Trade offers for Phillips

You wanna trade who for who? Wow, that's awful/great/horrendous/beautiful/really terrible?
BigAhnold
Posts: 191
Joined: Fri Feb 04, 2011 11:33 pm

Trade offers for Phillips

Postby BigAhnold » Thu Jul 25, 2013 6:16 pm

AL+NL, 5x5, 10 owners, redraft, team in signature. Currently tied for 2nd. Kicking butt in HR, RBI, R, sucking in WHIP, ERA (thanks, Gallardo and Lester!), and dropping like a stone in BA.

A suitor very much wants Brandon Phillips. He has Segura, but has expressed reticence to include Segura in a trade.

A key question is whether Cole Hamels is a buy-low.

Which side do you like in each of these:

ONE
A) Brandon Phillips
for
B) LeMahieu, Cole Hamels, Romo
(I would drop or send him Benoit and my worst pitcher, likely Stults)

TWO
A) Brandon Phillips, Jimmy Rollins, Benoit, Gallardo
for
B) Segura, LeMahieu, Hamels, Romo

THREE
A) Brandon Phillips, Jimmy Rollins, plus a mediocre starting pitcher - Stults, Gallardo, Maholm, Lester, or Hellickson
for
B) Segura, LeMahieu, Cole Hamels

I like trade three best, but he may only be willing to go trade one.

Which side wins in each, and how do you rank the three trades from the Phillips side?

All help appreciated.

BigA
NL only, 5x5, 10 team, Roto, keeper
C Contreras C d'Arnaud 1B MReynolds 2B JBaez SS ABlanco 3B KBryant MI TTurner CI Gyorko OF Osuna OF OHerrera OF JPederson OF GPolanco OF DSantana UT DDietrich BN: SMarte
P Greinke P McCarthy P GCole P AWood P Knebel P Nola P Strop P Uehara P TWatson BN: Vizcaino, RHill, JGuerra
DL: Ethier, Cozart, BAnderson
Farm: EJimenez. Tapia, BRodgers, AReyes

AL only, 4x4, 10 team, Roto, keeper
C DNorris C SLeon 1B Mauer 2B Odor SS Segura 3B Longoria MI Merrifield CI HRamirez OF Marisnick OF Pinder OF Dickerson OF DFisher OF SSmith UT VMartinez
P Shoemaker P MFeliz P Verlander P Strahm P Porcello P AChapman P Kintzler P JKelly P Paxton
DL: Smyly, Skaggs, Bird, Trout
Minors: LMartin

AL+NL, 5x5, 12 team, Roto, Redraft
C Rupp C Flowers 1B Rizzo 2B BPhillips SS Story 3B Donaldson MI Forsythe CI HRamirez OF GPolanco OF KDavis OF Altherr OF Duvall OF Inciarte UT Hosmer BN: Castellanos, Kepler, (DL)DTravis
P Arrietta P Maeda P Lackey P FRivero P Pomeranz P CAnderson P AChapman P Casilla P Wacha BN: Foltynewicz, (DL) Salazar, Neris
DL: McHugh

thorbs
Posts: 357
Joined: Tue Feb 16, 2010 2:41 am

Re: Trade offers for Phillips

Postby thorbs » Thu Jul 25, 2013 6:37 pm

I like 3 personally.
12-team, 10x10 H2H, NS + H, OPS, etc.; 20 MLB, 8 MiLB keepers
Cx2: W. Ramos/Pina
1B/3B/CI: Votto/Arenado/Bour
SS/2B/MI: Story/Kinsler/Odor
LF/CF/RF/OFx2: Bryant/Betts/Ozuna/Calhoun/Pham
UTILx2: Taylor/Goodwin
Bench: Tapia, Pujols
SP: Kluber, Cueto, Verlander, Tanaka, Montgomery, Pivetta, Foltynewicz
RP: Britton, Knebel, Kelly, Norris, Madson, Rosenthal, Uehara, Bedrosian
DL: Trout, Bird, Duffy, Solarte
Minors: Acuna (ATL), Robles (WAS), Weaver (STL), Verdugo (LAD), Duplantier (ARI), Mahle (CIN), Bader (STL), Maitan (ATL)

User avatar
rightwingjedi
Sponsor
Sponsor
Posts: 1870
Joined: Sun Mar 14, 2010 5:20 am
Location: In The Hole

Re: Trade offers for Phillips

Postby rightwingjedi » Thu Jul 25, 2013 6:56 pm

Phillips, Rollins and Maholm or Hellboy for Segura and Hamels

BigAhnold
Posts: 191
Joined: Fri Feb 04, 2011 11:33 pm

Re: Trade offers for Phillips

Postby BigAhnold » Thu Jul 25, 2013 7:36 pm

I would love that...but would have no 2b - would need to go to the waiver wire. How about the other trades? Is trade 1 worthwhile?
NL only, 5x5, 10 team, Roto, keeper
C Contreras C d'Arnaud 1B MReynolds 2B JBaez SS ABlanco 3B KBryant MI TTurner CI Gyorko OF Osuna OF OHerrera OF JPederson OF GPolanco OF DSantana UT DDietrich BN: SMarte
P Greinke P McCarthy P GCole P AWood P Knebel P Nola P Strop P Uehara P TWatson BN: Vizcaino, RHill, JGuerra
DL: Ethier, Cozart, BAnderson
Farm: EJimenez. Tapia, BRodgers, AReyes

AL only, 4x4, 10 team, Roto, keeper
C DNorris C SLeon 1B Mauer 2B Odor SS Segura 3B Longoria MI Merrifield CI HRamirez OF Marisnick OF Pinder OF Dickerson OF DFisher OF SSmith UT VMartinez
P Shoemaker P MFeliz P Verlander P Strahm P Porcello P AChapman P Kintzler P JKelly P Paxton
DL: Smyly, Skaggs, Bird, Trout
Minors: LMartin

AL+NL, 5x5, 12 team, Roto, Redraft
C Rupp C Flowers 1B Rizzo 2B BPhillips SS Story 3B Donaldson MI Forsythe CI HRamirez OF GPolanco OF KDavis OF Altherr OF Duvall OF Inciarte UT Hosmer BN: Castellanos, Kepler, (DL)DTravis
P Arrietta P Maeda P Lackey P FRivero P Pomeranz P CAnderson P AChapman P Casilla P Wacha BN: Foltynewicz, (DL) Salazar, Neris
DL: McHugh


Return to “Baseball - Trade Talk”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google and 4 guests