Intro

Greetings Razzers, it’s another hot season here at Razzball, and have I got a treat for you. This year’s preseason edition of outfield rankings done by yours truly will now feature outfield TIERS. Everybody loves tiers. However, these aren’t just your everyday run-of-the-mill tiers, No sir (/ma’am). These are Coolwhip’s latest labor of love and lament to navigate the wild field of outfielders. My mission, to help you sort through the mess and guide your ship to port. Outfielders are the most prominent position on the offensive side of the ball and I thought I would take a stab at putting together a pairings tool built into the rankings board similar to what Grey has with the starting pitchers (sorta). During the season I’ll be updating a ROS board based on production and my tea leaves but for today, a bit of a draft guide. Let’s talk about it.

CWT – What the hell is that?

These are patent-pending Coolwhip Tiers (CWT). And what CWT does for you is it allows you see where I have the wide breadth of the outfield landscape valued among their peers. These tell you whether I view said outfielder as an OF1 to OF5. And each tier corresponds to a particular Coolwhip $ value. The tiers though are important for guiding you on when you should look at taking an OF for each slot. Most standard leagues these days have 5 OF slots and it’s important to fill those spots in an intentional manner while you juggle the rest of the roster. If you overcommit it can lead you to be thin in other areas that are harder to replace in the season. Since every MLB team has 3 starting outfielders there are more players for those spots (duh) and thus they are easier to replace. You can then make sure to leave a spot or 2 clear for weaker/riskier players that can be cycled. Utilize at least 1-2 players from tiers 4 and 5. could be two 4s, two 5s, whichever.

CW$ – What’s with the money?

That’s Coolwhip Dollars, my dude! Does it mean you can buy something? Not really. The “$” is really a stand-in for value. The CW$ is me assigning a single simplified numerical value to the contribution of the player, paired with risk, injury, etc. And the idea behind these values is that your goal (minimum) should be to collect a 5-person outfield around the $15 total. If you can get close to that, fine. This obviously doesn’t take into account the rest of your roster (that’s what Rudy’s War Room is for). The dollars though aren’t the main focus, it’s more a tool to help you with spreading resources through the tiers. So think more 15 points on the tiers (CWT) vs the dollar amounts. You could follow the traditional route and take one from each tier and that will get you to 15 (OF1, OF2, OF3, OF4, OF5) or shake it up.

My goal for this is to provide you with a roadmap for building out your outfield during the draft without overinvesting in roster positions in FAAB/waiver leagues that are usually ideal for churning out weak links for hot bats and breakouts (MI/CI/UT, OF4, OF5). I’ve talked about this some before, but let’s revisit it now. You usually want 2-3 of these spots to remain flexible and not grow too attached to them so that you can adapt to variance and the hot/cold of less valuable players. Without this adaptability, you are handicapping your potential to remain competitive. So the idea is don’t invest too heavily in OF in the CWT 1-3 range and take some risks with some 4s and 5s so it is easier to let them go should they fail. Be like water, my friend. Without further ado the list…

The List

Rank Name Team POS CWT CW$
1 Juan Soto WSH OF 1 10.4
2 Ronald Acuna Jr. ATL OF 1 9.1
3 Luis Robert CHW OF 1 7.8
4 Kyle Tucker HOU OF 1 7.6
5 Bryce Harper PHI OF 1 7.6
6 Mike Trout LAA OF 1 7.6
7 Mookie Betts LAD OF 1 7.5
8 Yordan Alvarez HOU OF 1 6.8
9 Aaron Judge NYY OF 1 6.5
10 Teoscar Hernandez TOR OF 1 6.1
11 Tyler O’Neill STL OF 1 5.8
12 Eloy Jimenez CHW OF 1 5.4
13 Cedric Mullins BAL OF 1 5.3
14 Starling Marte NYM OF 1 5.2
15 Nick Castellanos PHI OF 1 4.8
16 Randy Arozarena TB OF 1 4.6
17 Giancarlo Stanton NYY OF 1 4.5
18 Whit Merrifield KC 2B/OF 1 4.5
19 Seiya Suzuki CHC OF 2 4.3
20 Ketel Marte ARI 2B/OF 2 4.2
21 Kris Bryant COL 3B/OF 2 4.2
22 J.D. Martinez BOS OF 2 4
23 George Springer TOR OF 2 4
24 Byron Buxton MIN OF 2 3.9
25 Lourdes Gurriel Jr. TOR OF 2 3.7
26 Tommy Edman STL 2B/OF 2 3.7
27 Christian Yelich MIL OF 2 3.6
28 Ryan Mountcastle BAL 1B/OF 2 3.5
29 Cody Bellinger LAD OF 3 3.4
30 Bryan Reynolds PIT OF 3 3.4
31 Kyle Schwarber PHI OF 3 3.2
32 Trent Grisham SD OF 3 2.9
33 Fernando Tatis Jr. SD SS/OF 3 2.8
34 Mitch Haniger SEA OF 3 2.7
35 Hunter Renfroe MIL OF 3 2.6
36 Marcell Ozuna ATL OF 3 2.6
37 Eddie Rosario ATL OF 3 2.5
38 Austin Meadows TB OF 3 2.5
39 Alex Verdugo BOS OF 3 2.5
40 Jesse Winker SEA OF 3 2.5
41 Jarred Kelenic SEA OF 3 2.5
42 Daulton Varsho ARI C/OF 3 2.3
43 Randal Grichuk COL OF 3 2.1
44 Adolis Garcia TEX OF 3 2.1
45 Avisail Garcia MIA OF 4 2
46 Ian Happ CHC OF 4 1.9
47 Myles Straw CLE OF 4 1.8
48 Jo Adell LAA OF 4 1.7
49 Jesus Sanchez MIA OF 4 1.6
50 Charlie Blackmon COL OF 4 1.6
51 Joey Gallo NYY OF 4 1.6
52 Dylan Carlson STL OF 4 1.6
53 Alex Kirilloff MIN 1B/OF 4 1.5
54 Michael Conforto FA OF 4 1.5
55 Andrew Vaughn CHW OF 4 1.4
56 AJ Pollock LAD OF 4 1.3
57 Austin Hays BAL OF 4 1.1
58 Tommy Pham CIN OF 4 1.1
59 Chris Taylor LAD 2B/SS/OF 4 1.1
60 Jorge Soler MIA OF 4 1.1
61 Mark Canha NYM OF 4 0.8
62 Akil Baddoo DET OF 4 0.7
63 Adam Duvall ATL OF 4 0.7
64 Andrew Benintendi KC OF 4 0.6
65 Harrison Bader STL OF 5 0.6
66 Enrique Hernandez BOS 2B/OF 5 0.6
67 Ramon Laureano OAK OF 5 0.5
68 Anthony Santander BAL OF 5 0.5
69 Josh Rojas ARI 2B/SS/OF 5 0.5
70 Wil Myers SD OF 5 0.5
71 Michael Brantley HOU OF 5 0.5
72 Willie Calhoun TEX OF 5 0.4
73 Robbie Grossman DET OF 5 0.4
74 Tyler Naquin CIN OF 5 0.4
75 Andrew McCutchen MIL OF 5 0.3
76 Lane Thomas WSH OF 5 0.3
77 Lorenzo Cain MIL OF 5 0.2
78 Julio Rodriguez SEA OF 5 0.2
79 Max Kepler MIN OF 5 0.2
80 Brandon Nimmo NYM OF 5 0.2
81 Brandon Marsh LAA OF 5 0.1
82 Jeff McNeil NYM 2B/OF 5 0.1
83 Manuel Margot TB OF 5 -0.1
84 Nick Senzel CIN OF 5 -0.1
85 Mike Yastrzemski SF OF 5 -0.1
86 Kyle Lewis SEA OF 5 -0.4
87 Yoshi Tsutsugo PIT 1B/OF 5 -0.5
88 LaMonte Wade Jr. SF 1B/OF 5 -0.5
89 David Peralta ARI OF 5 -0.5
90 Tony Kemp OAK 2B/OF 5 -0.5
91 Garrett Hampson COL 2B/OF 5 -0.5
92 Seth Brown OAK OF 5 -0.5
93 Garrett Cooper MIA OF 5 -0.6
94 Luis Arraez MIN 2B/3B/OF 5 -0.6
95 Hunter Dozier KC 3B/OF 5 -0.8
96 Michael A. Taylor KC OF 5 -0.8
97 Steven Kwan CLE OF 5 -0.8
98 Chad Pinder OAK OF 5 -0.8
99 Rafael Ortega CHC OF 5 -0.9
100 Eric Haase DET C/OF 5 -0.9

Once again, the individual ranks (and to a degree the dollars) don’t really matter, what’s important are the tiers :) Any outfielder not listed, consider them tier 5.

If you want more Coolwhip to top off your baseball experience, fantasy or otherwise, you can follow me on Twitter: @CoolwhipRB.

28 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
snapper
snapper
3 months ago

I love Luis Robert. How not?
Last year he batted .338 with an xBA of .285. If his BA goes under .300 with its across the board effect on counting stats, he slots in at 11 for me on the OF list.
Watcha think?

foul balls
foul balls
3 months ago

Yikes I drafted franmil reyes and don’t see him on this list

TarmanGotHim
TarmanGotHim
3 months ago

Hey Coolwhip!!

You know, in 7-8+ years I don’t think I’ve asked you many questions and I’d like to apologize for that.

Anyhow, my Keeper lock date in this Friday and I can keep 7 in a 12 Team H2H 6X6 with OPS AVG R HR RBI SB K:9 QS S+H K ERA WHIP as our 12 Cats

I have won the league 2 or 3 times, made the Playoffs all but 1 year and took 2nd once. I finished in 5th last year so I’ll be drafting 7th which I like unless I win the league if that makes sense, lol.

My keepers are: (look at that OF BTW)
OF – Juan Soto
OF – Bryce Harper
OF – Luis Robert
1B – Matt Olson
2B/SS – Jazz Chisholm
SP – Shane Bieber
SP – Alek Manoah

My question is, I have a few others guys who I could keep, but I’m pretty set on the 7 above. In the group below, would you be interested in replacing any of the above?

Swanson – SS
Muncy – 3B
SP – Trevor Rogers
SP – Tyler Mahle
SP – Pablo Lopez

I personally like Rogers more than Manoah but I know I could snag Rogers after Manoah and I believe Bieber is going to be back to form. I like Jazz a lot and I like Muncy but nobody else does and his injuries scare me and everyone.

Also, a lot of people are low on Lindor, not just because he’s looking great this spring, but is his value worth it? He seems like a steal in the 3-5 round. I mean, we can’t write off a 28 year old stud on a great team hitting in the top of the order because of one bad season, no?

Thanks!!

TarmanGotHim
TarmanGotHim
Reply to  Coolwhip
3 months ago

Haha, I rant!

Spot on. Thanks for the accurate assessments and responses.

It is a QS league and not a W league but Mahle always fell short of 6 IP LOL, last year it was 5.2 IP 75% of the time. He would get pulled every game at like 89 pitches with 1 out to go in the 6th.

I don’t know how many Innings Manoah will pitch but it doesn’t seem like a concern + I go pitcher heavy of course. A Razzball narrative.

Thank you and keep up the great work!

Five-on-One
Five-on-One
3 months ago

I think you nailed exactly how I can improve my drafting (auction). I rely a bit too heavily on values and rarely go over values to get a guy. As a result, in my auction (12 team, $260, 24 active players/team) There were 24 guys that went for $30 or more, and I got none of them. I ended up with a kick ass OF (Eloy, O’Neill, JDMartinez, Arozarena and Gurriel), but unless someone gets injured, I have no room for a break out guy (like last years Adolis). I might be better off grabbing Acuna (or Trout or Bryce) at over value and then having a $1 guy that I can easily replace later. Maybe I will learn and change my ways next year. Meanwhile I will have to enjoy the stats as they roll in.

Laura Holt
3 months ago

Hey there CW! I thought I was probably the low (wo)man on Reynolds but I see he didn’t make CWT 2… are you basing that on the suckiness of the team, or are you suspecting some average/power regression?

Laura Holt
Reply to  Coolwhip
3 months ago

Yeah, exactly what I was thinking… I feel like he has to repeat last year just to earn his current price. I still don’t own him anywhere; wouldn’t have minded a share or two but there’s always been options on the board that I like better.

Clay
Clay
3 months ago

Thanks! Where would you rank Josh Bell, who’s OF-eligible in certain leagues?

Grey
Admin
3 months ago

Finally, something to argue about!

Seiya should be higher, have you seen Coolwhip’s post? Don’t answer that!

Couldn’t pay me to draft Starling or Whit

Cody Bellinger is done done done

Grey
Admin
Reply to  Coolwhip
3 months ago

By May 1st, Acuna, Soto, Seiya, Dom Smith…

Norman Ginsberg
Norman Ginsberg
3 months ago

Like the format very much. But wondering why several of my OF (Franmil; Walsh) aren’t listed. Surely these aren’t Tier 5 (with negative CWS); I envision them at least mid Level 3.

Last edited 3 months ago by Norman Ginsberg
Uncle Razzkai
Uncle Razzkai
3 months ago

Thanks for the rankings! One question about CWT vs. CW$

I love the CW$ as it indicates how much more you value some player compared to other players ranked below. But there seems to be some tension between your CWT and CW$ as the CW$ difference between players at the bottom of one tier and those at the top of the next tier are often very small (at times zero)

For example, Benintendi (#64, Tier 4) and Bader (#65, Tier 5) have the same CW$ of 0.6. Is this a typo or is there some reasons why you have the two in different tiers?

Aryeh
Aryeh
3 months ago

Need help picking 4 keepers – here are my options (with the round I’d get to pick them at in the snack draft) Help please!

Tyler O’Neill 26
Emmanuel Clase 28
Alek Manoah 28
Logan Webb 27
Logan Gilbert 28
Ranger Suarez 28
Jo Adell 28
Kevin Gausman 13
Jesus Sanchez 28
Corbin Burnes 4
Matt Olson 5

Aryeh
Aryeh
Reply to  Coolwhip
3 months ago

Thanks! H2H standard 5×5 except for SvHlds. 12 teams. O’Neill, Olson, Burnes are pretty much my locks but having trouble with that last spot.

everywhereblair
3 months ago

Bottom 100 OF are ranked with CoolWhomps.