Page 1 of 1

Blockbuster - Kemp, ARod, and more. Who wins?

Posted: Sun Apr 04, 2010 6:38 am
by Bed Sheets
No limit keeper. 8 teams. Roto 5x5 14/9. 1250 Max IP.

Team A gets:

A. Rodriguez 3B
M. Holliday OF
J. Votto 1B
A. Lind OF
Trevor Hoffman RP

Team B gets:

M. Kemp OF
D. Wright 3B
G. Sizemore OF
C. Pena 1B
B. Lyon RP (Team B has Lindstrom)

Re: Blockbuster - Kemp, ARod, and more. Who wins?

Posted: Sun Apr 04, 2010 7:15 am
by Simply Fred
First thing that strikes me is that team B takes a severe hit in AVG.

Team A has a steady closer (for short term). Lyon no gimme long term. SAGNOF.

Team A my pick.

Wait for Grey's. I'm not much on "keeper" stuff, just weighing in.

Re: Blockbuster - Kemp, ARod, and more. Who wins?

Posted: Sun Apr 04, 2010 7:21 am
by Bed Sheets
I forgot to mention that only eight players are kept. No closers were kept this year.

I added my team as my signature. I was Team B in the trade.

Re: Blockbuster - Kemp, ARod, and more. Who wins?

Posted: Sun Apr 04, 2010 10:45 am
by cws05nuts
A

Re: Blockbuster - Kemp, ARod, and more. Who wins?

Posted: Sun Apr 04, 2010 11:32 am
by Big Jgke
Team A wins this one. Rodriguez is better than Wright, Holliday and Kemp is a wash (but i think Kemp is overrated this year) and Votto and and Lind are a better combo than Sizemore and Pena. Hoffman will close all year again, so he's just a bonus. Team A would win this deal even without him.



A. Rodriguez 3B
M. Holliday OF
J. Votto 1B
A. Lind OF
Trevor Hoffman RP

Team B gets:

M. Kemp OF
D. Wright 3B
G. Sizemore OF
C. Pena 1B
B. Lyon RP (Team B has Lindstrom)

Re: Blockbuster - Kemp, ARod, and more. Who wins?

Posted: Mon Apr 05, 2010 1:35 am
by Bed Sheets
Does the fact that it is a no limit keeper not change things? I felt like I had to get
rid of ARod while he still had top 5 value. Personally I am ecstatic to get so much younger, going
from my top 2 keepers ages 35 and 30 to ages 27 and 26.

Re: Blockbuster - Kemp, ARod, and more. Who wins?

Posted: Sat Apr 10, 2010 3:58 pm
by 5toolGeezy
A

Re: Blockbuster - Kemp, ARod, and more. Who wins?

Posted: Sat Apr 10, 2010 4:39 pm
by rightwingjedi
I would take A all day over B.

If a team needed SB's real bad, I could see them wanting B though.