1. Orioles SS Jackson Holliday | 19 | A | 2026

The number one overall pick in 2022’s amateur draft, Holliday is a 6’1” 175 lb left-handed hitter who appears to have inherited his father’s all-out approach to baseball. He’s probably in a batting cage or a weight room right now. Everyone works hard at this level, but Holliday’s had access to baseball resources for a long time, and you can see the results in his game and his build. He dominated on the complex for just eight games before the team had seen enough and sent him to Low-A for the final two weeks of the season, where he posted a .439 on base percentage. He’ll likely head back there to open the year but should be able to force a promotion at some point. I suspect we’ll see more aggressive timelines with this next cohort of young Orioles in general. Holliday could be a nice bellwether for that. 

 

2. Diamondbacks OF Druw Jones | 19 | NA | 2026

Jones suffered the mandatory D-Back shoulder injury shortly after draft night, when Arizona landed him with the 2nd overall pick. Their top three prospects here all feel like windfall profits. You can make a pretty good case none of them should’ve been on the board, but there they were, and Arizona didn’t overthink it trying to pinch pennies or find the Vitruvian man in the case of Carroll, who was clearly an elite prospect who fell to 16th due to his size. At 6’4” 180 lbs, Jones looks like the 2.0 version of his old man. Or maybe it’s more accurate to say he’s an impressive variation on the young version of his dad, one with more speed.

 

3. Mets RHP Kodai Senga | 30 | NPB | 2023

Senga is six-foot even and 202 lbs but can generate upper nineties velocity atop the zone and send hitters to the dugout with his trademark forkball or solid slider. The Mets signed for him for $75 million across five seasons. If he can stay healthy, he’s the safest money in this draft.

 

4. Angels SS Zach Neto | 22 | AA | 2023

Neto has cruised through the minors. He played 30 Double-A games and slashed .320/.382/.492 with four home runs and four stolen bases. It’ll be hard to hold him back if he replicates that success this coming season.

 

5. Red Sox OF Masataka Yoshida | 29 | NPB | 2023

At 5’8” 176 lbs, Yoshida is exactly the kind of player scouts doubt every step of the way. The key takeaway for now is that he was completely dominant for a half-decade in Japan, walking twice as much as he struck out while swatting 20-plus home runs and producing MVP-level slash lines. He’s currently around the 400 spot in NFBC drafts. Feels like easy money there. We know one thing for sure: Boston loves him and will give him more time than they gave Rusney Castillo to get situated . . . I hope.

 

6. Reds 3B Cam Collier | 18 | CPX | 2025

A sturdy left-handed hitter with big-league bloodlines, the 6 ‘2” 210 lb Collier represented huge value for Cincinnati with the 18th pick in this year’s draft. Other clubs were reportedly scared off by signing bonus demands, but that’s an old story that gets older every year. Take the best players you can get, especially early, and let the chips fall where they may. Collier rewarded the Reds with a silky smooth transition to pro ball, slashing .370/.514/.630 with two home runs in nine complex league games. 

 

7. Pirates 2B Termarr Johnson | 18 | A | 2025

A double-plus hit tool leads the way for Termarr Johnson, a 5’7” 175 lb left-handed hitter who calls Jose Ramirez to mind on a quick visual evaluation. The organization will be thrilled if Johnson follows a similar path, grinding his way up the chain before growing into power at the highest level. He’s off to a great start, slashing .275/.396/.450 with one home run and four stolen bases in 14 Low-A games. He also walked 18.9 percent of the time. Scouts have hung a lot of superlatives on Termarr. Some called him the best high school hitter they’ve ever seen. It’s a high bar, but I’m not going to bet against him.

 

8. Nationals OF Elijah Green | 19 | CPX | 2025

Green turned 19 in December but has already posted major league exit velocities. The fifth overall pick in this year’s amateur draft, Green could’ve gone first overall and might’ve been the best athlete on the board. He’s already 6’3” 225 lbs and figures to get even bigger in his twenties. Despite the size, he’s an easy plus runner and defender who will probably push Wood to a corner outfield spot. Hit the ground running in the Florida Complex League, too, slashing .302/.404/.535 with two homers and a steal in 12 games. Struck out 21 times, for what it’s worth, which will be the primary hurdle between Green and becoming an impact major leaguer. I’d bump these three teenage hitters above Yoshida in a rebuild. 

 

9. Dodgers C Dalton Rushing | 22 | A | 2025

Nobody hit better than Dalton Rushing last year. The Dodgers’ first pick in 2022 at 40th overall, Rushing had been blocked by Henry Davis at Louisville and didn’t play full time until his Junior season, when he popped 23 home runs and slugged .686 in 64 games. His professional debut was even better. In 30 games at Low-A, Rushing slashed .424/.539/.778 with 21 strikeouts and 21 walks. Scary stuff. A thick 6’1” 220 lbs, Rushing bats left-handed and feels like a safe bet to smash his way quickly through the minors. Might have to switch positions to move up the levels as his bat demands it. 

 

10. Twins SS Brooks Lee | 22 | AA | 2024

The adverbial form of doing something the way a person named Brooks would do it, Lee had an outstanding debut season after being selected 8th overall in 2022, slashing .289/.395/.454 with four home runs in 25 High-A games. Even finished up with two games at Double-A. A switch-hitter at 6’2” 205 lbs, Lee looks like a high-probability major leaguer even if his position outlook is cloudy in Minnesota.

 

11. Guardians OF Chase DeLauter | 21 | NA | 2025

DeLauter offers a glimpse at the downsides of separating studs from duds too young, as he wound up playing at James Madison University after going undrafted out of high school. Along the way, he grew into a 6’4” 235 lb center fielder with double-plus speed and power. For what it’s Wuertz, DeLauter has played 100 total games since 2020: three short seasons with JMU and one in the Cape Cod League, where he was good with the wooden bat: .298/.397/.589 with 21 walks and 18 strikeouts across 34 games (146 plate appearances). That small sample with the ash and maple is where I’m hanging this hat. Cleveland has made a concerted effort to minimize strikeouts. If they think DeLauter can keep doing it, I’m here to find out. Tried to trade up for him when he fell to 19th in the Razz 30 FYPD that began this week. No joy, but I made a competitive bid (1.29 and 3.29). 

 

12. Mets SS Jett Williams | 19 | CPX | 2026

It wouldn’t be fair to compare Williams to Corbin Carroll, but here I go putting them in the same sentence anyway. At just 5’8” 175 lbs, Williams doesn’t have the power or (probably) the number-one-overall-prospect type topside of Carroll, but their games are similarly electric. I’m not especially moved by complex league stats, but Williams recorded as many stolen bases (6) as he did strikeouts in ten games at the level.

 

13. Mets C Kevin Parada | 21 | A | 2024

Aftering setting the Georgia Tech record with 26 home runs this year, Parada kept hitting for his ten games in Low-A, posting a .464 On Base Percentage and adding one home run. He’ll likely open 2023 in High-A and should climb quickly.

 

14. Yankees OF Spencer Jones | 21 | A | 2025

The scouting department found a Judge-ian prospect on the board at the 25 spot in this year’s draft and couldn’t resist the allure of 6’7” Spencer Jones: a 225 lb left-handed hitter with double-plus power and unique athleticism. From Judge to Oneil Cruz to James Wood to Jordan Walker to Elly De La Cruz to Spencer Jones, we’re seeing a trend of NBA-style athletes these past few years. Jones struck out just 18.9 percent of the time in 22 Low-A games, stealing ten bases and slashing .325/.411/.494 with three home runs. Side note, as a team teaching the high fastball approach for years now, the Yankees clearly believe the simple equation that taller-than-tall hitters plus high fastballs equal home runs. Hard to disagree.

 

15. Royals OF Gavin Cross | 22 | A | 2024

The club’s first pick this summer at 9th overall, Cross features plus power and an above average hit tool at 6’3” 210 lbs from the left side. He got to work right away as a professional, slashing .293/.423/.596 with seven home runs in 26 games at Low-A. Great match between player and org given his advanced approach and near-term opportunities in the lineup. 

Thanks for reading!

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

32 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Marianne Unfaithful
Marianne Unfaithful
1 month ago

Top 100 by….August maybe?

Burke Ellis
Burke Ellis
1 month ago

Who’s the last to the Top 100 Prospects race? Yep. Scratch that itch.

Jen U Flect
Jen U Flect
Reply to  Burke Ellis
1 month ago

And don’t you just love the snotty eff-them attitude of this site?

Bill
Bill
1 month ago

*wispers* Brooks Lee= adverbial

Sport
Sport
1 month ago

Thank you so much Itch! Perfect timing!

I always feel like I get value in my second round (12 team drafts) and third rounds due to your rankings.

I have the first pick in one my leagues (orphaned team I took over). I had read another ranking that had Holliday number one and I was pretty pumped to sulk have them there also.

Thanks for all your hard work! Doing this while teaching AND having a family is very much appreciated.

Philip
Philip
1 month ago

Super helpful, Itch. Thank you.

Where would you slot in Painter, Manzardo, Mervis, Stone, and Pfaadt?

Appreciate it!

Ryan
Ryan
Reply to  Philip
1 month ago

Also curious about this. I have 2 of the first 7 picks in my draft and Painter/Manzardo both are in the player pool in addition the thy FYPD guys

Philip
Philip
Reply to  The Itch
1 month ago

Awesome! Thanks!

junior56
junior56
1 month ago

Thanks Itch! Good Intell!

Had 6 picks in a 16 team HTH Dynasty league. Ended up adding.

Neto
Gentry
D. Gilbert
Cole Young
J. Ortiz
Jaison Chourio

Can you rank these pitchers?

Noah Schultz
Brandon Barriera
Justin Campbell

Prawn Lord
Prawn Lord
1 month ago

Hi Itch!
Noting beats your prospect lists.
Wondering how close any of the J2 guys were to making this list. Were they considered at all or are you generally shying away from them until at least their first season with an org?

Dude
Dude
1 month ago

Good morning Itch! 14 team dynasty. I currently have the following on my minor league roster. Are there any of these guys that you would “throw back” or move on from?
Will Bednar
Jordan Wicks
Ethan Small
Asa Lacey
Blaze Jordan
Bubba Chandler

Dude
Dude
Reply to  The Itch
1 month ago

Thank you sir!

Dude
Dude
Reply to  The Itch
1 month ago

What do you expect from Drew Waters in KC? Is he worth holding onto?

Dude
Dude
Reply to  The Itch
1 month ago

Gracias

phennore
phennore
1 month ago

30-team dynasty FYPD draft. I’m drafting 26th. Who do you like? Eric Brown, Jordan Beck, Jud Fabian or Tyler Locklear? I’ll leaning Locklear if only because I don’t think he’ll be available for my second round pick (52). Thoughts?

Thanks,

Cujo
Cujo
1 month ago

Great list. I have the first pick this year and intended on taking Holiday, so happy for the confirmation. A lot of other guys on this list are also taken in my league as well.

Question on pitching prospects: Assuming anyone in the top 100 prospects is taken, is Chase Dollander the best pitching prospect?

galica1234
galica1234
1 month ago

The Itch!!!!

Awesome!!!!!

a. Awesome read. So much intelligence. To capture a Nepali saying, I hope I don’t burn my brain reading and regurgitating your content.

b. Near the end of round 17 (28 rounds in total) of a 10-team, 5×5 roto, 22+6+2 (roster+bench+IL) daily league with unlimited WW, 1000 IP minimum and 200 GS maximum with a painful AF 4-hour slow clock.

Here’s the team so far.

Varsho
VGJ
Gleyber
Witt
AmedR
Riley
Hoerner
Carroll
O’Neill
Ward
Yoshida San
Tellez

Manoah, Triston, Severino, Strider
Romano, Holmes

I have Senga San queued for my next pick (four picks to wait). Question.

Could you give me your top 5 unknown rookies who will excel this year in MLB? Or just your best 5.

Cheers,
Ante

toolshed
toolshed
1 month ago

Hey Itch, I’ve been waiting for this list. Thanks.

Quick question, you did a post draft update last August and had Druw Jones ahead of Holliday. Did you move Holliday ahead now due to jones’s shoulder injury or did something else change? It is only 1 spot, but I wanted to know for sure. Thanks