LOGIN

It’s tricky business reacting to spring training outcomes. Veterans are working on their game, treating reps like practice, while youngsters and journeymen are striving to make a good impression. That doesn’t negate all the outcomes, of course, but I feel a little silly reading sentences about how a player looks based on a week of half-games, and I feel even sillier writing them. Nonetheless, playing time is up for grabs, and small samples or not, guys are proving themselves worthy (or unworthy) of season-opening opportunities, so we can’t just play ostrich and ignore the new realities revealing themselves. 

If you’ve been around a while, you know I’m not crazy about Brayan Rocchio. SS Angel Martinez is my preferred pick among Cleveland’s options at shortstop, and he’s in a heavenly rhythm right now, batting .529 with two homers and a triple. Rocchio is hitting .118. Both players have 19 plate appearances. Would be a pretty big upset in the echo chamber if Martinez claims the gig, but I doubt the Guardians see it that way. Here’s a link to a story by Jesus Cano on mlb.com that details the changes Martinez made heading into 2024. 

Tigers OF Parker Meadows was already the likely opening day center fielder in Detroit, but slashing .350/.381/.750 in the early going can’t hurt his chances. I traded him away in a 15-teamer where I have an outfield crunch, and I’m feeling the familiar pang of regret that’s inevitable in any fair trade. 

Down a similar street, around the bend toward a high-end suburb, Brewers OF Jackson Chourio has the center field job on lockdown, but it’s still nice to see him slashing .323/.364/.419 through 33 plate appearances. 

Padres 3B Graham Pauley has a sweet left-handed swing and an all-fields approach. He’s slashing .333/.440/.619 through 25 plate appearances and might be the opening day third baseman, considering Manny Machado hasn’t played the position yet due to off-season elbow surgery. Even if Machado gets back in time, Pauley could make the roster as the everyday designated hitter. The team says it won’t bring any rookie out of camp who isn’t slated to be a starter, which is another way of saying they might have three rookies (Merrill, Marsee) in the opening day lineup. 

Dodgers OF Andy Pages is in the books with two home runs and a .471 batting average through 21 plate appearances. The team has Teoscar Hernandez and Jason Heyward installed as corner outfielders, and those guys are solid, but there’s probably room for Pages as a short-side platoon piece with starts against the occasional righty. 

Mariners SS Ryan Bliss seems happy enough with Seattle, slashing .389/.450/.444 with three steals through 20 plate appearances. He doesn’t have an angle on any particular job but is first on the call sheet for just about anything that goes wrong on the infield early in 2023.

Mighty Cubs OF Owen Caissie is bringing joy to Mudville this spring with a .440/.517/.680 slash line in 29 plate appearances. He’ll likely open the year in Triple-A and might beat Pete Crow-Armstrong to the majors in 2024 if the Cubs need a corner bat early. 

Yankees C Austin Wells looks good. Might wind up a top-five catcher. Top ten is well within his reach given the short porch. He homered out of the two-hole Saturday to bring his spring slugging percentage to .632. 

I’m just gonna put this here and then duck and move on until next week, but Atlanta OF Forrest Wall makes an interesting hedge for Kelenic, in a league deep enough for that to matter. He’s hot this spring (3 HR, .476 OBP) after hitting .462 with five steals in 15 plate appearances down the stretch last year. Maybe not a long-term solution at 28 years old, but he’s stolen 50-plus bases each of the last two seasons at Triple-A and would matter for our game if he found himself in the lineup. 

Thanks for reading!

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

26 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
frankgrimes
1 month ago

Yo itch you got a few starter recommendations to stash After our small supplemental minor draft this week that possibly help this year?

frankgrimes
Reply to  The Itch
1 month ago

thanks! yes some guys like this that prolly make starts this year. Last year I stashed guys like woo and bibee.

Corey
Corey
1 month ago

Any chance Ricky Tiedemann breaks camp with Gausman and Manoah dinged up? Or do you think he’s starting in AAA regardless?

toolshed
1 month ago

Does the Noelvi Marte news change your long term outlook on him? Are you holding if you have him? Are you selling low? Thanks

jbona3
jbona3
1 month ago

Thanks Itch, always appreciate your POV on prospects, esp when you provide an opinion that’s different from consensus. I’ve got a couple keeper questions:
–Is Cal Raleigh ($6) or Austin Wells ($2) worth a keep? I tend not to spend a C, but both could represent value.
–Thoughts on Jordan Westburg at $6? I’m leaning yes, but…
–It’s time to cut bait on Marco Luciano ($4), right?

jbona3
jbona3
Reply to  The Itch
1 month ago

I can keep as many players as I want, and our draft tends to go stars and scrubs – so very high prices at the top end, a small middle class, and a long tail of cheaper (sub $10) options. Those are my borderline guys, and I’m trying to have enough capital in the draft to land Mookie or someone like that.

Thoughts on Bello at $10?

junior56
junior56
1 month ago

Thank you Itch!

1. Grabbed Wall in 3 leagues!

2. Do you have any intel on Jackson Baumeister and Josh Knoth? A couple of arms on my radar.

3. Would you deal Jobe for PCA? in a 16-team dynasty league that differentiates LF, CF&RF.
Thanks again.

Duda Want to Build a Snowman?
Duda Want to Build a Snowman?
1 month ago

Great stuff Itch! Wondering if Victor Scott II might be an interesting last bench spot in my 12 team roto keeper (weekly lineups 7 bench spots) or if you’d wait til he gets closer? Seems like he could be a better E Ruiz if he just has the playing time…

Richard DeBehnke
Richard DeBehnke
1 month ago

In AL only league what starting pitcher would be fair trade for Wells?

Foxman
Foxman
1 month ago

Itch
In a 12 team H2H league, we keep 5 plus 1 rookie elig player
Am I crazy for trading the 87th pick, my 2nd rd pick, for Wyatt Langford?
My other option was to keep Colt Keith, and not trade away a draft pick.

Foxman
Foxman
Reply to  The Itch
1 month ago

Thanks Itch
I like gamble on the youngster too, but feel even better about my odds with your endorsement!
Appreciate your words of wisdom on these prospects, keep up the great work!

ashtray
ashtray
1 month ago

I’m in a 10 team league where you can keep 10 forever and having a hard time with my keepers.
7×7 H2H
Hits, Walks, R, HR, RBI, SB, AVG
Losses, Total Bases Allowed, W, SV, K, ERA, WHIP
CI, MI, 4 OF, and 8 man benches

I’m definitely keeping:
Carroll
Olson
Harris
Arozarena
Rutschman
Gleyber
Gallen

Having a hard time with my last three and could use your advice:
Abrams
Chisholm
Jung
Chourio
Caminero
Lawlar
Aaron Nola

ashtray
ashtray
Reply to  The Itch
1 month ago

Thanks. Would you keep any of the other guys over Gleyber? I’ve had no one suggest to me that I should keep him but I really like him and have struggled at filling 2B in the past so wanted to take a chance on him.

Chin Music
Chin Music
Reply to  ashtray
1 month ago

Jung and Chourio are tough cuts too. Sorry for chiming in but was jus reading and felt compelled

Ante
Ante
1 month ago

The Itch!!!

Love the report, man. Chock full of goodness.

Squirreling away my questions for March 28+ when I have to finalize my lineup.

Chris Rock quote of the day for March 10, 2024

Shaq is rich. The white man who signs his check… is wealthy. “Ah, here you go, Shaq. Go buy yourself a bouncing car. Bling, bling!”

Cheers,
Ante