Justin Upton left yesterday’s game with a sprained ankle.  It’s obviously not easy carrying around millions of fantasy baseballers’ hopes and dreams.  He hurt his ankle while stealing second, then he advanced to third and scored one batter later.  I liked Upton 1.0 better, which came with customizable speed and power but no hustle.  The good news is Upton wasn’t removed until after scoring, so it doesn’t sound serious.  Just precautionary.  It’s an exhibition, after all.  You know, like when Kenny Mayne ran Daisy Fuentes for Jerry O’Connell in the 2005 Celebrity Softball game.  Anyway, here’s some more news in fantasy baseball:

Dustin Pedroia – Left wrist sprain.  It’s spraining, men!  That’ll teach Pedroia to try and open the pickle jar all by himself.  This actually worries me more than the Upton sprain.  Injured wrists are tricky for, ya know, hitting.  He’s scheduled to take BP on Thursday so hopefully it’s very minor and the pain doesn’t have to, doesn’t have to, doesn’t have to let it linger.

Ian Desmond – With five errors this spring (as of this writing), he was making it hard for the Nats to choose him over the yawnstipating Guzman.  Nevertheless!  Jon Heyman of SI, which I believe is not a Spanish language magazine, says Desmond is going to win the starting job.  Shine on you crazy Desmond!

Jaime Garcia – Will be the Cards fifth starter.  In the minors, he showed a solid K-rate and great ground ball rates.  Strikeouts + ground balls = Success.  The only downside is his lack of experience, i.e., he can blow up in your face.  Right now, he’s a solid NL-Only sleeper, but he can easily jump onto mixed league radars.

Albert Pujols – Returned to the lineup.  Pujols eats MRIs for breakfast.

Sean Rodriguez – Zobrist will definitely be playing somewhere, but where might factor into if Matt Joyce or Sean Rodriguez play.  Sean-Rod has been hitting in the spring and has a solid pedigree.  I put Rodriguez in my top 20 2nd basemen post, and I’m a big fan if he can score an every day job.  Joyce, meanwhile, hasn’t done anything and may start the season on the DL.  If Gabe Kapler starts in lieu of Rodriguez and Joyce, then it’s welcome back 1999.

Ervin Santana – Hurt his elbow after hitting it on some furniture.  Not a broken armchair, just a slightly sore armchair, thankfully.  Word on the streets of Bobby Grichville is Ervin will be fine.

C.J. Wilson – Will be the Rangers number two starter this year.  (Feldman, Harrison and Colby Lewis will join him after Harden.  I wish the Rangers would dump Wilson and Harrison and add some guys named Astin and Brolin to Feldman.  Let’s get some Goonies up in there!)  I’d chalk up Wilson becoming a starter to the Rangers going with an innings eater, but he’s never pitched more than 74 innings any season in his career.  If Wilson can maintain his reliever K-rates, he could surprise, but I wouldn’t touch him outside of AL-Only leagues until during the season.  And even then, I’ll have a hard time adding him.

Gil Meche – Out with shoulder stiffness.  If you needed a reason to ignore him, now you have one.

Alex Gordon – Won’t be ready by Opening Day.  Not sure if this is good news or bad news for Royals, fantasy baseball owners or Gordon.  Jury’s been out for three years now.

Alberto Callapso – Hillman plans on trying Callaspo out in the three hole.  This is one of the funniest bits of news I’ve read this Spring Training.  It’s just inherently hilarious.  Callaspo a three hitter?  Ha!  Ladies and gentlemen, your peasant Royals!  If Alex Gordon was the unrealized hopes of another George Brett.  Callaspo is Kevin Seitzer.

Blake DeWitt – I might be the only one that cares about this because I drafted Belliard in my Fantasy Razzball league, but DeWitt looks like he has the inside track for the 2nd base job.  He’s a poor man’s Casey McGehee. (<–Not a compliment)

Chris Iannetta – I wish I could say Chris Iannetta is proving Olivo to be from The Department of Redundancy Department.  Still think Iannetta emerges with more ABs, but they might be pretty close to a timeshare like your Aunt Mitzi has in Boca.  Playing only four days a week, Iannetta might just be Napoli for the NL.  If only Joe Torre managed them… Or Paul Sorvino.

Andrew Bailey – Close to returning to action and should be ready for Opening Day.  Doesn’t mean another flare-up isn’t a week or so away.

Mike MacDougal – Released by the Marlins and signed by the Nats.  Capps is still the closer in Washington, but MacDougal could serve as insurance.  He was good in Washington last year and he was great in the Doobie Brothers.

Jon Niese – Just about has the 5th starter job locked up.  He hasn’t reached mixed league material yet.  In NL-Only leagues, he’s there.  He’ll get you a mid-4 ERA and a near 7 K/9.  Last round or dollar flier?  It can’t hurt.

Daniel Murphy – With Ike Davis sent down (surprisingly, Ike is not a slap hitter), Murphy has secured the 1st base job.  It won’t be pretty though.

Jose Reyes – Reyes finished first in full-squad sprints.  I’m putting it at 3 to 1 for him playing Opening Day.  Even odds says he’s back within two weeks.  The time to buy low is running out.

Gary Matthews Jr. – Okay, this is the funniest news I’ve read this Spring Training.  The Mets are shopping Gary Matthews Jr.  Reminds me of the homeless man who lives down the street selling his barely used pants.

  1. matthole says:

    do you view pacman jones as a #2 or #3 OF….thanks

  2. DrEasy says:

    Ike jokes, now that’s slapstick!

  3. Ben C says:

    “Hit me again Ike..and this time put some stank on it!”

    Looking to add some depth to my starting pitching, 14 team, auction, 9 keepers, 3yr max. Current staff is Grienke,
    F-Her, Oswalt, Correia. Wells, Bumgarner, Jaime Garcia. The free agent list be slim pickins so the options are
    pretty yucky. Looking to add a few, what names would you recommend?

    Cahill, Zito, Hammel, Kawakami, Padilla, Paulino, A. Sanchez, Duensing, Stauffer, Rzepcynski, Nieve,
    Niese, C. Lewis, Pavano, B. Myers, Garland, Gallagher.

    Thank you

  4. JRT says:


    Would you potentially suggest Sean-Rod over Scutaro for a 2b/SS position?


  5. Tony says:

    @simply fred: let me know about the war room, i haven’t even accessed it yet at home, and I can’t at school. Our draft was impressive, ichiro went into the 7th round? HA! Thats awesome, and sick chubbs…

    @grey: i snagged zigler in my RCL last night just in case bailey hiccups, and would you rather have rollins or reyes? I went Fielder, Rollins, and Youk in my first 3 last nite. Kinda wishing I woulda went Fielder, Agon, and then Reyes for the speed and SS fill. Hindsite is 20/20 huh?

    my head still hurts from that draft…..

  6. Eric says:

    I’ve got a draft tonight. In a 5X5 mixed roto league, around what pick overall would you take Jose Reyes? I pick 8th in a 10-team league, so I’ve got the 8th, 13th, 28th, 33rd, 48th, 53rd, etc picks.

  7. Josh says:

    would you put Garcia or Niese in your top 300? if so, roughly where?

  8. Tony says:

    @Eric: 28th or 33rd, he shouldnt be there if your league knows anything by 53….. i’d almost say take him with your 3rd round pick 28th overall….

  9. David says:

    @Grey: I’m a little confused with your assessment of my team. As a refresher, my team (12 team points league) is as follows:

    C: Soto
    1B: A. Gonzalez
    2B: Utley
    SS: Andrus
    3B: Chipper/C. Davis/Headley
    OF: Kemp
    OF: Sizemore
    OF: Cruz
    Util: Pence
    SP: Haren
    SP: Ubaldo
    SP: Garza
    SP: Wandy
    RP: Wagner
    RP: Hoffman

    Bench: Jon Sanchez, Masterson, Corey Hart, Fowler, Harang, Desmond

    You said I was weak on power, but looking at your projections everybody except Andrus, Chipper (20), and Soto (18) is expected to hit over 25 HRs. I realize I drafted 3 third basement, but I am trying to hedge my bets with Mr. Glass at third. Pitchers went so quick in this draft that by the 15th, Masterson and Harang were the only guys left from your top 80, which is why I picked up some bench hitters with upside/backups to my starters.

    Love the site and surely appreciate any advice.

  10. eltoo says:

    @Tony: For a second I thought you did stay up really late to work the waiver wire, forgot that the comments post showing pacific time. I’m still getting over the shame of not being prepared for when the guy I was sitting on was taken right before me, catching me with my queue empty and ESPN auto picking Brandon Webb when I timed out.

  11. Tony says:

    @eltoo: haha, ya that sucks, my queue was filled then just destroyed each round…. i literally got sniped all damn draft. I wish i woulda took reyes now instead of Rollins, i think that might be my one regret, in a league like this the risk/reward would have been HUGE. Razz favs just flew off the board, almost to the point i think alot of value was lost, what do you think?

    I mean andrus in the 8th was it? I know fred wanted stewart but in the 7th or 8th where he took HIM?

  12. ThePoonTycoon says:

    @David: i think your team looks damn solid. i like hedging your bets with multiple 3Bs if you aren’t landing one of the top guys (longoria, wright, zimm, youk, reynolds, and i guess kung fu panda too). that’s what i’m trying to do, i figure if i have 2 or 3 lower 3Bs, hopefully at least one of them breaks out and has a solid season.

  13. Jesse says:

    I am thinking of hitchin a ride on the Sean Rodriguez bandwagon. Only problem is, in order to make room, I’ve got to drop formerly-awesome, then formerly-shizzy Kelly Johnson. Is it worth dropping Johnson to see what Rodriguez can do?

  14. magicterp says:

    “The Department of Redundancy Department” – nicely played!
    In NL-Only, better catcher – Clement, Olivo or Pudge? (yeah, I punted catcher) Clement looks to get the most ABs, but he’s had a rough spring.
    Also, will EY Jr. break camp w/ the Rox? If not, how long’s the wait?

  15. steamer says:

    draft strategy question guys….drafting 11th – 12 team H2H – be looking at 1b/3b in 1st/2nd rounds (some combo of Tex/Cab/Howard/Long/Wright), unless someone drops. In my mocks I’m consistently seeing Phillips there at the end of round 3. Would you grab him, or Mourneau/Youk to shore up my CI spot & grab 2nd later (Stewart). I’ll be getting my #1 OF at the beginning of round 4, unless I already have one.

  16. Beau says:

    Hey guys, after much prep finally had my keeper draft last night. I think I did pretty well after having to punt ss/3b/mi. Its a 10 team 5×5 mixed league with standard positions plus MI, CI, 2 util, 3 of, 3 sp, 3rp, 5 p spots and only 2 bn spots. Here is my team, any thoughts?
    c: napoli
    1b: fielder
    2b: utley
    3b: chris davis
    ss: miguel tejada
    ci: fielder
    of: ellsbury, holliday, quentin
    util: beltran, garrett jones
    sp: lester, hamels, nolasco, garza, webb, buchholz, hughes
    rp: marmol, aardsma, jenks, capps, perez

    I probably shouldve filled my infield before grabbing some of the pitchers, but with so many pitchers being kept i wanted to make sure i got solid middle tier value. Here are some players on waivers, anyone think i should grab them:
    Juan rivera, fragu, s.sizemore, mcgehee, ervin santana, dotel, lyon


  17. eltoo says:

    yeah, I took Andrus real early, but have no regrets about that pick. didn’t think he’d make it back to me in the next round and as it stands he’s the only guy on my team thats a lock to steal 20+ bags. I was hoping to grab beckham there, but like all the guys I usually start reaching for in the 7th round on, he was long gone in this draft.

  18. GopherDay says:

    Grey, what do you think about my team? Its a 12 team 6X6 ROTO league (Ks and HLDS added) where we keep players 2 rounds ahead of where they were drafted.

    I auto-picked the team because I couldn’t make the draft, so my team is not ideal, but I am wondering what you think about it.

    C: Mike Napoli
    1B: Albert Pujols
    2B: Robinson Cano
    SS: Jimmy Rollins
    3B: Ryan Zimmerman
    MI: Ian Desmond
    CI: Ian Stewart
    IF: Nick Swisher
    LF: Carlos Quentin
    CF: Curtis Granderson
    RF: Josh Hamilton
    OF: Austin Jackson
    Util: Vladimir Guerrero

    SP: Johan Santana
    SP: Cole Hamels
    RP: Brian Fuentes
    RP: Chris Perez
    P: Mike Adams
    P: Clayton Kershaw
    P: Chad Billingsley
    P: Roy Oswalt
    BN: Franklin Morales
    BN: Kevin Slowey
    BN: Clay Bucholze
    BN: Nick Masset

    I’m a little speed light, but then again….what are SAGNOFs for?

  19. mc serch says:

    @David: I think your team looks pretty stacked. How the heck did you end up with Utley, Kemp, A-Gon and Grady in a 12 teamer? IMO, you need a low WHIP fifth starter (you have tons of k’s) and another guy for saves, but that’s about it. Good draft!

  20. Tony says:

    @eltoo: normally I would never go verlander then wainy, but hey everyone was zigging i zagged? we all waited on closers then they went and went and gone….

  21. Tony says:

    @eltoo: ya i feel light on SB’s, but what can i do…. got sniped!

  22. Tony says:

    @Beau: i think i’d own dotel over perez? just for the fact that perez’s job might be temporary and Dotels is more safe.

  23. Frank Rizzo says:

    Damn, the news about Reyes is coming too early. Hope ESPN keeps him 81st overall for just one more day (draft Friday).

    Does the CJ Wilson news mean Francisco is without competition for the closer’s roll now?

  24. David_C says:

    K’s plus Gb’s dont always guarantee sucess if you walk the ball park half time…
    I.E. Manny Parra….Not saying Garcia is parra but you have to acknowledge the Walks

  25. Back to Minors says:

    Question: Rios vs Pence. IMO Pence seems to be the overall better choice, yet Rios is ranked 80 vs Pence at 102. I guess just don’t get it.

    Grey, would you ever take Rios before Pence?

  26. Beau says:

    @Tony: That sounds decent. I guess I dont need 5 closers. Might as well accumulate talent and then try to trade a few weeks into the season.

  27. David says:

    @ThePoonTycoon: Yeah, after I didn’t land Zim, I had to shift my strategy. No way I’m trusting Chipper to man the third base spot all season.

    @mc serch: Thanks! This was by far the weirdest draft I’ve ever participated in. Pitchers were flying off the board early and I loaded up on studs. The only downside is I didn’t get guys like Cole and Bills because they were gone way before I was expecting to draft them. Kurt Suzuki got taken in the 7th!

  28. Jesse says:

    Um, just a thought, but let’s maybe not abuse the privilege of getting all kinds of advice at all times of day that we’ve been spoiled with by posting our entire fantasy teams and asking Grey to break them down. I mean, ultimately, all you’re looking for is someone to say, “You did a good job!” and give you the proverbial pat on the back – there’s no real substantive question or request for advice there, so maybe let’s just keep our entire rosters to ourselves, huh?

  29. Tony says:

    @Beau: ya at the moment if you’re that deep and those guys are on waivers, i doubt anyone is dealing for a closer….

  30. ThePoonTycoon says:

    go ian desmond go!!

    also, am i the only person who feels like they may end up with dotel on every team?

  31. Beau says:

    @Tony: Yeah, for a $$ keeper league it was a weird draft with a few people autodrafting from their queue towards the end and the commish just plain not showing up a lot of closers were left late in the draft. I decided to stick with my overall strategy and punt offensive bench and just grab low risk extra pitchers.

  32. PepeSilvia says:

    hey Grey, I wanted to ask for your thoughts on a proposed trade. here’s my current starting lineup and starting rotation (12 team keeper league, no MI or CI but we do have a U):

    C Montero
    1B Fielder
    2B Roberts
    3B Wright
    SS Andrus
    LF Morgan
    CF Pacman
    RF Bruce
    U Morales
    SP Lester
    SP Jimenez
    SP Nolasco
    SP Shields
    SP Webb

    I’m really not happy with Morgan as my LF (also took Coghlan but I don’t think he really helps things), took him too early b/c the decent LFs were running out and I thought I needed speed but I ended up getting that from Andrus later.

    Anyway, what do you think of a deal where I give up Morales and Shields and get back Lind and Sheets? One point in my favor is that Lind is an 18th round keeper whereas Morales is a 13th. But am I still getting hosed?

  33. Thunder Dan says:

    Grey, you know I’m such a fool for you…

  34. GopherDay says:

    @Beau: The commish didn’t show up?? Is the league very competitive?

  35. Beau says:

    @GopherDay: Thats such the strange thing, it is a very competitive keeper league, I think its the 3rd or 4th year of the league and he has been very active keeping everything set up with all sorts of keeper trades and draft pick trades in the off seasons, and then just didnt show up and no one could get a hold of him. Bizzare. Maybe he was hanging out with grey and some “actresses” or something.

  36. mannybeingmanny says:

    Had a keeper league draft last night- 3rd year of league H2H 5×5.
    First 6 selections were keepers, would appreciate any and all feedback?

    1. (11) Albert Pujols 1B
    2. (14) Chase Utley 2B
    3. (35) Troy Tulowitzki SS
    4. (38) David Wright 3B
    5. (59) Carl Crawford OF
    6. (62) Zack Greinke SP
    7. (83) Cole Hamels SP
    8. (86) Nelson Cruz OF
    9. (110) Carlos González OF
    10. (127) Carlos Quentin OF
    11. (131) David Price SP
    12. (138) Brian Fuentes RP
    13. (155) Álex Ríos OF
    14. (158) James Shields SP
    15. (179) Ryan Franklin RP
    16. (182) Brad Lidge RP
    17. (203) Johnny Cueto SP
    18. (206) Jon Rauch RP
    19. (227) Clay Buchholz SP
    20. (230) Rich Harden SP
    21. (251) Matt Lindstrom RP
    22. (254) Travis Snider OF
    23. (275) Everth Cabrera SS
    24. (278) Chris Iannetta C

  37. Baron Von Vulturewins

    Baron Von Vulturewins says:

    @Back to Minors: Rios is terrible. Stay away from him.

    You never want a player whose desire is widely questioned by actual major-league scouts. That’s the knock on Rios — great talent, apparently can’t give a shizz.

    He hasn’t been good for years, and he is heartbreak in a bottle. AVOID.

  38. Tarasco'sSecretStash says:

    You shall know my squad’s name only by the rumors of its terrible deeds. And you shall tremble and gasp when confronted by its awesome suckitude.

    Also, hot tub party at my place in October. Bring wine coolers and women (no Zima!).

    C: (Captain) Jason Kendall
    1B: Casey Kotchman
    2B: Luis Castillo
    SS: Cliff Pennington
    3B: Jhonny Peralta
    CI: Andy LaRoche
    MI: Edgar Renteria
    OF: Scott Podsednik
    OF: Coco Crisp
    OF: Kosuke Fukodome
    OF: Melky Cabrera
    OF: Chris B. Young
    Util: Will Venable

    BN: Kelly Shoppach
    BN: Jack Cust
    BN: Clint Barmes
    BN: Jeff Baker
    BN: Garrett Jones

    P: Jon Garland
    P: Oliver Perez
    P: Daniel McCutchen
    P: Jake Westbrook
    P: Randy Wells
    P: Homer Bailey
    P: Chris Volstad
    P: Brett Cecil
    P: Aaron Cook

  39. Dingo says:

    Callaspo is actually a pretty valuable player in real-world baseball, not that it matters much here. In fantasy, his upside is probably crapolanco with a teeny bit more power. Ever since he pooped the bed on me for the week that I rostered him last year, I can’t see his name without thinking “Alberto Collapso”

  40. Eric H. says:

    This question is for anyone:

    I’m in a 5×5 12-team ML (3 OF, Util). I have those 4 spots filled by Jayson Werth, Curtis Granderson, Carlos Quentin and Vlad Guerrero. Would you trade Guerrero for Nate McLouth? Or should I hold onto Vlad and see what he does batting between Hamilton and Cruz in Texas?


  41. royce! says:

    I was all excited to share the news that Chris Young pitched very well yesterday (6IP, 3 H, 5 K, ER), but then realized he pitched against the Mariners. And, though it was not a split-squad game, neither The Big FraGu nor Figgy played.

    So I guess the news is that Chris Young will pitch very well…in Portland!

  42. royce! says:

    @Tarasco’sSecretStash: That is the first full Razzball team I’ve viewed, but I don’t see how it can be beat. Or win. Or whatever you call it. I tremble before it.

  43. Jason says:

    Not particularly related to the post….but I’m drafting tonight and was hoping for a little advice.

    I’ve drank/drunken/drunk/poured-the-powder-directly-into-my-mouth of the kool-aid on waiting until late in the draft on catchers and closers, but still haven’t mastered how long to wait. In a 10 team 5×5 league, how long do you suggest holding off on grabbing one of those two positions?

  44. charlie batch says:

    what do you think about vlad guerrero this year? bounce back? over/under garrett jones?

  45. nmdunkel says:

    Anyone else noticed how late 1B power is going? After the first round, everyone seems to be passing, thinking they can get those stats late because it’s such a deep position. Which it’s not, after I (you) take them all.

    Just saying, because it’s become an exploitable market inefficiency. I’ve never seen 1B so ignored after the top 3 or 4 are gone.

  46. ichirosan says:


    If Callaspo was just a bit more… well, more, that term should go straight into Razzball Glossary

  47. Beau says:

    @Jason: I like to grab a closer somewhere near the 10th round, a second maybe around 15-20 range and then a couple near the very end of the draft. I am definitely a sagnof guy but i hate relying completely on waivers. I think the best way to approach closers is to being the guy in my keeper draft last night who took Mo in the 4th, but if its the 20th and you dont have any you are probably screwed.

  48. Beau says:

    @Beau: I mean NOT be the guy in my draft who took Mo in the 4th…

  49. charlie batch says:

    @Jason: hey man. I know youre looking for grey to respond but personally, using razzball philosophy, I like to wait until the 13th or 14th round before looking at closers, and the 16th/17th for a catcher. If all the good catchers are gone before the 16th then I take the best one available in the last round. Theyre all the same!

  50. nmdunkel says:


    My two cents would be to use your very last pick on a catcher. Like a John Baker or a Molina.

    Closers? That differs from draft to draft. Sometimes people get crazy and you end up with the Dotel’s of the world. But I’d definitely want a core lineup that I felt good about and a couple quality SP before I jumped into the closer pool. If you end up getting burned on closers, load up on setup guys and pray. Usually about a 30% turnover rate with them.

  51. @royce!:

    Love Chris Young, I think the Dbacks stole like 30 bases last year just vs him.

  52. nmdunkel says:


    1) Is Zima even still being sold? Seriously…

    2) That team will be even more razztastic after you lose robot jones.

  53. Tony says:

    @PepeSilvia: morales and shields for lind/sheets? are we talking kendry? kendry probbaly not, franklin go for it….

  54. Jackie says:

    OK, last time I ask this as my draft is Friday:

    12-team mixed league, 5×5, with $260 in auction money. I can keep three of the following:

    BJ Upton: $1
    Hanson: $1
    Wieters: $1
    ARod: $37

    I’m torn between keeping Arod or Wieters. Since there are so many good players being kept (Braun, Lincecum for $1), we have some price inflation that will drive Arod’s value to around $55.

    So, do I keep Arod for $37 and save ~$18 while going with a $1 Napoli or do I stick with Wieters for $1 and drop the $50+ on an Arod or Utley?

    Thanks all. Last time I ask I promise!!

  55. Lines says:


    Not cool, man. I was a huge Kevin Seitzer fan. You’re a funny guy, but that Callaspo comparison was just plain hurtful.

    I’ll let it slide this time, but if you say one unkind word about Corey Snyder or Jeff Frye, I’m through with Razzball. For at least an hour.

  56. Tarasco'sSecretStash says:

    @ Tony: I dunno, I kinda like Robot as a razzball flyer, if such a beast can be said to exist. He whiffs a good deal, his steals don’t count, Pittsburgh’s offense sucks so he won’t score or drive in many runs, he’s reasonably guaranteed a full season of AB’s regardless of performance, and if his seems-too-high-to-be-sustainable 21+% HR/FB and .323 BABIP rates regress this year he could be a nice little cornerman.

  57. GopherDay says:

    @Jackie: If I were you, I wouldn’t keep Hanson for a dollar. Wieters > Hanson….at that price, go for hitters….So then your keepers would be A-Rod, Upton, Wieters.

    Just my two cents.

  58. Grey

    Grey says:

    @matthole: Yup

    @Ben C: Lose Bumgarner for Paulino.

    @JRT: If he starts…

    @Tony: Rollins is fine.

    @David: Your hitting looks very balanced. All I can say is some times I’ll scroll up to look at a team and scroll down to write a critique and when I scroll back up I look at the wrong team. Easy way around this is the forums.

    @Eric: 48th

    @Josh: 300

    @Jesse: Kinda depends on the team, but I probably wouldn’t right now.

    @magicterp: Clement — No on Young.

    @steamer: Phillips

    @Beau: For a ten team league, it should be a stronger offense even with Fielder listed twice. Your pitching looks fine.

    @GopherDay: Really not a terrible team considering it was autodrafted. Your pitching looks stronger than your hitting, which isn’t great. You’ll probably need to trade a starter for some hitting help. But you have the arms to do it.

    @GTS: Thanks for the update!

    @Frank Rizzo: Francisco never had competition. He had a capable setup man. He still does.

    @Back to Minors: If I needed Runs/Speed over RBIs/power.

    @PepeSilvia: Lind over Morales, but those pitchers make the deal not so good.

    @Thunder Dan: Hehe

    @mannybeingmanny: Need to know how many teams.

    @Tarasco’sSecretStash: That’s awesome! Krispie’s downside worries me a bit and some of those bench hitters can go real cold. Nice team though!

    @Dingo: Ha!

    @Eric H.: They’re pretty equal, do different things. Depends what you need. McLouth will give you 20 steals, Vlad won’t. Vlad could give you a .300 average and 100 RBIs, McLouth won’t.

    @royce!: Ha!

    @charlie batch: I’ve gone over him.

    @Jackie: Gopher’s idea isn’t bad.

    @Lines: Sorry, man.

  59. Beau says:

    @Grey: Sorry, insert Miggy instead of one of the fielder entries, does that make offense more palatable?

  60. mrbaseball says:

    my 20 team dynasty team – I am one away from picking in draft – These are the three best left for me to pick here – or I can play my hand

    Octavio Dotel -saves

    Peter Moylan -holds

    Kevin Correia -sp

    Jarrod Saltalamacchia
    (Tex – C)
    Joey Votto
    (Cin – 1B)
    Casey McGehee
    (Mil – 2B,3B)
    Adrián Béltre
    (Bos – 3B)
    Jhonny Peralta
    (Cle – 3B,SS)
    Matt Kemp
    (LAD – OF)
    Carlos Quentin
    (CWS – OF)
    Shane Victorino
    (Phi – OF)
    Cameron Maybin
    (Fla – OF) ultilty
    Ian Desmond
    (Was – 2B,SS)
    Chase Headley
    (SD – 3B,OF)


    Chad Billingsley
    (LAD – SP)
    Ubaldo Jiménez
    (Col – SP)
    Wandy Rodríguez
    (Hou – SP)
    David Aardsma
    (Sea – RP)
    Heath Bell
    (SD – RP)
    Brandon Morrow
    (Tor – SP,RP)
    James Shields
    (TB – SP)
    Clay Buchholz
    (Bos – SP)
    Madison Bumgarner
    (SF – P)
    Jonathan Sánchez
    (SF – SP)

  61. Cheese

    Cheese says:

    Were your projections for Desmond made with the belief of him starting the whole season?

  62. Grey

    Grey says:

    @Beau: Yeah, since I just ignored Fielder the first time.

    @mrbaseball: Dotel, Correia…

  63. matthole says:

    @Grey: which one? would you be happy with adam jones as a #2 OF or do you view him as more of a really good #3 with upside? I have Adam Jones as my #2 OF on a few teams….

  64. Tony says:

    @mrbaseball: 20 teamer? thats a nice team MR.B….. i’d go saves, dotel….

  65. ThePoonTycoon says:

    @Jason: i generally try to wait til at least round 10 for catchers in a 12 team draft. then i start closely monitoring soto, montero, suzuki, and napoli. if all 4 are still on the board, i’m not worried. once they start going off the board, i’m probably grabbing one of those 4. probably would rank them montero, soto, napoli, suzuki, but that’s kinda personal preference.

  66. ThePoonTycoon says:

    @Jason: as for closers, i’ll usually try to grab guys considered low-end heading into the season, but who don’t have much immediate competition. last season i drafted franklin, rodney, and frank frank. this year, i will probably end up with dotel on a lot of teams.

  67. JoeC says:

    @Jesse: Agree 100,000 percent. If you want a gold star for you draft, go back to kindergarten.

  68. Commish Cauda says:

    Who would you rather have as your MI/CI in a 16-team league, Ian Desmond or Sean Rodriquez?

  69. Ian says:

    Grey, at this point would you recommend Shoppach over Iannetta just because Shoppach should get more PT with Navarro dinged up?

  70. David says:

    @Grey: Boy, do I feel stupid. I never even realized that the forums were there.

  71. Grey

    Grey says:

    @Commish Cauda: Desmond

    @Ian: Iannetta for now, but that could change.

    @David: No problem, was my bad.

  72. ThePoonTycoon says:

    @Commish Cauda: desmond just cause it looks like he’s got a clearer path to full-time ABs. plus, if he doesn’t perform right off, the nats can afford to let him learn on the job, whereas if sean-rod struggles (assuming he gets full-time ABs at some point), the rays can’t afford to let him drag them down.

  73. Commish Cauda says:

    @ThePoonTycoon: @Grey:

    Thanks fellas…I drafted Desmond over Rodriguez last night in the 20th round of my 16-team, 22 round draft. I knew I would only get one, so I was curious if I made the right decision.

    Funny thing is, I think I was the only one who knew Desmond won the starting SS job in WAS. I kept on pushing him off until the end.

  74. and1mcgee says:

    who the hell is Ike Davis?

  75. Commish Cauda says:

    16-team, H2H-Points League with HR=4pts, 3B=3pts, etc., BB=1pt, SO=-1, Steal=3pts., CS=-1pt.

    I own A-Rod. I took Ryan Zimmerman in the late 2nd round because no 1B were left and he was the best value. I currently do not have a 2B.

    What do you think of this deal?

    Prince Fielder & Jose Lopez
    Ryan Zimmerman & Carlos Pena

  76. Commish Cauda says:

    the future starting 1B for the Mets, rook

  77. and1mcgee says:

    @Commish Cauda if Lopez’ K total will be less than the blow from losing (15 jacks x 3 pts) – Pena’s anticipated K’s, then yes.

    For example, even with 44 jacks, doesn’t Reynolds’ K’s cancel out his HR points?

    I’d say good trade for you cuz Pena is a K machine.

  78. Mike MacDougal was great in the Doobies! But if you think he can help your fantasy team, well, that sounds like something what a foot believes.

  79. Back to Minors says:

    Is Granderson not leading off for the Yanks?

  80. ETMcgee says:

    @Jason: in my 12 team 10×10 draft, i punted catcher entirely (grabbed AJ perz off FA list) and didn’t draft a closer until the 14th round. still ended up with: B Wagner, Frank Frank, M Gonzales, Chris perez, although i somehow missed Dotel.

  81. Stephen says:

    @Grey: Jaime Garcia did have Tommy John surgery a couple of years ago. That is why he has yet to pitch a full season in the minors. Keep a close eye on his innings and his ability to stay healthy.

  82. Bert says:

    On the topic of injured players, how should I feel about Kinsler going into the season? Was offered Kinsler/Garza for Phillips/Butler in a pre-draft deal and my feelings are pretty split on it at the moment.

  83. Paulie Allnuts

    Paulie Allnuts says:

    @Grey: Well, Grey (Gulp) I’m ready to face the music. As Tony may have told you, “One’s are GOOD right?” League had a kick-ass draft last night, and this is what I came out with. Simply Fred kicked out his figures, and somehow I came out second in his War Room Projections, which isn’t too bad. I knew I was short in Homers and WHIP is perilous, and my team, for some reason is old. But here it is…



    1 (10) MARK TEXIERA NYY 1B
    2 (15) IAN KINSLER Tex 2B
    3 (34) JOSE REYES NYM SS
    13(154) CHIPPER JONES Atl 3B
    12(135) MIGUEL MONTERO Ari C
    4(39) BJ UPTON TB OF
    6 (63) SHIN SHOO CHOO Cle OF
    15(178) DEXTER FOWLER Col OF
    21(250) MAGGLIO ORDONEZ Det OF
    18(207) MIGUEL TEJADA Bal SS (SS/2B)
    20(231) JHONNY PERALTA Cle SS (3B/1B)



    17 (202) BRANDON LYON HOU RP
    24(279) SCOTT DOWNS TOR RP


    22(255) CLINT BARMES COL 2B/SS
    25(298) D DREW BOS OF

  84. Back to Minors says:

    @Simply Fred: thanks for the link.
    I don’t like Granderson down in the order…seems kinda wonky to me.

  85. aj says:

    “the pain doesn’t have to, doesn’t have to, doesn’t have to let it linger.”

    Well… they can’t all be winners.

  86. Chicago Mike says:

    @ Grey: Could you give me your advice on this mock? 12 Team Yahoo! H2H Snake Draft Daily League. Pos: C, 1B, 2B, SS, 3B, OF, OF, OF, Util, SP, SP, RP, RP, P, P, P, 5BN

    1. Albert Pujols (StL – 1B)
    2. Grady Sizemore (Cle – OF)
    3. Ryan Zimmerman (Was – 3B)
    4. Justin Morneau (Min – 1B)
    5. Jon Lester (Bos – SP)
    6. Andre Ethier (LAD – OF)
    7. Clayton Kershaw (LAD – SP)
    8. Ricky Nolasco (Fla – SP)
    9. Hunter Pence (Hou – OF)
    10. Francisco Rodríguez (NYM – RP)
    11. José Valverde (Det – RP)
    12. José López (Sea – 1B,2B)
    13. Mike Napoli (LAA – C)
    14. Brian Fuentes (LAA – RP)
    15. Roy Oswalt (Hou – SP)
    16. Colby Rasmus (StL – OF)
    17. David Price (TB – SP)
    18. Mike González (Bal – RP)
    19. Ervin Santana (LAA – SP)
    20. Ted Lilly (ChC – SP)
    21. Alcides Escobar (Mil – SS)
    22. Dexter Fowler (Col – OF)
    23. Daisuke Matsuzaka (Bos – SP)

  87. Tony says:

    @Paulie Allnuts: do you remember where i projected? haha…. i haven’t even been into this “war room”. Who projected in First? Fred?

  88. Paulie Allnuts

    Paulie Allnuts says:

    @Tony: Sorry, Tony, you projected 12th! Don’t blame me, I’m only the messenger! NYC Situation was 1st, and Fred was third…

  89. Maitland says:

    @Bert: I like Garza a bunch this year, but, I think I like the Phillips/Butler end of it. I don’t think Kinsler is that much of an improvement over Phillips, so I think the Butler/Garza swap is worth it.

  90. Paulie Allnuts

    Paulie Allnuts says:

    @Tony: BTW, I picked up on Fred’s plan, as it was done in another league I played in last year, where one of the managers stole all of the relievers. Luckily, I got just enough saves to get by. He has the rest of you guys by the cajones, though…

  91. Mic says:

    @Bert: don’t do it… butler is pretty overrated… and there are alot of good options at 2B if kinsler does go down (depending on league depth)…

  92. ThePoonTycoon says:


    how many ABs do the rangers let him get this season? 550+ or do they keep him under 500 like last season?

  93. NateMarcum

    Nate Marcum says:

    About two weeks ago, we agreed that the pitching staff of my team was a little wonky at the bottom, but after a few dazzling spring training starts (oxymoron, I know), do you think it might look a little better now?

    Madson (lidge)

  94. royce! says:

    Probably old news, but Hughes was named the 5th starter.

    Drop Buchholz for him in a 10-team league, or just let him be?

  95. Mr2Bits says:

    Question Grey

    If you were in a 12 team keeper(24 round draft) would you make the following move?

    Carlos Santana (a 24 round keeper)


    Josh Hamilton (9th Round)

    If I kept Hamilton next year, I’d give up my 9 spot where as Santana would essentially stay on my minor league squad until called up and then be a 24 pick for the next 5 years

  96. ThePoonTycoon says:

    @Nate Marcum: all 3 twins SPs look good going into the season, but i think it’s just oo many eggs in one basket. is it roto or h2h? roto, i guess it doesn’t matter as much since stats are cumulative and 3 SPs can have good seasons on 1 staff, but h2h could suck if the twins have tough matchups for a week. i would probably want more/better depth behind liriano than just niemann, that’s for sure.

  97. Real Tom says:

    Vincente Padilla was just named Opening Day starter. Did he threaten to clean his gun in the locker room? What the hell?

    I have tickets to the game at PNC, over five hours from where I live in Jersey. I want my money back. Gross.

  98. Mr2Bits says:


    Let him be, don’t trust yankee pirchers

  99. royce! says:

    @Real Tom: “Did he threaten to clean his gun in the locker room?” Zing!

    Seriously, tho, that has to be to schedule Kershaw for the Dodgers home opener. Sucks for those going to the Pirates home opener, but understandable.

  100. Commish Cauda says:

    same 16-team, H2H-POINTS league as above

    Which side?

    Zimmerman & Carlos Pena
    Adrian Gonzalez & Chris Davis

    remember, strikeouts =-1pt. and BB=1pt.

  101. matthole says:

    @Paulie Allnuts: way to take the plunge!

  102. Grey

    Grey says:

    @Stephen: Gotcha

    @Paulie Allnuts: I trust Fred’s breakdown. Seems surprising to me that you came in 2nd with those homers, guess Kinsler at 2nd is helping that. I think you’re heavy on speed and light on power, obviously. Your WHIP will be an issue, I think your staff hinges on Wandy.

    @aj: You getting tart on the Cranberries?

    @Chicago Mike: Hard for me to pick out something I really don’t like on your team, so that’s a good thing. Your speed hinges on Alcides. But if Lilly comes back strong, which I doubt, then you’ll have SPs to trade.

    @Nate Marcum: You have 4 starters and two are Twins and one is the AL East. That doesn’t scream confidence to me, but if Liriano can step up you could be fine. But then you’ll have three Twins.

    @Mr2Bits: I’d want Hamilton.

    @Real Tom: Ha!

    @Commish Cauda: Zimmerman’s.

  103. NateMarcum

    Nate Marcum says:

    @ThePoonTycoon: It is Roto, but I agree 100% with you on the Twins thing. It was the NFBC, which I will admit, was a little nerve wracking. I truthfully went into this thinking that Gardenhire would use Liriano in the closer’s role, but figured in any role, he would provide value. I personally don’t like that much volatility in the RP, but competition was tough, so I will just have to be content, my offense should be solid enough to off-set some of the pitching woes.

  104. Grey

    Grey says:


  105. Real Tom says:

    @Grey: @royce!: I agree with the scheduling argument, but c’mon!

    choosing Padilla as your opening day starter is like going to prom with your sister when you have a hot girlfriend.

  106. Baron Von Vulturewins

    Baron Von Vulturewins says:

    @Grey: Now that I-Stew is inching up draft boards, what’s your take on him v. Uggla? Projections-wise, they seem pretty close, and with Stewart going in the 8th round now, Uggla seems like the Unsexy Alternative(tm)

  107. matthole says:

    @Paulie Allnuts: when you have a chance can you pls direct me to Fred’s War room? If it hasnt been done already we should create a space on the forum section for our league.

  108. Real Tom says:

    @Baron Von Vulturewins: @Baron Von Vulturewins: I agree with the Baron (who I feel like I haven’t seen on here in a while, btw, so greetings!) because someone in my commenters league took him in the 7th round. At that point, I realized that the lack of 3B combined with Grey’s obsession had made him somewhat overrated. He could outperform that draft position, but seriously, that’s not a huge bargain. Jose Lopez went 33 picks later, and I grabbed him. They have same eligibility, and I liked my pic much more. Agree or no?

  109. Real Tom says:

    Sorry, meant to direct that at Grey, and not twice to the Baron.

  110. Clodbuster says:

    @Grey: Hey Grey, perhaps I’m the only half wit who needs such a thing but, is there a way you could incorporate the comment number you’re responding to in your replies? I’m assuming the software/program could be adjusted to do it automatically.

    I always read the comments and end up wasting time bouncing back and forth searching for the comment you’re responding to and this would make it much less time consuming. If the number were posted in the answer, I’d know right where to go.

    As always, thanks for all the hard work!

  111. Paulie Allnuts

    Paulie Allnuts says:

    @matthole: Sorry – I don’t really have a clue where the War Room is. Fred just sends me reports. Statistical breakdowns are all a bit beyond me.

  112. Steve says:

    @Clodbuster: If you click on the @… at the start of each comment (any comment, not just Grey’s), you’ll be bounced back to the comment that is being responded to.

  113. JoeC says:

    @Maitland: I don’t know. Kinsler has Phillips by about 10 home runs, 10 RBI, 20 Runs and perhaps 10 stolen bases. That seems like a pretty significant gap.

    Granted, Kinsler could regress a bit and he loves the trainer’s table. As well, Phillips could go all All-Starry on us like he did in 2007. But apples being apples, I would hesitate to say that Kinsler isn’t “much of an improvement on Phillips”.

  114. Clodbuster says:

    @Steve: That explains the color! Thanks Steve! I did say half wit, perhaps I give myself too much credit at times.

  115. Tom Emanski says:

    Grey, can you rank these OFs for an OBP instead of AVG league: SeanRod, JustMax, WillAble, GerryParr, RySween

    Yes, I’m in a really deep league.

  116. Dean says:

    Desmond or EverCab?

  117. Grey

    Grey says:

    @Dean: EverCab


Comments are closed.