LOGIN

Diamondbacks 1B Tim Tawa (25, AAA) had three walks, three home runs, two steals and zero strikeouts in his first four games, a monster start in all of our Triple-A fantasy leagues. Have to take his Salt Lake outcomes with a grain of . . . skepticism . . . but Tawa has produced throughout his career, which you kind of have to do to make your way as a 5’11” utility type, and the organization has enough confidence in him to use him at the keystone in Ketel Marte’s absence. If he hits, they might try to find room for him off the bench. 

Tigers OF Justyn-Henry Malloy (25) got the call with Gleyber Torres heading to the injured list. He was off to a hot start in three Triple-A games and kept it cooking in his first six plate appearances, going two-for-four with two walks. He batted just .203 in 71 Triple-A games last year, but Malloy has always put in good at bats and generated good outcomes, so I’d be surprised if he doesn’t play better this time around. 

Pirates RHP Thomas Harrington (23) got knocked around in his debut, surrendering six runs in four innings. Command is typically his calling card, but he wasn’t hitting his spots at all on Tuesday, walking four batters that night after walking just eight in 46 Triple-A innings last year. Carmen Mlodzinski looked incredible for three innings in his season debut, but he ran out of gas in the fourth inning and wound up with four earned runs despite a 2.31 FIP. If Pittsburgh has tipped its hand about who will get the ball next time the team needs a fifth starter, I haven’t seen it, but I like both pitchers and think either could get the job done. David Bednar’s demotion adds another wrinkle in the sense that Mlodzinski could be part of the late-inning picture. 

Angels 2B Kyren Paris (23) caught my eye this spring with his approach and physicality (he looks bigger/stronger at a glance through the television). I think he got promoted a little fast for his hit tool, but he almost certainly got promoted earlier than his man-muscles developed, which makes it hard to get a real read on a young hitter. The spring gains appear to have carried over, as Paris is slashing .545/.643/1.000 with a homer and three steals. He’s played center field three times, so he’s about to add OF eligibility in our game. His role is uncertain, but the team’s release of Mickey Moniak makes more sense today with the Angels needing to hold space for Paris. 

Rockies OF Zac Veen has a 152 wRC+ through six games, in case you’re wondering how that’s going. 

Athletics 1B Nick Kurtz (22, AAA) is slashing .462/.500/.923 with three home runs in six games. He’s looked ready for the majors all spring. Wish I had him everywhere. Trouble is, Tyler Soderstrom has three homers in six big league games, and Brent Rooker isn’t going anywhere. Seems Kurtz will need an injury to get the call. 

Cardinals DH Luken Baker (28) has a similar issue in that he has nothing to prove in the minors but can’t get a regular lineup spot to save his life. St. Louis has Willson Contreras at first base and Alec Burleson at designated hitter most nights. Baker gets Burleson’s spot against lefties, and I suspect he’ll mash in that role, but he’ll probably need an injury to get on the field more than that. 

White Sox C Kyle Teel (23, AAA) is slashing .286/.355/.571 with two home runs and nine RBI in seven games. Edgar Quero (21, AAA) is at .400/.556/.450 through six games. While the long-term organizational plan might involve both guys spending most of this season in the minors, that’s not going to be practical if they’re dominating. I’d try to make room for Teel in redraft leagues where I needed some help behind the plate. Matt Thaiss appears to be the team’s everyday catcher, so any ideas that Korey Lee could command a full season of reps is already a bit outdated. 

Marlins SS Max Acosta (22, AAA) just keeps hitting, slashing .333/.394/.467 with a homer and two steals through seven games. I’m starting to build my first stash list of 2025, and Acosta was pretty quick to mind among guys who should get a good long look this year. 

I started hitting with wooden bats in Perfect Game leagues when I was 14 years old, and lately I’ve been reminded of my early thoughts in regard to the shape of the bats. They were so much skinnier than metal bats, and skinnier for so much longer than metal bats, that it took me a long time to trust my swing. Did that to a lot of kids. One of the best hitters on our high school team went something like zero for his first 50 at bats. I still have a pretty clear memory of lobbing soft toss with him during and in-between the games as we tried to work our way out of it. All this is to say the torpedo bats seem way overdue to me. Interesting creatures: humans. Not uncommon to see us just ignore the most obvious thing in the universe. 

Thanks for reading! 

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

44 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Pope
Pope
1 month ago

Hey Itch,

Could you please give me your opinion on Aidan Smith (TB)?

Heard some buzz about him lately but haven’t seen you mention anything about him. Maybe he’s just a bit too far away from the show to be ranked on your 2025 lists?

For context we’re talking 12 team Ottoneu dynasty. I’ve been trying to stash as many from your top 50 (2025 lists) as possible.

David
David
1 month ago

Good read Itch, thanks.

steve stevenson
steve stevenson
1 month ago

Hey Itch, what do you think about Saggese in NL-only? I know you were kinda on him more than most a year or so ago (prompted me to stash him) but I haven’t heard much on him since.

Turn Two
Turn Two
1 month ago

Tawa instead of Lawlar.. as a Lawlar owner, how should I read into this move? Why do I feel like he’ll be a trade chip later this year.

Oddball Herrera
Oddball Herrera
Reply to  Turn Two
1 month ago

I would read “we just needed a guy for 10 days” into it personally

Turn Two
Turn Two
Reply to  The Itch
1 month ago

I thought I read he was out weeks, not days

SteveNZ
1 month ago

Hey Itch – need a guy for my NA slot that isn’t going to be called up in the next 5 minutes so that I have to screw around with my roster to fit him in! So a longer-term hold, basically.

Sounds like Kurtz might fit that bill?

SteveNZ
Reply to  The Itch
1 month ago

Thanks man – appreciate you manning the late shift to answer!

Dom Cobb
Dom Cobb
1 month ago

Kurtz with another dinger today!

Dom Cobb
Dom Cobb
Reply to  The Itch
1 month ago

Gimme the over, seems like health is the only thing that can hold him back. Feels like almost every HR I see from him is an oppo tank.

junior56
junior56
1 month ago

Hi Itch Thank you for the Insite!
Maikel Garcia, do think he is the long-term solution for KC at 3B or is he going become more of a Swiss army knife role in the future? He’s played 2b.ss.3b he took reps in the OF in ST. Also do you think his bat is good enough that he can move closer to the top of the order?

toolshed
1 month ago

Hey Itch,

Do you think there needs to be an injury for Anthony to crack the big league lineup this year? Thanks

Goldirocks
Goldirocks
1 month ago

Hey Itch; I’m competitive in a 12 team 5×5 roto keeper (keep forever ) league.
Would it be in my best interests to trade young phenom Kristian Campbell while he has a ton of helium – plus a first rounder to a rebuilding team for SP Garret Crochet in return?

My pitching is in the top 3rd of the league as is, and my 2B / MI is in the top half without Campbell.

What is the risk that :
1/ Crochet is a one year wonder, but otherwise a high K guy with poor ratios?
2/ Campbell is a future top 20 overall player for fantasy roto?
(I realize you have to give to get)

PS – there’s no innings limits in my league.

Braves233
Braves233
1 month ago

What are your thoughts on lawler when/if he gets called up?

Dancin Homer
1 month ago

Awesome read, thank you!

Could use your help in my Yahoo redraft league where I get a “NA” spot (i.e. minor league stash).

Which of the following you think will be up the soonest/ make the biggest impact on this season (6×6 OPS)?

  • Travis Bazzana
  • Marcelo Mayer
  • Coby Mayo
  • Nick Kurtz
  • Chandler Simpson
  • Zac Veen

Thanks in advance for your insight!

Hutch
Hutch
1 month ago

Thanks itch! Holding Sproat on my minors team….would you drop him for Simpson, Veen or Harrington….apples and oranges I know!

John
John
1 month ago

2 things. Did you see the oppo HR for Kurtz? Holy! Also, Simpson Chandler beat out an infield single on a routine grounder to FIRST BASE!

I have B Chandler and N. Schultz on my bench. Do you think they are up after these clubs get an extra year of service? As always, fine work sir.

Rigatoni Volpe
Rigatoni Volpe
1 month ago

I am looking for a long term solution at 1B in my dynasty league. I have Kurtz in the minors, with Manzardo, Torkelson, Rice, and Busch fightin it out on the live roster.

Fingers crossed one of these darts is a bullseye.

random boners
random boners
1 month ago

You going bananas for Bazzana like me? Hot start.

Rotorooter
Rotorooter
1 month ago

10 team 40 man roster dynasty league- my team is not that competitive so I tried loading up on minor leaguers to play for the future, however, I’m finding it difficult to have enough bench bats to fill a lineup consistently, who (if anyone) would you drop for the time being?

Samuel Basallo
Xavier Isaac
Jesus Made
Sebastian Walcott
Jett Williams
Justin Crawford
Walker Jenkins
Lazaro Montes

Thanks!

Rotorooter
Rotorooter
Reply to  The Itch
1 month ago

No, I’ve been punting saves already (weekly roto H2H 10 category league) and carry 3 bench bats, but, when they’re injured or sitting it would be nice to have another free spot to add a bat quick to boost counting stats. My Bench bats are max muncy/Josh Jung/ Zach Neto/Parker meadows. That brings up my next question- do I drop Parker meadows? My OF is not strong (Aaron judge/Lourdes gurriel/George springer/Kyle Schwarber/ and JJ Bleday)

Thanks so much for all the content!

Chucky
Chucky
1 month ago

Thoughts on Noelvi Marte? Is a call up imminent or waiting for that injury? It’s not like Candelario is earning that contract but are the Reds bound to him because they can’t/won’t admit their mistake? After three consecutive 1-0 defeats, it’s not like they can’t use some offensive infusion.

Chucky
Chucky
Reply to  The Itch
1 month ago

Nailed it! Welcome to The Show 4-8-25

Dude
Dude
1 month ago

Keep forever, PCA or Soderstrom?

Nittanychris
Nittanychris
1 month ago

Great write up! I know it’s very difficult to predict how the Rockies will handle their prospects, but any idea when Veen will get the call up and will they give him enough playing time when they do? Thanks!

Ante
Ante
1 month ago

Itch,

Awesome report!!!

a) Start or sit Dollander in standard RCLs? I’m thinking sit to see how he fares against the As in Coors then if he does well start, him everywhere. I need all pitching categories.

b) Rodney Dangerfield quote of the day for April 6, 2025

You kidding, no respect. I told my son, I said son, some day you’ll have kids of your own. He said, some day you will too. No respect.

Cheers,
Ante