Actually, full deal is:

1: Hamels / Morneau / Headley

2: Fielder / Burnett / Sherrill / Randy Wolf

Which side do ye prefer?

Assuming this is a 10 or 12 team league, I'd say Headley and Wolf don't have much value. I'd say Hamels/Morneau vs. Fielder/Burnett is an even trade so the addition of Sherrill would skew me towards #2.

but it's close...

I'd say that Sherrill has way more value than he's worth, so the addition of him to the trade would make him an okay trading piece to flip to another team looking for trades.

I really like Hamels, but that trade is pretty good..considering Sherill is a good closer....keep in mind though Sherill could go at the dead line.

I really don't think Sherrill will get more than 12 saves from now until seasons end.
Baltimore is going to play under .400 ball to finish the year.

And Hamels is wayyy better than Burnett. So I would keep my players if i was team 1