LOGIN

Guys and five girl readers, let’s remember back to last week when Fantasy Pros said I was the best fantasy baseball rankings:

Ah, what a time. We were younger then, and you had more hair! So, we know my 2024 fantasy baseball rankings are best now, empirically. There’s no reason to look elsewhere. Some of you, though, I know you’re curious like a bodega cat. You go around looking at other fantasy baseball rankings. Shame on you, of course, but I won’t shame you to your face, I will roll my eyes behind your back. I will politely hold my nose like I just smelled a fart when you reveal to me you look at ESPN fantasy baseball rankings. I am the greatest GOAT of all-time. I am the GGOATOAT of rankings! Why then did I do so poorly last year in my leagues? Who’s asking?! Who?! I will destroy them! Okay, so I had a rough year with my leagues, which is why I say rankings are only going to get you so far. I drafted Oneil Cruz and Jazz Chisholm Jr. in so many leagues last year, and whose fault was that? Yours! No, it was mine. But this is a long way of saying that rankings can help, but you still need some luck. Sorry, there’s no exact science. With that said, I will scientifically give you some guys who are higher and lower in my rankings than ESPN’s fantasy baseball rankings:

So, this post was originally looking at Points Rankings, which was incorrect. I’m the number one ranker, not the number one pay-attention’er, clearly. I’m now looking at their roto rankings, so I don’t have time for the jibber-jabber as I update this. My big takeaway is there’s a ton of players that just weren’t ranked. The NR’s go crazy. I limited them to the guys I ranked within the top 300, because they ranked up until 300.

Going to list players in a handy chart. The Thank You’s have it. It being good value from my rankings vs. ESPN’s. The No Thank You’s don’t have it. They’re bad people. Meh, they might be okay people, but they’re likely not ending up on any of my ESPN drafted teams. For this, I’ll be using my 2024 fantasy baseball rankings (go figure!) and ESPN’s 2024 fantasy baseball rankings (crazy, right?). Note: I wrote this the other day, so if the numbers aren’t exactly right, it’s because they heard my footsteps. Though, they still have Kodai Senga at 43rd overall, so I’m not sure they’re updating their rankings.

THANK YOU

Player Grey’s Ranking ESPN’s Ranking Overall Difference
Overall Overall
Bryce Harper 11 17 6
Cody Bellinger 35 49 14
Randy Arozarena 30 40 10
Gleyber Torres
74 93 19
Adolis Garcia
28 39 11
Spencer Steer 64 115 51
Nolan Jones 34 65 31
Riley Greene 102 158 56
Nelson Velazquez 244 NR NA
Tyler O’Neill 173 NR NA
Masyn Winn 254 NR NA
Ezequiel Duran 231 NR NA
Cristopher Sanchez 225 NR NA
Michael Wacha 243 NR NA
Seth Lugo 198 NR NA

NO THANK YOU

Player Grey’s Ranking ESPN’s Ranking Overall Difference
Overall Overall
Gerrit Cole
23 16 7
Kevin Gausman
42 25 17
Zack Wheeler 32 22 10
Luis Castillo
43 33 10
Royce Lewis 77 41 36
Framber Valdez
73 44 29
Adley Rutschman
113 47 66
J.T. Realmuto 117 51 66
Kyle Schwarber 115 73 42
Yandy Diaz 166 100 66
Brandon Nimmo 171 126 45