My main league is a 10 team, keeper, h2h league where the categories used are:
Hitting = TB, RBI, R, SB, OBP and Pitching = Ws, Ks, QS, ERA, and WHIP

We may keep 1 hitter and 1 sp per year. My personal top choices this year (for hitters) are: Starlin Castro, Jay Bruce, Allen Craig.

I also have first pick of the 2013 draft. I am debating between Miguel Cabrera and Ryan Braun (Trout will be someone's keeper so he isn't an option here.)


Based off of the league settings above...Which direction would you all suggest I go in with these two choices?
(I am personally stuck between Castro and Bruce...and I realize the first overall pick will hurt me either way...obviously 2 studs there...just a matter of preference I guess)

Thanks for the help! Looking forward to what a lot of people have to say.

Keep Castro, take Miggy...

Thanks, Gray. I tend to agree...but can you offe Some of your personal reasoning ?

Miggy just hit for the Triple Crown, you need reasons? Castro is a top 5 SS...Bruce is an outfielder that gets insanely hot and cold...Craig can't stay healthy....

Any other hitters you can keep? Must be a limit on how many years you can keep players.

And I agree Miggy. Just don't like the idea of Castro as the basis of your offense. I mean he is solid everywhere and doesn't hurt you, but in H2h, I prefer to set up a consistent advantage in a few cats. Bruce is too streaky for H2h.