It's time to start finalizing my keepers for my 12 team NL-only auction league. I can keep up to 6 players a year for a maximum of 3 years of service (players can be kept 2 times at an additional $4/year). Here are my choices:

Gaby Sanchez - $13
Yonder Alonso - $5 (Can keep 2 years)
Logan Morrison - $10
Michael Morse - $11
Ryan Roberts - $9 (Can keep 2 years)
Freddie Freeman - $9
Daniel Murphy - $6 (Can keep 2 years)
Ike Davis - $9
Randy Wolf - $5 (Can keep 2 years)
Jason Bourgeois - $7 (Can keep 2 years)

I have 5 possible 1B keepers and I am really tempted to keep them all (I can play Morse and Yonder in the OF) since the NL first base crop is so weak this year. Is that a good strategy or should I just try to trade one or two? Who else on my list would you keep (leaning towards Morrison, but Bourgeois' SAGNOF potential is tempting)?

I'd keep the first 6 on your list. Right after the draft you could probably flip one for a pretty penny to someone who doesn't have a worthwhile 1B with the Pujols/Prince exodus. I'd probably make Gabby my first 1B to target as my trade-away player or Yonder since he's a pretty big gamble.

OK, so I have an offer on the table that I would love to hear some opinions on. Given my keeper options above, would you do this deal?

Gaby ($13) and Alonso ($5) for
J. Zimmerman ($9) and R. Bentancourt ($5)