Get JD Martinez, Give Rhys Hoskins?

[EthanRoto]

I'm in a 12 team, competitive, 5x5 (OBP) auction keeper (keep 6) league, with in-season cap of $310, and $100 in FAAB. I'm in the running, and a dump trader is looking to move JD Martinez.

I've got:

C - Grandal, Mesoraco
1B/3B/CI - Goldy, Beltre, Encarnacion (Bench: Aguilar, Gurriel)
2B/SS/MI - Albies, Simmons, Kipnis (bench: Addison Russell)
OF - Cain, Gardner, Dustin Fowler, Leonys Martin, Gorkys Hernandez (DL: Hoskins, Cespedes)
UT- Matt Olson
SP - Carlos Martinez, Paxton, Cole, Richards, Happ, Ross Stripling, Marco Gonzales (bench: Pomeranz)
RP - Cody Allen, Morrow, Kela

I'm solid mid-to-top-of-pack in HR, Runs, and OBP, and could use some help in RBIs and SB.

I have Hoskins on a 3-year deal, so next year would be at $11 and the following at $16. JD Martinez is in his final year at $17.

Two questions:

1. Pull the trigger on the other owner's proposal for me to include Hoskins and Aguilar ($1) (obviously have more 1B than I can ever hope to start, but is that overpaying too much and an asset I could move in a different trade)? He's offered Nick Kingham ($5) in his initial 2-for-2 offer.

2. Say that it's too much, and counter on a straight-up deal to get JD Martinez to get after it this year, and give up Hoskins and his long-term potential/additional 2 affordable years (assuming he finds his form)?

Don't want to artificially value Aguilar and lose sight of the bigger picture. Thoughts?

~Ethan

[Grey]

I'm in a 12 team, competitive, 5x5 (OBP) auction keeper (keep 6) league, with in-season cap of $310, and $100 in FAAB. I'm in the running, and a dump trader is looking to move JD Martinez.

I've got:

C - Grandal, Mesoraco
1B/3B/CI - Goldy, Beltre, Encarnacion (Bench: Aguilar, Gurriel)
2B/SS/MI - Albies, Simmons, Kipnis (bench: Addison Russell)
OF - Cain, Gardner, Dustin Fowler, Leonys Martin, Gorkys Hernandez (DL: Hoskins, Cespedes)
UT- Matt Olson
SP - Carlos Martinez, Paxton, Cole, Richards, Happ, Ross Stripling, Marco Gonzales (bench: Pomeranz)
RP - Cody Allen, Morrow, Kela

I'm solid mid-to-top-of-pack in HR, Runs, and OBP, and could use some help in RBIs and SB.

I have Hoskins on a 3-year deal, so next year would be at $11 and the following at $16. JD Martinez is in his final year at $17.

Two questions:

1. Pull the trigger on the other owner's proposal for me to include Hoskins and Aguilar ($1) (obviously have more 1B than I can ever hope to start, but is that overpaying too much and an asset I could move in a different trade)? He's offered Nick Kingham ($5) in his initial 2-for-2 offer.

2. Say that it's too much, and counter on a straight-up deal to get JD Martinez to get after it this year, and give up Hoskins and his long-term potential/additional 2 affordable years (assuming he finds his form)?

Don't want to artificially value Aguilar and lose sight of the bigger picture. Thoughts?

~Ethan

2 should be enough, but would do 1 if won't go for 2

[EthanRoto]

Thanks for the reality check - was able to swing it as a 1-for-1, but agree that the bigger trade would have made sense too.