Would you trade josh Hamilton 8 thrnd keeper one more year then 4th then 1st for any two of these guys and if so which pairs would you be willing to do it for.

They are all 12th rnd keepers for 3 yrs
Des Jennings
Manny machado
Will Myers
Profar
Will Myers
Jason kipnis
Oscar Tavares

My keepers are.
Kinsler 2
Votto 3
Beltre 4
Verlander 6
Heyward 7
Hamilton 8

I wouldn't. Hamilton is a great value this year. Could still be a very solid keeper next year. While I like those prospects none are likely to be even worth a 12 round pick for this year or next. Maybe one or two but it is just a dart throw on who that might be.

1) If you add two players do you have to remove one of the keepers listed?

I'd def consider it. I'd probably do Jennings since he'll have solid value this year and Profar since he's the best of the minor guys.

May consider Machado and Myers as well I guess. Lean Machado as the most secure to produce this year. 2 players for 3 years in the 12th I think has to be looked at closely. Frankly 32 yr old Hamilton in LAA, type of guy I'd rather move a year too early than a year too late...

I have no problem moving Hamilton but when you trade a top 20 player, you should be getting at least a top 50 player in return along with a prospect of some sort.

You shouldn't trade top 20 guys for 2 prospects who are years away from ever being a top 25 player IF they ever make it that far. Every year people jump on the bandwagon of prospects only to be disappointed. Last year it was Hosmer, Lawrie and Moore. Then there was Wieters and Price and I could go on and on with the list of guys that have been called up and failed to meet expectations right away. Then add in that they are prospects and only a few of those listed will actually turn into stars.