.505/.545 with two home runs and two steals in 28 games while striking out just 11.6 percent of the time. Like Marinez, he’s nearing a potential escalator for his value in the dynasty game.
7. LHP Hunter Dietz | 22 | NCAA | 2029
At 6’6” and 235 pounds with a low-three-quarters delivery and a mid-90’s fastball that moves all over the place, Dietz fits the prototype of a nasty lefty who wins on deception and stuff and a diverse arsenal: 4-seam, cutter, slider, curve, change. In 85.2 innings for Arkansas, he struck out 131 batters. That’ll do, Hunter. The Yankees selected him 35th overall in this year’s draft and haven’t assigned him yet, opting to rest him after the long college season.
8. OF Brando Mayea | 20 | CPX | 2029
In his final month-plus (27 games) of full-season Low-A, Mayea slashed .333/.398/.548 with six home runs and five stolen bases. That’s not bad for a 20-year-old in a 21-year-old league. He’s also younger in baseball years than Gregorian ones, having played just 169 games since signing for $4.35 million signing out of Cuba in January of 2023. Listed at 5’11” 175 pounds, Mayea’s a right-handed hitter with power and speed to help in our game, and while it might take a while for him to actualize, he’s well worth keeping an eye on.
9. RHP Ben Hess | 24 | AA | 2028
The 26th overall pick in the 2024 draft, Hess has the build and repertoire of a prototype innings eater at 6’5” 255 pounds. He can gas it up to 99 mph with the fastball but sits in the mid 90’s. It’s a typical Yankees heater in that it has good armside run from a balanced delivery that gets good extension, so it plays well up in the strike zone and sets up a curveball with sweeper action coming from his low three-quarter delivery. His season ended in early August, and the club never disclosed the injury, but considering he missed time early in the year due to unspecified arm trouble, his near-term outlook is not looking great until we see otherwise.
10. OF Wilberson De Pena | 20 | A | 2030
Power comes naturally to De Pena, a right-handed hitter at 6’2” 185 pounds with a ferocious swing. In 56 DSL games, he smashed 16 home runs and slashed .358/.411/.677 to earn himself a promotion to Low-A, where the swing-and-miss in his game got exposed, and he slashed .183/.272/.366 with 27 strikeouts in 21 games. This ranking is a bet that it’ll be good for him. Human development is not linear, and this dude can rake.
Thanks for reading!