Keeper league-keep 6, would you trade kershaw 7th rnd keeper for 1 more yr. after that 4th rnd then 1st rnd for Jason heyward who is a 7 th rnd keeper for 3 more years..

Kinsler rnd 2
Votto rnd 3
Belter rnd 4
Verlander rnd 6
Kershaw rnd 7
Hamilton rnd 8

I'd take Heyward...

I am going to stick with Kershaw. I like Heyward a lot but I want to see more from him. So far he has traded good years with bad years and he has been far from the healthiest player. Keshaw is a stud SP with only Verlander ranked higher and should still be a good value as a 4th round pick. After that, things change but I think I would stick with the better player and maybe look to make a deal next year while going for a title this year.

Id take the hitter

Maudid--

Heyward was only injured one year (the year he sucked). If you're talking about health, Kershaw's hip waves hello.

That is what I get for trusting my memory. Most of the point still stands. Heyward doesn't have a great track record yet and in pretty much any draft, Kershaw is going to go ahead of Heyward. I am actually a big fan of Heyward and tried to get him in every keeper league I play in but if someone was to offer me Kershaw for him, I would do it in a second. People seem to forget that Kershaw is only 24 and while he has put a lot of innings on that arm, there is very little to be concerned about. From all reports, the hip is fine.